OpenNashPodcasts

Person

Benedict Evans

This page collects what Benedict Evans said on the Analyse Asia podcast with Bernard Leong, in an episode asking what investors are buying if AI models have no moat. Evans discusses the economics of AI, chip manufacturing and telecoms, and compares today's spending with the fiber bubble.

He also draws on history, from 1980s software and the 2007 iPhone to 20th-century accounting jobs. Evans says coding is the only AI use case that has clearly reached product-market fit, and that most people use large language model products weekly or monthly rather than daily. Each fact below has his exact quote and a link to that moment.

1 episodes · 21 quoted claims

Benedict Evans says the mobile telecoms industry earns about $1 trillion a year in revenue, spends about $200 billion a year on capital expenditure, and has seen its stocks go nowhere in 20 years.

“it's 1 trillion dollar annual revenue industry pays $200 billion a year on CapEx and the stocks have gone nowhere in 20 years”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:07:51

Benedict Evans says Rock's Law observes that semiconductor manufacturing gets more expensive with every generation.

“What Rock's Law observes, it gets more expensive every generation.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:08:41

Benedict Evans says leading-edge chip manufacturing has narrowed to about three companies or fewer, compared with dozens 30 or 40 years earlier.

“And so now there's basically three chip companies. Whereas, or two, or one, or however you want to count it, as opposed to 30 or 40 years ago when there were dozens.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:09:06

Benedict Evans contrasts the fiber bubble, built ahead of demand, with AI infrastructure, which he says is built behind demand because every token produced can be sold.

“Whereas this, of course, is being built out behind demand, like you can sell every token you can make.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:09:34

Benedict Evans says the fiber market became disaggregated into separate layers such as ducts, dark fiber, light fiber, wavelengths and IP streams, with others trading bandwidth on top.

“So what happened with fiber was that you got split up. So you had ducts and dark fiber and light fiber and wavelengths and IP streams and probably some other stuff.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:09:34

Benedict Evans recalls that as a junior technology analyst in 1999 he visited a company selling computer parts and components online.

“there was a company that sold computer parts, computer components, chips and memory and computers and printers, all this stuff.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:11:24

Benedict Evans says the online computer-parts reseller had revenue of about 100 million pounds a year after launching its website.

“So they make a website, they're doing 100 million quid a year in revenue. We all go up to see the company.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:12:21

Benedict Evans says Anthropic got coding working first and reached product-market fit with it, with no inherent reason Google or OpenAI cannot catch up.

“so what we see now is Antwapic got code working and got coding working and got product market fit.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:03:53

Benedict Evans says that late last year OpenAI tried many products at once, including a social video app, app stores and an e-commerce checkout flow, to find what worked.

“we'll try a social video app, we'll try an app store, we'll try another app store, we'll try an e-commerce checkout flow”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:21:27

Benedict Evans says a late-1980s program called Sideways sold for about $150 and only printed spreadsheets in landscape, a function later reduced to an operating-system checkbox.

“There was a program called Sideways that you could buy in the late 80s. And it was like $150 in late 80s dollars”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:23:09

Benedict Evans says spellchecking was once a standalone software category, with computer magazines running group tests of ten programs priced at $200 to $300.

“they would have a group test of 10 different spellchecking programs that were all $200 and $300”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:23:09

Benedict Evans says US census data show the number of accountants and bookkeepers rising in a near-straight line through the 20th century despite decades of automation.

“You go look at the US census data, the number of people who are called an accountant and a bookkeeper basically goes up in a straight line from the 20th century.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:35:16

Benedict Evans says the internet hurt journalism not by changing the editor's job but by removing the local advertising monopoly of the printing and trucking business that paid journalists.

“journalists were being paid through a light manufacturing and trucking business that had a monopoly on local advertising.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:36:28

Benedict Evans says about 200 years ago roughly 90 percent of people were peasants, and automating farming over the following centuries did not reduce the number of jobs.

“200 years ago, most of us were peasants. And, you know, we worried that the crops would fail. And, you know, 90 % of us were peasants.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:38:09

Benedict Evans recounts that a BlackBerry co-founder, on seeing the iPhone, said that if it worked BlackBerry would be competing with a Mac.

“this is a great quote from one of the co-founders of BlackBerry. He said, you know, he looked at the iPhone, if this thing works, we're competing with a Mac.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:18:29

Benedict Evans says the original iPhone had four or eight gigabytes of storage and ran a PC operating system, which is why BlackBerry and Nokia were badly placed against it.

“And it had like four or eight gig of storage, which was just a ludicrously large amount of storage. And it was running a PC operating system.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:18:56

Benedict Evans says that around 1978 an Apple II with enough memory and disk drives to run a spreadsheet cost roughly $10,000 to $15,000.

“to buy an Apple II with enough memory and the disk drives and stuff with like $10 ,000 or $15 ,000”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:54:07

Benedict Evans says most people use large language model products weekly or monthly rather than daily, even among 13 to 19-year-olds.

“most people are weekly active users and monthly active users and not daily active users.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:54:34

Benedict Evans says that around 2010 many clever people in tech expected mobile to repeat Windows versus Apple, with Apple obliterated, and that this did not happen.

“this was going to play out like Windows versus Apple, Apple was closed, Apple would get obliterated and that was just not what happened”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:15:54

Benedict Evans describes the AI model market as three to six companies spending heavily plus up to a dozen others willing to run three to six months behind.

“you've got pick a number of sort of three to six companies spending a lot of money and then maybe anything up to a dozen companies that are willing to be three to six months behind”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:03:53

Benedict Evans says coding is the only AI use case that has clearly reached product-market fit, a market he puts at tens of millions of people rather than hundreds of millions.

“The only thing that's actually got product market fit, like really, really got product market fit is coding.”

Analyse Asia with Bernard Leong · 0:07:07