OpenNashPodcasts

Person

David Booth

David Booth is the founder and chairman of Dimensional, an investment firm, and the podcasts on this page cover his career in indexing and finance. He appeared on Odd Lots and on Goldman Sachs Exchanges, where he discussed the early days of index investing, his work with Nobel laureates, and investing through uncertainty.

Booth said he started the University of Chicago PhD program at 22, when Eugene Fama was 30. He told the hosts that Dimensional's first fund, launched in 1981, was a small-cap fund, and that early indexing pioneers expected perhaps $10 billion in assets, not trillions. He also described the stock market as the original AI application.

2 episodes · 30 quoted claims

Errol Morris won an Academy Award for his film The Fog of War, according to David Booth.

“he won the Academy Award for his film Fog of War and well-known documentarian.”

Odd Lots · 0:03:53

In 1971 David Booth took a job at Wells Fargo that was arranged through Mac McQuown.

“So I called Mac McQuown and got David a job that way with Wells Fargo, I guess it was at the time, David, right? Right. 1971.”

Odd Lots · 0:05:11

After Booth's group at Wells Fargo was shut down, Mac McQuown volunteered to share its data with Vanguard's Jack Bogle.

“when the group I was working on, Wells, got shut down, Mac just volunteered to Bogle to share all of his data with him.”

Odd Lots · 0:06:33

Jim Lorie and Larry Fisher persuaded Merrill Lynch to fund a survivorship-bias-free stock database that enabled young researchers to do their work, according to Booth.

“they persuaded Merrill Lynch to fund a study to collect a survivorship bias-free database, which enabled all these new young hotshots to do their research.”

Odd Lots · 0:09:39

Booth says that over roughly the last 20 years indexing grew enormously while trading volume also rose strongly, which he cites against the claim that indexing destroys price discovery.

“There's been an incredible movement to indexing over that time period. And yet there's been an incredible increase in trading volume.”

Odd Lots · 0:21:48

Booth notes the S&P 500 contains 500 of the largest companies rather than the 500 largest, since an investment committee uses subjective judgment to choose additions.

“it's the S &P 500 is 500 of the largest companies, but it's not the 500 largest companies.”

Odd Lots · 0:25:04

Booth credits Fama and Ken French's 1992 paper, The Cross-Section of Expected Returns, with giving empirical support to multiple dimensions of returns.

“Gene's research that he did with Ken French, his landmark 92 paper called Cross-Section of Expected Returns.”

Odd Lots · 0:27:52

Dimensional's first clients were large institutions that held only large-company stocks because they hired managers to outguess the market.

“Our first clients were large institutional clients, and they were only holding stocks of bigger companies because they were trying to hire managers to outguess the market.”

Odd Lots · 0:34:22

David Booth sold shoes on commission from his senior year of high school through his first three years of college.

“I sold shoes, amazingly enough. And what it taught me, I was a commission salesman.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:01:07

Booth says there was little data available to test investing claims before 1960, and data became available in the 1960s.

“before 1960, there was really no data to test people's claims.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:01:57

Booth identifies Fama's efficient market hypothesis, Merton's multi-factor theory and the Black-Scholes-Merton option pricing model as the biggest finance events of the 20th century, clustered between 1969 and 1972.

“You have Gene Fama's efficient market hypothesis. You have Bob Merton with his multi-factor theory, the intertemporal capital asset pricing model, as it were. And you have the Black-Scholes-Merton option pricing model.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:02:24

Eugene Fama offered to call Mac McQuown at Wells Fargo, who was creating the first indexed portfolio, when Booth wanted to leave the PhD program.

“I'll call up Mac McQuown at Wells Fargo, who was creating the first indexed portfolio.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:04:28

Booth says indexing at Wells Fargo originated with Myron Scholes and Fisher Black, who persuaded McQuown to create an indexed portfolio.

“the idea of indexing at Wells sprang from Myron Scholes and Fisher Black. They convinced Mack McQuown to create this indexed portfolio.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:04:53

Booth says the early indexing pioneers expected assets under management of perhaps $10 billion, not trillions.

“We thought maybe we could get up to $10 billion in AUM or something like that.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:06:06

Booth says the SEC questioned why a fund that did not try to pick winners could charge a management fee.

“when we started to create a fund, the SEC wrote back, look, you guys aren't trying to pick winners. Why would they pay you a management fee for doing what you're doing?”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:06:48

Dimensional's first fund was a small-cap fund, called a dimensional fund rather than an index fund, which Booth says is the origin of the firm's name.

“The first fund we launched was our small cap fund. And because of this active-passive confusion, we just call it a dimensional fund rather than an index fund.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:08:19

Booth says Fama and French's paper on the cross-section of expected returns, about ten years after Dimensional's founding, documented size as a dimension of returns.

“It wasn't 10 years later until FOM and French, with their paper on the cross-section of expected returns, documented that it really was a dimension.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:08:34

Booth and co-founder Rex Sinkfield asked Merton Miller to serve as an independent director of the Dimensional mutual fund, and he agreed.

“Rex Sinkfield, my co-founder, and I walked over to the business school, and in his office that day was Merton Miller, who was a legend among professors.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:09:43

Merton Miller won the Nobel Prize in 1990, the first Dimensional director to do so.

“He got his Nobel Prize in 1990. He was the first of our directors to get a Nobel.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:10:04

Booth asked Eugene Fama to be a founding partner of Dimensional and head its research, and Fama agreed.

“I said, I'd like to have you be a founding partner and really head up our research activities.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:11:16

Booth says Dimensional's early small-cap fund began outperforming benchmark indices instead of lagging them, which he called a shock.

“instead of lagging the performance of small cap indices, we started actually having higher returns than benchmark indices.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:13:05

Booth says index funds must buy stocks added to an index at the closing price, so managers trying to track the same index trade at the same moment.

“you'll say, I will pay anything, but I have to have tonight's closing price guaranteed.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:14:44

By 1989 Dimensional was well established with institutional clients, when financial advisor Dan Wheeler asked for access to its funds.

“So we started the firm in 81. By 1989, we were pretty well established with the institutional clients with the mutual fund.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:17:34

Dimensional required advisors to attend a day or two of training at their own expense and to invest through omnibus accounts at firms like Schwab and Fidelity.

“they need to come at their own expense to our offices for a day or two of training.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:18:17

Booth was 22 when he started the University of Chicago PhD program, when Eugene Fama was 30.

“when I went to the PhD program, I was 22 and Fama was 30.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:06:06

Booth says basketball was founded in 1892 in Springfield, Massachusetts, as a class project by James Naismith.

“It was founded actually as a class project by James Naismith in 1892, Springfield, Massachusetts.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:28:39

Naismith's original rules of basketball stayed in his family until 2010, when Sotheby's auctioned them and Booth bought and donated them to the University of Kansas.

“they'd been in the family from 1892 to 2010. And then it was sold in auction at Sotheby's.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:28:56

Booth attended the Nobel ceremony in Stockholm in 1997 for Merton and Scholes and in 2013 for Fama.

“Once when Bob Merton and Myron Scholes got in 97 when they got their Nobels. And then in 2013, when Gene Fama got his Nobel.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:29:53

In 2008 Booth offered a large gift to Chicago Booth dean Ted Snyder, who said the school would name itself after him.

“I approached the dean of the business school, Ted Snyder at the time, said look this is what I would like to give to the school.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:27:13

Booth describes the stock market as the original AI application, since prices reflect all available information, and says the industry has handled big data for 60 years.

“the stock market is really the original AI application. Yeah, because prices reflect all available information.”

Goldman Sachs Exchanges · 0:31:03