Person
David Merritt
David Merritt appeared on Becker's Healthcare Podcast to discuss what is driving healthcare affordability pressures, focusing on the No Surprises Act and its independent dispute resolution (IDR) process. He said the law passed with bipartisan majorities and eliminated surprise medical bills for patients.
Merritt also argued the arbitration process has become costly. He cited a Georgetown study putting its cost at $22 billion in a couple of years, and said IDR awards are typically 400 to 500 percent above negotiated market rates. He said bipartisan leaders in Congress are looking at restoring the qualified payment amount as the starting point for awards.
1 episodes · 14 quoted claims
The No Surprises Act passed with bipartisan majorities and eliminated surprise medical bills for patients, according to David Merritt.
“the No Surprises Act, the legislation that was actually passed with bipartisan majorities, solved a real problem for patients. And that was eliminating surprise medical bills.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:06:35
A Georgetown study cited by David Merritt put the cost of the No Surprises Act arbitration process at $22 billion in a couple of years, including administrative fees and above-market awards.
“researchers at Georgetown put out a study that said in just a couple of years, the price tag on that process is $22 billion.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:07:18
David Merritt said the Business Group on Health estimated that nearly a third of current premium increases can be attributed to the IDR problem.
“the business group on health recently estimated that nearly a third of the premium increases that we're seeing can be attributed to this problem.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:07:18
David Merritt said the Georgetown study found IDR claims grew by 77 percent in the most recent year.
“That same study said that claims grew by 77 % last year.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:07:58
David Merritt said the association estimates 40 percent of IDR claims should not be heard, yet half of those result in awards and required payments.
“our estimates are that 40 % of them should not be heard in the first place, yet half of those actually result in awards and required payments.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:08:29
David Merritt cited an IDR award of nearly $500,000 for a breast reduction procedure.
“there was a nearly a $500 ,000 breast reduction.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:08:29
David Merritt said IDR awards are typically 400 to 500 percent higher than negotiated market rates.
“And the awards are typically, you know, four to 500 % higher than the market rates.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:09:04
David Merritt said administrative fees collected by IDR arbiters grew by more than $1 billion over a couple of years.
“So more than $1 billion and just in the last couple of years.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:14:51
David Merritt said the May operations rule lowered the barrier to filing a claim, which he expects to increase dispute volume.
“it did lower the barrier to file a claim, which we think will simply increase volume.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:19:06
David Merritt said one health plan reported a single provider group filing about 350 disputes a day, 80 percent of them ineligible.
“one plan that said a single provider group filed about 350 disputes a day and 80% of them were ineligible.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:19:51
David Merritt said Halo MD did not exist before the No Surprises Act and now accounts for more than half of all IDR claims filed.
“there was one company, Halo MD. It didn't exist before the No Surprises Act. And now it accounts for more than half of all claims that are filed.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:20:59
David Merritt said bipartisan leaders in Congress are looking at restoring the qualified payment amount, the privately negotiated local market rate, as the starting point for IDR awards.
“fundamentally restoring the qualified payment amount and those those privately negotiated market rates in each of in each of the local markets.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:21:28
David Merritt cited California as a state that has minimized surprise-billing arbitration problems through state-level guardrails.
“You don't see a lot of these problems in states that have a reasonable state process. California is a good example where they've minimized a lot of this because they have good guardrails in place.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:23:12
David Merritt said employers have responded to rising costs by increasing coinsurance and cost sharing for employees and trimming benefits.
“employers have really struggled and have made tradeoffs to increase coinsurance and cost sharing with employees. They've trimmed benefits in many cases.”
Becker's Healthcare Podcast · 0:17:08