OpenNashPodcasts

Person

John Barbella

John Barbella is a fintech executive who appeared on the Breaking Banks podcast to discuss fraud, and how banks and fintechs can work together to stay ahead of it. He told the show he began his financial services career at Deluxe, a check printing company, and entered electronic payments in 2006.

Barbella described Neighborly, a data-sharing network whose member banks set its operating rules. He said 10 to 15 banks would cover most of the industry. He also said fraudsters can make synthetic accounts look real, leave them dormant, then reactivate them. He predicted the fintech account industry could shrink from about 10X to 4 or 5X.

1 episodes · 20 quoted claims

John Barbella began his financial services career at Deluxe, a check printing company.

“I started with that deluxe check printers way, way back when, and it was paper payments.”

Breaking Banks · 0:02:35

John Barbella says he entered the fintech and electronic payments industry in 2006, a few years after the pioneers.

“I joined in 2006. The industry had maybe been perking along for three, four, five years, maybe with some of the real pioneers.”

Breaking Banks · 0:03:12

Check Systems began in the 1980s and was later acquired by Deluxe.

“Deluxe owned a company by the name of Check Systems. And Check Systems started in the 1980s and was acquired by Deluxe.”

Breaking Banks · 0:04:50

Check Systems assembled a network of about 15,000 financial institutions that contributed data on people who had mishandled bank accounts.

“assembled a network of 15 ,000 financial institutions that all contributed data on people that had misstepped or not adjudicated their accounts with a bank.”

Breaking Banks · 0:04:50

John Barbella says that at The Bancorp, the bank gave provisional credits on disputed transactions and lost the money when disputes were illegitimate.

“we were offering provisional credits as a bank, and then we'd be left in the lurch, and that money would walk away.”

Breaking Banks · 0:06:06

John Barbella says the idea for Neighborly took shape between about 2014 and 2016.

“that's really where that passion grew in the kind of the mid-2014 to 2016 era, said, hey, there's got to be a better way.”

Breaking Banks · 0:06:40

John Barbella says the FDIC evaluated banks partly on customer complaints relative to asset size, including complaints triggered by rejected illegitimate disputes.

“And guess what? That's how the FDIC assessed the bank. And they said, hey, you can't have this many customer complaints based on your asset size.”

Breaking Banks · 0:11:09

John Barbella says that in traditional banking, a demand deposit account cost roughly $150 to $175 to acquire and was a loss leader.

“You brought on that account. It might cost you in the neighborhood of $150 to $175 to bring them on.”

Breaking Banks · 0:12:10

John Barbella says that in 2019 to 2021, fintech companies were valued at roughly $1,000 for each account they added.

“every account that you brought on in the madness of 2019, 2020, 21, everything, every time you brought on an account, it had a value of roughly $1 ,000.”

Breaking Banks · 0:12:10

Neighborly launched in 2022, as fintech valuations began to normalize.

“that's about the time where we got out the door with Neighborly when we started in 22.”

Breaking Banks · 0:13:09

John Barbella describes a conference exchange in which banks said they wait six to nine months for feedback after filing suspicious activity reports with FinCEN.

“We're providing the SARS. We don't hear back for six to nine months. You know, how is this being actionable?”

Breaking Banks · 0:15:52

John Barbella says 10 to 15 banks participating in Neighborly would cover most of the industry, in contrast to Check Systems' 15,000 institutions.

“We're talking about 10, 15, where you're going to get the lion's share of the industry, that if they're participating, you are making it harder for that fraudster.”

Breaking Banks · 0:22:48

Neighborly ran a fourth-quarter data study with an ACH payments processor to detect fraud from payroll-switching patterns.

“So the data study that we just conducted here in the fourth quarter was pretty cool. We worked with an ACH payments processor.”

Breaking Banks · 0:25:04

In the data study, some banks had identified an account as fraudulent on February 12, though the payroll processor's data had flagged it as bad on January 3.

“we can tell you on January 3rd, this account went bad. Do you see this? And it was pretty powerful to get the feedback to say, yeah, we identified it, but we didn't identify until February 12th because they didn't have it.”

Breaking Banks · 0:25:40

John Barbella says member banks in Neighborly set the network's operating rules.

“The banks that are member banks in Neighborly, they set the operating rules. They tell us what we want.”

Breaking Banks · 0:26:42

John Barbella predicts the fintech account industry could shrink from about 10X to 4 or 5X as dormant accounts are removed.

“So if our industry is 10X right now, I could see it being 4 or 5X. much, much smaller than it is now.”

Breaking Banks · 0:29:07

John Barbella says fraudsters can make synthetic accounts look real, leave them dormant, then reactivate them to commit fraud.

“they'll make those accounts, those synthetic accounts appear to be real. Then they'll go into some period of dormancy and then they'll come back up and get gotcha.”

Breaking Banks · 0:29:36

John Barbella says some payers refuse to send payments to routing numbers tied to fraud-heavy prepaid programs.

“you're not having someone in Treasury say, no, we're not going to pay that routing number. There's too much fraud out there. I mean, that actually occurs today.”

Breaking Banks · 0:30:38

John Barbella expects the next phase of fintech growth to be more organic than the boom of 2010 to 2020.

“And that growth that will come will be more organic and more reasonable than the growth that we experienced from 2010 to 2020.”

Breaking Banks · 0:31:09

Neighborly operates through partners rather than employees, with the Advantage Technology team managing its infrastructure.

“Neighborly doesn't have employees per se. We have partners that help us enable this. We have the Advantage Technology team that manages our infrastructure.”

Breaking Banks · 0:34:20