OpenNashPodcasts

Person

Kyle Harper

Kyle Harper is a historian who appeared on the Dwarkesh Podcast to discuss why Rome fell, covering plagues, slavery and a cooling climate, along with the history of disease more broadly. Harper said a series of volcanic eruptions in the 6th century cooled global temperatures by roughly one to two degrees, and that Emperor Justinian had retaken Africa and most of Italy when plague struck in the 540s.

He also described Roman slavery as central to the economy from about the 3rd or 2nd century BCE, and said the Roman world had the most advanced financial markets before the 17th or 18th century. Harper said plague never sustains itself in human populations, and that the 14th-century Black Death killed 50 to 60 percent of the population in entire regions.

1 episodes · 27 quoted claims

Kyle Harper says the city of Rome had perhaps 50,000 to 100,000 people by the 6th or 7th century, a fraction of its former size.

“by the end of this period, the city of Rome has, you know, we don't know, 50 to 100 ,000 people.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:01:59

Kyle Harper says the 14th-century Black Death killed 50 to 60 percent of the population in entire regions.

“It kills 50, 60 % of the population in entire regions.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:03:34

Kyle Harper says Emperor Justinian had retaken Africa and most of Italy when the plague struck in the 540s.

“He's retaken Africa. He's mostly retaken Italy when the plague hits.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:05:12

Kyle Harper notes that the eastern Roman state kept calling itself the Roman Empire until the 15th century.

“And remember, it does. And it calls itself the Roman Empire until the 15th century.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:05:50

Kyle Harper says a series of major volcanic eruptions caused the abrupt 6th-century climate cooling.

“we know the cause, that there was a series of really significant volcanic eruptions”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:08:47

Kyle Harper says the volcanic cooling lowered global temperatures by roughly one to two degrees.

“It was like a degree to two degrees cooler, which we all kind of know now, like two degrees.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:09:53

Kyle Harper says the Roman world had the most advanced financial markets in the world before the 17th or 18th century.

“They have like the most advanced financial markets in the world before like the 17th or 18th century.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:15:15

Kyle Harper says Roman banks took deposits, kept balances and lent money to debtors.

“There are banks that take money from depositors and, you know, keep balances and then lend out to debtors”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:15:15

Kyle Harper says royal societies for science appeared first in France and then in Britain, promoting basic science, empiricism and useful knowledge.

“this happens first in France and then Britain, but you get royal societies for science”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:17:19

Kyle Harper cites the French engineer Denis Papin, in Leibniz's circle, as an example of mathematics and engineering working together to build vacuum pumps.

“look at Denis Pepin who's a French engineer who's like very much in the circle of like Leibniz”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:18:57

Kyle Harper says Roman conquests of Mediterranean lands brought mass enslavement of captives, which became central to the Roman economy from about the 3rd or 2nd century BCE.

“As the Romans conquer other parts of the Mediterranean, they start taking captives as slaves en masse.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:24:50

Kyle Harper says Romans justified slavery through law and status, as conquered people spared from death and sold as property, rather than through racial ideology.

“The Roman ideology of slavery is really rooted in the law of property and status.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:28:13

Kyle Harper says the slave population of Pompeii must have been around 30 percent, many of them domestic workers rather than plantation laborers.

“It must be 30%. And not all of these people would have been like plantation workers who were lashed every day”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:32:04

Kyle Harper says the Italian historian Aldo Schiavone argued that slavery discouraged Roman innovation, but Harper does not find the argument persuasive.

“Aldo Schiavone, who's an Italian historian, has argued that. It's kind of like a neo-Marxist tradition that argues this.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:33:18

Kyle Harper says Homo sapiens spent 90 to 95 percent of its history as foragers.

“We emerge in Africa and disperse, multiply. But we spend 90, 95% of our history as foragers”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:36:55

Kyle Harper notes that Jared Diamond called the shift from foraging to farming humanity's biggest mistake.

“But there is this idea that the transition from foraging to farming – I mean, Jared Diamond called it humanity's biggest mistake.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:39:45

Kyle Harper says goats were the first domesticated livestock, and that domestication happened through gradual unintended steps rather than a deliberate decision.

“the first livestock that are domesticated are goats. And nobody says like, hey, let's become goat farmers.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:42:52

Kyle Harper says forager women had lower fertility, closer to four children than six, because they walked long distances and carried children.

“it's like more like four than six. Because women who are moving with the foraging bands miles and miles on foot on average a day”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:46:08

Kyle Harper says infectious disease imposes a heavy energy cost on the body because the immune system is metabolically expensive, which can limit childhood growth.

“Infectious disease imposes a huge burden on the body. The immune system is extremely metabolically expensive.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:49:38

Kyle Harper explains that vaccination uses cowpox lymph to trigger immunity, unlike earlier inoculation with actual smallpox.

“Vaccination uses cowpox, the lymph of an infected cow, to intentionally cause the immune reaction of humans.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:55:44

Kyle Harper says that in a world where 10 to 20 percent of children died of smallpox, deliberately inoculating with live smallpox was a rational though dangerous choice.

“But in a world where like 10, 20% of kids die of smallpox, it's this horrible decision.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:55:44

Kyle Harper says it took another 60 to 70 years after Jenner's vaccine before Louis Pasteur systematized the approach.

“And then even after Jenner, it's like another, you know, 60 years, 70 years before Pasteur kind of systematizes it”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 0:56:18

Kyle Harper says the plague bacillus was discovered in India during the third plague pandemic by Alexander Yersin, for whom Yersinia pestis is named.

“It's, in fact, where the plague bacillus is discovered by Alexander Yersin. It's called Yersinia pestis.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 1:00:03

Kyle Harper says plague's natural animal reservoir lies in the Tian Shan mountains where China, Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan meet.

“the plagues in enzootic, it's like natural animal reservoir, is the Tianchan Mountains where China, Kazakhstan, and Kyrgyzstan meet”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 1:01:49

Kyle Harper says plague bacteria form a biofilm in the flea's gut that makes the flea feed repeatedly and regurgitate bacteria.

“It forms this biofilm in the gut of the flea that like chokes it and makes the flea feel like it's starving.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 1:09:10

Kyle Harper says plague never sustains itself in human populations and always dies out after transient outbreaks.

“Plague never sustains itself in human populations. It can transiently infect human populations, but then it always dies out.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 1:10:28

Kyle Harper says SARS-CoV-1 in 2003 was slightly more virulent and made people sick quickly, which made it easier to contain than COVID-19.

“Like the first COVID, SARS-CoV-1, 2003, slightly more virulent. And in fact, it was just more virulent enough that it made you sick pretty quick.”

Dwarkesh Podcast · 1:14:52