In brief
Banks keep failing at anti-money laundering (AML) because compliance is treated as a cost, not a priority. Consultant Aaron Ansari argues that the TD Bank case shows the pattern: the bank starved its compliance program of resources, and incentives that reward deposits and growth push staff and systems to wave money through.
The tension is between frictionless deposit-taking, which makes banks money, and the scrutiny that catches criminals. Ansari says fines have often been small enough to be a cost of doing business. He thinks better use of existing tools, AI with humans in the loop, and new verification technology can help, at some cost to customer convenience.
Questions
Why did TD Bank get such a huge money laundering penalty?
Penny Crosman says TD pled guilty in October and agreed to pay more than $1.8 billion to resolve the Justice Department's investigation. Ansari, citing Lisa Monaco, says the bank starved its compliance program of resources, and a criminal network bribed employees with gift cards.
Why don't banks' transaction monitoring systems catch more money laundering?
Ansari says criminals can look convincing enough to bypass checks for a long time, and software across a bank's divisions often does not talk to each other. Banks also tend to invest only the minimum in people, processes and technology.
Is AI the answer to catching money laundering?
Ansari says it is part of the answer. It can scale analysis and rank alerts so analysts are not overwhelmed, but he says a human should stay in the loop and that better use of existing tools comes first.
What is the 'cost of doing business' problem with bank fines?
Ansari says fines were often smaller than the money banks made from loans and deposits tied to laundered funds, so banks simply accepted them. He also says individuals are not facing jail, though he thinks there should be some recourse for them.
Will stronger anti-money laundering checks affect ordinary customers?
Yes, Ansari says. Tighter analysis will likely mean more inconvenience, such as automated account closures without explanation, though customers typically do not lose access to their money. He says that cost is small next to the fines.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
TD Bank pled guilty in October and agreed to pay more than $1.8 billion in penalties to resolve a Justice Department investigation into Bank Secrecy Act and money laundering violations, according to Penny Crosman.
“So in October, TD Bank pled guilty and agreed to pay more than $1.8 billion in penalties to resolve the Justice Department's investigation into its violations of the BSA Act and money laundering rules.”
0:01:07 · Penny Crosman · TD Bank penalty
Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco said every bank compliance official in America should study the TD Bank charges as an example of what not to do.
“Every bank compliance official in America should be reviewing today's charges as a key study of what not to do, Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco said when the charges were announced.”
0:01:07 · Penny Crosman · DOJ statement
Attorney General Merrick Garland said TD Bank chose profits over compliance with the law, as quoted by Penny Crosman.
“TD Bank chose profits over compliance with the law, a decision that is now costing the bank billions of dollars in penalties.”
0:01:43 · Penny Crosman · DOJ statement
The operators of one money laundering network that processed more than $470 million through TD Bank gave employees gift cards worth more than $57,000 to keep their transactions processing.
“The operators of one money laundering network that processed more than $470 million through the bank gave employees gift cards worth more than $57 ,000”
0:01:43 · Penny Crosman · Employee bribery
Aaron Ansari cites Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco as saying TD Bank starved its compliance program of the resources it needed to obey the law.
“for years, TD Bank starved its compliance program of the resources they needed to obey the law.”
0:03:33 · Aaron Ansari · Compliance resources
Aaron Ansari says banks' employee handbooks include anti-bribery policies and limits on gifts from customers and vendors, such as coffee worth under $15 or $20.
“All banks in their employee handbooks, in their acceptable use documents when an employee is onboarded has an anti-bribery and in just a limit on the acceptance of gifts”
0:02:41 · Aaron Ansari · Gift policies
Aaron Ansari says Wells Fargo bankers opened fake accounts because internal contests and promotions rewarded the number of accounts and deposits.
“You think back to Wells Fargo, when they were opening fake accounts under companies and humans that didn't exist, those bankers were incentivized by Wells Fargo due to internal contests”
0:07:19 · Aaron Ansari · Wells Fargo accounts
Penny Crosman says a large bank kept Jeffrey Epstein as a customer for many years after he had been indicted, despite compliance flags on his account.
“there was a large bank that kept him on as a customer for many years after he had already been indicted for various crimes.”
0:09:08 · Penny Crosman · Epstein banking
Aaron Ansari says bank fines historically did not exceed the revenue generated from laundered money, so banks still profited.
“The fines didn't outdo the monetary value that was generated from the programs. So if you're generating a lot of money and loans off of the laundered money, and your fine is much less than that, you're still making money.”
0:11:04 · Aaron Ansari · Fines economics
Aaron Ansari says TD's fine is paid from actual cash on hand, not future profits or deposits.
“This is the money that's sitting, quote unquote, in their bank.”
0:10:35 · Aaron Ansari · TD fine
Aaron Ansari says there should be some recourse for individuals as well as the organization when banks circumvent best practices, though he does not say people should go to jail.
“there should be some sort of recourse for the individuals as well as the organization.”
0:13:10 · Aaron Ansari · Individual accountability
Aaron Ansari describes a laundering method in which people overpay loan installments with dirty funds and receive a refund check for the excess.
“a lot of times people take out loans from institutions and then they pay back more than what's due on the loan each month.”
0:13:31 · Aaron Ansari · Loan overpayment laundering
Aaron Ansari says software across a bank's divisions sometimes does not communicate, letting laundering continue unnoticed for a long time.
“sometimes the software doesn't talk to each other. Sometimes the platforms don't necessarily align and you're able to get by for a long time”
0:14:57 · Aaron Ansari · System silos
Aaron Ansari says that in consulting he advises banks to refine existing systems before buying new software.
“You can work a lot with what you have currently, and we want to just ensure that we refine it so that it's as efficient as possible.”
0:17:34 · Aaron Ansari · AML consulting
Aaron Ansari says artificial intelligence helps analysts with scale and alert fatigue in AML monitoring.
“artificial intelligence certainly helps from a scalability and from a fatigue standpoint for analysts that are doing the alert and the monitoring of these sorts of things”
0:18:12 · Aaron Ansari · AI in AML
Aaron Ansari describes rules-based AML monitoring as if-then rules, such as a phone call when someone deposits more than $10,000 in cash.
“if you deposit more than $10 ,000 cash, then you get a phone call.”
0:20:15 · Aaron Ansari · Rules-based monitoring
Aaron Ansari describes the placement stage of money laundering as the first step, using structuring, currency exchanges or asset purchases to move dirty money into the legitimate system.
“There's what's called the placement stage, right? Where there's structuring or currency exchanges or asset purchases that are done sort of in the first step”
0:20:50 · Aaron Ansari · Laundering stages
Aaron Ansari says TD is the 10th largest bank in the world, or at least North America, and was hit with a $3 billion penalty.
“TD's 10th largest bank in the world, or at least North America, and they're hit with a $3 billion penalty.”
0:22:37 · Aaron Ansari · TD Bank size
Aaron Ansari says some software packages automatically decline and close accounts, and retail bankers may not know why.
“certain software packages automatically decline and even close accounts.”
0:23:51 · Aaron Ansari · Automated account closures
Aaron Ansari predicts banks will adopt software that monitors for insider threats, though not Big Brother-style monitoring.
“software that's used to look at insider threats or insider malicious activities for sure.”
0:26:44 · Aaron Ansari · Insider threat monitoring
Aaron Ansari says distributed ledger technology (blockchain) provides immutable, transparent transaction records that could make tracing money easier, though it is still nascent.
“distributed ledger technology or blockchain, right? Like you've got blockchain that provides, you know, immutable, transparent records of transactions that make it easier to trace money.”
0:26:44 · Aaron Ansari · Blockchain
Aaron Ansari says biometric know-your-customer checks will spread only if banks can counter voice cloning and deepfake facial overlays.
“provided that you can mitigate the stolen voice AI sort of things that come out there and mimic somebody's voice or do the facial overlays from a deepfake standpoint.”
0:27:50 · Aaron Ansari · Biometric KYC