OpenNashPodcasts

American Banker Podcast

Why banks keep failing at money laundering

7 Jan 2025 · 29m · Aaron Ansari, Penny Crosman · 22 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Banks keep failing at anti-money laundering (AML) because compliance is treated as a cost, not a priority. Consultant Aaron Ansari argues that the TD Bank case shows the pattern: the bank starved its compliance program of resources, and incentives that reward deposits and growth push staff and systems to wave money through.

The tension is between frictionless deposit-taking, which makes banks money, and the scrutiny that catches criminals. Ansari says fines have often been small enough to be a cost of doing business. He thinks better use of existing tools, AI with humans in the loop, and new verification technology can help, at some cost to customer convenience.

Key insights

  1. Underfunded compliance, not missing tools, drove TD's failure

    Ansari quotes Lisa Monaco saying TD Bank 'starved its compliance program of the resources' it needed. Software and expertise exist, but a program without budget cannot meet even the legal minimum.

  2. Banks are built to make deposits frictionless

    Taking deposits is a bank's core business, and retail bankers are rewarded for more accounts and deposits. That incentive, as in Wells Fargo's fake accounts, works against questioning suspicious cash.

  3. Fines only work when they exceed laundering profits

    Ansari says penalties long cost less than the revenue from loans built on laundered money, so banks treated them as a business expense. A fine paid from cash on hand, like TD's, changes that math.

  4. Existing systems can be refined before buying new ones

    Ansari says better configuration, cross-platform communication and alert tuning cost little. Systems that do not talk to each other let schemes like overpaying a loan and taking a refund slip through.

  5. AI helps triage alerts but needs human oversight

    AI can rank alerts from 'hair on fire' to low priority and spot placement, layering and integration patterns that thousands of fixed rules would slow down. Humans must stay involved to avoid alert fatigue, and legitimate customers may face more friction.

Questions

Why did TD Bank get such a huge money laundering penalty?

Penny Crosman says TD pled guilty in October and agreed to pay more than $1.8 billion to resolve the Justice Department's investigation. Ansari, citing Lisa Monaco, says the bank starved its compliance program of resources, and a criminal network bribed employees with gift cards.

Why don't banks' transaction monitoring systems catch more money laundering?

Ansari says criminals can look convincing enough to bypass checks for a long time, and software across a bank's divisions often does not talk to each other. Banks also tend to invest only the minimum in people, processes and technology.

Is AI the answer to catching money laundering?

Ansari says it is part of the answer. It can scale analysis and rank alerts so analysts are not overwhelmed, but he says a human should stay in the loop and that better use of existing tools comes first.

What is the 'cost of doing business' problem with bank fines?

Ansari says fines were often smaller than the money banks made from loans and deposits tied to laundered funds, so banks simply accepted them. He also says individuals are not facing jail, though he thinks there should be some recourse for them.

Will stronger anti-money laundering checks affect ordinary customers?

Yes, Ansari says. Tighter analysis will likely mean more inconvenience, such as automated account closures without explanation, though customers typically do not lose access to their money. He says that cost is small next to the fines.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

TD Bank pled guilty in October and agreed to pay more than $1.8 billion in penalties to resolve a Justice Department investigation into Bank Secrecy Act and money laundering violations, according to Penny Crosman.

“So in October, TD Bank pled guilty and agreed to pay more than $1.8 billion in penalties to resolve the Justice Department's investigation into its violations of the BSA Act and money laundering rules.”

0:01:07 · Penny Crosman · TD Bank penalty

Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco said every bank compliance official in America should study the TD Bank charges as an example of what not to do.

“Every bank compliance official in America should be reviewing today's charges as a key study of what not to do, Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco said when the charges were announced.”

0:01:07 · Penny Crosman · DOJ statement

Attorney General Merrick Garland said TD Bank chose profits over compliance with the law, as quoted by Penny Crosman.

“TD Bank chose profits over compliance with the law, a decision that is now costing the bank billions of dollars in penalties.”

0:01:43 · Penny Crosman · DOJ statement

The operators of one money laundering network that processed more than $470 million through TD Bank gave employees gift cards worth more than $57,000 to keep their transactions processing.

“The operators of one money laundering network that processed more than $470 million through the bank gave employees gift cards worth more than $57 ,000”

0:01:43 · Penny Crosman · Employee bribery

Aaron Ansari cites Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco as saying TD Bank starved its compliance program of the resources it needed to obey the law.

“for years, TD Bank starved its compliance program of the resources they needed to obey the law.”

0:03:33 · Aaron Ansari · Compliance resources

Aaron Ansari says banks' employee handbooks include anti-bribery policies and limits on gifts from customers and vendors, such as coffee worth under $15 or $20.

“All banks in their employee handbooks, in their acceptable use documents when an employee is onboarded has an anti-bribery and in just a limit on the acceptance of gifts”

0:02:41 · Aaron Ansari · Gift policies

Aaron Ansari says Wells Fargo bankers opened fake accounts because internal contests and promotions rewarded the number of accounts and deposits.

“You think back to Wells Fargo, when they were opening fake accounts under companies and humans that didn't exist, those bankers were incentivized by Wells Fargo due to internal contests”

0:07:19 · Aaron Ansari · Wells Fargo accounts

Penny Crosman says a large bank kept Jeffrey Epstein as a customer for many years after he had been indicted, despite compliance flags on his account.

“there was a large bank that kept him on as a customer for many years after he had already been indicted for various crimes.”

0:09:08 · Penny Crosman · Epstein banking

Aaron Ansari says bank fines historically did not exceed the revenue generated from laundered money, so banks still profited.

“The fines didn't outdo the monetary value that was generated from the programs. So if you're generating a lot of money and loans off of the laundered money, and your fine is much less than that, you're still making money.”

0:11:04 · Aaron Ansari · Fines economics

Aaron Ansari says TD's fine is paid from actual cash on hand, not future profits or deposits.

“This is the money that's sitting, quote unquote, in their bank.”

0:10:35 · Aaron Ansari · TD fine

Aaron Ansari says there should be some recourse for individuals as well as the organization when banks circumvent best practices, though he does not say people should go to jail.

“there should be some sort of recourse for the individuals as well as the organization.”

0:13:10 · Aaron Ansari · Individual accountability

Aaron Ansari describes a laundering method in which people overpay loan installments with dirty funds and receive a refund check for the excess.

“a lot of times people take out loans from institutions and then they pay back more than what's due on the loan each month.”

0:13:31 · Aaron Ansari · Loan overpayment laundering

Aaron Ansari says software across a bank's divisions sometimes does not communicate, letting laundering continue unnoticed for a long time.

“sometimes the software doesn't talk to each other. Sometimes the platforms don't necessarily align and you're able to get by for a long time”

0:14:57 · Aaron Ansari · System silos

Aaron Ansari says that in consulting he advises banks to refine existing systems before buying new software.

“You can work a lot with what you have currently, and we want to just ensure that we refine it so that it's as efficient as possible.”

0:17:34 · Aaron Ansari · AML consulting

Aaron Ansari says artificial intelligence helps analysts with scale and alert fatigue in AML monitoring.

“artificial intelligence certainly helps from a scalability and from a fatigue standpoint for analysts that are doing the alert and the monitoring of these sorts of things”

0:18:12 · Aaron Ansari · AI in AML

Aaron Ansari describes rules-based AML monitoring as if-then rules, such as a phone call when someone deposits more than $10,000 in cash.

“if you deposit more than $10 ,000 cash, then you get a phone call.”

0:20:15 · Aaron Ansari · Rules-based monitoring

Aaron Ansari describes the placement stage of money laundering as the first step, using structuring, currency exchanges or asset purchases to move dirty money into the legitimate system.

“There's what's called the placement stage, right? Where there's structuring or currency exchanges or asset purchases that are done sort of in the first step”

0:20:50 · Aaron Ansari · Laundering stages

Aaron Ansari says TD is the 10th largest bank in the world, or at least North America, and was hit with a $3 billion penalty.

“TD's 10th largest bank in the world, or at least North America, and they're hit with a $3 billion penalty.”

0:22:37 · Aaron Ansari · TD Bank size

Aaron Ansari says some software packages automatically decline and close accounts, and retail bankers may not know why.

“certain software packages automatically decline and even close accounts.”

0:23:51 · Aaron Ansari · Automated account closures

Aaron Ansari predicts banks will adopt software that monitors for insider threats, though not Big Brother-style monitoring.

“software that's used to look at insider threats or insider malicious activities for sure.”

0:26:44 · Aaron Ansari · Insider threat monitoring

Aaron Ansari says distributed ledger technology (blockchain) provides immutable, transparent transaction records that could make tracing money easier, though it is still nascent.

“distributed ledger technology or blockchain, right? Like you've got blockchain that provides, you know, immutable, transparent records of transactions that make it easier to trace money.”

0:26:44 · Aaron Ansari · Blockchain

Aaron Ansari says biometric know-your-customer checks will spread only if banks can counter voice cloning and deepfake facial overlays.

“provided that you can mitigate the stolen voice AI sort of things that come out there and mimic somebody's voice or do the facial overlays from a deepfake standpoint.”

0:27:50 · Aaron Ansari · Biometric KYC

Chapters

  1. 0:03:33TD Bank's case and the question of bribed employees

    Introduces the TD Bank guilty plea and gift-card bribery, and why starving compliance of resources matters more than pay or culture.

    “for years, TD Bank starved its compliance program of the resources they needed to obey the law”
  2. 0:06:17Why deposits come first at banks

    Explains how the drive for deposits and account-based incentives, as at Wells Fargo, leads staff to accept suspicious cash.

    “The primary business is to take deposits, right? So you want to be as frictionless as possible”
  3. 0:11:04Fines as the cost of doing business

    Covers how historically small penalties let banks profit from laundering and why Ansari wants individual recourse.

    “The fines didn't outdo the monetary value that was generated from the programs.”
  4. 0:14:57Why monitoring software misses laundering

    Describes loan overpayment schemes and disconnected systems across bank divisions that let activity go unnoticed.

    “sometimes the software doesn't talk to each other. Sometimes the platforms don't necessarily align”
  5. 0:18:12Using AI and tuning alerts

    Argues for refining existing tools first, then using AI with humans in the loop to rank alerts and detect laundering stages.

    “there should always be a human in the loop”
  6. 0:23:51Customer lockouts versus billion-dollar fines

    Explains why banks accept closing legitimate accounts when the alternative is a massive penalty.

    “Is that worse than a billion dollar fine in actual cash on hand? Never.”
  7. 0:27:50Future tools: insider monitoring, blockchain, biometrics

    Previews technologies expected to help, and the deepfake risks that come with biometric checks.

    “you'll see a larger proliferation of fingerprint, facial recognitions, biometrics”

Transcript

0:00:00
Speaker 3

Want to know the latest on what's happening in the world of financial services? Tune in to Banking with Interest, a podcast from Intrify, a fintech that provides innovative products to help banks and financial firms of all sizes stay competitive. Hosted by Rob Blackwell, the former editor-in-chief of American Banker, Banking with Interest features current and former regulators, banking executives, journalists, and analysts discussing the financial services policy debates roiling Washington. Listen to Banking with Interest, available on all major podcasting platforms, or go to www.intrafine.com to click on the link on our homepage.

0:00:36
Penny Crosman

Welcome to the American Banker podcast. I'm Penny Crosman. For some large banks, compliance with anti-money laundering rules has been an epic fail. TD Bank, Bank of America, and Wells Fargo are among the banks that have been cited recently for AML violations. All the big banks have software that's designed to catch money laundering and people who are trained to investigate transactions for signs of money laundering. So why does this keep happening? Our guest today, Aaron Ansari, oversaw anti-money laundering efforts at a large U.S.

0:01:07

bank and a prior job. Today, he's an independent consultant, but he has an insider view of what goes wrong and what might be done to fix it. Welcome, Aaron. Pleasure to be here. Thank you, Penny. So in October, TD Bank pled guilty and agreed to pay more than $1.8 billion in penalties to resolve the Justice Department's investigation into its violations of the BSA Act and money laundering rules. Every bank compliance official in America should be reviewing today's charges as a key study of what not to do, Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco said when the charges were announced.

0:01:43

Merrick Garland said by making its services convenient for criminals, TD Bank became one. TD Bank chose profits over compliance with the law, a decision that is now costing the bank billions of dollars in penalties. So not to pick on TD Bank, but it has had one of the biggest cases in recent history. So one problem in TD's case is that criminals were apparently bribing employees to help them launder money. The operators of one money laundering network that processed more than $470 million through the bank gave employees gift cards worth more than $57 ,000 to ensure they would continue to process their transactions.

0:02:24

Aaron, what might a bank do to discourage employees from taking bribes like this? Is there an element of if you pay people better and treat them well, they're less likely to be lured into this kind of complicitness, or is that naive?

0:02:41
Aaron Ansari

Certainly that's an element of any business. having a culture where the employees are happy and treated well, obviously will make the output and the performance of that business as high capacity wise as it can be. But I think in this instance, it goes beyond the treatment of employees. All banks in their employee handbooks, in their acceptable use documents when an employee is onboarded has an anti-bribery and in just a limit on the acceptance of gifts that can be received from customers vendors or any third-party entity so if i'm a software vendor that that provides you you know the anti-money laundering software platform i can't send you lavish gifts i can maybe take you out for a cup

0:03:33

of coffee or something under $15, $20 or sorts of things. So that anti-bribery policy is there, and it's founded based off of best practices and those sorts of things. In this instance, if you look further into the DOJ finding, there was a quote from Deputy Attorney General Lisa Monaco that said, for years, TD Bank starved its compliance program of the resources they needed to obey the law. And that fundamentally is what we want to get into, or at least kind of my major point is, as you said in the intro, technology exists, services exist, laws, regulations, platforms, advisors, they all exist to be able to support, I'll say a healthy anti-money laundering program.

0:04:24

But when you starve that program, you don't have what's necessary to do the minimum required for the law. And I'd imagine if you don't give your employees the technology and resources that they need, regardless of how well you treat them, they're not going to be happy.

0:04:44
Penny Crosman

So there are a couple of things I want to follow up on there because I definitely wanted to ask you about the idea of starving the compliance department. But just when you think about the branch employees, You know, there was a description of a criminal network that just dumped piles of cash on the bank's counters. In another case, the people were withdrawing amounts from ATMs that were 50 times higher than the daily limit. But just, you know, when you picture somebody dumping wads of cash on a teller counter, what is it about a bank that just lets employees go along with that and not question that?

0:05:23

I mean, is there – do banks need to have some kind of if-you-see-something-say-something policy like we have the New York City subway or, you know, that idea that everyone's just closing their eyes to this? What culturally causes that and what culturally could stop that?

0:05:45
Aaron Ansari

Sure. So the primary, you know, business of a bank is to take deposits, right, and make money off of those deposits, right, from interest and loans and those sorts of things. If you look back, you know, USV, Isaac Catan Cassin, USV, Alfredo Ruiz Hernandez, these are money laundering, you know, back in the 80s, 90s, where people would drive up with their cars, drug dealers in this instance, and healthcare fraudsters would drive up with their cars with trunks full of money.

0:06:17

and the bank employees would help them unload the wads of cash and the duffel bags full of cash and put them in from a deposit standpoint. The primary business is to take deposits, right? So you want to be as frictionless as possible when you're taking that deposit because the more assets that you have on hand, the better your business is and the more you're able to be able to conduct the business that you want to conduct.

0:06:43

So the more assets you have, the more loans you can get, The more small businesses, you can enable to do their jobs. So fundamentally, that first step for a bank to succeed is taking the deposit. And you want to make that as easy as you can, as compliantly, if that's a word, or being as compliant as possible during that process. And that's sort of the key. If you look at the retail level, so when we're talking about a bank, lots of divisions, you know, there's lending, there's financing, there's investments.

0:07:19

And typically, when I say retail, that's what I mean, you know, the branches that you have out in the physical offices that do consumer and commercial deposits for business accounting. So when you look at the retail level, you know, these bankers are incentivized to have more deposits, to have more accounts. You think back to Wells Fargo, when they were opening fake accounts under companies and humans that didn't exist, those bankers were incentivized by Wells Fargo due to internal contests and internal promotions that were based off of the number of accounts and deposits that they had on hand or loans that were applied for.

0:08:02

And so the bank didn't do a good job to stop Wells Fargo from creating fictitious accounts. So looking at this, they want to do as much as possible to enable the deposits. I think recently there was a case of money laundering that came, I believe it was from some quote unquote princess or royalty in the Middle East that wanted to deposit $9 million to start an account and was depositing large amounts or transferring large amounts of money to a financial institution from the Middle East with no, obviously we know about KYC, know your customer laws.

0:08:40

Nobody had met this person. And the story kept changing on if they were royalty or how they got their money or the source of funds and these sorts of things. Eventually, the account was closed because it was proven to be money laundering. So good on the bank for finding things. But the primary function of the way that the business is, is to make that deposit and access to taking money as frictionless or as easy as possible.

0:09:08
Penny Crosman

Well, your example reminds me of the Jeffrey Epstein case. And, you know, there was a large bank that kept him on as a customer for many years after he had already been indicted for various crimes. And the overall sense you got is that he was not only a lucrative customer in his own right, but would be able to bring in other wealthy customers and that all of that overrode the compliance flags that continually cropped up on his account.

0:09:42

So I don't know if there's an answer to this, but banks are intrinsically wired to try to generate revenue and to put that above things that are cost centers like compliance. I mean, is there any way to kind of flip that around other than a very large fine?

0:10:05
Aaron Ansari

You know, the carrot versus the stick sort of is an easy way to boil down this. And I mean, if you look at this fine, it's astronomical, right? Like just if and to the people that I talk to in the financial services industries that see this, understand that this is a fine. This isn't, this is actual cash on hand that's being given. It's not future profits or deposits or those sorts of things that are being penalized.

0:10:35

This is the money that's sitting, quote unquote, in their bank. And, you know, if you look at some of the reasons of how banks allow money laundering, right, there's a couple of main domains that I talk about. There's active collusion, right, where key offices that are directly involved in circumventing regulations happen. So in your example, right, the gift cards and those sorts of things, there's active collusion with the fraudster to do this. So that facilitates laundering.

0:11:04

negligent practices, right? A lack of compliance or internal checks that are in place that just allow this to happen. The point that I want to harp on next is like exportation of jurisdictional loopholes or regulatory weaknesses, right? For the longest time, the enforcement and or the penalty that came down to the poor practices that were being exposed. The fines didn't outdo the monetary value that was generated from the programs. So if you're generating a lot of money and loans off of the laundered money, and your fine is much less than that, you're still making money.

0:11:55

so you know these these people aren't going they're not suffering federal crimes or aren't going to jail themselves so the bank still having to pay you know some sort of penalty in this instance well what great is in certain instances something that that several institutions are just you know accepting as the cost of doing business.

0:12:25
Penny Crosman

So basically there is no way to make compliance feel more important except by making the fines extremely large, is that?

0:12:36
Aaron Ansari

For the most part, sure. I mean, I'm not going to say that people should go to jail over things like this because that gets into a larger discussion of corporate responsibility and individual responsibility to corporations. But, you know, at the end of the day, when you are found guilty of something by the DOJ, and it's pretty obvious as your business practices supported that, there are people within that organization that made the decisions to circumvent those best practices and to ignore the warning signs that were popping up, as you just gave in your example.

0:13:10

And, you know, in my mind, there should be some sort of recourse for the individuals as well as the organization.

0:13:17
Penny Crosman

Well, now most banks have transaction monitoring software that is supposed to flag the signs of money laundering. Why doesn't that work the way it should?

0:13:31
Aaron Ansari

Yeah, so that other piece that I just mentioned, like circumvention of, we'll say, technology, jurisdictional loopholes or regulatory weaknesses, is kind of the name of the game. And when and if you can sound convincing enough or be somebody that's committing fraud that will be able to bypass things for long enough, you can get away with a lot. An easy example is when you're laundering money, a lot of times people take out loans from institutions and then they pay back more than what's due on the loan each month.

0:14:13

So they then have access to that additional funds that are being deposited back either to borrow from or to get a refund check for. and so in an instance if I take out a loan and my payment is my my installment every month is $10,000 and I pay $12,000 I get 2,000 dollar check back right and in that in that instance I'm wandering money right I'm using dirty funds to pay the $12,000 and I'm getting you know a certain the $10,000 I pay twelve and I get 2,000 of it back so there are certain you know ways that you can get around even the softwares and the regulations to

0:14:57

find things. And from a bank perspective, it's great. You know, somebody's paying us on time, everything's good. And for most of the systems that cover or check that, because remember, this is across multiple divisions or institutions within a bank, sometimes the software doesn't talk to each other. Sometimes the platforms don't necessarily align and you're able to get by for a long time doing things or operating you know sort of under the radar and it's unfortunate but you know from a business standpoint you don't want to invest these are these organizations are trying to be profitable and you know if they don't have to invest more into people into processes into technologies that that will mitigate this, they won't.

0:15:45

And that's not just anti-money laundering. That's everything. Software, programs, benefits, right? Most organizations don't want to invest more than they have to from a bare minimum standpoint. And you see that, I think, more publicly with money laundering cases, but that pervases across a lot of how an organization's culture is.

0:16:09
Penny Crosman

So if a bank, say, is subject to a large penalty or thinks they might be, they realize they've got to step up their AML efforts, what might they do with their software? You know, if this were you, would you look into an AI-based AML system? Would you look into tuning the AML system to have stronger signals? Are there other things that could be done from a technology point of view to help a bank better catch all of this?

0:16:48

And I realize it depends on the bank and what's happening. But generally speaking, for instance, do you think AI is part of the answer?

0:16:57
Aaron Ansari

Part of it, sure. I don't want to go through and say that spend more money and grow your tech stack to be bigger and more complex is the answer. But I do want to say a couple of things. Setting up your environment correctly, ensuring cross-platform communication, ensuring configuration. configuration as it relates to the money laundering itself, as well as notifications of the team, as well as investigations and enabling those sorts of things, won't necessarily cost you more.

0:17:34

So when I am consulting with somebody, I don't try to come in and say, you need to buy this newest and greatest and shiniest software, otherwise your program is just not going to work. It's not true. You can work a lot with what you have currently, and we want to just ensure that we refine it so that it's as efficient as possible. Then once you've sort of used the building blocks and the bricks that you've got in place, then we can talk about stacking more on top, or we can talk about removing one component and adding something else in to sort of augment things.

0:18:12

artificial intelligence certainly helps from a scalability and from a fatigue standpoint for analysts that are doing the alert and the monitoring of these sorts of things but there should always be a human in the loop and i you know when i'm talking to these organizations i always want to make certain that that there's enough human in the loop involved to where the team isn't being totally overrun with alerts and notifications so that they just, you know, get what's called alert fatigue and they just, you know, blanket accept or completely ignore things that are medium or low criticality.

0:18:51

When we're looking at things, refinement of those rules, high, medium, low, or, you know, super critical is paramount because, you know, not every alert should be super high critical, but not every alert should be medium or low. And that's where artificial intelligence can really help. Because if you're using a software platform that will help you understand kind of the nuances and the components between what is hair on fire and what is, we could probably ignore this and look at it once we get more capacity on the team.

0:19:27

That's where you're really gonna have a good balance and have a lot of value to both your customers as well as your compliance and regulatory team.

0:19:35
Penny Crosman

Yeah, that's an interesting observation that the red flags could be given, you know, indicators of how hot and cold they are. And when you talk about this refinement, is there an element of law enforcement or somebody providing some of the patterns of behavior that money launderers are having, and then you can kind of plug that into your system. So like if this network is doing, you know, has this pattern of transactions in these regions, for instance, then you might be on the lookout for that.

0:20:15
Aaron Ansari

that part of that work? For certain. So, you know, years ago, we'll use what's called sort of the rules-based methodology. And if you think of them as like if-then statements, if you deposit more than $10 ,000 cash, then you get a phone call. Or if you transfer more than X amount of dollars in a 48, 72-hour period, you get a phone call or an investigation. Now, obviously, there's more complex stages that criminals have used to bypass these things.

0:20:50

There's what's called the placement stage, right? Where there's structuring or currency exchanges or asset purchases that are done sort of in the first step to move dirty money to put it in some sort of legitimate financial system or financial structure so that if it's an asset or some currency exchange that's happening, it looks to be a little bit more legitimate. And that's harder to track from a rule standpoint. And so if you start writing a thousand rules to look at every transaction, your transactions start to slow down.

0:21:26

So this is where artificial intelligence comes in, right? And it's able to do complex analysis at millions, if not trillions of permutations per second. And it's able to come through and say, hey, okay, I know what placement staging looks like. I know what layering stages or concealing the source looks like. I know what integration stages or legitimizing funds looks like. And I'm going to go through here and I'm going to tell you, you know, this is the integration stage or this is the layering stage and you should look at it.

0:21:57

The rub comes between applying those techniques or those systems to, you know, legitimate transactions, right? And then you've got an instance where you're stopping a business from being able to do its business or stopping, you know, grandma from transferring money for Timmy's college fund sort of thing. However, most institutions need to either educate their consumers on the fact that this is going to be coming or do more for it. Because, you know, And I keep going back to it.

0:22:37

TD's 10th largest bank in the world, or at least North America, and they're hit with a $3 billion penalty. That is a lot of money to be penalized. And inconveniencing the customer is probably going to be something that's more of the norm as organizations start to tighten up on the analysis that's used to do these stages.

0:23:01
Penny Crosman

Well, that's another really interesting aspect of this because you and I have talked about this before, but when banks really ratchet up their flagging process for, you know, whether it's for AML or for other kinds of suspicious transactions, that legitimate consumers can suddenly get locked out of their accounts, have their accounts shut down or frozen. And I think we talked about how AI can help with that as well, right? Can AI kind of help to find the nuance between the legitimate money launderers versus someone who just, you know, went on a worldwide trip and was buying gifts for friends or something like that that might look anomalous?

0:23:51
Aaron Ansari

For sure. And what we need to think about here is consumer or small time versus big time. And what I mean by that is certain software packages automatically decline and even close accounts. And okay, I closed John's account and I no longer have John with a hundred some odd $1,000 in deposits in my banking system. Boo hoo. Is that worse than a billion dollar fine in actual cash on hand? Never. and I could lose 100 Johns or 100 Johns businesses or Jane's or Sally's businesses and still not equal the penalty that could come from future deposits versus cash on hand.

0:24:41

And so you will see, and I think you have seen, software packages and platforms and artificial intelligence, right? Algorithmic decisions that are being made that are automatically just telling the retail banker that, hey, you know, the system was closed. I don't know why it was closed. You know, if I'm at the retail bank level, I don't know why it was closed. The system just says it's closed. So sorry, we can open you a new account or we can transfer this over to another institution or something for you.

0:25:09

You don't typically lose access to your money. But that inconvenience is so much more minimal than the actual fine is.

0:25:20
Penny Crosman

Interesting. And is there any other kind of technology that could be brought to bear on these money laundering cases? You know, for instance, do you think there's going to be more banks are going to be looking at employee surveillance to try to catch these kinds of complicit behavior that we saw in this case? Or are there other things that the banks could be thinking about that could help them not allow criminals to use their banks as part of their networks?

0:25:53
Aaron Ansari

Yeah, so insider fraud, that's something that's a tough thing because you want to trust the employees that you have working for you. And it's appropriate that you started this discussion with kind of culture as the question that you posed because we're coming back around to it now. Now, do I want to work in a culture where every decision I make is scrutinized and watched, monitored, questioned? Probably not, right? So having that balance between enabling the employee to do their job as well as trusting the employee to do their job versus ensuring that there aren't some bad actors within your organization is certainly going to increase.

0:26:44

And I think you'll see, I won't say Big Brother like monitoring, but I will say software that's used to look at insider threats or insider malicious activities for sure. You know, the other thing, you know, I think you'll see this come to light in the next few years is, and I'm not trying to use buzzword bingo here, but distributed ledger technology or blockchain, right? Like you've got blockchain that provides, you know, immutable, transparent records of transactions that make it easier to trace money.

0:27:16

I'm not talking about Bitcoin or those sorts of things, but I'm talking about the smart contracts, decentralized identifiers, transparent transactions that can come with sort of that DLT, distributed ledger technology. That'll be something that I think will help once it gets more than where it is now, which is completely nascent. And once it gets a little bit more bigger and, you know, I wouldn't even say mainstream, I'll say just accept it as part of a technology stack.

0:27:50

I think you'll see that help a little bit, right, as it relates to understanding, you know, what's happening. And then I think at sort of the customer level or even the retail level, enhanced technologies for KYC will start to help. I think you'll see a larger proliferation of fingerprint, facial recognitions, biometrics, right? Those sorts of things that will enable KYC to be easier and more frictionless, provided that you can mitigate the stolen voice AI sort of things that come out there and mimic somebody's voice or do the facial overlays from a deepfake standpoint.

0:28:45

I do think you'll see some sort of enhanced customer verification that can come and bypass some of the threats that's coming off of things. as well as better refinement, more cloud computing and scalability that comes to the AML, things that are there, robotic process or automations that can be applied to AML and repetitive tasks and those sorts of things that'll come into play. You'll start to see that proliferate more and more.

0:29:18
Penny Crosman

Well, that makes sense. Well, Aaron, thanks so much for joining us today. And to all of you, thank you for listening. to the American Banker podcast. I produced this episode with audio production by Adnan Khan. Special thanks this week to Aaron Ansari. Rate us, review us, and subscribe to our content at www.americanbanker.com slash subscribe. For American Banker, I'm Penny Crosman, and thanks for listening.