# OCC's Michael Hsu on crypto policy: 'We want to get it right'

- **Show:** Barefoot Innovation Podcast
- **Published:** 27 Apr 2022
- **Source:** https://barefootinnovation.libsyn.com/occs-michael-hsu-on-crypto-policy-we-want-to-get-it-right
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/barefoot-innovation/occs-michael-hsu-on-crypto-policy-we-want-to-get-it-right-cad1df/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

Acting Comptroller of the Currency Michael Hsu argues that crypto is not inevitable and that regulators and the public should decide now what they want from it. He treats stablecoins as the foundation of the crypto system. In his view, three choices (how stable, how interoperable and how separable from banking they should be) should be settled early, so that innovators can build within them and regulators stop chasing each new product.

The main tension is between innovation and protection. Crypto promises inclusion and lower costs, but it also brings volatility, scams, irreversible transactions and weak consumer recourse. Hsu says regulators must look at the big picture and the details at once. They should favor stability for money-like products and leave room for innovation elsewhere. He also warns that blockchain technology has built-in trade-offs, and that a community-driven culture may sit on top of very transactional technology.

## Key insights

1. **Stablecoins are the base layer of crypto** Hsu says about $180 billion of stablecoins supports a crypto market of roughly $1 trillion or more, because most exchange trading is done against stablecoins. Trouble there would spread to the whole ecosystem, which is why regulators are starting there.
2. **Three early design choices should guide stablecoin policy** Hsu proposes deciding how stable, how interoperable and how separable from banks stablecoins should be. Once those lines are set, innovators can work inside them and regulators stop reacting to each new product.
3. **A bank-style approach yields more stable money** Hsu contrasts a disclosure-based model like money market funds with a bank-supervision model. Money funds needed bailouts in 2008 and again during the pandemic, so he argues the bank approach is more reliable when stability matters most.
4. **Blockchains cannot easily talk to each other** Hsu compares each blockchain to a different rail gauge, since Ethereum, Solana and Tron use different code and cryptography. The cross-chain bridges that connect them are fragile, and hacks such as the Axie and Wormhole incidents came from bridges.
5. **Crypto's inclusion promise has real trade-offs** Hsu notes that some communities are drawn to crypto because traditional banking has served them poorly. But Ethereum gas fees can be very high, and irreversible, intermediary-free transactions leave consumers with little recourse after scams or lost keys.

## Questions this episode answers

### What is a stablecoin and why do regulators care so much about them?

A stablecoin is a crypto token meant to hold a steady value, such as one US dollar. Hsu says about $180 billion of them supports the whole crypto market, so a failure could hurt many people and weaken the dollar's role.

### Should stablecoin issuers have to be regulated like banks?

Hsu says there are two models: a disclosure-based one like money market funds, and a bank-style prudential one. He argues the bank approach is more stable, and notes that a presidential working group report also leaned that way. The exact setup may need new legislation.

### Why can't one stablecoin or blockchain just work with another?

Hsu says today's stablecoins like Tether and USD Coin are separate and must be traded to move between them. Blockchains such as Ethereum and Solana use different code, and the bridges linking them are fragile and have been hacked.

### What is the blockchain trilemma?

Hsu cites Vitalik Buterin's idea that a blockchain can have only two of three qualities: decentralization, security and scalability. Ethereum is decentralized and secure but struggles to scale, while Solana gives up some decentralization to scale.

### Is crypto good or bad for lower-income and minority consumers?

Hsu says both are true. Crypto appeals to groups that traditional banking has often failed, and it is disproportionately held by younger, diverse and underbanked people. But it is volatile and full of scams, so he wants opportunity and protection together.

## Facts

- **Jo Ann Barefoot** [0:07:45]: "Its arcane-sounding name arises from the fact that it was established during the U.S. Civil War to literally get control over the currency at a chaotic time when money consisted of privately issued banknotes."
- **Jo Ann Barefoot** [0:01:34]: "that framing has shifted in March when President Biden issued an executive order on the topic."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:10:33]: "And as we all know, it got out of control. And that's kind of how we got into the financial crisis of 2008."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:12:15]: "That Larry David ad is hilarious. It's a really funny ad. And it's very effective because it equates crypto to the wheel, the fork, the light bulb."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:14:23]: "In some cases, it's not. I mean, look at the gas fees on Ethereum. Those are very, very high."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:17:36]: "almost one in five Americans has crypto. Almost as many people have crypto as they do fixed income exposure."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:18:08]: "I was at a recent event with the Financial Literacy Education Commission, which is kind of co-headed by Treasury and the CFPB, and we were talking about crypto literacy."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:22:40]: "the crypto total value out there is around $2 1 trillion, plus or minus. That rests on about $180 billion of stablecoins."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:24:11]: "The dollar cannot live on-chain. Stablecoins can live on-chain. The dollar cannot."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:27:00]: "if you look at money funds, we've had to bail them out twice now. So in 2008, they had to get bailed out. And again, in the pandemic, they had to get bailed out."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:27:24]: "that's why the PWG report has come out to say, hey, if you want this thing to be stable, you should take a bank approach."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:35:03]: "Before the OCC existed, we had this really unstable free banking system in the U.S. where there was no uniform dollar."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:35:34]: "And with the National Currency Act and the creation of the OCC, you start to stabilize it. You have an interoperable dollar across the whole country."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:38:15]: "The stablecoin world we have today does not have that, right? A USD, a Tether, USD, C-Circle, those are not interoperable."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:39:27]: "Those are fragile. These hacks, the Axie hack that just happened, Polygon, Wormhole, are because of these cross-chain bridges."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:40:42]: "TCP IP was created, right? It was a standard that was created upon which everything else kind of gets built on top of it."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:41:24]: "some of them are actually today part of the crypto world, are saying, hey, they were part of W3C and IETF and these kinds of things."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:44:34]: "Vitalik Buterin has highlighted this blockchain trilemma. You can have decentralization, security, scalability. You can basically have two out of three, but you can't get all three."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:45:07]: "some of the alternatives to Ethereum, like Solana, basically give up decentralization for scalability."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:45:07]: "And I think Moxie Marlins Spike kind of highlighted this in one of his blog posts, you know, was skeptical of saying, hey, there's always going to be centralized intermediaries."
- **Michael Hsu** [0:49:54]: "A DAO is just a set of rules. And so like, what do you grab?"
- **Michael Hsu** [0:50:27]: "Philip Dan at Cornell has talked about minor extractable value. You got this MEV problem with Ethereum or with some of the blockchains in general, which is basically front running."

## Transcript

**[0:00:00] Michael Hsu:** my starting points in terms of thinking about stable coins. Once you identify those kind of overall objectives, I think there's really three main, what I call architectural choices with stable coins. There's going to be many more, but the three that I would start with are how stable do you want stable coins to be? How interoperable do you want stable coins to be? Like how fungible and how separable from the banking system, at least initially, do want them to be.

**[0:00:28] Michael Hsu:** Because once you set those choices, then the innovators can innovate. And we can let that kind of take, otherwise you're constantly be, we as regulators are constantly chasing whatever the next new thing is and how do we think about it. And every week there's a new thing. It's very hard to keep up with. Every day. Every day, right. So I think we really do want to kind of step back and say, well, what are the architectural considerations about what we really care about.

**[0:00:57] Michael Hsu:** Let's try to snap those chalk lines in place and then move from there. And I think it's really stability, interoperability, and separability are kind of the three. There's going to be more, but I would start there.

**[0:01:34] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Barefoot Innovation starts right now. My guest today is Michael Hsu, the acting controller of the currency, and we are talking all things and only things crypto. Financial regulators everywhere have escalated this issue in 2022 as the volumes of activity and the flows of capital in crypto markets have skyrocketed. Until recently, U.S. regulators have tended to emphasize crypto's risks, but that framing has shifted in March when President Biden issued an executive order on the topic. It calls on multiple agencies to develop strategies that are going to aim for a balance, are going to seek to reap the potential benefits of this new technology while also minimizing its dangers.

**[0:02:24] Jo Ann Barefoot:** More and more agencies and officials have been weighing in. As part of that dialogue, the conversation in today's episode really stands out. The acting controller shares reflections that reach down deeply, parsing these challenges and all their novelty, complexity, and nuance. He doesn't claim to have it all figured out, but in my view, he has figured out a great deal about how to approach the decisions ahead, starting with the values that should underpin public policy. He talks us through what the goals should be, how crypto is and is not similar to earlier kinds of financial innovation, the trade-offs that we're going to have to choose among the types of regulatory strategies available, and even how to ponder some of the

**[0:03:11] Jo Ann Barefoot:** philosophical questions arising in this new financial terrain. Acting controller Sue is known for his intense intellectual curiosity, and I think it really shows in this conversation. One key insight is his focus on stable coins. He views them as the foundation layer of the whole crypto system and argues that if we regulate them wisely, the rest is likely to work. He cites the three core questions that need answers, namely how stable should stable coins be, how fungible should they be, and how separable should they be from the banking system.

**[0:03:48] Jo Ann Barefoot:** He also cites the two basic models that we could use for regulating them along with what he calls the knobs and dials available for fine tuning. And another helpful insight is his argument that we're going to need to figure out both the macro and the micro issues at the same time. He calls it zooming in and zooming out simultaneously if we're going to get it right. I really think that's a powerful insight. Another key issue is financial inclusion.

**[0:04:19] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Crypto investors are disproportionately young, lower income, and people of color. That is, they come from groups that have often not felt well-served by traditional finance. I think this fact has actually given pause to many people who jump to the assumption that crypto is bad for consumers. But how real is the chance that crypto actually could open doors for more people to build wealth? And how can they be protected from the tremendous risks in this sector?

**[0:04:49] Jo Ann Barefoot:** The acting controller reminds us that April is financial literacy month, and we know that not many people are literate in crypto yet. For example, he points out that blockchains reduce costs by removing intermediaries from the system, but in the process of doing that, they may also remove recourse. And he points out that consumers are not accustomed to that, so how much regulatory protection should they have? Our conversation covers a lot of other ground. We talk about the lack of interoperability among today's stablecoins.

**[0:05:26] Jo Ann Barefoot:** We talk about the whole question of chartering versus stablecoins. We talk about inherent limitations in blockchain technologies, the evolution of central bank digital currencies, the role of the U.S. dollar as the world's reserve currency, whether U.S. regulation could undermine America's international competitiveness, the unique challenges that are posed by regulating DAOs, since they are basically just sets of rules, the potential lessons from the birth of the internet, and the blockchain trilemma that has been cited by Vitalik Buterin, forcing prioritized choices for us between decentralization, security, and scalability.

**[0:06:12] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Acting controller Sue also ponders the human factor as people feel a sense of community in decentralized finance, but at the same time are embracing a world that promises the potential to monetize and transact around nearly every aspect of our lives. We talked about the challenge arising from the sheer pace and novelty of all this change, especially for regulators. The acting controller challenges the stereotype that financial regulators are, as he put it, stodgy and living in the past.

**[0:06:45] Jo Ann Barefoot:** And in my view, the interview is Exhibit A in making his point. At the same time, we hear in this conversation the voice of the seasoned financial regulator who knows things can go wrong because they have. He makes a critical point that I think needs to animate all the work ahead, which is that now is the time to get the architecture right and that we need to have all of the right people at the table now.

**[0:07:13] Jo Ann Barefoot:** The innovators and the commercial interests, yes, and also the people whose role is to represent the public interest and they need to work together. If we could turn back the clock and design the Internet with the benefit of what we know today, we probably would have done some things differently. And in fact, maybe we'll actually get to do that in Web3. But this is the time to be thinking through these issues for crypto and DeFi. The Office of the Controller of the Currency is America's oldest federal financial regulator.

**[0:07:45] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Its arcane-sounding name arises from the fact that it was established during the U.S. Civil War to literally get control over the currency at a chaotic time when money consisted of privately issued banknotes. I myself was a deputy controller of the currency years ago. And as crypto comes of age, we are seeing these new issues raising similar challenges to the ones that faced people over 150 years ago. I know you're going to enjoy listening to my guest today, acting controller of the currency, Michael Hsu, on how best to meet these challenges.

**[0:08:24] Jo Ann Barefoot:** is today's show is incredibly special because my guest is Michael Hsu the acting controller of the currency welcome thanks for having me I'm thrilled to have you on the show as I think you may know I myself am an OCC alum I was deputy controller of the currency many years ago and love to talk about what the OCC is doing so we're really really thrilled to have you on the show today. And I'm especially excited because we are going to talk all about and only, I think, unless we go off our plan, about crypto and especially stable coins.

**[0:09:08] Jo Ann Barefoot:** And I think the very fact that we're doing that tells us something about the moment that we're in. Not long ago, these were peripheral issues in the financial world. And now we've got Super Bowl commercials and everything else telling us that these kinds of financial activities are going mainstream. So I want to start by asking you to just take a wide lens to this and frame it up for us in terms of how you're thinking about the advent of these new technologies in crypto and even maybe beyond crypto, what we're looking toward on DeFi and Web3.

**[0:09:50] Jo Ann Barefoot:** where do you think we're headed and what are you worried about and what are you positively excited

**[0:09:56] Michael Hsu:** about? So as some of your listeners may know, I've been somewhat of a skeptic with regards to crypto. And part of that's due to the fact that I see some parallels between the rise and promise of crypto with the rise and promise of derivatives. And derivatives is something that's something I've dealt with up close and personal for quite a while. Because in the early 90s, leading into the 2000s, if you go back to that time, a lot of the language and the vibe feels very similar.

**[0:10:33] Michael Hsu:** Because derivatives were seen as solving a problem. They were seen as ways to hedge risk, to lower the cost of credit. And there was a lot of excitement around financial engineering and kind of attracting that talent. And as we all know, it got out of control. And that's kind of how we got into the financial crisis of 2008. And so I see some parallels there that immediately put me into a particular posture of wanting to ask a lot of questions.

**[0:11:04] Michael Hsu:** That being said, I understand crypto is different. So I don't want to belabor the analogy too much. in the kind of the crypto space, I have been trying to just take in a lot of different perspectives because you've got a lot of advocates who lay out very compelling stories and visions for what could be. And then there are some skeptics out there too, who I think have, some of them, the ones who are crypto fluent, if you will, have, I think, laid out some pretty compelling arguments for why one might question the value proposition or the long-term sustainability of cryptocurrencies or Web3.

**[0:11:44] Michael Hsu:** So I've taken kind of all of that in. And I think it's at the same time, no one can deny that there's a huge and growing developer community with a lot of talent. So anytime you get that many smart people together, things are going to happen. The valuations are very high. So there's real money there who are seeing some potential. And there's governments and agencies who are embracing crypto. So those are all data points. Those can't be ignored.

**[0:12:15] Michael Hsu:** But, you know, Joanne, to your original question, I don't have a crystal ball on this any more than anyone else does. The one thing I would say is I do want to push back on this sense of inevitability with crypto on the Web3. You mentioned the Super Bowl ads. That Larry David ad is hilarious. It's a really funny ad. And it's very effective because it equates crypto to the wheel, the fork, the light bulb. And those things have a certain inevitability around them.

**[0:12:51] Michael Hsu:** And I think we're actually in a moment where we should not succumb to that. We should actually, now is the time to take our values. What do we value? What do we want the system to look like? We should have that discussion now. Now is exactly when we should say, okay, what are the choices? What are the trade-offs that we want to make so that the system works for us instead of us working for the system?

**[0:13:14] Michael Hsu:** And I think that that's, you know, I'm really heartened by a lot of the attention and discussion. like you pointed out, huge amounts of discussion right now on stablecoins, because I think people want to engage and have that discussion of like, okay, how do we make this work for us?

**[0:13:31] Jo Ann Barefoot:** So tell me if this is too much asking for the crystal ball, but when you say, let's figure out the values that we want to drive, whatever's going to happen here, can you articulate yet what you think those key values are, the ones that we're at risk of maybe of getting wrong?

**[0:13:50] Michael Hsu:** So the one value I hear more than any other is inclusion. And I think that is fantastic. I think that is really, really value. If I could start somewhere, I would start with inclusion. But that's not just me. I think the industry, a lot of advocates point to inclusion. They say crypto can be more inclusive because it's decentralized and all these other things. Great. Now, I think we need to move down from just the buzzword into, well, what does that mean in practice?

**[0:14:23] Michael Hsu:** And what are the tradeoffs that are involved in achieving that? And one of the things about inclusion that I think right now there's a bit of a reaction to the traditional banking and finance system, which to many people feels not inclusive. It feels like there's a lot of barriers. It's expensive. So is crypto less expensive than the traditional system? In some cases, it's not. I mean, look at the gas fees on Ethereum. Those are very, very high.

**[0:14:53] Michael Hsu:** So is that inclusive? It's not. Now, there's layer two solutions. There's other things around that. But I think we have to be really thoughtful about that because inclusion is not very profitable. And so, you know, how do we ensure that something that's not profitable is protected, is part of the system as a feature, not as kind of an extra? And I think that that deserves a lot of discussion.

**[0:15:18] Jo Ann Barefoot:** I think there are two dimensions to the inclusion issue. Excuse me for my voice. I've got a little bit of a cold. One is the opportunity to drive down costs and make it more profitable to serve more people. And the other is the fact that these new investments are attracting investors who are not sought after. If we talk about crypto assets, they're disproportionately attracting younger people, lower income people, and people of color. And there's one school of thought that is appalled by that because these are the people who perhaps would be most vulnerable to losing money in a high-risk investment and therefore should be protected from it.

**[0:16:07] Jo Ann Barefoot:** And there's another school of thought, and a lot of it is coming from communities of color, arguing that there are a lot of people who have not felt well served, as you just said, by traditional finance. And they see an opportunity here to be welcomed into something that's new and different. And they want a chance to have the upside opportunity that you don't get in a bank savings account. Very complex issue. How are you thinking about that one?

**[0:16:37] Michael Hsu:** So, Joanne, I think you've really laid out some of the key markers there. And it's, you know, April is financial literacy month. So this is kind of a hot topic now is that, you know, what does being crypto literate mean? So I would step back. I like where you started. I think it's good to first acknowledge context. So historically, the US banking system, the traditional banking system, there's a history of redlining, there's a history of predatory lending.

**[0:17:09] Michael Hsu:** That's not the whole system, but those elements have impacted communities of color disproportionately. So we have to acknowledge that. And I think when you, and those are things we're working on, away from crypto, just as part of my day job, what we're focused on the OCC, we're trying to address those things. But that history, I think, is informing why there are some communities that are drawn to crypto because they feel that the traditional system hasn't served them well.

**[0:17:36] Michael Hsu:** And crypto has, because it's decentralized and it's open and et cetera, there's a certain draw to that. I think that is interesting. So you can't discount that. At the same time, though, crypto is very, very volatile. There are a lot of scams. There's a lot of fraud. There are a lot of hacks. So there are people who have lost a lot of money doing that. And so we do want to protect people. I think you had cited, there are these stats now, almost one in five Americans has crypto.

**[0:18:08] Michael Hsu:** Almost as many people have crypto as they do fixed income exposure. That's astounding. That's an astounding statistic. And just like you said, it's disproportionately young, diverse, and underbanked. So I think we want a system that provides opportunities, but it protects people at the same time. Now, going back to financial literacy, I was at a recent event with the Financial Literacy Education Commission, which is kind of co-headed by Treasury and the CFPB, and we were talking about crypto literacy.

**[0:18:40] Michael Hsu:** and within kind of regular financial literacy, they've got this thing called the mymoney5.gov, which is a government website, which is kind of just trying to teach financial literacy. And those principles apply to crypto. I would highly encourage if there's one of your listeners is like, maybe I should get into crypto, go look at those principles because it's all about how do you make your money? You want to earn, you want to save, you want to protect, you want to spend, you want to borrow.

**[0:19:10] Michael Hsu:** Those are the principles. How does crypto fit into that? It will fit in differently for different people, but I can guarantee you in no case will it say, put all your life savings in crypto. Don't do that. But you hear that chatter because I think there's a lot of excitement around it. So I think when it comes to matters of money, we have to be objective. We want to make sure that we're protecting people while enabling those opportunities at the same

**[0:19:35] Jo Ann Barefoot:** time. I couldn't agree with you more. At the same time, we know that our efforts at financial literacy and educating people through disclosure have had mixed success at best. And if we think about how can we protect people better in coming into these new kinds of areas, Does the technology itself, does the fact that this is at its heart technology even more than, you know, we can make that same point about money, but this is digitized information.

**[0:20:18] Jo Ann Barefoot:** That's all it is. Does that create opportunities to regulate and supervise in new ways in an area like consumer protection or any area, really?

**[0:20:31] Michael Hsu:** It may. I think it's one of the trickiest things about, we'll just talk about blockchains in general, is that the way it's designed, it's supposed to be trust-resistant, censorship-resistant. So it's less on the intermediaries, less reliance on intermediaries, more reliance on yourself, and it's irreversible by design. from a consumer protection. Those are very tough things from a consumer protection standpoint. You hear if you're in the Bitcoin world, you lose your keys, you lose your coin.

**[0:21:08] Michael Hsu:** Not your keys, not your coin. There's a lot of self-responsibility. These are complicated things to do. I think people are not necessarily used to that. Can they get used to it? Maybe. I think this is where a lot of this conversation has to take place at multiple levels. And I think it is worth it kind of engaging communities to say, well, where are you on these things? Recognizing that there's an awful lot of, again, I just wanna ramp a lot of scams, a lot of fraud out there that is dangerous.

**[0:21:44] Michael Hsu:** That's part of what's exciting and also part of what's dangerous in this space. And I think we wanna be cognizant of that.

**[0:21:50] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Yeah, I couldn't agree more. You may have seen the recent paper by Chris Brummer at Georgetown arguing for your disclosure regimen. I think it's really interesting. I'll put that in the show notes. And I'll also put the site that you just mentioned on basic financial literacy. Make sure that that's in the show notes as well. If we, let's go to stable coins. There's tremendous growth in stable coins. You've been making remarks in this area. And one of the challenges is there's so many uses of them, such a wide array of possibilities.

**[0:22:30] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Talk a little bit there about the risks and how you think they and banks should be coexisting.

**[0:22:40] Michael Hsu:** Sure. So the way I like to go back to kind of first principles, you know, why do stable coins matter? Why should I, as a regulator, care about stable coins? And I think it's really from two perspectives. One is that if we get it wrong, if we don't get the policy around stablecoins right, people can get hurt. So we already talked about this, but the crypto total value out there is around $2 1 trillion, plus or minus.

**[0:23:09] Michael Hsu:** That rests on about $180 billion of stablecoins. That $180 billion of stablecoins really provides support for the entire crypto ecosystem. If you go to any exchange, whether it's centralized or decentralized, most of that trading is against stablecoins. So they're kind of the grease for that system in the same way that the U.S. economy kind of rests on the banking industry. If you have trouble in the stablecoin system, you're going to have trouble in the entire crypto ecosystem.

**[0:23:40] Michael Hsu:** And a lot of people have exposure. So I want to make sure that, again, people are protected. People are taking informed risks. The second part really has to do with this more forward-looking part, which is we want to make sure that the dollar is the base currency in whatever future blockchain-based economy there may be. Because there's been a lot of talk about dollar as the reserve currency. In this specific instance, we're talking about blockchain-native money.

**[0:24:11] Michael Hsu:** The dollar cannot live on-chain. Stablecoins can live on-chain. The dollar cannot. So in that case, how do we ensure that the dollar is the base currency? So we want to think about that too. So we want to protect people. We want to protect the dollar. Those are kind of my starting points in terms of thinking about stable coins. Once you identify those kind of overall objectives, I think there's really three main, what I call architectural choices with stable coins.

**[0:24:38] Michael Hsu:** There's going to be many more, but the three that I would start with are how stable do you want stable coins to be? how interoperable do you want stable coins to be, like how fungible, and how separable from the banking system, at least initially, do you want them to be? Because once you set those choices, then the innovators can innovate, and we can let that kind of take, otherwise, you're constantly, we as regulators are constantly chasing whatever the next new thing is, and how do we think about it?

**[0:25:10] Michael Hsu:** And every week, there's a new thing. It's very hard to keep up with. Every day. Every day, right. So I think we really do want to kind of step back and say, well, what are the architectural considerations about what we really care about? Let's try to snap those chalk lines in place and then move from there. And I think it's really stability, interoperability, inseparability are kind of the three. There's going to be more, but I would start

**[0:25:33] Jo Ann Barefoot:** there. And when you think about what that means in terms of opportunities for banks to be performing crypto-related activities and also this whole question of whether a stablecoin should have

**[0:25:48] Michael Hsu:** to have a bank charter. Talk about those. Sure. Sure. So let me do the second one first, because I think whether it should have a bank charter or not, I would put that under the umbrella of how stable do we want stablecoins to be? And this question, it seems on the one hand, a relatively straightforward question of, well, as long as there's enough stable stuff, reserves backing it, we should be fine. I think for those of us who have been in the financial regulatory world for a while and been through various crises, that's not a full answer.

**[0:26:28] Michael Hsu:** You basically have two ways of approaching stability. I'm going to oversimplify this, But then we can get one is basically a disclosure based, which is the money funds like money funds are supposed to be stable. How do they achieve that? Lots and lots of disclosures. And there's some high level asset requirements. But that's it. The other is a bank supervision approach. And so it's a prudential approach. Like we're going to approach it like a bank to protect depositors.

**[0:27:00] Michael Hsu:** So these are two very different regimes. And I would argue that the bank approach leads to more stable outcomes. Because if you look at money funds, we've had to bail them out twice now. So in 2008, they had to get bailed out. And again, in the pandemic, they had to get bailed out. So there's something, they're good most of the time, but it's really that 1 % of the time that you need them to be stable that they're not.

**[0:27:24] Michael Hsu:** And that's what banks, I think bank, on the bank side, we've kind of figured that out. Now, and I think that's why the PWG report has come out to say, hey, if you want this thing to be stable, you should take a bank approach.

**[0:27:40] Jo Ann Barefoot:** I'll just say we'll put that in the show notes as well, the Presidential Working Group. I have a big global audience, so I sometimes try to translate our acronyms.

**[0:27:49] Michael Hsu:** Yes, I'm sorry. I'll try not to use them. So within the space of bank approaches, there actually is a spectrum within that. And I think that right now, a lot of the conversation is, well, within that spectrum, is there a way, what are different options for configuring a stablecoin issuer within those options? And some of them may not fit cleanly within what those options exist, in which case, you know, is the burden and the risk-reward sweet spot achievable within existing authorities or do we need new authorities?

**[0:28:27] Michael Hsu:** And I think that's where a lot of the legislative discussion going on right now is like, oh, maybe there's like a sweet spot that can be kind of legislated. And we're open to, you know, engaging on that discussion. I've been talking to folks on the Hill Treasury about that. But I think that's where a lot of that discussion is. So it's not necessarily a clean option A, option B, IDI. I think the folks who are involved are a couple layers down, which is great, in terms of thinking through what are the other knobs and dials and attributes that can be negotiated.

**[0:29:02] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Yeah, that touches on something else I wanted to ask, because President Biden issued an executive order, which has been called an all of government approach. How is crypto broadly defined going to impact all the way across the government? And some agencies are specifically responding to it and others are in the dialogue. But it does raise this question of whether, how confident are we that we can fit these innovations into our existing legal and regulatory framework based on their functions versus whether they're just breaking the molds.

**[0:29:48] Jo Ann Barefoot:** And if we try to squeeze square pegs into round holes, things eventually are going to not work well. How do you think about that?

**[0:29:57] Michael Hsu:** So I'll go back to, I heard, I think it was Chris Brummer answer a very similar question using a puzzle analogy. And he said, if you think about the U.S. regulatory landscape, it's a little bit like a puzzle. The SEC covers securities, the CFTC covers commodities, the FDIC, the OCC. So all these puzzle pieces kind of fit more or less with regards to the traditional system. And then you bring in crypto, which doesn't fit anywhere.

**[0:30:30] Michael Hsu:** And then the question is, well, you know, which parts of the puzzle can apply and where are there gaps? And so that's one way of kind of thinking, you know, recognizing that you can't start with a completely new sheet of paper. And there's no need to start with it. We've got existing things which we can leverage, we can learn from. So how do you do that? And sticking with that analogy for a moment, I think it's good to focus on the boundary.

**[0:30:55] Michael Hsu:** Where should the boundary line be for the puzzle? Because I think that that goes back to this, what are our values? Like stepping away from my parochial role as the head of a particular agency, but just thinking more broadly, where should, and I think identity, privacy, inclusion, ownership, you know mediums of exchange like all the stablecoin architecture those to me are kind of on the boundaries and it's helpful to do both of these at the same time let's think about the boundaries and you know what should be um where should those edge cases how should we think about what's acceptable and not acceptable and then at the same time we do have to figure out you know how does the

**[0:31:37] Michael Hsu:** howey test apply to to these things like we do have to figure those things out but i think we have to operate at two speeds simultaneously otherwise if you do too much of the micro we're We're going to get lost. And if we do too much of the macro, we're not answering questions that people need to answer. So it's a little bit of zooming in and zooming out simultaneously. And, you know, the thing that I worry about, but I'm hopeful about, but I worry about is just an unlevel playing field.

**[0:32:06] Michael Hsu:** You know, before 2008, before that crisis, a lot of the puzzle pieces in this landscape were very inwardly focused. They were focused on their own thing. And what ended up happening is you had all sorts of gaps. Like shadow banking basically just lived in the gaps of that puzzle. And then you had a lot of arbitrage and a very unlevel playing field. And I think the key today is that we need to make sure that that doesn't happen again.

**[0:32:36] Michael Hsu:** And so that does require a lot of interagency coordination. I'm really heartened by the amount of communication and engagement that's good, especially at the federal level. but even federal to state, because there's a lot of developments at the state level as well. And so that's something that we always have to constantly be on kind of pushing is that we have to collaborate more than compete.

**[0:33:02] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Yeah, I love that. As you say, the states have a tremendous role to play, especially the ones that are licensing crypto companies per se. and therefore basically regulating them top to bottom in ways that none of our federal functional regulators have the jurisdiction to do. And then we have the international piece, obviously also thinking of the boundaries of the puzzle. You said early on here that we shouldn't think that crypto is inevitable. um how do you answer the the argument that if the united states tries to regulate crypto in a uh restrictive way it's just going to go somewhere else and united states could lose some of our uh innovation and competitive edge in in world and world commerce how

**[0:34:01] Jo Ann Barefoot:** do we deal with that

**[0:34:02] Michael Hsu:** Commando. So whenever that comes up, I try to say, let's get specific. Because I think it helps to be specific. There are some things for which I think we may be okay with that quote unquote innovation going somewhere else. I think we have to be careful. Like I want to make sure that when we're talking about trade-offs, whether it's between innovation and stability and things like that were as specific as possible because that's where the rubber meets the road.

**[0:34:33] Michael Hsu:** So with stable coins, for instance, just to go back to that for a moment, the folks that I talk to and as I think about it, I think about we want money. Stable coin is basically functioning like money in the blockchain system. Great. Money, we generally want to be stable. That's the whole point is that we want it to be there. We want it to be reliable. We want to be able to kind of use our creative energies for other things.

**[0:35:03] Michael Hsu:** And what's really interesting for the OCC, this kind of, I mean, Joanne, you know this, this gets to the core of our history as an agency. Before the OCC existed, we had this really unstable free banking system in the U.S. where there was no uniform dollar. It was, you know, every bank issued its own version of a dollar. and the public just had to deal with this whole plethora of different notes and discount rates and you had money men and all this stuff.

**[0:35:34] Michael Hsu:** And there were a lot of bank runs. There were a lot of scams. And with the National Currency Act and the creation of the OCC, you start to stabilize it. You have an interoperable dollar across the whole country. So those features feel good. Those features feel unfamiliar. And then you have innovation on top of that. And I think that's an interesting part when people talk about if you want to trade off innovation versus stability and predictability.

**[0:36:01] Michael Hsu:** For stable coins, we may want to err on the side of stability and predictability. Now, for other things, we may want to err on the side of innovation, but let's be precise. And what I worry about in some of these arguments is that it's kind of a broad brush. Well, if you're not for innovation, Mike, you must be against progress. And that's not a very productive discussion. Let's break that down and to try to work out where we want to make those trade-offs.

**[0:36:30] Jo Ann Barefoot:** So that actually is also a great segue to talking a little bit about CBDC, Central Bank Digital digital currency. And I know this is not the OCC's domain here, but when you think about, you talked earlier about the dollar being the world's reserve currency, we know there's a challenge from China with its CBDC. People are beginning to talk about the potential of the world dividing into two rival monetary systems? How should we be thinking about those challenges and what are the principles to getting that right?

**[0:37:14] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Yeah. So I would go back to the

**[0:37:18] Michael Hsu:** interoperability architecture point I made before earlier. And let me just, this actually deserves a little bit of explanation. What do I mean by interoperability? So our current money is highly interoperable. Like the physical dollar I have in my wallet is the same as the physical dollar you have in your wallet. When we go spend it, no one cares whether it came from me or came from you. That's great. The same goes for our bank deposits. And I think this people don't fully appreciate.

**[0:37:49] Michael Hsu:** You know, my bank deposit at bank A is different than your bank deposit at bank B. And those deposits are not money. It's not central. It's not a central bank liability. It's a liability of that bank. Yeah. Right. And yet we treat it as fully fungible. And I think that it's kind of magical. Like, how did that come to be? Well, it came to be because the monetary and banking architecture that we have for the U.S.

**[0:38:15] Michael Hsu:** makes it so. Right. It makes it so that these things can be fully interoperable and fungible and the world can kind of move on. The stablecoin world we have today does not have that, right? A USD, a Tether, USD, C-Circle, those are not interoperable. If you want to kind of, you have to trade them if you want to get from one to the other. And if you want to fast forward into a world where we've got a large, diverse blockchain-based economy, I think we want those things to be interoperable with each other and with the CBDC.

**[0:38:50] Michael Hsu:** That would help ensure that the dollar is the base currency for trade and payments and et cetera, finance, in a blockchain-native world. And that's going to take some work because right now there is no interoperability within a coin. I don't think people realize this either. Each blockchain is like a different rail gauge. Ethereum, Solana, Tron, different code, different cryptography, different architectures. They don't talk to each other. And so getting them to talk to each other requires these cross-chain bridges.

**[0:39:27] Michael Hsu:** Those are fragile. These hacks, the Axie hack that just happened, Polygon, Wormhole, are because of these cross-chain bridges. So these are very technical problems. Sometimes they can be solved. I think the verdict is out as to whether this one can be solved. But again, I want to get away from the details. Big picture, what do we want? I think we want interoperability, which would help with that dollar question. If that's the case, what's the plan to get there?

**[0:39:57] Michael Hsu:** And this is one of the things where I think that the industry and others, we need to start engaging. What is that plan?

**[0:40:03] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Absolutely. One of the interesting things I'm starting to hear people talk about is whether we can have a U.S. digital dollar that will become a platform on which others can create interoperable solutions. and, as you're saying, bring interoperability across the system and also accelerate desirable innovation if it's all built to the correct architecture with the necessary risk management built underneath it.

**[0:40:42] Michael Hsu:** That's right. There's a very interesting, I've been reading and kind of studying more about the birth of the Internet. because the internet is an interesting, the protocols that underlie the internet didn't come out of nowhere. TCP IP was created, right? It was a standard that was created upon which everything else kind of gets built on top of it. And there's standard setting bodies that evolved to do that. We've got a lot of technicians And the folks who are at that table didn't necessarily have corporate interests in mind.

**[0:41:24] Michael Hsu:** And I think this is something to think about a little bit, is that you had very public-minded folks. And some of them are actually today part of the crypto world, are saying, hey, they were part of W3C and IETF and these kinds of things. Today, there's a lot of money. There's a lot of money that's behind the development of these things. There's nothing wrong with that. But I think we want to make sure that there's someone with the public interest in mind who's at that table helping to define what should those standards be.

**[0:41:55] Michael Hsu:** How is that going to help people, not just corporations, people, and the U.S. economy to make sure that those interests are kind of integrated into whatever develops? I think we're still at the early stages of this. And so this is something that I engage with other people to say, OK, how are we going to solve this? Because it's not going to solve itself.

**[0:42:17] Jo Ann Barefoot:** yeah i i agree with you looking at those roots of the internet and the worldwide web are so instructive and you know my guesses were probably going to need to evolve to some sort of a public private uh governing body of some kind that can continue to be nimble um you know can continue innovating but as keeping the necessary but but since we touched on uh the internet i'd love to hear whether you have thoughts on the vision that's being laid out for web3 but you know we are hearing this tantalizing possibility and the people who who developed the original internet were not ever expecting it to be used by everyone in the world right They thought it was going

**[0:43:10] Jo Ann Barefoot:** to be a community of researchers and so on. And so they didn't design it for privacy. They didn't design it to be a good vehicle as a medium of exchange of value as opposed to information. and so now people are saying we we've got the technology today to have a different architecture and to decentralize in ways that we won't have uh the power in the hands of a few big tech firms and and that we can have this defy possibility of equipping uh each of us to have more of an ownership stake.

**[0:43:54] Jo Ann Barefoot:** The example I love to use was in the Economist article, I think at the beginning of the year, maybe on DeFi. I think it was a cover story. And they said, what if you were a fashion model and your picture is taken and it's owned by the photographer? And if two years from now, you're a supermodel, you know, you don't get any value in that. What if you could keep a token that would be 10 % ownership in your likeness or in the, you know, anything that you create.

**[0:44:26] Jo Ann Barefoot:** How are you thinking about that possibility and whether it's in the realm of reality?

**[0:44:34] Michael Hsu:** So I guess I'll answer this at maybe three different levels. So one is just technologically. And I think this is where a lot of the debates that I find compelling are, is that, you know, Vitalik Buterin has highlighted this blockchain trilemma. You can have decentralization, security, scalability. You can basically have two out of three, but you can't get all three. And one of the challenges that Ethereum is having right now is scalability. So they've got the decentralization and the security, but they're having problems with scalability.

**[0:45:07] Michael Hsu:** And some of the alternatives to Ethereum, like Solana, basically give up decentralization for scalability. But if you give up decentralization, you're right back to where we started by having lots of centralized entities. And I think Moxie Marlins Spike kind of highlighted this in one of his blog posts, you know, was skeptical of saying, hey, there's always going to be centralized intermediaries. So this dream of everything being decentralized is a bit of a fantasy if you want to do it at scale.

**[0:45:38] Michael Hsu:** I find that compelling. Now, I think there have been other arguments are like, well, this is early days and things can evolve. So we'll see. So there's kind of a technological set of questions there that I think are worth kind of exploring. Again, dispassionately, because I know people feel very passionately about it. Yeah. Then there's like a philosophical thing. And this is something where I think we do need to think and talk about this. Part of the excitement around crypto, the sense I get is it's very community driven.

**[0:46:10] Michael Hsu:** Like people are drawn to it because there's a community of people. that are really into it, whether they're developers or people who are investing. And so it's very relational in that sense. And I think that's exciting. I think people are very hungry for relationships. But the technology itself is highly transactional. The technology is basically saying, we're going to take all of this data and break it down into pieces that can be bought, sold, and staked. Is that what we want?

**[0:46:41] Michael Hsu:** I don't know. I think like I think I've heard stories about the fashion model the musician like there's a lot of these stories which from the creator perspective sound attractive but I think if you take it to its logical extreme like I think we may want to have that debate do I want do I want an economic system where I'm basically every single piece of data I can lend lease buy sell stay like I don't know But that system seems to be building towards that.

**[0:47:12] Michael Hsu:** And so that's more of kind of a philosophical question, which is not part of my day job, but I think it's worth kind of posing to folks out there. So I think those are at least two different. And then, of course, the third is as a regulator, how am I thinking about this? And at the end of the day, financial, like money, payments, lending, all of that rests on trust. So the real question is, how does trust evolve?

**[0:47:39] Michael Hsu:** People's trust in each other, trust in intermediaries, trust in the government. I want to make sure from my seat that that trust evolves in a healthy way that's accountable and stable and kind of leads, doesn't lead to nasty surprises. because that's, as we all know, like we're still dealing with the overhang from the 2008 financial crisis. And that's like, we really have to, I take that to heart. Like we don't want to recreate that. That would be Pennywise pound foolish.

**[0:48:10] Michael Hsu:** And so I think that those are kind of deeper questions that we're going to have to grapple with as regulators. I know we're just about out of time.

**[0:48:18] Jo Ann Barefoot:** We touched on this earlier, but I want to circle back just briefly to the possibility of regulating or supervising this in different ways. one of the trends that we're seeing at regulators around the world is a move for example to digital regulatory reporting so that regulators can get more timely and accurate and full information reported to them in forms where you can use a AI and natural language processing and machine learning techniques on it. And I think one thing that people are realizing is that if you're going to start to do that, a place to start might be with crypto, because these companies are tech companies through and through from the beginning, no prior form.

**[0:49:17] Jo Ann Barefoot:** They're young, they're very nimble, They know how to change quickly. And you can almost see in them the possibility of beginning to build toward regulatory approaches that would gather information differently, monitor it differently, you know, have the power to be far more accurate, far more nuanced in terms of detecting trends early, also more efficient for both government and the private sector. do you think there's a something there that's worth thinking about and and if so how would

**[0:49:54] Michael Hsu:** go about it yeah so i i think what's really um so it's early days still but if you take like in some cases there's not even a company that's a good another challenge yeah kevin warden he does a great job of articulating some of these are not even companies it's just code It's just platforms. It's just like, what is a DAO? A DAO is just a set of rules. And so like, what do you grab? So we have all sorts of really novel questions about how we deal with that.

**[0:50:27] Michael Hsu:** But even in the blockchain space, or in the Bitcoin space, you've got others who have been thinking really hard about, well, what is the governance? I think you have to take this back to governance because at the end of the day, who is making decisions for whom? And what standard, what expectations are on those decision makers? And then what is the role of regulation relative to that? Those are really critical. And I think you get little test cases like Philip Dan at Cornell has talked about minor extractable value.

**[0:50:59] Michael Hsu:** You got this MEV problem with Ethereum or with some of the blockchains in general, which is basically front running. It's like a form of front running in the blockchain space. How do we deal with that? Great question. We don't have great hooks, abilities to do that. Now, Joanne, I think to your question, it's like, well, maybe we can rethink this. Rather than trying to shoehorn that into our existing tools and the things, maybe there's another way of dealing with it.

**[0:51:28] Michael Hsu:** I think that's interesting. I think that's an interesting thing to debate and discuss. In the meantime, we've got to make sure people are protected. So this is the constant balance of if it wasn't growing so fast, we could take our time to get this right as we were going. But the pace of growth is really forcing, I think, a lot of hard questions. I think that's why a lot of us are focusing initially on stablecoins, because you get a lot of bang for your buck with stablecoins from a regulatory perspective.

**[0:52:00] Michael Hsu:** And then there's a host of other questions that have to get answered. But if you get that one wrong, then we're going to be dealing with a lot of harder issues far out into the future.

**[0:52:12] Jo Ann Barefoot:** And undermining trust, as you said before, which could destroy the whole potential to do a lot of things better. If we had more time, I would ask you how the regulators can keep up with the pace of all this change. Regulators aren't built to be moving fast like this, and it's a challenge, but I won't put you on the spot on that, but I will ask you, is there anything you want to add

**[0:52:39] Michael Hsu:** that we haven't talked about? No, I'll take the bait on that question. I think we as regulators get painted as horribly behind the times, stodgy folks who are living in the past, which is not true. I mean, you do know this. It is super exciting to be a regulator right now. We get to see a really broad perspective. We have a really wide perspective, bird's eye view, on all these different issues. And we're trying to work out what are ways through this that protect people, protect the dollar, is good for the public, that others just don't have that mandate.

**[0:53:23] Michael Hsu:** So if you're working at a company or something, you may be working towards that, but there's just different motivations and incentives. And the incentive for us is just to get it right for the public. And so it's really exciting. I think we have some fantastic discussions both internally and with others, other agencies, other players. So I think keeping up is hard for anybody. Even people in the industry have a hard time keeping up. But we've kind of adapted to some of this pretty well.

**[0:53:57] Michael Hsu:** And turning it into action, I think that's a harder part, but we want to get it right. People say, oh, you're moving slowly. Well, we're moving at a deliberate pace because if you get it wrong, it's hard to undo. And so that's part of getting it right takes a little bit of time. It's like cooking a meal. You don't want to microwave it.

**[0:54:21] Jo Ann Barefoot:** You want to do it right. Well, if there are any listeners who are thinking that regulators are stodgy and living in the past, I think you have disabused them of that in this conversation. It's been fascinating to talk with you. I cannot thank you enough for being our guest today. So Michael Sue. Thank you for being on the show. Thank you so much, Joanne. I really enjoyed it. I hope you enjoyed today's show. Come to regulationinnovation.org for the show notes and a lot more information.

**[0:54:54] Jo Ann Barefoot:** We've put many, many links into the show notes about the things that we talked about in this episode. I hope you're loving the shows of 2022 so far, and we have some more wonderful ones coming up. We're going to have Costa Peric, Deputy Director of Financial Services for the Poor at the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation. We'll have Deborah Young, CEO of the RegTech Association. We'll have Queen Maxima of the Netherlands. We'll have Siegel Mendelker, former Treasury official who is now at Ribbit Capital.

**[0:55:26] Jo Ann Barefoot:** We're going to have Nicole Elam and Robert James of the National Bankers Association talking about minority depository institutions. We'll have returning guest Jeremy Allaire, CEO of Circle, along with Tomika Tilleman speaking about Web3. And we're going to have Sunaina Tuteha, who is the first ever Chief Innovation Officer of the Federal Reserve System, among others. There are also many exciting events coming up. Join David on Thursday, April 28th, at the Treasury Minority Bank Summit. And then join me at this year's Shared Assessments Third Party Risk Summit at LendIt FinTech and at the ABA Compliance Conference.

**[0:56:09] Jo Ann Barefoot:** Again, we've got details in the show notes. And for those of you who are in or near Zurich, please join me in June at the Point Zero Forum, a unique event set up by the Swiss government and Elevandi, which is a nonprofit entity created by the Monetary Authority of Singapore, MAS. I serve on Elevandi's board. Don't forget to follow Aira on LinkedIn and Twitter, and be sure to follow me on Twitter at Jo Ann Barefoot. And please be sure to give us a five-star rating on your favorite podcast platform.

**[0:56:41] Jo Ann Barefoot:** And please keep on innovating.
