In brief
Medicare Advantage plans now face bigger financial risk from unsupported diagnosis codes in federal RADV audits, which check whether the diagnoses used to set payments are backed by medical records. Dave DeHommel argues plans should stop relying mainly on after-the-fact chart chasing and instead build year-round clinical data capture, a central records repository, and audit-ready routines.
The tension is between legal uncertainty and operational certainty. A Texas court vacated CMS's extrapolation method after a Humana challenge, and CMS has appealed, so the audit rules may change. Yet CMS is still catching up on audit years, and every plan is expected to be audited. DeHommel says plans must prepare regardless of how the courts rule.
Questions
What is a RADV audit and why does it matter to Medicare Advantage plans?
RADV (risk adjustment data validation) is a CMS audit that checks whether the diagnoses a Medicare Advantage plan reported are supported by medical records. Unsupported diagnoses can mean the plan has been overpaid and may owe money back.
What was the fee-for-service adjuster and why did removing it matter?
According to Dave DeHommel, it was a statistical buffer that accounted for plans' payment rates being built on unverified traditional Medicare data, so plans did not have to be perfect in audits. Removing it increased plans' exposure to repayment.
Is the new RADV extrapolation method still in effect?
Not currently. DeHommel says a federal district court in Texas vacated it after Humana challenged it, and CMS appealed in November 2025, so the outcome is still awaited.
Why can't plans just rely on reviewing charts after the fact?
DeHommel says retrospective review will continue, but claims take roughly 90 to 180 days to complete, and CMS is focused on capturing patients' full illness at the time of care. Plans are therefore moving toward capturing information during visits.
What should a plan leader do in the next 90 days?
DeHommel suggests starting a central clinical data repository, adding contract language that prioritizes audit-related record requests, running mock RADV audits when possible, and deciding whether to build or buy retrieval and coding support.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
CMS, in its 2023 RADV rule, estimated $17 billion in annual Medicare Advantage overpayments from unsupported diagnosis codes.
“I think CMS, when they came out with the 2023 ruling, they had estimated $17 billion in annual MA overpayments from unsupported diagnosis codes.”
0:02:17 · Dave DeHommel · Overpayments · 2023
Humana challenged CMS's RADV rule, and a federal district court in Texas vacated it.
“that RADV ruling was challenged by Humana. And a federal district court in Texas essentially vacated that ruling.”
0:02:17 · Dave DeHommel · RADV litigation
CMS appealed the Texas court's ruling on its RADV extrapolation methodology in November 2025.
“And as we know, CMS did appeal that ruling back in November of 2025.”
0:03:00 · Dave DeHommel · RADV appeal · 2025
The CMS extrapolation methodology that excluded the fee-for-service adjuster was vacated and is not currently applicable, according to Dave DeHommel.
“the extrapolation methodology that CMS defined, which excluded that fee-for-service adjuster is no longer applicable.”
0:03:00 · Dave DeHommel · Extrapolation
Dave DeHommel says Medicare Advantage plans set bids and premiums using traditional fee-for-service data, which includes unvalidated diagnosis codes from claims.
“they're doing it based off of traditional fee-for-service data, which is raw and unverified and includes essentially unvalidated diagnosis codes through claims.”
0:03:46 · Dave DeHommel · Bid process
Dave DeHommel describes the fee-for-service adjuster as a statistical buffer that kept health plans from having to be perfect in RADV audits.
“that fee-for-service adjuster essentially was that buffer, that statistical buffer to support health plans.”
0:04:40 · Dave DeHommel · FFS adjuster
CMS plans to audit four additional payment years in calendar year 2026 and the remaining two in 2027, according to Dave DeHommel.
“But catching up with four additional payment year audits in calendar year 2026 and the remaining two in 2027, health plans have to focus and really execute in this area moving forward.”
0:05:26 · Dave DeHommel · Audit schedule · 2026
Dave DeHommel says scrutiny from RADV, Office of Inspector General audits and MedPAC commentary centers on whether plans capture patients' full burden of illness.
“with the MA RAD-V and the OIG audits and some of the industry commentary, like from MedPak and others, it's really about, is that full burden of illness capture”
0:07:24 · Dave DeHommel · Scrutiny
Dave DeHommel says all plans are now being audited under RADV, whereas historically plans might or might not be selected.
“I think health plans are challenged because all health plans are being audited as part of this risk adjustment data validation audit, where historically it was maybe I will be selected”
0:11:18 · Dave DeHommel · Audit scope
Dave DeHommel says claims data can take roughly 90 to 180 days to complete after a visit.
“there's a very long tail there, anywhere between 90 on a good day to 120 days to 180 days to get the bulk of that information”
0:13:32 · Dave DeHommel · Claims lag
Dave DeHommel gives an example of plans pursuing medical records for 2026 dates of service during 2026 rather than waiting until 2027.
“going after medical records, for example, in calendar year 2026 on 2026 dates of service, as opposed to waiting the next year in 2027”
0:14:46 · Dave DeHommel · Concurrent review · 2026
Dave DeHommel says CMS's final notice this year introduced claims-linking criteria tying retrospective chart review documentation to an encounter.
“the advance notice just kind of reinforced tying the retrospective chart retrieval encoding documentation to the encounter through their claims linking criteria that was new and came out in the final notice this year.”
0:15:31 · Dave DeHommel · Claims linking · 2026
Starting with 2027 dates of service, retrospective chart review results that affect a plan's risk score must be linked to an encounter.
“starting on 2027 dates of service, the results of retrospective chart retrieval and coding projects, if it is going to impact the health plan's risk score calculation, it must be linked now to an encounter.”
0:15:31 · Dave DeHommel · Risk scores · 2027
The only exception to the encounter-linking requirement is for new plan members, whose records may be reviewed retrospectively and submitted unlinked.
“the only exception there is if there's a new member that joins the health plan, then they're able to look back and do some retrospective retrieval and coding and submit those unlinked.”
0:16:14 · Dave DeHommel · Linking exception · 2027
Dave DeHommel previously served as managing director of risk adjustment at Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan and spent 16 and a half years at Priority Health.
“previously, I was managing director of risk adjustment at Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan, spent 16 and a half years at Priority Health”
0:00:48 · Dave DeHommel · Speaker background
Dave DeHommel has 20 years of health plan leadership experience focused on seniors and vulnerable populations.
“20 years of health plan leadership experience focused on care for seniors and vulnerable populations.”
0:00:48 · Dave DeHommel · Speaker background
Reveleer offers a resource page on its MA RADV audit solution and a newly released clinical data repository.
“Reveleer put together a resource page at reveleer.com slash beckers dash rad v”
0:19:56 · Dave DeHommel · Reveleer products