# Battling Fraud in Fintech: How Banks and Fintechs can Stay Ahead

- **Show:** Breaking Banks
- **Published:** 26 Jun 2025
- **Source:** https://provoke.fm/battling-fraud-in-fintech-how-banks-and-fintechs-can-stay-ahead-2/
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/breaking-banks/battling-fraud-in-fintech-how-banks-and-fintechs-can-stay-ahead-37e06f/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

Fraud in fintech persists because there is rarely any consequence for the person who commits it. John Barbella argues that banks can fight back by sharing anonymized fraud data through Neighborly, a network modeled on Check Systems, which tracked bad-check writers across thousands of banks. When banks share what they know, a fraudster cannot burn one bank after another.

The central tension is between growth and discipline. Barbella says fintech's boom rewarded account counts, so nobody worried about fraud on the back end until the bottom fell out. He sees a more sober "FinTech 2.0," where cleaner accounts, proactive alerts and shared data matter more. He admits fraudsters will always move faster, so the goal is to make fraud harder, not to end it.

## Key insights

1. **Fintech's account-count valuations hid its fraud problem** Barbella says each new account was worth roughly $1,000 in valuation during 2019-2021, so companies chased volume and ignored back-end fraud. Many accounts were dormant or illegitimate, so he expects the industry to shrink to perhaps a half or less of its size.
2. **Illegitimate disputes can hurt banks with regulators** Rejected first-party fraud disputes still produced customer complaints. Barbella says the FDIC judged banks on complaint volume relative to asset size, whether or not the complaints were valid.
3. **Neighborly copies the Check Systems data-sharing model** Check Systems built a network of about 15,000 institutions sharing data on people who left bad accounts. Barbella says Neighborly needs only 10 to 15 large banks to cover most of the industry, because each participant makes the fraudster's next target harder to find.
4. **Early payroll-switch signals can predict account fraud** A fourth-quarter data study with an ACH payments processor flagged accounts that went bad on one date, while some banks only found them weeks later. The plan is real-time alerts so a bank can watch an account before losing an average of about $1,200.
5. **Fraudsters always move faster, so sharing matters** Barbella concedes banks will never get in front of fraudsters, especially with AI. He says industry-wide anonymized pattern sharing is the realistic counter, and he contrasts it with the slow FinCEN suspicious-activity-report (SAR) feedback loop.

## Questions this episode answers

### What is Neighborly and what does it do?

Neighborly is a network of banks that share anonymized data on fraud, especially first-party fraud, so a bad actor can't keep opening accounts at one bank after another. John Barbella says member banks set its operating rules.

### What is first-party fraud, in plain terms?

It is fraud by the account holder, such as disputing a purchase they actually made and keeping the money. Barbella calls it "mom-and-pop stuff" that won't break the industry but steadily drains profit.

### Why does the Check Systems comparison matter?

Check Systems was a 1980s network of about 15,000 financial institutions that shared data on people with bad accounts, which created consequences for bad-check writing. Barbella says Neighborly applies the same idea to fintech, where he says consequences were missing.

### Why did fintech have so much fraud and so many weak accounts?

Barbella says companies were valued on how many accounts they opened, roughly $1,000 each at the peak, so growth was rewarded and fraud was ignored. Many accounts were dormant or illegitimate.

### Can banks ever beat fraudsters?

Barbella says no, since fraudsters will always be ahead of banks and are using AI and machine learning. He says the aim is to make fraud harder and less profitable by sharing information and acting on earlier warning signs.

## Facts

- **John Barbella** [0:02:35]: "I started with that deluxe check printers way, way back when, and it was paper payments."
- **John Barbella** [0:03:12]: "I joined in 2006. The industry had maybe been perking along for three, four, five years, maybe with some of the real pioneers."
- **John Barbella** [0:04:50]: "Deluxe owned a company by the name of Check Systems. And Check Systems started in the 1980s and was acquired by Deluxe."
- **John Barbella** [0:04:50]: "assembled a network of 15 ,000 financial institutions that all contributed data on people that had misstepped or not adjudicated their accounts with a bank."
- **John Barbella** [0:06:06]: "we were offering provisional credits as a bank, and then we'd be left in the lurch, and that money would walk away."
- **John Barbella** [0:06:40]: "that's really where that passion grew in the kind of the mid-2014 to 2016 era, said, hey, there's got to be a better way."
- **John Barbella** [0:11:09]: "And guess what? That's how the FDIC assessed the bank. And they said, hey, you can't have this many customer complaints based on your asset size."
- **John Barbella** [0:12:10]: "You brought on that account. It might cost you in the neighborhood of $150 to $175 to bring them on."
- **John Barbella** [0:12:10]: "every account that you brought on in the madness of 2019, 2020, 21, everything, every time you brought on an account, it had a value of roughly $1 ,000."
- **John Barbella** [0:13:09]: "that's about the time where we got out the door with Neighborly when we started in 22."
- **John Barbella** [0:15:52]: "We're providing the SARS. We don't hear back for six to nine months. You know, how is this being actionable?"
- **Host** [0:17:55]: "there are millions and millions of synthetic IDs out there that have legitimate activity that's going on there to establish an identity that is looking to become more bulletproof over time."
- **John Barbella** [0:22:48]: "We're talking about 10, 15, where you're going to get the lion's share of the industry, that if they're participating, you are making it harder for that fraudster."
- **John Barbella** [0:25:04]: "So the data study that we just conducted here in the fourth quarter was pretty cool. We worked with an ACH payments processor."
- **John Barbella** [0:25:40]: "we can tell you on January 3rd, this account went bad. Do you see this? And it was pretty powerful to get the feedback to say, yeah, we identified it, but we didn't identify until February 12th because they didn't have it."
- **John Barbella** [0:26:42]: "The banks that are member banks in Neighborly, they set the operating rules. They tell us what we want."
- **John Barbella** [0:29:07]: "So if our industry is 10X right now, I could see it being 4 or 5X. much, much smaller than it is now."
- **John Barbella** [0:29:36]: "they'll make those accounts, those synthetic accounts appear to be real. Then they'll go into some period of dormancy and then they'll come back up and get gotcha."
- **John Barbella** [0:30:38]: "you're not having someone in Treasury say, no, we're not going to pay that routing number. There's too much fraud out there. I mean, that actually occurs today."
- **John Barbella** [0:31:09]: "And that growth that will come will be more organic and more reasonable than the growth that we experienced from 2010 to 2020."
- **John Barbella** [0:34:20]: "Neighborly doesn't have employees per se. We have partners that help us enable this. We have the Advantage Technology team that manages our infrastructure."

## Transcript

**[0:00:05] Brett King:** Welcome to Breaking Banks, the number one global fintech radio show and podcast. I'm Brett King. And I'm Jason Henrichs. Every week since 2013, we explore the personalities, startups, innovators, and industry players

**[0:00:20] Host:** driving disruption in financial services. From incumbents to unicorns, and from cutting-edge technology to the people using it to help create a more innovative, inclusive, and healthy financial future. I'm JP Nicols, and this is

**[0:00:34] Brett King:** Breaking Banks. Welcome back to Breaking Banks. This week, we are privileged to introduce the Social Currency podcast. It's hosted by Tyler Seydel and Eric Schurr. We think it's great content for you guys to have a look at. The role of social currency specifically in society, particularly with how AI and bias and so forth is creeping in, we want to look at the innovative change makers in finance, in tech, in ESG, how these leaders are dismantling barriers and reshaping industries for a more inclusive, equitable, and sustainable future.

**[0:01:18] Brett King:** Now, this is an important conversation to have because the more we automate society, the more that those existing biases become a problem and become ingrained. And we need a process to talk about that, continue to think about social entrepreneurship, and to think about a world that we can create where everyone has equitable access to opportunities. So check out the Social Currency podcast.

**[0:01:44] Tyler Seydel:** I'm Tyler Seydel. And I'm Eric Schurr. And today we're joined by John Barbella. He is the founder and president of Neighborly, a network of financial institutions that are working to prevent fraud within the fintech space. And if ever there was an oversimplification or a sweeping generalization, I just made one. But John's going to unpack that with a little bit more detail for our listening audience. Beyond that, he also has three decades of experience working in the financial services industry, and a good portion of that is within national products, certainly in the prepaid space.

**[0:02:14] Host:** Well, John, welcome to the podcast today. It's a real pleasure to have you on. Thanks, Eric. Appreciate it. So, John, to kick us off today, you spent three years in financial services. We'd love to hear your journey. How did you get from where you started to today, fighting fraud and cooperation with other financial institutions?

**[0:02:35] John Barbella:** Yeah, Eric, thanks again for having me along. It's always a pleasure to talk with one of our key partners. And my story is pretty straightforward. I'd like to tell you there's something sexy about it, but I started with that deluxe check printers way, way back when, and it was paper payments. And paper, as I started with deluxe, they said, we'll be writing the last check in the next couple of years. Well, that never happened. But as I spent the early formational part of my career with Deluxe, I was adjacent to banks and the payment system.

**[0:03:12] John Barbella:** And I made the decision to move and say, hey, this isn't going to last forever. Let's move to the electronic world. And that's when I got involved with the fintech space. And I was early, early on. I joined in 2006. The industry had maybe been perking along for three, four, five years, maybe with some of the real pioneers. And it was wild, wild west. There were some really interesting things happening. But you could see the excitement that there was something else, another method of payment.

**[0:03:43] John Barbella:** But one of the things that's always been interesting to me and a partner like Sunrise is the idea of inclusion. And when I was in more in the traditional banking world, the large banks that we worked with, everybody talked about banking the unbanked and banking the underbanked. And those terms, you don't hear much about them anymore, but that's essentially what we were doing. There was a whole portion of the economy that wasn't participating in the banking world.

**[0:04:13] John Barbella:** And I thought FinTech was a terrific method to get to that. And, you know, it took something as terrible as the pandemic to say everybody really does need to be included in this or they're not going to be able to participate in a way that would make it easy and efficient for them as individuals. So, you know, I started in paper, moved to electronics, and I really kind of built a passion for some of the things that we're doing now with Neighborly.

**[0:04:39] Tyler Seydel:** Can you unpack maybe a little bit more, John, that passion, kind of that inspiration behind Neighborly and how that inspiration or that passion led to the formation and the vision of Neighborly?

**[0:04:50] John Barbella:** It's a bit foundational. Going back to my early days, Deluxe owned a company by the name of Check Systems. And Check Systems started in the 1980s and was acquired by Deluxe. And it was fascinating. Check Systems identified the fact that people could write bad checks and there was no consequence for writing a bad check. And they very systematically assembled a network of 15 ,000 financial institutions that all contributed data on people that had misstepped or not adjudicated their accounts with a bank.

**[0:05:29] John Barbella:** And there was no consequence in the past. Check systems implemented that. So as you fast forward 30 years and my time with Bancorp in the fintech space, there was some really good stuff going on. We had some neat opportunities where we could bring banking to those that hadn't been banked previously. But we're still living in a world where there wasn't a consequence. So we, in my time at Bancorp, we had a multitude of processors, and I won't delve too deep into that, but there were so many sources of information, and we had to pull that together.

**[0:06:06] John Barbella:** And if a consumer were to be untoward and suggest a dispute that was not lawful. They went down a path and they said, hey, I didn't make this transaction. And the bank has to go do the research to find out whether they did or they did not. And so that's where that passion really grew, why neighborly was necessary. Because in fintech, we didn't have those protections that were there. So we were offering provisional credits as a bank, and then we'd be left in the lurch, and that money would walk away.

**[0:06:40] John Barbella:** There was no consequence for that consumer to move on to the next player. So there are a couple elements we'll get to in a bit, but this idea of a dispute that there really was no reason not to dispute a transaction if you were a consumer and the banks sitting there wasting an awful lot of time, its partners are losing a lot of money with the bank and the reputations of the industries being jeopardized. So that's really where that passion grew in the kind of the mid-2014 to 2016 era, said, hey, there's got to be a better way.

**[0:07:10] John Barbella:** And that's how the idea for Neighborly was born. I think that's well captured. One thing

**[0:07:15] Tyler Seydel:** that I'm really taking away from that conversation, and this is a parallel that I haven't made yet, is that Neighborly really is the check systems for fintech, loosely said, and to underscore it differently. And I think that that's profound. When you position it like that, you can immediately see the value just insofar as to what you're doing by way of screening, kind of keeping the bad actors out if we're going to start to make product inferences.

**[0:07:38] Tyler Seydel:** And I know we're going to unpack that a little bit deeper as well. As you were starting, and just simply because you're an entrepreneur, you saw a need, you see how we can do things differently, you're drawing on your experience, you're getting emboldened, you're getting passionate about it. What was the greatest unexpected win you had in starting Neighborly? Something that maybe came easier than you thought

**[0:07:58] John Barbella:** it would. Easier than we thought. So I'd say the acceptance of the idea. Tyler, if I had to pinpoint something. First of all, there's not just check systems out there. There's other companies that have delved into this early warning. I worked with them when I was at Deluxe as well. So there were a lot of elements to this. But what there was was a uniform passion to address this issue of first party fraud. So I guess I would say that would have been the impetus to say, hey, let's go start something here.

**[0:08:32] John Barbella:** So I think that would be the first thing. So the surprise, I guess, I would see is that everybody sees a reason that we need to do this. I believe that the industry is far larger than it actually is. There are so many illegitimate accounts that are out there, and that's what we intend to address. And how can we crystallize and really right size the industry? So I think the easiest part would be getting the buy-in from the banks and the programs to say, yes, we do need to do something here.

**[0:09:08] John Barbella:** I'll get into some of the complications. I'm sure there's some additional questions that come there. But there's been some surprises along the way to say, yeah, there's buy-in. Everybody sees that it makes sense. So that's kind of the easy answer. But there has been so much that's happened in the last couple of years where we've had a restatement of the fintech landscape. And it's made it interesting, that's for sure. But we've got some terrific partners that are lined up and saying, hey, we're going to take a swing at this in a big way.

**[0:09:41] John Barbella:** And we need a partner like Neighborly to be involved. I love that job. Thank you.

**[0:09:45] Tyler Seydel:** And you're right in terms of there's other questions that could kind of lead in here. So we covered maybe that unexpected win. We covered really what you're looking to touch on by way of products. We covered some of the other participations. When you were pulling together this product, it looks like you had early buy-in. I will say from our perspective, certainly Sunrise, we saw this opportunity and we jumped at it. One, simply because we agree that there's maybe an underlying component here, but it's also a situation that if you're not addressing or you're not wise to it, fraud just kind of follows new program launches.

**[0:10:16] Tyler Seydel:** And so at the end of the day, if you can start to capture these bad actors and you can start to share that maybe more broadly, you can really start to stem losses that people would incur just from new products starting to take flight and moving into market. We touched on what came easiest. What was maybe the most challenging component of putting together Neighborly just as an entrepreneur and as a startup?

**[0:10:37] John Barbella:** So here's where there's an awful lot of moving parts. So I'll go down the first foray at this. It's really the frustration. So we talked about the impetus where you've had these illegitimate disputes being filed. What really, really threw me and said, we've got to fix this, was not only so when the bank went through the process and disallowed a dispute, it said, nope, we're going to reject that. We would get customer complaints that would come back from that illegitimate dispute.

**[0:11:09] John Barbella:** And guess what? That's how the FDIC assessed the bank. And they said, hey, you can't have this many customer complaints based on your asset size. And we're like, these complaints aren't legitimate. And it wasn't a matter whether they were or weren't legitimate. It was just the fact that you had a customer complaint. I said, well, this is madness. Why are we being evaluated this way? So that's where it kind of got us down the path to say, OK, how can we right size this?

**[0:11:36] John Barbella:** So when you start to think about some of the complexities, we had an industry that was just soaring. Everybody was, it was a terrific ascent and everybody was benefiting. But then we started to look at some of the factors that weren't necessarily the most prudent. I'll just say that in that way, in that programs, fintechs were being valued on crazy valuations based on the total number of accounts they brought on. Well, back in the old traditional banking world, a demand deposit account was a loss leader.

**[0:12:10] John Barbella:** You brought on that account. It might cost you in the neighborhood of $150 to $175 to bring them on. But then you would lose money if that was the only account that they had with you. So then we were in a position where every account that you brought on in the madness of 2019, 2020, 21, everything, every time you brought on an account, it had a value of roughly $1 ,000. So everybody was incented to bring on more accounts, but nobody was worrying about the back-end fraud.

**[0:12:40] John Barbella:** So when you ask what was the most challenging, you say, I have a very logical solution to the fraud problem that you're facing, but nobody was interested in addressing that problem until the bottom fell out. And then people started to look at this in a more realistic way, say, hey, how can you really make money on these accounts? If John Barbella has 35 accounts with a variety of fintechs, but none of them are his primary account, you're not making any money on his account.

**[0:13:09] John Barbella:** And that's where people started to look at this and say, OK, we can't continue on this ascent forever. And we do have this back end problem. And there was significant fraud in the industry. And that's about the time where we got out the door with Neighborly when we started in 22. to it was beginning to right size. And I'll say, I'll call it Bass 2.0, FinTech 2.0, where the valuations have normalized and the companies are being valued on what they're doing, how they differentiate themselves in the marketplace, who their bank partners are, who their other partners are.

**[0:13:45] John Barbella:** There's a big element here. We've heard about some of the challenges in the industry in recent years, but let's get back to some of the blocking and tackling. And there is a traditional element of this. And we need to bring that into focus, whereas it had gotten out of focus there for a few years.

**[0:14:02] Host:** So, John, when you talk about the morphing, the evolution of the financial service of the fintech world, that's one side of the coin. Can you talk about the evolution of the fraudster during this time? What are your observations about their level of sophistication, their speed to market, if you will? And you've talked a little bit about how FinTech 1.0, how they exploited those capabilities. Can you talk a little bit in specifics around how FinTech 2.0 has shifted to maybe mitigate some of the accelerating sophistication you're seeing on the other side of the equation with regards to the fraudsters, capabilities, skills, technology, etc.?

**[0:14:44] Host:** Good question, Eric.

**[0:14:46] John Barbella:** as I look at this, I'd like to tell you that we're doing a better job and we're addressing some of these issues. I am a realist and I've come to the conclusion we are never going to be in front of these guys. They're an impressive bunch. I often wonder and say, hey, if they would just put their evil genius to work for the good, we could really have something here. So we're always going to be outpaced by the ideas, the concepts, the schemes of the fraudsters.

**[0:15:17] John Barbella:** So what we've described largely with first-party fraud, it's kind of mom-and-pop stuff. It's not the kind of thing that's going to break the industry's back, but it's just going to always be a drain, a drag on profitability and the like. Now, with things like AI and machine learning, It's pretty frightening to see what the bad guys are cooking up. And in some ways, we have our arms tied behind our backs. I was at a conference back in May, and a gentleman from FinCEN was talking, and they were talking about SARS.

**[0:15:52] John Barbella:** And it was a largely bank audience. And he kept explaining the mandate and the need for the SARS. And the question came up to say, this is great. We're providing the SARS. We don't hear back for six to nine months. You know, how is this being actionable? And he assured us that for certain it was. But this is where I think we're operating with our hands tied behind our backs. Like we have this great information. Yes, it's the privacy of that information is critical.

**[0:16:23] John Barbella:** But is there a way that we can anonymize that information and with AI and machine learning identify schemes and patterns as we're uploading it to FinCEN where we could be taking a look more broadly across the industry to say, hey, we see what's going on. There's a cartel activity in this area, and we see all these deposits that would suggest that activity, but it's not happening just at one bank. Why can't we take that information and be much more proactive in analyzing it rather than sending it up to the magic czar and say, hey, tell us what happens when this comes back.

**[0:17:03] John Barbella:** And oftentimes we're waiting and there's nothing timely. So I think that's where we're at a disadvantage as an industry. I think we have the tools and it's going to take pioneers that are going to say, hey, we are in the midst of right-sizing with a reboot of the FinTech space. Let's do it right. We have these tools. There's no reason we can't assess it. And Neighborly is one of those tools that can help us unrise.

**[0:17:30] John Barbella:** And it's competing banks to say, hey, let's join together. We're joining together in a neighborly way to say, hey, let's find out, root out the bad guys. But now let's find out really bad stuff. You know, when they described how the cartels operated, it was devilish to see how this whole opportunity unfolded. And there's no reason we couldn't nip it in the bud and we just aren't doing it.

**[0:17:55] Host:** Sure. You know, aside from the friends and family fraud, it felt like for the longest time, time was on the side of the financial institutions. If you placed enough governors within your payments process and the transaction, the frosters, they would just go away. They would find the place of the least resistance. However, now with technology, it feels like they have set up, you know, there are millions and millions of synthetic IDs out there that have legitimate activity that's going on there to establish an identity that is looking to become more bulletproof over time.

**[0:18:31] Host:** So time itself isn't necessarily an asset of the financial institutions anymore. It's really more of a level playing field. And I think that's where the network effect of what you're providing through Neighborly and the partners there, I think that's going to help us get a broader view, which I think is so necessary in combating fraud during this time.

**[0:18:57] John Barbella:** No doubt. And it takes a village. There's no doubt about it. You can do a lot of things well internally, and some of the big banks have done that. And it has been a painstaking endeavor to put together an anti-fraud system when there are some pretty basic things. I'd like to tell you that neighborly is rocket science. It isn't. This is a matter of having banks share their information with one another in a way that it's in an anonymous way so that that information, that individual is not going to continue to burn one bank after another, after another.

**[0:19:32] John Barbella:** And those programs are the ones that are taking the fall for that with its actual hard dollar losses. And then we haven't even discussed the reputational risk that the banks take. Like, why on earth would you continue to offer an account to this individual when this has happened over and over again? And some banks don't have the ability even to know that they've been burned by the same person. And when you talk about the synthetic IDs, that's going to take us too far off path.

**[0:20:01] John Barbella:** But there's so much more there and what Neighborly can do to assist in that regard. Because once you identify them, don't let them keep doing it to the industry. And that's what we're doing now. We let it happen.

**[0:20:13] Host:** This show is brought to you by Alloy Labs. As much as we love talking on the show, we believe that action is more valuable than talk. Alloy Labs is the industry leader in helping fearless bankers drive exponential growth through collaboration, exclusive partnerships, and powerful network effects that give them an unfair advantage. Learn more at AlloyLabs.com. Alloy Labs. Banking Unbound.

**[0:20:43] Tyler Seydel:** Well, what I think is exciting, John, is that there's been this problem. It's plagued the industry. You walked through some of the incentives and disincentives as to why. And a lot of that stems from valuation. And we even saw that a little bit in fintech that wasn't perhaps prepaid. And some of the crazy valuations that come out, certainly when a lot of these things might even be still in the idea phase, might not even start gaining traction in market.

**[0:21:09] Tyler Seydel:** And simply what you're doing is saying, hey, let's pool our resources. Let's take our collective experiences. Let's bring them together. And through that commonality, we'll be able to identify likely folks that are affecting everybody or a significant majority of folks within this industry. It gives you the tools to keep bad actors out as they get identified by others. And so that truly is a great experience where if there is harm done, it gets fed into this system and it kind of helps preclude harm from happening again.

**[0:21:35] Tyler Seydel:** That, in my mind, is the real overt value proposition. But would you put a finer point on it for our audience?

**[0:21:41] John Barbella:** certainly other issuing banks out there? Yeah, I think, Tali, you did a really nice job of describing it. If I added another point to beat the dead horse is the banks that are playing, they need the support. I don't want to say a support group, but in some ways, that's where it is. There's not a lot of positives coming out to say what we're seeing in the industry with some of the lapses that have occurred, there's things that you have to do really well.

**[0:22:14] John Barbella:** I mean, you have to be able to balance out each and every day. But what are the banks bringing to those programs to say, we're going to bulletproof you? Here's how we're going to do it. There are some elements that we can bring to the table to really make this effective. And this should be easy or easier than it is. And that is, when I gave the check system example, I cannot imagine setting out on a journey to bring 15 ,000 financial institutions into the fold.

**[0:22:48] John Barbella:** We're talking about 10, 15, where you're going to get the lion's share of the industry, that if they're participating, you are making it harder for that fraudster. And all you want to do is push them down the road. What's the next thing that they're going to do? How do you keep them out of your backyard? And that's where, if I could put a finer point on your comment is, if the other banks are participating and you're not, there's a vulnerability there.

**[0:23:15] John Barbella:** And that's how I see this playing out, where when the banks start to realize the benefits that neighborly can bring to one another, to those member banks, they're going to say, hey, I've got my protection. I'm seeing my fraud numbers go down. But guess what? Down the street, their numbers are going up. And their numbers are going up because the fraudsters are going to figure it out faster than we could where the protections are. And why would they work harder than they have to?

**[0:23:43] John Barbella:** And that's exactly what we've seen in the past. So that's kind of the exciting element of this to say, get on board or the ship's going to leave.

**[0:23:53] Tyler Seydel:** Yeah, I appreciate you calling that out in a sense because there's almost like herd protection or herd immunity. You know, if you're with us, you're protected. But if you're not, by any other stretch of the imagination, the fraudsters are going to go where the path of least resistance lies. And at the end of the day, if that's at an institution that's not participating in neighborly, that's exactly where it's going to migrate to. And I think that that's a sharp call out.

**[0:24:17] Tyler Seydel:** And what I would also like to say, John, and maybe not speaking on behalf of the entire banking industry, but I do think that issuing banks probably do need support groups. But jumping in, because I know you folks have started to look at varying issuing institutions data, and you're probably starting to see some trends or things that excite you, is there anything you'd like to share in some of the data studies that you've done and some of the conclusions that

**[0:24:40] John Barbella:** you've reached and some of the insights that you've gained? Thank you, Tyler. I really appreciate the setup because this is in my notes to say, hey, if there's one thing that's going on, that's kind of cool. One of the things is how do you get to the fraud at the earliest, earliest stage? So if Sunrise gets beat for a thousand bucks, you know, is there something that we could have done proactively to root that out before it happened?

**[0:25:04] John Barbella:** So the data study that we just conducted here in the fourth quarter was pretty cool. We worked with an ACH payments processor. And if fraud happens, it often, you can identify it as it is at the time of payroll where I shipped my account from from Wells Fargo Bank to Program A in fintech. I don't want to point anybody out here. They look like I'm casting aspersions. But that is indicative of potential fraud. So I've been paid on Wells Fargo for the last 10 years, and all of a sudden, my transaction shifts, my payroll shifts.

**[0:25:40] John Barbella:** So this payroll company has a method in order to identify where that fraud occurs, that it is fraud, and And they take that a step further. So what we did in this data study, we then reached out to all the banks that were affected within that. And we said, we can tell you on January 3rd, this account went bad. Do you see this? And it was pretty powerful to get the feedback to say, yeah, we identified it, but we didn't identify until February 12th because they didn't have it.

**[0:26:11] John Barbella:** It takes a while to get that data before we could get it. Well, we're going to be able to do that in a real-time environment. And that's what we're talking about now and say, hey, let's take this. Let's not have Sunrise query Neighborly. Let's have Neighborly say this this account is on your routing number and it's bad. And you can go in and you can put a watch on that account before you get burned. And that is, you know, Neighborly has historically been positioned as a reactive, you know, so has there been fraud?

**[0:26:42] John Barbella:** We can say, we know the fraud's coming. Here's what you need to do about it. And that's kind of cool. And the banks get to set that. The banks that are member banks in Neighborly, they set the operating rules. They tell us what we want. They want to have done. And this is an example of something that we're seeing. It isn't fully in effect yet, but we're just in the data study level. But it's really cool to be able to go proactively.

**[0:27:07] John Barbella:** And I think that's even more valuable because you can stop that fraud. So say the average fraud is $1 ,200, that query, that proactive alert is going to save that bank. It's pretty hard dollar savings.

**[0:27:20] Host:** So, John, as you're looking, so what I've heard is the road, the path for a financial institution to become more fraud resilient is, First off, try to align yourself with the network. Expand your sample size, if you will, to capture a more comprehensive view of the financial activity that's going on in relation to yours so you can react. Secondly, to be able to gear up, staff up, to be able to handle real-time data, respond quickly to fraud because you're going to have that data that's going to give you early insights into this.

**[0:27:57] Host:** as you look out into the future, five, 10, 10 years, what do you see a well-positioned against fraud financial institution? What do you see that? What do you see the key strengths as being? Does it change? And then I guess the other side of the coin is when you think of neighborly, are there things that you're looking at and on your roadmap that reflect trends that you are anticipating in the fraud space three, five, 10 years out?

**[0:28:32] John Barbella:** I'll take the first question first. And so what I see happening, and I referred to it a bit, there are every bank has vulnerabilities in this space. And one of those vulnerabilities are dormant accounts. And I won't delve too deep into a sheetman being one of those issues that just make everybody scratch their head and say, well, there's not a whole lot of value here. What's the best way to handle this? And there's some automated solutions coming on market that are encouraging.

**[0:29:07] John Barbella:** But I see the marketplace changing. So if our industry is 10X right now, I could see it being 4 or 5X. much, much smaller than it is now. And a lot of that is based on all those dormant accounts that I was bringing in just for valuation purposes. And the dormant accounts are vulnerabilities because, first of all, you have to sheet the money, whatever is in there, you have to take care of that in an effective way.

**[0:29:36] John Barbella:** We'll say that. And I would say you'd want to do it more rapidly than is occurring today. But in that dormancy, you have the potential for those bad accounts. And I think, Eric, you were going down this path where a lot of these individuals, they'll make those accounts, those synthetic accounts appear to be real. Then they'll go into some period of dormancy and then they'll come back up and get gotcha. And that's where I think we need to do a better job as an industry.

**[0:30:06] John Barbella:** So I could see a right sizing of the industry. I could see more effectiveness in how we bring on those accounts. And then ultimately, I see the fintech space being able to be more of all things to all people. So that this is the kind of the grand plan for fintech to say, how do we make that leap to becoming a more traditional bank? How can I do all my banking within this ecosystem? And that is a big play.

**[0:30:38] John Barbella:** I think Neighborly can help support that first phase to say, hey, let's get the industry into a healthier place than it is right now. And let's make sure that all the routing numbers are pristine, that you're not having someone in Treasury say, no, we're not going to pay that routing number. There's too much fraud out there. I mean, that actually occurs today. So I see those types of things. What we need to do in 2.0 is we have to clean up and make sure that the tracks are ready for the growth that'll come.

**[0:31:09] John Barbella:** And that growth that will come will be more organic and more reasonable than the growth that we experienced from 2010 to 2020.

**[0:31:20] Tyler Seydel:** John, one thing you mentioned just around routing numbers and treasury or others looking to freeze disbursements to those routing numbers, what you capture there is absolutely accurate, and it does happen in this prepaid space. And it's absolutely a difficult situation to solve, because at the end of the day, you're getting cardholder calls or your customer service is getting impacted as folks are looking to find resolution. And there's not really anything you can do to resolve that other than direct them perhaps to a different product.

**[0:31:45] Tyler Seydel:** And that's a very unique situation for some issuers to be finding themselves in. And so you're absolutely right. For those that may not know, that does happen in the industry. And John Barbella is absolutely accurate in what he's positioning with you folks. The other thing too, John, that I'd look to ask you, tying it back to Neighborly, is how do you describe the culture or your corporate values

**[0:32:08] John Barbella:** within Neighborly? Sure. Thank you, Tyler. First of all, Neighborly is being a startup. We have aligned with some sister companies. So I want to make sure that I put a shout out to those guys. And the way I was able to launch Neighborly is we had, when I was at Bancorp, we were assessing the disputes problem. And one of the things that came was painfully evident is that all our source of information was very difficult to bring that all together.

**[0:32:39] John Barbella:** And so I set out at Bancorp to say, let's identify who or what company would be the best disputes platform. And so I identified a company by the name of APS out of Fargo. And I began to work with those guys. I'm getting to an answer to your question here. And Dave Campbell is the CEO of APS. And the alignment was terrific. And when I shared that we were interested at the bank to say we need to have a solution like APS where we can have consistency and have visibility into that disputes data real time, that was kind of the starting point of that relationship.

**[0:33:17] John Barbella:** And so as we took that further and I shared with them, say, what could this industry be? talking about what I had previously called the Good Neighbor Project, these guys were like, we absolutely, that is a great adjacency to us. And so that's how we got to work together. So I would say our culture is that of a family-owned organization where Neighborly is an extension of what the APS culture is, which is, hey, we're going to do the right thing for our clients.

**[0:33:50] John Barbella:** And there isn't anybody that has met Dave and members of that APS team that doesn't think the world of those guys. So we're looking to do the right thing. And when I've been able to connect APS to other light companies, and you'll see some of them in the industry where they're really committed to doing the right thing, regardless of that expense. They obviously want to manage the money so that it is not out of hand. but they're going to be down to earth.

**[0:34:20] John Barbella:** And that's where our culture as Neighborly is growing. And as we will expand, it's really how do we treat our partners? I mean, Neighborly doesn't have employees per se. We have partners that help us enable this. We have the Advantage Technology team that manages our infrastructure. They've got all the necessary credentials that we would need in order to manage the data on behalf of our partners. But then the neighborly culture is going to be, hey, how are we going to work with our partners?

**[0:34:51] John Barbella:** What does that feel like? How are we going to let the partners drive this bus? Because this is not a neighborly is going to create this product, that product, that product. We only need to create the products that the banks think that they need. And I would also say and working with the regulators. So it's about a roundabout way to answer your question about culture. But in partnering with the APS team and building out neighborly, it's how do we interact with our partners?

**[0:35:18] John Barbella:** And we do that in the same family-oriented way that our friends at APS do.

**[0:35:24] Tyler Seydel:** I thought that was a great answer, John. For those of you that have not had any interaction with APS or certainly Dave Campbell or the Campbell family, immensely genuine and authentic group of folks. And to be honest, when you go to some of these trade publications, seek out John or even Dave and have a conversation. You'll leave that conversation going, wow, they're very grounded, down to earth and immensely helpful. It absolutely is that way. There's a lot of folks that have a lot of industry expertise, a lot of experience, and they're truly doing what's right.

**[0:35:52] Tyler Seydel:** And that's a value that I put a lot of emphasis on. John, just to start to close things up, I always like to ask a question that helps personify, for lack of a better turn of phrase, folks for the audience. And what is something that you could share about yourself that very few folks would know about you, John?

**[0:36:08] John Barbella:** Boy, that's a right. My wife would tell you that's a big opportunity for closure. I've got to be careful where I go with this one. Let's see. So I think the way I was works really important to me, but I am really committed to new ideas, new thoughts. What what can we do? So generally in my world, I work. We have three kids that are all out of the house. Last one still in college, but just about done.

**[0:36:43] John Barbella:** So I was always very involved with the kids in their their various activities, largely sports. So served in coaching roles and served in boards, became a sports official, given some of the you may have heard that there's a dearth of officials. And with the number of games exploding, it's something that we have to address as a society because, you know, sports, kids, sports are a big part of a lot of people's lives. And so I'd say that would probably be the primary.

**[0:37:15] John Barbella:** Many people probably know that about me, but don't talk too much about that stuff in a professional endeavor. But it's really important that I stay active and I love working with kids and still play baseball and those kinds of things. So anything with a ball involved, I'm probably there and hopefully helping out and making things better for everybody.

**[0:37:36] Tyler Seydel:** Well, I like that you give back to the youth, John. They truly are the future. and for those folks that do have kids, I think everybody recognizes that there's a lot of things you could spend your time and your money on, but one thing that you'll always get is interaction with kids is far better and beyond dollars and time. It's heartwarming in a whole different kind of way. Is there anything that we didn't cover today, John, that you'd like to leave us with?

**[0:38:01] Tyler Seydel:** Is there any thoughts percolating within that head that you'd like to get out in front of our audience before we look to close?

**[0:38:08] John Barbella:** I think we've touched on most things, Tyler. I am optimistic where we're headed as an industry. I think we're doing the right things. It's really a cool time for me personally, where I've been able to partner with organizations like Sunrise, some of our other investors, some of the other banks that have expressed interest in joining. we've got a lot of really cool things going. And it's not, I feel like I've been released a bit from some of the mundane things that I had to contend with at the bank where, you know, that they're hard.

**[0:38:47] John Barbella:** I mean, when you have to work with your regulator and the like, it's not the easiest thing. So how can we take some of that burden off the banks? And we would like that any interaction with Neighborly is we're talking ways that we can improve the industry, but improve that bank, that program's interactions with the regulators. We think that Neighborly is a powerful tool, and we're looking forward to having it go full tilt. And the way to do that is bringing more banks on board.

**[0:39:16] John Barbella:** We've got a handful that we're really excited about. And as some of the big wins that those banks like Sunrise have had recently, that's all the better for everybody. And we think that we can develop a tool that's going to really propel the industry forward.

**[0:39:32] Host:** Well, John, it's been so great to talk to you today. It's been a pleasure. Thank you so much for joining us. And we look forward to seeing you again really soon.

**[0:39:42] John Barbella:** Hey, thanks, Eric. Thanks, Tyler. See you guys in a couple of weeks. Thanks, John. So long.

**[0:39:48] Brett King:** That's it for another week of the world's number one fintech podcast and radio show, Breaking Banks. This episode was produced by our US-based production team, including producer Elizabeth Severins, audio engineer Kevin Hersham. If you liked this episode, don't forget to tweet it out or post it on your favorite social media. Or leave us a five-star review on iTunes, Google Podcasts, Facebook, or wherever it is that you listen to our show. Those actions help other people find our podcast.

**[0:40:15] Brett King:** And in return, that helps us build an audience that can be supported by sponsorship so we can continue to provide you with our award-winning content every week. Thanks again for joining us. We'll see you on Breaking Banks next week.
