OpenNashPodcasts

The Business Times Podcasts

S1E1: Compliance to competitiveness: Why SEFR matters

28 Sep 2025 · 29m · Kok Ping Soon, Marcus Lam, Claressa Monteiro · 19 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Singapore's delay to mandatory climate reporting for smaller listed companies is a pause, not an exemption. Kok Ping Soon of the Singapore Business Federation and Marcus Lam of PwC Singapore argue that customers, parent companies and export markets will keep demanding emissions data. Companies that treat the extra time as a reason to wait risk being dropped from supply chains.

The tension is between regulatory relief and commercial pressure. Regulators eased the heaviest requirements, especially Scope 3 for smaller firms, while big buyers still need that data from their suppliers. The Singapore Emission Factor Registry (SEFR) and the NetZeroHub.sg portal are presented as shared tools. They aim to cut the cost for small firms and turn compliance into a selling point.

Key insights

  1. The delay covers only some reporting duties

    Kok says Scope 1 and 2 reporting is still due for all listed firms by FY2025, and the top 30 companies keep their original deadlines. Only the heavier disclosures for the other roughly 550 companies move back, to 2028 or 2030.

  2. Small firms get squeezed by customers, not regulators

    Kok describes an international school's bus tender that demanded baseline emissions data, which many small bus operators could not supply. Marcus adds that demands from headquarters and overseas customers keep rising regardless of the local delay.

  3. Local emission factors make carbon numbers credible

    An emission factor is the multiplier that converts activity such as electricity use into greenhouse gas emissions. Without Singapore-specific factors, firms borrow US or UK ones, which Kok says could produce figures that are too high or too low.

  4. Industry-average factors spare small suppliers Scope 3 work

    For Scope 3 services such as cleaning, security and professional services, SEFR is building sector averages. A large buyer can multiply contracted hours by the factor, so the cleaning company does not have to calculate its own emissions.

  5. Product carbon footprints can win sales

    Kok says Razer published product carbon footprints on SEFR. He says Amazon's search can then rank those products higher for environmentally conscious shoppers, and that Razer reported increased sales as a result.

Questions

Did Singapore cancel mandatory climate reporting for smaller companies?

No. Kok Ping Soon says Scope 1 and 2 emissions reporting is still required for all listed companies by FY2025. Other disclosures are delayed to FY2028 for companies above $1 billion market cap and to 2030 for smaller ones.

What are Scope 1, 2 and 3 emissions?

Marcus Lam explains that Scope 1 is what a company directly controls, such as its vehicles. Scope 2 is purchased electricity, and Scope 3 is everything outside its direct control, both upstream (what it buys) and downstream (what customers do with its products).

What is the Singapore Emission Factor Registry (SEFR) and why does it matter?

It is a database of local numbers used to convert activities such as electricity use or time into greenhouse gas emissions. It matters because using US or UK numbers would be less accurate for Singapore's energy mix and conditions.

Why should a small business care about emissions reporting if it isn't legally required yet?

The guests say larger customers, overseas headquarters and tenders increasingly ask suppliers for emissions data. Kok warns that firms without it risk being 'green out' of the supply chain, meaning shut out for failing sustainability requirements.

Where can a company get help starting?

Kok points to the NetZeroHub.sg portal, which lists training, solutions, grants and events. He also mentions a government grant covering up to 30% of first-report costs, capped at $150,000, and says SBF has sustainability advisors.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Kok Ping Soon says Scope 1 and Scope 2 emissions reporting was not delayed and all SGX-listed companies must report by FY2025.

“as far as scope one and scope two emissions are concerned, there is no delay. All companies listed, whether you're big or small, you're still required to report by FY 2025.”

0:01:46 · Kok Ping Soon · Climate reporting · 2025

Kok Ping Soon says SGX-listed companies above $1 billion market capitalisation get a delay until FY2028 for other climate disclosures, while smaller ones get until 2030.

“If you're more than $1 billion, which is about 60-odd companies, the delay is three years up to FY 2028. Then for the rest, which is less than one billion market cap, the delay is, as you have pointed out, five years to 2030.”

0:02:21 · Kok Ping Soon · Reporting deadlines · 2028

Kok Ping Soon says Scope 3 reporting is still due by FY2026 for the top 30 SGX companies but is now voluntary for the rest.

“for scope three emissions, again, if you are the top 30 companies, no change. By FY2026, you have to report. But for the rest of the companies on SGX, it's now voluntary.”

0:02:49 · Kok Ping Soon · Scope 3 · 2026

Kok Ping Soon says a survey of over 500 small and medium enterprises found three recurring challenges, which he calls manpower, method and money.

“when we spoke to 500 over SMEs last year in a survey, consistently, they told us they faced three key challenges.”

0:05:56 · Kok Ping Soon · SME survey

Kok Ping Soon says an international school in Singapore required bus operators to submit baseline emissions data in a procurement tender, which many small operators could not do.

“We know of an international school in Singapore that put out a procurement tender to buy buses to ferry their students. And in their procurement specs, they require the bus operators to submit their baseline emissions data.”

0:06:49 · Kok Ping Soon · Supply-chain pressure

Kok Ping Soon explains that an emission factor is the number by which an activity, such as electricity use, is multiplied to get greenhouse gas emissions.

“So to translate from this to this, you need to multiply with a number. So that number is called emission factors.”

0:09:15 · Kok Ping Soon · Emission factors

Kok Ping Soon says the need for localised emission factors was raised in a Forward SG conversation hosted by PwC with a government minister around 2022.

“This very idea of the need, this problem statement was actually articulated in a forward SG conversation that PWC hosted with Minister Graceful. In, I think, 2022, thereabout.”

0:09:39 · Kok Ping Soon · SEFR origins · 2022

Kok Ping Soon says the United Kingdom has about 700 emission factors.

“the number of factors is not trivial. UK has about 700 of these emission factors.”

0:10:35 · Kok Ping Soon · Emission factors

Kok Ping Soon says the SEFR partnership was announced in April and its first version, with over 200 factors, followed in October, covering about 80% of Scope 1 and 2 needs for most users.

“we announced the partnership in April last year. In October last year, we had the first iteration of the SEFR with 200 over factors that can complete about 80 % of scope one, scope two emissions for most people.”

0:11:47 · Kok Ping Soon · SEFR launch

Kok Ping Soon says Scope 3 accounts for about 80% of most companies' total emissions and is divided into 15 categories.

“for most companies, scope 3 emissions account for 80 % of the total emissions of a company. And to add another level of complexity, there are 15 categories of this scope 3.”

0:16:23 · Kok Ping Soon · Scope 3

Kok Ping Soon says SEFR chose cleaning, security and professional services as its first three Scope 3 categories, based on materiality and the lack of usable international factors.

“we landed on three categories of scope three emissions factors that is quite important that contribute to purchase goods and services. So cleaning services, security services, and professional services”

0:16:54 · Kok Ping Soon · Scope 3 factors

Kok Ping Soon says SEFR's industry-average factors mean individual cleaning companies need not calculate their own emissions for clients' Scope 3 reports.

“So now I relieve the need for individual cleaning company to generate it because I now give an industry cleaning average emission factor for those companies that need to report scope 3.”

0:19:08 · Kok Ping Soon · Industry averages

Kok Ping Soon says SEFR's methodology is aligned with the PACT network run by the World Business Council for Sustainable Development, and that it is the first national emission factor registry to join.

“So what it does is that our methodology is aligned to PAC, which means that SEFR, and we are the first national emission factor registry that is part of this PAC network.”

0:20:35 · Kok Ping Soon · PACT network

Kok Ping Soon says Amazon has started asking for product carbon footprint data as a differentiating factor.

“Amazon, because it's a progressive company, has started to ask for product carbon footprint as a differentiating factor.”

0:21:02 · Kok Ping Soon · Product footprints

Kok Ping Soon says Razer published product carbon footprints on SEFR, ranked higher in Amazon searches for environmentally conscious shoppers, and reported increased sales.

“Razer's product is going to be listed on the top, above those who have not published their data and all that. And Razer actually reported increased sales because of that.”

0:21:28 · Kok Ping Soon · Razer case

Kok Ping Soon says the government's enterprise sustainability reporting grant covers up to 30% of costs, capped at $150,000, for a company's first report.

“And it provides up to 30 % support, if I remember, up to 150 ,000 for companies to do their first report.”

0:23:16 · Kok Ping Soon · Government grant

Kok Ping Soon says that about a year after launch, between 800 and 1,000 organisations had benefited from the NetZeroHub.sg portal.

“We're happy that since we launched it about a year ago together with the SEFR, over 800 to 1 ,000 organizations have benefited from it.”

0:24:16 · Kok Ping Soon · NetZeroHub portal

Marcus Lam says that other countries in the region, such as Australia, have continued to push ahead with climate reporting, making Singapore look somewhat behind.

“I think every other country, especially in the region, some countries like Australia, they have continued to push forward.”

0:03:46 · Marcus Lam · Regional comparison

Marcus Lam describes Singapore as an open economy that is about 80% export-oriented and a hub for aviation, logistics, finance and trading.

“We are export-oriented economy 80 % export-oriented We are Aviation hub logistic hub financial hub trading hub entire open economy”

0:27:23 · Marcus Lam · Singapore economy

Chapters

  1. 0:01:46What the reporting delay does and doesn't change

    Kok breaks down which deadlines moved and which did not. Scope 1 and 2 reporting and the top 30 companies' obligations are unchanged.

    “scope one and scope two emissions are concerned, there is no delay”
  2. 0:05:10SMEs aren't in PR mode, they're stretched

    Both guests say small firms are held back by cash flow, manpower and know-how, not indifference. The 'three Ms' framing sets up the rest of the discussion.

    “Economic uncertainty, cash flow issues, survival issues.”
  3. 0:06:49Supply-chain pressure reaches domestic firms

    A school's bus tender shows that buyers of purely local services can require emissions data. The guests say such demands will keep growing.

    “they require the bus operators to submit their baseline emissions data”
  4. 0:09:15Why Singapore needed its own emission factors

    Kok explains emission factors and why borrowed US and UK numbers are a poor fit. He also traces how SBF ended up building the registry.

    “this is a case where everybody saw a need. Everybody felt that they have a part to play.”
  5. 0:16:23Tackling Scope 3 with sector averages

    Scope 3 is the largest and hardest part of a company's footprint. SEFR starts with cleaning, security and professional services to ease the load on suppliers.

    “scope 3 emissions account for 80 % of the total emissions of a company”
  6. 0:21:28Product carbon footprints and the Razer example

    Publishing product-level footprints can become a sales advantage. The Razer and Amazon example is the guests' proof.

    “And Razer actually reported increased sales because of that.”
  7. 0:23:43Support tools and the NetZeroHub portal

    Kok maps the SME problems of money, manpower and method to a grant, training and the NetZeroHub.sg portal.

    “this netzerohub.sg is actually a resource portal by the industry for the industry.”
  8. 0:28:13What failure looks like for an open economy

    Marcus frames emissions reporting as strategic for a trade-dependent economy, not a government box-ticking exercise. Kok urges firms not to wait.

    “I see it as, I have to say, existential for an open economy here”

Transcript

0:00:00
Claressa Monteiro

Singapore delayed mandatory ESG reporting for smaller listed firms. That buys time, but also raises the stakes. What does that mean for businesses here? This is a podcast from the Business Times, produced in collaboration with PwC Singapore. Hello, and welcome to Ask PwC Singapore, a new podcast series that answers important questions for businesses. I'm Claressa Monteiro. Singapore just delayed mandatory climate reporting by three to five years. So what does this delay really mean? And how do we make sustainability actually sustainable for business?

0:00:41

Joining me are two excellent guides, Kok Ping Soon, CEO of the Singapore Business Federation, and Marcus Lam, Executive Chairman of PwC Singapore. Let's get real so you can act with clarity and build real value in your sustainability journey. ACRA and SGX have just extended the timeline for climate-related disclosures. What does that actually really imply?

0:01:11
Kok Ping Soon

Sure, let me start. The way I look at it, there are three conclusions that you can draw from this delay. I think number one, I would like to credit that SGX and ACRA are listening. We have given feedback to them Based on ground engagement with businesses On the challenges they have And they have hurt us Number two I would like to characterize their approach To be one, being practical And not being dogmatic And then the third I would say that It shows that they understood That it is important to focus on quality Then rather than to go through the process And kind of check the box And I would like to take this opportunity To kind of unpack You know,

0:01:46

this delay that you talk about And I will do it in three parts It is important that businesses understand what are the components that are being delayed and what are not being delayed. So the point number one that I want to make is that as far as scope one and scope two emissions are concerned, there is no delay. All companies listed, whether you're big or small, you're still required to report by FY 2025. Point number two, as far as other climate reporting disclosures are concerned, companies who are on SDI, which are the top 30 companies, which are the biggest and the most liquid, compliance deadline has also not changed.

0:02:21

It's post-reported by FY 2025. But for the remaining companies on SGX, which is probably about 550-odd companies, you're right to say that delay has been given for either three years or five years, depending on the market cap. If you're more than $1 billion, which is about 60-odd companies, the delay is three years up to FY 2028. Then for the rest, which is less than one billion market cap, the delay is, as you have pointed out, five years to 2030.

0:02:49

Now, the third point that I want to make is that for scope three emissions, again, if you are the top 30 companies, no change. By FY2026, you have to report. But for the rest of the companies on SGX, it's now voluntary. So what it shows is that the authorities here are taking a very calibrated approach in doing mandatory requirements. It's really the more resource-intensive reporting requirements, such as requiring companies to do impact analysis, right? You know, financial impact analysis on risk and opportunities require them to compile these emission data from companies that are supplying to them that's not under their control.

0:03:32

These are the ones that are actually being delayed. And for good reasons, because of the maturity of the ecosystem and the resources that's needed to do those work.

0:03:41
Claressa Monteiro

Could we look at it as a second chance for smaller cap companies to get ready?

0:03:46
Marcus Lam

Marcus? Our government has taken a look and seen what they can do to support businesses. I think this delay will allow time to build capacity, to understand the requirement, right, and to work internally of what they can do, right, to adjust themselves and get ready to support and adjust in terms of meeting the requirement. So I think it's a good timing. The only downside is I think every other country, especially in the region, some countries like Australia, they have continued to push forward.

0:04:20

So in that context, you may see as we're a bit behind. But we have to acknowledge that getting behind but getting high quality.

0:04:31
Kok Ping Soon

I totally agree. I think in this case, as I mentioned earlier, it's about being pragmatic. And the good news is that when we engage many of the listed companies, It's a smaller one. After the announcement has been made, other than bringing a sigh of relief, they did assure us and authorities that it does not detract them from the preparatory effort that they're doing.

0:04:52
Claressa Monteiro

So we're not backing down on our sustainability goals? No, we're focusing on quality rather than just checking the box. Okay, so... Are Singaporean SMEs moving fast enough? Or are we still stuck in PR mode sustainability?

0:05:10
Marcus Lam

You know, my friends in the SME, whether it's in logistics, retail, F &B, honestly, everyone look at me and say that they are not in PR mode. What they're struggling with is sometimes lack of understanding of where sustainability should be. They have to deal with very clear challenges that we see in the market at the moment. Economic uncertainty, cash flow issues, survival issues. So smaller SMEs across those sectors has been sharing with us, those are real issues on the ground.

0:05:45

And so how would they be able to address those real issues with this that's coming? So clearly, in my mind, they are not in PR mode.

0:05:56
Kok Ping Soon

You agree with him? I totally agree. And when we spoke to 500 over SMEs last year in a survey, consistently, they told us they faced three key challenges. and I call it the 3M, not MediShield, MediSave. But really, number one, I think they lack the capacity and the capability to do things in-house, which is manpower. Number two, yes, there's a lot of solutions out there, but they're just not aware of that and that's what I call method.

0:06:21

And the third one is, of course, no price for guessing, they just don't have enough financial resources, not enough money. Wouldn't they say money would be first? Yes, money is certainly important, but let's also not forget that if the money you have, you still need to get the resources in terms of manpower and method. Money buys manpower. It does buy manpower, but I think it's important to prioritize along this tree. But at the same time, because of all these challenges that SMEs faces, they're not fast enough to respond to the changes in the market.

0:06:49

And there are increasingly cases where SMEs realize that if they don't spend some time to do that, they get kind of green out from the supply chain. And they may think that they are not supplying to MNCs or international but domestic. And I'll give you an example. We know of an international school in Singapore that put out a procurement tender to buy buses to ferry their students. And in their procurement specs, they require the bus operators to submit their baseline emissions data.

0:07:16

Guess what? Many of the smaller bus operators are just not prepared to do that. First of all, they haven't figured out what is scope one, what is scope two, what is scope three, right? So they were not able to participate in a tender. So this is an example of an international school based in Singapore, but they had to take compliance requirements from their HQ outside of Singapore.

0:07:35
Marcus Lam

I think over a period of time, you'll find that the requirement either from HQ, the requirement coming out from the customer or internationally, will continue to increase. We don't see that slowdown. Actually, when we work with SME and we speak to the region, it's quite clear that this requirement is here to stay.

0:07:56
Claressa Monteiro

It's interesting you say that because I think if more businesses realise that there is a positive financial impact to this, they'll embrace it faster, right?

0:08:09
Marcus Lam

Whether it's on electricity, whether it's on waste, waste is plenty of opportunity, whether it's on packaging, whether it's on transportation, and all those differences, it adds up. And I come back to the point, you will have a competitive advantage, whether it's on cost, whether it's on branding, whether it's on reputation, why.

0:08:32
Claressa Monteiro

Okay. Now, let's go to SEFR. In a conversation we had earlier, you said it's a welcome development, but why did it take so long? What were the roadblocks? How did that delay affect business? So many questions, Bingsu. Maybe you can break it down first.

0:08:49
Kok Ping Soon

So it stands for the Singapore Emission Factor Registry. Okay. And just to explain a little bit of technicalities, what is emission factors? We talk a lot about carbon reporting, right? So carbon reporting is to be able to translate all the operational activities you have into what they call greenhouse gas emission. The type of operational activities could be in terms of time, in terms of money, in terms of electricity. They're all in different matrices, right? But now we need to change it to a thing called GHG.

0:09:15

So to translate from this to this, you need to multiply with a number. So that number is called emission factors. So the question is, what took so long, right? Well, I think, you know, there's all this story about a story of like, you know, everybody, somebody, anybody, nobody, that kind of story. But I wouldn't repeat the whole story. But I think this is a case where everybody saw a need. Everybody felt that they have a part to play.

0:09:39

But it was not clear that it is a problem that's owned by anybody. So as a result, you know, things did not move along quite far. And actually, I would like to credit PwC. This very idea of the need, this problem statement was actually articulated in a forward SG conversation that PWC hosted with Minister Graceful. In, I think, 2022, thereabout. In that conversation, the industry gave feedback to the ministry. He said, hey, minister, we need localized emission factors.

0:10:07

Because if you don't have these localized emission factors, companies will have to use factors from the US and from the UK. And obviously, the operating conditions in US and UK are different. Just look at the energy mix that we have used to produce electricity. Obviously, very different from UK and US. Even our public buses, or cars, you know, are very different. So if you don't have the localized factors, companies like the Singtel, the big companies who have to use US and UK factors to multiply whatever they do here.

0:10:35

It wouldn't be ideal. Obviously, it could be either too high or it could be too low. So it's not accurate. And if you don't have things that's accurate, that cannot be the basis for any decision making. So that was the problem statement. So, but as I said, it's like nobody kind of own it because you need public factors, you need private factors. And by the way, you know, the number of factors is not trivial. UK has about 700 of these emission factors.

0:10:58

That's not insignificant. That's not insignificant. So, SBF was called, you know, I was called, I said, SBF, do something about it.

0:11:06
Marcus Lam

And SBF volunteered.

0:11:08
Kok Ping Soon

Was volunteered. Was volunteered, I think. And we were volunteered, but I also recognize because this is the problem of the commons, right? And I think as the business, Apex Business Chamber, we know that this will benefit the industry. we know you need to work with the private and the public sector and so we leaned forward to do that and we managed to pull together a collision of like-minded partners that involve MTI and MSE and those two are important because they are the ministry that owns the agencies that produce many of the public EFs including water, electricity, waste and so forth but we also brought together ASTAR and we wrote in PwC we wrote in Singtel

0:11:46
Claressa Monteiro

well since it started with them

0:11:47
Kok Ping Soon

since it's their compensation you better own it right but more importantly because PwC is a preparer They work with many companies. And Singtel is one of the STI companies, so they know what is needed. And then we wrote in SBF Foundation, which is a social impact arm for SBF. And once we got that together, I would like to think that it didn't take so long. You know, we announced the partnership in April last year. In October last year, we had the first iteration of the SEFR with 200 over factors that can complete about 80 % of scope one, scope two emissions for most people.

0:12:18

And come October in the first anniversary, will be making further announcement of a new set of EFs to be published.

0:12:25
Claressa Monteiro

Okay, Marcus, since it started with PWC Sample, I'm wondering, what was the driving factor? Was there a gap that you saw, that you raised? What was the opportunity?

0:12:39
Marcus Lam

So, just like Ping Sun mentioned, actually, you know, what we do is we have hosted many of the clients, right, in the market together with a government agency. And so all this conversation actually was trying to find, you know, what's really the challenge and the pinpoint in the market. It gets even more difficult because as more and more people comes to measure the emission factor, I think their challenge is that it's just not representative. It's not representative of the condition in this region.

0:13:14

There are also international emission factor that's available elsewhere. that they provide, it's a baseline for anyone that operates in those regions that you can calculate. Those stuff then force us to rethink that what else can we do for this market? This is something that not just Singapore company will benefit. I mean, I just want to expand a bit there. If you look at the entire ASEAN region, there are many other companies in here that will benefit from relying on emission factor that we can cover beyond what is in Singapore.

0:13:49

So we believe really, if you think about it, what's the ASEAN emission factor registry? That would be super powerful. And with that, you essentially are able to, first, you have consistency, comparability. You're helping the company in this region to be able to find a way to communicate using methodology, right? They're similar internationally and recognized. I think that's a powerful way for us to be plugged into the ecosystem globally and differentiate. Rather than you have international standards that set themselves that may disadvantage some of the companies that's operating in this region.

0:14:33

So I'm super excited about this and can't wait for the second iteration to come from Bing soon and the third iteration to come. And so we are working hard on this. I mean, we talked about scope one, scope two.

0:14:45
Claressa Monteiro

That's pretty straightforward at this point. Scope three, still a bit of a confusion, still a bit of a black hole.

0:14:54
Marcus Lam

So what's scope one? So anything that you control directly in terms of, let's say, electricity that you use. That's either the vehicles that you use in the plants in order for transportation, that's one. Scope two is very simply electricity that you purchase in Singapore to power your plant. That's scope two. scope tree very simply is everything that's not directly under your control it could be upstream downstream very simply upstream means that whatever the products that you buy for what are those emission or the carbon that's associated with it right on downstream could be anything that you sell to the customer that's directly relating to the waste directly relating to what your customer actual impact on the goods that you sell

0:15:47

to them. So the scope tree is the one that is most complex actually because one and two is much easier to do. Scope tree, it's also not so straightforward. There are multiple areas that you have to consider. The adjustment that you have to take into consideration and there's a worry about double counting. That's another area. There's also a worry that if you are not using the same level of factors, you may be disadvantaged and you may calculate more than what you think it is.

0:16:16

So, scope 3 is the one that's outside your main control domain. Very simply, upstream, downstream.

0:16:23
Kok Ping Soon

But why is scope 3 important? Because for most companies, scope 3 emissions account for 80 % of the total emissions of a company. And to add another level of complexity, there are 15 categories of this scope 3. Purchase goods and services, waste generated from operations, finance emissions. So that is a challenge that's actually faced the SEFR. You know, where are you going to start? There's 15 categories, right? Yes, we have done the first 200 EFs that meet most of scope one, scope two, but how do you tackle the scope three?

0:16:54

So we did the extensive consultations with companies that have to do such reporting with inputs from preparers like PWC. And we use a very simple two-by-two matrix. Number one, materiality. Number two, are there factors out there internationally that we can actually use that doesn't make much of a difference anyway. So with that, we landed on three categories of scope three emissions factors that is quite important that contribute to purchase goods and services. So cleaning services, security services, and professional services, which of course include the consulting companies, the legal services.

0:17:29

These are the type of goods and services that most big companies would buy, even SPH, for example, right? And so we have been working with the Cleaning Association, Security Association, ISCA, and with a representative pool of companies in this to generate a set of localized emission factors, which can then convert the amount of time that the company purchased from a security company or cleaning service companies into a set of GHG, carbon emissions, that they can use for their scope tree reporting.

0:17:59

And there's urgency to do that because, as I mentioned earlier, the scope tree reporting, at least for the big listed companies, remains by FY2026. So we better get this ready. Exactly. So it's not delayed.

0:18:12
Claressa Monteiro

But if it's scope 3, that means everybody is involved in the reporting, including smaller companies, right? Oh, yes. So I'm just wondering, if you are a big company and you have to start reporting in 2026, but the smaller companies have got a delay in reporting.

0:18:32
Kok Ping Soon

See, so that's why the industry average ES becomes useful. So let's say SPH Is going to engage a cleaning company To do your thing Now you don't need to ask The cleaning company What is your EF You know in your contracting With the cleaning company I'm just making things up A few hours a day So there's a number of hours You have multiplied By the number of days And then you use a factor That we generate Because this factor Is not specific company That you get But it's representative Of the cleaning sectors In Singapore And these services are in Singapore So you take that factor Multiply with the amount of hours you contract and you get your carbon emission.

0:19:08

So now I relieve the need for individual cleaning company to generate it because I now give an industry cleaning average emission factor for those companies that need to report scope 3.

0:19:17
Marcus Lam

So you want to take an approach where you can solve it by relieving the pressure on the SME. Right? But at the same time, being able to comply with the requirement that is suitable for here. And for the SME going forward, actually, imagine, even for them, the compliance requirement is much less. Because once we can sort this out, any of the stuff that they use is

0:19:41
Kok Ping Soon

much easier for them to do. But for the more progressive company, and I'll take this discussion a bit further, we're talking a lot about industry averages, EFs. There's a thing called product carbon footprint. At that product level, what is your carbon emission? Now, SMEs are probably not ready for that, but there are many Singapore companies that are quite prepared because they believes that by publishing carbon-based emission factors that is based on their product, it can differentiate them from the market.

0:20:08

And SEFR, other than abiding by international standards for the computation of this EF, we have also signed up to the PAC. PAC is a Partnership for Action for Carbon Transparency. It's being done by this organization called, another long acronym, it's called the World Business Council. There seems to be a few of them. Yeah, it's a whole alphabet soup of a different organization. And Pink Soon likes to have acronyms. It's an acronym. So it's called WBCSD, the World Business Council of Sustainable Development.

0:20:35

It's a bunch of 200-odd international companies that account for a significant contribution to global carbon footprint. So what it does is that our methodology is aligned to PAC, which means that SEFR, and we are the first national emission factor registry that is part of this PAC network. What it means is that if you publish your product carbon footprint there, it abides by international standard and it allows companies to access Very abstract. I'll give you one example, right?

0:21:02

So one of the companies that published their PCFs on SEFR is a company called Razer. I think many companies, many of the listeners would know about Razer. As you know, they sell many of the computer peripherals. I think all of us have Razer products somewhere in our office. Very good. So where would you buy the Razer product? In the US, maybe you buy from Amazon. Guess what? Amazon, because it's a progressive company, has started to ask for product carbon footprint as a differentiating factor.

0:21:28

and it's in their search algorithm. So when you go Amazon and search for mouse peripheral and all that, if you say that, I want to be a bit environmentally conscious, then Razer's product is going to be listed on the top, above those who have not published their data and all that. And Razer actually reported increased sales because of that. So this is a very good example of how the companies who are progressive, who are publishing their emission factor beyond a company to product level, actually generate more sales.

0:21:56
Marcus Lam

I think that product level I would say carbon footprint is taking off especially in Europe has some impact but I think what we can expect is that the rest of the world are still continuing to push on and the product differentiation on carbon footprint will come full steam in time to come and so any of the companies in here, the larger company I think will all get ready but the SME that's coming out and to think about, firstly, what do you want to tell the world in terms of where your carbon footprint, that's the one that you can differentiate in the market.

0:22:38

And the more that they can do that, whether it's in retail that we see, in electronic products that we see, which is one, in components or electronic products that's produced in here, you will get a different set of customer and a different set of buyer in Europe as compared to what you have today. So what's the resource portal? That's a great one. Resource portal. Someone will say, why do we come out a resource portal? Then I will let Ping Sun explain why he needs a resource portal.

0:23:16
Kok Ping Soon

Why are you always directing all these difficult questions to me? That's why you're sitting over there. That's why I'm sitting over there. Well, I go back to that three M's that I talk about, right? that SMEs face challenges. I mentioned, and since you said, the first M ought to be money and not manpower, the government do have an enterprise sustainability reporting grant in that formulation of words. And it provides up to 30 % support, if I remember, up to 150 ,000 for companies to do their first report.

0:23:43

So that's addressed. Manpower, there's a lot of training, but beyond training, the government actually has a career conversion program for sustainability professionals, of which SBF is one of their partners. But it's a central one, the so-called methods. So this netzerohub.sg is actually a resource portal by the industry for the industry. We want to be a trusted platform to put together not just playbooks, but resources such as where they can go for training, resources of where they can find the right solutions, where they can get the government grants, as well as an events calendar.

0:24:16

We're happy that since we launched it about a year ago together with the SEFR, over 800 to 1 ,000 organizations have benefited from it. But as with all of such digital portal, you know, it gets up to date the day that you launch it. So there's a lot of work that goes behind it to curate the content, keep it updated, and to refresh it with newer features as we go along.

0:24:40
Claressa Monteiro

You talked about collaboration. The public sector, the private sector, trade groups, all that came together. but we do, we have examples and we have all seen cooperation can stall. So what makes this different and how do we keep the momentum moving forward?

0:25:03
Kok Ping Soon

Well, I think Marcus from the PWC who has much more experience in putting together all this.

0:25:10
Marcus Lam

If you ask me this question about four or five years ago, I may not say this is sustainable By today, I believe that the initiative and what has been launched, it's the word sustainability, it's highly sustainable. SEFR is a must in the market, whether it's done by us or done by someone else. And it has to be a collaboration between industry, government, and private. That's the only way to sustain it. If you look at the international one, that's how they have sustained it.

0:25:44

And our question more for ourselves is, don't keep it to Singapore. Be bold. Go to ASEAN. That's the differentiator. And we take the lead. We take the chance. Everybody in this industry in Singapore and elsewhere will benefit from it. So I see that this is a blueprint for many people in this region that could do better. So when we are looking at this initiative at the moment, there is alignment of three things very clearly. Alignment of goal, alignment of the interests, alignment of the challenges in the market.

0:26:23

I firmly believe this will continue.

0:26:26
Kok Ping Soon

So we certainly look forward to PWC leadership, you know, in bringing this resource portal beyond Singapore to the region.

0:26:34
Claressa Monteiro

What does failure look like if this doesn't work out, if it falls short?

0:26:40
Kok Ping Soon

Cliché to say, obviously, failure is not an option, you know. Failure is never in our plans. But I suppose what failure looks like would be, you know, many of our companies, you know, are not doing the reporting. They don't get the urgency to do it. And as a result, you know, they will be, as I mentioned, potentially green out the supply chain for SMEs and all companies. Notwithstanding the fact that, yes, the headline may sound that, you know, there's a delay in the mandatory requirement.

0:27:06

Don't wait, right? If you don't know where to start, go to netzerohub.sg. Resource portal Resource portal And then after that If you still haven't Really figured things out You can call SBF We do have Sustainably advisors Who can walk the journey with you

0:27:23
Marcus Lam

I love his Rallying call Just for your point about What does failure look like Okay Maybe we take a step back We look at We are export-oriented economy 80 % export-oriented We are Aviation hub logistic hub financial hub trading hub entire open economy and so what do we depend on? Trade flows finance flows aviation flow and all those if we are not forefront in here and be able to make sure that it's not about compliance it's about meeting the customer need it's about differentiating ourselves if we don't do that I think we'll be in big trouble to stay ahead.

0:28:13

So I don't see it as meeting a requirement by the government on net zero. I see it as, I have to say, existential for an open economy here to be able to continue to punch above the weight. And if you don't do that, then clearly we'll fall behind, decarbonize and position yourself, right, for your customer and seek an advantage in the market. Sounds like it's actually an opportunity

0:28:42
Kok Ping Soon

Yes, very much so Let's turn compliance to competitiveness Right

0:28:47
Claressa Monteiro

You know that it's been a great conversation And I certainly learned a lot more I got clarity Thank you so much gentlemen That's it for today's conversation My thanks to Marcus Lam From PwC Singapore And Kok Ping Soon From Singapore Business Federation For joining us This podcast by PwC Singapore is produced in collaboration with the Business Times. Until next time.