# S1E68: High claims, low margins: How sustainable is Singapore's health insurance?

- **Show:** The Business Times Podcasts
- **Published:** 9 Nov 2026
- **Source:** https://omny.fm/shows/wealthbt/high-claims-low-margins-how-sustainable-is-singapores-health-insurance
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/business-times-podcasts/s1e68-high-claims-low-margins-how-sustainable-is-singapores-health-insurance-8650ba/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

Dr Jeremy Lim argues that Singapore's private health insurance can stay viable only if insurers and policyholders move upstream: catching and preventing disease earlier instead of just paying bills. Ageing and better but costlier medicine will keep claims rising, so savings must come from smarter purchasing, shifting care out of hospitals, and keeping people healthier for longer.

The central tension is short-term cost against long-term payoff. Prevention costs money now and pays back over five to fifteen years, but annually renewable policies let customers leave before insurers benefit. If premiums keep climbing and healthy people drop out, risk pools could shrink and the system could collapse, pushing the burden onto the strained public sector. Lim is optimistic that government will step in firmly.

## Key insights

1. **Insurers have shifted from passive payers to active buyers** Digitised records and analytics now let insurers compare a hospital's costs against thousands of similar paid cases and demand explanations for premium pricing. Lim says they are becoming 'smart payers' who can channel patient volumes to better-value hospitals.
2. **Prevention pays back too slowly for annual policies** Wellness programmes need upfront spending but savings arrive five to ten years later, while premiums renew annually and customers can switch. Insurers therefore doubt they will keep the customers whose health they invest in.
3. **Ageing and better medicine both push costs up** Lim names population ageing and improved treatment, such as much better cancer survival than 25 to 30 years ago, as the two main drivers of double-digit medical inflation. Better outcomes come with bigger bills.
4. **Shrinking risk pools could collapse private insurance** If people drop riders and integrated plans because of high premiums, pools may become too small to share risk. Lim says that would leave the public system carrying the whole load, at taxpayers' expense.
5. **Delaying disease can shift the whole curve** Lim says that with lifestyle changes, diabetes onset predicted in 15 years might be pushed back to 25 to 30 years. He cites international literature that two-thirds of major killers, such as cancer and cardiovascular disease, are preventable.

## Questions this episode answers

### Why are health insurance premiums in Singapore going up so fast?

Jeremy Lim says the two main drivers are an ageing population and medical care that is getting better but costs more. Insurers' loss ratios, meaning the share of premiums paid out as claims, are also worsening.

### What does 'moving upstream' mean in healthcare?

It means acting before people get sick, by assessing future disease risk early and helping them change diet, sleep and lifestyle. Lim says this could delay chronic illness by a decade or more and reduce the need for care.

### Why don't insurers just invest in keeping policyholders healthy?

The payoff comes five to fifteen years later, but medical policies renew every year and customers can switch. An insurer may fund prevention and then lose the healthy customer to a competitor.

### What happens if too many people give up private health insurance?

Lim warns the risk pools could become too small to work, and the system could collapse. Private hospitals would lose funding and the public system would have to absorb everyone, burdening taxpayers.

### Is the Singapore healthcare system sustainable, according to the guest?

Lim is 'perversely optimistic', believing the government will act firmly once the situation is dire enough, helped by Singapore's long political continuity. He adds that the public must accept trade-offs and cannot have the latest of everything.

## Facts

- **Genevieve Cua** [0:00:06]: "Consumables may be three to five times the price charged by a pharmacy. Room rates approach $1 ,000 for a single bed"
- **Genevieve Cua** [0:00:37]: "Recently, I wrote about how employer-sponsored group plans are facing similar challenges, rising chronic disease, aging, and high claims that impact integrated shield plans."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:04:08]: "If we look at say survival from say breast cancer or from lung cancer 25-30 years ago compared to where we are today, it's a sea change of difference."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:04:41]: "And we know that most Singaporeans will die from cancer, cardiovascular disease, or from some neurological disease like a stroke."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:05:20]: "the international literature is very clear, two-thirds of these diseases are preventable with the appropriate diet lifestyle interventions."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:06:18]: "the insurers are moving to be much more interventionist. And in fairness, for the longest time, it was very difficult when records were paper-based"
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:06:48]: "over the last 10 ,000 of such cases that we have paid for, you are consistently in the 85th, 90th centile"
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:06:18]: "Pretty much the healthcare providers decided what was appropriate for how long and in what setting and the insurers paid."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:07:20]: "hospital A you're really good in knee replacements I can channel more of my policyholder volume to you I want a better price"
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:08:08]: "remember that the hospital is also a major purchaser of medical consumables and equipment."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:08:49]: "So what we describe as clinical pathways are getting more and more robust, more and more recognized"
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:12:09]: "for medical premiums, they are annually renewable and both corporates and individuals do have the option, particularly if the individuals are otherwise healthy, to switch."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:13:44]: "And I think Minister Ong has spoken about this."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:14:30]: "And these are already showing in that the majority of the patients in private hospitals are funded through some insurance plan, whether it's individual, whether it is group."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:15:40]: "waiting three months and not knowing whether you have cancer, whether the disease is serious, is certainly not something we will wish on anyone."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:16:08]: "healthcare creates good jobs. It contributes to the economy, whether private sector doctors, nurses, the administrators"
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:16:41]: "there's been only one ruling party since 1959."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:17:12]: "we've had only four prime ministers since 1959. and therefore any prime minister would expect to stay at least a decade, possibly two."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:18:18]: "It's very similar to the private hire vehicle sector. All they want is a level playing field."
- **Jeremy Lim** [0:18:49]: "as what Simon Sinek says, we are playing the infinite game. You may win today, I will win tomorrow, but in the long run, we all play."
- **Genevieve Cua** [0:19:21]: "that healthcare accounts for just 10 % of health outcomes. The bigger factors are behavioral and social with a 60 % share and 30 % genetics."
- **Genevieve Cua** [0:01:18]: "He has founded his own company, Amili, which focuses on services to address gut microbiome in Asia."

## Transcript

**[0:00:00] Speaker 3:** This is WealthBT, a podcast of BT Correspondence.

**[0:00:06] Genevieve Cua:** If you've recently sought treatment at a private hospital, maybe a scan or a short stay, you'll probably brace yourself. A short stay at a private facility could easily cost thousands of dollars. Consumables may be three to five times the price charged by a pharmacy. Room rates approach $1 ,000 for a single bed, and then there are specialist charges, operating theater, and so on. Without health insurance, most of us would never be able to afford private health care.

**[0:00:37] Genevieve Cua:** But insurers themselves are under tremendous pressure. What's the solution to this negative cycle of high claims, high costs, and ever higher premiums? Recently, I wrote about how employer-sponsored group plans are facing similar challenges, rising chronic disease, aging, and high claims that impact integrated shield plans. Welcome to WealthBT, part of the BT Correspondents family of podcasts. I'm your host, Genevieve Cua, Wealth Editor of the Business Times. My guest today is Dr. Jeremy Lim, a leading voice in healthcare.

**[0:01:18] Genevieve Cua:** He has founded his own company, Amili, which focuses on services to address gut microbiome in Asia. Welcome, Jeremy. Thanks for being here.

**[0:01:29] Jeremy Lim:** Thank you very much, Jen. Delighted to be here.

**[0:01:31] Genevieve Cua:** Okay, let's start. Both IPs and group medical plans grapple with ever-rising claims and premiums. That's despite features like co-payments and panel doctors. What do you think is wrong? Are premiums fundamentally underpriced?

**[0:01:48] Jeremy Lim:** And then that is a billion-dollar question. The challenge when we try to match the premiums with the consumption of really healthcare services is really threefold. We first need to figure out how are we delivering the right care to the right patients or really to the right insured members at the right price. The second bucket of issues really revolve around could this care be provided in some alternate setting? And finally, what can we do to prevent these episodes by moving more upstream?

**[0:02:24] Jeremy Lim:** And a lot of the efforts by insurers have been really focused on delivering care at the right price. But I think there's a lot more effort that can be done to move care out of a hospital setting and also to move upstream to prevent individuals from falling sick in the first place. We cannot control the rate of population aging. Singapore is super aged and is going to get worse. But what we can be more proactive about is whether the 65-year-old Singaporean is unhealthy with two or three chronic conditions or is really a very robust, sprightly person still.

**[0:03:04] Jeremy Lim:** So when you say

**[0:03:05] Genevieve Cua:** move upstream, the current framework, as you've said, is like the claim is made when he fall ill. So what exactly does moving upstream mean?

**[0:03:13] Jeremy Lim:** Moving upstream means that insurers need to come in earlier. We as policyholders need to essentially work with insurers from a much earlier stage, understand what our risk for really future disease looks like, and work with the healthcare professionals, work with the payers, in this case the insurers, so that if all things being equal, we would have developed diabetes in say 15 years. If we had then taken proactive steps to manage our lifestyle, change our diets and sleep better and all of these, these 15 years could be pushed back to 25 to 30 years.

**[0:03:49] Jeremy Lim:** And if we did all this sensibly, we could then shift the entire disease curve to the right-hand side and this would then lead to a commensurate decline in the need for so much healthcare utilization.

**[0:04:01] Genevieve Cua:** How do you think the medical expense rate can be tamed? Because all these consultant reports is in double digits, right?

**[0:04:08] Jeremy Lim:** Well, sadly, yes. And that's really because we are aging. That's the first driver that is not going to change. The second driver is that medical care is indeed getting better. So for the same dollar that we spent 15 years ago, we can get a lot more value today. But that has to come at a price that as society, we have to pay. If we look at say survival from say breast cancer or from lung cancer 25-30 years ago compared to where we are today, it's a sea change of difference.

**[0:04:41] Jeremy Lim:** But the bills then become larger. And if we recognize these two factors, we then need to ask ourselves, where else then can we optimize the limited healthcare dollars? And there's the downstream, how can we do the same things much more efficiently? Can we squeeze down cost, collective bargaining and all of these. But can we also move upstream so that we can detect disease earlier? And even more upstream, can we prevent individuals from developing disease? And we know that most Singaporeans will die from cancer, cardiovascular disease, or from some neurological disease like a stroke.

**[0:05:20] Jeremy Lim:** And for all of these, the international literature is very clear, two-thirds of these diseases are preventable with the appropriate diet lifestyle interventions.

**[0:05:30] Genevieve Cua:** I think your point on collective bargaining, that's quite intriguing. And apart from the cancer drug list, which is a kind of a collective arrangement, what can we expect that insurers will actually exert their power?

**[0:05:45] Jeremy Lim:** Well, Jen, I remember many years ago, one of the hospital CEOs relating his conversation with one of the insurance CEOs. And the insurance CEO said, you know, I spend a few $100 million with your hospital every year and I want a better price. The hospital CEO smiles and says, you pay the bills, but you're not the customer because you don't decide which patients go where. And that was how healthcare providers and insurers worked for many years.

**[0:06:18] Jeremy Lim:** Pretty much the healthcare providers decided what was appropriate for how long and in what setting and the insurers paid. But now that, as you rightly pointed out, that the loss ratios are worsening, the insurers are moving to be much more interventionist. And in fairness, for the longest time, it was very difficult when records were paper-based, when insurers did not have the expertise. probably it was not worth the effort to scrutinize every bill and try to ask, is this suitable?

**[0:06:48] Jeremy Lim:** Could there be better pricing for this? But in today's world, healthcare records are fully digitalized and the analytical tools are very much more mature. So we as medical doctors used to be able to say, every patient is different. How dare you question me? Today, the insurer can say over the last 10 ,000 of such cases that we have paid for, you are consistently in the 85th, 90th centile, but over a one-year period as measured by claims, medical leave and so on, your results are not better.

**[0:07:20] Jeremy Lim:** So we need you to explain why you have a price premium. So what's really changed is that the insurers have really gotten their act together and they are now no longer, pardon the term, dumb payers. They've become smart payers and increasingly they want to become smart partners and essentially by working with the hospitals and analyzing their own data will say hospital A you're really good in knee replacements I can channel more of my policyholder volume to you I want a better price but because hospitals provide better outcomes and remember hospitals have very high fixed cost so with assured pretty much guaranteed volumes, the hospitals will be far more willing and able to offer better pricing.

**[0:08:08] Jeremy Lim:** And this cuts across the entire value chain because remember that the hospital is also a major purchaser of medical consumables and equipment. And at the end of the day, we are all patients. We want our care to be the best possible at the best possible price and none of us want complications. I don't know anyone who wants a free bypass surgery if they don't need one.

**[0:08:31] Genevieve Cua:** So let's get into the next question because it's kind of related. Seems to me that there should be greater transparency on facility charges. And not just facility, of course, and consumables are all in there. Like some kind of benchmarking. What are your thoughts on this and how realistic is it to get something like this together?

**[0:08:49] Jeremy Lim:** Well, just 10, 15 years ago, it would have been much more difficult. but today now that we are electronic and the medical community has also developed much more consensus on what care settings, what sort of equipment, what sort of consumables. So what we describe as clinical pathways are getting more and more robust, more and more recognized and so payers as well as patients now have an objective almost like a yardstick or a checklist to ask both the doctors on the healthcare professional side for the professional services as well as the facilities.

**[0:09:27] Jeremy Lim:** Do you have 1, 2, 3, 4, 5? Is this the right price? And as we look at it, if we bought any consumer electronics product, we would also have a checklist, memory, screen size, number of pixels, and all of these. The equivalent does exist in the healthcare world.

**[0:09:43] Genevieve Cua:** So it's just a matter of time or setting the framework that you want on the comparables?

**[0:09:50] Jeremy Lim:** Yes. And then being, I guess, firm and assertive enough as insurers to advocate for the patients so that the patients get the best value and in return, part of the social compact has to be much better managed premium increases. And then the whole system essentially manages. Because what I share with the insurers and with the healthcare providers alike is that we're not competing with each other. At the end of the day, the enemy is death, is premature morbidity, it is disease.

**[0:10:24] Jeremy Lim:** And if we can help individuals to live the best possible lives, then we deserve to

**[0:10:29] Genevieve Cua:** be fairly compensated for that. Still to come, with a high cost of care, risk pooling by insurance is a must. But how sustainable really is the Singapore health insurance market? market focus weekly now hosted by howie lim a sharp weekly deep dive into what's moving markets in singapore and across the region with analysts and market insiders to break down the forces

**[0:10:54] Speaker 3:** shaping the week ahead new episodes every friday powered by the journalism of the business times find market focus weekly wherever you get your podcast and now back to wealth bt a podcast of

**[0:11:05] Genevieve Cua:** BT Correspondence. Welcome back. Jeremy, you've talked and written about the finding that healthcare itself accounts for just a small share of health outcomes. Healthier SG tries to take a preventive approach and many companies have wellness programs. How effective are these and what else can be done

**[0:11:24] Jeremy Lim:** to, as you say, be more proactive? Well, let's look at the effectiveness of these programs. And Honestly, there is no doubt that lifestyle interventions, wellness programs, whatever we want to call them, if they are scientifically based, they are well executed, they make a substantial difference in patients' lives and in overall cost. Study after study has demonstrated this. The challenge then comes in the economics of the short-term versus the long-term. And unfortunately, for many of the lifestyle and disease interventions, there's cost upfront in setting up the program, building up the digital platforms and all these so that we can have a good start.

**[0:12:09] Jeremy Lim:** And then we have to invest in the people, in the technology to achieve these good outcomes. And the savings come from cost avoided five years down the road, 10 years down the road. And the challenge with insurance as we classically utilize it here in Singapore is that for medical premiums, they are annually renewable and both corporates and individuals do have the option, particularly if the individuals are otherwise healthy, to switch. And so the insurer reasonably says, I can do all of this but what will assure me as the insurer that the policy holders will stay with me for 10 years, for 15 years so that the investments that are made up front, I will accrue the benefit.

**[0:12:53] Jeremy Lim:** And this challenge of the short-term versus the long-term is not unique to the health financing. We see this in politics everywhere also, that short-term pain for long-term gain. And that equation can be very challenging. Although switching itself is rather

**[0:13:09] Genevieve Cua:** difficult in the integrated shield market, wouldn't that be so for individuals to just switch?

**[0:13:15] Jeremy Lim:** Yes, and that's both good and bad because if it's hard to switch, then insurers should feel more motivated to invest in the longer term. The corollary to this, which can be a bit ugly, is that the insurer might say, these guys are locked in, so I don't need to do anything special because it's very hard for them to move. And the concern at the end of it is if the customer elects to vote with his or her wallet and just stop playing.

**[0:13:44] Jeremy Lim:** And I think Minister Ong has spoken about this. And Jen, you have written about this, that the concern is that in a market like Singapore, where we're already relatively small, and insurance, as you said, is all about risk pooling, it's all about large numbers. As more and more people look at the premiums and decide that they don't actually want a rider, they don't want an integrated plan taken to its logical conclusion 10 years from now, 20 years from now, the pools may be too small to effectively risk pool, and the entire system just collapses and it's not viable.

**[0:14:18] Jeremy Lim:** And that, I would submit to you, is the poorest outcome for all of us.

**[0:14:22] Genevieve Cua:** And that scenario puts the burden on the public system, which again is rather strained at the

**[0:14:30] Jeremy Lim:** moment. Yes. And Jen, you are right. Without insurance, most of us cannot afford private healthcare. And these are already showing in that the majority of the patients in private hospitals are funded through some insurance plan, whether it's individual, whether it is group. So if we don't have private health insurance, we're unlikely to have a vibrant private hospital system. And without that, the government or the public healthcare system then has to take the entire load, which is a tremendous imposition on the taxpayer.

**[0:15:03] Jeremy Lim:** That's you and me. And even if we had the money? Would we be able to find the warm bodies, the expertise to do all of these? And certainly as Singapore gets more and more super aged, we really don't want to live in a place where every other building is a hospital or a clinic. So we have to do better in this respect and really think of sustainable ecosystem solutions. Actually, in that recent piece I

**[0:15:29] Genevieve Cua:** wrote about group health, one of the consultants actually mentioned encouraging employees to go public instead of private. But again, this brings up this issue of the public system. It's already

**[0:15:40] Jeremy Lim:** like you have to wait very long for a room. No, Jen, the consultant that you referenced is saying absolutely the right thing from a financial point of view. From an individual experience point of view, waiting three months and not knowing whether you have cancer, whether the disease is serious, is certainly not something we will wish on anyone. And from a societal point of view, we really want to reserve the public healthcare system for the average Singaporean.

**[0:16:08] Jeremy Lim:** And those who can afford it should then seek private healthcare because we also shouldn't lose sight of the reality that healthcare creates good jobs. It contributes to the economy, whether private sector doctors, nurses, the administrators, all this creates that very vibrant commercial ecosystem that's good for Singapore.

**[0:16:28] Genevieve Cua:** So how optimistic are you on the entire ecosystem's sustainability? Because it would be untenable for insurance to consistently have very thin or even negative margins.

**[0:16:41] Jeremy Lim:** Well, Jen, I will be politically very incorrect here. I am perversely optimistic that when the situation gets dire enough, the government will be politically motivated and strong enough to do the right things. The challenge, as has been said in many political quarters, has been, we know what are the right things to do. We don't know how to be re-elected after that. And the good thing in the Singapore setup is there's been only one ruling party since 1959.

**[0:17:12] Jeremy Lim:** And what I share with many of my foreign friends is that a lot of Singapore's policy stability is because we've had only four prime ministers since 1959. and therefore any prime minister would expect to stay at least a decade, possibly two. And this then means a strong degree of thinking for the long term, not just in political cycles but what's good for Singapore 10 years from now, 30 years from now. And healthcare will always be about difficult trade-offs.

**[0:17:43] Jeremy Lim:** There is no running away from it and the system is only sustainable if the public understand that compromises will have to be made. We cannot have the best, the latest of everything. And sometimes for the good of the country, for the greater good, we may have to individually settle for slightly less. And as long as Singaporeans and Singapore recognise this reality in the healthcare world, I think we will be sustainable.

**[0:18:10] Genevieve Cua:** I'm just wondering from what you said, what does this mean really? Would it mean more top-down, prescriptive to the insurers?

**[0:18:18] Jeremy Lim:** Well, every insurer will have to be financially driven to a large extent because as commercial entities, they have to think about their shareholders, they have to think about profit. And this then needs to be balanced by governments with a strong policy, a longer term horizon. And frankly, I've spoken to so many of the insurers. It's very similar to the private hire vehicle sector. All they want is a level playing field. If any interventions are unilaterally imposed.

**[0:18:49] Jeremy Lim:** They have to be imposed on the entire industry and the sector just understands the changes and adapts and life goes on because as what Simon Sinek says, we are playing the infinite game. You may win today, I will win tomorrow, but in the long run, we all play. Singapore needs private healthcare, Singapore needs private health insurance and both of them need a strong government that can keep the ecosystem sustainable and their level playing field.

**[0:19:18] Genevieve Cua:** Thank you, Jeremy, for sharing your time.

**[0:19:20] Jeremy Lim:** Thank you very much, Jen.

**[0:19:21] Genevieve Cua:** I recently sat at a health conference where Jeremy was a guest speaker. Something he said struck me, that healthcare accounts for just 10 % of health outcomes. The bigger factors are behavioral and social with a 60 % share and 30 % genetics. The implication for all of us is clear. While we seek to ensure ourselves for events where we need specialist care, we ourselves need to step up efforts to fix the factors we can control, like lifestyle, diet, and yes, even looking into our gut microbiome.

**[0:19:55] Genevieve Cua:** That's it for World BT this week. BT Correspondents will be back next week with an episode on transport. This episode was produced by Rachna Raghu and Nicole Teo, together with our editor, Claressa Monteiro, and was written and presented by me. I'm Genevieve Cua. Thank you for listening.

**[0:20:43] Speaker 3:** and advice.
