In brief
Howard Marks argues that investing success comes from price discipline and risk control, not from owning good assets. Every strategy, including today's booming private credit, moves through a pendulum from unloved to overcrowded. Once a strategy is popular, the bargain is gone and mostly risk remains. Private credit is now fairly priced, not cheap, and lending standards are somewhat lax.
The main tension is between the appeal of private credit and its untested weak spots. Loans that are rarely repriced look calm in a downturn, but that calm may only reflect not looking at the price. Marks says no one knows how these funds behave in a real recession, with delayed payments and funds nearing the end of their lives. Private equity's slowdown shows how rising rates can end a boom.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Howard Marks began his career at Citibank in September 1969, when money center banks were heavily invested in the Nifty Fifty stocks.
“I started work in September of 1969. The bank and the rest of what we called the money center banks were nifty 50 investors”
0:07:52 · Howard Marks · Nifty Fifty · 1969
Howard Marks says that holding the Nifty Fifty stocks for five years from 1969 lost about 95% of an investor's money.
“If you held the stocks for five years from the day I got there, you lost about 95 % of your money in great companies.”
0:08:25 · Howard Marks · Nifty Fifty · 1969
Howard Marks was asked to start Citibank's high yield bond fund in 1978, which he believes was the first such fund from a mainstream financial institution.
“I was asked to start Citibank's high yield bond fund in 1978. And it was the first high yield bond fund from a mainstream financial institution, as far as I know.”
0:09:30 · Howard Marks · High yield bonds · 1978
Howard Marks recalls that the high yield bond market was about $2.5 billion in outstanding bonds when he started in the third quarter of 1978.
“I think when I started, picked it up in third quarter of 78, I think there was $2.5 billion of bonds.”
0:12:38 · Howard Marks · High yield market · 1978
Howard Marks says that in the mid-1980s leveraged buyouts allowed a buyer with $50 million to purchase a billion-dollar company by borrowing about 95% of the price.
“if you had 50 million of capital, you could buy a billion dollar company. You could borrow 95 % of the money.”
0:13:15 · Howard Marks · Leveraged buyouts · 1980s
Howard Marks says a 1991 crisis sank many prominent 1980s leveraged buyouts, including Macy's, Federated and National Gypsum.
“In 1991, we had our first crisis, and many of the prominent LBOs of the 80s went under. Macy's, Federated, National Gypsum, U.S. Gypsum”
0:13:48 · Howard Marks · LBO crisis · 1991
Howard Marks says that after the 1991 crisis buyout financing fell from about 95% of the price to about 75%.
“The other thing is now you couldn't get 95 % financing. You could only get 75 % financing.”
0:14:21 · Howard Marks · Buyout financing · 1990s
Howard Marks says the tech bubble burst in 2001-2002 produced the first three-year decline in the S&P since the Great Depression.
“Then we had the tech bubble burst in 2001 and 2002, first three-year decline in the S &P since the Great Depression.”
0:15:24 · Howard Marks · Tech bubble · 2001
Howard Marks says private equity funds first crossed the $10 billion size mark around 2005 or 2006.
“And around 05 or 06, that's when private equity funds first started. They crossed the $10 billion line, and people were eager to do those.”
0:15:55 · Howard Marks · Private equity · 2005
Howard Marks says Bruce Karsh approached him to partner and start a distressed debt fund.
“I was approached by a guy named Bruce Karsh who wanted to partner with me and started the stress debt fund.”
0:17:27 · Howard Marks · Distressed debt
Howard Marks says he found high yield bonds in 1978 and distressed debt in 1988 as markets to invest in.
“And then I stumbled on markets like high yield bonds in 78 and distressed debt in 88.”
0:48:55 · Howard Marks · Career · 1988
Howard Marks says private credit loans paid about 6%, which funds using leverage could raise to about 9%.
“these loans, interestingly, they only paid about 6%. But with a private fund, the manager can deliver you a leveraged solution and get the return up to about nine.”
0:18:56 · Howard Marks · Private credit returns
Howard Marks wrote a memo in February 2007 titled The Race to the Bottom.
“I wrote a memo in February 2007 called The Race to the Bottom.”
0:21:06 · Howard Marks · Memos · 2007
Howard Marks says the swing of investor sentiment was the subject of his second memo, written in 1991.
“It was the subject of my second memo, which was written in 1991. I called it the pendulum.”
0:18:22 · Howard Marks · Pendulum · 1991
Oaktree Capital Management was founded in 1995 with a written investment philosophy, and its 30th anniversary fell on April 10.
“We have an investment philosophy, which we wrote down when we started. April the 10th will be our 30th anniversary. We started in 95.”
0:22:01 · Howard Marks · Oaktree founding · 1995
Oaktree's six-point investment philosophy includes not relying on macro forecasting or market timing.
“Number five, non-reliance on macro forecasting. And number six, non-reliance on market timing.”
0:22:57 · Howard Marks · Investment philosophy
Howard Marks says pandemic relief spending boosted the economy and brought inflation of about 9.5% at its peak.
“Then we had the COVID pandemic, rescue finance, big distributions of relief money, which goosed the economy and brought on inflation at about 9.5 % at the high.”
0:34:18 · Howard Marks · Inflation · 2022
Howard Marks says private equity accumulated about $2.5 trillion of dry powder, meaning committed capital not yet invested.
“The money gushed into private equity and they got up to 2.5 trillion or so of what we call dry powder, money waiting to get invested.”
0:35:31 · Howard Marks · Private equity
Howard Marks says borrowing for private equity deals cost about 6% in the 2010s and now costs roughly 9-10%.
“In the 20 teens, you could borrow money at 6 % to do private equity deals. Now you have to pay it probably a 9 % to 10%.”
0:36:35 · Howard Marks · Private equity · 2010s
Howard Marks wrote a memo in December 2022 titled The Sea Change about the shift in the interest rate climate.
“I wrote a memo in December 22 called The Sea Change, and it talked about the change in the interest rate climate”
0:41:02 · Howard Marks · Memos · 2022
Howard Marks says Brookfield owns about 70% of Oaktree and partnered with it to add credit to its offerings.
“Brookfield happened to own about 70 % of Oaktree now. But they had an idea that they wanted to round out their product offering, and they didn't have credit.”
0:43:47 · Howard Marks · Brookfield ownership
Howard Marks says Oaktree was semi-public from 2007 to 2012 and publicly traded from 2012 to 2019.
“We were semi-public from 07 to 12 and then public from 12 to 19.”
0:45:43 · Howard Marks · Oaktree public listing · 2007
Howard Marks says he and his colleagues managed about $7 billion when they left TCW, versus over $200 billion at Oaktree today.
“So when we left TCW, my colleagues and I, we were earning $7 billion.”
0:49:20 · Howard Marks · Oaktree founding · 1995