In brief
Rodney Comegys of Vanguard argues that index investing works because it accepts the market's collective pricing rather than second-guessing it. Owning nearly everything, at very low cost and with tight tracking, is the product. He says the S&P 500 is a narrow benchmark, and a real portfolio should add small caps, international stocks, bonds and, selectively, low-cost private assets.
The central tension is between purity and practicality. Comegys says indexing means matching the index, yet his team makes small, risk-controlled choices around trading, taxes, corporate actions and securities lending to add value. Similar tensions run through the rest of the talk: Vanguard's huge ownership stakes against its pledge to stay long-term and non-interventionist, and public markets against growing private ones.
Questions
What does it actually mean to run an index fund at Vanguard?
It means owning the securities in an index and keeping returns as close to it as possible, which Comegys says is how the world judges index funds. His roughly 50-person global team does this daily, investing new cash so the fund matches the index at the 4 p.m. close.
Is the S&P 500 too concentrated in a few big tech companies?
Comegys says seven companies are about 30% of the S&P 500, but the answer is to own more than the S&P 500 rather than to underweight them. Adding small caps, global stocks and bonds reduces the exposure, and deviating from market prices would turn an index fund into an active one.
Can an index fund ever beat its index?
Slightly, Comegys says. Vanguard may buy shares in secondary offerings, choose the better option in a merger, or lend securities to short sellers, and it returns 95% of that lending income to the fund.
Does Vanguard have too much power by owning so much of every company?
Comegys says Vanguard owns about 8% of every free-floating U.S. company on behalf of 50 million Americans. He describes the firm as a long-term owner focused on good governance, not telling companies what business to run, and lets fund investors choose among five voting policies.
How is AI changing index investing at Vanguard?
Comegys says AI helps active managers price stocks better, which benefits index funds. Internally, Vanguard hopes to use it to capture trading and corporate-action knowledge now held by veterans like Mike Perry, and to personalize customer service and advice, though he says it is very early.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Rodney Comegys attended the University of Pennsylvania on a Navy ROTC scholarship that paid his tuition, and studied engineering there.
“a chance to go to Penn with a Navy ROTC scholarship, which paid the Penn tuition and got me to go to a great school where I studied engineering”
0:07:36 · Rodney Comegys · Comegys background
Rodney Comegys served six and a half years in the Navy on a submarine based out of Groton, Connecticut.
“which I turned into six and a half on a submarine out of Grodden, Connecticut”
0:07:36 · Rodney Comegys · Navy service
A Harvard Business School case about Vanguard written by Professor Andre Perold, on which Tim Buckley had worked, introduced Rodney Comegys to the firm; Buckley later became Vanguard's chief investment officer and CEO.
“Andre had written a case about Vanguard, and Tim Buckley had actually worked on it, who became our chief investment officer and eventually our CEO here at Vanguard.”
0:10:32 · Rodney Comegys · Vanguard history
Rodney Comegys says that when he joined, Vanguard's fees averaged about 30 basis points, compared with about 100 basis points for the industry.
“The fees at the time were probably on average 30 basis points. The industry was probably 100 basis points.”
0:11:04 · Rodney Comegys · Fees
Rodney Comegys says that when he joined, Vanguard's business was about 80% active and 20% passive.
“We were still 80 % active at the time, 20 % passive, but you could see what we were doing.”
0:11:04 · Rodney Comegys · Active vs passive
Comegys says his Vanguard team worked for a couple of years to help make a closing auction in India possible, which he says makes trading cheaper and improves price discovery.
“My team, for example, has worked very hard in the last couple of years to make the closing auction in India possible.”
0:12:14 · Rodney Comegys · India market
Rodney Comegys worked with the Center for Research in Security Prices (CRSP) and FTSE to change Vanguard's index products in order to reduce costs.
“I worked specifically with CRISP, the Center for Research and Securities Pricing, and with FTSE to make some changes to our index products to reduce cost.”
0:15:21 · Rodney Comegys · Index providers
Comegys says his global equity indexing portfolio team has about 50 people who invest clients' money each day.
“Every day, my portfolio team, 50 people on a global basis, they're putting people's money to work.”
0:18:10 · Rodney Comegys · Vanguard team
Comegys says Vanguard uses more sophisticated models built on an Axioma risk engine and an optimizer to manage index tracking.
“Then we have more sophisticated models using an axioma risk engine that looks at it in an optimizer.”
0:19:06 · Rodney Comegys · Risk models
Comegys says tracking error for a Vanguard 500 index fund is no more than a couple of basis points and typically less than one.
“Something like a 500 index fund, we're going to see tracking error be no more than a couple basis points, typically less than one.”
0:20:57 · Rodney Comegys · Tracking error
Comegys says Vanguard participates in secondary offerings because it has usually bought shares at a lower price than the price at which they are later added to the index.
“Statistically, we've seen that we can buy it from the bank at the time of offer, and by the time it's added to the index, we've usually bought it at a lower price.”
0:22:24 · Rodney Comegys · Secondary offerings
Comegys says Vanguard's securities lending program returns 95% of its income to the fund and keeps 5% to run the program.
“95 % of the money made in the program goes back to the fund, the 5 % of it is kept to run the program.”
0:23:38 · Rodney Comegys · Securities lending
Vanguard's Investor Choice program lets fund shareholders pick one of five proxy voting policies, according to Comegys.
“For that, we think about returning the vote to them and they can choose one of five policy portfolios.”
0:25:00 · Rodney Comegys · Proxy voting
Comegys says Vanguard has about $8.5 trillion in index fund assets across equity and fixed income.
“We have about $8.5 1 trillion of index fund assets.”
0:29:16 · Rodney Comegys · Assets
Comegys says the Vanguard global equity indexing team that reports to him runs about $5 trillion in assets.
“One is the team that reports to me, the global equity team. We run about $5 1 trillion of assets.”
0:29:16 · Rodney Comegys · Equity indexing
Rodney Comegys says seven companies make up about 30% of the S&P 500.
“30 % of the S &P 500 is made up by seven companies.”
0:00:25 · Rodney Comegys · Index concentration
Comegys says the number of U.S. public companies fell from a peak of about 6,000 to 7,000 around the late 1990s to about 4,000, mostly micro-cap and small-cap firms.
“The shrinking number of companies from a peak in the U.S., 6 ,000, 7 ,000 securities, about the time we graduated business school, down to about 4 ,000 U.S. companies is just a fact.”
0:33:30 · Rodney Comegys · Public companies
Comegys says best-practice indexes add newly public companies about three to five days after their IPO to allow price discovery.
“Our best indexes add those securities in day three or day five. That's the best practice.”
0:34:57 · Rodney Comegys · IPO indexing
Comegys cites Yahoo's IPO as a case where a small float and heavy index buying pushed the price up, which led Vanguard's Gus Sauter and Mike Buek to push for float-adjusted indexes.
“Many years ago, Yahoo came public with a small float. Indexers bought a lot of it and the price went up.”
0:35:24 · Rodney Comegys · Float adjustment
Comegys says Facebook's stock fell below its IPO price after listing and stayed down for nearly a year.
“Facebook broke price, went down, and stayed down for nearly a year.”
0:36:08 · Rodney Comegys · Facebook IPO
Comegys says Vanguard owns on average about 8% of every free-floating U.S. company, on behalf of about 50 million Americans.
“We own on average about 8 % of every company in America that's free floated.”
0:37:03 · Rodney Comegys · Ownership
Comegys says fixed income index funds cannot own every bond in an index, so they rely on sampling and optimization while controlling duration and credit quality.
“At a high level of fixed income indexing, you can't own every security.”
0:37:37 · Rodney Comegys · Bond indexing
Gus Sauter pitched Jack Brennan on Vanguard offering ETFs as an alternative distribution vehicle, and Brennan initially threw him out of the office.
“Gus Sauter came to Jack Brennan and said, we should offer these. Gus pitched it to Jack Brennan and said, this is an alternative distribution vehicle.”
0:39:26 · Rodney Comegys · Vanguard ETFs
Jack Bogle, Vanguard's founder, was highly opposed to exchange-traded funds because he disliked intraday trading, according to Comegys.
“In the early days, Jack Bogle was highly opposed to this.”
0:39:26 · Rodney Comegys · ETFs
Comegys says Vanguard investors hold funds for five to 10 years, whether in ETFs or mutual funds.
“The majority of our investors are long-term holders, whether they're in ETFs or mutual funds, holding periods at Vanguard are five to 10 years.”
0:40:25 · Rodney Comegys · Holding periods
Comegys says the Wellington Fund is Vanguard's oldest fund and the second-oldest mutual fund, a balanced fund run by Wellington.
“Our oldest fund is the Wellington Fund, second oldest mutual fund around.”
0:41:04 · Rodney Comegys · Wellington Fund
Vanguard has a partnership with HarborVest to offer private equity fund-of-funds exposure to some high-net-worth retail investors.
“We do have a partnership with HarborVest for some of our high net worth retail investors.”
0:42:22 · Rodney Comegys · Private equity
Rodney Comegys moved to Australia for three years, where he ran Vanguard's investment team.
“My family and I had a chance to move to Australia for three years where I ran the investment team.”
0:49:59 · Rodney Comegys · Career