OpenNashPodcasts

Conversations with Mike Milken

Ep. 8: Legacy, with former FDA Commissioner Andrew von Eschenbach

8 Apr 2020 · 20m · Andrew von Eschenbach, Mike Milken · 15 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Andrew von Eschenbach argues that decades of investment in cancer and molecular biology have given the world tools to fight COVID-19 quickly. He says the FDA is now the agency that must turn that knowledge into tests and treatments. His proposals are shared real-world data, working in parallel, repurposing existing drugs, adapting cancer immunotherapy, and closer global cooperation.

The episode moves from urgent practical steps to a personal and moral point. Vaccines will take time, so treatments and data sharing matter most in the short run. Von Eschenbach and Mike Milken both lost fathers to cancer. They frame that loss as a 'legacy' that should drive society to be better prepared for the next threat.

Key insights

  1. Treatments matter more than vaccines in the short run

    Milken says wide vaccine distribution is unlikely before the fourth quarter of 2020 or 2021. Von Eschenbach therefore stresses antivirals, antibodies and repurposed drugs to save lives now.

  2. Real-world data can substitute for slow trials

    Von Eschenbach says long randomized trials are too slow for off-the-shelf drugs. He wants electronic medical records, with patient permission, aggregated and analyzed to show which patients benefit.

  3. Cancer immunology can be turned on viruses

    He reasons that a body able to recognize cancer cells can recognize virus-infected cells. He cites FDA-approved trials using natural killer cells, which are abundant in the lung.

  4. Developing products in parallel is worth the cost

    He argues that waiting for each step to finish is too slow. Spending hundreds of millions on a vaccine that may not prove the best would still be worthwhile if it works.

  5. Global data sharing is still below what's needed

    Milken asks about data from countries like South Korea, Italy and Israel. Von Eschenbach says cooperation falls short and cites his 'FDA Beyond Our Borders' offices abroad and real-time electronic exchange as the model.

Questions

Why does Andrew von Eschenbach say the FDA is so important in the pandemic?

He says research knowledge only helps people once it is delivered as tests and therapies. The FDA must make sure those products reach people quickly while also being safe and effective.

What does it mean to use 'real-world data' instead of a clinical trial?

Von Eschenbach means collecting information from how patients are actually treated now, using electronic medical records with their permission. He says this can show when and for whom existing drugs work faster than long randomized trials.

How could cancer research help fight a virus like COVID-19?

Von Eschenbach says cancer research taught us how the immune system recognizes diseased cells. That same ability should work on virus-infected cells, and he cites FDA-approved trials using natural killer cells.

Which existing drugs does he mention, and are they proven to work?

He mentions hydroxychloroquine, used for malaria, rheumatoid arthritis and lupus, and an antibiotic he calls erythromycin. He does not claim they are proven. He says data is needed to learn when, how and for whom they work.

What does the 'legacy' he talks about refer to?

Both he and Mike Milken lost their fathers to cancer. They turned that loss into a lifelong effort to prevent others from suffering the same way, and von Eschenbach hopes the pandemic prompts the same response.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Andrew von Eschenbach, a former FDA commissioner, is a former director of the National Cancer Institute and is president of Samaritan Health Initiatives.

“He is also the former director of the National Cancer Institute and is currently president of Samaritan Health Initiatives.”

0:00:18 · Speaker 3 · Von Eschenbach · 2020

Mike Milken says he and Andrew von Eschenbach have devoted much of the past 50 years to accelerating medical research.

“Andy, you and I have devoted much of the last 50 years of our life to accelerating medical research.”

0:00:46 · Mike Milken · Medical research

Andrew von Eschenbach says modern cell-based methods could cut vaccine production from the normal year to 18 months down to six months or less.

“not take the normal year to 18 months, but to cut that immediately down to six months or less.”

0:05:23 · Andrew von Eschenbach · Vaccine production · 2020

Andrew von Eschenbach says monoclonal antibodies could be developed from antibodies made by people who have recovered from the coronavirus.

“develop monoclonal antibodies by finding people who have conquered the virus, have already made an antibody within their own system to destroy or fight off that virus.”

0:06:27 · Andrew von Eschenbach · Monoclonal antibodies · 2020

Andrew von Eschenbach says the FDA approved clinical trials using the body's immune system, including natural killer cells, against the coronavirus.

“FDA has approved clinical trials to use our own body's immune system, including using natural killer cells that are already in our body.”

0:08:11 · Andrew von Eschenbach · Immunotherapy · 2020

Andrew von Eschenbach says hydroxychloroquine was already used for malaria, rheumatoid arthritis and lupus before it was used against COVID-19.

“hydroxychloroquine, which was used for malaria and rheumatoid arthritis and lupus”

0:08:45 · Andrew von Eschenbach · Hydroxychloroquine · 2020

Andrew von Eschenbach says real-world patient data must be acquired, aggregated and analyzed to learn how off-the-shelf drugs work against COVID-19.

“we'll have to capitalize on the opportunity to acquire, aggregate, and analyze real-world data”

0:10:09 · Andrew von Eschenbach · Real-world data · 2020

Andrew von Eschenbach says existing electronic medical record systems should be used, with patient permission, to capture COVID-19 treatment data.

“We need to capitalize on the healthcare systems that are already in place based on an electronic medical record, recruit and utilize them with patient's permission to be able to get access to that data.”

0:11:03 · Andrew von Eschenbach · Medical records · 2020

Andrew von Eschenbach says spending hundreds of millions on a vaccine candidate that proves not to be the best would still be a worthwhile investment.

“It may very well be that we'll develop a vaccine and spend a considerable amount of money, hundreds of millions perhaps, and it may not be the absolute best vaccine in the long run.”

0:11:40 · Andrew von Eschenbach · Vaccine investment · 2020

Andrew von Eschenbach says that while he led the FDA, much production of drug ingredients, excipients and gelatin capsules took place outside the United States.

“the production of, for example, active pharmaceutical ingredients and excipients, even the gelatin that you find your medicines encapsulated in, and many other things were occurring and being developed outside the United States.”

0:13:54 · Andrew von Eschenbach · Global supply chain

Under Andrew von Eschenbach, the FDA created its 'Beyond Our Borders' program and placed personnel and offices in China, India, Europe, Central America and later the Middle East.

“we created FDA Beyond Our Borders and actually put FDA personnel and offices in China, in India, in Europe, in Central America, and eventually in the Middle East.”

0:14:35 · Andrew von Eschenbach · FDA Beyond Our Borders

Andrew von Eschenbach says Mike Milken advocated for dramatic funding increases at the National Cancer Institute and the National Institutes of Health.

“You not only advocated for dramatic increases in funding at the National Cancer Institute and the NIH”

0:07:02 · Andrew von Eschenbach · Research funding

Andrew von Eschenbach says Mike Milken pushed the academic and scientific community to collaborate and break down silos, helping create an era of molecular medicine.

“And what you did was force us to collaborate and cooperate, to break down silos.”

0:07:02 · Andrew von Eschenbach · Research collaboration · 1990s

Mike Milken says his father was dying of melanoma during the 1970s, when Milken was having enormous professional success.

“In the 1970s, I had enormous success, but I could never share my success with my father because he was dying of melanoma.”

0:16:08 · Mike Milken · Milken's father · 1970s

Mike Milken recalls an event on the steps of the U.S. Capitol honoring doctors and scientists who made dramatic changes in cancer research, where von Eschenbach spoke of his late father.

“as we stood on the steps of the Capitol, honoring the doctors, scientists that had made dramatic changes in cancer and cancer research”

0:16:40 · Mike Milken · Capitol event

Chapters

  1. 0:01:22Applying decades of biomedical progress to COVID-19

    Von Eschenbach says investment in molecular biology lets scientists dissect the virus and find targets quickly.

    “bring together the incredible wealth of knowledge and understanding we now have”
  2. 0:03:25Why the FDA is the central agency

    He argues that knowledge only helps if tests and therapies reach people, which makes the FDA's role critical.

    “the most central and critical of all the federal agencies”
  3. 0:05:23Vaccine timelines versus immediate treatments

    Vaccines are the long-term plan, but antivirals, antibodies and repurposed drugs are what can help now.

    “cut that immediately down to six months or less”
  4. 0:08:11Cancer immunology applied to viruses

    Advances in understanding the immune system in cancer could translate to fighting virus-infected cells.

    “if our bodies can recognize a cancer cell, they can recognize a cell that's been infected by a virus”
  5. 0:09:35Real-world data and parallel development

    Von Eschenbach calls for aggregating patient data and building products while evidence is still emerging.

    “benefit from the experience that's happening right now in the real world”
  6. 0:14:35Global cooperation and FDA Beyond Our Borders

    He describes how the FDA placed offices abroad and says real-time data sharing is still lacking.

    “So we created FDA Beyond Our Borders”
  7. 0:18:15Fathers, loss and building a legacy

    Both men connect their fathers' deaths from cancer to their commitment to preventing future suffering.

    “take that wound and recognized that it was also a legacy”

Transcript

0:00:00
Speaker 3

Now from the Milken Institute, responding to COVID-19, conversations with Mike Milken.

0:00:06
Andrew von Eschenbach

If we think of the game changers of what is going to get America and the rest of the world back functioning normally, FDA is probably right now the most essential and critical of all the federal agencies.

0:00:18
Speaker 3

That's Dr. Andrew von Eschenbach. As former commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration, he knows firsthand how vital that agency can be. He is also the former director of the National Cancer Institute and is currently president of Samaritan Health Initiatives. He spoke recently with Chairman Mike Milken. Andy, thank you for joining us today.

0:00:41
Andrew von Eschenbach

Mike, it's always both productive and certainly a great pleasure to join you and be with you.

0:00:46
Mike Milken

Andy, you and I have devoted much of the last 50 years of our life to accelerating medical research. We've worked as a team for decades, but never has it been more important to find a solution in a short period of time. You have served our country as the head of the National Cancer Institute, as the head of the FDA. If you were running those two organizations today, and we're told we only had 60 days to get these under control, what would you be doing?

0:01:22
Andrew von Eschenbach

Michael, you and I have both witnessed this disease as well as cancer, not just taking individual lives, but destroying lives, destroying the lives of others who are around and watching people suffering and dying. So if I was back at the National Institutes of Health at NCI or at the Food and Drug Administration, first and foremost, bring together the incredible wealth of knowledge and understanding we now have of these basic fundamental biological processes, the genetic, molecular and cellular mechanisms that drive diseases like cancer and particularly are responsible for why this virus, this coronavirus, is creating so much disruption and destruction of lives.

0:02:11

So we now have made that investment over a period of decades, an investment that you have been principally responsible for driving and creating. And what that investment has enabled us to do is to now have new knowledge and new tools where we can rapidly understand this virus, understand the fact that we can dissect its genetic makeup and we can immediately identify targets for things like antibodies. We can figure out how this virus is invading and multiplying in cells.

0:02:46

And so we can begin to imagine what antivirals we can create or what medicines we even have on the shelf that we can repurpose, like hydroxychloroquine and the antibiotic is erythromycin. But from the point of view of capitalizing on all of that knowledge and understanding and focusing it on this immediate pandemic from the research and National Institutes of Health perspective, we need to move over to the Food and Drug Administration because from the perspective of the American people, all that knowledge has to be delivered and disseminated to them in the form of a solution to this problem.

0:03:25

And the FDA is probably right now the most central and critical of all the federal agencies. If we think of the game changers of what is going to solve this problem for us and save lives and restore our economy and get the America and the rest of the world back up to functioning normally, those game changers are going to involve for people the availability of diagnostic testing and for patients who are infected and sick. We need a therapy.

0:03:56

We have to be able to deliver those. And that requires the FDA to assure the American people an efficient and rapid access to those products, but that they are also effective and safe. So from the perspective of NIH, NCI, and our former life of driving progress,

0:04:18
Mike Milken

it's time to capitalize on that progress. So Andy, they are moving very quickly in vaccines. We know the first vaccine went into a human being in the middle of March. And even the accelerated rate that Johnson & Johnson and the more than 50 others that are trying to bring a vaccine, we probably aren't going to have wide distribution at best to the fourth quarter of this year or 2021, which will be the fastest they've ever come.

0:04:49

What is going to work in the short run? And when you talk about the FDA, we need to know what exists that has actually gone into humans that might work. Can we take these antibodies and put them into humans and protect them, our healthcare workers, or even the people at a grocery store who never thought of themselves as frontline in a war, in this war of disease? Once again, let's take you to the FDA. You're the commissioner.

0:05:18

you've called everyone in, and what are you telling them today?

0:05:23
Andrew von Eschenbach

Michael, you're absolutely correct. We need to work across the entire agency. We need a long-term and a short-term strategy. From the long-term perspective, as you pointed out, we need to continue to drive the development of a vaccine. We need to capitalize on modern technologies, such as cell-based methodologies, for being able to rapidly produce these vaccines and not take the normal year to 18 months, but to cut that immediately down to six months or less.

0:05:54

To your point, that vaccine is for the future to protect us going forward. But right now, to save lives and to restore our lives, to be able to come back as a society, we need treatments, we need therapies. So we need to look across that portfolio of therapies from what do we need to discover and develop right now? And what do we already have that we can repurpose or utilize in a different way? We know that there's opportunities to develop antivirals.

0:06:27

We know that there are opportunities to develop new things that we have not previously done, such as being able to develop monoclonal antibodies by finding people who have conquered the virus, have already made an antibody within their own system to destroy or fight off that virus. And we take that and we, one, can give it to other people, or we can break it down and figure out rapidly how to recreate it at scale. And then we can explore some of the progress that's been made in other areas.

0:07:02

This is particularly true and interesting from the perspective of the incredible investment and the new way of doing business with regard to cancer research. You were a critically important part of that. You not only advocated for dramatic increases in funding at the National Cancer Institute and the NIH, but I remember you almost 30 years ago telling me that the academic and scientific community needed to do business in a different way. And what you did was force us to collaborate and cooperate, to break down silos.

0:07:39

What did that get us? What it got us was a transformation by working in cancer research to create this new era of molecular medicine. Now we can take that progress in cancer and transfer it to this pandemic. How could we do that? One of the things we've learned, one of the more recent advances in cancer research has been our understanding of the immune system, how a body, our bodies can recognize and fight off a cancer cell.

0:08:11

And if our bodies can recognize a cancer cell, they can recognize a cell that's been infected by a virus. So there's work being done as we speak in developing innovative ways. And FDA has approved clinical trials to use our own body's immune system, including using natural killer cells that are already in our body. And it particularly happened to be abundant in our lung. We need to also look not only at what research and development is making immediately available to us and accelerate that, we also look at what we've already have on the shelf.

0:08:45

And it turns out that people quickly recognized that by looking at the epidemiology of this virus, seemingly there were people who were taking certain medications for malaria or rheumatoid arthritis, perhaps were better protected against the virus. That resulted in the opportunity to use off-the-shelf medications already approved by the Food and Drug Administration and able to be prescribed by physicians. So what we've seen is an explosion of utilization of hydroxychloroquine, which was used for malaria and rheumatoid arthritis and lupus, and an antibiotic, it's erythromycin, the Z-Pak that everybody's familiar with when you get an upper respiratory tract infection or bronchitis.

0:09:35

Where we find now the opportunity, we also have a challenge. There's the opportunity that's readily available. But what we need is data. We need to understand when and how and for whom those off-the-shelf drugs are working. It's not the kind of answer that we can get from taking the time and trouble to do complicated, long-term, prospective, randomized, controlled trials. What we have to do is benefit from the experience that's happening right now in the real world.

0:10:09

And so we'll have to capitalize on the opportunity to acquire, aggregate, and analyze real-world data and understand how and why and for whom these drugs are working, and then make that the immediate part of our attack to save lives, to restore the quality of life, and in fact, restore and salvage

0:10:37
Mike Milken

our economy. With the number of patients, there's no difficulty of accruing patients to clinical trials, which in many cases was a long, arduous process of delay. But what we're seeing today is the ability to quickly accrue patients for these clinical trials. Should we gear up a large volume that could be used if it works? If you were at the FDA, what would you be saying?

0:11:03
Andrew von Eschenbach

Well, let me take that in two parts, if you don't mind. The first, I think, is really critical. Patients are willing to provide their data, but we need a sophisticated way to capture that data. We need to capitalize on the healthcare systems that are already in place based on an electronic medical record, recruit and utilize them with patient's permission to be able to get access to that data. We need to have that data flow. We need a way of being able to connect all those various sources of data so that it can be aggregated and then shared.

0:11:40

And then beyond that, we need sophisticated data analytics. To your other point, as we're doing that, as we are seeing that there are clues, indications that this particular intervention may be quite effective or quite useful, we need to parallel process. We can't wait for this to be sequential. When the earliest indications are sufficient that this is a solution to this problem, we need to start in parallel processing the development of that product. It may very well be that we'll develop a vaccine and spend a considerable amount of money, hundreds of millions perhaps, and it may not be the absolute best vaccine in the long run.

0:12:24

But that's okay. That would be an investment well worthwhile making, because if it did work, then the multiple of that investment is almost exponential. You're the economist. You have to help me understand the ROI. But I believe, to your point, we should first create the opportunity to acquire, aggregate, and analyze the data. Look immediately for clues as to what looks like it will be the more likely, effective, and safe therapy, and immediately in parallel start to produce that so at the end of the day we can deliver to the American people on the promise.

0:13:05
Mike Milken

So Andy, I know you were one of the key proponents for it, both at the NCI and at the FDA, is not just US-based data, but international-based data. And are we doing enough today to take the information out of South Korea, China, Singapore, Israel, Italy, Spain? If you were at the FDA, there's a lot to be learned from what these countries experienced, how the patients reacted. Is international cooperation at a level that I know you try to move faster during your days at both the National Cancer Institute and the FDA?

0:13:47

Is it today at a level that we're sharing data on an international basis? It's not at the level, Michael, that it

0:13:54
Andrew von Eschenbach

needs to be or it should be, but we have made important progress in that regard. As you pointed out when I was at FDA, I recognized that we were living in a global economy where the production of, for example, active pharmaceutical ingredients and excipients, even the gelatin that you find your medicines encapsulated in, and many other things were occurring and being developed outside the United States. It was no longer made in the USA. In many cases, it was assembled in the USA with components, whether it be for drugs or devices, coming from a global marketplace.

0:14:35

It was apparent that we could not serve the American people by simply sitting here, waiting for all that to arrive on our shores and then be able to make regulatory decisions. So we created FDA Beyond Our Borders and actually put FDA personnel and offices in China, in India, in Europe, in Central America, and eventually in the Middle East. To the point that you're making, we need to be engaged globally, and we need to be there globally.

0:15:07

We need better ways of communicating globally. And I think there are areas in which that's worked quite well. Cancer, I think, is one of them. And there are clearly areas where we need to improve and do better. We're living in a digital world. You and I are having this conversation essentially using digital technology. That has to become part and parcel of our communications as well. We should be electronically transferring data and information in real time, not waiting for a conference, not waiting for a meeting scheduled six months or a year from now where we all come together.

0:15:47

This has to be a way of being able to conduct our mission in real time by recognizing it is now a partnership. This virus is teaching us things. It's teaching us things scientifically and medically, but I think it's also teaching us things from a cultural societal point of view.

0:16:08
Mike Milken

Andy, this virus in many ways has brought the world together. Understanding what happens in one country vastly affects another. For me and for you, it's also brought us back to another point in our lives. In the 1970s, I had enormous success, but I could never share my success with my father because he was dying of melanoma. No matter how many cancer centers I visited or what I did, I could not accelerate science to save my father's life.

0:16:40

And it has forever changed my life and my commitment to science. For you, Andy, as we stood on the steps of the Capitol, honoring the doctors, scientists that had made dramatic changes in cancer and cancer research, I remember you telling me how you wish your father could be there that day, but he had died of cancer, and you, a young doctor, scientist, could not save your father's life. Today, to me, every day is a month, and And therefore, we have this available to us and all of our skills and others, not just you and I, but thousands of others are required to turn this solution into a couple months, not years.

0:17:26

Is there any message that you would like to give to America in trying to get through these difficult times?

0:17:33
Andrew von Eschenbach

You and I have both been wounded by that loss, that loss of someone who at one point held us in their arms and nurtured us and cared for us. And that wound changed up. There are thousands and perhaps millions of lives right now who are being wounded by this experience. either they're dying of the virus or they're watching someone else. They're caring for or caring about dying. They're being wounded by watching their lives torn apart. They're being wounded by not knowing what tomorrow is going to bring.

0:18:15

What you and I did was to take that wound and recognized that it was also a legacy, that we had to, from that experience, learn from it and use it and use it so that we would not allow someone else to be wounded in that way, that we would go about finding a way to eliminate the suffering and death due to cancer. We need to move beyond this wounding of ourselves and of our society to create a legacy.

0:18:50

to make sure that this does not happen again, because the threats will happen again, whether it's another virus or whether it's just the continuing evolution of disease, be it cancer or Alzheimer's or any of the other things that are wounding us. We need to learn from this. We need to be better from this. We need to do more from this. And we need to do it efficiently and effectively for everyone. That's the legacy that your dad gave you.

0:19:26

That's the legacy my father gave me. That's why you and I are on this call today, years later. And there will be others perhaps listening to this call who will have to do what you and I are doing tomorrow.

0:19:40
Mike Milken

Andy, I want to thank you for joining us. I want to thank you for your service to our country. and we look forward to you helping to accelerate in the next 30 to 60 days a solution, a short-term solution and then someday a long-term solution.

0:19:59
Andrew von Eschenbach

Well, Michael, the good Lord has blessed me far more than I ever deserved in my life and I must always tell you and the world that you, Michael Milton, have been one of those very, very special blessings in my life. God bless you and thank you for all that you have done.

0:20:16
Speaker 3

Coming soon on Conversations with Mike Milken. Mike speaks with former chief medical officer of Pfizer and longtime Faster Cures board member, Freda Lewis-Hall, and former Google CEO, Eric Schmidt. Find those upcoming episodes along with the latest COVID-19 updates at milkeninstitute.org slash podcast. Until next time, stay safe and healthy.