In brief
This episode argues that the public story of Maura Murray, a UMass nursing student who vanished after a car crash in New Hampshire in February 2004, is tangled up with rumor. Ashley Flowers draws on her sister Julie Murray's new podcast, Media Pressure, to separate documented facts from online lore. She says the evidence points to police errors and unanswered questions, not to any one proven explanation.
The central tension is between the police theory and what the family found. Police said Maura was drunk, upset and walked into the woods to die. The family found a trail of oddities: no footprints, a car that still started, conflicting witness accounts and unexplained police vehicle sightings. Flowers asks whether this was negligence or something worse, and cautions against theories that accuse real people without evidence.
Questions
What happened to Maura Murray?
Maura Murray, a 21-year-old UMass nursing student, crashed her car on Route 112 in Haverhill, New Hampshire, on February 9, 2004, and was never found. She was last seen by a bus driver, and a search turned up no trace of her.
Why did police think she left on her own?
Police, especially Chief Jeff Williams, pointed to alcohol in her car, a printed email about cheating, lies to professors about a family death, and a recent car accident. They concluded she was drunk, crashed and walked off to hurt herself.
Why does the family doubt the police theory?
Fred Murray and Julie Murray say the email was two years old and she hadn't been packing up. Dogs and searchers found no trail in deep snow, and Fred noted the car started right up.
What is Media Pressure and why does it matter here?
Media Pressure is a nine-episode podcast hosted by Sarah Turney in which Julie Murray tells her sister's story. Ashley Flowers used an advance copy as source material and says it is far more detailed than her one episode.
Is there any proof of what happened to Maura?
No. The episode lists leads, including cadaver-dog alerts at a house, luminol-positive blood in a closet and a 2010 pond search, but none has been confirmed. Flowers says these lead nowhere definite and warns against accusing anyone without evidence.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Haverhill police were called on February 9, 2004, to a 1996 black Saturn that had crashed and been abandoned beside Route 112 in Haverhill, New Hampshire.
“his department had been called to the scene off the side of Route 112 in Haverhill, New Hampshire, where a 1996 black Saturn had seemingly hit a tree and then just been abandoned near the woods.”
0:04:14 · Ashley Flowers · Crash scene · 2004
The Saturn was registered to Fred Murray, who had given the car to his youngest daughter, Maura Murray.
“even though the car is registered to her ex-husband, Fred, she knows that Fred had given the car to their youngest daughter, Maura.”
0:05:07 · Ashley Flowers · Car ownership · 2004
A mechanic attributed the Saturn's loud noise and black smoke to a blown cylinder gasket.
“According to a mechanic, that's because the cylinder had blown a gasket.”
0:06:31 · Ashley Flowers · Car condition · 2004
Police told Fred Murray they found an open malt beverage, a damaged box of wine and a Bailey's nip in Maura Murray's car.
“An open sky blue malt beverage, an opened or damaged box of wine, and a Bailey's nip.”
0:11:21 · Ashley Flowers · Alcohol evidence · 2004
Police dogs were given a pair of gloves from Maura Murray's car as a scent sample, though the gloves were a recent Christmas gift and may never have been worn.
“It turns out they used a pair of gloves from her car, but those gloves had just been given to her that Christmas.”
0:15:06 · Ashley Flowers · Tracking dogs · 2004
Butch Atwood was driving a school bus home after dropping off students who had gone skiing when he stopped at Maura Murray's crashed car.
“he was on his way home in a school bus after dropping off students who'd gone skiing that day.”
0:26:09 · Ashley Flowers · Witness account · 2004
Maura Murray attended the United States Military Academy at West Point, where her sister Julie also attended college, before transferring to UMass.
“It's what had pushed her to go to the United States Military Academy, West Point, where Julie attended college.”
0:33:19 · Ashley Flowers · Education
Police inventoried 109 items from Maura Murray's car, including snacks, toiletries, clothes and textbooks.
“There were 109 items total from the car. Some snacks, like Twizzlers and pickles, some random toiletries, some clothes, textbooks.”
0:43:57 · Ashley Flowers · Car contents · 2004
Fred Murray says he told Maura that if she had to drive the Saturn, she could put a rag in the tailpipe to hide its smoke, which explains the rag found in the tailpipe.
“he told her if there was an emergency and you absolutely have to drive it and you're somewhere that you might get stopped by police, you can put a rag in the tailpipe to hide the billowing smoke”
0:46:01 · Ashley Flowers · Tailpipe rag · 2004
Sergeant Cecil Smith completed his accident report on Sunday, February 15, 2004.
“Sergeant Cecil Smith finally completed his accident report. This happened on Sunday, February 15th.”
0:46:30 · Ashley Flowers · Accident report · 2004
After a Vermont teenager disappeared in March 2004, police briefly considered a serial-killer link and compared her case with Maura Murray's before ruling out a connection.
“For a moment, police considered the idea of a serial killer and compared the cases.”
0:49:31 · Ashley Flowers · Related case · 2004
John Smith, a former law enforcement officer, says state police detectives threatened to arrest him for interfering if he kept offering to help the Murray family.
“they told him to stop trying to help, stay out of it, or he'd be arrested for interfering with an investigation.”
0:53:57 · Ashley Flowers · Police conduct
Police say the whimpering voicemail Bill Rauch received was traced to a Red Cross calling card.
“Now, that whimpering voicemail that Bill received that he thought was Maura was eventually traced, police say. They attribute it to a Red Cross calling card.”
1:01:49 · Ashley Flowers · Voicemail · 2004
Witness Karen McNamara says Maura Murray's car was nose to nose with a police SUV when she passed it, before first responders officially arrived.
“when Karen passes Maura's car, she says it was nose to nose with a police SUV.”
1:03:41 · Ashley Flowers · Police SUV · 2004
Haverhill Police Chief Jeff Williams eventually left his post after being arrested for drunk driving by Sergeant Cecil Smith.
“he eventually ends up leaving his post after he's finally arrested for drunk driving. By Cecil Smith, by the way.”
1:06:26 · Ashley Flowers · Police chief
The black box in Maura Murray's Saturn recorded two events, a non-deployment and a deployment, within 0.02 seconds at low speed.
“Maura's shows the accident recorded two events within two one hundredths of a second while she traveled at a low speed.”
1:08:08 · Ashley Flowers · Car black box · 2004
Julie Murray tracked down a person whose name and number were found in Maura's car, and whose family owns a condo about 25 miles from the crash site.
“it turns out that this family owns a condo just 25 miles from where Maura crashed in the direction she was going.”
1:11:09 · Ashley Flowers · Unexplored lead · 2023
French Pond was searched in 2010 in an effort led by Massachusetts attorney Terry O'Connell, who has helped the Murray family.
“In 2010, that pond was searched. The search was headed up by the Massachusetts attorney, Terry O 'Connell, who has helped the Murray family over the years.”
1:12:58 · Ashley Flowers · Pond search · 2010
In 2019, cadaver dogs alerted at a nearby home and ground-penetrating radar detected something, though police said they found only pottery.
“Cadaver dogs were brought out there in 2019 and alerted. Ground-penetrating radar even picked something up.”
1:14:49 · Ashley Flowers · Basement search · 2019
Human remains were found on Loon Mountain in 2021, but they were not Maura Murray's.
“In 2021, remains were discovered on Loon Mountain. For years and years, there has been a rumor about the, quote, Loon Mountain 3,”
1:15:17 · Ashley Flowers · Remains found · 2021
Testing by a later homeowner found human blood, a mixture of male and female, in a closet searched after cadaver dogs alerted, but it was too degraded to link to anyone.
“Further testing that was done showed that it was human blood in there, a mixture of male and female.”
1:16:40 · Ashley Flowers · Blood evidence