Questions
Would the atomic bomb have been built even without World War II?
Rhodes thinks it was essentially inevitable once fission was found in 1938 and physicists calculated the energy release. He says it would probably have come more slowly, because fear of a German bomb drove the wartime rush.
Why do people say the first atomic bombs were really firebombs?
Rhodes says their job was to start mass fires, like the incendiary raids that had already burned out every major Japanese city over 50,000 people. He says the lab designed the burst height so the fireball would not touch the ground and spread fallout.
Did Soviet spies let Russia build the bomb much faster?
Rhodes says probably not by much. Soviet physicists had their own better design by 1947, but Beria insisted on copying the proven American bomb. He says the hard part is getting the nuclear material, which Russia could do itself.
Why is Rhodes worried about Russia's nuclear approach in Ukraine?
He says Pakistan's 1999 conflict with India introduced the idea of fighting a conventional war while holding nukes as a backstop, and he says Putin now uses it. He calls it terrifying because it risks escalating too fast.
How does Rhodes compare the Manhattan Project to AI?
He agrees AI will likely be at least as transformative as nuclear weapons and energy, and says it frightens many people. He also warns that calls for 'a Manhattan Project' for other problems are misleading, since that effort was mostly engineering on settled science and was run as a secret government project.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Rhodes says nuclear fission was discovered in Berlin in 1938, about nine months before World War II began in Europe.
“Nuclear fission had been discovered in Nazi Germany, in Berlin in 1938, nine months before the beginning of the Second World War in Europe.”
0:06:35 · Richard Rhodes · Fission discovery · 1938
Rhodes says a chain reaction that doubles each generation reaches a city-destroying explosion in about 80 generations.
“So in about 80 generations, for most of our bombs today, I'm sure, the initial fission leads to, in 80 generations, to a city-busting explosion.”
0:09:18 · Richard Rhodes · Chain reaction
Two émigré physicists in England estimated a uranium-235 bomb needed about one pound, though Rhodes says the real figure is about 125 pounds.
“And they did the numbers, and they came up with one pound, which was startling to them. Of course, it is more than that. It's about 125 pounds, but that's just a softball.”
0:11:09 · Richard Rhodes · Critical mass · 1940
Joseph Rotblat left the Manhattan Project in May 1945 after Germany's defeat, and General Leslie Groves was upset and threatened to have him arrested.
“In May of 1945, he packed up and left. General Groves, the imperious Army Corps of Engineers general who ran the entire Manhattan Project, was really upset.”
0:16:44 · Richard Rhodes · Manhattan Project · 1945
The largest hydrogen bomb ever tested, by the Soviet Union, had a yield of 56 megatons of TNT equivalent.
“the biggest one ever tested was 56 million tons of TNT equivalent, 56 megatons. The Soviets tested that.”
0:29:43 · Richard Rhodes · Hydrogen bomb
Rhodes says Hiroshima and Nagasaki were spared conventional bombing because General Groves wanted to study the atomic bomb's effects there.
“The only reason Hiroshima and Nagasaki were around to be atomic bombed is because they'd been set aside from the target list.”
0:32:51 · Richard Rhodes · Target selection · 1945
Rhodes says Edward Teller calculated that a 1,000-megaton hydrogen bomb was possible, with a fireball about 10 miles across.
“He came up with a thousand megatons. And then he looked at the effects. 1 ,000 megatons would be a fireball 10 miles in diameter.”
0:37:30 · Richard Rhodes · Hydrogen bomb
Rhodes says the U.S. Air Force commanded 47 percent of the federal defense budget by the mid-1950s.
“So by the mid-1950s, the Air Force commanded 47 % of the federal defense budget.”
0:41:01 · Richard Rhodes · Defense budget · 1950s
Rhodes says the Soviet Union had 75,000 nuclear weapons at the height of the Cold War.
“So by the height of the Cold War, they had 75 ,000 nuclear weapons, which would have been,”
0:48:05 · Richard Rhodes · Soviet arsenal · Cold War
Rhodes says Soviet physicists told him they had a 1947 design with half the weight and twice the yield of the Fat Man bomb.
“So by 1947, they had a design for a bomb that they said was half the weight and twice the yield of the Fat Man bomb.”
0:51:02 · Richard Rhodes · Soviet bomb design · 1947
Rhodes says Lavrenti Beria ordered Soviet scientists to copy the American plutonium implosion bomb, threatening them if they did not.
“And Beria said, comrade, I want the American bomb. Give me the American bomber. You and all your families will be camp dust.”
0:52:50 · Richard Rhodes · Soviet program · 1940s
Rhodes says natural nuclear reactors in Gabon ran for about 100,000 years before shutting down.
“And they ran for about 100 ,000 years and then shut themselves down. because they had accumulated enough fusion products that the U-235 had been used up.”
1:03:03 · Richard Rhodes · Natural reactors · 2 billion years ago
Rhodes says the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty was signed around 1968 and took effect in 1970.
“the Nuclear Nonproliferation Treaty, which was, I think, 1968. and it took effect in 1970.”
1:18:44 · Richard Rhodes · Nonproliferation · 1970
Rhodes says South Africa built six gun-type uranium bombs in the late 1980s.
“South Africa, which did build a few bombs in the late 1980s. Six World War II type gun bombs fueled with enriched uranium”
1:19:59 · Richard Rhodes · South Africa bombs · 1980s
Rhodes quotes John F. Kennedy as saying he feared 10 nuclear-armed countries by 1970 and 30 by 1980.
“I lose sleep at night over the real prospect of there being 10 countries with nuclear weapons by 1970 and 30 by 1980.”
1:19:59 · Richard Rhodes · Proliferation fears · 1960s
Rhodes says a 1999 border conflict between India and Pakistan led Pakistan to argue nuclear weapons let it fight conventional wars without escalation.
“But then in 1999, there was a border conflict between the two countries. And Pakistan came up with a whole new argument about nuclear deterrence.”
1:28:16 · Richard Rhodes · India-Pakistan · 1999
The Soviet Union tested its first atomic bomb in August 1949.
“That worked until August 1949 when the Soviets tested their first atomic bomb.”
1:31:51 · Richard Rhodes · Soviet bomb test · 1949
Rhodes says Oppenheimer and a graduate student published a paper in 1929 on what was essentially the physics of a black hole.
“They published a paper on what was essentially the physics of a black hole in 1929.”
1:39:40 · Richard Rhodes · Black holes · 1929
Rhodes says the average age at Los Alamos was 27, while Oppenheimer was 39.
“The average age at Los Alamos was 27. Oppenheimer was an old guy. He was 39.”
2:00:30 · Richard Rhodes · Los Alamos · 1940s
Rhodes says Stalin moved the Soviet invasion of Manchuria up to August 8, 1945, between the two atomic bombings.
“Stalin, having heard that the bombs really worked, moved up the date of the Soviet invasion of Manchuria to the 8th of August between Hiroshima and Nagasaki and invaded early.”
2:07:53 · Richard Rhodes · Soviet invasion · 1945
Rhodes says the Soviet Union proposed a global smallpox eradication program to the UN in the 1960s, run by the World Health Organization under D.A. Henderson.
“Back in the 60s, I think, the Russians proposed a world-scale program of public health to eradicate smallpox to the UN.”
2:13:31 · Richard Rhodes · Smallpox eradication · 1960s
Rhodes says Boy Scouts collected 500,000 tons of milkweed fluff during World War II to line life vests.
“They collected 500 ,000 tons of milkweed fluff in the course of the war.”
2:25:25 · Richard Rhodes · Wartime collection · 1940s
Rhodes says nuclear winter simulations of an India-Pakistan war found up to 2 billion people could die of starvation over several years.
“But then over the course of the next several years, up to 2 billion people would die of starvation because you would have the same phenomenon”
2:34:17 · Richard Rhodes · Nuclear winter