In brief
Terence Tao argues that AI has made generating scientific ideas almost free, but science depends on checking those ideas, and checking is the bottleneck. Kepler's story shows that verifying a correct idea can take decades, and a correct theory can look worse than the old one for a long time. Judging which ideas matter relies on judgment, persuasion and the test of time, which are hard to turn into a training signal.
The central tension is breadth versus depth. AI tools can try every standard technique on many problems at once and clear the easy ones, but success rates on any single problem are about 1-2%, and they do not build up progress step by step. Tao expects human-AI teams to dominate for a long time, and he wants science redesigned to use AI's breadth.
Questions
Why does Terence Tao say AI won't automatically speed up science?
Tao says AI makes ideas cheap, but each idea still has to be checked, and checking is slow and hard to automate. Kepler's laws took decades to be explained, and the correct theories sometimes looked worse than the old ones.
How well has AI actually done on the Erdős math problems?
About 50 of roughly 1,100 problems were solved with AI help, mostly ones that had little earlier literature. Tao says that in systematic tests an AI succeeds on a given problem only about 1-2% of the time, and that pure AI solutions have stopped appearing.
Is AI making Terence Tao twice as productive?
He says it is hard to measure that way. Papers he would now write would take about five times longer without AI, but only because of extras like code, plots and literature searches, while the hardest core reasoning is unchanged.
What is Lean and why does it matter for AI in math?
Lean is a formal proof language that checks every step of a proof, so a computer can verify it. Tao says this makes deductive proofs easy to automate and to train AI on, and lets people study each step of a giant AI-made proof on its own.
What career advice does Tao give to people entering math?
He says to expect a lot of change and to stay adaptable, and to keep following curiosity. He thinks traditional education is still worth getting for now, and that AI tools and Lean may let even high schoolers contribute to research.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Johannes Kepler proposed that the five Platonic solids could be nested between the spheres of the six known planets, matching their orbit sizes.
“there were six planets, none of the time, five gaps between them, and there were five perfect platonic solids, the cube, the tetrahedron, isochedron, octahedron, and dodecaedron.”
0:01:25 · Terence Tao · Kepler's model
Tycho Brahe persuaded the Danish government to fund an expensive observatory where he recorded decades of planetary observations.
“Tycho Brahe, this Danish astronomer, very wealthy, eccentric astronomer, had managed to convince the Danish government to fund this extremely expensive observatory.”
0:01:53 · Terence Tao · Astronomy data
Tycho Brahe was the last major astronomer to make his observations with the naked eye.
“With the naked eye, actually, he was the last of the naked eye astronomers.”
0:02:22 · Terence Tao · Astronomy data
Tycho Brahe's data did not match Kepler's Platonic-solid theory, which disappointed Kepler.
“he worked out to kind of his disappointment that his beautiful theory didn't quite work like the data was sort of off from his platonic solid theory”
0:02:22 · Terence Tao · Kepler's model
Kepler found that planetary orbits are ellipses rather than circles, which he found shocking.
“he eventually worked out that the ellipses were actually ellipses, not circles, which was shocking for him.”
0:02:58 · Terence Tao · Planetary motion
Kepler gave no explanation for his three laws, and Isaac Newton supplied a theory explaining all three about a century later.
“it took Newton a century later to give a theory that explained all three laws at once.”
0:03:33 · Terence Tao · Planetary motion
Kepler's third law was fitted to only about six data points, one for each known planet's orbital period and distance from the sun.
“Kepler had like six data points um like every planet uh you knew the length of the orbit and the distance of the sun”
0:09:35 · Terence Tao · Kepler's third law
The distance of Uranus, discovered by William Herschel, fit the geometric pattern proposed by Johann Bode.
“when Uranus was discovered by Herschel, the distance Uranus fit exactly this pattern.”
0:10:49 · Terence Tao · Bode's law
Neptune's discovery showed that Bode's distance pattern did not hold, so it was a numerical fluke.
“But then Neptune was discovered and it was completely like way off.”
0:11:19 · Terence Tao · Bode's law
Dwarkesh Patel says Kepler developed his polygon and Platonic-solid theories in 1595 and 1596, and that they were wrong.
“1595 and 96 is where he comes up with first polygons and then platonic objects theory, but they were wrong.”
0:08:48 · Dwarkesh Patel · Kepler's model · 1595
Aristarchus proposed heliocentrism in the third century BC, and critics objected that the stars should show parallax.
“Aristarchus had heliocentrism in the third century BC and then the ancient Athenians were like, this can't be because if the earth is going around the sun, we should see the relative position of the stars change”
0:17:35 · Dwarkesh Patel · Heliocentrism · 3rd century BC
Darwin's On the Origin of Species appeared in 1859, about two centuries after Newton's Principia in 1687.
“The Origin of Species is published in 1859. The Principia Mathematica is published in 1687.”
0:21:35 · Dwarkesh Patel · Scientific history · 1859
Tao says Newton wrote in Latin and invented new mathematics, and that his work spread widely only after other scientists explained it more simply a couple of decades later.
“Newton wrote in Latin. he had invented you know entire new areas of mathematics just to explain what he was doing”
0:23:42 · Terence Tao · Scientific communication
Tao says almost all of the roughly 50 Erdős problems solved by AI had little or no prior literature.
“Erdős posed the problem once or twice. I think maybe some people tried it casually and they couldn't do it, but they never wrote up anything.”
0:43:31 · Terence Tao · Erdős problems
Tao says systematic studies show AI tools succeed on any given hard math problem only about 1-2% of the time.
“any given problem, an AI tool has a success rate of maybe 1 % or 2%.”
0:44:34 · Terence Tao · AI success rate · 2026
Jane Street trained a ResNet, shuffled its 96 layers, and challenged people to restore the order using only the model's outputs and training data.
“Jane Street trained a ResNet and then shuffled all 96 layers and then challenged people to put them back in the right order”
0:27:34 · Dwarkesh Patel · Jane Street puzzle
Tao says the four-color theorem was proved essentially by brute-force computer checking, and no conceptually elegant proof has been found.
“A full-color theorem is a famous example. We have still not found a conceptually elegant proof of this theorem.”
0:53:38 · Terence Tao · Four color theorem
Carl Friedrich Gauss computed the first 100,000 or so primes, creating one of the first mathematical data sets.
“Gauss was interested in the prime numbers, and he computed, he created one of the first mathematical data sets.”
1:03:19 · Terence Tao · Prime numbers
Gauss conjectured the prime number theorem, that the number of primes up to x is roughly x divided by the natural logarithm of x.
“The number of primes up to x is like x divided by the natural log of x.”
1:03:57 · Terence Tao · Prime number theorem
The twin prime conjecture, that infinitely many pairs of primes differ by two, remains unproved, though the random model of primes makes mathematicians confident it is true.
“there's a still open conjecture in number theory called the twin prime conjecture, that there should be infinitely many pairs of primes that are twins”
1:05:28 · Terence Tao · Twin primes
Tao says that if the Riemann hypothesis were false it would seriously undermine the random model of the primes and could threaten cryptography based on them.
“if the real hypothesis failed um we knew it was false it means that it would be a serious blow to this model.”
1:06:37 · Terence Tao · Riemann hypothesis
Tao says the standard axioms of mathematics, known as ZFC, and of first-order logic were formalized only in the early 20th century.
“only in like the early 20th century did we finally list our, here are the axioms of mathematics, well, the standard axioms of what we call ZFC”
0:59:34 · Terence Tao · Mathematical logic · early 20th century
Tao notes that sequencing one organism's genome once took an entire PhD, but now costs about $1,000 and can be sent to a sequencer.
“So in genetics, to sequence the genome of a single organism, that was an entire PhD of a geneticist.”
1:18:52 · Terence Tao · Genetics
Terence Tao spent a year at the Institute for Advanced Study and said he ran out of inspiration after several months there.
“I spent a year once at the Institute for Advanced Study, which is a great place to, you know, there's no distractions.”
1:15:46 · Terence Tao · Tao's career