S2E7: Chow Kiat Lim, GIC Going Long ยท 19 Apr 2021 Source: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/going-long-fcltglobal/episodes/S2E7-Chow-Kiat-Lim--GIC-eup58t Transcript: https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/going-long/s2e7-chow-kiat-lim-gic-f4ef42/ (via OpenNash Podcasts, machine-generated) I'm Sarah Williamson, and this is Going Long with FCLT Global. On this show, you'll learn what it means to be long-term from the top minds in global business and investing. Leaders from companies and investment organizations join us to discuss how they are leading their teams for the long run on issues including capital allocation, risk management, climate change, and sustainability. To learn more, visit our website at fcltglobal.org. Our guest today is Chow Kiat Lim, the CEO of GIC, Singapore's sovereign wealth fund. He's been GIC's CEO since 2017 and was the group chief investment officer since 2013. Chow Kiat is also an active supporter and member of the board of directors of FCLT Global and has been involved in the beginning for which we are very grateful. So welcome Chow Kiat, thank you for joining us today. Thank you, Sarah. It's great to be here. Great. So for our listeners around the world who are less familiar with GIC, could you discuss the organization's origins and its purpose? Just tell people a little bit about who you are and why you do the work you do. Right, thank you. Let me actually start by just putting some words on FCLT. I've been involved with FCLT Global's effort for quite some years now. The mission really resonates with what I think is the right way of wiring the capital markets. It certainly resonates with GIC's way of doing things, focusing on the long term. And I really enjoyed working with and learning from many of my esteemed peers and colleagues. So it has been a great privilege and opportunity to do this. Now on to GIC. GIC was set up in 1981 by the Singapore government. So in fact, this year is our 40th year. We are celebrating our 40th anniversary this year. It's quite a milestone. It was set up 40 years ago as our Sovereign Wealth Fund, even though back then nobody really would sort of look at a fund of this nature as a Sovereign Wealth Fund. That term only came about 12, 13 years ago. The objective was very clear, which was to build a long-term value out of our reserves. That's something our founding fathers, Lee Kuan Yew and Dr. Goh King-Sui, recognized that GIC should be set up to do that job. One way to think about GIC is that we serve three sort of functions. One, we are a rainy day fund, for any contingencies where financial resources are needed by the country. GIC plays a role in that. We are also a stability fund with the reserves which we manage. It helps to make sure that the Singapore financial system operates well. And the third is as an endowment fund. about 15, 16 years ago, we amended our constitution to allow the government to draw down part of the returns from the reserves, which are managed by GIC and our sister organizations, Tamasic and MAS in Singapore, as part of the government spending. So GIC invests globally outside of Singapore in a diversified way across different asset classes for 40 years now. I think one of the things for those of us who spent a little time in Singapore that's so inspirational is the long term objectives that both Lee Kuan Yew and the founders of Singapore, but also the founders of GIC had, which is it is interesting in your 40th year to think that 40 years ago with a fairly small amount of money and a fairly young country that there was the foresight to set this up. So how do you continue to have that long-term look forward as you, you know, as you, and that, and that sort of big aspiration of, of being such a significant participant in the global capital markets? Right. Sarah, as you noted, right, that we have this way of doing things. It, it sort of came from the history, right? partly as you said, when GIC was set up, that was already the thinking that we would like to invest the money over a long period of time to generate long-term return. I would also say long-termism is a bit of a national ethos that I think the people here like to kind of think about, when we embark on an effort that take a long-term mindset, make it sustainable. And really the nature of these funds which we manage ultimately, of course, are for the benefits of Singaporean. And that means to think about it as an intergenerational fund. Often we would hear that pension funds are very long term in nature because the money is needed for retirement needs of people. In the case of GIC, the funds are in a way of even longer nature because it goes beyond even the current generation. so that I guess define how we think about time horizon so that's you know how I guess every day we we try to abide by it. And could you give us some examples of how that comes into to play either in terms of how you manage the organization or how you manage investing where you've perhaps been willing to make an investment in something that you knew wasn't going to pay off very soon, but that would pay off over a number of years? Right. Yeah, maybe a few comments on this. One is basically how does long-term kind of mindset gets into our investing approach or our strategy? I think it's important to emphasize that to do this well, you need the kind of whole ecosystem to function consistently. And that requires quite a few things, right? The starting point for any investor would be our investment philosophy. In the case of GIC, our philosophy is one that focuses on fundamental value of assets. So we do a lot of work to try and determine what is the fundamental value of an asset that we come across. And also we try to add value to that assets once we have acquired it. So that is very much the philosophy, which of course is consistent with having a long-term mindset. The second thing is really very importantly, the governance. Because we want to make sure that our work is, our objective is aligned with our stakeholders. So in the case of GIC, the governance, thankfully our clients and our board of directors of the same mindset, right? That when they look at the policies of GIC, when they look at the results of GIC, when they look at the activities of GIC, they wear the long-term hat. They look through the lens of long-term. So governance is important. The third will be, of course, the mandate itself, right? There is clarity of this emphasis on long-term outcome. Our primary performance measure, for example, is a rolling 20-year rear rate of return measure. I think in the marketplace, you actually don't see a lot of that kind of performance measure. So in GIC's case, of course, we measure across different time horizon, but the 20-year rolling return is what gets the most attention from the management, from our staff, from our stakeholders. So mandate clarity is the third thing that is important. The fourth is, of course, organizational practices. Some people would call this culture. So you have to do a lot of work. You have to align incentive, for example, you have to align your recruitment policies or your HR practices should be aligned to that idea that we want people to sort of make decisions with the long-term mindset. And finally, communication. We have to take care in how we talk about our activities, our results, our strategies. Just as an example, I think in financial markets, sometimes we hear comments like long term is but a series of short term. That is something we do not agree with. And that's something we would not say in GIC because the drivers of long-term outcome and the drivers of short-term outcomes are very different. So we take quite a lot of care in how we communicate internally and externally. We take a lot of care, for example, when we show performance of our portfolios. even if we have multiple time period, we put particular emphasis on the longer term horizon ones, right? We might put them on the same page, but we might start with the 20 year or the 10 year rather than the, you know, last quarter or last six months. So little things like that actually are important because there's always this temptation and this pressure to want to go short. So we have to be consciously designing and practicing long-term in how we run the company. So with all these five things, I would say then the portfolio or the investment strategy almost quite naturally would look at drivers or value, which is long-term in nature. And we find, in fact, that does give us quite a bit of advantage. Having a long-term mindset translate to quite a few positive things. First, of course, is you can take advantage of compounding. For us, or for I think a lot of long-term investors, one of the success formulas is really to look for quality assets which compound over a long period of time. That doesn't require you to constantly be buying and selling to try and create return. Of course, it's not easy to find these assets, but if you have this mindset, you're more able to get to a kind of a smaller universe of that. So compounding is an advantage. The second, of course, is it allows you to harvest risk premium. So as a long-term investor, we are able, for example, to allocate some part of our funds to illiquid assets, which tend to give you a little bit of extra. And because you have the time horizon, you can harvest that. And that also is, of course, partly because not every investor can do that. So if you're lucky to have that time horizon, make use of it. And the third way is you can do what we call counter cyclical rebalancing. Rebalancing, of course, is quite a standard kind of asset allocation practice. But really, only long-term investor can do that well. So that over time also gives you a little bit of extra return. Maybe the fourth way is from time to time, you get dislocations, either because investors are forced to buy or forced to sell because they have short-term pressures or short-term requirements. Then long-term investors actually are in the position, you might say, to take advantage of those dislocations. And finally, we find having a long-term mindset is really helpful for building partnership. Because I mean, to really build a good partnership, it takes time. It takes, frankly, sometimes give and take. And you can only do these over a long period of time. So in GIC's case, for example, we have had we have some relationships which go back a long way, you know, like 30, 30, 30 odd years. You know, many of our actually business partners are very successful, very big, very, you know, sort of really successful today. But when we started with them, they were very small. We were very small as well, but we grew together. And after 30 years, even longer, I think we got really solid relationship with many of them because we really have gone through the ups and downs. And time really can help in building relationship. And GIC depends a lot on our partners. So again, having these, actually we have many really good relationships, quite a helpful thing for GIC. So that's how we have kind of looked at having a longer horizon has helped GIC to progress over a long period of time. and certainly we have a lot of conviction that it is a winning formula and that it will still continue to give us many of these benefits going forward. I think it's definitely a winning formula and listening to you talk about it, I think the other thing that's so interesting is how all the pieces fit together. I find sometimes people try to do one of the things that you mentioned. They try to have long-term investments, but they don't have long-term governance. or something like that. And then, of course, it can't last. So I think that one of the lessons that we can all learn from GIC is the importance of integrating all of those pieces that you discussed and aligning them against the long term rather than just trying to do one or the other on its own. Right, right. I mean, having that whole ecosystem, right, as I said, is really key. and for each of these I would say you do have to exercise quite a bit of thinking as an example when you look at performance how do you how do you tell right if the short-term performance is either good or not good how do you tell you're on the right track it requires you to really understand the process. So we emphasize a lot of the quality of process of decision making, because that gives us, I guess, more confidence that the short term results, I guess, good or bad, will eventually pan out as good long term result. you have to kind of exercise your mind when you look at short-term result to think about whether it is consistent with that investment process, right? Whether it is reasonable, right? So what we strive for is at least reasonable short-term result, but certainly superior long-term result, right? So you have to, for each of these areas, actually you have to exercise quite a bit of thinking and in fact that is where I find the learning from my peers you know at in organizations like FCLT being really helpful because as we try to extend our horizon we will encounter similar challenges and it is really good you know then to have all of us kind of compare notes and and come up with you know practical right solutions which is another thing that I think we like to emphasize at FCLT. Yes, and we try to be very practical and to your point, knowing whether your short-term results are aligned with the right long-term path sounds easy, but it's not always easy for an investor or a company. So, and sometimes that's where we see the conflict. Right. So, you've talked about a way that you work with partners and your own team and so on. Can you talk a little bit about how you engage with companies that you own, investing companies, you set up front, you look for fundamental value and then try to add value over time. How do you think of the role of GIC as an owner of a company and in terms of your engagement? Right. So I guess we start with who we are, who we are, long-term investor, long-term owners of our assets. Now, we own many assets. So to be sure, we have to prioritize our engagement effort. But certainly, our mindset is we like to own them for a long period of time. And in fact, as you noted, we like to add value even during our ownership period, if we can. And I guess the adjective to describe our engagement would be constructive, right? That we like to engage with the company. If we see that there are opportunities, you know, for them to do better, we will tell them. So our teams would meet with our investees regularly. Of course, if our, I guess our ownership stake is bigger, we will meet them more often. Or if we have maybe, you know, special kind of expertise in certain area that we think we can be more helpful, we will meet them more often. We give them suggestions on, you know, on how to move forward. we listen to them, we try to understand their strategy. So it is that kind of relationship. And because we also invest through outside managers, so as part of the engagement, sometimes we would also work with other managers to try and understand the issues which different companies face. But objective really is to help them to be as successful as possible. That makes sense. And bringing your expertise where you have that as well as your influence can be really helpful. I think we've at FCLT thought a lot about the levers of being long-term and you've already mentioned most of them, governance, incentives, engagement. so that's one of the levers that can be very important Right I mean we have some initiatives which you might say directly add to the company's business for example we have what we call a bridge forum which we hold every year where we bring together what people might call incumbent companies, companies which have been around and successful for many years to meet with the startups and the venture capital which we invest in. So we try to create opportunities for companies to come together, to in a way share our network. And even so far, for example, that effort has been a few years, we've brought together more than 450 companies. And those are kind of, you know, I guess, value add that we try to give to the companies and the partners which we invest with. So that's, you're both adding value directly, but also encouraging them to add value to each other through your network, which is... Right, right. Because it's a challenging world out there, right? Whether it's for investors or businesses. In the age of disruption, everyone has to kind of stay on top of, keep up with new ideas, new technology, new trends. since we already have this network we make it available for our partners and investees to benefit from and obviously we benefit from that too learning through the process new understanding of trends and in some cases maybe even investing opportunities So we see that as something that is really worthwhile and definitely constructive. So we talk about our mission as being rebalancing capital markets to support a long-term sustainable economy. And we've talked a lot about long-term here. How is GIC approaching sustainability in your strategy and in your investing? How are you adding that into your calculus these days? I think long term and sustainability have a huge overlap. In fact, they are almost interchangeable. What is long term is sustainable. And what is sustainable will last for a long time. So because of that, we find sustainability actually quite a natural match in terms of GIC's mandate. How we have translated it into our operations is to use a very simple kind of framework, which internally we call it ODE. Ode stands for offense, D stands for defense, and E stands for organizational excellence. So let me take just a few minutes to explain. Offense is simply finding opportunities. Maybe in the area of sustainability, people will think about it as impact investing. That you do well and do good at the same time, and you hope to create some really good outcome in sort of along the ESG dimension. So we have a few efforts going on in that area. Defense, of course, is to make sure that our portfolio holdings are not facing difficulties in terms of ESG requirement. So we actively, as much as possible, help our investee companies to go through the transition. We are quite a big believer of transition, recognizing that in quite a few cases, you cannot quite sort of turn from brown to green, for example, overnight. You, of course, have to put in concerted effort, but it might take a little bit of time to make that change. As an example, actually two months ago, GIC invested about $2 billion in a utility company in the US, Dew Energy Indiana, in fact. And what we found was that in that particular state, the regulators actually facilitate the transition from, say, a coal power plant into a renewable. type of infrastructure. So our capital actually goes towards a transition effort like that. So that would be a form of, I might say, I guess in that case, a mix of defensive and offensive move. So in the defensive side, we work with, I guess, to the earlier question about engagement. We work with our investee companies to make sure that they are not on the wrong side of sustainability. And then the last one is organizational excellence. As we manage our portfolio and engage with investees and external managers, we also have to make sure our own operations are up to scratch. So whether it is our procurement, whether it is our carbon footprint, whether it is our recycling effort internally, we try to make sure we live up to a good standard. And we are on the way of carbon neutrality by the end of this fiscal year. So that's an effort that we also make, which resonate with all our people. So these three areas, offense, defense, and organizational excellence, is kind of a simple way for us to move forward on this important issue of sustainability. And as I mentioned, because we have a long-term mandate, we have long-term governance, we have long-term mindset, it makes it easier. Because some of these sustainability efforts might take time to see results. So thankfully, in our case, our stakeholders, for example, have the patience. In fact, they would want to make sure that we are on that path, such that we can not just do well, but, you know, do good in the process. It's a great way to keep that all in mind, the offensive defense and organizational excellence. That's very memorable. So you talked about resilience. Clearly, that has been tested in the last year with everything that's happened, obviously, with the COVID-19 pandemic. Maybe, hopefully, we're turning our attention forward. Can you talk a little bit about, as you look forward, what kind of long-term opportunities that you see coming out of this dislocation that we've had in this very, very difficult year? We've had over the last year, it was just over a year ago, that we had hoped to be together at a conference, which you had to not come to at the last minute. and then from there everything sort of went awry. But as we look forward coming out of this time, what signs are you looking for? Right, yeah, it is a crisis, right, and it's big, right, it's pandemic, it's global indeed and has lasted already more than a year. It's been tough on many people. We are not yet out of the woods, but I guess with the vaccination, there is light at the end of the tunnel. And hopefully, I guess, people can come out safe and in many cases, to rebuild the economy, the businesses, and can move forward. As investors, I guess we looked at this as, of course, a huge disruption. It changed, I think, many business models. There are some, you might say, obvious trends. For example, digitalization just got accelerated in a big way. many people basically have been forced right on online to do things and that obviously was very helpful to those businesses or business models which write on digitalization for certain businesses it's so important right in fact for most businesses it's so important to go online right so I think have seen quite a lot of that and that itself produces opportunities. It creates new categories of services and goods that a post-pandemic world will most likely continue with. So the whole kind of work from home trend is a big one right. Of course we are not 100 % sure you know post-pandemic where we settle in terms of work from home practices, travels and things like that. But we are quite clear that digitalization will continue. So that's one kind of big tech trend. Another area of course is healthcare. I think pandemic was a bit of a wake-up call to many countries of the need to invest in healthcare. And in fact, the intersection of tech and healthcare has also seen innovation and new business model. So that looks quite promising in terms of potential investment opportunities. Sustainability, I think we talked a little bit just now. Again, I think the pandemic is a bit of a joke on the importance of that. There's importance of being prepared, being early to be on that path and not be too late. When disaster has already struck, it's pretty hard to try and cope with it or recover from it. So hopefully we all have learned some lessons from that. So sustainability in the last one, two years, one year in particular, I think have seen a really big step forward, but a lot more needs to be done and need to happen. Again, technology may do some of that. I don't think itself can solve all the problems, but even when you looked at an area like infrastructure, which is a big area, which is quite carbon intensive, you are seeing new technology being developed, hardware and software in the area of, let's say, energy, which I must say look quite promising. So I think investor businesses, countries need to pay attention to that. I will highlight maybe just two other things. China is an interesting case. They managed the pandemic well, came out of it, produce growth, right, when most other countries couldn't really do that last year. They also have embarked on a green economy plan. They have also got a policy or effort to develop the domestic economy, right, their so-called dual circulation. They have been quite restrained in their use of stimulus, which I think give them in a way more fiscal flexibility down the road. So we have quite a few significant developments in that country. So for investors or businesses, I think that's an important area to watch as well. And finally, in talking about China, of course, we have also seen, I guess, development in the geopolitical space. We expect more intense competition among the great powers. We believe that given the transition to a multipolar world, that competition is a given. Of course, we hope that it will be healthy, it can produce actually many positive things. and the interdependency among the great powers. And the need for collective efforts to solve big problems like climate change can sort of help to make sure that the competition is a healthy one. But as investor, of course, we have to think about the risks that things can turn somewhat ugly. as this competition across many different fields is taking place. Because the nature of geopolitical competition is quite risky, because you need trust. and that is not easy to build. And sometimes the actions of a particular power, might be defensive action, can be viewed as offensive. So you can get a lot of misunderstanding as well. So we hope all the leaders in charge are able to make sure that they have good channels, the understanding mechanism to de-escalate if there is a problem. So that whole geopolitical area also demands attention from all businesses and all investors. It's something that I think is going to be with us for a long time. So, especially for a long-term investor, I think we have to get used to this competition and in our own processes, at least build up some understanding of how things are likely to evolve and have an ability to look through the lens of geopolitical competition when we view or when we look at developments in the market. place or in the economies. So that is also an important development, maybe not quite as an area of opportunity, but certainly an important trend that one cannot afford not to be, you know, kind of monitoring. Well, as we look at risks and opportunities, I think you've given us both sides there, which is some very important risks and maybe some opportunities as well. And with the hopefully silver lining of COVID making the world understand that we are interdependent and whether we like it or not when it comes to pandemics or climate or anything else, it's pretty hard to mull oneself off and be separated from the rest of the world. So Singapore, of course, has always played such an important role in trying to encourage discussion around some of the global competitive issues. So that's important. Right. I mean, we I guess we have also I mean, just speaking for GIC, we have the mindset of, you know, wanting to expand the pie. that as a long-term investor, our long-term fortune really depends on the pie growing. It's not so much which you get a bigger slice of that. That might be helpful in the short term, but really in the long term, it is if we can help, I mean, say, FCLT's effort in rebalancing the capital markets, or efforts like I think we have worked together on helping to make fund management mandates a longer term in nature. I mean, those are concrete ways we can help to expand the pines. And if we can do that, actually, I mean, certainly GIC will benefit and the whole system will be better off. So I think it's critical, actually, the work that FCLT is doing to get us to a place that is more sustainable. Well, obviously, we really appreciate that and your involvement and your GIC's involvement in support of FCLT since the very beginning. And this idea of expanding the pie is so important. And to your point, over the long term, that is one of the critical things that we could do. There's no winners on a losing team, as you say. So I think that that is part of the idea of rebalancing these capital markets so that savers and communities benefit and asset owners, asset managers and companies work together. Right. I think fairly early on, I mean, in FCLT, we recognize that it takes the whole value chain. Right. So thankfully, I mean, over the last few years, we have been able to get many, you know, esteemed organizations in the whole value chain involved in this effort. So I'm definitely very hopeful and optimistic that, you know, we can move the needle. Well, thank you for your words of wisdom, for your time today. You've given us an awful lot to think about. I think that GIC is often the model for other organizations, but like people say about Roger Federer, a great athlete, you can watch him swing the tennis racket like that, but it's pretty hard to do. So we appreciate watching you play like you do and trying to trying to aspire to build organizations that can do some of what you do. So thank you very much for your time and your insight today. Thank you, Sarah. Thanks for the opportunity to have this conversation. Thanks for listening to today's episode of Going Long with FCLT Global. Be sure to hit subscribe to get new episodes every other Monday. To learn more, visit our website at fcltglobal.org.