OpenNashPodcasts

Goldman Sachs Exchanges

General Catalyst CEO Hemant Taneja on mission-driven investing, health assurance, and AI’s transformation advantage

6 Oct 2023 · 42m · Hemant Taneja, Michael Brandmeier · 24 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Hemant Taneja, CEO of General Catalyst, argues that the best venture returns come from backing companies built to last, and that lasting companies are the ones that create positive change in society. He says this means thinking in decades, building governance in from the start, and treating technology as a pillar of healthcare, education and finance. He rejects 'move fast and break things' as a societal principle.

The central tension is time. Venture funds run about ten years, yet Taneja says healthcare and climate are 30-to-50-year problems. He says General Catalyst responded by creating companies itself, offering growth financing that avoids dilution, and partnering with health systems. He also frames AI as a tool that helps large incumbents transform, not one that replaces them, and sees a geopolitical race over whose AI model prevails.

Key insights

  1. Enduring companies drive venture returns

    Taneja says venture returns follow a power law, where a few outlier companies produce most of the gains. If those companies keep growing, the investment keeps compounding, so the firm's mission is built around companies that last.

  2. Venture's ten-year funds cannot fix healthcare

    Taneja says ten-year funds applied to 30-to-50-year problems like healthcare and climate do not work. He says General Catalyst had to 'transcend the venture capital model' and take a longer-term view, partly because earlier short-term wins left the mission unfulfilled.

  3. Livongo's sale showed the limits of exits

    Livongo reached about an $18 billion valuation roughly six or seven years after launch, but served only half a million of 35-37 million people with diabetes and other chronic conditions. Taneja says this shows a quick exit can cap impact, which pushed the firm toward partnering with health systems.

  4. AI's edge is transformation, not distribution

    Taneja contrasts the app-store era, when new companies won on access to consumers, with AI, which he says helps transform how things are done. He expects the next 15 years to give small-company capabilities to big companies, so most value lands in partnerships with incumbents.

  5. Responsible innovation is an input, not ESG

    Taneja argues ESG (environmental, social and governance scoring) tweaks the outputs of existing companies. For companies built from scratch he wants governance designed in from the start, to anticipate harmful unintended consequences and keep stakeholders beyond shareholders in view.

Questions

What does General Catalyst mean by a mission-based approach to investing?

Taneja says the mission is to invest in 'positive, powerful change that endures.' The reasoning is that companies which last keep compounding returns, and the most effective way to build lasting companies is to focus on those that do good.

Why does Hemant Taneja say 'move fast and break things' is a bad idea for society?

He says it is an engineering design principle that people wrongly treated as a societal one, which contributed to problems like social media misinformation and could worsen with AI. He wants companies to plan for harmful consequences and build governance to reduce them.

What is the customer value fund General Catalyst offers founders?

Taneja describes it as a way to fund growth based on the return a company earns on its customer acquisition spending, giving capital against those return thresholds instead of selling more equity. He says it helped companies that needed capital while valuations were inflated and the markets were weak.

How does Taneja think AI will change business over the next decade?

He says AI is a 'transformation advantage' rather than a way to reach consumers, so its value will mostly come from helping big companies transform in partnership with technology firms. He names healthcare, legal, media, drug discovery, financial services and customer support as areas to change.

What is 'health assurance' and why does Taneja want it?

It is his idea for a healthcare system that is proactive instead of reactive, affordable and accessible. He says healthcare costs approaching 20% of GDP are unsustainable and that inner-city and rural America lack a viable system.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

General Catalyst was started in 1999 by co-founders David and Joel, who were Hemant Taneja's longtime partners.

“So David and Joel were my partners of long time and co-founders of the firm. They started the firm in 99.”

0:01:52 · Hemant Taneja · Firm founding · 1999

In its first 14 years, General Catalyst invested in HubSpot and started Kayak, according to Hemant Taneja.

“We invested in interesting companies like HubSpot. We started interesting companies like Kayak.”

0:02:16 · Hemant Taneja · Early portfolio

In 2014, after Hemant Taneja had moved to the Bay Area to open General Catalyst's Silicon Valley office, he asked the founders what they wanted the firm to become.

“And it wasn't until 2014. And at that time, I had already moved to the Bay Area to open our Silicon Valley presence that we sat down”

0:02:16 · Hemant Taneja · Firm strategy · 2014

General Catalyst brought on Ken Chenault, who later joined as chairman, to help it become an enduring organization.

“was to bring on Ken Chenault, who joined us a few years later as our chairman and helping us be on that journey”

0:02:45 · Hemant Taneja · Leadership

Andy Golden, who has run the Princeton endowment for about two decades, has been a lead investor in General Catalyst and advised it to 'play your own game'.

“he is this iconic LP who's been running the Princeton Endowment for the last couple of decades and has been our lead investor”

0:05:11 · Hemant Taneja · Investors

General Catalyst's CVF product funds company growth by giving capital based on the return a company earns on its customer acquisition spending, instead of requiring more equity.

“think about the investment that any company makes in CAC, cost of customer acquisition, almost look at a return on that investment and give them capital”

0:08:04 · Hemant Taneja · Growth financing

General Catalyst started Kayak and had Demandware, the commerce cloud business that is now part of Salesforce.

“So we started Kayak. We had Demandware, which is the commerce cloud, and that's part of Salesforce now.”

0:09:45 · Hemant Taneja · Company creation

Hemant Taneja describes Livongo as the first digital health company to reach a certain scale, focused on consumers with chronic conditions.

“And Livongo, which was the first digital health company that got to a certain level of scale, focusing on consumers with chronic conditions.”

0:10:14 · Hemant Taneja · Digital health

Hemant Taneja says General Catalyst has invested in Europe for almost a decade and treats Europe and the US as a single technology ecosystem.

“We've been investing there for almost a decade. And the way companies move fluidly between Europe and the US, especially in technology”

0:12:21 · Hemant Taneja · European investing

The host says Hemant Taneja and Ken Chenault wrote a 2019 article arguing that the era of 'move fast and break things' is over.

“threw down the gauntlet when you wrote the article, the era of move fast and break things is over.”

0:16:31 · Michael Brandmeier · Responsible innovation · 2019

Hemant Taneja's book Intended Consequences lays out the responsible innovation framework that General Catalyst built into its investment process.

“And that's what my last book, Intended Consequences, was about laying that framework out.”

0:17:35 · Hemant Taneja · Books

Hemant Taneja argues that ESG is the wrong framework for companies built from scratch and that an inputs-oriented approach is needed.

“ESG, I'd argue, and I have argued in my book, is that it's just the wrong framework to think about when companies are being built from scratch.”

0:18:00 · Hemant Taneja · ESG

Hemant Taneja dates the start of society's digital transformation to 2007, when Facebook Connect, AWS and the iPhone came together.

“the digital transformation of society really started in 07. You had Facebook Connect, AWS, and the iPhone all coming together.”

0:19:31 · Hemant Taneja · Digital transformation · 2007

Hemant Taneja expects most AI value over the next 15 years to come from partnerships in which technology firms help established industries transform.

“but we think the next 15 years, the use of AI, most of the value is going to get captured in this transformation role and in this sort of partnership between technology industry and other industries”

0:21:35 · Hemant Taneja · AI value

Hemant Taneja co-wrote a piece with Fareed Zakaria about a 'digital cold war' between a US-centric democratic technology system and a Chinese authoritarian one.

“This is the digital cold war that Faree Zakaria and I just wrote about recently.”

0:23:34 · Hemant Taneja · Geopolitics of AI · 2023

Hemant Taneja says US healthcare spending is approaching 20% of GDP and that this is a breaking point for policymakers.

“doing it in a way that is affordable for society, reduce the GDP of healthcare. It's approaching 20%.”

0:25:59 · Hemant Taneja · Healthcare costs

The host says General Catalyst's Health Assurance Ecosystem Partnership includes 18 health systems across four countries covering 40 million people.

“But you've partnered with 18 health systems across four countries covering 40 million people.”

0:28:13 · Michael Brandmeier · Health partnerships

Livongo merged at an $18 billion valuation about six or seven years after its product launched, which Hemant Taneja calls a sale at the peak.

“It merged at $18 billion valuation, probably about six, seven years after we launched the product.”

0:28:59 · Hemant Taneja · Livongo outcome

Hemant Taneja says Livongo served only about half a million of the 35 to 37 million people in the US with diabetes and other chronic conditions when it was sold.

“But we were only serving half a million people at that time out of 35, 37 million people with diabetes and other chronic conditions in the US.”

0:28:59 · Hemant Taneja · Livongo reach

The host says Hemant Taneja left MIT in 1999 to join a startup after planning an academic career.

“You were planning an academic career, but you left school in 1999 to join a startup.”

0:33:07 · Michael Brandmeier · Career · 1999

Hemant Taneja helped create an MIT course called Founder's Journey, taught in the computer science department, to teach engineers how to start companies.

“I helped create a course called Founder's Journey, which was taught in the CS department.”

0:35:06 · Hemant Taneja · MIT teaching · 2009

Hemant Taneja says he met Stripe's John and Patrick Collison through his MIT class, which John Collison visited with Greg Brockman.

“I actually met John and Patrick through that because John had visited my class along with Greg Brockman, who is now the president of OpenAI and was the CEO of Stripe.”

0:36:01 · Hemant Taneja · Stripe origins

Hemant Taneja helped Sal Khan start Khan Lab School, a K-12 school built on mastery-based and self-paced learning.

“Sal had written this book, One World Schoolhouse, and we helped him start the school, Khan Lab School.”

0:36:52 · Hemant Taneja · Education

Hemant Taneja's first investment was Cite Advisor, a Safe Search company founded by Chris Dixon and two others, which McAfee acquired a year later.

“they were working on Safe Search. And it was acquired by McAfee a year later.”

0:38:10 · Hemant Taneja · First investment

Chapters

  1. 0:00:58A mission built around enduring companies

    Taneja explains why General Catalyst ties its mission to companies that last and create positive change, since compounding outliers drive returns.

    “Our mission is to invest in positive, powerful change that endures.”
  2. 0:01:52From serendipity to an enduring firm

    The firm's 1999 founding by entrepreneurs and the 2014 decision to build something that outlasts its founders, including bringing on Ken Chenault.

    “why don't we go be entrepreneurs investing in entrepreneurs”
  3. 0:08:04Founder financing and company creation

    Taneja describes the growth financing product and the firm's habit of starting companies itself, which shapes how it supports founders.

    “think about the investment that any company makes in CAC, cost of customer acquisition”
  4. 0:13:09Betting on India and Europe

    The firm sees India's entrepreneurial energy and Europe's need for resilience as the next decade's opportunities.

    “no country is more entrepreneurial than India”
  5. 0:16:56Responsible innovation versus ESG

    Taneja argues governance and anticipating unintended consequences must be built into companies from the start.

    “Move fast and break things is an engineering design principle.”
  6. 0:20:33AI as a transformation advantage

    He contrasts the mobile-era distribution advantage with AI's role in helping large companies transform.

    “it's not a distribution advantage, it's a transformation advantage”
  7. 0:23:34The digital cold war between AI systems

    Taneja frames a geopolitical race between democratic and authoritarian AI models and calls for a shared code of conduct.

    “the world's breaking up into two technology systems”
  8. 0:26:53Health assurance and the Livongo lesson

    He lays out a proactive, affordable, equitable healthcare vision and explains why Livongo's sale left impact on the table.

    “the Amazon of healthcare is 1 trillion dollar ecosystem, not 1 trillion dollar company”
  9. 0:31:27Why this is a golden age for venture

    Taneja sees bubble cycles, AI and geopolitics combining to create mispriced growth assets and early-stage opportunity.

    “it could not be a more exciting time because you've got mispriced assets for growth”
  10. 0:36:01MIT, Stripe and a path of serendipity

    His teaching at MIT led to relationships with the Stripe founders and shows how he moved from accident to intention.

    “I actually met John and Patrick through that”

Transcript

0:00:03
Michael Brandmeier

Welcome back to another edition of Goldman Sachs Exchanges, Great Investors. I'm Michael Brandmeier, Global Co-Head and Co-Chief Investment Officer of the External Investing Group at Goldman Sachs Asset Management, and your host for today's episode. Today, I'm delighted to be joined by Hemant Taneja, the CEO of General Catalyst, a venture capital firm focused on early stage and growth investments. Hemant was an early investor in companies such as Stripe, Snap, Grammarly, Samsara, Andrile, Gusto, and Applied Intuition, and is known for his frameworks around investing in enduring mission-driven businesses.

0:00:38

He's also an author and entrepreneur, having founded several companies such as Livongo that are focused on transforming the healthcare industry. Hemant, welcome to the program. Thank you. I'm so excited to be here. Let's start with your mission-based approach to investing, an approach that sets you and General Catalyst apart in the VC space. Explain to our listeners what this means.

0:00:58
Hemant Taneja

Our mission is to invest in positive, powerful change that endures. And every word there is very carefully chosen. Our belief is that to create a high performance firm, you have to invest in companies that can endure for a long time. Because if companies are enduring and growing, your investment is compounding. And in our industry, it's the compounding outliers that drive all the returns. There's a power law. Working backwards from what are the kinds of things that make these companies endure is where our mission comes from.

0:01:29

And honestly, the key observation we have made, especially in this era of technological transformation of society, is that the most effective way to build enduring companies is focusing on companies that create a positive change in the world.

0:01:42
Michael Brandmeier

So this was an evolution at General Catalyst. Discuss when you started to think about the General Catalyst platform differently and how you arrived at a values-based approach to building the firm.

0:01:52
Hemant Taneja

Like most great organizations, there's always some element of serendipity in how they get started. So David and Joel were my partners of long time and co-founders of the firm. They started the firm in 99. And when they saw a lot of what was happening with the internet and there was this vibrant entrepreneurial ecosystem in Boston, they were entrepreneurs. They said, hey, why don't we go be entrepreneurs investing in entrepreneurs? That was literally our tagline at that time.

0:02:16

And the first 14 years of investing, we did a good job. We built a good firm. We invested in interesting companies like HubSpot. We started interesting companies like Kayak. And it wasn't until 2014. And at that time, I had already moved to the Bay Area to open our Silicon Valley presence that we sat down and I asked David and Joel, what do you want to do with this? We actually have an opportunity to build something that could really endure, but this is a business you guys started and you should decide what the goals are.

0:02:45

And they were very keen on building something that could endure, something that could outlast them and outlast me. That's when this started. And the very first thing we did at that time, because we also didn't know how to build an enduring firm, by the way, was to bring on Ken Chenault, who joined us a few years later as our chairman and helping us be on that journey where General Catalyst could not only be an interesting investment firm, but actually be an organization that can endure for a long time.

0:03:12

And that's when this whole exercise of mission and value started for us.

0:03:16
Michael Brandmeier

And you were definitely early on that, and you developed something that you call responsible innovation that you've written about broadly. Talk about why responsible innovation is core

0:03:26
Hemant Taneja

to your investment process. Yeah. First of all, we were 18 years into our journey doing our mission and values work. So we certainly weren't early because companies do that at the beginning, but we had to go find ourselves and who we are almost retrospectively with a lot of Ken's guidance. By then, we had noticed that the role of technology in society was changing, and we were using it to build core pillars of society online. It was almost a digital transformation of society happening across all these major areas, healthcare, education, finance, pretty much every sector of society.

0:03:58

And our view was, gee, if you're going to build a modern set of companies for healthcare as an example or education, you have to think with a much longer horizon than we were used to in the traditional venture capital. And you had to build these companies with a lot more sense of responsibility. So your governance mindset had to be different because now you're building companies that really touch people's lives. It wasn't just technology providing efficiency. And that's when we started to think a lot about what does responsible innovation really look like?

0:04:26

What are the mindset and mechanisms that can help these companies be in the interest of society and simultaneously focusing on purpose and profit?

0:04:37
Michael Brandmeier

We'll come back to that in a moment, but I love the story that you tell of your time with Andy Golden and his advice to you on building your firm and some version of become your best self. But one of the things that I really love about the makeup of General Catalyst is how diverse the managing partners of the firm are and how you've really come to embody a common set of values, both in terms of the firm that you've built, the diversity of your staff, and it goes all the way through to your investment approach, which I think is super interesting.

0:05:11
Hemant Taneja

Yeah, Andy Golden, he is this iconic LP who's been running the Princeton Endowment for the last couple of decades and has been our lead investor and a true guiding force for the evolution of General Catalyst. And I used to always ask him at the end of each annual meeting, I think probably for several years in a row, he probably got tired of being asked the same questions like, Andy, how do we become the leading venture capital firm?

0:05:33

And he would always say, play your own game. And I think this idea of being first principled, have a true growth mindset, I give him a lot of credit for making us think about that in the context of even building our own firm. So if I go back to the values and mission exercise that we did, we realized who we are. And the core values, which I mean, I love these words that our CMO came up with around diversity of thought, depth of relationship, creativity of approach, audacity of ambition, mindfulness of impact.

0:06:02

And when you look at those things, what we started doing was how do we bring people together that share these core values? because that's who we were. And honestly, I think Ken came there because that's who he is fundamentally. And at the same time, what diversity of thought means is that they bring in new dimensions to how we think about stuff. So if you look at the team at General Catalyst, we have Fortune 500 CEOs, we have an Oscar-winning filmmaker in David, and we've got trained investors from other elite firms.

0:06:30

We've got the most preeminent bankers who's taken most of the technology companies public in the last 20 years. We've got this incredible team where they all come at this process of supporting founders to build enduring companies, which is really our core focus with a very different lens. And the key to our culture has been how do you activate that diversity of thought? Because if everybody's speaking a different language, you can actually be in a place where nobody understands each other.

0:06:56

But if you really lean into a culture where you can leverage all those points of views, then you have magic. And I think it's taken us a few years to get there, but it's just amazing to see how all these different thought leaders from different categories come together in support of the

0:07:09
Michael Brandmeier

founders, the general catalyst. It is really amazing to think about how different you guys are as individuals and yet how it all does come together, which is amazing. Another one of your core pillars has been on supporting entrepreneurs and founders, and you've developed a product set around that to enable them and what they're doing. Let's talk a little bit about that, starting with what you're doing on the customer value side. Yeah. So if you go back to our mission

0:07:34
Hemant Taneja

to invest in positive, powerful change. At the end of the day, founders are those agents of change. And the change that they create is building these enduring companies that are focused on improving society, focused on creating both purpose and profit with their work, supporting their purpose. And what we have been thinking about from our own product strategy, the financial tools we have, the governance tools we have in support of the founders is how can we help them navigate these inflection points to become those enduring institutions?

0:08:04

And in one of those dimensions, the observation we made for a lot of technology companies, which tend to be following the subscription-based business models or models that mimic subscription-based behavior with their customers, there was a better way to help those founders support their growth than necessarily raising more and more equity and diluting themselves. And so we have a young guy in our team who came to us with an idea one day and essentially said, hey, what if we started funding growth with this fundamentally different view, which is think about the investment that any company makes in CAC, cost of customer acquisition, almost look at a return on that investment and give them capital based on those return thresholds

0:08:43

and their performance. And that idea, talk about being lucky in terms of the timing of the idea, because over the last couple of years where the markets took us to a spot where all these companies were mispriced, heavily overpriced, frankly, from their valuation perspectives in the bubble, but they still need capital to grow. We were able to come in and help these companies support their growth in a way that it necessarily didn't require them to go raise equity.

0:09:06

And so that product has had tremendous product market fit and CVF, as we call it, is getting great traction with companies in really all major parts of their venture capital has helped build subscription businesses, consumer, gaming, enterprise infrastructure, you know, U.S. and international. And we're very excited about having that tool in our toolbox to help these companies become enduring.

0:09:29
Michael Brandmeier

Yeah, it's a super powerful tool for entrepreneurs and super innovative that you guys came up with it. something else that you guys love to do is start companies on a napkin or just around a table with founders. And so you have an entire strategy around that. Talk about that.

0:09:45
Hemant Taneja

Yeah. If you think about the last 20 years of GC, one of the unique strengths and a secret sauce, what we now call is creation, which is hatching and transforming businesses. And it came from the original DNA of the founders, because that's what they were doing before they started the firm. And over the last 20 years, I think we're the only firm that has created companies, category-defining companies in multiple categories. So we started Kayak. We had Demandware, which is the commerce cloud, and that's part of Salesforce now.

0:10:14

And Livongo, which was the first digital health company that got to a certain level of scale, focusing on consumers with chronic conditions. And we really leaned into that. We think that in addition to the idea of serendipitously supporting founders that bring ideas to us, we do have deep perspective on certain set of areas where often there are certain kinds of companies that are not getting built that would advance the evolution of that sector. And they're not getting built because either they're too capital intense and venture capital firms don't want to fund them, or they're very multidisciplinary and the right team zone self-combust.

0:10:48

There could be a variety of reasons. In those areas, we will put teams together, put the capital to work and have the long-term mindset of, hey, let's go solve this problem. And with the benefit of hindsight, that has been a phenomenal part of our business. So we have continued to lean into that and we're expanding our capabilities to do that across many different sectors in addition to the ones we've already done it. Yeah, that's value creation at its essence.

0:11:11

That's really why we call it creation, because we are actually truly doing value creation. And a lot of these companies fundamentally won't exist if it wasn't for General Catalyst.

0:11:19
Michael Brandmeier

Yeah. Now, something else you're doing is expanding internationally. Now you're investing actively in Europe. You're investing actively in India. Talk about where you're seeing the most interesting opportunities these days.

0:11:29
Hemant Taneja

Yeah. So we are very excited about the opportunities in India. If you think about India rising as a third geopolitical power and an economic power and the dynamics around how U.S. and India are really aligned from a technology development perspective, we think there's a great opportunity for us, having done work in our core areas, to bring that perspective and help with the transformation of India. I grew up there. I have several other partners who have affinity to that.

0:11:59

We understand the local markets and the areas that we care about are very relevant when you think about what India needs to accomplish for its own people. And so we've been investing there for a few years. These companies are extraordinary. The Indian public markets have opened up and you can see venture capital can actually generate strong returns there. So we're leaning into it. And Europe, we always look at that as an extension of our core business from the beginning.

0:12:21

We've been investing there for almost a decade. And the way companies move fluidly between Europe and the US, especially in technology, we look at that as a single ecosystem. But from a resilience standpoint, Europe has its own set of challenges it has to get itself out of. And so when you think about energy transitions, especially if you look at the energy issues around the Ukraine war, there's so many areas like that where Europe has to become more innovative.

0:12:44

And so we think working with entrepreneurs there and helping them, again, in our own areas that we understand, build that resiliency for Europe is also a tremendous area over the next decade for us.

0:12:55
Michael Brandmeier

Yeah, I mean, India is a place where it really feels like something fundamentally special is happening right now with good governance, a lot of reform, massive infrastructure investment. What's the nature of the opportunities that you see?

0:13:09
Hemant Taneja

There's one other thing that has happened, first of all, which is no country is more entrepreneurial than India. I mean, I grew up there and everybody's an entrepreneur there. And now that you have seen success in companies like Flipkart and Freshworks and others in the technology sector, that's an aspirational path for India. If you look at the Indian community, they're very entrepreneurial in that regard. I think they believe that technology-based entrepreneurship is a great thing for India and a great thing from a career standpoint.

0:13:36

So every parent would use to talk about go into multinational companies and India is now encouraging their kids to be like, go be an entrepreneur. That is a sleeping giant that's just woken up. And if you think about, as you said, good leadership and governance in the country, it's a massive opportunity. is almost akin to what happened in China over the last 20 years. And that's one of the reasons we're very interested. I think we can bring a lot of our learnings from what's happened with the role of technology in the US and Europe into India and help get these companies built with responsible innovation in mind and with the idea of inclusive capitalism.

0:14:10

Let's do this in a way that India really uplifts because it's the most populous country in the world and it can't really

0:14:15
Michael Brandmeier

be innovating just for the affluent. Yeah. Hemant, when I think about what makes you distinctive as a CEO and GC distinctive as a firm, in my mind, it's really a combination of three things. Number one is you guys are very long vision, but a lot of people are very long vision. It's number two, the frameworking that you put around vision. And then number three, it's a collaborative and partnership mindset that I think is really differentiated from most firms out there.

0:14:41

What is it about your background and your formative years at GC that brought you to

0:14:46
Hemant Taneja

this approach? Yeah, look, I think the most important thing about GC is its growth mindset. When the firm started, the founders weren't investors or technologists. And today we have a preeminent technology investment firm. The only way an organization that serendipitously starts and becomes that intentional is because it's got a true growth mindset. So I think that to me is the core reason why we are where we are. Second is our values. So I think when you think about the focus on building a high-performance investment firm and truly believing that purpose-driven, enduring companies is the key to driving that performance, then you have to think long-term.

0:15:22

I think the moment you start thinking that way, it forces you to do a lot of the kinds of decisions we have made. And frankly, if we want to transform healthcare in the US, something I have been working on with several others in the firm for over a decade now, or areas like that, or have an answer to how do we truly use innovation for solving climate change, you have to transcend the venture capital model. Venture capital model doesn't get you there because you've got 10-year funds applied towards problems that are 30 to 50-year problems.

0:15:52

So it was a choice. We either had to stay niche like the way the industry has stayed and generate performance, but on a short term basis. And frankly, we did that a bunch and it was dissatisfying because we didn't accomplish the mission part of our journey in those experiences. Or we can think very long-term and frankly, take on much bigger opportunity, but with a longer-term mindset, a mindset of responsible innovation. And we just believe that's our raison d 'etre.

0:16:18

And I'm very hopeful that we will show this new investing model in the world of innovation that we are now in some ways pioneering, that that's the key to the greatest performance. In some ways, in 2019, you and Ken Chenault

0:16:31
Michael Brandmeier

threw down the gauntlet when you wrote the article, the era of move fast and break things is over. And you had been acting this way for a while. But one of the things I find really interesting, especially since you invest in some industries that are quite regulated, is how you think about different stakeholders. So unpack a little bit within this theme of responsible innovation, how you think about interacting with stakeholders in this both

0:16:56
Hemant Taneja

growth and long-term mindset? Move fast and break things is an engineering design principle. And when we started doing the digital transformation of society with technology, we somehow thought it was a societal design principle. That's really where a lot of the issues happen when you think about the issues around social media and the misinformation and disinformation. And frankly, a lot of the issues that can now happen with AI, we're going into this even accelerated area. And so the intentionality of it to build these companies and having the mindset and mechanisms in the way you build these companies so that you are actually minimizing the unintended consequences and having a governance models for nefarious intended consequences, that has to be part

0:17:35

of how we build a new new. And that's what my last book, Intended Consequences, was about laying that framework out. And what Ken and I and others in the firm have done is really integrate that into our investment process. So we always start to think about what could happen to a company as it develops, where could intended and unintended consequences that are negative happen? And how do we make sure we have a governance model that prevents as much of that as possible?

0:18:00

And that I think in some ways is very important to note as a difference from the application of ESG in corporations. So there's a lot of conversation today about what does ESG mean in the venture capital ecosystem? And ESG, I'd argue, and I have argued in my book, is that it's just the wrong framework to think about when companies are being built from scratch. because that's more of a, how do you tweak the outputs? We need a more inputs-oriented mindset.

0:18:24

And responsible innovation mechanisms are that input into how do you build these companies so they are built for growth and good from the beginning and in the way they use technology. We call this concept called algorithmic canaries and how AI should be used. The business model choices, the way you make sure you think about your immediate stakeholders, but also broader society as to how your business touches them so that can your business succeed in a way that is actually good for all stakeholders?

0:18:48

Because if you're actually being in service of one stakeholder, but really having adverse selection in others, there's going to be backlash. And so how do you really think about your role as a business and society in a way that's much more expansive than just your shareholders and your customers and your employees? That's a lot of what we think about in our governance model.

0:19:06
Michael Brandmeier

Yeah, I mean, this idea of thinking about technology is not just enabling efficiencies, but creating new pillars to society and working to collaborate and transform existing industries is just a very big idea. Maybe let's talk about that in the context of the hot topic du jour, which is AI. What do you think about the intended and unintended consequences as you embark on investing in that sector?

0:19:31
Hemant Taneja

So the digital transformation of society really started in 07. You had Facebook Connect, AWS, and the iPhone all coming together. And then you could actually build digital experiences for consumers in all different dimensions. So that has been the journey we're on. I actually said this middle part of last decade that that's a 30-year cycle. We're still going through that transition. And what happened in the last decade, a lot of what happened with innovation was that because you were using the mobile phone, there was a new distribution advantage on how to get to consumers.

0:20:03

And because of that distribution advantage, you could actually build these modern experiences, the modern taxi experience, which became Uber, or the modern food and dining experience that became DoorDash and other things. A lot of innovation and the companies that got built were in service of giving these new upstarts that were essentially building on the mobile app store, these superpowers of big companies. That's what striped it. You can actually not be a global business, even though you're like a small shop in Ohio somewhere and sell to the rest of the world because Stripe's going to give you a commerce stack that allows you to do that globally.

0:20:33

As an example, enter AI. What happened in November is we created this incredible capability that is a transformation capability. So if the last decade was an era of sort of disruption and new sort of full stack company creation, what AI does, because it's not a distribution advantage, it's a transformation advantage. It allows you to transform your consumer experiences and how you learn and how do you do drug discovery, all the things you can do, but it's not how you access consumers necessarily.

0:21:01

So essentially what's going to happen in this decade is giving the superpowers of small companies to big companies. So a lot of our focus has been on, well, gee, if we have these language models plus other forms of AI, because that's not the only AI, we've been using other parts of AI for a while now. If you had all these capabilities, how can we go to these larger companies and help them transform? and there our core principle of radical collaboration is essential because there we're not going to these big companies saying we're just going to go replace you and take share from you we're actually going to build these technologies that help you transform be more ai enabled and do

0:21:35

it in a responsible way because you do have to think about workforce transformation in that context you have to think about how do you do it in the way that you are serving everybody all the same issues in this new sort of transformation effect you have to be mindful of but we think the next 15 years, the use of AI, most of the value is going to get captured in this transformation role and in this sort of partnership between technology industry and other industries

0:21:59
Michael Brandmeier

to bring about this change. So it's obvious to who some of the big winners are, and they tend to be big companies. In the startup sector, what are some of the areas that you're seeing as being

0:22:10
Hemant Taneja

most promising right now? I'm very optimistic about what the AI and language model parts of AI can do in healthcare, for example. Imagine instead of having a couple million nurses in this country, you had infinite number of nurses because you could do this digitally in a very cost-effective way. How does the care model change? So that's an example. I think you could do that in legal where LLMs are actually very well suited. We think there's a big transformation in media coming because of this.

0:22:37

Obviously, there's a strike and you're dealing with the concerns around it from the workforce in that industry. But my expectation is by embracing it, you could actually unleash creativity to the next level. So I actually think most of these industries are going to evolve. I mean, drug discovery and life science is a huge area. I actually think financial services is a big place where that's going to change. And then think about the call center industry and the customer support and service industry.

0:23:03

There is so much more that can be done in enhancing experiences and how these businesses serve their customers that is going to get adopted in a lot of those places. I mean, we must have seen close to a thousand companies in the first half of this year now. And people are attacking the use of language models in every different direction, every different one of these kinds of use cases. It's very exciting. I do think it's going to be a tremendous era of building innovative companies over the next 15 years because of this shift.

0:23:26
Michael Brandmeier

Yeah, we're certainly at Goldman Sachs spending a lot of time thinking about it internally as it relates to our own business. And what about the broader implications for how AI may affect

0:23:34
Hemant Taneja

the geopolitical landscape in society at large? Yeah, if you think about the technology systems in the context of geopolitics, the world's breaking up into two technology systems, the US centric system, which is more democratic, open, and most of Europe, India, US, they're aligned. And then there's the Chinese system, which is more authoritarian. So I actually think there are two models of AI that are going to be in a race against each other. This is the digital cold war that Faree Zakaria and I just wrote about recently.

0:24:05

And a lot of our focus is on how do we make sure the AI system and the AI industry that is supportive of democratic values and is respecting human rights and freedom of speech and privacy and values like that is the one that ends up being dominating in business. It requires a collaboration that's unprecedented in AI across these different nations, which is a lot of where I've been spending time because we need a responsible AI code of conduct that gets embraced.

0:24:34

And it does in a way that every nation feels they are AI resilient. In the era of globalization, US technology companies would build products and the rest of the world would just embrace them. But post-pandemic, post-Ukraine, post seeing that somebody can be removed out of SWIFT, as a nation, every country is now saying, how do we be resilient for our people? So in that context, they're going to want resiliency in AI. So it has to be done in a way that you're building local capabilities, but then And there's a collaboration so that this federated model of AI across the democratic world can have the same scale advantage that an authoritarian model would, where you actually would put all

0:25:15

the data in a single model and there's no constraints and there's no complex set of fragmented regulatory frameworks that are getting in the way. So I think it's a race of a bottom-up versus top-down AI system. And we're spending a lot of time thinking about how do we make sure there's a collaboration that drives the development of AI in the democratic world with the democratic values as a leading enabler of business.

0:25:35
Michael Brandmeier

Absolutely fascinating. Let's pivot and talk about healthcare. Healthcare is a sector you're very focused on. And as you mentioned, you wrote a book called Unhealthcare, Manifesto for Health Assurance. And you've also co-founded several healthcare startups, including Livongo, which was acquired by Teladoc Health, and Commure more recently. Are we making progress in making healthcare more accessible to people through companies such as the ones you're building?

0:25:59
Hemant Taneja

The vision for healthcare for us has been something we call health assurance, which I wrote about in that book. And that's really three things. One is transition the care model to proactive care. Consumers want health. They don't want an expensive, high-efficacy sick care system only. doing it in a way that is affordable for society, reduce the GDP of healthcare. It's approaching 20%. At some point, if healthcare costs keep outpacing the growth of GDP, you as a policymaker is borrowing more and more dollars from supporting education and defense and other areas.

0:26:30

It's just, it's a breaking point. And we saw the vulnerability of the system post COVID. And the third thing is health equity. We have no viable healthcare system for inner cities and rural America. And we have to fix that. And so when we think about, okay, this goes back to my long-term enduring mindset in 30 to 50 years, what should the system look like? It needs to be a system of health assurance, proactive, affordable, accessible.

0:26:53

In order to do that, there's no single company that's an answer to that. And I've said this before, the Amazon of healthcare is 1 trillion dollar ecosystem, not 1 trillion dollar company. So what happened post COVID is that there was this can be an explosion of a lot of companies that have been building towards these kinds of proactive, affordable, accessible experiences. And what we have to do is we have to help our health systems become more vibrant.

0:27:18

We need to help them move towards value-based care. And we need them to be built with the mindset of health assurance. I think there are a lot of leading indicators that the companies are going to change the system are already in motion. We are supporting many of them. We have over 100 companies now in healthcare that are working on different parts of the ecosystem. And I'm very optimistic that in this decade, you're going to start to see the health systems become more vibrant and the system becoming more economically rational.

0:27:45

Because right now, who pays and who benefits are two different stakeholders. And that's a lot of why the misalignment happens in this industry. And we think that this innovation is going to help us move to a sort of rational economic system. And frankly, Livongo, that's the company, as you mentioned, we helped build in our own offices, was one of the first examples where you could see that you could do that at scale. And Livongo in some ways was the first health assurance company.

0:28:05

And we now have so many of them that are following those footsteps and thinking about both business model and consumer experiences with that mindset.

0:28:13
Michael Brandmeier

Yeah, I love your framework that what we talk about is healthcare is really sick care. And the core idea here is we need to move away from that and keep people healthy and avoid what we call healthcare today. You launched the Health Assurance Ecosystem Partnership, which I think brings a lot of this together, your partnership mindset, your long-term mindset. But you've partnered with 18 health systems across four countries covering 40 million people. Another

0:28:37
Hemant Taneja

big idea. Why did you go down this path? Yeah, I know our belief is that, again, if you want to do this transformation and make a dent in the healthcare ecosystem in its transition to health assurance, it wasn't going to happen just by building a few portfolio companies and you take them public and exit. In fact, I have very mixed feelings about the Livongo outcome. It was a great financial success for us. We sold it at the peak.

0:28:59

It merged at $18 billion valuation, probably about six, seven years after we launched the product. But we were only serving half a million people at that time out of 35, 37 million people with diabetes and other chronic conditions in the US. It was in some ways short-term success, but long-term we could have built a business that was going to be so much bigger and so much more impactful. I think thinking with that mindset, a lot of what we are doing is that help these companies scale, help these companies make a real impact.

0:29:26

And the answer to that is to be in partnership with the ecosystem. You need the existing healthcare system to embrace these companies, partner with them, and think about a transformative consumer experience that is aligned with the health assurance principles. So we don't see any other path to do this type of a long-term transformation if it wasn't for a true partnership in service of these partners and working closely with them.

0:29:49
Michael Brandmeier

Yeah. We've talked a lot about the general catalyst approach to investing and to venture. let's talk a little bit about the macroeconomic environment for venture capital in general. We may be going through a period of massive disruption for the VC industry, just given the fact that we've been through a severe market retrenchment over the last 18 months. How do you see the industry evolving?

0:30:12
Hemant Taneja

Yeah, so I think it's a superposition of a few things going on in our industry. One is just bubbles get created, which are actually good for innovation because a lot of capital goes towards interesting technologies and market changes. Then bubbles burst. So there's one of this sort of 10, 15 year accordion that sort of impacts the industry. So that's a lot of where the focus is on, hey, a lot of companies got overpriced. How are they going to navigate the next few years?

0:30:34

But resilient entrepreneurs find a way and maybe there's some of them will have down rounds, but a lot of public companies had their valuations get reduced as well. So to me, that's just ordinary course of business. And I frankly don't pay much attention to that because it's just what happens in markets. Then there's the, as I mentioned earlier, the bigger shift around AI being a technological shift with which there's a new model to engage with the rest of the economy for technology.

0:30:57

So that's sorting itself out. So all that infrastructure and tooling is getting built. And then founders are realizing the values actually in working with these systems and go do their transformation. And then frankly, the third, when you go sort of, you know, zoom out even further is around the changing geopolitics. So with technology, we're building core pillars of society and every nation is trying to figure out how to be more resilient in those core pillars for their people than the way our companies get built and how they think about becoming global and at scale and enduring, those models have to change.

0:31:27

So that is another place where we think a lot about, you know, if you were an AI company today, how do you become global? That's an example. So I think the geopolitics dynamics trump business in some ways, there's an AI transformation. And then in the short term, there's the, how do you cross the chasm from this like last bubble where things were overpriced? Overall, I would say is it could not be a more exciting time because you've got mispriced assets for growth.

0:31:51

You've got AI innovation for early stage investing. And then you've got some industries that are all going through this change around resilience, healthcare, climate, education, others. It's in some ways the golden age. I've been saying this for a few years. I feel very lucky. My whole career is going to coincide with this digital transformation of society that has a huge runway for this particular

0:32:10
Michael Brandmeier

asset class. Yeah. I always say invest in innovation because even though we're at the end of one cycle, at least one financial cycle. It's just so exciting how many interesting themes that are out there and megatrends that you can invest behind. Let's rewind the clock for a moment and go back to when you were still in school at MIT. How did you end up with five degrees?

0:32:30
Hemant Taneja

I often call it the lack of focus. I think the reality is I was very curious. And my favorite thing to do when I was in college was look at the course catalog. I would look at it all the time. What else can I learn about? And how do I learn about something in every department? And then And when it was senior year, I'd taken all these classes, but I wasn't going to be able to graduate in any one of them.

0:32:49

So I just looked at which ones were close to finishing, and then I just leaned in and got those done. But I was on a path to being an academic and following my curiosity, which in hindsight was a good training for this job. I didn't think I was going to be a venture capitalist when I was in college. But it was a great experience being at MIT. I mean, just learn about all these interdisciplinary ideas.

0:33:07
Michael Brandmeier

You were planning an academic career, but you left school in 1999 to join a startup. Of course, that was at the height of the dot-com boom. What was it like for you at the time? And what was the tipping factor for you to join the startup after having such a great experience at MIT?

0:33:22
Hemant Taneja

Yeah, you know, just like I was saying before the General Catalyst journey started with serendipity, I think that happens in life too. And that particular life decision of, let me just take a sabbatical and I'll just go take a break and I'll come back and finish my PhD and go be part of this movement. because all these smart folks at MIT were going in and building these internet businesses, Akamai and others, it felt like a moment in time that just was very unique and I wanted to be a part of it.

0:33:46

So I literally put the academic career on pause, partnered with three of my very close friends in college, my best friends, and we started this company. And it was very serendipitous. We didn't really have an idea. We just knew mobile was happening and it was a technological shift. So we're like, we'll figure it out. And I look at my career starting from there to where I am today, which is all about building intentional technology-led companies.

0:34:08

And I've gone through my own journey of how you go from serendipity to intentionality in building a career, which is in some ways no different than how you build an organization. That might have started as an accident with a good, cool insight, but then you have to become very intentional and values-driven and mission-driven along the way to really build a great legacy.

0:34:27
Michael Brandmeier

Talking about serendipity, one of my favorite stories is about how you met the founders of Stripe, the Collison brothers during your MIT days. And of course, that relationship has resulted in one of your most successful investments. Tell us that story. So I studied in the computer science

0:34:43
Hemant Taneja

department and also I was studying in the Sloan School at MIT. And there was this dynamic at MIT where at that time, if we wanted to learn about business, you had to go to business school. And I knew that a lot of the engineers, if you expose them to what business was with an engineering mindset and did it in their own comfortable setting that more engineers would want to become entrepreneurs. You could unlock entrepreneurship at a greater scale.

0:35:06

So I helped create a course called Founder's Journey, which was taught in the CS department. This was actually when I was at General Catalyst, we were investing. And I used to always think about how do I stay close to the students on campus? Because they often know where innovation is going. They're the bleeding edge of it. And General Catalyst being in the Cambridge area, MIT was obviously a natural spot for me to think about going and teaching, A, because I went there, but then also so much of the engineering work happens at the Institute.

0:35:35

So engineers would come and learn what it took to start a business. And I really deconstructed it into nine different set of exercises that we would walk these folks through and help them start a company and learn those skills. And it was in the middle of the App Store stuff. So this was, I think, in 2009, 2010. So right after the App Store launch and all these interesting businesses that students on campus could build, because it was so simplified with AWS tools, everybody was thinking about starting companies.

0:36:01

I actually met John and Patrick through that because John had visited my class along with Greg Brockman, who is now the president of OpenAI and was the CEO of Stripe. I met the BenchLink founder through that. I met the Segment founder through that. It was like, I was just teaching because it keeps you vibrant, learning from these smart students on these amazing university campuses, but ended up being a boon for us as well because we ended up investing in some of these companies, obviously Stripe being the most prominent.

0:36:26

And they've become great friends and have had a great impact on our own journey at General Catalyst as well, just learning to watch them build their intentional businesses. Amazing. So fast forward to today, let's talk about some of

0:36:37
Michael Brandmeier

your outside interests. In addition to your many pursuits as an author, entrepreneur, and investor, you're also an educator through your involvement with Khan Lab School and Sal Khan, an innovative K-12 school. How did you decide to focus on education along with everything else you're doing?

0:36:52
Hemant Taneja

That might have been just entirely personal. So Sal is one of my dear friends from college, and obviously he's built this incredible movement around Khan Academy. And when our kids were getting older and we were starting to think about school for them, Sal had written this book, One World Schoolhouse, and we helped him start the school, Khan Lab School. And the whole idea was to leverage this whole idea of mastery-based learning and self-paced learning and rethink what the model is.

0:37:17

I think most parents who might be listening to this would agree that almost everybody's unhappy with the school that their kids are in because the reality is that the existing Prussian model just doesn't really lend itself for a culture of lifelong learning and what you really need to thrive in society today. And so we're like, we know the right answer isn't to go to one of the existing schools, probably. So why don't we just take a shot at starting something that's a human experiment in our own kids?

0:37:39

But my wife was very encouraging of that because she had been thinking a lot about what's going to be great for our kids. So then that's how we started. The school started supporting up to Isabella, who's our eldest, and she was, I think, in sixth grade at that time. And then today it's a K-12 school. They've had a couple of classes that have been very successful in how they got placed. I think their kids feel very resilient.

0:37:59

They've learned to learn anything, which is really the goal. And we've been on that journey for about eight years now.

0:38:04
Michael Brandmeier

So we like to end these sessions with a lightning round. So we're going to run through a couple of questions and just get a quick answer.

0:38:10
Hemant Taneja

What was your first investment? My first investment was a company called Cite Advisor. It was founded by Chris Dixon, who's at another venture firm as a crypto investor and a good friend of mine and two of my friends from MIT. And they were working on Safe Search. And it was acquired by McAfee a year later. And I thought venture capital was very easy at that time.

0:38:28
Michael Brandmeier

What is your biggest lesson you've learned as an investor, knowing that sometimes you learn great lessons on good investments, but sometimes you learn lessons on your worst investments?

0:38:38
Hemant Taneja

The biggest lesson for me, having done this for 20 plus years, is to really appreciate what humility means as an investor. Not to sound too crass, but when you're selling money and you get to say yes, no, it has a profound impact on you because you start believing your own view of what's going to happen in the world. And the reality is that you have to completely disengage from that in how you make investment decisions. And from my standpoint, never starting to think about our own views of what's going to happen in the future and really look at the investments from the lens of the founders and seeing if you want to get behind that or not is the essence

0:39:09

of staying humble and staying first principled as an investor. Which investor do you admire most? I would have to say Warren Buffett. And I say that because he's got the long-term enduring perspective and he's very principled. It may not be that all those principles apply all the time to what's happening with businesses, but he's consistent and doesn't operate with FOMO. And so that to me, because there are many strategies to create success and there's many great investors, but those are interesting criteria to be thinking about and sort of staying consistent.

0:39:40

And obviously he's had an amazing run in Berkshire. And how about your biggest mentor? So my biggest mentor, I would have to say, has been Ken Chenault, our chairman. We've only worked together for a few years, but he has helped me coalesce so many key insights and learnings that were all over the place in my mind in the things I did just by sheer instinct and become a lot more intentional. and working with him on advancing on the principles of responsible innovation and learning how to be a leader.

0:40:09

Frankly, as General Catalyst scales, it's not good enough for me to be a good investor. I need to also learn to have that servant leader mindset in the way we build our own organization. And honestly, I didn't know any of that a few years ago, and he's had a huge influence on me. Ken's amazing.

0:40:23
Michael Brandmeier

What's the best piece of investment advice you can give to our listeners that you wish someone had given to you when you were younger? Invest in people, not ideas. Finally, what are you most excited about in the world right now?

0:40:34
Hemant Taneja

I am very hopeful that the confluence of technologies that are all coming together, if you look at AI, if you look at applications of AI and materials and biology, if you think about a lot of the new biological technologies that are coming about, I think the answers to an inclusive society where everybody prospers and a sustainable planet are all through those technologies. Innovation is the answer for the great life that we all covet as a society.

0:41:05

And this is the moment. I think these next 20 years will do a lot. We're going to look back and if we're intentional and we have the responsible innovation mindset, we're going to look back and say we made a big difference for the generations after us. Well, very mind-bending and inspirational. Hemant, it's always such a pleasure to speak with you. Thanks for having me, Mike. That was so fun. You just took me down 20 years of memory lane.

0:41:26
Michael Brandmeier

Thank you all for listening to this special episode of Goldman Sachs Exchanges. Great Investors. This podcast was recorded on September 12th, 2023. If you enjoyed the show, we hope you'll follow us on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or Google Podcasts, or wherever you listen to your podcasts and leave us a rating and comment. The opinions and views expressed in this program are not necessarily the opinions of Goldman Sachs or its affiliates. This program should not be copied or published without the express written consent of Goldman Sachs.

0:41:59

Each brand mentioned in this program is the property of the company to which it relates and is not used to imply any ownership or license rights. Goldman Sachs is not providing any financial, economic, legal, investment, accounting, or tax advice through this program. Neither Goldman Sachs nor any of its affiliates makes any representation or warranty as to the accuracy or completeness of any information contained in this program.