In brief
After the collapses of FTX, Terra's Luna and Celsius, the guests disagree on whether U.S. crypto rules are unclear or simply ignored. Jay Clayton and Timothy Massad say the rules are clear enough. They argue that crypto firms avoid costly compliance and that regulators should enforce existing law. Gary Gorton warns that stablecoins, a form of private money, could cause a future financial crisis.
The main tension is between enforcing what exists and building something new. Marcel Kasumovich wants clarity so risk-taking returns onshore. Clayton favors narrow fixes. Massad proposes common standards from the SEC and CFTC, possibly through a jointly supervised industry body. Beneath the debate is agreement that the technology worked through the crashes, while Gorton argues that only a crisis will force the reforms he wants.
Questions
Why did FTX and other crypto firms end up offshore?
Marcel Kasumovich says unclear U.S. rules pushed risk-taking abroad, which is why FTX was based in the Bahamas and why the main options exchange, Deribit, is offshore. Clayton disputes this and says the rules are clear but unpopular.
Is crypto a security or a commodity, and why does it matter?
Securities face strict SEC rules, while commodity spot markets (direct buying and selling) have no federal regulator. Massad says exchanges exploit this by claiming their tokens are commodities.
What is Timothy Massad's proposed fix for crypto regulation?
He says the SEC and CFTC should set shared standards to protect customer assets and prevent fraud and conflicts of interest. A joint self-regulatory organization, supervised by the agencies and funded by the industry, could enforce them.
What is a stablecoin and why does Gary Gorton worry about it?
A stablecoin is a crypto token that claims to be backed one-for-one by assets such as dollars. Gorton says no one can be sure the assets are really there, and he fears runs on them, like bank runs, as they connect crypto to the real economy.
Did the technology fail during the FTX collapse?
No. Kasumovich says Bitcoin and Ethereum ran around the clock during FTX's failure, settling billions of dollars of transactions daily. Clayton agrees the technology is promising but says it should not replace proven regulation.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Marcel Kasumovich said Deribit controls 95 percent of open interest in crypto options, and that U.S. persons are barred from using it.
“If you want to trade options markets in digital, you have to do that offshore. Deribit controls 95 % of the open interest in options.”
0:01:28 · Guest · Crypto options · 2022
Marcel Kasumovich said the SEC is still owed $30 million of a $100 million fine against BlockFi, making it the fourth largest creditor in the BlockFi bankruptcy.
“They're still owed $30 million of the $100 million fine that they gave to BlockFi for violating what they thought was two forms of regulation.”
0:00:59 · Guest · BlockFi fine · 2022
The host explained that the CFTC oversees commodity derivatives but not the underlying spot markets, which is why commodity treatment is seen as lighter regulation.
“Commodities regulation is apparently considered less onerous because the CFTC only has oversight over commodity derivatives, not the spot markets that underlie them.”
0:02:00 · Allison Nathan · CFTC jurisdiction
Jay Clayton noted that Bitcoin was designated a commodity some years earlier, and that some argue many other digital assets should be treated likewise.
“And they look at the fact that Bitcoin was designated as a commodity some years ago.”
0:04:10 · Guest · Bitcoin classification
Jay Clayton argued that the U.S. financial regulatory system involves many agencies, including the Fed, CFTC, OCC and FDIC, with more overlaps than gaps.
“In the United States, we have a multifaceted regulatory regime. We have the Fed, the CFTC, the OCC, the FDIC.”
0:04:38 · Guest · U.S. regulators
Timothy Massad said most large U.S. crypto trading platforms are regulated only under state money service business laws.
“Most big trading platforms in the U.S. are regulated only under state money service business laws.”
0:05:35 · Timothy Massad · Exchange regulation · 2022
Timothy Massad said state money service laws originated in the telegraph era to regulate Western Union.
“Literally, they were designed to regulate Western Union because it had offices in different places and it was wiring money from one to the other.”
0:06:03 · Timothy Massad · Money service laws
Timothy Massad compared the CFTC's role in crypto to its role with cattle: it regulates futures but not spot buying and selling.
“it regulates cattle futures, but it doesn't regulate the buying and selling of cows.”
0:07:25 · Timothy Massad · Spot markets
Jay Clayton said the SEC cracked down on initial coin offerings in 2017 and 2018 during his time as chairman.
“I'm very proud of the crackdown that we did on ICOs, initial coin offerings in 2017, 2018.”
0:13:10 · Guest · ICO crackdown · 2017
Marcel Kasumovich said SEC staff guidance SAB 121 requires digital custodial assets to be held on balance sheet, which keeps banks out of crypto custody.
“The staff guidance 121 basically said digital custodial assets have to be held on balance sheet. That takes banks out of the business.”
0:11:39 · Guest · SAB 121
Marcel Kasumovich said the SEC's custody rule has not been revised to address where digital assets fall within it.
“Custody rule has not been revised to make it clear where digital assets sit inside of the custody rule. That's an SEC provision.”
0:09:35 · Guest · Custody rule
Marcel Kasumovich said the Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC, was driving the post-FTX hearings, rather than Senate Banking, which oversees the SEC.
“Senate agriculture is driving the process. CFTC reports into the agriculture group. SEC reports into Senate banking.”
0:08:35 · Guest · Congressional hearings · 2022
Marcel Kasumovich said Tether is the dollar collateral unit for Asia's crypto system and will not become dominant in the U.S.
“Tether is the dollar unit of collateral for the Asia system and probably going to stay that way. But it will never trade in the U.S.”
0:12:16 · Guest · Tether
Jay Clayton said much of the Dodd-Frank Act required the CFTC and SEC to write rules jointly because their jurisdictions overlap.
“A large swath of Dodd-Frank required joint rulemaking between the CFTC and the SEC because their jurisdictions overlap.”
0:14:21 · Guest · Dodd-Frank
Timothy Massad said he co-wrote a paper with Harvard Professor Hal Jackson proposing a joint self-regulatory organization for crypto.
“I've written a paper with a similar argument with Professor Hal Jackson at Harvard, where we argue this could be done by setting up a joint self-regulatory organization.”
0:17:43 · Timothy Massad · Joint SRO proposal
Timothy Massad cited FINRA and the National Futures Association as examples of self-regulatory organizations supervised by government agencies.
“FINRA is the classic example. The National Futures Association is another.”
0:18:17 · Timothy Massad · Self-regulatory organizations
Timothy Massad said William O. Douglas, as SEC chair before joining the Supreme Court, oversaw the development of self-regulatory organizations.
“William O. Douglas, the former Supreme Court justice, before he was on the Supreme Court, was chair of the SEC. And it was really under his tenure that self-regulatory organizations were developed.”
0:18:17 · Timothy Massad · SRO history
Timothy Massad said swaps rules were set through standards agreed by G20 leaders and then implemented in each nation's laws.
“Over-the-counter swaps were unregulated. We developed some standards that the G20 leaders agreed to. Each nation then went and implemented those standards in its laws.”
0:19:44 · Timothy Massad · Swaps regulation
Marcel Kasumovich said Ethereum and Bitcoin kept operating around the clock during FTX's collapse, settling billions of dollars daily without intermediaries.
“Both operated 24-7 through the downfall in FTX. From a settlements perspective, we're settling billions of dollars of transactions on those rails every day with no intermediation”
0:21:17 · Guest · Blockchain resilience · 2022
Gary Gorton said many supply chains already use blockchain and that it could bypass the inefficient correspondent banking network for international payments.
“Many global supply chains now use blockchain to keep track of things. And the correspondent banking network, which is used for international payments, is extremely inefficient”
0:23:11 · Gary Gorton · Blockchain payments
Gary Gorton said stablecoins are the first privately produced circulating money in 150 years, which he considers a financial stability risk.
“stable coins are the first time in 150 years that we see a privately produced circulating money.”
0:23:42 · Gary Gorton · Stablecoins
Gary Gorton argued for a central bank digital currency, comparing it to government cash replacing private bank notes issued before the U.S. Civil War.
“It's the same as saying we should have government cash and not private bank notes like we did before the Civil war.”
0:24:13 · Gary Gorton · Digital currency