OpenNashPodcasts

In Good Company with Nicolai Tangen

Alphabet President and CIO: Advancing AI, Quantum Computing, and Self-Driving Cars

12 Mar 2025 · 51m · Ruth Porat, Nicolai Tangen · 22 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Ruth Porat, Alphabet's President and Chief Investment Officer, argues that Google is well placed in the AI race because it controls the whole stack: research talent, models, its own chips (TPUs) and products used by billions. She says lasting advantage also needs constant, patient investment and a culture of humility. The conversation covers Gemini, quantum computing, Waymo and healthcare AI.

The central tension is between bold bets and discipline. Porat says Google must invest aggressively for the long run, or it risks becoming a dinosaur. But she also stresses guardrails, accuracy, resilience and data-driven checks on returns. Her lessons from the 2008 financial crisis, Bill Campbell's coaching and her cancer experience shape that view: spot your biggest vulnerability early and don't postpone what matters.

Key insights

  1. Google bets on owning every layer of AI

    Porat says Google's edge comes from combining DeepMind's research, its own TPU chips, and products that already reach billions of people. It still uses NVIDIA GPUs alongside TPUs, so the strategy is control over key layers rather than isolation.

  2. AI's value depends on rethinking whole businesses

    Porat says the large estimated economic gains only arrive if companies and governments redesign how they serve customers and run operations. Simply adding chatbots is not enough. She also says efficiency gains in chips and models are needed so the heavy capital spending earns a return.

  3. Google moved carefully on generative AI because of trust

    Porat says early worry about hallucinations, where AI states false things confidently, mattered because people rely on Google for answers such as a child's medicine dose. That is why the company wanted quality consistent with its brand before pushing models out widely.

  4. Crisis lessons: find your biggest weakness early

    From Treasury work in 2008, Porat says banks needed liquidity secured months before the crash, and AIG failed partly because risk in a derivatives unit was invisible. She applies this at Google by naming innovation and long-term investment as its greatest vulnerability.

  5. AI diagnostics may lift doctors everywhere

    Porat describes a Google breast-cancer detection test that found 20% more cases with no false positives in an 80,000-sample set. She adds that early detection helps only if the rest of treatment is available, and her oncologist called it an assist for any doctor.

Questions

Who does Ruth Porat think will win the AI race?

She doesn't name a winner but says Google is in a strong position because it covers research talent, models, its own chips and widely used products. She also says there is a lot of innovation at other companies too.

Why did Google seem slow to release AI models compared with rivals?

Porat says Google worried about hallucination, meaning AI confidently giving wrong answers. For something like a child's medicine dose there is no room for error, so Google wanted the quality its brand stands for before releasing widely.

What is Google's Willow quantum chip and why does it matter?

Porat says Willow did a calculation in under five minutes that the best supercomputers would need 10 septillion years to do. She says commercial use is still a number of years away, perhaps three to five, but is getting closer.

What is Waymo and how is it doing?

Waymo is Alphabet's self-driving taxi service. Porat says it has about 200,000 paid rides a week and operates in San Francisco, Los Angeles, Phoenix and Austin, with a pilot in Japan. Its original aim was to cut the million-plus road deaths each year.

How does Google decide where to put its money?

Porat says Google must keep investing aggressively for the long run or risk its own destruction. She describes an early rule of 70% core business, 20% adjacent and 10% moonshots, and says Google now builds data centers and subsea cables worldwide and kills weak experiments fast.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Norway's sovereign wealth fund, run by Nicolai Tangen, owns about 1.3% of Alphabet, worth roughly $30 billion according to Tangen.

“And we own 1.3 % of the company, totaling roughly $30 billion.”

0:00:00 · Nicolai Tangen · Fund stake

Ruth Porat said Google's Willow quantum chip can do a computation in under five minutes that the best supercomputers would take 10 septillion years to complete.

“So the Willow chip is able to handle a computation in less than five minutes that previously, on the best supercomputers on the planet today, would take 10 septillion years”

0:11:04 · Ruth Porat · Quantum computing

Ruth Porat said Waymo's original thesis was that AI driving could improve safety, given that more than a million people die on roads every year.

“And the original thesis is that more than a million people die on the road every year in accidents.”

0:13:36 · Ruth Porat · Waymo safety

Ruth Porat said Waymo's driverless taxi service had become one of the top attractions in San Francisco.

“It's now one of the top attractions in San Francisco.”

0:14:03 · Ruth Porat · Waymo rollout

Ruth Porat said Waymo was running a pilot in Japan.

“We're doing a pilot in Japan right now, And there's an opportunity, we think, to help save lives”

0:14:29 · Ruth Porat · Waymo expansion

Ruth Porat said Google's early investment mantra was 70% on its core business, 20% on adjacent areas and 10% on moonshots.

“The early days, there was a kind of a mantra, which is 70 % in your core, 20 % adjacent, 10 % moonshots.”

0:15:45 · Ruth Porat · Capital allocation

Waymo was incubated in X, Alphabet's moonshot factory, before becoming an independent company.

“out of X came, for example, Waymo. It was incubated in X and then got moved out to become an independent company.”

0:17:24 · Ruth Porat · Moonshot factory

Ruth Porat said Google's Trillium TPU chip is about 67% more efficient than the previous generation.

“our Trillium chip, our most recent chip, is about 67 % more efficient than the prior one.”

0:23:11 · Ruth Porat · AI chips

Ruth Porat cited Android as an example of open source being core to Google since its founding.

“So open source has been core to Google, really, since inception. If you think about something like Android, which is such an important operating system globally, it reflects who we are.”

0:08:37 · Ruth Porat · Open source

Ruth Porat said Demis Hassabis and John Jumper were awarded a Nobel Prize in the fall of 2024 for AlphaFold.

“What Demis Asabas and John Jumper awarded the Nobel this past fall, that was for something called AlphaFold,”

0:10:14 · Ruth Porat · Nobel Prize · 2024

Ruth Porat said Google's subsea cable build-out connected Fiji, through nodes on a trunk cable running from Africa to Australia.

“one of the ones I'm really proud of is when we lit up Fiji.”

0:20:41 · Ruth Porat · Subsea cables

Ruth Porat said about a third of the world's population is still not online.

“And what's really important to remember is a third of the globe still is not online, still is not connected.”

0:21:12 · Ruth Porat · Internet access

Ruth Porat said Alphabet's market capitalization was about $400 billion when she joined in 2015.

“So I got here in 2015, the market cap was $400 billion.”

0:32:54 · Ruth Porat · Market cap · 2015

Ruth Porat said Google Lens handles 20 billion camera-based searches a month.

“we now have 20 billion searches a month using your camera with Google Lens.”

0:28:12 · Ruth Porat · Google Lens

Ruth Porat said NotebookLM came out of Google Labs and was named an innovation product of the year.

“It was the time innovation, product innovation of the year last year. And that's an example of something that came out of labs.”

0:24:59 · Ruth Porat · NotebookLM · 2024

Ruth Porat said Google's early breast cancer detection tool found 20% more cases and no false positives in an 80,000-sample test.

“relative to the 80 ,000 sample set, they found 20 % more cases, more incidences of cancer and no false positives.”

0:29:11 · Ruth Porat · Cancer detection

Ruth Porat said she was seconded to the US Treasury in July 2008 to work on the housing crisis involving Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

“And initially, I went down in July of 08 to focus on the housing crisis, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac”

0:37:17 · Ruth Porat · Financial crisis · 2008

Ruth Porat said the AIG crisis started in its UK derivatives subsidiary, not its insurance operation, because the risk was not visible.

“As we now all know, the crisis in AIG really started because of the derivative sub in the UK, not the insurance operation.”

0:38:57 · Ruth Porat · AIG crisis · 2008

Ruth Porat became Morgan Stanley's CFO on January 1, 2010, the day James Gorman became CEO.

“So I started his CFO January 1st, 2010, the day he started as CEO.”

0:42:00 · Ruth Porat · Morgan Stanley · 2010

Ruth Porat described Bill Campbell as a coach who had advised Steve Jobs, Larry Page and Sergey Brin, and who suggested she become Google's CFO.

“1 trillion dollar coach, because he had coached Steve Jobs and Larry and Sergey.”

0:42:00 · Ruth Porat · Bill Campbell · 2015

Ruth Porat said Larry Page and Sergey Brin placed a dinosaur named Stan on Google's campus to remind staff of the need to keep innovating.

“Larry and Sergey put a dinosaur on our campus that's named Stan, to remind us every day that if we don't innovate, we too can become dinosaurs.”

0:40:20 · Ruth Porat · Google culture

Ruth Porat said Minnesota asked Google for help serving residents in four languages, then returned asking for 26 more, with Google Translate covering about 250 languages.

“We said, of course, Google Translate, 250 languages, no problem there.”

0:46:50 · Ruth Porat · Google Translate

Chapters

  1. 0:00:43Google's full-stack case in the AI race

    Porat explains why she thinks Google is well positioned: talent, models, chips and products all under one roof. This frames the rest of the discussion.

    “we have a very differentiated approach, which starts with the extraordinary team”
  2. 0:04:13Why Google moved carefully on generative AI

    Porat explains that Google's reputation for accurate answers made hallucination a serious concern. This is her answer to critics who said Google started slowly.

    “there can be no margin for error”
  3. 0:07:43TPUs and the open-versus-closed debate

    She says Google uses both its own TPU chips and NVIDIA GPUs, and that open source is part of Google's history but needs guardrails.

    “They're a strong partner of ours. So, we use both GPUs and TPUs.”
  4. 0:11:04Willow and the quantum computing timeline

    Porat describes Google's Willow chip and its enormous speed advantage on one test. She is cautious about when quantum computing becomes commercial.

    “would take 10 septillion years, which even I had to Google”
  5. 0:13:36Waymo's safety thesis and rollout

    Porat explains the safety reasoning behind self-driving taxis and where the service operates. She also says it is too early to predict who will own cars in ten years.

    “the AI does not get tired. It does not get distracted.”
  6. 0:15:45Capital allocation, moonshots and global infrastructure

    The discussion covers how Alphabet decides where to invest, and how its X lab produced Waymo and Wing. It also covers subsea cables and resilience.

    “you're sowing the seeds of your own destruction”
  7. 0:27:09Google's culture and the 'why not' mindset

    Porat describes how curiosity, humility and ambitious projects like AlphaFold shape how people at Google work.

    “And his answer was, why not?”
  8. 0:29:11AI in healthcare and Porat's own cancer story

    She links Google's early cancer-detection work to her own experience with breast cancer. She says such tools can raise the level of care doctors give everywhere.

    “they found 20 % more cases, more incidences of cancer and no false positives”
  9. 0:39:29Lessons from the 2008 financial crisis

    Porat draws lessons from her time at the US Treasury and AIG that she now applies at Google, including protecting against your biggest vulnerability.

    “You cannot run a business or a country with mud on the windshield”
  10. 0:49:09Bill Campbell, mentorship and advice for graduates

    She recounts how Bill Campbell steered her to Google and shares career advice from her father's story: keep learning, anchor in data and don't defer life.

    “education is a passport for life. And I firmly believe that.”

Transcript

0:00:00
Nicolai Tangen

Hi everybody, I'm Nicolai Tangen, the CEO of the Norwegian Sovereign Wealth Fund, and today I'm in really good company because I'm here with Ruth Porat, the President and Chief Investment Officer of Alphabet, which is the parent company of Google. Now, of course, Google needs no introduction, but Alphabet, in addition, also makes self-driving cars, AI chips, it owns YouTube, and many more things. And we own 1.3 % of the company, totaling roughly $30 billion. So big welcome, Ruth.

0:00:29
Ruth Porat

It's great to be with you. Thank you.

0:00:39
Nicolai Tangen

Who is going to win the AI race?

0:00:43
Ruth Porat

Well, we feel we're in a really strong position for a number of reasons. I think when you look at the history of Google focused on AI, we started many, many years ago. And at this point, we have a very differentiated approach, which starts with the extraordinary team we have led by Demis Asabas, who obviously just won the Nobel Prize. That goes to the strength of the models. You look at what we're doing on chips with our TPUs.

0:01:15

And then we're already really using it across our various platforms. So billions of people are benefiting from AI. So this full stack approach, we think is an important element. That being said, what's exciting to see is how much innovation there is broadly. And so what we're looking at is the opportunity, I think, collectively, globally, to have an unlock from the upside, given the innovation that we're seeing, not just at Google,

0:01:45
Nicolai Tangen

but at other places. So is it now a matter of who's got the best people or the most money or the best data or the best chips? What is it about? Well, the reason I started with what we're really

0:01:56
Ruth Porat

proud of, our full-stack approach from talent and models to the platforms and chips, is it really is taking this full-stack approach and, I think very importantly, this intense focus on innovation and continuing to push forth. You know, one of the things that really struck me when Demis was awarded the Nobel Prize this last fall, and he was asked, what was it that really started him on this journey? And he said what motivates him is to take on the most intractable, what were thought to be the most intractable problems facing humanity.

0:02:32

And I think that ethos is another really important element of how one continues to drive forth and have the biggest impact with AI.

0:02:43
Nicolai Tangen

Do you think generative AI can be monetized the same way as search is?

0:02:48
Ruth Porat

I think generative AI is continuing to enable us and others to expand kind of the quality of what is being delivered across a wide set of opportunities. So just to give you two examples, I'm often asked, where are we investing extensively? And probably not surprisingly, and you know this well, given how close you are to all that we've been doing. but search remains so core to who we are and we've evolved search meaningfully over the years and we're continuing to apply generative AI to what is that experience that one has when you search and what we're finding is that it opens the the types of queries that are being explored it goes for a deeper richer engagement so that's one

0:03:39

area the other area that's really important is what we're seeing on the enterprise side and the ability to help companies and the public sector transform the businesses and their approach, whether it's engaging with customers or on the efficiency side or on risk analytics or with constituents. Each of those provides opportunity for monetization.

0:04:00
Nicolai Tangen

Some of your competitors say that you were a bit slow out of the box when it came to AI models, but your latest, Gemini, it's phenomenal. So what happened here?

0:04:13
Ruth Porat

Well, Google's search for decades has really stood for extraordinary quality. It's what everybody around the globe expects of us. When you go to Google, quality answer very rapidly surfaced for you in the most potent way. And one of the very important questions for us, Sundar's talked about this, In the early days of generative AI, internally, we were all talking about the risk of hallucination. And that term now is very well known quite broadly. And one of the concerns is if you, in the middle of the night, wake up, your child is sick, you want to figure out how much Tylenol to give to a three-year-old, there can be no margin for error.

0:04:59

That's what our brand stands for. And so it was very important to us to make sure that as we were evolving and applying generative AI, we did it in a way that was consistent with the quality that's expected appropriately from Google. And I appreciate your question because what you've seen is the really ongoing momentum in models and introducing models more broadly externally. What we've done with, for example, AI overviews where when you search, you'll get this kind of an AI cockpit is the way I like to think about it.

0:05:32

You're seeing more in things like model advancement that can be applied in other applications. And so we're excited about the momentum that people have seen through 2024 and what is ahead in 2025.

0:05:47
Nicolai Tangen

Talking of which, you call the latest model for the agentic area. What does that mean? What do you put in that?

0:05:56
Ruth Porat

So that's one area that Sundar and Demis and the team are really excited about, which is how can AI actually be an agent working on our behalf? How can it help you do some of the administrative tasks that are going to make your life easier and actually free you up to do something else, book a reservation for you, research something for you? How can it even be applied, for example, in science to do some of the basic inquiries?

0:06:23

So set it out to do something to work on your behalf.

0:06:27
Nicolai Tangen

So three years from now, what does your day look like? How is it changing your life?

0:06:32
Ruth Porat

You know, it's a great question. As it relates broadly to AI, I think one of the most important things for all of us is that AI can really be an assist. It can be operating leverage for every one of us. When I started my career on Wall Street, how was it as you were moving from big computers to laptops to phone, this becomes operating leverage if appropriately applied. And so what one scientist once said to me that they view this as augmented intelligence, not artificial intelligence, in which that had been the word that was used.

0:07:10

That's what it is for each one of us. And I think what's really important is to understand that, in fact, it's not that we will be replaced by AI in our roles, but we can be replaced by someone who's using AI, who's getting that operating leverage if we're not. And so it's so important for people to just start experimenting, just start playing so that you're

0:07:30
Nicolai Tangen

on that learning journey. Now, you make your own AI chips, the TPUs. Why? Could you explain just how they are different from other chips and why you do this? Well, we work very closely with

0:07:43
Ruth Porat

NVIDIA. They're a strong partner of ours. So, we use both GPUs and TPUs. And many years ago, the team started on this journey of developing our own chips, TPUs, to address some of the specific requirements that we felt we needed. And what we found is that we continue to have the type of performance that we're looking for, in particular in training. And as we've advanced the TPUs, what we're seeing is we're continuing to drive greater efficiency in all elements of energy requirements with TPUs.

0:08:15

So there's a cost benefit for us and an impact benefit. And so we're using both in the fleet.

0:08:21
Nicolai Tangen

Talking about various versions of things. So now we've had DeepSeek being launched, which is an open source model. Now, just how do you look at open versus closed source models now?

0:08:37
Ruth Porat

So open source has been core to Google, really, since inception. If you think about something like Android, which is such an important operating system globally, it reflects who we are. When you think about the transformer paper, which has been so critical for anybody who's thinking about how do you build in this AI world? Like what's the next step, the next iteration? So open source has been important to us. At the same time, this is a really powerful technology.

0:09:09

And so what we're looking at is how does one maximize upside but have the appropriate guardrails and controls over certain elements of it too? ensure that you're protecting how it's used and where it's used. And getting that balance right

0:09:25
Nicolai Tangen

will continue to be very important for all of us. What are you personally most excited about in terms of usage? I mean, you talked about medicine, alpha fold, and so on. You personally,

0:09:40
Ruth Porat

what do you feel more strongly about? So when we look at AI, I think there are four primary areas that are really exciting. First is the economic upside. Globally, the estimates are there can be $20 1 trillion added to GDP in the next decade, again, if appropriately executed, if adopted across industry. When you think about the benefit to society, if in fact we have anything close to that economic uplift, I get excited about it. It's not to be taken for granted.

0:10:14

As I said, it requires what economists call diffusion across industry, adoption, a radical rethink of many elements of the way the public sector and the private sector works. Excited about that. Very excited about the breakthroughs in science. What Demis Asabas and John Jumper awarded the Nobel this past fall, that was for something called AlphaFold, which you're familiar with, which has been described as the greatest contribution to drug discovery. That is exciting. Then just even sitting here today, the practical applications of AI in healthcare, in education are really exciting.

0:10:50

So I would put those at the top of the list.

0:10:52
Nicolai Tangen

Talking about something slightly different, you, before the holiday season, sent shocks waves through the world with your Willow quantum chip. So why is that such a leap forward?

0:11:04
Ruth Porat

So we've been working on quantum AI, quantum computing, for quite some time, well over, I think, a decade at this point. And what's really exciting is the computational capabilities with quantum. So the Willow chip is able to handle a computation in less than five minutes that previously, on the best supercomputers on the planet today, would take 10 septillion years, which even I had to Google, it's 24 zeros on the back of it. So what that means in terms of the ability to see and analyze more, whether it's in biology or other areas, is exciting and profound.

0:11:45

And so we see this as another path that we will continue to execute against.

0:11:51
Nicolai Tangen

How do you view Microsoft's version of it?

0:11:57
Ruth Porat

We're really proud of our own. We think that what you've seen time and time again is the breakthroughs from that team, led by an extraordinary leader, Hartman Nevin, published in all sorts of different places. And we just continue to build success to success with the Willow Chip being the most recent.

0:12:16
Nicolai Tangen

When do you think this will be commercial?

0:12:18
Ruth Porat

Yeah, it's a great question. Not surprisingly, I ask that question all the time as well and have been for some time. You know, I think there's still a number of years ahead. It's starting to point to different applications that we're excited about, but whether we're three years, five years, you know, hard to say. But it's getting closer since I started asking that question.

0:12:39
Nicolai Tangen

And when you talk about these kind of 24 zeros and so on, just what are the implications for this? What are the kind of things we can do when we have that kind of compute power?

0:12:51
Ruth Porat

Well, when you think about it, take something like the human body and the complexity of the human body or anything in nature that's multidimensional. The ability to actually crunch data more efficiently to have better insights is one area that's very exciting for us to think about and the possibilities that come from that.

0:13:15
Nicolai Tangen

Another thing is where you are strong. It's a self-driving taxi company. Now, I'm not sure what the latest number is in terms of rides per week. Where are you now?

0:13:26
Ruth Porat

200 ,000 rides, paid rides.

0:13:28
Nicolai Tangen

Wow. So what will the city look like in five years time or 10 years time? When do you think it will be properly rolled out?

0:13:36
Ruth Porat

Well, I think if I just step back and talk a bit about Waymo, because we are very excited about it. We started on that journey more than a decade ago as well. And the original thesis is that more than a million people die on the road every year in accidents. And if AI can help improve the safety of driving, because our Waymo self-driver, the AI does not get tired. It does not get distracted. It stays focused on the road.

0:14:03

You've got camera sensors everywhere. We can improve safety. We can help save lives. And that was a really exciting motivator for the team. We've been rolling it out. It's been extraordinary to see the take-up. It's now one of the top attractions in San Francisco. if anyone's out this way, but we're also in LA and Phoenix and Austin and expanding. And we're going to continue to expand because you see both the reaction to it when people get in.

0:14:29

Some people are anxious about it at first, and then within literally under a minute, they just go right into whatever it is they wanted to be doing. There's a safety element around it. So we think it'll continue to be rolled out. We're doing a pilot in Japan right now, And there's an opportunity, we think, to help save lives and are excited about doing that.

0:14:50
Nicolai Tangen

So 10 years from now, who is going to own a car?

0:14:53
Ruth Porat

You know, I think it's too early to call. You know, a couple of reasons. One, many people in particular in the States, other developed markets own more than one car. There are good reasons to own a car. And so we'll see human nature and human behavior changes over time. The other is that Waymo is primarily now focused on what are these robo-taxis, as you described it. But it's reasonable to assume that this capability, this extraordinary technology, can also be an assist with cars that are owned.

0:15:25

And so there are a lot of execution paths which enable you, me, others to decide how they actually want to get around.

0:15:31
Nicolai Tangen

Now, you're also the chief investment officer, and you are in a very fortunate position in that you are sitting on roughly $100 billion. And you have all these interesting areas. Just how do you allocate capital between them?

0:15:45
Ruth Porat

So capital allocation, like I think one of the core elements in capital allocation is that you need to ensure that you're continuing to invest aggressively for the long run. If you don't invest for the long run, you're sowing the seeds of your own destruction. And that's a lesson I've seen throughout my career over and over. And so very important. It's been core to the ethos, obviously, of this company since inception. The early days, there was a kind of a mantra, which is 70 % in your core, 20 % adjacent, 10 % moonshots.

0:16:18

And that's evolved over time. But this core sense of you've got to continue to invest aggressively for the long run remains core to who we are. And we're at such an exciting time in history, given the opportunity with AI, both on the consumer side, on the enterprise side. So we're certainly making investments there. I end up spending a lot of my time globally because what is really key is every head of state is saying the same type of thing, which is I want to be a part of this digital transformation.

0:16:48

It is key for all the reasons that we've already talked about. And so what we spend time looking at is as we're continuing to invest in our technical infrastructure globally, in other words, data centers, subsea cables, how do we link up the world? The opportunity is how do we engage more deeply? What work are we doing on their behalf to help accelerate their digital transformation? How do we engage on the public side? And so there's a really global view to this.

0:17:18
Nicolai Tangen

Now, you have this moonshot factory in-house. What are the type of things you're working on there?

0:17:24
Ruth Porat

So the Moonshot Factory, as it was lovingly named years ago, is one of the core areas within other bets. It's called X. And out of X came, for example, Waymo. It was incubated in X and then got moved out to become an independent company. They've also worked on, for example, Wing or Incubated Wing, which is our drone business. Excited about Wing. They're doing work, as an example, with Walmart, and we're seeing really exciting results there and see the upside.

0:17:59

They're also, they've been incubating, and you'll hear more about a company called Intrinsic, which is a robotics operating system. And so they have a number of different things that they've been working on. I think one of the very important elements there is that when they are approaching any incubation, their mindset is, obviously, you can't incubate everything and have it work well. And so, kill things fast in order to move into the areas that are the most promising.

0:18:28
Nicolai Tangen

That sounds really fun. I think it was Charlie Munger who said that Google appeared like a very rich kindergarten.

0:18:35
Ruth Porat

well so we've got everything from kindergarten all the way through to postgraduate robotics

0:18:42
Nicolai Tangen

um now you mentioned um subsea cables the fact that you also do subsea cables and so on does it make you more resilient you think as a tech company i think there are a lot of elements that

0:18:54
Ruth Porat

build resilience and one of the area one of the important areas is continuing to invest in subsea cables, but it's also what we call technical infrastructure more broadly. So it's data center resilience, data center redundancy, so that you can actually be positioned to serve customers when and where needed. And in the event of something that happens and things, unfortunately, always seem to happen around the world, you've got the resilience needed to continue to operate at a high level.

0:19:23

It's our cybersecurity defenses. One of the things I've learned in my career is it is much easier to prevent than to fix a problem. And so building in this strength up front is key. And it's technical infrastructure. I'm happy to talk more about cables because really proud of the network we have globally. But it's the other elements like a zero trust approach on cybersecurity so that you're fortifying defenses in a world that is continuing to become ever more challenging.

0:19:49

And I think that's one of the key additional applications of AI that's important.

0:19:53
Nicolai Tangen

And how do you look at these additional challenges? I mean, we are seeing attacks on subsea cables. We are seeing, of course, accelerating cyber attacks. How do you assess the state of the world?

0:20:07
Ruth Porat

It's better to remain paranoid, which we do, and build in resilience, as you said. And so, when we're looking at our subsea cable network, we do build in resilience to have alternate approaches. We're building globally. We've been building now in the Southern Hemisphere as well. When we build cables, as an example, one of the things that has multiple benefits is we will build what I will call a trunk from, say, Africa to Australia. And then we will have it in chunks with nodes along the way.

0:20:41

That builds in a resilience for the cable itself, but it also provides something else that we're really proud of. It provides the ability, off of a node to light up island nations along the way. Oftentimes working with governments that say we want to help light up a nation, which maybe Google otherwise wouldn't. So as an example, one of the ones I'm really proud of is when we lit up Fiji. And I was talking about this at the Asia Pacific Economic Conference, and we had the prime minister of Fiji happen to be in the room.

0:21:12

I said, we lit up Fiji. And his comment was, it was a gift to everyone in Fiji because what that does is link them to all the opportunities that come otherwise from having access. And what's really important to remember is a third of the globe still is not online, still is not connected. So this gives us that added ability to provide something that, as he described, is an economic opportunity for Fiji for generations to come.

0:21:44
Nicolai Tangen

With all these tech companies chasing the opportunities here, do you think tech companies are now accepting lower returns for their investments?

0:21:53
Ruth Porat

I think that at this point, what we're all looking at is this theoretical economic upside, which, assuming it materializes, creates the opportunity for attractive returns. And I think there's a self-calibrating element to the pace of investment that comes from that thesis. Now, when I said $20 1 trillion theoretical economic upside globally, it's $4 1 trillion in the U.S. alone, what does it require to get that? It's not applying using chatbots. It's actually radically rethinking every element of your business.

0:22:30

It's how do you interact with customers to drive more revenue. It's what are operating efficiencies in the business. It's what are risk analytics, thinking front to back on your operating processes, because this gives you an opportunity to approach them differently. That's what leads to the economic upside, which then drives the returns. And so I think that we've each got to make sure that we're calibrating as we go regarding the upside. And then the other part to your question about returns that we're very focused on and others are as well, is how do you increase the efficiency of that denominator, all the capex that it's being invested?

0:23:11

And so we're approaching that in a number of ways. Sundar's talked about it. the meaningful improvements in model efficiency. The meaningful improvements you've already asked about in TPUs, our Trillium chip, our most recent chip, is about 67 % more efficient than the prior one. So we're continuing to drive efficiency in the CapEx utilization while also trying to help unlock really that monetization upside.

0:23:39
Nicolai Tangen

Now, related to this is the corporate culture and how you structure innovation. Is there a particular way that you structure innovation at Google?

0:23:49
Ruth Porat

It's been such a core part of who we are. It's, I think, the driver of everything that we do. And there are elements of it that are about how we bring in talents and apply them to explore different avenues. We have an extraordinary research team, as an example. Everything that's being done in Google DeepMind, the Demis is leading. And then on top of that, we have efforts, I think more to your question, For example, in the early days of Google, there was something called Google Labs, small scrappy teams and told go find something.

0:24:21

And Sundar reconstituted that a couple of years ago. And you've seen already a number of really exciting things come out of a small scrappy focused empowered team. So, for example, hopefully you and others listening have used Notebook LM. It's one of my favorite. it's the opportunity to take your own your content speeches you're interested in anything you're interested in ingest it into notebook lm it can give you some of the information that you need but you can also listen to it as an ai podcast that can make things sort of more accessible maybe within an enterprise or i've talked to some people in the public sector and their wow moment was wow you mean i can take all these things

0:24:59

that we publish that people probably don't read and make it easier for them to ingest the information? The answer is yes. It was the time innovation, product innovation of the year last year. And that's an example of something that came out of labs. So we're continuing to add on in a lot of different ways to make sure we're

0:25:17
Nicolai Tangen

inspiring people to dream big and think big. But if I walk around at Google and let's say now you took down all the Google signs. I mean, you've got a Google sign behind you, right? You take away all the G's, all the Google signs. Just how would I know that I was in Google? How do you relate to each other in a different way? Do you talk to each other in a different way? Do you behave in a different way compared to the other tech companies?

0:25:40
Ruth Porat

I have so many different ways to answer that. When I first got here, I saw how different it was in the way we worked and granted. I was coming from a financial institution, not another tech company. But it's literally embedded in the technology that we use. So it just starts right from square one with Google Docs, collaborative docs, every way we're constantly interacting. And it just adds a velocity to the work that you do. Right across the street from me here, we have a wonderful building that we put up recently that is where our AI team, GDM, is operating.

0:26:16

You just see people constantly coming together in ways that are exactly what the founders talked about at inception. It's about serendipity and the joy that comes from that. But then it is in the mindset that goes through our people ops and our workplace services teams to have serendipity in a lot of places so that people do congregate and exchange ideas. I think the core point is it's the ethos. When the people come in, there's a high bar that's set.

0:26:41

We want to make the maximum difference to humanity. That's what we talk about a lot. It's, you know, I'll give you one more Demis story. when he was embarking on AlphaFold and the concept of predicting the protein structure for every protein known to humanity. And previously, it would take a year or two just to do one. He wanted to do all 200 million. It was one of the grand challenges that had been out there for a long time.

0:27:09

And some scientists said, how could this be possible? And his answer was, why not? and that ethos that why not is a large part of how i answer your question and you hear it in meetings it's like why not take it on so that to me is the explainer

0:27:32
Nicolai Tangen

so um tell me about a time recently when you learned something about a project and you just I thought, wow, this is just like way cool. Or does it happen all the time?

0:27:43
Ruth Porat

It does, frankly. That's why I'm like, where do I go? You know, when I saw Notebook.lm, I'm like, wow, this is really amazing. The ability and starting to think about what are all the applications. I remember calling the guy who runs Google Labs, who's extraordinary, and I said, if I'm running a government, can I ingest reports from across agencies and see where there are inconsistencies? And he's like, why not? Yes. Going back to the why not point.

0:28:12

So that's really exciting. You know, a little further back, this was years ago, actually, but we now have 20 billion searches a month using your camera with Google Lens. If I want your shirt, you know, I can take a photo of it and then I can find where to buy it and priced and everything else. Or I can I do with other things like art. Who's that artist? I still get an oh, wow moment from that.

0:28:37

I ride Waymos all the time in San Francisco. And I always tell people when I'm in the car, watch the left turn because the left turn, that's pretty cool and gives you a sense of what the engineers have accomplished. So I think the awe of what the team continues to do is there constantly. And then there are the human moments. I am completely in awe of what we're able to do with healthcare. And, yeah.

0:29:09
Nicolai Tangen

Because you had breast cancer, right?

0:29:11
Ruth Porat

Exactly. I've had breast cancer twice, actually. And Google, the amazing engineers identified the opportunity to diagnose early stage metastatic breast cancer. And what's extraordinary is in the testing of it, they found that relative to the 80 ,000 sample set, they found 20 % more cases, more incidences of cancer and no false positives. And as we all know, the difference between survival or not, or a really difficult course of treatment at stage four versus two is really meaningful.

0:29:57

And so the ability, I still have a wow moment with that, that we with AI and with breakthroughs like that can give people the opportunity for the early diagnosis that's needed. And what's really important in discussing this with my oncologist, he said, what it does is it enables any doctor anywhere across the U.S. around the globe to be operating at the highest level because they have this assist, this augmented intelligence. To me, that becomes an extraordinary wow moment when you think about what we can do.

0:30:35

And we're doing it not just in breast cancer. There's early diagnosis in lung cancer, in something called diabetic retinopathy, which is blindness from diabetes. And in that instance, early detection leads to early intervention that's manageable around the globe. Many places, early detection isn't a panacea. It's not an answer. It's an assist, but then you need the rest of the treatment as well. So there are a lot of wow moments that come. And I think it goes back to the importance of each of us asking how can we apply it.

0:31:08
Nicolai Tangen

Well, thanks for sharing that. Now, how has the culture evolved during your time at Google?

0:31:16
Ruth Porat

You know, when I got here, I think one of the first questions I asked, because I've always believed that culture is more important than rules, regulations coming from a regulated financial services environment. It's such an important explainer. And so that's where I spent some of my early time asking people, so how do you define the culture? And I do think it comes back to inquisitive people who believe that with technology, we can have a positive impact on humanity.

0:31:43

It's not a panacea, but we're technology optimists. We often use that phrase. And it goes back to Demis' comment, I want to take on the most intractable problems in society. That's very much the ethos of the founders of what Sundar has been pushing. And it's what I've seen throughout. And I think it's what is inspiring for a lot of what we've done. And I've seen the application of it. So when I got here as a former banker, I was very excited to look under the hood and see, so what really are the numbers?

0:32:16

The mantra, as you may recall, back in 2015 when I arrived was the desktop is dead. can Google actually make the transition to mobile and who knows about YouTube? And it was sort of, we'd been sort of sliding for a bit. And obviously history has shown the application of solutions on mobile. It's been a pretty wonderful decade. And it's that intense focus on innovation and providing better ways for advertisers, for people around the globe to use mobile, get what they want, access how and where.

0:32:54

It's this innovation cycle that we've continued to see. And so I got here in 2015, the market cap was $400 billion. It's now north of $2 1 trillion. And I think to that questioning back then, and yet the whole series of innovation that we've seen since then, and that is the evolution. And it's been this recurring, let's keep pushing it. And there's another really important element, and I think it's two sides of the same coin, which is there's an incredible humility here, a sense every year that this is the last great year.

0:33:26

And that started the moment I got here. And I remember as I was listening to this story, it's like, well, there are all these headwinds. There are always headwinds. And so that humility, I think, inspires people to push higher for themselves and their team and try and figure out what else can we do. And that's been an ethos. I think search for innovation coupled with humility.

0:33:47
Nicolai Tangen

How do you install humility in our organization?

0:33:53
Ruth Porat

it starts from the tone from the top. I mean, if you look at Sundar as a leader, he brings this integrity and ethos about him. And that's the expectation, I think, for the entire team. We are privileged to be at this moment in history with the opportunity set that we've talked about. And we better approach it responsibly and boldly to have the right to continue to execute in the way that we are, I think it's got to come to the top.

0:34:26
Nicolai Tangen

Very interesting. Do you think it makes a difference that the founders are still around?

0:34:30
Ruth Porat

Well, I think it's been, you know, Sergey in particular, a couple of years ago, as the team was pushing forth on Gemini, was very engaged and back in sitting with them. And he made a comment that this is the most exciting time in computer science, that we had only just scratched the surface previously. And when you think Google's done pretty well, like when he first said that to me, I got chills because I think about how much has been accomplished by Google.

0:35:06

But that level of excitement and the magic of what's to come has to be infectious for everyone. And so it's been, yeah, it's been a joy.

0:35:17
Nicolai Tangen

I just saw him in an interview saying that 60-hour work during the week is perfect. That's where you have your optimal production and innovation and creativity.

0:35:30
Ruth Porat

So he's, yes, he's certainly motivated. And as I said, he's viewing this as the most exciting time in computer science. I think that when you look at that building over there that I described with the Google DeepMind team and the effort everyone's focused in, people are working because they're getting a real charge out of what they're doing. And you don't need to tell you or me how many hours to work. There's a joy that comes from it.

0:35:57

At Google, we're still of the view that the way we get the best outcome is we want people in three days or more a week and teams can figure out what works best for them to get maximum kind of maximum productivity progress. Who do you hire? Really smart people. And? It remains a rigorous process. The number of applicants remains daunting. I think that depending on the area, you know, there's, there's a mix of, you know, what I would say, what I will look for is a mix of those people who come with what I will call pattern recognition, the experience that gives you a sense that predicting what's going to come from here or very specific domain expertise, but then

0:36:48

evidence, high performance and creativity, pushing themselves, achieving, achieving remarkable things along the way.

0:37:01
Nicolai Tangen

talking of which Ruth you've uh achieved remarkable things uh and you worked in Morgan Stanley before you before you joined Google uh and you were there during the financial crisis and uh did a did an incredible job what did you what did you learn from the financial crisis because

0:37:17
Ruth Porat

you were really involved at the very top yeah I learned I learned a lot at the time I was running the financial institutions group, which meant responsible for banks, insurance companies, asset management. I was on the investment banking side. And one of the most privileged times in my career is when Secretary Hank Paulson, Secretary of the Treasury, called and said he wanted a team to come basically be seconded down at U.S. Treasury. And initially, I went down in July of 08 to focus on the housing crisis, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and to try and understand and diagnose what could be a trigger for what we would call a run on the bank, run on agencies.

0:38:00

So we went through Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac with him. And then I led the group that went through the AIG crisis as well, and then onward. And there were a lot of really important lessons that came out of it. And when I got to Google, I was asked about them, which struck me is a bit odd because Google had only seen sunny days. And I think really importantly, the lessons are good for good times and bad.

0:38:22

And I've already said it, it is easier to fortify oneself ahead of an issue to prevent than to deal with it in the moment. The most important lesson from the crisis is to identify your greatest source of vulnerability ahead of time and protect against it. So for financial institutions, that would be liquidity. Without liquidity, nothing, you couldn't operate. And in that moment, in that September, October 2008 moment, you couldn't procure liquidity, durable liquidity, if you tried.

0:38:57

And we did. And you couldn't. But six months prior, you could have. And I think a really important lesson for everyone is to do that question. What is your greatest source of vulnerability? You can protect against it early on, but not in the moment. The second really came out of AIG. As we now all know, the crisis in AIG really started because of the derivative sub in the UK, not the insurance operation. And the problem was there wasn't visibility about the risk that was being taken on by the derivative sub.

0:39:29

And so the metaphor that I've used since then is you would not drive a car with mud on the windshield. You cannot run a business or a country with mud on the windshield, use data and analytics to clear away that mud, and then you can actually go faster because you're taking calculated risks. You're taking smart risks. And I think the other really important lesson was that there are no good choices in a crisis. And so go for the least worst and just keep moving because standing still can actually just amplify magnify and you're not going to end up with a good solution in any event by definition you're in a crisis say actually the last one is make sure you

0:40:12

have a team with horizontal vision because you got to connect the dots across a lot

0:40:15
Nicolai Tangen

of different issues it's a lot of wisdom here now how do you protect google against future

0:40:20
Ruth Porat

vulnerability so i asked myself that i then said okay i need to apply those same rules here i think the greatest source of vulnerability for us, and frankly, really across industries, is around innovation and long-term investing. And notably, when you come to campus, you will see that Larry and Sergey put a dinosaur on our campus that's named Stan, to remind us every day that if we don't innovate, we too can become dinosaurs. And I think it's really important to maintain efforts like what Sundar did with labs, Google Labs, other things that are continual catalysts to continue to really spur small teams to think big and also from a capital allocation perspective to make sure you're investing for long-term

0:41:15

growth.

0:41:19
Nicolai Tangen

talking a bit about the personal growth you worked with what is called the 1 trillion dollar coach bill campbell who has uh well worked with a lot of incredibly successful people but how did you how did you end up working with him just what did you learn from him

0:41:35
Ruth Porat

so when i was at morgan stanley i've always had this view in life that i should ask what's my highest and best use and keep learning. And I loved being CFO with James Gorman. He was an absolutely extraordinary CEO. I joined him as his CFO the day he began as CEO.

0:41:55
Nicolai Tangen

We've had him on the podcast and I fully agree. Extraordinary person.

0:42:00
Ruth Porat

So I started his CFO January 1st, 2010, the day he started as CEO. But after about five years, I thought, you know, I feel like I'm plateauing here and I'm wondering what my next chapter is. And as you said, Bill Campbell is one of the most extraordinary people that anyone could meet, 1 trillion dollar coach, because he had coached Steve Jobs and Larry and Sergey. And I sat down with him and said, I don't know what my next chapter should be.

0:42:29

And I'd love to get your thinking about it. I was out at a Stanford board meeting where I'd served for years and so got together at his house. And we spent a couple hours together. and he started by saying, so the one thing you know is you won't leave Morgan Stanley as CFO to be CFO anywhere else. And I'm like, that's the only thing I know, but what's the next chapter? And at the end of the two hours, he said, I have the perfect role for you, CFO of Google.

0:42:53

We both sort of laughed because I had been so adamant the one thing I wouldn't do was be CFO again. I'm like, if it's Google, of course. I had run tech banking at Morgan Stanley, involved with the Google IPO, loved Google for years. And so that's how I ended up here. And then he was always an advisor who was here on campus and just the wise voice who was blunt and clear. And when something didn't make sense, he was famous for saying, kind of throwing the flag on the field and just truly brought out the best in everyone, told each of us, make sure you always have that human connection and then go into the business item.

0:43:36

He tragically passed away with cancer shortly after I arrived, but it is a gift that keeps giving.

0:43:46
Nicolai Tangen

Do you mentor people? What's the key to good mentorship?

0:43:52
Ruth Porat

Well, I think when you asked that question, I immediately thought of one of the most important discussions I had with someone who ended up becoming, whether you call them a mentor or sponsor, a key person in my career. And it was back in 1996. And I was asked to lead technology equity capital markets, the part within a bank that's between banking and sales and trading that really launches IPOs. And this was right at the beginning of the whole internet run of IPOs.

0:44:28

There were not very many women on the trading floor. And the guy who ran institutional equities called me into his office and he said, I think you're going to soar, but if you stumble, I'm here. I will backstop you. I am your senior air cover. And what really struck me is that we all need senior air cover and we all need to be senior air cover for someone. And what he was saying is, I know you're going to run far and you're going to run hard.

0:45:00

But I'm here if there's ever an issue, if you need me for something. And so for me, people who work hard for me, and I see this is a star who needs to be sort of unleashed to run, to soar. I try and give them the advice that I think has served me best throughout my career, and it's about continuing to learn and have that senior air cover and really apply data and analysis to everything you do.

0:45:28

And I just keep coming back to those rules in particular. I think it's so important we each have senior air cover and are senior air cover.

0:45:36
Nicolai Tangen

Did you have a need air cover?

0:45:40
Ruth Porat

You know, I've reflected on, did I actually run into issues? There were small ones. There wasn't a crisis moment where I needed to go to him. But the insurance policy of knowing he was there and the message that he said, I know you'll soar, but I'm here to backstop you in case there's an issue, is actually a real catalyst. It's empowering.

0:46:06
Nicolai Tangen

You mentioned the need and wish to continue to learn. What are you most exciting about learning now?

0:46:15
Ruth Porat

Well, there's so much. When I talk about AI in this moment and the conversations I'm having globally about the economic unlock, the real question is, what does it mean to radically rethink your business or radically rethink the way you run the public sector? I've had quite a number at this point of public sector leaders, finance ministers who said, I'm not going to get more budget. How do I get more out of my budget? And really trying to drill into what can we do that makes a difference?

0:46:50

How can we be specific? So for example, one of my favorite, in the state of Minnesota, they wanted to do a better job delivering services to their constituents. And they came to us and said, can you help us in four of our critical, we have four critical languages in Minnesota. We said, of course, Google Translate, 250 languages, no problem there. We're going to help you rethink how you engage. Within six months, they came back and they said, actually, we need another 26 languages.

0:47:19

Now that Minnesota experience for me can be repeated over and over around the globe. How do you interact better with customers, constituents? But there's more to it about Efficiency Unlocked. I think we're at this very early stage of something that's huge and possible and excited to make sure that I understand how does it actually work and what are the implications. How do you relax? I love what I do. So that's a source of relaxation. And then beyond that, you know, there's the biggest joy is family and kids.

0:47:57

I'm taking hikes with my kids. I've got a book club with my kids, comparing notes on books. I had dinner with one of my kids last night. It's everything that we can do together. Travel, explore new places, and I work out.

0:48:15
Nicolai Tangen

Last question. So we both went to Wharton, and if you were giving the commencement speech, which I'm actually doing in May, what would you be telling the graduate students?

0:48:30
Ruth Porat

you know i actually did do that a number of years ago and

0:48:36
Nicolai Tangen

but what would you tell them now i mean have you changed your mind

0:48:39
Ruth Porat

probably not because i think the core principles for me never stop learning my father was a holocaust refugee he had no high school or college education he ended up enlisting in the british army he fought in the two battles of el alimán and he taught himself engineering and physics because he knew or he assumed that if he survived, he wanted to get to a place that was safe and he needed a skill that people would value.

0:49:09

And he thought engineering and physics would be that skill. And as a child, he always told me that his fellow soldiers would tease him and say, you're going to be dead before you can ever use this. And he would say, I'd rather die an educated man. And then the lesson for me as a child, my siblings, was education is a passport for life. And I firmly believe that. And I think that one of the most important things is never stop learning.

0:49:36

So that's why I said when I found myself plateau in my career, I would go to somebody I respected and say, what is my highest and best use? And I was open to change and continuing to grow. I think that's one really important one. The other is anchor everything in data. At Wharton, you clearly get great analytical skills, a lot of other places as well. You can argue with me and my approach to something, but you can't argue with data.

0:50:02

And I always say, don't give me flat data. Put it into a sensitivity analysis so that we can debate your assumptions about the state of the world. Growth rates, how much do I need to invest? Let me engage you with the data. And that could be the basis for the argument. And then the other thing I believe I told them, and I believe it as firmly today as I did then, is embrace life as it comes.

0:50:25

Don't defer to a later time, something which you can do now, because as I saw with cancer, you don't know if you're going to have that later time. Unfortunately, that was 20 years ago and I'm fine, but in the moment I didn't know, but I was grateful. My bucket list wasn't very long. I had done what I wanted. I've been married to the same guy for many, many decades, have three amazing kids, professional career I wanted.

0:50:49

Don't put it off because life doesn't actually stick to your predefined schedule.

0:50:57
Nicolai Tangen

Well, Ruth, that's a really motivational and beautiful place to end this podcast. Big thanks for being with us and thanks for sharing all your thoughts and backgrounds. Thank you so much.

0:51:09
Ruth Porat

Thank you. It is always wonderful being with you. Thank you for having me. you