OpenNashPodcasts

In Good Company with Nicolai Tangen

Larry Fink CEO of BlackRock

11 Jan 2023 · 37m · Larry Fink, Nicolai Tangen · 24 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Larry Fink, CEO of BlackRock, argues that a giant asset manager should act as a fiduciary (someone legally bound to put clients' interests first), not push personal views. He says the right tools are dialogue, long-term thinking and engagement with companies rather than divesting from energy, plus giving clients the vote on their shares.

The central tension is between BlackRock's huge influence and Fink's insistence that it is only managing other people's money. He defends stakeholder capitalism, passive investing and ESG as long-term profit strategies. He also stresses culture, listening to clients and constant learning, drawing on the 1986 trading loss that shaped BlackRock's risk focus.}

Key insights

  1. Fink says divesting from energy changes nothing

    He describes an energy CEO who had to sell refineries in an emerging country, where the president begged him not to because a private buyer would damage the region more. Fink concludes that divestiture just moves assets from public to private hands.

  2. BlackRock's risk focus came from a 1986 loss

    Tangen notes Fink's First Boston team lost $100 million in 1986. Fink says the team should have been fired the quarter before, when it made $140 million while taking too much risk, and that this experience underpins BlackRock's risk management system.

  3. Voting Choice aims to return votes to asset owners

    BlackRock built technology letting asset owners vote their own shares, and wants to extend it to retail investors. Fink argues that democratizing votes would largely answer concerns about index funds holding concentrated ownership.

  4. Fink believes tokenization could identify every beneficial owner

    He says that if bonds and stocks were recorded on a DeFi (decentralized finance) ledger, everyone would know who the beneficial owner is. Each owner, from a small investor to a sovereign fund, could then vote directly.

  5. Fink says remote work erodes firm culture

    He says working from home worked well in the first year of COVID but later degraded firms. Young people cannot learn across different parts of the business, and the most important conversations happen unplanned in hallways.

Questions

Why does Larry Fink say BlackRock shouldn't be seen as having personal influence over markets?

Fink says the money BlackRock manages belongs to clients, not the firm, so its job as a fiduciary is to help clients build strategies rather than impose his opinions. He says BlackRock's role is to raise issues and start conversations.

What is Fink's argument against divesting from fossil fuel companies?

He says selling shares does not change the world, because the assets just move from public to private owners who may behave worse. He also says investors who divested from energy stocks over the last two years underperformed.

What is the annual BlackRock CEO letter and why did it start?

Fink says it began in 2012 so BlackRock, as a major index investor, could tell companies what it expects. Early letters pushed long-term thinking, more transparency and access to boards.

Do index funds and ETFs make markets more volatile, according to Fink?

Fink says the research BlackRock has seen shows the opposite. He claims 50 to 70 percent of daily ETF trading volume is active investing, which he calls a good gauge of market sentiment.

What is the 'scope three' issue Fink raises?

Scope 3 refers to emissions from a company's wider value chain, beyond its own operations (scopes one and two). Fink says he won't police it, and that governments should apply decarbonization rules to all companies, not just public ones.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Larry Fink says his annual letter to companies began in 2012.

“the letter started in 2012 when I realized that there's a huge responsibility with the indexers to making sure that our vote counts.”

0:04:24 · Larry Fink · Annual letter · 2012

Fink says that from 2012 to 2015 his letters focused on long-termism, and that 54 percent of BlackRock's managed assets are retirement assets of some sort.

“Most of the narrative was about long-termism, why short-termism is not good, especially with 54 % of all the assets we manage or retirement assets or some sort.”

0:04:24 · Larry Fink · Long-termism · 2012-2015

Fink says BlackRock asked companies for access to their boards in 2012 to 2015, when most companies did not allow board members to talk with investors.

“We actually asked in 2012 to 2015, can we have access to talk to the board? Before that, most companies would not allow their board members to have any conversations with their investors.”

0:05:01 · Larry Fink · Board access · 2012-2015

Fink says a U.S. senator told him that stakeholder capitalism is communism.

“Some people, I had a U.S. senator point his finger at me and said stakeholder capitalism is communism.”

0:08:35 · Larry Fink · Stakeholder capitalism

Fink says at least 30 percent of his role is spent working with clients worldwide.

“at least 30 % of my role has to be working with clients worldwide, spending time with them, understanding it.”

0:10:07 · Larry Fink · Client work

Fink says he helped set up the mortgage securities market at First Boston in the late 1970s and early 1980s.

“when I was at first boston setting up the mortgage industry in the late 70s early 80s you know we had to work both”

0:10:35 · Larry Fink · Mortgage market · 1970s-1980s

Fink says BlackRock had been operating for 34 years at the time of the interview.

“And we've been doing this for 34 years, and I believe it's about this relentless pursuit.”

0:16:16 · Larry Fink · BlackRock history

Fink cites Phil Jackson, who coached the Chicago Bulls and Los Angeles Lakers, as an example of a coach who won nine championships.

“you've got Phil Jackson in the United States who coached the Chicago Bulls and the LA Lakers and had nine champions.”

0:15:09 · Larry Fink · Team building

Fink says investors who divested from energy stocks over the previous two years underperformed dramatically.

“Over the last two years, if you divested of energy stocks, you underperformed dramatically.”

0:17:52 · Larry Fink · Energy divestment

Fink argues that divesting energy assets does not change the world and only moves ownership from public to private hands.

“Divestiture doesn't change the world that zero. It just moves it from public hands to private hands.”

0:19:51 · Larry Fink · Divestment

Fink says BlackRock, on behalf of its investors, recently created the biggest carbon sequestration investment in the United States.

“we just created the biggest sequestration of carbon in the United States.”

0:20:14 · Larry Fink · Carbon sequestration

Fink says he expects returns of around 20 percent for investors in BlackRock's carbon sequestration project.

“And the returns for our investors are going to be in the 20%.”

0:20:52 · Larry Fink · Investment returns

Fink says he does not want private companies to be able to pay CEOs more than public companies, which would push firms to stay or go private.

“I do not want an arbitrage of private companies having higher CEO pay than public companies.”

0:21:22 · Larry Fink · CEO pay

Fink says BlackRock will account for its own scope one and two emissions but will not police scope three emissions.

“I'm perfectly responsible of identifying what my scope one and two admissions are. I'm not going to do scope three.”

0:23:35 · Larry Fink · Emissions scopes

Fink estimates that more than 50 percent, possibly 70 percent, of daily trading volume in any ETF comes from active investing.

“I would say to you 50 plus percent of any daily volume on any ETF is active investing. And if I'm wrong, it's probably 70%.”

0:25:30 · Larry Fink · ETF trading

Nicolai Tangen says BlackRock, Vanguard and State Street together control nearly 20 percent of the American stock market.

“you, Vanguard, and State Street together control nearly 20 % of the American stock market.”

0:27:20 · Nicolai Tangen · Index fund ownership

Fink says BlackRock announced Voting Choice about a year earlier, technology that lets asset owners vote their own shares.

“A year ago, we announced something called Voting Choice, where we developed the technology to give the vote back to the asset owner.”

0:27:34 · Larry Fink · Voting Choice

Fink says he believes the future of bonds and stocks lies in tokenization, and that BlackRock is studying crypto and DeFi architecture.

“Because I believe the future in bonds and stocks is going to be tokenization of bonds and stocks.”

0:28:13 · Larry Fink · Tokenization

Fink says that working remotely has degraded every firm over time and breaks down culture, although it worked well during the first year of COVID.

“But over time, working remotely has degraded every firm. It is a breakdown of culture.”

0:29:17 · Larry Fink · Remote work · 2020

Nicolai Tangen says Fink's team at First Boston lost $100 million in 1986.

“because you and your team lost $100 million in 1986. That's the first Boston, yeah.”

0:31:26 · Nicolai Tangen · First Boston loss · 1986

Fink says his First Boston team earned $140 million in the quarter before the loss while taking too much risk.

“we should have been fired the quarter before when we made $140 million because we were taking way too much risk”

0:31:35 · Larry Fink · First Boston loss · 1986

Fink says BlackRock's risk management system, which he calls the most important in the world, grew out of his losses at First Boston.

“And we have now the most important risk management system in the world today. And it's on the back of my losses at First Boston.”

0:31:35 · Larry Fink · Risk management

Fink says the one time he felt starstruck was watching Bruce Springsteen's Broadway show.

“I was starstruck at the majesticness of Bruce Springsteen when he did his show on Broadway”

0:34:29 · Larry Fink · Bruce Springsteen

Fink says BlackRock hired 540 young college graduates in the year of the interview.

“because this year we've hired 540 young college students.”

0:36:25 · Larry Fink · Hiring

Chapters

  1. 0:00:25Size, fiduciary duty and influence

    Fink explains that BlackRock manages client money and must treat every client alike, and he rejects the idea of using personal views to steer investments.

    “The money I manage, none of it's our money.”
  2. 0:04:24The annual letter and stakeholder capitalism

    Fink traces the letter from 2012 and defends stakeholder capitalism as a route to durable long-term profits.

    “the letter started in 2012 when I realized that there's a huge responsibility with the indexers”
  3. 0:13:21Building BlackRock: clients, culture and team

    Fink describes his client-first approach, his early career in mortgages, and why he thinks culture and teamwork sustain a firm.

    “We use a pronoun, a we, not I.”
  4. 0:19:51ESG, energy and why not to divest

    Fink explains his view that divestment fails, that hydrocarbons will be needed longer, and that carbon sequestration is the next big opportunity.

    “Divestiture doesn't change the world that zero.”
  5. 0:23:35CEO pay, scope three and Europe

    Fink says pay should track shareholder returns, and that rules should apply to private as well as public companies.

    “I don't believe in scope three”
  6. 0:27:34Passive investing, voting and tokenization

    Fink answers concerns about index fund concentration with Voting Choice and a vision of tokenized ownership.

    “we developed the technology to give the vote back to the asset owner”
  7. 0:32:38Remote work, setbacks and the 1986 loss

    Fink argues remote work harms culture and explains how a trading loss shaped BlackRock's risk approach.

    “I want everybody running into the fire, not running away from the fire.”
  8. 0:36:25Advice for young people

    Fink urges following your passion and continuing to learn, noting BlackRock hired 540 young college graduates this year.

    “your first job should be go where you can learn the most”

Transcript

0:00:08
Nicolai Tangen

First of all, Larry, very welcome onto this podcast. We're absolutely thrilled and honored to have you on. Now, I thought the Norwegian Saoven Wealth Fund was pretty big until I saw that you guys have six times as much money as we have. So how do you think about the size of BlackRock?

0:00:25
Larry Fink

Well, let me start off and say, the money that you manage is all your money. The money I manage, none of it's our money. So I start with that foundation. I always have started that our job is to be a fiduciary to every client. Whether that client is giving us $1 ,000 of their savings or a large fund that's giving us tens of billions of dollars of money to manage, We have to treat them the same.

0:00:52

We have to be thoughtful about, you know, what are they looking to do? You know, we're not a firm that people are going to invest in us if they're interested in short term trades. That's what a hedge fund for. We have hedge funds as a firm. But generally, I would think of BlackRock is somebody where from from small investors to large investors come to BlackRock with the idea that we could give them better contextual knowledge. to help them formulate a decision as to where do they want to put their money and how should that be managed and organized.

0:01:27
Nicolai Tangen

But even though, Larry, the assets are not yours, it gives you as a firm an enormous influence. And how do you want to use that influence?

0:01:35
Larry Fink

The last thing I ever want to do is use my personal opinions, my personal feelings on how we invest. That's not my fiduciary responsibility. where we could use our knowledge is helping clients formulate a strategy, a portfolio, a desire. You know, we believe that let's just talk about the energy transition, which is so topical in the United States. We believe the energy transition has to be very aggressive, aggressive in making sure we have enough hydrocarbons to have a fair and just transition, which we don't have now.

0:02:10

At the same time, we have to rapidly have our investors invest in new technologies to find new solutions so we can bring down the green premium. Our job is to say, and we've always said it, do not divest of hydrocarbons. We've always said that. We also said that we believe gas is going to play a longer role in the decarbonization future than many people think, which means to me, we are going to have to find more and more solutions towards sequestration and carbon capture, because I just don't believe we're going to wake up one day and find all these new technologies that can bring down the green premium and make renewable energy to be as competitive across the board.

0:02:56

So I don't want to use, as you use the word influence on anything. I don't believe that is our responsibility. Our job is to use our information that we seek, raise topical issues. A topical issue is climate risk, is investment risk, okay? Some people don't agree, some people do, but I'll use that to frame a conversation. And probably the most important thing that we want to do with every client, with every regulator, with any citizen, is to have a conversation.

0:03:26

I mean, what I think is missing in the world today we need to have conversation we need to be sharing a meal with them if we can have a conversation i do believe we can minimize the extremes and then we can move forward together now we're not going to agree on everything no one's going to agree on everything but we can formulate a means to just build better consensus building i actually believe what is the greatest thing that is missing in the world today, especially for savers, is hope.

0:03:58

I believe there's more fear in the world, more fear from savers, what the markets did, what the bond market did, more fear, who do I trust, what media stores I should trust. And so with that backdrop of this fear, I believe BlackRock has a huge responsibility to try to be part of a conversation.

0:04:18
Nicolai Tangen

One of the ways you communicate with the world is through your yearly letter. Tell us about it.

0:04:24
Larry Fink

Well, the letter started in 2012 when I realized that there's a huge responsibility with the indexers to making sure that our vote counts. The other thing is you look at the letters from 2012 to 2015. Most of the narrative was about long-termism, why short-termism is not good, especially with 54 % of all the assets we manage or retirement assets or some sort. So we have this long responsibility. So the letter was just a statement to all the companies we invested about, you know, we want leadership in their boards to focus more on long-term issues.

0:05:01

We also asked board members and management to provide more transparency so we understand how they're moving forward. We actually asked in 2012 to 2015, can we have access to talk to the board? Before that, most companies would not allow their board members to have any conversations with their investors.

0:05:23
Nicolai Tangen

Do you come up with the ideas for the letter?

0:05:26
Larry Fink

I think I plagiarize everybody. Most of the information I get is from conversations with clients. I then synthesize that and write up the ideas, yes. So the ideas are mine, but they're from a series of internal and external conversations. and I get this little kernel of information with this client, one little kernel of information with this client, and I just bring it together as the year ends.

0:05:52
Nicolai Tangen

What are the cleverest people you speak to?

0:05:55
Larry Fink

You know what? I wouldn't say there's any one type of characteristic that I find inspiring. It just could be one little fact, or it could be somebody who's very aberrant in the way he or she thinks, And I just found that little narrative to be really important. And I write it down and just pack it away. The other thing, because I visit so many clients, Nicolai, after a series of meetings, let's say eight meetings a day for a bunch of days, you can then weave a thread of what's on their mind.

0:06:31

You know, so having that type of convening ability of having these meetings, you really get a good foundation of what's on the mind of our clients worldwide. And it's really rare that clients in Asia are thinking much different than clients in Europe or clients in North America. There is that thread. And that's the beauty of the global capital markets. And, you know, getting back to BlackRock for one second, one of the most important points why we were successful, we made a foundational belief when we started the company that the global capital markets are going to be the engine of economic prosperity.

0:07:09

The role of banking is going to be diminished. and that obviously over the last 30 odd years, and it's accelerating post-financial crisis with Dodd-Frank and Basel, the role of banks have diminished worldwide extraordinarily fast. And the rise of the global capital markets, it's a mirror image of that. And that was one of the foundational beliefs for BlackRock that we thought that we could play a role in the global capital markets. Linking back to the letters, Much of the letters and the foundational letters about long-termism, the role of the capital markets, more transparency.

0:07:47

And then as America and Europe became more divided, it was very clear to me that the role of a management team, a CEO, a board, and the whole focus on stakeholder capitalism became more and more something that I believed in. That if we are going to maximize profits for our shareholders, who are the primacy of every company, your shareholders, you have to be fully connected and engaged with your employees, your clients, and your communities. If you can do that well and successfully, you then have more durable long-term profits, and your shareholders are the big beneficiary of that.

0:08:29
Nicolai Tangen

Your letter about stakeholder capitalism was quite groundbreaking in terms of changing the focus.

0:08:35
Larry Fink

It's still about long-termism, Nicolai. It was still about long-termism. What can create durable, long-term profits? That's the whole foundation. And look, it was groundbreaking, and it's still hotly debated. Some people, I had a U.S. senator point his finger at me and said stakeholder capitalism is communism. So, you know, you know, I don't think of the Nordics. They think that stakeholder capitalism is is communism. I think, you know, from the from our visits to to the Nordics, I would say almost the entire society of the Nordics believes that the responsibility of companies is beyond just their shareholders.

0:09:18

It is their employees. It is their community.

0:09:20
Nicolai Tangen

it is uh their client we we call it common sense um but um i just want to go i just want to go take one step back here so it's quite extraordinary that you as a ceo of the biggest asset manager in the world are still seeing clients so tell us about it i mean i mean this kind of this kind of service uh client mindset is that something tell us about it where does that where does that come

0:09:43
Larry Fink

from that was the whole foundation of the firm listen to your clients uh by listening to your clients, you then have the ability to understand what their needs are. And then through that iterative process, I believe you could stay in front of the needs of clients. You cannot, if you don't understand what's on your mind or your clients or where do they believe they're taking their business, their companies, it's hard for you then to anticipate where they're going next.

0:10:07

So I believe at least 30 % of my role has to be working with clients worldwide, spending time with them, understanding it. And that's how, you know, the other part of my career, My job is strategy. I understand strategy a lot more by understanding the needs of our clients worldwide.

0:10:25
Nicolai Tangen

But do you think that focus on clients, I believe that when you were young, you worked in your father's shoe shop. Yeah, I did. What have you taken from that experience and brought into BlackRock?

0:10:35
Larry Fink

That was just how to sell yourself and how to be patient, especially when somebody wants to try and 12 pairs of shoes. we were always very client-centric and keep in mind even when i was my first career when i was at first boston setting up the mortgage industry in the late 70s early 80s you know we had to work both this is the uniqueness of what with my career not only did i run a trading desk and started a new market but i had to then go to the originators of the mortgages i had to sell ourself to to buy those mortgages off a savings and loan or insurance company.

0:11:15

We had to learn risk management to package those and then go to the clients and tell them why this is a superior investment versus owning, let's say, a corporate bond back then or a treasury. So all of that was probably from the foundation of starting a new market. And I think starting new markets, you have to not only understand the attended risks of what you're creating. You have to understand the origination side of that, and then you have to understand and sell yourself to the client so they are better equipped.

0:11:46

And that was the foundation of BlackRock when we started it.

0:11:54
Nicolai Tangen

But when you think about how you built up BlackRock, what has been the most important decisions on the way, the most critical junctures?

0:12:01
Larry Fink

Well, I would just say the consistency of being client-centric and being principled. I mean, we've always been a really highly principled firm. Culture is another place where I spend my 30 % of my time in allocation, making sure that our culture is what we want it to be. Lapses in firms are very easy, but if you don't have a culture of identification problems, of mitigating problems, and correcting problems, you know, you generally fall down. Every firm can have a growth spurt, but growth spurts, we all know, don't last forever.

0:12:40

You're going to have intended problems from all that growth. How are you mitigating that? How are you managing that? How are you trying to reposition? You know, we all live in a market that is very cyclical and volatile, and you need to create a culture that is robust and resilient, that is thoughtful and creative. You need to create a dynastism where people want to be part of that, that they believe in the firm. They believe in the purpose of the firm.

0:13:08

And so to me, if you don't have a strong culture, a strong purposeful organization, you're going to have bouts of success, but you're not going to have the longevity of success.

0:13:19
Nicolai Tangen

What's the most important part of the BlackBow culture?

0:13:21
Larry Fink

We strongly believe in team. We use a pronoun, a we, not I. We must live our principles every day. I mean, all the founders are still friends, and many of them had other careers during the years and doing other things, but we're still friends, and it's about a culture of belonging.

0:13:43
Nicolai Tangen

Do you look at the team as a family or a sports team?

0:13:47
Larry Fink

The more intimate direct reports of family as he firm it's a sports team. I spend a lot of time thinking about the management of sports. And when you think about these athletes, I don't care what field, these athletes who are best in their field, they're generally highly individual. They're generally, at a young age, learned that they have to be very aggressive and it's all about them. And they don't have the skill sets, generally, to be a team.

0:14:23

But it's that great manager coach who tries to blend, I would say, these individual specimens into a team. And give them the confidence that if you work as a team, the outcomes are far better. And the key is you can always build that team with superlative results and winning the championship in one year. Everybody can rally for a year to get that one thing done. I don't care about those coaches or managers. What I get inspired by are those coaches or managers who can go in their field for five-ish years, get the championship.

0:15:06
Nicolai Tangen

So who's the best coach you've come across?

0:15:09
Larry Fink

Oh, my gosh. I mean, you've got Phil Jackson in the United States who coached the Chicago Bulls and the LA Lakers and had nine champions. And every one of those athletes were superb. And every one of them were probably taught about, you know, you've got to be first. You've got to be first. You've got to be first. Being first does not win a championship. It's about the blending. I think basketball is where you see the greatest amount of individuality.

0:15:36

And to put those 10 people together and make it a team with regularity, to me, those are the inspirational managers, leaders for me.

0:15:47
Nicolai Tangen

What is the key to building a team?

0:15:48
Larry Fink

It's understanding the purpose of an organization. If you want to be the best in history, it's not about winning one time. It's not about winning two times. You might be a footnote in the history books by winning two champions or being a good firm for one or two years, and then you blow it out. To me, it's about this long-termism, then building a culture, a team, building a principle around that and trying to carry that forward.

0:16:16

And we've been doing this for 34 years, and I believe it's about this relentless pursuit.

0:16:24
Nicolai Tangen

So if you hire, what do you look for when you hire? So let's say now you're interviewing me, you are thinking about hiring me. What kind of things do you ask me?

0:16:33
Larry Fink

So I'm the last to interview. I don't interview a person for his or her skill sets. I assume through the interviewing process, their skill sets are good. Now, there may be one little thing that I want to ask about his or her career and their path. But the first question I'll ask you, okay, let's assume this is your resume. What is not on this that you need to tell me about? That's the first question I had generally asked.

0:16:58
Nicolai Tangen

Well, I'm not going to tell you because it's so bad, right?

0:17:01
Larry Fink

Right, but that's, you know, I can read what's there. You know, I assume the fact that I'm interviewing you, people have, they believe in your skill set for the various jobs that you're being interviewed for. I want to know about you. What makes you tick? Okay, that's always my first question. What should I know that's not on your resume?

0:17:20
Nicolai Tangen

Larry, what is it that is not on your resume that we should know about you?

0:17:25
Larry Fink

What's on my resume right now? I mean, I'm a big, big family man. I'm a grandfather of seven people that wouldn't need to be on my resume. So it's more, I would tell you something more personal about me that I'm not frightened of exposing my vulnerabilities.

0:17:47
Nicolai Tangen

Changing tacks a bit here. Why is it important to think about ESG when we invest?

0:17:52
Larry Fink

Over the last two years, if you divested of energy stocks, you underperformed dramatically. This is why I've always said you cannot divest. And let's be clear, in the United States, the energy complex is massive and the jobs. And so you have governmental officials who are in those states where the energy complex is large. and that's across coal and gas and oil and they're supporting their country their state their region and i understand that and the problem in government is they're too short term they're focusing on their their district they have you know and transitions are always painful we have a life history as human beings of transitions transitions are rough they're awful you have big winners and big losers.

0:18:45

Today, in this more real-time, just-in-time political cycles, the news cycles, having big losers creates a noise of the people losing.

0:18:58
Nicolai Tangen

I should add here, Larry, that we really concur with your thinking about not divesting and instead going into a dialogue with companies. We are exactly in the same camp because if you divest, somebody irresponsible is going to end up with the shares and it's not going to bring the world to a better place.

0:19:14
Larry Fink

My epiphany was exactly that. Without identifying the energy company, I was with a CEO of a big energy company. He was telling me he has to divest out of an emerging world country where he has refineries. And the president of the country is begging him not to sell. Begging him. Because who he would be selling to would be a private firm within the country that will actually degrade the forest, the region more. And the epiphany came to me.

0:19:51

This is a good example of a conversation, of that conversation. I said, that's where I came up with the idea. We cannot divest. Divestiture doesn't change the world that zero. It just moves it from public hands to private hands. And so the insanity of forcing divestiture so private hands can do it.

0:20:11
Nicolai Tangen

What do you think is going to be the next big thing in ESG investing?

0:20:14
Larry Fink

It's going to have to be sequestration and decarbonization alongside blue hydrogen. Blue hydrogen still has, you know, obviously huge potential, hard to execute, hard to do. You know, everybody in Europe is talking about hydrogen, but nobody wants a hydrogen electrolyzer there. And so, you know, we're going back to the same arguments. But I do believe, and this is why BlackRock is working with every energy company, we just did, on behalf of our investors, we just created the biggest sequestration of carbon in the United States.

0:20:52

And the returns for our investors are going to be in the 20%. So we're doing good, and they're great investments. Because I do believe we're going to need hydrocarbons longer than people think. And the only way to mitigate the utilization of hydrocarbons is being very aggressive in the sequestration.

0:21:08
Nicolai Tangen

A slightly different topic. We have taken a strong position when it comes to CEO pay. Do you think there is such a thing as too much pay?

0:21:17
Larry Fink

Of course. And it should be totally aligned to the performance of a company.

0:21:20
Nicolai Tangen

But why are you guys not more vocal about it?

0:21:22
Larry Fink

I think we have been. But let me be clear also, I do not want an arbitrage of private companies having higher CEO pay than public companies. Once again, the problem I have is it is more advantageous to remain private or to take yourself private and you get much more benefits. I believe in public markets. I believe in the global capital markets being public. I believe we have more transparency. I believe CEO pay, management pay should be totally correlated to the relationship of what you're returning to your shareholders.

0:21:57

And when you have a bad year and your shareholders have bad years, your comp should be cut a lot. I'm very strong about that because I'm not involved in any of the voting, but our team is supposed to be correlating comp versus shareholder returns over time, looking at them and adjusting that. But we are not against high-paying CEOs if the shareholders are benefiting too. Now, I believe our views are a little different than European views.

0:22:24

So European views have a more what I would call a socialistic view, that they believe that companies, public company CEOs should be much lower. My worry about Europe is more and more great companies are going to be in the United States. I mean, it's a big world out there. And, you know, there is a big reason why more high quality Ph.D. students from Europe ultimately come to the United States and work. So I believe in, you know, in free trade of capitalism.

0:22:54

Nicolai, you ran a private fund. You know, the difference between public and private. But you chose to go into the role that you presently have with a full knowledge that, you know, your COP is going to be considerably lower. and you did that with purpose and desire and that's great and it's the best and it's the best thing i ever did i'm confident in and i'm jealous that you did it because i want to do that one day but i don't want to admonish and hurt public ceos versus companies that are in their field that are private there should be a correlation this gets back to government policy related to esg or government.

0:23:35

We need to make sure, this is why I've always said, I don't believe in scope three, you know, because I don't want to be the environmental police. Okay. If governments want every company to move forward on decarbonization, ask every company, but don't ask public shareholders to, you know, to police these other companies on scope three. I'm perfectly responsible of identifying what my scope one and two admissions are. I'm not going to do scope three. and it's the same idea.

0:24:05

We need to make sure that we are not admonishing just public companies, that if we want a societal change, let's do it for all companies. The problem is so much is done conveniently. It's so convenient to just do public companies and they don't want to go the extra mile. And so we, and I think Europe is more at fault than the United States in this. And that is one of the reasons why I believe Europe has less innovation than the United States, which is a huge systemic problem of Europe.

0:24:36

And privately, when I talk to political leaders in Europe, they all recognize that. They won't say it publicly. Europe does not have the same innovation because there is limitations. Now, I'm very pleased what's going on in Europe with the rise of private companies and the rise of fintech and more tech companies. And maybe that's going to change. But the question, will they ever go public with that societal force on things like that?

0:25:04
Nicolai Tangen

I'd love to ask you some questions on ownership. So just to explain to the listeners, you have active investing where you pick single individual stocks and then you have passive investing or index investing where you basically buy the whole broad index. And you guys are big in both, but you are huge in passive investing. Do you think all these passive assets amplifies greed and fear and increase bubbles and these kind of things?

0:25:30
Larry Fink

I think there is a strong conversation related to that very question. And all the research that we have seen is the exact opposite. But where there's more volatility in some of the indexes, there actually is probably the greatest change in the, let's use ETFs because that's what I'm really talking about, the subset of indexing. I would say to you 50 plus percent of any daily volume on any ETF is active investing. And if I'm wrong, it's probably 70%.

0:26:10

More and more investors are looking to get their exposures not through an individual stock. They're getting their exposures through an ETF. ETF, and they're actively managing those ETFs where they have the exposures of, and they're actively managing those exposures. You could do it with more liquidity, you can do it with more ease. And I believe the narrative is looking backwards. I believe the key today is determining how many people are using ETFs for active purposes. And that's a better barometer of market sentiment than people realize.

0:26:47

And when I then moved to the bond market, where my whole foundation is, why on earth do you want to own 3 ,000 bonds to replicate the Bloomberg index, if you wanted to be close to that, where you could buy one or two different ETFs, one that is a credit exposure, one is a convexity exposure, one is a duration exposure. and you get 90 % of all the exposures of bonds. So you don't need to own 3 ,000 bonds.

0:27:11

You're going to own a few ETFs and navigate around the convexity or credit or duration through using ETFs.

0:27:20
Nicolai Tangen

But if you look at the stats, and let's just stick with equities for a little while, you look at the stats, you, Vanguard, and State Street together control nearly 20 % of the American stock market. What are the potential problems with that?

0:27:34
Larry Fink

A year ago, we announced something called Voting Choice, where we developed the technology to give the vote back to the asset owner. And I did a recent CEO letter that you received, and we are trying to expand that to retail. well, we want to democratize all the votes. And if we can democratize the vote, almost all the societal questions on the role of indexing and its responsibility is mitigated quite extensively. Now, one other new technology, obviously in light of all that's going on in crypto, look, we're not surprised at all these blowups.

0:28:13

We're surprised at the speed of the blowups. We are spending a great deal of time on the architecture of crypto. Because I believe the future in bonds and stocks is going to be tokenization of bonds and stocks. If we all had a DeFi ledger of every ownership, I don't have to vote on anything. Every asset owner through their tokenization, we know who's the beneficial owner. And that's why we are spending so much time on architecture of crypto and DeFi.

0:28:42

So we believe the applications are going to be monstrously meaningful in the future. And we hope there's a future one day when we tokenize all bonds and stocks. We can identify every beneficial owner across the board. Everybody knows it. And the beneficial owner, whether it's that $1 ,000 investor, he or she could vote their shares as they choose to or the big sovereign fund can do it there. And we are not responsible.

0:29:11
Nicolai Tangen

I wanted to ask you some other questions. What do you think about the working from home model?

0:29:17
Larry Fink

Working from home during the first year of COVID, before a vaccination, was so successful. It worked so well beyond any imagination. I mean, all our fears were shown that our fears were not necessary. And during that one year, we were able to very well work in our verticals. Everybody was proper and all that. But over time, working remotely has degraded every firm. It is a breakdown of culture. Young people cannot learn the horizontal across the different components of the business.

0:29:55

They don't understand the holistic components of how to do business. They're just in their little vertical.

0:30:01
Nicolai Tangen

Are you productive at home?

0:30:03
Larry Fink

Of course not. Not as well as I'm here. I mean, I'm just not.

0:30:07
Nicolai Tangen

Same here, same here.

0:30:08
Larry Fink

No, I'm better than I've ever imagined. You know why? Because I can't walk the hallways at home. I can't walk into somebody else's office. What's going on? I can't walk into a trading floor. I can make phone calls. I can do Zoom calls like this. But no, you don't have the most important conversations are not the planned conversation. The most important conversation is after the planned conversation. OK, what else is going on? What else? What's on your mind?

0:30:34

What are you feeling? That's how you get translational ideas, not vertical ideas.

0:30:44
Nicolai Tangen

What's the best piece of leadership advice you have ever been given?

0:30:48
Larry Fink

You've got to be authentic. You've got to be who you are. You've got to show it. You've got to be proud of who you are.

0:30:53
Nicolai Tangen

I think you said at some stage that you are still a student. In what ways are you still a student?

0:30:59
Larry Fink

If I have a bad day, I've had only two or three new facts every day. I mean, everybody should try to learn something new every day. something I, and so to me, when you stop being a student, somebody is passing you by because another person is learning and keep in mind. I mean, I came up with that idea from my first career when I thought I knew it all and the market evolved and changed and I lost money.

0:31:24

Okay, we all do that and I never forgave myself

0:31:26
Nicolai Tangen

for what happened. Yeah, you and your, because you and your team lost $100 million in 1986. That's the first Boston, yeah. What did you learn

0:31:35
Larry Fink

from that? Well, what I learned was we should have been fired the quarter before when we made $140 million because we were taking way too much risk and it showed up the next quarter and we didn't have proper risk management. And so today, and this is the whole foundation of BlackRock, building a whole firm on risk management. And we have now the most important risk management system in the world today. And it's on the back of my losses at First Boston.

0:32:04

I'm knowing your risk, managing your platform, understanding it. And keep in mind, when I first told the story when we started the firm about this whole risk management, and they said, well, is that risk avoidance? I said, no, it's just knowing your risk means if you think you can take more risk, you can add more risk. When you think you're too many, you can mitigate it. It just allows you to more properly, systematically navigate your portfolios and understanding your risk during different scenarios.

0:32:35
Nicolai Tangen

But generally speaking, how do you cope with setbacks?

0:32:38
Larry Fink

I think this is one thing that's culturally part of BlackRock and it's part of my DNA. When there's a problem, I want everybody running into the fire, not running away from the fire. And that's a hard thing to teach people. um our job i want everybody even if it's not part of their business but you know help out run into the fire try to mitigate it and fix it you you know i don't need people to be standby you know watching the fire you know this is something uh i've always said too i do not want observers i don't need people sitting in the in the in the stands i want people to in the play every day using a

0:33:15

sports analogy.

0:33:16
Nicolai Tangen

It's interesting. I interviewed Lisa Su at AMD. She said that you have to run towards the problems and it seems like you were sharing that attitude.

0:33:25
Larry Fink

Yeah, because great firms are firms that mitigate problems sooner. We all are going to have problems. We all have judgment errors. We all have, we find an average human being. We all have an issue. The faster we identify it, mitigate it, the better you'll be. great great firms are not firms who just make tons of money in the upside everybody does that that's one of the you know the way you know the the ocean rises and everybody makes more money but you know the key of success is through is mitigating problems so you can you can respond and when you have problems the amount of management at time on the problems is enormous you don't have as much time being

0:34:06

offensive seeing clients focusing on the next idea the next trend And so the faster you can mitigate a problem, the more you can be offensive again.

0:34:16
Nicolai Tangen

You meet a lot of people. When were you last starstruck?

0:34:21
Larry Fink

Gosh, I don't know if I ever was. Why not? We're all people.

0:34:28
Nicolai Tangen

That's very true.

0:34:29
Larry Fink

You know, we're all people. You know, I mean, we all have the same issues. We all generally have insecurities and fears. I learned that really quickly. I'm never starstruck. I mean, I enjoy people. So I love being with people. To me, this is just part of our lives. If I had to say I was starstruck, but I was an observer. I was in the audience. I was starstruck at the majesticness of Bruce Springsteen when he did his show on Broadway and the stories around his songs and his life.

0:35:04

you know to me that is that is a moment where i could always relish yeah yeah my last question

0:35:12
Nicolai Tangen

to you we have um a lot of um well we have got thousands of students listening into this and um what is your advice to young people always focus on what you're passionate about

0:35:23
Larry Fink

what makes you move and inspire you and go into that field never go into a field that you're doing it because your parents want you there, or you might make more money, or you might have more influence. The best way of making a mark is being in a field that inspires you, where you can be the most authentic. You know, as a parent, I saw my three children, same mother and father. They're so wildly different. Now I see my seven grandchildren that are wildly different.

0:35:54

We all have a different unique spark. That's the beauty of humanity. We all have this individuality. And, you know, we all think we have to conform or do what people want. And, you know, those, you generally are not successful there. Go into the field that totally inspires you, that gives you a smile, that you can differentiate yourself, that you can really build something and grow into something. And, And, you know, and your first job is never your last job in most cases.

0:36:25

Go, you know, go. Your first job should be go where you can learn the most. And the one thing I say, because this year we've hired 540 young college students. When I give my speech to them, I say, if you believe your days of learning are over, it's time for you to leave BlackRock. If you don't believe you're a student and the demands on you to learn more and more now, you're mistaken. You know, you just acquired your entry level to get into this job.

0:36:54

Okay, you're starting at ground zero. You may have been the best in your class. You may have been a great athlete. You may have been whatever you were, but now you're starting at ground zero with so many other people. How do you differentiate yourself as being your authentic self and then being a student? And when you stop learning, you're not going to be at the finish line with somebody else.

0:37:16
Nicolai Tangen

Great. Well, you for sure are your authentic self. And Larry, it's been tremendous, an honor and a pleasure to have you on the podcast. Thank you so much.

0:37:25
Larry Fink

Nicolai, thank you. And thank you, everyone in Norwich, for the partnership, the relationship. And I am confident there's so many things we'll be doing together in the future. Wonderful.

0:37:34
Nicolai Tangen

Thank you so much.