In brief
Insurance innovation will succeed when it pairs the industry's hard-won skill at pricing risk with outsiders' willingness to test and fail quickly. Bryan Falchuk argues that both startups and incumbents are arrogant about what they know. Real progress needs genuine reasons to exist, sound underwriting economics, and teams with healthy disagreement.
The central tension is between what is hard and what is merely slow. Falchuk says legacy insurers got the hard part, underwriting, right but treat easier customer-experience and technology changes as impossible. COVID showed rapid change was achievable. The episode ends on whether a giant insurtech will emerge or whether distribution, such as embedded insurance, is the real disruption.
Questions
Why did insurtech funding getting harder turn out to be good for the industry?
Bryan Falchuk says tighter investment in 2022 forced a rationalization where underlying economics and a genuine reason for existing matter. Startups that merely claimed to be better than old insurers got less funding.
Can an insurance startup just grow its way out of losing money?
Falchuk says no: unlike retail or consumer tech, scale makes a fundamentally bad underwriter worse. Underwriting means judging and pricing risk, and selling coverage far below its true cost is not sustainable.
Why do some insurers take so long to make changes that seem simple?
Falchuk says much of it is choice, such as insisting a project will take 18 months or dismissing cheap fixes as not serious enough. He points to USAA, which went remote in five days after planning an 18-month study.
What is embedded insurance and is it working yet?
Embedded insurance is cover sold inside another purchase, such as travel or a phone. Alex Bond says one investor reported only two of four embedded bets made money and one was profitable, though Falchuk says embedded travel cover does much better than standalone.
Will a new insurtech become the next giant insurer?
Falchuk says he honestly doesn't know, noting that Tesla surprised people in cars but no new record label has risen to a Sony. He thinks many startups are more likely to be acquired, and doesn't see the right underwriting economics in the biggest unicorns.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Bryan Falchuk says he has worked in property and casualty insurance for more than twenty years across carriers, consulting and insurtechs.
“I've been around PNC for like 20 something years. And through that, I've spent time at carriers, consulting, insurtechs.”
0:01:10 · Bryan Falchuk · Career
Bryan Falchuk set up Insurance Evolution Partners a few years before 2022 to help insurers and insurtechs engage with change.
“a few years back, I set up insurance evolution partners to try to help the industry engage in the possibility of change”
0:01:42 · Bryan Falchuk · Company founding
Bryan Falchuk publishes a book series and a podcast series both called The Future of Insurance.
“I've got a book series called the future of insurance podcast series called the future of insurance”
0:01:42 · Bryan Falchuk · Publications
Bryan Falchuk says investment in insurtech became tougher to obtain during 2022.
“In this year where investing has been a lot tougher or it's been tougher to get investment dollars”
0:04:15 · Bryan Falchuk · Insurtech funding · 2022
According to Bryan Falchuk, USAA, a roughly $28 billion property and casualty business, scoped a project in early 2020 to begin later that year studying remote work.
“I talk about USAA, you know, this like $28 billion PNC business roughly. At the beginning of 2020, they had scoped a project to begin at the end of the year, like Q3, to look at remote work.”
0:26:10 · Bryan Falchuk · Remote work · 2020
Bryan Falchuk says USAA moved to remote work in five days after COVID hit, having expected 18 months before it even had an answer on the question.
“it took them five days but it took them five days where they said it was going to be 18 months before they even had a sense of the answer”
0:26:45 · Bryan Falchuk · Remote work · 2020
Bryan Falchuk says a small New York regional carrier paid claims by paper check because its agents insisted on delivering checks personally to be seen as the hero.
“The reason was the agents really insisted on getting a paper check, driving out to the insured and delivering it because they wanted to be the savior.”
0:19:17 · Bryan Falchuk · Claims payments · 2020
Bryan Falchuk estimates the carrier's check process could take about two weeks after a claim determination was made.
“What's that, two weeks maybe since the determination was made, let alone when the actual loss occurred, that business may be out of business by now.”
0:20:32 · Bryan Falchuk · Claims payments · 2020
Bryan Falchuk says in the United States roughly 40-something percent of personal lines insurance is still sold by agents, and commercial lines more so.
“in the U S we've got in personal lines and 40 something percent are still agents sold, but in commercial lines, quite a bit more.”
0:18:46 · Bryan Falchuk · Distribution · 2022
Bryan Falchuk cites the British supermarket chain Tesco selling insurance as an example of how UK distribution differs from the United States.
“I mean, Tesco selling insurance. I can't imagine a supermarket chain in the US selling insurance and lots of other non-food things.”
0:18:11 · Bryan Falchuk · UK distribution
Bryan Falchuk says the number of the next-largest public carmakers that Tesla was worth more than rose from about nine to 13 within roughly six to eight months.
“So like, six, eight months ago, it was like nine companies, it's 13 last time I looked.”
0:38:21 · Bryan Falchuk · Tesla valuation · 2022
Bryan Falchuk says Amazon, initially a bookseller, made outdoor furniture its first product expansion.
“just selling books and then they added like outdoor furniture was their first product expansion”
0:38:52 · Bryan Falchuk · Amazon history
Bryan Falchuk says the component businesses of Booking Holdings were huge money losers during the dot-com era of 1999 and 2000.
“Booking holdings. I just saw like they had a great quarter. You know, their component businesses in the dot com days, 99, 2000 were huge money losers.”
0:38:52 · Bryan Falchuk · Booking Holdings · 1999
Bryan Falchuk argues that no new startup record label has risen to rival majors such as Sony or BMG.
“there's no new record label that has suddenly become you know the likes of of a sony or bmg”
0:37:06 · Bryan Falchuk · Music industry
Bryan Falchuk names Wefox as a giant insurtech whose underlying economics he does not know well enough to judge.
“I don't know, like WeFox is another giant one. I don't know them well enough to know their underlying economics.”
0:39:47 · Bryan Falchuk · Insurtech unicorns · 2022
Alex Bond says an investor told them that of four embedded insurance investments, two made any money and only one was profitable.
“i spoke to someone that said they'd invested in like four embedded plays and they said like two of them were making any money at all yeah and only one of them was profitable”
0:41:23 · Alex Bond · Embedded insurance · 2022
Alex Bond cites Accelerant as an example of a newer model in which an insurance carrier acts like a hedge fund with a pool of underwriting capacity.
“carriers acting like almost like a hedge fund and say right we've got this pot of capacity and yeah we've already seen people like accelerant come in with”
0:42:52 · Alex Bond · Carrier models · 2022