OpenNashPodcasts

The Leadership in Insurance Podcast

Discussing The Future of Insurance : An Interview with Bryan Falchuk

5 Dec 2022 · 45m · Alex Bond, Bryan Falchuk · 17 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Insurance innovation will succeed when it pairs the industry's hard-won skill at pricing risk with outsiders' willingness to test and fail quickly. Bryan Falchuk argues that both startups and incumbents are arrogant about what they know. Real progress needs genuine reasons to exist, sound underwriting economics, and teams with healthy disagreement.

The central tension is between what is hard and what is merely slow. Falchuk says legacy insurers got the hard part, underwriting, right but treat easier customer-experience and technology changes as impossible. COVID showed rapid change was achievable. The episode ends on whether a giant insurtech will emerge or whether distribution, such as embedded insurance, is the real disruption.

Key insights

  1. Tougher funding made insurtechs justify their existence

    Falchuk says harder fundraising in 2022 forced startups and buyers to care about underlying economics and a genuine reason to exist. Being new technology on a clean slate is no longer enough, because the slate stops being clean the day you start.

  2. Growing does not fix bad underwriting

    Falchuk notes that unlike retail or consumer tech, scale makes a fundamentally bad insurer worse. Selling coverage for a fraction of its cost is a money loser however good the brand or technology looks.

  3. Mixed insurance-and-tech founding teams outperform uniform ones

    Both speakers say founding teams now more often pair an insurance expert with a tech expert. Falchuk adds that a team of old friends who always agree lacks the healthy tension that challenges decisions.

  4. COVID proved big insurers can move far faster

    USAA planned an 18-month study of remote work, then went remote in five days when the pandemic hit. Falchuk uses this to argue that long timelines are a choice rather than a fixed limit.

  5. Distribution, not new carriers, is the likelier disruption

    Using the music industry as an analogy, the speakers argue the threat is a change in how people buy insurance, such as embedded insurance sold inside other purchases. Alex Bond notes the evidence is thin, citing an investor whose embedded bets were mostly unprofitable.

Questions

Why did insurtech funding getting harder turn out to be good for the industry?

Bryan Falchuk says tighter investment in 2022 forced a rationalization where underlying economics and a genuine reason for existing matter. Startups that merely claimed to be better than old insurers got less funding.

Can an insurance startup just grow its way out of losing money?

Falchuk says no: unlike retail or consumer tech, scale makes a fundamentally bad underwriter worse. Underwriting means judging and pricing risk, and selling coverage far below its true cost is not sustainable.

Why do some insurers take so long to make changes that seem simple?

Falchuk says much of it is choice, such as insisting a project will take 18 months or dismissing cheap fixes as not serious enough. He points to USAA, which went remote in five days after planning an 18-month study.

What is embedded insurance and is it working yet?

Embedded insurance is cover sold inside another purchase, such as travel or a phone. Alex Bond says one investor reported only two of four embedded bets made money and one was profitable, though Falchuk says embedded travel cover does much better than standalone.

Will a new insurtech become the next giant insurer?

Falchuk says he honestly doesn't know, noting that Tesla surprised people in cars but no new record label has risen to a Sony. He thinks many startups are more likely to be acquired, and doesn't see the right underwriting economics in the biggest unicorns.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Bryan Falchuk says he has worked in property and casualty insurance for more than twenty years across carriers, consulting and insurtechs.

“I've been around PNC for like 20 something years. And through that, I've spent time at carriers, consulting, insurtechs.”

0:01:10 · Bryan Falchuk · Career

Bryan Falchuk set up Insurance Evolution Partners a few years before 2022 to help insurers and insurtechs engage with change.

“a few years back, I set up insurance evolution partners to try to help the industry engage in the possibility of change”

0:01:42 · Bryan Falchuk · Company founding

Bryan Falchuk publishes a book series and a podcast series both called The Future of Insurance.

“I've got a book series called the future of insurance podcast series called the future of insurance”

0:01:42 · Bryan Falchuk · Publications

Bryan Falchuk says investment in insurtech became tougher to obtain during 2022.

“In this year where investing has been a lot tougher or it's been tougher to get investment dollars”

0:04:15 · Bryan Falchuk · Insurtech funding · 2022

According to Bryan Falchuk, USAA, a roughly $28 billion property and casualty business, scoped a project in early 2020 to begin later that year studying remote work.

“I talk about USAA, you know, this like $28 billion PNC business roughly. At the beginning of 2020, they had scoped a project to begin at the end of the year, like Q3, to look at remote work.”

0:26:10 · Bryan Falchuk · Remote work · 2020

Bryan Falchuk says USAA moved to remote work in five days after COVID hit, having expected 18 months before it even had an answer on the question.

“it took them five days but it took them five days where they said it was going to be 18 months before they even had a sense of the answer”

0:26:45 · Bryan Falchuk · Remote work · 2020

Bryan Falchuk says a small New York regional carrier paid claims by paper check because its agents insisted on delivering checks personally to be seen as the hero.

“The reason was the agents really insisted on getting a paper check, driving out to the insured and delivering it because they wanted to be the savior.”

0:19:17 · Bryan Falchuk · Claims payments · 2020

Bryan Falchuk estimates the carrier's check process could take about two weeks after a claim determination was made.

“What's that, two weeks maybe since the determination was made, let alone when the actual loss occurred, that business may be out of business by now.”

0:20:32 · Bryan Falchuk · Claims payments · 2020

Bryan Falchuk says in the United States roughly 40-something percent of personal lines insurance is still sold by agents, and commercial lines more so.

“in the U S we've got in personal lines and 40 something percent are still agents sold, but in commercial lines, quite a bit more.”

0:18:46 · Bryan Falchuk · Distribution · 2022

Bryan Falchuk cites the British supermarket chain Tesco selling insurance as an example of how UK distribution differs from the United States.

“I mean, Tesco selling insurance. I can't imagine a supermarket chain in the US selling insurance and lots of other non-food things.”

0:18:11 · Bryan Falchuk · UK distribution

Bryan Falchuk says the number of the next-largest public carmakers that Tesla was worth more than rose from about nine to 13 within roughly six to eight months.

“So like, six, eight months ago, it was like nine companies, it's 13 last time I looked.”

0:38:21 · Bryan Falchuk · Tesla valuation · 2022

Bryan Falchuk says Amazon, initially a bookseller, made outdoor furniture its first product expansion.

“just selling books and then they added like outdoor furniture was their first product expansion”

0:38:52 · Bryan Falchuk · Amazon history

Bryan Falchuk says the component businesses of Booking Holdings were huge money losers during the dot-com era of 1999 and 2000.

“Booking holdings. I just saw like they had a great quarter. You know, their component businesses in the dot com days, 99, 2000 were huge money losers.”

0:38:52 · Bryan Falchuk · Booking Holdings · 1999

Bryan Falchuk argues that no new startup record label has risen to rival majors such as Sony or BMG.

“there's no new record label that has suddenly become you know the likes of of a sony or bmg”

0:37:06 · Bryan Falchuk · Music industry

Bryan Falchuk names Wefox as a giant insurtech whose underlying economics he does not know well enough to judge.

“I don't know, like WeFox is another giant one. I don't know them well enough to know their underlying economics.”

0:39:47 · Bryan Falchuk · Insurtech unicorns · 2022

Alex Bond says an investor told them that of four embedded insurance investments, two made any money and only one was profitable.

“i spoke to someone that said they'd invested in like four embedded plays and they said like two of them were making any money at all yeah and only one of them was profitable”

0:41:23 · Alex Bond · Embedded insurance · 2022

Alex Bond cites Accelerant as an example of a newer model in which an insurance carrier acts like a hedge fund with a pool of underwriting capacity.

“carriers acting like almost like a hedge fund and say right we've got this pot of capacity and yeah we've already seen people like accelerant come in with”

0:42:52 · Alex Bond · Carrier models · 2022

Chapters

  1. 0:01:10Bryan Falchuk's background and mission

    Establishes the guest's two decades in property and casualty insurance and why they publish thought leadership on its future.

    “I'm an insurance industry veteran”
  2. 0:04:15Funding pressure forces genuine reasons to exist

    Explains how the 2022 funding squeeze pushed insurtechs toward specific, real problems rather than hype.

    “it's forced a rationalization where underlying economics matter”
  3. 0:08:58Legacy insurers get risk right, newcomers get experience right

    Argues both sides are arrogant and that underwriting skill is the real path to profit.

    “scale makes you worse, not better”
  4. 0:12:55Founding teams need healthy tension

    Discusses why mixing insurance and tech backgrounds, and honest challenge from boards and mentors, improves decisions.

    “tension is valuable, it's invaluable, whether it's different backgrounds, different styles”
  5. 0:19:44When distribution relationships hurt customers

    A New York carrier's agent-delivered paper checks show how protecting a distribution channel can slow claims for customers.

    “they were afraid of disintermediation”
  6. 0:26:45Slow change is a choice: the USAA example

    Shows with COVID that timelines insurers call fixed can collapse when they have to.

    “going to be 18 months before they even had a sense”
  7. 0:30:10Clients now ask to be challenged

    Falchuk says demand has shifted from tactical recommendations to boards wanting their assumptions challenged.

    “What I'm finding now is people are really curious for challenge.”
  8. 0:39:18Will a giant insurtech emerge?

    Compares insurance with music, cars and Amazon to argue prediction is hard and acquisition is likely.

    “many of them are more likely to be acquired”
  9. 0:42:18Embedded insurance and the real disruption

    Debates whether embedded sales are profitable or convenient enough to change how people buy insurance.

    “the travel insurance is 23 pounds and you could get it for 19 yourself”

Transcript

0:00:09
Alex Bond

Good morning and welcome to the Leadership and Insurance podcast. I'm your host Alex Bond and I'm very lucky today to be joined by Bryan Falchuk who is a founder and management partner of Insurance Evolution Partners but as I think we'll find out he's a lot more than that as well published author one of the futurists looking at kind of the future of insure tech looking at the current state of insure techs many many things and we always enjoy his content over the leadership insurance podcast so we you know we throw out we always say that we're very lucky but today i do feel very lucky so Bryan welcome to the podcast thank you thank you for

0:00:46
Bryan Falchuk

having me and uh hopefully i don't like steal all your luck and trash it i've got a lot to live up

0:00:51
Alex Bond

too now. Yeah, I know. I feel a bit mean that I've given you that much of a hype. No pressure. That's a difficult place to start. But Bryan, before we dive in, we obviously, we know you are, we follow your content. But just in case the folks that are listening, you know, aren't aware, how would you put yourself in what you do and particularly what you do at Insurance Evolution

0:01:10
Bryan Falchuk

Partners or all the other things that you get up to? Yeah, it's not an easy thing to clarify. But I always say like I'm an insurance industry veteran. I've been around PNC for like 20 something years. And through that, I've spent time at carriers, consulting, insurtechs. And it's given me a really, I think, somewhat unique, but interested, more so perhaps an interesting, but interested perspective on where the industry is and where it could go. I like solving problems and I like opportunity.

0:01:42

And so a few years back, I set up insurance evolution partners to try to help the industry engage in the possibility of change, whether that's some carriers I work with or insurtechs and kind of helping them navigate a bit of bringing their solutions into the industry and succeeding to help drive that change. And through that, I've been putting out a bunch of different thought leadership content. You mentioned I'm an author. So I've got a book series called the future of insurance podcast series called the future of insurance everything basically because i can't come up with other names called the future of insurance but it's really i just put all this stuff out there to give people something to engage in

0:02:18

to say you know is there something in my context we could do differently and maybe i can take a bit of inspiration from someone else who's done that so uh i you know just like getting the stories of different players at different parts of the industry who are overcoming all the barriers we all talk about every day to try to innovate and evolve.

0:02:37
Alex Bond

Awesome. Awesome. And that's what I'm looking forward to having this conversation because I think, you know, we talked a little bit just before we came on and usually we're talking about, you know, founders that have got a discrete solution. So it's really nice to have kind of a macro look at the industry. And particularly at the time, you know, we're recording this in the later stage of 2022. There's been a lot that's been happening. And obviously there's a lot that's going to happen as well next year.

0:03:03

So we'll probably make a bunch of predictions that won't happen. So I'm looking forward to that. So I wanted to look back at the year, particularly what we've seen sort of a trends perspective. So, I mean, the trend that we've kind of acknowledged on a macro level from the FinPro team is that the focus has been on underserved, underinsured markets. and the kind of opportunities that lie with kind of better customer needs. Do you, I mean, do you see the same kind of macro trend?

0:03:38

Is that what you've been kind of focusing on? Or what's been your overriding 2022 takeaway?

0:03:45
Bryan Falchuk

Yeah, well, so interestingly, I think, I mean, I think it's something I would agree with that I probably didn't even realize. You know, if I'm honest, I think looking back, a lot of the earlier insure tech activities were in, by and large, were in sort of broad brush spaces where someone, you know, looked at insurance, thought it was stupid, or the players were stupid or lazy or slow or whatever. And we can do better and maybe be a bit cheeky about it in the marketing and take advantage of that.

0:04:15

To different degrees of success, there's some players who really are just hype. And there's others who have a lot of hype, but actually their substance behind it and the results play out. But on the investing side, there was also a lot of hubris and hype. And so lots of things got funded that maybe shouldn't have big TAMs, big potential upside, but not necessarily able to seize on that. In this year where investing has been a lot tougher or it's been tougher to get investment dollars, I think that's, while it's been hard, it's also been a good thing because it's forced a rationalization where underlying economics matter.

0:04:49

but also having a genuine reason for being matters. And so I think, to your point, that's why we get to see some more, maybe you can call them niche-y kind of solutions or at least more specific, like there's a reason why this exists or needs to exist rather than it's doing the same thing that someone else has been doing for hundreds of years, but their slate was clean. So they're not starting with legacy tech. Like that's not actually, to me, a material advantage because the day you start, your tech starts to, your slate's no longer clean.

0:05:20

And so someone else could just come along a year later and be like, well, we've got an even cleaner slate, so now we're better. So when you have folks who are trying to serve underserved markets or create solutions where there wasn't one before, yet there was a need, someone is suffering and we actually have a mechanism to speak to that, or there's a gap in the customer experience or customer journey or how agents or brokers can do their work and no one's really been solving for that i think you've seen people looking for genuine reasons for being and the same thing on the buyer side and the investor side where just being new tech that's not enough to get funding

0:05:58

or buyers anymore so i think it sort of maybe comes from that rationalization and frankly it's nice to see because we need that and you're solving genuine

0:06:08
Alex Bond

problems. Yeah. Yeah. I think it's so true. It's really interesting. The earlier, very big, very large insured techs. And I wrote an article back to the other day that said, yeah, the second you start, as you said, you're getting tech debt. But the other point I kind of wanted to make on the tech debt conversation and legacy tech as people kind of want to talk about is that I think if you come from tech and come into insurance you can overplay the impact of that tech on things like profitability on things like actually the customer experience because a lot of the tech that we're aware of being bad uh we're aware because we're industry people we're not aware as a

0:06:53

customer not necessarily you can change the front end relatively quickly what we're usually talking about is the mechanics in the back end you know uh how can we access our data are we recording the right data but as a customer i don't care like i don't really if your house is not in order a big carrier as long as you can pay my claim i don't really care um so i think sometimes some of the emphasis was so heavily on i know a lot of it was a customer experience but i felt like customer experience was something that you can probably change quicker if you're a b2c player in insurance than you can anything to do with the back end

0:07:30

and there was a slight overplaying of that hand and saying whereas what they weren't taking into account which was we've seen they might have not been great at tech but they're really good at managing risk that's why they've

0:07:41
Bryan Falchuk

been around for 200 years 300 years yeah and that's the hard bit um and so you know i talked about that actually is the opening salvo in my first book um which was looking at all legacy players who had done something interesting and kind of innovative because by and large, and it's not to say they've always been stellar underwriters or haven't had hard times, you know, a lot of them going through that right now. But they have gotten the hard parts right.

0:08:07

And the easy bits they've not gotten is right. And that's more on the CX and the digital journey kind of things that have become much more front and center, but they're learning and they're getting better. And actually those are far, when I call them easy, it's not that they're easy, but they're much easier to make progress on. And they're easier to get right because we have a lot of answers for them today. Ultimately, you could say, well, we have answers for underwriting because we've been doing it forever.

0:08:31

Well, if that was the case, we wouldn't have some who lose money and some who make money. We've already learned the lesson that accuracy and rating is unbelievably powerful. And that's the path to profitability. Yet, plenty of folks struggle with that. And we still seem to have some players out there, newer players in particular, who think that selling a dollar or a euro or a pound or a yen or whatever of coverage for 20 cents is somehow some brilliant new idea.

0:08:58

No, it's still a wild money loser. No matter how cool your brand looks, how great your tech is, that is not sustainable. And unlike tech and B2C, you know, retail kind of things, scale makes you worse, not better. So you don't outgrow bad underwriting to, I mean, look, to an extent because your book starts smoothing. And there are things that small books just inherently are problematic because one loss can blow the whole thing up. But if you're fundamentally bad underwriters, getting bigger just makes you fundamentally a worse underwriter.

0:09:31

So for a lot of them, it's like, well, it's just because we're growing. No, that's actually not the problem. You are fundamentally broken as an insurer, but let's not swear them off because there's lots to learn from them. And I think that's actually something where the industry needs to do better is we have hubris on both sides. Hubris from the insure techs for, oh, these dinosaurs, they don't know what they're doing. Well, they do know some things they're doing.

0:09:53

You best learn from them on those things and do better on the other things. And the dinosaurs, the legacy folks, which I count myself in that bucket, we also can learn from these insure techs or these newer players, whether we think they're viable or not. Surely there are things that really we should be learning from, even just the mentality of being willing to try things and fail and learn. And a lot of us need to get more comfortable with that.

0:10:17

So I think ultimately the biggest shift I would like to see, and I know you didn't ask me this, but it's a mentality shift. And I think we've got examples on both sides that speak to that, whether it's the hard stuff or the easy stuff.

0:10:31
Alex Bond

I think I've seen that play out, and I'd be interested to get your take on this. So, you know, we specialize in providing senior hires into earlier stage businesses. So we're typically working through C throughout series B. The complexion and the makeup of the teams that I'm working with now, as opposed to three years ago, three years ago, it would be some tech entrepreneur coming into insurance and, you know, we might be hiring them their first insurance hire, but they're already up and running.

0:11:03

They've already structurally up and running. The teams I'm working with now tend to be, there's an insurance founding partner, and then there's a tech founding partner and they've come together to go right we're going to solve a problem in the market or there are there are more insurance heavy knowledge and they're acknowledging a problem and then they're hiring in tech talent so the change has been

0:11:27
Bryan Falchuk

subtle but significant is is that something i totally agree with you um and i i think i think it's it's not that subtle because if you're talking about a founding team of two to four people if none of them versus one or two of them has an insurance background that's actually quite profound and I think I think you've seen a few where it's pure insurance folks and that's okay but my concern there is are you you know has has your horizon been open enough are you willing to be as tough on the things we've always done and think in totally new ways or structuring your thoughts very differently.

0:12:04

So I, what I love to see is the mix. And then to think about, you know, how are they kind of coming together symbiotically or not? And, and is there actually a power play where one side is winning out more than the other? So I agree with you, I have seen a shift. And then I looked deeper within that. And as I'm sure you do, too, and you're thinking of placing someone or not is, how are they going to work together and challenge each other, and support each other.

0:12:30

And, you know, I talked to some VCs who were like, we really look at the dynamics of the leadership team. And, you know, one of the VCs who told me that was bringing up a particular startup as an example of how great it can be. And I was like, well, I've actually done quite a bit of work with that startup. And I know the leadership team is three old friends who've worked together forever. They've done other startups together and they're always on the same page.

0:12:55

And when they disagree, they're disagreeing in unison. You know, they're all disagreeing with something they did. There isn't actually that healthy tension, because they've almost gotten too comfortable with each other. So I think you need to look for that and make sure it's survivable tension. But tension is valuable, it's invaluable, whether it's different backgrounds, different styles, different, you know, focus areas. But I think you're seeing more of that these days than you did with the sort of gen one insure techs in the mid to late 20 teens as the word insure tech was

0:13:28
Alex Bond

starting to come to be yeah yeah as we were still trying to debate how to spell it does it have an

0:13:33
Bryan Falchuk

e or not i like efficiency so i don't i don't put the e in there but you know caribou honig disagrees

0:13:39
Alex Bond

with me so that's his that's his prerogative yeah i know um that always throws me out with the itc um but uh but no i don't i don't put the e in there either but i think that's um you and i exchanged on something I put up on LinkedIn the other day which is about mentors which is the same kind of type of thinking was that I think now if you're an insurance professional and you've got a mentor and you're looking to what your future career should look like I worry if your mentor is a industry insurance veteran and that's and that's your only reference point um now obviously it was me getting a bit bent out of shape because

0:14:16

I was headhunting someone and they said no but i just it was it just it did make me think i mean if you're if you're talking to some industry veteran senior underwriter and and we've got an underwriting proposition which looks a bit unusual i think if that's our only reference point you're always going to turn it down that doesn't mean that's not the right decision but there's no challenge in thought process yeah and it's the same for founding teams if you don't have and if they don't have equal weight in like you say if if you're a tech driven, the tech driven teams I saw, and then they would bring that insurance person in, that insurance person is not on

0:14:54

an equal footing. So they're not there to kind of give feedback. So, I mean, but I mean the makeup of teams is essential in the success of startups anyways. So healthy tension, I think it's a really lovely way of putting it.

0:15:06
Bryan Falchuk

And at the board level as well. And the advisory board, I mean, I think the word mentor, like let's broaden that out to all the different contexts where we get to have mentoring. And, you know, I think it's just as dangerous for a board to be complacent as it is for them to be adversarial. You can't survive if your board is just fighting everything and making it really difficult. You have to ask yourself why. Is it the board or is it you?

0:15:30

Could be either side. But equally, you're also going to fail if your board is just rubber stamping everything. I think you need a healthy tension and you need a good relationship whether it's your advisory board or your board board or your mentor your sort of career board if you will or just in life you know your your friendships your relationships your life board um we need to find people who think like us and don't think like us and have our context and don't have our context context and and sort of ask around yeah yeah that's a

0:16:02
Alex Bond

yeah i i was thinking about the friendship thing uh that came up in conversation conversation um i was out with a friend last night and he basically disagreed me on something that i'd done in my personal life and um that's why he's a good friend of mine yeah he was right exactly showing that mirror to me and everyone else hadn't picked it up and they said he was like i know i don't think you did the right thing here anyway yeah okay you know it was it was it was it was interesting and healthy yeah i want to i want to talk to you about something that a previous guest had said uh and i think i think this is

0:16:34

interesting because i saw this the piece you did about customer experience and i think this will probably play into that um we had a guest on previously um i want to say it's herman for and i'm not sure but i'll check and i'll put it back in the notes but they said that the broker is the only true customer of the insurance industry were they in the uk no they were they were in europe um and they felt that the they felt the insurance industry completely built around the broker do you think that's true um i think in

0:17:04
Bryan Falchuk

some markets yeah yeah um and i think i mean like having having worked at a global carrier like when i was at hiscox um i was i was squarely in the u.s business then but you know my peers uh running claims for the european continent i mean it's almost a foolish term to say like head of european claims because every market is so different and it does boil down largely to the distribution prevalence, you know, where some markets are really heavily broker driven, and some markets have really accepted bank assurance or direct sales or what have you.

0:17:43

And you see that pervasive in what the customer experience is about what people's expectations are, what sort of staffing we would need to have to support them through the claim. And so I'm trying to think if it was like German, the German market was very broker driven, if I'm remembering right. And apologies to any German listeners who are like, no, that's not correct at all. But I think it is. You really must be thinking about how you work with the brokers through those claims or any other part of the process.

0:18:11

And then, and I'm probably going to get one of these examples wrong, but I think it was Spain was more open to direct sales. And so you needed to think about your, you know, your, your sort of DTC offering and support capabilities. You like UK, there's a very strong agent broker community. And there's a very strong direct line wouldn't exist if there was no direct sales and bank assurance. And I mean, Tesco selling insurance. I can't imagine a supermarket chain in the US selling insurance and lots of other non-food things.

0:18:46

I think it is a local market question. Obviously, there's some markets that are similar, but then you have to ask yourself, how much is this the right answer and how much is, is this a sort of defense of the past answer? So that to, to add some color to that, you know, in the U S we've got in personal lines and 40 something percent are still agents sold, but in commercial lines, quite a bit more. And I was doing some work for a small regional carrier in, in New York state that's agent distributed.

0:19:17

And this was early days of lockdowns where like, you know, you couldn't have two human beings that didn't live together already in the same building at the same time, basically. And so they had very old tech, did a lot of things through checks to pay insureds in claims. And the reason was the agents really insisted on getting a paper check, driving out to the insured and delivering it because they wanted to be the savior. They want to be the hero for the insured.

0:19:44

And frankly, they didn't want the insurance company getting any of that credit because they were afraid of disintermediation. So they held really firm on that, which meant in COVID, you had the claim adjuster who had to figure out how much to pay. So they're in the office because their systems didn't work remotely. And then they'd all have to be out of the office one day for the check processing people in finance to come in to process those payments.

0:20:09

So however long the claim needs to come to a determination, then add at least one day for that check, the check producer, but then the head of claims has to sign every single payment. There was no minimum threshold, which is, you know, that's something that could be fixed. So that adds another day. And then someone else in the mail room has to actually mail the checkout to the agent and the mail's running, you know, the post is running slow.

0:20:32

So like now we're talking five to eight days, not business, but days that have elapsed since we figured out we have to pay 10 grand to this person. to then go to the agent. The agent has to drive out to see the insured who those days may not have wanted the agent coming to see them to give them the money. What's that, two weeks maybe since the determination was made, let alone when the actual loss occurred, that business may be out of business by now.

0:20:59

And that's very much a case of very strong distribution relationship and paradigm there in that part of the market that's completely failing to realize the impact on the customer and that is a case of the industry's built around that distribution decision. And I think it's a bit like the music industry in the early days or the publishing industry fighting against Amazon where consumers have clearly said they want something different. And because that something different feels dangerous to us, we're gonna make that impossible and we're gonna make them suffer, but at least we get to hold on to what we have.

0:21:36

That never works out in the longterm. forcing people to have a bad experience because you want to keep things the way you have things might work today might work for a few more days but ultimately people are going to start pirating music and apple and spotify will own everything which is exactly what the music industry was afraid of you know amazon will rise to basically controlling book distribution which they kind of do certainly book sales as an author i can tell you like it's basically amazon or nowhere else Yeah.

0:22:07

These are all the things that those traditional folks said, we never want to see that. So we're going to lock in and make it impossible. That doesn't work out ultimately. So even if that's how the market is, those players that those agents should be thinking, well, how can I stay relevant and important and valuable, but not because I've made it so difficult for them to do anything else. don't don't make your customers hate you in the process of defending your existence find another way um and i think that's the challenge we need to give ourselves doesn't mean distribution changes or cx changes per se but we do need to be more open to rethinking that

0:22:44
Alex Bond

i mean i i think one of the interesting misnomers for people discussing particularly the outside looking in the insurance industry particularly carriers i think i i think look at carriers and brokers slightly differently i think i think brokers i've seen much more resistance because they own that relationship and and you're right like the middle they are the middle person and the middle person is always at risk uh every year i've been in business in my business i've been told i'm gonna be out of a job uh first it was because monster existed and then it was because linkedin exists um and and and it has changed my role like it has changed my role um we have to embrace that

0:23:24

tech i have to add value in different ways you know there's a reason i do a podcast there's a reason there's a reason we have a networking platform for women in insure tech um you know these things are kind of adding value on top of kind of traditional services but i think the carrier um community largely i haven't seen a resistance to change the people are you know for example we talk about tech debt the person that knows how much tech debt there is an insurance insurance carrier is the cto they're not sitting there going oh we're unaware of our tech yeah we're like we just can't press a button and change it today because we have all the stuff

0:24:02

so i think culturally it's been interesting to me um is that something that you've seen i don't see this big resistance i just see a sort of lack of ability to uh maybe even lack of knowledge or lack

0:24:15
Bryan Falchuk

of creativity to go in the right direction yeah well so i think it's it's a bit of that um and i think it's uh i think you're right that they do realize like yeah this is a problem um but then it's it's the choice that comes in after that so the choice to say but we can't because and we sort of like i mean it's like mansplaining like we mansplained like well you don't understand And this is much harder than you think.

0:24:43

So we can't just do that. It's like, well, okay, but these folks over here are doing that. So maybe you can. And the other side of it is, even when there is an acceptance, I hear things from carriers that are like, you know, yes, we made a decision. We're going to move ahead. But just so you understand, it's going to be at least 18 months before this even begins, because that's just the way we work. And like, for you to make that last statement, that's the choice.

0:25:08

It doesn't just have to be the way. I always say if someone says just watch out for what's about to come because it's a gross underrepresentation of the real situation. And I think there are moments where we actually could do things differently. You know, maybe it's like you said, we can put an outward facing CX layer on top of legacy tech. The tools are there. They're quite lightweight, easy to deploy. But actually for some CTOs or CIOs, like that's too cheap.

0:25:33

It must not be able to do it. So it doesn't have to be $80 million. It could be $50 ,000. you know but it's like well clearly that's not good enough or there's something wrong with it so we're not going to look at that these are all choices of how we engage and I think that's what's exciting is that's something and that's part of what my work is about is I need to chip away at that we all need to chip away at that but it's not for impossibility and I do think you're right generally in the carrier space not 100 but there is an understanding and an acceptance it's now for us to start to challenge how much we

0:26:10

can and can't do or how fast we can do it. And COVID actually was a brilliant reminder because, you know, I share this in my first book. I talk about USAA, you know, this like $28 billion PNC business roughly. At the beginning of 2020, they had scoped a project to begin at the end of the year, like Q3, to look at remote work. So nine months from now, we're going to start looking at this. they said it's going to be a kind of six to 12 month initiative to then make a recommendation for what they could or couldn't do and how they could or couldn't do it so 18 months roughly speaking till they had some sense of the art

0:26:45

of the possible and where to move ahead but it would be like a 2022 implementation then of course march comes covet hits and they weren't one of these like tomorrow morning we're all remote it took them five days but it took them five days where they said it was going to be 18 months before they even had a sense of the answer. And that was like, yes, it was hard. People burnt out. And I'm expanding this out to every one of these Herculean, you know, super fast efforts.

0:27:11

It might've been done with a bit of duct tape and hamster wheels and whatever else, but we did things super rapidly that allowed us to keep processing business and handling claims and what have you. I don't want us to forget that. So now the question is, how can we do these things in more sustainable ways so that people aren't burning out? Or we're not, you know, just layering on all of this disparate tech and it's barely standing up anymore.

0:27:35

But we can't just fall back and be like, yeah, you know, that's, we'll put that on the two year horizon and we'll investigate it for a year and a half. It's like, that's not the world anymore. And it doesn't have to be your reality. So that's a choose your own adventure kind of shift.

0:27:50
Alex Bond

yeah that is in front of us the pandemic did a really interesting thing for large companies because that that that's the perfect example that that that can we work from home it's creating actually environment of entrepreneurship because entrepreneurship is yeah you have to make decisions you have to make them quickly you have to be able to change you have to be able to adapt um big companies don't have to do that most of the time yeah when you actually put those uh you know there's parameters in what's fascinating is how well everyone rose to the occasion yeah and and good enough is is good enough but you know at a certain stage you know it doesn't mean that you kind

0:28:32

of that's that's the goal but you know one of my things is that i've had various businesses um not and they're not all uh particularly you know i've owned a shop and owned a retail you know brand and and that's not on the linkedin page but yeah so friends will go oh i need i want to start this business and i you know the answer is always just start it's just like just start just go oh it's not going to be perfect if you wait for it to perfect you'll never do it and so like the kind of rollouts um of anything in insurance you know and i worked in insurance there's this big kind of conversation about this new

0:29:05

claims technology and it took forever to roll out and when it rolled out it was really bad but if they rolled it out in a couple of months and then this is bad let's change it you know all of that time could be spent getting it right right but it was trying to get it perfect ahead of time um have talking about your work um what's changed in terms of what people are interested in because you're there to support them for a change right and advise yeah you started three years ago i'm interested to see the kind of journey of what conversations you were having then to what your conversation

0:29:40
Bryan Falchuk

um so i've actually been reflecting on this lately um because i've noticed a difference in the outreach i get for speaking and and other other things um i think early days in my work it was a lot more about something more point specific and tactical maybe the wrong word but it was like we're struggling with this what do we do about it you know do some analysis give us a recommendation come in and speak to us about these kinds of things in this particular area.

0:30:10

And like, that's all fine. What I'm finding now is people are really curious for challenge. So, you know, come and speak to our board about what's changing in our space or around our space that wouldn't necessarily be a one-to-one analog here. Like I spoke at a board meeting for a workers' compensation carrier, and they wanted to know, what are some early brewing things changing in workers' comp? And I said, so I gave him a few things there.

0:30:38

I said, but I want you to be aware of this thing that's happening over here. It's not directly relevant to your business. And we can talk about why that is and why it isn't. But I want you to see the shift in the dynamic and what it means to that legacy area, because there's actually things that could happen similarly in workers' comp. And I want you aware of that because you should all be curious and think about it.

0:31:00

And I see people eating that up now. I've done some talks for a particular core system provider at some of their client events, and they were really, really clear. They're like, we want things that people may not agree with. We want things that people have a feeling about one way or the other, and they're willing to engage with. because if nothing else, even if they come to the same answer they have today that like, oh no, this is never going to happen.

0:31:27

At least they've challenged their thinking to engage in it and to wonder, you know, what if, or what would we need if, and that's sort of how I position a lot of these things is let's suspend disbelief for just a moment because you could be totally against this and say it won't play out and that's fine. But what if it did, what are things you would need to have from an enablement standpoint, from a capability standpoint to respond to that?

0:31:48

and then ask yourself, should we be investing in those things anyway? And that was sort of the idea with that comp carrier is like, this may never play out for you and that's fine. But if it did, what would you need to respond to that? And if something similar were to happen, would those same enablers pay dividends? And so that's the question you should ask yourself is, are we investing in the right kind of things for the potential threats and opportunities that hit us?

0:32:11

And I've seen, especially this year, much more engagement in like, can you challenge us? Can you tell us about things that may make most of us put our head in the sand or be like, yeah, that's ridiculous. And it's fine. It may be. But if we're not thinking about these things, that sort of exercise that forces us to broaden our perspective a bit, we're probably going to end up missing something that was right in front of us otherwise.

0:32:36

So that's different. And I prefer that. I don't like giving people specific recommendations on like you need this tech or this solution provider or what have you. And sometimes people get frustrated with me that I don't tell them like no sign with these folks. And there's a right answer for every RFP and that's fine. But like, that's not what we should be engaging. And that's what your RFP process is for. I want to talk about your values, your culture, your thinking, your challenge, because that's the stuff that will ultimately lead you to success or failure.

0:33:06

And I've seen more happiness to engage in that and request for that in the past year or so.

0:33:13
Alex Bond

isn't that i think i was just smiling when you were sort of talking through because all i could think about you know i'm a big proponent of having personal therapy i i have therapy every week i'm a big fan of it it's it's the it's the mental um personal trainer you know that's the way i've always looked at it and as you're doing that i'm thinking most of the time mine's about it's about challenging my thought process it's about challenging what i believe about the world um and the point is that my my therapist always says well i'm never here to give you answers like a specific answers that you have to work out anyway i was like you're basically

0:33:51

doing Bryan you're doing business therapy with these people you're going look all we can do is challenge your thinking um because they've got you can't being prescriptive never works um everyone's got to be on board you know one of the things that i see which is still challenging I was you know there's a very large American insurer that I've done some work for they invest in lots of funds and the reason they invest in funds is they're very transparent we want to see all the new tech we want to see all the new ideas we want to have a an awareness of that and that's the easiest way for us to see it but then interestingly it's controlled by a

0:34:30

very small team so it has no visibility into the broader business and my argument I mean is you know what do I know about running a multinational tens of thousands of persons business but i said that is kind of meaningless if it's not being made aware so let's say you're looking at claims tech if your global claims director isn't seeing that yeah you know what what what impact does it actually have so uh it's interesting to hear that you're having those conversations at at a sort of more expanded level and i think generally i'm seeing that i'm seeing initiatives supported more by senior uh

0:35:06
Bryan Falchuk

C-suite execs. Yeah. Yeah. It's still very senior though. Yeah. It's rare. You know, I did, I did a talk at the beginning of 2022 for carrier and they asked me to do it twice once for their senior leadership team, plus like director. So it was about 30 people. So definitely more than, you know, the C-suite, but then they had me do it later in the day for like 90 people. And that was sort of like mid-level manager group.

0:35:32

And that's the only time I've seen that happen where it was like, we actually need everyone talking about it. And it's like, yeah. And if you're looking at a solution to invest in or otherwise, why don't you have line adjusters and underwriters in those meetings? Because they're the ones who would actually be customers or users of this. Or they're the ones who are at the coalface with the customers or the brokers or whoever to understand whether like, is that a problem or is that just some tech?

0:35:56

You know, and like engage them in it. And the dividends that pays for what they then are able to do for all the people around them. um i used to bring adjusters with me to you know to sit with some of the startups and it was like all right we're going to we work for the first time and have you ever seen like you know the kombucha tap and whatever like it sounds silly but actually it's just getting them out of the context they're in seeing something totally different with people who don't come from their background get them to engage in it um you may learn something about that solution but you may

0:36:28
Alex Bond

learn more about the person that you just brought in do you um shifting gears slightly so what we've both sort of sort of said that we're reflecting on is we're seeing a lot more discrete solutions right that are working with the industry so that's that's a trend i think is going to continue do you think the biggest insure techs as we define them are yet to come like i feel like we're building with all these discrete insure techs the blueprint of the modern insurer is like our eyes is there do you think there'll be that that huge player that comes in that really gets all this right or am i just slightly deluded enough yeah like is there an

0:37:06
Bryan Falchuk

aviva 2.0 brewing or or state farm yeah yeah um well this is one of those moments we get to make a prediction and hopefully no one ever well hopefully anyone listening like it'll be long since retired hopefully still alive before any of this would have i i mean i think this is a case of um i honestly have no idea and i think um you know there's other industries where we could have done the same thing and been dead wrong so you know i mentioned the music industry there's no new record label that has suddenly become you know the likes of of a sony or bmg maybe that's the same company.

0:37:45

I don't even know now. There's been consolidation, but you haven't seen a true startup that has risen to the top of a major. You look in the auto industry, let's rewind 15, 20 years, whatever it was. Is there going to be a startup car company that rises to preeminence? Absolutely not. The barriers to entry, the fixed costs. And now we have the most valuable car company by a factor of many multiples was a startup. You know, Tesla's every time I check the how much how many of the next public car makers is Tesla worth more than every time I look, it's another one.

0:38:21

So like, six, eight months ago, it was like nine companies, it's 13 last time I looked. And so like, their their value advantage is increasing. So they're getting better at the value game, not worse. Would anyone have said that 20 years ago? Probably not. Do I think Ribbian or Lucid are the next ones? Probably not, but I don't know. And so I think it's really hard to make a prediction like that reasonably because we don't know what will change.

0:38:52

Like Amazon, I mean, just selling books and then they added like outdoor furniture was their first product expansion. You're like, these people are idiots. Like, what are they? This makes no sense. And they're losing so much money and they're all going to die. Booking holdings. I just saw like they had a great quarter. You know, their component businesses in the dot com days, 99, 2000 were huge money losers. And it's like, yeah, that's but look, look today.

0:39:18

And so would we have made those right calls? I think we over egged on some we under egged on others. So I don't know. I do think it's hard. And I think many of them are more likely to be acquired because of the scale of capital that exists in the legacy world. I think that's a mixed bag. I think for some of those acquisitions, it could create great possibility by the combination. I think chances are it will stifle more possibility than it creates, but I could be wrong on that too.

0:39:47

And there may be one or two who do rise to preeminence. I don't think the ones that will do that are the ones we're seeing talked about the most right now. At least one or two in particular I can think of. I don't know, like WeFox is another giant one. I don't know them well enough to know their underlying economics. But I think the sort of mega unicorns that we see, I haven't seen the right unit economics in the pure underwriting sense to suggest that like, that is going to be the next Aviva.

0:40:19

You know, we're so many years on hundreds of billions of assets. I have a very hard time seeing that because they're not accruing those assets as a viable carrier would need to and they're carriers now they're not just mgas so i don't know so my answer is like don't call me out either way because i don't know

0:40:39
Alex Bond

i i think your your music industry analogy was or or observation was probably the closest to how i think about it that if you look at the disruption in the music industry that happened to the labels it wasn't that there was another label it was just the distribution of music change right and so in insurance it's it's that seems the most likely threat is that actually just the way that people purchase or engage with insurance is fundamentally changed yeah embedded obviously um we joked before we came on that you know if i had to talk about embedded again i might go slightly mad but but the reason it's so exciting as a proposition is because of the way that we

0:41:23

currently it challenges how we currently buy insurance yeah having said that the one thing i wanted to see was the data on how much you know i i spoke to someone that said they'd invested in like four embedded plays and they said like two of them were making any money at all yeah and only one of them was profitable um how many people are actually buying via embedded solutions currently but it makes sense it's one of those that makes sense but i still don't think is that i'm bearing in mind what we do for a living talk about it all the time i still don't buy anything for an embedded model um because i don't trust it i'm like i'm

0:42:02

probably overpaying because every time i look at an embedded solution i'm usually overpaying i can usually get it cheaper by going somewhere else so you know i did this with my phone just recently they tried to sell me some embedded your mobile phone insurance travel insurance is exactly the same you know so but

0:42:18
Bryan Falchuk

it's the it's the cost of the the process of looking for yourself so if the travel insurance is 23 pounds and you could get it for 19 yourself it's like yeah but i gotta re-enter like so that's the choice that is what's convenience worth yes and you find actually in travel insurance the embedded offering does so much better than the standalone ever did um but but maybe you get it through your your credit card um so then that's i don't buy it because i know i've got it if i use you know card x and so i don't i don't need to spend or worry about it yeah yeah so i think but

0:42:52
Alex Bond

i but i i see the true disruption the true kind of change in evolution is rather than i think we'll see a new carrier i think we'll see loads of new carriers but whether they're any better i think the carriers have got very very good at what they do um they can just get better at it and maybe the rise more of carriers acting like almost like a hedge fund and say right we've got this pot of capacity and yeah we've already seen people like accelerant come in with that's quite an interesting model yes yeah and and and i think we'll just see more players like that um so yeah interesting um well i'm really conscious of time and i

0:43:28

don't want to overstate our welcome i appreciate that i've gone completely off script and asked you hardly any of the questions that i pre-agreed to ask you. I hated the questions anyway, so this worked. No. It was a good conversation though. But Bryan, I want to give you the opportunity to kind of talk about what's coming up for you. Are you doing any speaking engagements? What's the best way to people to reach out to you?

0:43:53
Bryan Falchuk

Yeah. There's always new ideas that flash into my head. And then I'm really lucky that I've gotten great opportunities to share them with people. I think I'm recovering from being on the road a bit. So there's nothing like pressing right now. But I'm sure that'll pick up again, starting, well, I know, starting in January. But, you know, I've got all these signs behind me that the easiest way for people to engage in what I put out there other than LinkedIn, which is how you and I connected, is at future-of-insurance.com.

0:44:22

I try to put from a thought leadership standpoint, I try to like, bang everything in there, the podcast, the books, papers that I put out and I try to get as much of it out for free. Obviously the books aren't. If you have a, like a Kindle select subscription, I think they're free, but otherwise like my intention is just to spark the industry thinking and engaging in this stuff. So there is a lot you can consume and I hope people do.

0:44:46

And by the way, I hope you disagree with me or challenge or think of something else and reach out about it. You know, people hit me up on LinkedIn or Twitter or whatever. As long as I'm still on twitter which i don't know how much longer that'll be but at least for today i am um i'm not i'm anti cesspool generally so we need to see how this all plays out but um yeah engage you know let's talk about it i think you're allowed on twitter as long as you're not

0:45:10
Alex Bond

rude about mr musk otherwise you're all yeah that's true or pretending to be him that's uh apparently that's how you get it i've never seen a man with so much money be so sensitive um it's quite seen that a couple times but yeah he might be well not quite as much money you know Yeah, right. No one like that. Surely with that much money, you can build a moat around your ego, but seemingly not. Bryan, thank you so much.

0:45:34

It's been a really enjoyable conversation. And I'm glad we got the chance to do this. So thank you so much for your time. Yes, good fun. Thanks, Alex. Thanks, man. you