# Guiding The Future of Insurance : An Interview with Bruce Carnegie Brown, Chairman at Lloyd's of London

- **Show:** The Leadership in Insurance Podcast
- **Published:** 1 Aug 2022
- **Source:** https://shows.acast.com/theleadershipininsurancepodcast/episodes/guiding-the-future-of-insurance-an-interview-with-bruce-carn
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/leadership-in-insurance/guiding-the-future-of-insurance-an-interview-with-bruce-carnegie-brown-chairman-bc46b3/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

Insurance innovation is not just technology. It means steadily improving existing processes and creating products for new, unmet customer needs. Bruce Carnegie Brown, Chairman of Lloyd's of London, argues that insurers must tackle confidence, cost and relevance to close the gap where people are underinsured, using digitisation, parametric cover, and climate and diversity commitments.

The central tension is between a 330-year-old, human, in-person market and pressure to automate and decentralise. Brown says the simple, high-volume end of insurance digitises quickly, while complex risks still need human judgment. He sees history as a continuum, and says progress also depends on better management, talent retention and honest accountability on diversity and climate.

## Key insights

1. **Insurance digitises slower than banking for structural reasons** Brown says banking digitised early because payments are about speed, while insurance depends on accurate claim evaluation and trust. Simple, high-volume consumer lines have gone digital first, while large commercial and reinsurance risks stay human-heavy.
2. **Process work, not advice, is what drives costs** Brown says brokers and underwriters spend too much time on process, and rework after risk is placed because documentation lags. Straight-through processing would cut costs and free them for advising customers.
3. **Lloyd's plans a managed transition, not fossil fuel exclusion** Brown says Lloyd's backs net zero by 2050 but wants a glide path without cliff edges. It still insures some fossil fuel projects while underwriting new areas like hydrogen and nuclear.
4. **Diversity targets show progress but still fall short** Brown says women in market leadership are at 30% against a 35% target for 2025, and ethnic-minority hiring is about one in six against a one-in-three goal. He also cites a large fine against a managing agent for behaviour dating to 2018.
5. **Parametric insurance can pay claims within a day** Brown explains that parametric cover pays when a measurable trigger such as a river level is hit, without a loss adjuster. This turns flood claims from a long queue into a payment the next day.

## Questions this episode answers

### What does innovation mean in insurance, according to Lloyd's chairman Bruce Carnegie Brown?

Brown says it has two parts: continuous improvement of existing processes and products, and creativity in addressing new risks and unmet customer needs. He stresses that everyday process improvement matters as much as flashy insurtech.

### Why do people buy less insurance than they need?

Brown says it comes down to three things: cost, confidence and relevance. Insurance is expensive to deliver, customers must trust a claim will be paid long after paying a premium, and their risks keep changing.

### What is parametric insurance and why does Brown like it?

It pays out when an agreed measure, such as a river reaching a set level, is hit, with no need to assess actual damage. Brown says this can put money in a customer's account the next day, instead of waiting for loss adjusters.

### Does Lloyd's still insure fossil fuels?

Brown says Lloyd's backs net zero by 2050 but wants a gradual glide path rather than a sudden cutoff, which he says would hurt people and supply chains. He says some support for new fossil projects can be justified while the world moves to renewables.

### What is the Lloyd's Lab?

Brown describes it as a programme that has run for about three years, with eight cohorts of ten startups each. It pairs startups with people in the market so they can find capacity and scale, while the market learns new ways of working.

## Facts

- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:02:17]: "I tumbled into banking out of university and spent the first 20 years of my life in the banking industry, most of that with J.P. Morgan, and then made a switch in 2003 to the insurance industry"
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:02:17]: "working first for Marsh, first in their UK business and then running the European operations of Marsh."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:02:55]: "took on the chairmanship of Lloyd's of London in 2017 and have been doing that ever since."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:02:55]: "I also sit on the board of the Santander Banking Group based in Madrid, so keep my hand in from a banking perspective."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:03:29]: "I chair a small startup business called Cover that has been growing very fast. It's a motor insurance app and has just completed a fundraise."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:03:29]: "And then in terms of non-work activities, I'm chairman of the MCC, so that takes up a huge amount of time but allows me to watch a lot of cricket."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:06:20]: "you get 92 quotes for your motor insurance in the space of two minutes."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:08:25]: "We now even have sensors that you put into ships and you can track them as they go through war zones and out of war zones."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:15:11]: "we've been doing kind of earthquakes for 200 years at Lloyd's."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:19:51]: "by having been around for 330 years, we've done some pretty good things over time to adapt to very changing circumstances."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:23:59]: "has been the first underwriter of motor insurance, has been the first underwriter of satellites being projected into space, has been the first underwriter of cyber insurance risks."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:25:07]: "25 % of our capital in the Lloyd's market is put behind underwriting natural catastrophes around the world."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:27:02]: "we've signed up actively for net zero by 2050."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:27:02]: "we chair the Prince of Wales Sustainable Markets Initiative for insurance."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:28:54]: "We've been insuring nuclear in the Lloyd's market for a number of years"
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:31:58]: "we wanted to see 35 % of women in leadership positions in the marketplace by 2025. We're at 30 % today."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:32:31]: "we've set a target for the marketplace of having one in three people hired into the market being from an ethnic minority background."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:33:01]: "in the marketplace we're probably at one in six."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:33:50]: "We had quite a big fine for one of the managing agents just a few months ago."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:35:16]: "we're now in our sixth year of doing that and that started at Lloyd's and now is extended annually to upward of 100 countries around the world"
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:41:48]: "We're now into our eighth cohort. We've had 10 startup businesses in each of those cohorts."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:43:18]: "If you have a parametric product that just says, I will pay you if the river gets to this level, I'm not even looking at whether you've had damage or not."
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:43:42]: "we've aligned a sensor business called Parcel with an underwriting syndicate here at Lloyd's to provide that insurance cover"
- **Bruce Carnegie Brown** [0:44:18]: "There's another one that you wouldn't have dreamed of a while ago called Gaia that is underwriting IVF fertility treatments"

## Transcript

**[0:00:01] Alex Bond:** Hello and welcome to the Leadership and Insurance podcast. This is the podcast that brings you the greatest innovation changemakers in the world of insurance and insurtech. We speak to innovation leaders from carriers and brokers. We speak to insurtech founders and c-suite executives and we bring you all of the people that add value to that community whether it be private equity, venture capitalists or even people like organizational psychologists and thought leaders and futurists. We try really hard to bring you the most innovative people in the world of insurance on a global basis.

**[0:00:34] Alex Bond:** So with that in mind, we'd love your support. So please like, share, follow or subscribe to wherever you get your podcasts. I'm your host Alex Bond. Welcome to the Leadership Insurance Podcast. This podcast is brought to you by FinPro. FinPro is a leading InsurTech specialist recruitment business that operates on a global basis. We have delivered assignments across North America, throughout Europe and into Asia. We are super excited to speak to anyone who has some recruitment challenges that is either starting or scaling a business and we're confident we can help you find the people to help you innovate the world of insurance one new hire at a time.

**[0:01:14] Alex Bond:** Please visit our website www.wearefinpro.com for more information. Good morning and welcome to the Leadership and Insurance podcast. I'm your host, Alex Bond, and I'm very lucky today, and I'm aware that I say that every week, but I'm very lucky to be one in the Lloyd's Lab and secondly with my guest Bruce Carnegie Brown. Bruce, good morning. Nice to be here. Yeah, well thank you very, very much and as we always say, I could do a potted history of your background but it's probably better to hear it from you.

**[0:02:08] Alex Bond:** So it'd be great for you to introduce yourself to the cameras and your role here at Lloyd's and obviously a little bit about your journey to this point today.

**[0:02:17] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** Well, Alex, as you say, Bruce Carnegie Brown is my name. I tumbled into banking out of university and spent the first 20 years of my life in the banking industry, most of that with J.P. Morgan, and then made a switch in 2003 to the insurance industry, working first for Marsh, first in their UK business and then running the European operations of Marsh. I actually then had a spell in the private equity industry and during that time began to enjoy the sort of project nature of that work, working on a variety of different projects.

**[0:02:55] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** So after that I sort of moved into what people call a plural existence and most of my plural existence has been in either banking or insurance for obvious reasons. So I've worked for underwriting firms and the breaking firms in a non-executive capacity and then took on the chairmanship of Lloyd's of London in 2017 and have been doing that ever since. I also sit on the board of the Santander Banking Group based in Madrid, so keep my hand in from a banking perspective.

**[0:03:29] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And I chair a small startup business called Cover that has been growing very fast. It's a motor insurance app and has just completed a fundraise. and doing great work in the UK. And then in terms of non-work activities, I'm chairman of the MCC, so that takes up a huge amount of time but allows me to watch a lot of cricket.

**[0:03:57] Alex Bond:** I was going to say, that sounds slightly more fun than some of the other things. And Cover is one of those businesses, which is great from an insurtech recruiter's perspective to know I actually got to use it quite recently. I went to a wedding and my dad was very concerned about his car, but I managed to get insured on it for a short period of time. So, yeah, a shout out to cover, actually, because we talk about insured tech, but it's nice to actually be able to engage with one.

**[0:04:21] Alex Bond:** And the experience was really, really good. It was really easy. I wanted to talk to you about innovation. We're here in the lab. Innovation is what we sort of talk about here in the Lloyd's lab. I just want to start with a real general question of what innovation actually means to you.

**[0:04:38] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** I think innovation is essentially two things really. First it's about continuous improvement of existing processes and platforms and products. But secondly it's about creativity and I think thinking about new issues, new risks, new challenges that need to be addressed. Unmet needs of customers is a good way of framing it. And I think you need to move along both those axes. And sometimes the day-to-day process improvement is somewhat understated in an insure tech world, but it has every bit as important a role in making sure that insurance continues to be kind of relevant to its customers, really cost efficient in the way that it delivers its service, and improves the confidence of customers in our products.

**[0:05:25] Alex Bond:** It's interesting because we nearly started out the podcast going to the Leadership and Innovation podcast, or Innovation Insurance, and we were playing with that, but we were really concerned that I think innovation at some point got sort of hijacked to just talk about technology and it can't just be about technology and you know we're sitting here today and on the way in you know Lloyd's is a bit emptier because people are working remotely we're having kind of different working environments and you know that falls into the innovation bucket and we've changed the way that we work and you know I think it's pros and cons arguments for but I think most people are probably happier with this kind of flexible

**[0:05:59] Alex Bond:** working than we had so I think that's important. Talking about specifically insurance, what forms have you specifically seen in the insurance sector in terms of innovation? Where have you seen the kind of biggest leaps since you've taken on this role, particularly as a chairman of Lloyd's? Well actually in many ways the early

**[0:06:20] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** leaps for me came outside Lloyd's. So if you look at Money Supermarket where I sat on the board for a number of years, you look at how that's transformed the the motor insurance industry in the UK in the last 20 years. It's been quite extraordinary. And what you can do now is go online and you get 92 quotes for your motor insurance in the space of two minutes. And beforehand you had to go to a broker and it would be impossible for a broker to find 92 quotes for your business in two minutes and from which you then get to make an immediate choice.

**[0:06:53] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And so you think about the transformation of technology, in this case particularly the internet and digitization of processes. You then move to something like Cover. And Cover, you talked about Cover being an app that is really convenient to use but of course it's entirely digitally based and it's on your phone and it allows you to get covered for motor insurance for reasonably short periods of time with great efficiency. And if you look at the traditional ways of selling motor insurance it's a 12-month policy that you renew once a year and And again, this would not have been possible without progress around technology.

**[0:07:27] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** But it's also around all the other things, as you suggest, the non-technology things of customer service and understanding customer needs and trying to provide a different product for a different service. So we live our lives today much more in a subscription place than an ownership place today than was certainly true even 10 years ago. And applications that respond to that have a real purpose. I think this is beginning to infect our thinking about a traditional market like Lloyd's.

**[0:07:56] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** If you think about cargoes and shipping coming together at reasonably short notice, adapting the covers depending on the environment of those things happening. So it's one thing to insure things for a 12-month period. If you own an airplane or run an airplane, you're almost certainly just insuring it on a 12-month basis. But if you're bringing projects together at short notice, You're going to need something that responds in a short period of time. And the digitization of the insurance market opens up huge opportunities for adaptable product.

**[0:08:25] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** We now even have sensors that you put into ships and you can track them as they go through war zones and out of war zones. So you're only paying for the war zone cover while you're in the war zone. You don't have to buy that cover permanently for 365 days of the year. So those kinds of opportunities make us much more responsive to customer needs and much

**[0:08:46] Alex Bond:** more adaptable. It's interesting as well to hear you talk so much about customer. Is that really what we should have in mind when we think about innovation? Should it all come back to that end consumer? Well I will start with worrying

**[0:09:01] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** about how far insurance companies are from their customers, particularly insurance companies like Lloyd's that are markets essentially and are disintermediated from their customers by brokers. And you've got to keep thinking about the customer to get the right answer and what we know about all of our customers and indeed I suspect it's true of you as an individual is we're all underinsured and instead of saying our customers should buy more insurance we have to ask ourselves why they don't buy more of our product and I kind of referenced I think the three bases for me around that issue the first is confidence the second is cost and the third is relevance and I think our product is quite expensive to deliver

**[0:09:39] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** to our customers and we've got of think of ways of delivering it more efficiently to our customers. And I think actually the consumer lines business, things like motor insurance, household insurance, has done a better job of that than some of the big commercial lines that we're engaged in at Lloyd's. The second issue is confidence. Typically in a financial services product there's an exchange of value at the point that you do the transaction. I sell you a bond, you give me cash.

**[0:10:07] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** the deal wouldn't happen if there wasn't an equivalent exchange of value at that point. One of us may be the winner or the loser down the road, but at the point of exchange of value, you wouldn't do the trade unless it was an equal exchange of value. In insurance, it's different because you pay a premium today, but you may not have a claim at all, or you may have a claim that is deferred for months or even years.

**[0:10:28] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And so there's a confidence gap between those two points as to whether what you've bought will prove to be valuable to you and whether, of course, the insurer will pay your claim. And that's particularly true given that insurance is about insuring unknowable and unforeseeable things. So the risk issues are much greater in insurance than they are in most financial services transactions. They're less predictable in terms of their outcomes. And that's precisely the value of insurance, of course, is to take that risk off you and on to me.

**[0:10:59] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** But you need to have confidence that we're going to be able to pay the claim. And then the third piece on relevance, of course, is your risks are changing. And we often use the example here at Lloyd's of Airbnb being a hotel company that doesn't own any hotels or Uber being a taxi company that doesn't own any taxis. And so if you're really good at insuring property, which we've been doing for 300 years in this market, you're less relevant today because most things are now in an intangible world rather than in a tangible world in terms of where value is.

**[0:11:29] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And so making sure we have products that adapt to our customers changing risks is incredibly important.

**[0:11:35] Alex Bond:** Completely understand. I wanted to talk to you about your, I think you've got a great insight, an interesting insight, because you've worked on the kind of financial services side, banking sector, then you've moved into insurance. And in insurance, particularly when we talk about innovation, a lot of what we talk about is that we're sort of going through our kind of digitalisation 20 years behind banking. Would you say that's kind of fair? Your view, where do you think we are on our journey and how does it compare to the transition that maybe the banking sector

**[0:12:11] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** went through? Well, we are on that journey and almost certainly we started it later than other parts of the financial services market. I think there are some quite good reasons for that, largely to do with the timeliness of payments in the banking system. And in insurance, it's not all about speed of payment. It's about kind of accuracy of evaluation of a claim, and back to this comment before, about the promise to pay. And therefore, it's unsurprising that in insurance, the most active adopters of digitalization and new technology have been the consumer lines businesses which have huge volumes of activity, lots of high volume, low value claims in them where there's a huge need for efficiency around process.

**[0:12:56] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** When you get to the bigger end of the market, the large commercial and reinsurance risks, there are obviously fewer transactions, but the complexity of them is much greater. And therefore, the human interaction has been stickier in terms of its value proposition. So I sometimes use the example in banking of the difference between a foreign exchange transaction and a mergers and acquisitions transaction. In foreign exchange, pretty much 100 % of that market is now digital. There's a huge amount of data, so it's a reasonably perfect market in terms of information.

**[0:13:26] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** You get your quote, you decide to take it or not in terms of the exchange rate that you want. Very few conversations have to happen around that. But if you look at a merger and acquisition transaction, people are gathered in a room, there are lawyers, there are accountants, there are buyers, there are sellers. Quite a lot of support, expertise needed to affect that transaction, as well of course quite a lot of emotion when you're selling a business or buying a business.

**[0:13:52] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** There's quite a lot of emotion in it and that process has really not been digitized at all. The same is true I think increasingly in insurance. What you're seeing is the more commoditized ends of the business digitizing more quickly, use of algorithms to price product. But as you get into more complex space, if you're a global company with risks in different parts of the world requiring different lines of insurance to protect your business, you're going to have a more complex set of risks and risk solutions.

**[0:14:22] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And so inevitably there's quite a lot of advice that comes in to determining what your risk profile is, what risks you want to retain, what risks you want to lay off in the insurance market. And so that part of the market will continue to be slower to digitize than the commoditized part of the market. So what you see is already some growth out of the consumer lines business into small commercial. So if you're a plumber, you're busy wanting to do your plumbing job.

**[0:14:49] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** You aren't that interested in getting into the world of insurance. But what you know is that your insurance requirements are reasonably complex. You might have an employee. You might create a flood in the house that you're doing plumbing for. Or you've got a bunch of liabilities that you need an insurance policy for. But typically what you want to know is that you're buying a policy that works for all plumbers. And so, again, that's sort of capable of automation.

**[0:15:11] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** But we've been doing kind of earthquakes for 200 years at Lloyd's. It's quite hard to automate that process because even with all the data that we have, these things are less predictable. You can still add algorithms and improve the data that you have in those situations. But it still requires a bit of human judgment. And what is the hedge for an earthquake? How do you protect yourself against earthquake risk in an insurance market? As you know, insurance fundamentally is about collecting the premiums of the many and paying the claims of the few.

**[0:15:41] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And so understanding whether providing earthquake insurance in Tokyo is a hedge to providing earthquake insurance in Los Angeles is quite a technical issue, but it also requires quite a lot of individual judgment.

**[0:15:54] Alex Bond:** Do you think there's an element where we as a market have... I was going to make the argument that we've undersold the services to a certain point, because really we should be embracing the technology, because it enables us to serve our consumers, whoever they may be, more accurately. And we can get into the higher value that we add, which is that human interaction that consults these piece. Because I always think about broking. Broking, since I've been in the market for 15 years, was always seen as people wanted to reframe it as risk advisors, but actually weren't changing the role.

**[0:16:26] Alex Bond:** but I think that now is more pertinent to what they do and more pertinent to what the brokers of the future are going to look like, is utilising technology to give your clients, or whoever they may be, a much better forensic view of their risk profile, and then advising them accordingly. Because I think the M &A example is such a good one, because you wouldn't want to do it just based on their data, even if it was data that you could get yourself.

**[0:16:49] Alex Bond:** You still want someone to manage that transaction. Do you think it's fair to say that we've certainly maybe done a bad PR job of that kind of value added service that we do?

**[0:16:58] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** So I think there's multiple issues in that question. First, I think it is easy to say that insurance has not done a good enough job in promoting itself and the value proposition that it has. We've got to constantly address that and it comes back to this protection gap that we talked about before. People don't buy enough insurance and why is that the case? I think the second piece in terms of our working habits, for brokers and for underwriters, there's too much process alongside the value added.

**[0:17:26] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And I'm very clear that brokers have a huge role to play in providing advice to customers in the proper management of their risks and in the proper buying of insurance protection. But too much of their day job is taken up with the process of delivering that, which also accounts for why a lot of what we do costs too much. And if we can take the process away from brokers and underwriters by automating it, by creating straight through processing, then we're freeing up time for brokers and underwriters to have more substantive conversations on the value-added part of what they do.

**[0:17:58] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** Now, people are a little bit nervous about giving up on the process because they're in the process, they're part of the process, and they're a bit worried that if somebody discovers they're only doing half a job because we've taken away the process half of their job, that they'll get fired. And we haven't really persuaded people enough that actually it's a much more exciting opportunity if they're spending 100 % of the time on the value-added issues and they're not spending any of the time on the process.

**[0:18:21] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And so we have active conversations now with brokers about whether premium should be paid directly by the customer to the underwriter or the claim in reverse. Why do these things get channeled through brokers? It adds to the process. It slows the process down. It creates some inefficiency in all of that. In most large complex risks, and particularly in a market like Lloyd's, it's the responsibility of the broker actually to put the data into our systems. But one of the things that the market does well here is respond to a customer by going on risk before the documentation is complete.

**[0:18:58] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** Well, unsurprisingly, a broker loses interest once you've gone on risk. They move on to the next transaction. And so what happens is there's an endless cycle of rework afterwards to try to get the data populated, make sure it's accurate somewhere between broker and underwriter and the settlement systems. If we could make it straight through at the point of origination, we'd take a huge amount of costs out of the market. We would free ourselves up to doing more of what you suggest by way of advocating to customers, being better advocates of our product capabilities and our customer service propositions.

**[0:19:29] Alex Bond:** I wanted to talk about the history of Lloyd's, we've got three centuries of history. I mean you can't escape it when you're in the building, it's one of the charms of it. Where's the friction of, is there friction of old meets the new or how is that impacted by that kind of history do you think, the kind of drive towards innovation?

**[0:19:51] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** So I prefer to see the history as a continuum rather than as a juxtaposition. I don't think it is old versus new. I just think that actually you can celebrate the fact that by having been around for 330 years, we've done some pretty good things over time to adapt to very changing circumstances. And that should give us a lot of confidence about our ability to adapt and change into the future. Many other organizations, whether they're in insurance or other lines of business, have disappeared in that time.

**[0:20:19] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And the Lloyd's market has found a way to continue to thrive. It's also, of course, the reason why London is a global centre for insurance. By having been built up around Lloyd's within 10 minutes of Lime Street, you've got all kinds of insurance services, not just brokers and underwriters, but loss adjusters and accountants, actuaries, lawyers, they're all specialist experts in this issue. But it makes it quite a physical environment. And one of the challenges we've got to think about is if we're going to move towards more more remote working, more remote access to the market, will we lose some of that centricity that our location gives us?

**[0:20:59] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And how will we replace that? Have you identified the room as being quieter today than previously? And that's largely because our business is very much moved online. And so what is the value of the central trading room at Lloyd's? And in many ways, I think it probably goes back to that original coffee shop that we started in. But it's a convening space for people to come together and discuss. It's much less important as a transactional processing space, which is what it's been for the last couple of hundred years.

**[0:21:26] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** It'll become much more a place where people discuss issues, share risks, think about how risks can be underwritten and distributed. And I don't think we fully understand how that might evolve. But actually the truth is the market is much more digital than people sometimes give it credit for. We've clearly been closed as a physical building for large parts of the last two years because of the pandemic, and yet the business moved seamlessly online. And so, again, this juxtaposition of the old and the new is less binary than people think.

**[0:21:58] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** So I think it's much more about behaviors, adopting new ways of working. I was telling somebody the other day that I struggle with moving from a BlackBerry to an iPhone because I really like the tactile nature of the BlackBerry and the click of the keys, and my fat fingers on the Apple keyboard took a lot of time to adjust to. And these are things that young people find much more intuitive and older people struggle with. And it's those kinds of behaviors that we have to change.

**[0:22:22] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** So it's about adopting new ways of working and making sure people see the benefits of making that transition rather than a sort of more binary kind of is it old or is it new.

**[0:22:32] Alex Bond:** And I think it's the sort of evolution versus kind of revolution version of kind of working practices. I mean, we talk about this a lot. You know, we're an executive search business. We talk about people's working habits. and there was a big drive to say, well, we want to be remote, remote forever. Well, we've seen that since the world's opened up again, people don't want that. People do want places where they can come and meet. And if it's nothing more than building camaraderie, a sense of togetherness, particularly when you're in a marketplace like Lloyd's, that's important in its own right.

**[0:23:00] Alex Bond:** You know, I think about our business, we've been talking about, do we get an office? Do we not? And I think we almost certainly will. but what role that plays, what role the buildings play is changing and evolving. And I think you're right, I don't think people have the answer yet. Because we also talk about building the work environment for the future. We can't do that at the expense of today, whereas there'll be a generation of people coming through who've made friends online, who communicate online as their daily discourse, and they probably won't be impacted like the current working population.

**[0:23:33] Alex Bond:** But if you took it away immediately, I think it was very damaging in terms of quality. I think the customer would ultimately pay. I wanted to shift gears slightly away from the old versus the new, but how does Lloyd's remain relevant in this environment of change? And how have Lloyd's been acting to drive innovation?

**[0:23:59] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** Well, happily, Lloyd's has always had a strong reputation for innovation and over the decades has been the first underwriter of motor insurance, has been the first underwriter of satellites being projected into space, has been the first underwriter of cyber insurance risks. And I think we're very proud of that. And it's part of how we retain our leadership in the insurance industry prospectively. I do think the insurance industry itself is not over-blessed with innovation. And so by being the best in it, that isn't necessarily the best across classes of business.

**[0:24:33] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And I think the whole industry needs to become more alive to the challenge and opportunity presented by innovation. And, you know, we're faced with more complex risks today than almost at any time. When you think about what's happening around the pandemic and now the war in Ukraine and its impact on supply chains and the price of fuel, the price of agriculture, These are all having huge impacts on our customers' lives and livelihoods. Risk is very much an issue that is around the boardroom table here.

**[0:25:07] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** Insurance has a real role to play. We haven't even touched yet on climate change, which is a huge issue for everyone and where we already play a big role because we are essentially already underwriting climate change. 25 % of our capital in the Lloyd's market is put behind underwriting natural catastrophes around the world. Those are clearly increasing in frequency and severity, and I think that's pretty clear that it's because of climate change. And so one in a hundred events, one in a hundred year events, are occurring two, three, four times in a hundred years in recent memory.

**[0:25:43] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And how are we going to adapt and respond to that? How are we going to help our customers adapt and respond to those challenges? challenges and how can we be part of that conversation. All of these are issues that I think make us very relevant to the development of risk and risk management tools in the modern

**[0:26:00] Alex Bond:** world. I wanted to pick up on that point because I think it's a really important one. When it comes to the ESG initiative, Lloyd's has got the power to really set the tone for the industry. Do you think Lloyd's have been brave enough in their approach to them or potentially I'm oversimplifying or overstating the role that we can play, but looking at fossil fuels as an example, should they be insurable? Should we take a market view on to say that they're uninsurable because of the damage they do to climate change?

**[0:26:30] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** So I think we're clear that we want to ensure the transition, but there has to be a transition. And I think we need to avoid cliff edges because I think those are dangerous and I think actually that's been writ large in the Ukraine conflict, that where you suddenly have a conflict, supply chains collapse and we've seen dramatic changes in the price of energy and increasingly the price of food as a result. And we won't get to public support for the long-term need to move to net zero if we ruin people's lives along the way.

**[0:27:02] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And so I like to think of what we've done at Lloyd's as bookending the issues. So at the back end, we've signed up actively for net zero by 2050. We're in good company with most other financial services organizations through the Glasgow Financial Initiative, GFANS. We're also part of the Net Zero Insurance Alliance amongst insurance companies. And we chair the Prince of Wales Sustainable Markets Initiative for insurance. He's vertical on that. And that allows us actually both to convene our industry globally around these issues, but also to partner with other industries, energy, construction, transportation.

**[0:27:36] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** They're all faced with quite important impacts on their business models as a result of climate change. So first and foremost there's a convening power for Lloyd's in that. The second piece we've done in the bookend, the front end of the bookend of course, is just look at our own footprint. Relatively easy for services organizations. We don't emit a lot of carbon, but we do have a carbon footprint that we can work hard on reducing immediately our scope one and scope two emissions.

**[0:28:03] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And then you've got this tough bit in the middle, which is creating this glide path from where we are to where we need to get to, that fundamentally has to go through this fossil fuel bubble, if you like. And it isn't good enough to say switch it off. And we've even said, you know, people then say, well, I'm only talking about new projects. You say, well, okay, it's one thing to talk about new projects as long as you're confident in the supply of traditional projects.

**[0:28:25] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** But as we've seen in Russia, even the supply of traditional products can get cut off. And so there is a place for supporting some new products as long as ultimately we move to a net zero position. And alongside getting out of fossil fuels, we need to get into renewables. And so we are busy underwriting new products. And the one that's quite interesting to talk about is hydrogen, for instance. I mean, hydrogen has a very small carbon footprint.

**[0:28:54] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** But what we all know and grew up knowing is it's highly combustible. And therefore, as an insurance matter, it's quite risky. And if it's going to be manufactured at scale and be in the supply chains, the fuel supply chains of a whole variety of industries, It absolutely needs to be a stable product that's capable of being insured. And so we've got pilot projects going on that kind of issue. Nuclear is another thing. We've been insuring nuclear in the Lloyd's market for a number of years, but nuclear for a number of years has become less and less fashionable as people moved away from that.

**[0:29:24] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** It's now increasing in fashion because it has a zero carbon footprint. But that is a peculiarly difficult risk to underwrite. It's a very good risk until it isn't. Yes. And it's kind of binary in terms of its outcomes. And so thinking through all of these issues is part of making sure that we have a series of policies that allow the market to respond to the challenge. And so I think of it as a glide path. And I think it is really important that our customers are transitioning.

**[0:29:52] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** I think the piece that's missing, not just for Lloyd's or the insurance industry, but actually for all of us, is a relatively sensible measure of carbon impact so that we can evaluate the changes that our customers are making. we can see who's leading and who's lagging on these issues, and we can make sure we're all on this path to get to net zero. And I have some frustration that decent measurement systems are not yet available. And there's quite a lot of risk of fragmentation there that everyone's inventing their own, which of course exposes challenges of greenwashing around this.

**[0:30:22] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And some of them are too complicated, so people's eyes glaze over it, sort of gets like pension accounting, and they get lost in the mathematics. Some of them are too simplistic. It can't just be a sort of red, amber, green because it's a more complicated issue than that. And so finding something in the middle that allows us to get started, that will undoubtedly be refined and improved over time, is really important. So setting ourselves up for success in this.

**[0:30:47] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** I think the other piece is technology. It comes back to your questions around innovation. I think today it's incredibly difficult to see how we get to net zero as a world without technology coming to our rescue, without innovation coming to our rescue. And I think globally, the human race has shown its ability to innovate and adapt. And so you have to be pretty confident about that. But it's another reason to underpin why Lloyd's and places like the Lloyd's Lab, we need to be open and alive to these new ways of doing things that might help accelerate us along that glide path.

**[0:31:18] Alex Bond:** It's interesting when you talk about sort of an industry-wide change, it kind of actually magnifies the importance of a marketplace like Lloyd's because you can have an industry-wide conversation or at least an industry with Lloyd's businesses. I wanted to move on to talk about DE &I initiatives because it's long been a challenge in the insurance industry and other financial services industries. Insurance is not alone in that. But what's currently been done at Lloyd's and what do you think needs to change in respect to being more diverse and inclusive as an industry, I think, rather than just the corporation itself?

**[0:31:58] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** So I think this, a bit like the climate change conversation, starts with collecting the data. And we hadn't collected the data across the marketplace, across issues of gender and ethnicity and social mobility. And we're now doing that. And we started in a gender space and we set some quite aggressive objectives for ourselves. So, for instance, we wanted to see 35 % of women in leadership positions in the marketplace by 2025. We're at 30 % today. It's been creeping up a sort of percent per year since we started looking at this three or four years ago.

**[0:32:31] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** We've got to be careful not to celebrate that because I think if you're a woman who's been waiting for 2 ,000 years to have equality of treatment in the workplace, that doesn't feel like a fast enough pace, but we are making progress there. More recently, we've been trying to collect data on ethnicity. That's a bit harder because people are less trusting on that issue. but we've set a target for the marketplace of having one in three people hired into the market being from an ethnic minority background.

**[0:33:01] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** Interestingly we've achieved that for the corporation itself at the centre already but in the marketplace we're probably at one in six. And if we stay at one in six we won't move the dial sufficiently across the total population. So we've got some work to do but there is progress being made there. The other piece is social mobility? Are we providing opportunities to people from disadvantaged backgrounds to have the same opportunities as those of us who come from more privileged backgrounds?

**[0:33:25] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And what are our outreach programs? Back to your earlier conversation and challenge about insurance reaching out into its communities and its customer bases to prove the value of what it does and to showcase the value of what it does, to make this a more interesting place for people to want to come and work. And it's self-evidently true that if you're addressing the whole market of talent out there, then you have a better chance of getting the best talent in here and having the best talent stay.

**[0:33:50] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And it's not just about recruiting it, it is about retention and making sure everybody has a good experience in this market. And we'll find some issues where that's not true and where we're calling those out. We had quite a big fine for one of the managing agents just a few months ago. And of course that reprises the issue of whether we're genuinely an open and inclusive market. Now those issues dated back to 2018 and and the wheels of justice run slow.

**[0:34:15] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** But I don't think that's a reason not to get out the hammer and hit these things pretty hard when you discover them. And there aren't really any excuses anymore for bad behaviors in the marketplace. And actually, I think people are enormously supportive of what we've done. But you do have to call yourselves out at the beginning in terms of saying we're not in the best place, and we need to get to the best place, and how are we going to do it?

**[0:34:38] Alex Bond:** I think there's a Lloyd's report coming out this week, actually, that's from the market. yesterday and all the instances have been down of observed negative behaviours. But yeah, and I think you've answered it perfectly there, to say that it's gone down, but it's not zero, so we've still got some way to go. But it's positive to see that these things are having an impact and particularly, yeah, we saw the large vine and it is good to evidence that Lloyd's is taking this seriously because there's greenwashing in the environmental sector, but there's definitely been a good PR campaign on issues like diversity, equity inclusion which haven't actually moved the dial and I think it's great to see that Lloyd's is

**[0:35:16] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** But some things have been brilliant. You look at things like dive-in, you know, so again dealing with different kinds of minorities in the LBGTQ plus space and you know we're now in our sixth year of doing that and that started at Lloyd's and now is extended annually to upward of 100 countries around the world including some where where some of these behaviors are illegal and and punishable. And so again, that opportunity for Lloyd's as a convener then to let these things go out into the wider insurance industry and have other people embrace them.

**[0:35:46] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** The challenge we've got is why is it only one week a year? Why aren't we thinking about these things much more regularly? But I think most people you talk to come from these minority backgrounds, particularly in the areas of LGBT Q +, would say that they've seen an appreciable difference in Lloyd's willingness to welcome and be open to these issues over the last five or six years. I think that's something Lloyd's would be proud of.

**[0:36:12] Alex Bond:** Yeah, no, I completely agree, and reflecting on the 15 years I've been here, it's a very different landscape, and it is more diverse. I just wanted to come on to the kind of, you talk about talent more specifically, because I think you're an interesting case in point. Again, not treating you like a test bunny for the industry, but because you came from a different sector, and it strikes me as an obvious but brave appointment, taking someone from outside the sector to come and have a leadership role.

**[0:36:41] Alex Bond:** Do you think we've seen that enough? Because that's one of the things that in my role, I sort of find that we're not quite brave enough. We don't say this person was very smart and led a business very well. They can probably lead one in insurance, and perhaps we're too sort of inward-looking when we look at talent.

**[0:36:56] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** I think that's less and less true. I also think that the role of chair at Lloyd's is unique in a way because it is essentially a non-executive appointment. And I think when the market debates who it wants as its chair, it periodically wants an insider and periodically wants an outsider. And to some extent, I'm a little bit of a compromise because I started as an outsider, but I've done a number of years within the industry.

**[0:37:25] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** Nobody in the industry would call me a native from the industry. And again, that's in part some of the traditions of the industry. If you weren't born into it, you're not part of it. But I see in more and more operations in the marketplace, people, for instance, trying to recruit in technology talent. How can we make insurance really attractive to innovators and technologists in our marketplace in the way that banking and asset management are all trying to do as well?

**[0:37:50] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And so I do think the breadth of talent coming into the market is broadening all the time. And again, part of the challenge is to make sure that not only do we recruit them, but that we retain them and give them career opportunities in insurance that are as good as any other industry can offer. It's unsurprising. I mean, people in any sector surround themselves with their own jargon because it reinforces their expertise. My learning in coming from banking to insurance is it's a new vocabulary, but underneath it's all about risk.

**[0:38:19] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And so if you can translate between your experiences in banking into the insurance industry and overlay it with the language of an insurer versus the language of a banker, you can pretty quickly have the conversations that you need to about the key issues that the industry faces. And I think there's much to be celebrated. But there's also huge expertise within our industry that needs to be developed in its own right. I don't think it's right to say we should not stick with the old and constantly hire people from outside.

**[0:38:50] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** It's actually really nice to have that balance and continue to learn from each other in terms of our skills and expertise.

**[0:38:57] Alex Bond:** No, I think retention of talent is a really interesting point because it's something that I reflect on. I joined the insurance industry and at the time didn't feel I had the mobility within the organization, things I couldn't cross-pollinate to a different sector. If you joined as a claims person by accident because you stumbled into insurance, which is most people's story, you stayed in claims forever. You didn't realize you'd set yourself apart. And I think that's less and less and less true.

**[0:39:22] Alex Bond:** But I think we've got a way to go, but that is kind of on a case-by-case

**[0:39:25] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** basis for it. Well, I think you raised a different challenge, which is around management. And I think the average manager in insurance is poor at managing. It's true across financial services, interestingly, because the rewards typically go to the frontline people who are generating the revenues and it's always been true in financial services but there's a little bit too much patronage and insurance your boss looks after you for as long as he or she thinks you're working for them as soon as you want to work somewhere else they're not that interested in in helping you I spent quite a lot of time talking to people in the market about the value I think of developing your own management skills because it

**[0:40:05] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** helps you build followership as you become more senior you can't do everything and if you're going to have leverage around what you do. You've got to have people want to work with you. And people want to work for good bosses, not bad bosses. And in fact, the most toxic thing you can ever do is work for a bad boss. And I'm very quick to say if you've got a bad boss, you should leave them. It doesn't matter how good the organization is around that.

**[0:40:27] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** If the organization is content to support a bad boss, it's not the right place for you. But a good boss can make a huge amount of difference to your opportunities in the workplace and give you that stretch. I mean, I could certainly point to two or three occasions in my career where a boss took a bet on me for something that I wasn't fully capable of doing and believed that I could stretch into it. And not only was the stretching incredibly challenging but also fulfilling, but also the willingness of somebody to back you when you don't have kind of all the boxes ticked in terms of your capabilities.

**[0:41:01] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** These are the things that enable you to transform your own opportunities. And so I think that your comment is really much more about management than it is about the skills and capabilities that we have in the industry.

**[0:41:12] Alex Bond:** I think it's a really important point because, yeah, I mean, in my industry it's exactly the same. The leadership roles go to the revenue generating frontline people. Those skill sets have no correlation to being a good manager. In fact, they're quite counter-cultural to it in many extents. So just really conscious of your time and wanting to wrap things up, what do you think what do you think we need to do to stay further ahead? You know, because I was actually going to write this question as, do you think we're being reactive?

**[0:41:40] Alex Bond:** But I think in this conversation it's very clear we're not being reactive. Lloyd's is being proactive. So, you know, what can we do to stay further ahead when it comes to sort of market innovation?

**[0:41:48] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** Well, we haven't talked about the Lloyd's lab, despite the fact that we're sitting in it this morning. And, you know, I think that's a really good capability that we've developed at Lloyd's over the last three years. We're now into our eighth cohort. We've had 10 startup businesses in each of those cohorts. And we've done things that work both ways. So we've enabled small businesses to get access to a whole market. We buddy them up with somebody in the marketplace that allows them to go and market their products and services and look for capacity to support their product capabilities.

**[0:42:21] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And therefore help them scale more quickly than they would otherwise be able to do. But also the reverse is true. People in the marketplace have seen different ways of doing things. how you can use data, how you can use different distribution channels to develop business ideas. And there have been some remarkable things that have come out of that. I think parametric insurance, for instance, for me, has a huge future. And we've had, in the flooding arena, we've had a flood flash in this marketplace, now three years on, developing a business, a cover holder at Lloyd's.

**[0:42:54] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** But if you think about mass flooding, the challenges of that as an insurance proposition, and we do a lot of flood insurance at Lloyd's. You have to wait for the water to recede. You've then got to find a loss adjuster to go in and evaluate the claim. Loss adjusters are hard to find if it's mass flooding because there just aren't that many of them around, so you get in a queue for that. You've then got to do a calculation around the value of what's been lost under the policy and then pay the claim.

**[0:43:18] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** If you have a parametric product that just says, I will pay you if the river gets to this level, I'm not even looking at whether you've had damage or not. It's just actuarial. I can predict if the river's at this level, I will pay your claim because you're likely to suffer damage. You can have your check in your bank account the following day. I think that transforms the relevance of our industry to our customer base. And we've done good things around the vaccine.

**[0:43:42] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** As you know, a lot of these vaccines have to be stored at stable, very refrigerated temperatures. And as we've tried to expand the vaccine program into emerging markets, that risk, of course, grows. How do you get a vaccine that has to be stored at minus 20 degrees into the Congo, into somebody's arm in a stable way? Well, we've aligned a sensor business called Parcel with an underwriting syndicate here at Lloyd's to provide that insurance cover and to monitor those containers with the vaccine as they get transported.

**[0:44:18] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** There's another one that you wouldn't have dreamed of a while ago called Gaia that is underwriting IVF fertility treatments, for instance. These are all things that directly affect people's lives in a very positive way, and if we can help them. IVF treatment is incredibly expensive to do. You don't know whether you're going to need it when you start out in life. It's something that kind of happens to you. And so to be able to buy protection against those kinds of issues and have the support that you need that would enable you to produce an offspring that nature is making it hard to do is very exciting.

**[0:44:48] Bruce Carnegie Brown:** And I think we've got to keep pushing with the frontier on those things and making this a more exciting place for people to bring ideas, to bring capital and ultimately to bring customers.

**[0:44:59] Alex Bond:** Thank you, Bruce. I think it's a wonderful place to end it because the Lloyd's Lab is a big soft spot of ours. And I said this is episode 100 and the first 10 were basically going through the Lloyd's Lab list and inviting those guests on. So we've had many people from the Lloyd's Lab, and I know that from their experience, they've been blown away by the expertise they've been able to lean into here. And it's been really rewarding for them all.

**[0:45:20] Alex Bond:** So it's a great initiative. But thank you so much for your time, Bruce. I really appreciate it. Thanks for being a guest. Thanks for the opportunity. Thank you. as always this podcast is brought to you by FinPro often simply known as finpro finpro is an executive recruitment business working in the insurance and insurtech space on an international basis if you would like to find out more about finpro please visit our website www.wearefinpro.com or our FinPro company page on LinkedIn.

**[0:46:00] Alex Bond:** I've been your host Alex Bond and I would personally love to connect with anyone who is interested in the changing world of insurance so feel free to reach out to me directly either on LinkedIn or via my email of alex at wearefinpro.com I hope you enjoyed the podcast and I hope to see you back next week. Thank you.
