OpenNashPodcasts

The Leadership in Insurance Podcast

Reflecting On The Journey To Unicorn Status : An Interview with Rotem Iram, CEO & Founder of At-Bay

20 Jun 2022 · 52m · Rotem Iram, Alex Bond · 21 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Rotem Iram argues that cyber insurance works best when the insurer acts as a security partner, not only a risk-taker. At-Bay scans customers, keeps monitoring them all year, and helps them fix serious weaknesses. Automating small-business underwriting lets it decide in seconds and compete on speed and service instead of price.

The central tension is that better data does not automatically win business. Iram says half the time the scans led to worse terms, and brokers prefer predictable, cheap competitors. At-Bay's answer was speed: far more data, yet a decision in under 30 seconds. He also frames the company's rapid growth as a responsibility to its staff and to the wider market.

Key insights

  1. Cyber risk changes faster than annual policies

    Insurance terms are fixed for a year, but a new software flaw can make a good company dangerous within days. At-Bay therefore monitors customers all year and contacts them when a serious issue appears.

  2. Monitoring cut ransomware in the book fivefold

    Iram says At-Bay has about five times less ransomware than the industry average. Ransomware is more than 60% of cyber losses, so this drives much lower loss ratios.

  3. Better underwriting alone did not win brokers

    Scans often revealed problems, so at least half the time customers received worse terms. Brokers found that unpredictable next to rivals who were always cheap.

  4. Speed lets At-Bay avoid competing on price

    At-Bay collects far more data but decides in under 30 seconds. Iram says that if you win on service, you are not forced to cut prices and hurt your results.

  5. Insurers can force vendors to improve security

    Iram compares this to smoke detectors and seat belts, which became standard because insurers required them. He says At-Bay surcharges or declines customers using Microsoft Exchange servers, which are 125% more likely to be breached, to push vendors to act.

Questions

What does At-Bay actually do?

At-Bay is a cyber insurance MGA, a managing general agent that underwrites on behalf of insurers, and it sells through wholesale partners. According to Rotem Iram it scans customers' security, monitors them all year, and helps fix problems.

Why is cyber insurance harder to price than other insurance?

Policies last a year, but cyber risk can change in days when a new software flaw appears, often through no fault of the customer. Iram says an underwriter cannot know ahead of time which company in the portfolio will be hit.

How can At-Bay make an insurance decision so fast?

It collects the data automatically and automates the decision for small and mid-sized business risks. Iram says it gathers about 100 times more data points yet binds a policy in under 30 seconds.

How big is At-Bay and how is it funded?

Iram says At-Bay is a Series D company that has raised about $300 million. It has around 220 staff, adds about 2,500 customers a month, and expected to pass a $340 million premium run rate in June.

What does Iram say he got wrong at the start?

He assumed that underwriting better would automatically win business. In practice, brokers and customers did not care about the insurer's profit, and the extra data often produced worse terms for customers.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Rotem Iram says he spent about five years as a captain in the Israeli intelligence technology unit at the start of his security career.

“I spent most of my career in security started in the Israeli intelligence technology unit where I was a captain there for about five years.”

0:02:28 · Rotem Iram · Founder background

Rotem Iram says At-Bay runs a non-intrusive scan of each customer so that it can avoid insuring the riskiest 5% of companies.

“by forcing what we call a non-intrusive penetration test or a scan on each one of those customers, we can stay away from the bottom 5%.”

0:03:51 · Rotem Iram · Underwriting scans

Rotem Iram says At-Bay has reduced ransomware in its insured portfolio to more than five times lower than the industry average.

“we've been able to lower the amount of ransomware in our book by more than five times compared to the average in the industry.”

0:06:19 · Rotem Iram · Ransomware results

Rotem Iram says ransomware is the biggest attack vector in cyber insurance and accounts for more than 60% of At-Bay's losses.

“because ransomware is the biggest attack vector in our industry. It's more than 60 % of our losses.”

0:06:46 · Rotem Iram · Ransomware losses

Rotem Iram says At-Bay combines granular underwriting and year-round monitoring with an automated decision in 30 seconds for small-business risks.

“not only is it a more granular kind of underwriting assessment and an ongoing monitoring throughout the year, we also make a decision in 30 seconds.”

0:07:20 · Rotem Iram · Automated underwriting

Rotem Iram says staff who joined At-Bay report that issuing a binder took about 15 minutes of document production at their old employers and takes about two seconds at At-Bay.

“we have some folks tell us stories that when they need to issue a binder, it takes their machine like 15 minutes to produce all the documents. And with that bay, it takes two seconds.”

0:17:07 · Rotem Iram · Document automation

Rotem Iram says every employee at At-Bay has an equity stake in the company.

“the fact that everybody's a part owner of the company, everybody has equity, being part of that journey”

0:19:29 · Rotem Iram · Employee equity

Rotem Iram says about 50% of At-Bay's staff, including half of its leadership team, are women.

“at base, 50 % women from top to bottom, 50 % of the leadership team”

0:20:01 · Rotem Iram · Diversity

Rotem Iram says Lemonade had just emerged from stealth, with Israeli founders, when he was considering starting At-Bay, and he contacted them for advice.

“And I remember as we were kicking around this idea, Lemonade just came out of stealth and the founders are also Israeli.”

0:25:11 · Rotem Iram · Founding story

Rotem Iram says that when At-Bay launched in 2018, most small and mid-sized businesses were not yet buying cyber insurance, so the workload was manageable.

“you know when we launched in 2018 most smbs were not buying cyber insurance yet so it was manageable”

0:16:01 · Rotem Iram · Market timing · 2018

Rotem Iram says At-Bay's first investors gave it $3.5 million based on a basic PowerPoint deck.

“all we had was a powerpoint deck and it wasn't even like a really good one and and investors were like you know here's $3.5 million go try and build something”

0:32:04 · Rotem Iram · Early funding

Rotem Iram says At-Bay had to scale its security scanning from about a hundred scans a day to 10,000 scans a day.

“even scaling from doing a hundred scans a day to 10 ,000 scans a day.”

0:28:33 · Rotem Iram · Scaling operations

Rotem Iram says At-Bay issues more than a million documents a month.

“i think we're issuing more than a million documents a month and it's become a high-scale business at this point”

0:28:33 · Rotem Iram · Scale

Rotem Iram says At-Bay is about four and a half times bigger than it was a year earlier when it signed its Series D.

“even though public markets are not doing very well, At-Bay has grown almost, I think, well, about four and a half times”

0:29:44 · Rotem Iram · Growth

Rotem Iram says At-Bay expected to pass about $340 million in annualised premium run rate in June.

“we're going to pass about $340 million in premium run rate”

0:29:44 · Rotem Iram · Premium run rate

Rotem Iram says At-Bay has about 220 employees, of whom about 70 work in research and development, data science and cybersecurity research.

“Out of the 220 people, we have about 70 people that are pure R &D, data science, cybersecurity research.”

0:30:21 · Rotem Iram · Headcount

Rotem Iram says that in at least half of cases the data At-Bay collected in its scans led it to offer worse terms rather than better ones.

“at least half the times we were giving worse terms because of what we found, not necessarily better terms.”

0:39:51 · Rotem Iram · Underwriting lesson

Rotem Iram says At-Bay collects about 100 times more data points than competitors yet makes an underwriting decision in 11 seconds.

“you collect 100x more data points but then you make a decision in 11 seconds from start to finish”

0:41:36 · Rotem Iram · Underwriting speed

Rotem Iram says At-Bay's data shows companies running a Microsoft Exchange email server are 125% more likely to suffer a breach.

“you have a Microsoft Exchange email server, we find that you have 125 % more likely to have a breach.”

0:48:49 · Rotem Iram · Exchange risk

Rotem Iram says At-Bay tells customers with a Microsoft Exchange server to move to Google or Office 365 or face a doubled premium.

“we tell you either you move to Google, or you go to Office 365, or we're going to double your premium.”

0:48:49 · Rotem Iram · Pricing policy

Rotem Iram says seat belts became law after insurers refused to sell insurance unless vehicles had them, and he expects the same pattern in cybersecurity.

“seat belts became a law after the insurance companies mandated that they wouldn't sell insurance unless there was a seat belt”

0:48:03 · Rotem Iram · Insurance standards

Chapters

  1. 0:02:28Security-first approach to cyber insurance

    Iram explains why his security background led him to build an insurer, using scans to avoid the worst risks.

    “we came to this problem from the security side”
  2. 0:04:49Why annual policies clash with fast-moving risk

    He explains the core problem: a fixed-price year-long contract against risks that change in days, and At-Bay's monitoring fix.

    “insurance is a year-long contract, and you cannot change the terms for a full year”
  3. 0:09:12What surprised a security expert about insurance

    Iram describes insurance as selling first and learning costs later, with underwriters stuck doing data entry on old systems.

    “this is a product that you sell first and you learn how much it costs you a year later”
  4. 0:13:52Underwriters become portfolio managers

    Automation frees underwriters from paperwork to give brokers strategic portfolio advice, which makes small-business cyber profitable.

    “we're trying to automate most of it and turn our underwriters to portfolio managers”
  5. 0:20:01Building a diverse, engineering-led culture

    Iram links hiring, equity and a leadership team that is half women to attracting and keeping talent.

    “50 % women from top to bottom, 50 % of the leadership team”
  6. 0:26:50Building from scratch and the capital barrier

    He recounts the early days, the Lemonade advice, and why capital remains the biggest barrier in insurance.

    “biggest barrier in insurance remains capital”
  7. 0:29:44At-Bay's scale and funding today

    Iram gives the headline numbers: Series D, headcount, customer growth and premium run rate.

    “we're going to pass about $340 million in premium run rate”
  8. 0:42:20Why better underwriting alone did not win

    The key lesson: more data often meant worse terms, so speed and service became the real edge over cheap competitors.

    “if you can compete on service, you don't have to compete on price”
  9. 0:48:03Insurance as a force that sets security standards

    Iram's vision is to use policy terms to push technology vendors toward safer products, as insurers once did with seat belts.

    “seat belts became a law after the insurance companies mandated that they wouldn't sell insurance unless there was a seat belt”

Transcript

0:00:01
Alex Bond

Hello and welcome to the Leadership in Insurance Podcast. This is the podcast that brings you the greatest innovation changemakers in the world of insurance and insurtech. We speak to innovation leaders from carriers and brokers. We speak to insurtech founders and c-suite executives and we bring you all of the people that add value to that community whether it be private equity, venture capitalists or even people like organizational psychologists and thought leaders and futurists. We try really hard to bring you the most innovative people in the world of insurance on a global basis.

0:00:34

So with that in mind, we'd love your support. So please like, share, follow or subscribe to wherever you get your podcasts. I'm your host, Alex Bond. Welcome to the Leadership Insurance Podcast. This podcast is brought to you by FinPro. FinPro is a leading InsurTech specialist recruitment business that operates on a global basis. We have delivered assignments across North America, throughout Europe and into Asia. We are super excited to speak to anyone who has some recruitment challenges that is either starting or scaling a business and we're confident we can help you find the people to help you innovate the world of insurance one new hire at a time.

0:01:14

Please visit our website www.wearefinpro.com for more information. good morning and welcome to the leadership insurance podcast i'm your host alex bond and i'm very lucky today to be joined by rotem who's ceo and founder of At-Bay good morning sir how are you doing well alex thank you for having me no no thank you and thank you for persevering We've been trying to do this one for a little while. So I think we were supposed to do it when I was in ITI and I was going to run back to my hotel room for doing it.

0:01:57

So I was actually quite pleased. That's right. All good things happen to those who wait, right? Absolutely. Absolutely. No, I completely agree. And look, you know, At-Bay is a business. The reason that we've been so persistent in trying to get it on, you know, we watch from afar. We love a lot of what we hear. We're really excited about what you guys do. But just in case anyone's listening in isn't aware of At-Bay and the business, it'd be great if you could do an intro to what it is that you guys do there.

0:02:28
Rotem Iram

Yeah, sure. So, you know, At-Bay is building. We're building the cyber insurance company of the future or, you know, that's what we hope to do. We are a cyber insurance MGA operating and working with our wholesale partners. What's unique about At-Bay in my mind is that we came to this problem from the security side. And my background is in security. I spent most of my career in security started in the Israeli intelligence technology unit where I was a captain there for about five years.

0:03:08

I'm an engineer by training. And I found about eight years ago, I find myself working with the insurance industry on cyber insurance. And granted, cyber insurance in 2014 looks very different than it does today. But a lot of the principles remain the same. And what I found was that there's a real big disparity between the dynamic nature of cyber risk and the kind of traditional underwriting machine of PNC. So, and just to be kind of very concrete about it, I think the smaller gap that I found that is still meaningful is that there's a lot of technical data that can be acquired and leveraged to underwrite.

0:03:51

And really what it is, is that there are some companies who have holes in their security that are so big and so easy to find. It's a miracle they haven't been breached yet. And by forcing what we call a non-intrusive penetration test or a scan on each one of those customers, we can stay away from the bottom 5%. And really, that's kind of half the magic in insurance sometimes is if you can just stay away from the worst 5%.

0:04:18

But by the way, it's not just staying away from them. It's being able to tell them what it is that makes them so bad. I mean, they probably want to know, right? An underwriting exercise is also a really good external objective third-party assessment of your risk. If somebody tells you they are not willing under any condition to sell you insurance, that is a red flag that you should take into consideration. So actually working with them, explaining what we found, helping them fix it, and then happily providing them insurance if they did is kind of the first step.

0:04:49

But the big issue, the big gap that we found was that it doesn't matter how good you are at underwriting. The problem remains that insurance is a year-long contract, and you cannot change the terms for a full year. So whatever price you set needs to reflect the risk for the next 12 months. Now, the problem with cyber risk is that it changes quickly, and most times it is not your fault as a company that your risk has changed.

0:05:16

It's not anything you've done. So you could be a great company with great security. You're really on top of your stuff. Now there's a new critical vulnerability in a Microsoft Exchange server or in an Apache strut server or in whatever. You know, you have dozens, if not hundreds of technologies in your stack. One of them is going to have an issue. That issue makes you one of the bottom 5%. Now, you haven't done anything wrong, but you are now at a terrible danger.

0:05:45

and I can't know ahead of time who in my portfolio it's going to be because I don't know which one of the hundreds of technologies in your stack is going to be the one that has the critical vulnerability. It's just so dynamic and so much all over the place. And once there's a new critical vulnerability, the time it takes attackers to exploit it is days. Days are weeks tops. And so it's just not enough time to change your underwriting and kind of realign your book by just underwriting once a year.

0:06:19

You just can't wait to the end of the year. And so really what At-Bay does that is unique is that we actively monitor the security of every company in our portfolio throughout the year. And whenever we see that you now have an issue that would have caused us to stay away from you because you were too risky, we have a security team that reaches out and helps you fix the issue. And by doing that, we've been able to lower the amount of ransomware in our book by more than five times compared to the average in the industry.

0:06:46

And that's really important because ransomware is the biggest attack vector in our industry. It's more than 60 % of our losses. And so by having five times less ransomware, we were able to have loss ratios that are just dramatically lower from the rest of industry. And then using that to maintain appetite and good pricing kind of throughout this kind of hardening market. But the other thing that I'll say, which is kind of just really important, is that because all our data collection is automatic, we've automated the decision-making as well.

0:07:20

And so really, not only is it a more granular kind of underwriting assessment and an ongoing monitoring throughout the year, we also make a decision in 30 seconds. really we took out the human from the middle of the decision making again this is true for smb it's not true for the largest risks out there but you know for an smb risk we made it so the broker is actually getting better service faster first faster quoting at a much higher quote ratio and a much higher kind of win rate and we're and and we're getting kind of more underwriting data and a better way of doing it.

0:07:58

So it kind of feels like a win-win. And that was the engine that kind of helped fuel our growth over the last few years.

0:08:06
Alex Bond

I think it's so interesting when you're looking at it. It's such a dynamic risk. And it's something that there isn't necessarily any parallel to that. You know, the speed of change. You know, I was thinking about this. You know, I've obviously got my own small business and that's, you know, there's an exposure there. I definitely bury my head in the sand about it which I think is a problem for a lot of small business owners but you know the equivalent being that you you've got a house and someone's someone's putting holes in it but if you can't see the holes then you're not going to fill them up and and that relationship I think you know you guys felt like

0:08:45

the start of a trend towards that sort of proactive relationship between the insurer and the insured and we're starting to see that trend happen in different classes of businesses as well. Does it surprise you as someone that came from cybersecurity industry first and then came into the insurance industry, how much insurance is being offered without this kind of level of understanding, continuous assessment of risk?

0:09:12
Rotem Iram

Yeah, I mean, there's definitely a lot of things about insurance that weren't natural for me when I started. Maybe the strangest thing about insurance is that this is a product that you sell first and you learn how much it costs you a year later, which is not how you typically would like to price a product. You would like to know how much money you're going to be making before you offer it. There's a built-in lag between where the actual risk and the actual price is in your actions, right?

0:09:46

You're only going to discover it after the fact. And you're always kind of chasing where true risk is at. I think another part that surprised me was that how much of this business was just moving around data and not really making decisions. So underwriters at their best are these amazing kind of risk managers who can be really thoughtful and can really help guide and partner with a broker in a company to not only help them kind of discover what is their risk, but then also tailor the right coverage for them.

0:10:28

But in SMB market, a lot of what they were first doing is just copying and pasting data from one form to another, from one system to another, from one PDF to a system, doing a lot of manual back office, middle office work that is not inspiring and not really that useful for them. uh also not exciting um there's insurance is very um you know uh there are a lot of companies out there each one developed their own it systems and most it systems are 20 30 40 years old and um and it's just uh just very clunky the whole thing just feels very very clunky uh uh and you know one of the benefits of starting a company in you

0:11:10

know 2017 was that uh we were able to build our technology stack from scratch. And we, you know, we designed a company where engineers are in every part of the organization and are, and have a major kind of presence in the leadership team. You know, myself, I have an engineering background. We have a CTO and our executive team. And, you know, we made sure that technology is front and center. And so you end up just, just taking away a ton of the stuff that is just, I don't know, not inspiring.

0:11:45

And you empower underwriters to really make a difference. And, and, and that this ends up actually serving you and, and serving your customers because you can provide just much better service. You're not, our underwriters aren't busy in, in just entering data into, into systems for compliance reasons. The whole thing just happens on its own. And so they, they get to just spend time with the broker and with the customer.

0:12:08
Alex Bond

um so yeah just just to dive in so i'm just gonna say like you've automated so much what role does the underwriter play and what's the kind of um what's what's the kind of like ratio because everyone would be very underwriting talent heavy in their businesses but you're essentially doing that kind of almost the thing that happened in banking that for every investment banker you're lost as a bank you've got 10 engineers

0:12:36
Rotem Iram

is um what role do they play now so you know if the the way i i think about you know the vision for the work of the underwriter i would definitely split it between the large complex and uh risks and the smaller risk when it comes to complex risks it definitely i i think that the way the industry has been dealing with those risks is actually really good uh what we really want to do is just enhance what already exists with just better data, more insights, and perhaps add in-house security expertise into the conversation so that when we have a conversation with the customer and the broker, we have an insurance expert and a security expert in that conversation.

0:13:18

But when it comes to SMB risks, what we found was that the underwriters, you don't have enough time and you can't make money if you spend days and weeks on an account. There's just a limited amount of time that folks can spend on them. And so really what it was until now was just mostly just very basic categorizing. All right, what's your industry? What's your size? What's competition doing? Let me see if I can be competitive here and just shoot it out.

0:13:52

And you got like 10 minutes, 15 minutes to get it out the door. Again, so we're trying to automate most of it and turn our underwriters to portfolio managers, where you work with your broker on a portfolio view of, okay, what is the sum total of your customers? What is the risk? What is the appetite? What are the things that they should be caring about? How can we kind of educate the portfolio? How can we put you guys in a better position?

0:14:21

So instead of just moving around papers and drowning in administrative work, being able to kind of take a step back and have more strategic conversations with brokers about kind of how to manage their portfolio appetite risk and how to just kind of empower the brokers to provide better advice and better coverage to their customers.

0:14:42
Alex Bond

Is it fair to say as well that arguably that work, that SMB market in the cyberspace wasn't even particularly profitable prior to without that automation because the volume that you would require would just negate any profitability one would imagine yeah i think it's uh i think it's

0:15:00
Rotem Iram

true i mean the um you know the thing about insurance is that when the risks are very small you can uh you can probably just do portfolio underwriting meaning just give everybody the same price and not even do any underwriting and just try to make you know try to create an average price that makes sense. But when the risks go get a little bit bigger, you can't afford to have a portfolio underwriting approach. And that's where we think this kind of breaks down.

0:15:28

And for a lot of the other issue is that it's very non-standard. So it required kind of the wholesalers to do quite a bit of work to try and make sure they answer the right questions and do the things that the underwriters need to be able to process. So it definitely, you know, I think it was not profitable, but also just very intensive, very cumbersome. The other part is that because cyber is new, a lot of brokers, there aren't many good brokers and good underwriters in cyber insurance yet.

0:16:01

And so they just ended up having way too much work than they could handle. And I think that coming in with automation, and you know maybe when when you know when we launched in 2018 most smbs were not buying cyber insurance yet so it was manageable but as more and more companies started to buy insurance uh it was you know brokers started to gravitate more and more towards the automated solutions that that that we we've offered because there was there was just no other way for them to process

0:16:30
Alex Bond

all their work and obviously it speaks to you know my role is working in the recruitment sector we're always talking about, you know, people don't leave businesses because of money, they, you know, fulfillment, furtherment of career, leaving managers. And it speaks to that kind of rewarding part of the job, you know, like taking away that heavy administrative burden, workload, and getting into that relationship management. Presumably, you know, it's difficult to say, but have you ever got feedback from people that joins your business from other businesses in that there's more enjoyment from that relationship-driven approach?

0:17:07
Rotem Iram

Yeah, I mean, I think, first of all, when folks come in, typically their first reaction is just to be blown away by just, like, how much more fun the process is, you know, even before you get to the actual work. Like, you know, like, we have some folks tell us stories that when they need to issue a binder, it takes their machine like 15 minutes to produce all the documents. And with that bay, it takes two seconds.

0:17:39

And just the idea that you could produce something and just have it immediately available, it feels almost like going from this very old phone where nothing just gonna, everything's like slow. And to this like new, you got this new phone, this new iPad. Oftentimes it feels like going from coach to business class. Like it just feels, everything's just a lot easier. The amount of, like, I don't know, just like the amount of manual labor that you need to do to just get your stuff done and get off your desk is just so much lower.

0:18:18

That's more fun. But, and then the experience of having, not only having a lot more data, but having a security expert join every one of your customer calls and providing technical support, being able to have a much more technical and a much deeper conversation about risk. The feedback we get from our underwriters is that this feels like such better service to the brokers. They feel like they're being elevated as professionals. They're learning a ton. So, you know, we've been lucky to be able to attract like really amazing people into our company because they're like, I'm too young to be part of the industry that is just kind of, I don't know, staying left behind.

0:19:00

I want to be where kind of it's cutting edge. And obviously being part of a fast growing company where everybody's asked to do more than they can to stretch their capabilities to grow. You know, we're promoting from within. So, you know, a lot of our regional managers, our senior under, these are all people that came in, worked their butt off and just got further in their career a lot faster. They're managing books that are sometimes, 10 times bigger than what they did in their old shop.

0:19:29

And so it's just very, very exciting, dynamic environment. Obviously, the fact that everybody's a part owner of the company, everybody has equity, being part of that journey, I think it's really cool. And then maybe last but not least, which is personally important for me, is that we also have, by building an insurance company from scratch in the 21st century, we also have a chance to build a company that looks more like the world we want and less like the world we came from.

0:20:01

And so I'm talking specifically about diversity and inclusion. And, you know, at base, 50 % women from top to bottom, 50 % of the leadership team, you know, half of all the kind of VPs and executives in the company all the way down to the individual contributors. You know, it's it's interesting it started as a point of emphasis but at some point it just became self sustaining uh because uh you know amazing people saw a company that looked like the company they wanted to be part of and and and joined and we've been incredibly uh empowered by just having access to better talent and and then having that talent be kind of completely bought in and and really excited about

0:20:47

the culture and the environment. And, you know, and they really see this as a place where they have a shot at getting, you know, getting as far as possible. So that stuff's been really important for me. And especially as you climb towards the executive levels, I mean, the amount of 50 year old white men is just, you know, astounding, the numbers and I hope we can, I'm not 50 yet, but I fall into most of those privileged categories, but I'm hopeful that I can be part of this change and help build an industry that looks a lot more

0:21:26
Alex Bond

like the world we want to see. Yeah, and that's the thing, I mean, we've been doing some stuff at FinPro, we have a series, we're female leaders in insurance technology and we're involved in as many D &I initiatives as we can, mainly if nothing else to sort of learn. But one of the, you know, the most obvious and biggest takeaways is that we talk about the insurtech community a lot, because you've got a lot of really early stage companies, and that's your opportunity to get it right.

0:21:55

And then, as you found is that if you get it right, and you bring in, and it's about bringing in senior talent, it's putting people in positions of power, it's not saying, oh, we've got 50 % men and women for example but the 50 that are women are all in like junior roles you need to see leadership that's representative and and and that's obviously then going beyond gender into all sorts of kind of different criteria about how people self-identify people need to see businesses that look like them and there's two sides of that one is people coming into your business and and I've seen that a lot more in my role in the last kind of particularly 24 36

0:22:34

months people are not prepared to go and work for businesses where you know if i'm talking to a talented woman senior leader going trying to bring her in it's a lot harder if i'm pointing and saying do you want to join this business and you go who's the leadership team you go these eight 40 to 50 year old white guys um and and exactly i fall in that category as well but it it becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy so if you get it right and people could look at your business and and if you're sort of an ambitious woman that you're looking at businesses to work for if you can see that you're self-represented then you're going to do

0:23:10

that but flipping on its head it i had a really good conversation i mentioned this guy twice now um but i met brz insurance um at um the the iti event and and and their whole thing was look the latinx people in america don't buy insurance because they're not represented in any of the kind of insurance marketing. Things are not Spanish language. You know, they've got two service centers, one in Mexico, one in Brazil. Even their marketing is just representative of the 68 million Latino people that are in the US.

0:23:49

And it's something I was obviously oblivious to. One, not being a Brit and secondly, you know, being all the privileges there could be in a white guy. and it was so inherently obvious when he pointed it out it's like yeah you wouldn't want to buy insurance from people that don't represent you so yeah hugely important and hugely interesting um something I wanted to ask you you come from an engineering background there's lots of engineers in the business you started the business um you know in 2017 do you think you would change how much tech you built and and and there might be more of a balance between buying and building now because there is so much out there to support

0:24:31

insurtech startup businesses oh yeah 100 i mean

0:24:35
Rotem Iram

when we start we started it was we were part of the first wave so you know the first companies that uh by the way when you know early days i i was i was frustrated by i did not believe that i could build an analytics company and that people would actually use what I built because I thought that at the end of the day, the heart of an insurance company is underwriting. And it's the one like making decisions on like making risk decisions is the one thing they will never outsource.

0:25:11

And so I felt I had to build an insurance company to be able to actually kind of push the ceiling and leverage all of the expertise from security. But it felt like a very daunting experience. I mean, nobody was building insurance companies. It was very early. And I remember as we were kicking around this idea, Lemonade just came out of stealth and the founders are also Israeli. And so, you know, I connected with them. I was like, and they said, like, look, I mean, it's definitely complex, but, you know, so is cybersecurity.

0:25:45

security so you know you can you I mean you seem like a smart guy you can figure it out and so uh I was like well I don't know if I can but I know somebody who can and that's when I called up my co-founder and uh and said like you know you got to build an insurance company and uh and you know you start you start slowly uh there was nothing I mean we were um even the idea of how to set up an MGA was for people who came from outside the industry.

0:26:14

The resources, it wasn't clear where the resources even were, who to ask the question. So I think we, you know, if we were to launch this now, we would probably have saved, you know, close to a year on development. We probably would not have had to develop a lot of the back office that just even the back, you know, even the companies that we did work with in the beginning have done so much work and are and are so much better today than they were five years ago that five years ago we just couldn't use it it wasn't good enough today it would have been good enough and we would have been able to use it so um yeah i

0:26:50

mean 100 it's just like and i mean this is following the the exact same you know blueprint of fintech where you're starting with a few trailblazers who make everybody else interested in the space. And then you're starting to see not only kind of consumer facing companies, but a lot of infrastructure companies coming in and building the infrastructure and just making it, you know, lowering the barriers to, to enter. But I will say that the, the biggest barrier in insurance remains capital and the ability to access the ability to access capital in a good way and uh that part you know you know it's interesting every different stage of a company the stuff that keeps you up at night is very

0:27:37

different uh what you know when you just start you have nothing you know nothing uh you're trying to come up with a product and a go-to-market strategy that that makes sense we call it product market fit um you know and so that's kind of where all of your concern. And when we launched our product initially, did very poorly, because not surprisingly, we knew nothing about what it took to sell insurance. And so, you know, we fixed it.

0:28:08

We got great feedback that it sucked. And then we fixed it. And then we got great feedback that it was working. So, and, you know, once you pass that stage, you're like, all right, somebody's willing to buy this. Then you realize, oh, my God, I, I am not going to be able to actually sell a lot of these because I don't have any of the infrastructure. I'm just, you know, everything is manual. Everything's like not built.

0:28:33

I just don't have the, you know, even scaling from doing a hundred scans a day to 10 ,000 scans a day. It's like that takes a lot of scaling of the business. And so that was kind of a key concern for us for a very long time. And then once you reach scale at a company, you know, and At-Bay today is we're processing kind of hundreds of thousands of submissions in a year maybe even more i think we're issuing more than a million documents a month and it's become a high-scale business at this point then your concern kind of changes okay where am i going to get the supply of capital uh to support my continued growth and

0:29:14

it's just an

0:29:14
Alex Bond

interesting journey well i wanted to yeah i wanted to sort of take a pause on because i really want to dig into the challenges on the journey and i think you touched on some really interesting ones there but just to paint a picture um of the At-Bay business now today what does it look like geographies you're focusing on numbers of people um bits and pieces where are you sort of series b on the funding round i think you've raised no so we're a we're a series d company we raised

0:29:44
Rotem Iram

$300 million uh to date um last valuation was 1.4 $1 billion that was about a year ago So, you know, even though public markets are not doing very well, At-Bay has grown almost, I think, well, about four and a half times. We're four and a half times bigger than we were exactly a year ago when we signed a Series D. So we're still growing at a really fast clip. We're at about, you know, I think in June, we're going to pass about $340 million in premium run rate.

0:30:21

We have about 220 people. You know, we're adding 2 ,500 new customers a month to our book. Out of the 220 people, we have about 70 people that are pure R &D, data science, cybersecurity research. And then the rest of the organization is around, you know, underwriting, claims management, finance, marketing, all that stuff. That's kind of where we are. We sell it. We're exclusively in the U.S. uh we we work across the country in five kind of uh we have four regional offices and um we uh we know we have a bunch of people that are remote and uh yeah and we're exclusive to the wholesale community which is a thing that is a little bit different about ad

0:31:09

bay and some of our other startup competitors um you know we're very loyal to uh um to our wholesale partners um they've they've been incredible partners to us. And, uh, and so that's, that's kind of the focus for us on the go to market side. Um,

0:31:25
Alex Bond

yeah, brilliant, brilliant. I, uh, I think my brain had a meltdown there because I had the number and I was thinking that's the biggest series B I've ever seen. Um, I knew you'd hit the magic unicorn status as well. I'm always, I'm always interested if anyone has a unicorn party. Um, but, um, but touching on this stuff you said, it's just, i always this is just a personal question um from a kind of um point of view of you know i i've got a very small business and um but obviously we bootstrap everything but when you're doing venture-backed businesses does does it ever get scary did you ever sort of stop and think these

0:32:04
Rotem Iram

are pretty big numbers does it oh my god oh it's all the time uh i i i think the look when when we first started all we had was a powerpoint deck and it wasn't even like a really good one and and investors were like you know here's $3.5 million go try and build something and i was like that was that was scary because i never i mean i look i i was i was an executive before and i managed people and i had a budget that was bigger but you know it was a an established company and it didn't feel like it felt when it was just there we have nothing and there's absolutely no

0:32:50

guardrails and I think that you know when we when we raise our series you know then 3 million becomes 30 million and three million become 300 million and the numbers just become just you know they feel insane the the revenue part the the scale of the business the amount of people like all of it you know I think one thing about COVID which is interesting is that it masks a lot of the growth because you know I you don't see all the people that joined the company and and you don't necessarily see the the momentum the way that maybe we would have seen in you don't feel it we've just recently reopened our offices and um you know I traveled

0:33:33

to meet back teams and suddenly you're surrounded with 70 90 100 people and you're like oh wow this is like a big company now. And so, yeah, it feels I, you know, personally, I've been, I've been challenged and stretched more than any other time in my career. Every time you get comfortable, you immediately get uncomfortable again. The ambition is just really high across the board, the mission we're trying to build. And it's just, it's, look, it's the exciting part is that it's, I feel like, you know sometimes you need to be in the right place at the right time and we I feel fortunate to have found myself in a place where it's just uh there's just a lot of

0:34:14

really good momentum for the business and so it's just been growing really really fast so you're just there's almost no time to think about uh and reflect about what's going on you just gotta always be in you know be in the moment and execute uh uh to your best but yeah it's uh I still go back and and uh and just the sheer scale of the numbers feels uh feels ridiculous to me yeah i'm glad though i think

0:34:40
Alex Bond

if it didn't then i think you'd be taking it serious enough yeah i mean i'd be a psychopath i've got a really good friend of mine called uh rupert who is a headhunter and is a really good guy and he went into investment banking before he worked in recruitment and and uh uh he basically he came out and went into recruitment. He said, the day I get comfortable betting hundreds of millions of dollars of other people's money, is that's never going to be me.

0:35:10

And that's why he actually walked away from that industry and was just sort of talking about that pressure. And so I'm always intrigued. Funnily enough, for all the people I've had on the podcast, and we're sort of up to nearly 100 episodes now, I've never gone, what does it feel like to kind of put, you know, put yourself on the line for that. I've got great respect for it, especially with a company growing so much but it's a really interesting point you made about not being able to see the people it's almost kind of from you the scale of growth um do you

0:35:38
Rotem Iram

but i will by the way just yeah no just one more smaller thing i will say that you know the interesting journey for me was that when when we started you know there was an intellectual curiosity i wanted to solve cyber risk i wanted uh i i thought that there was a really important business to be built here where we could help figure out risk and help guide customers. So a lot of the, and still to this day, you know, from a mission perspective, you know, you know, my mission is around leveraging the position of the insurance company to really learn what matters about cyber risk and then use what we learn to help standardize the industry, guide our customers,

0:36:24

provide them with great risk transfer and great risk management. But the one thing that kind of surprised me in the journey is that as you start building it, you're no longer on your own. You now have, in the beginning, dozens and then at this point, hundreds of people that join your journey that wake up every day, every morning and give everything they have to try and build this business together with you. And you become, in a way, responsible for their journey, for their outcomes, for their success.

0:36:54

And at least personally for me, that has now become a much bigger and more important, you know, driving force in my own journey. Because there's, there are so many people who are just doing amazing, amazing, incredible. They're not the founders of the company yet. They wake up every day as if they were the founders. It's their baby. They, they, they give, you know, they poured their heart and soul into the business. And it's really important for me that they have, you know, an amazing journey and an amazing outcome.

0:37:24

And that's not something that I necessarily understood that was going to happen when we got started. But it's, you know, at the end of the day, it's like numbers are numbers. But people kind of that's the stuff that really matters when you go to sleep. So and that's the stuff that keeps me up at night if I feel that I'm not doing as good a job as I want to.

0:37:48
Alex Bond

Yeah. Yeah. No, I understand. you know there's been a it's been some really there's been some really tough moments as well for other other insurtechs out there at the moment with how to let people go and you know it's um it's the challenge between growing really aggressively um and and then you know if the funding doesn't happen then then you're in a difficult spot so yeah it's a huge responsibility i wanted to take it back to something you touched on firstly i love the fact that you started with a bad powerpoint slide because i keep seeing some really snobby pitch competitions where they're like no powerpoint and i'm like if the idea is good enough i don't care if it's

0:38:22

written on a napkin you know if you've got the right team and the right idea then that should take precedence as to whether you know how to build uh you know really exciting pitch decks i'm not saying they're not important but that sort of stuff frustrates me um but taking it back you touched on a few things what did you get wrong at the start i'm really intrigued about that and then you know was it right thesis wrong application um yeah i mean yeah we got i can i can fill a full

0:38:52
Rotem Iram

hour with the stuff but i will say one one thing that was was very surprising to me in the beginning was that i thought that if you could underwrite better then it's obvious that you can translate that into a better product and win in the marketplace by being a better underwriter by having better risk. And that is actually not true in insurance. So here's the thing about underwrite. So first of all, neither the broker nor the customer care about how much money you're going to make.

0:39:25

If anything, you know, they don't want you making a lot of money because that means they got a bad deal, right? You need, you want, you want to make sure that your capital providers get a good return and a solid return and that you're being responsible with their money. But But as far as winning in the marketplace goes, you're trying to squeeze out the best coverage and price for a given kind of loss ratio target, right?

0:39:51

And here's the problem with underwriting, Will, is that the more you know about a company, it doesn't necessarily translate into giving them a better rate. Because at least half the times what you discover makes you like the company less, right? So if you're coming in, so when we came in, we did all these scans, collect all this data, and at least half the times we were giving worse terms because of what we found, not necessarily better terms.

0:40:24

And then the broker is like, you're unpredictable. And sometimes you give me great product, but sometimes you give me shitty product. There's somebody else out here who's not doing any of the stuff you're doing, and they're always cheap. because the problem is that if for you to be able to so you need a couple things to happen to be able to leverage great underwriting to win in the marketplace one is that you need rational competition if there's somebody out there that is always really really cheap then from a broker perspective they are a lot more predictable and a lot easier to work with than somebody like you who takes a lot of um you know takes takes their time and

0:41:02

tries to figure it out the second part is you need capital partners who allow you to be selectively aggressive, right? And oftentimes, what you find is that when capital is loose, and so are, so is your competition. Because when people, when distribution companies get access to loose underwriting guidelines, they tend to overheat and compete too much. And so, you know, the real magic is, and it took us, you know, it took us a while to figure it out.

0:41:36

The real magic is that historically in insurance, the trade-off was between speed and depth of underwriting. You had to choose one because spending, like doing more underwriting work meant that it would be slower, it would take more time, would be more complicated it would be it would create more friction for the broker and the customer and our ability to actually get much more data through our scans but then also to provide a result a lot faster than competition even though our competition isn't collecting all this data they're actually taking longer than we are so you know you collect 100x more data points but then you make a decision in 11 seconds from start to finish so the collection the

0:42:20

analysis the results and the and the binding, the whole thing takes under 30 seconds. That was the magic because we could achieve better speeds and better underwriting by leveraging technology. And that's something that I didn't really understand before we started. And one thing that's really great about competing by having better, faster service is that as far as the broker's concerned, if you're slow, you better be cheap. What it means is that if you can compete on service, you don't have to compete on price.

0:42:53

And so you don't have to get pushed to a position where your only way of winning is to lower prices and therefore jeopardize your underwriting results and your loss ratios. And I think that that's just really key for, especially when you work in kind of SMB admin market spaces, the ability to achieve effectiveness and speeding up the process means that you can do a really good job on service levels and you don't have to compromise your pricing.

0:43:24
Alex Bond

Your depth of knowledge of cybersecurity sort of reminds me of the old adage in insurance that claims people tend to make terrible underwriters because when you see the back end of it, you wouldn't underwrite anything. And it's getting... 100%.

0:43:40
Rotem Iram

Yeah, by the way, when we started, our security team wouldn't want to sell insurance to anybody. because everybody was like they found something wrong with everybody and and it was a real learning process for us to say like okay uh you know obviously the lowest loss ratio is not selling a single policy you're never going to have a claim but can we find a price in which this is profitable you know and uh and training on uh also by the way training everybody both the underwriters and the security people to only concentrate on the things that actually drive meaningful losses uh instead because in security oftentimes because you have no idea what where money actually gets lost you tend to

0:44:23

talk about everything uh you also try to portray yourself as an expert so you you bring you build best practices and frameworks with like just so so many dashboards and it's just so convoluted and nobody can can follow uh and and you lose your audience where with an insurance company if it's if it's important then show me how that changes the policy Either price has changed or the sublimit or the retention, or you're even not willing to sell it to me.

0:44:52

Right. And if you're not really changing your price or your terms, it means it's not important or at least, you know, so actually using the insurance policy as the ultimate, you know, testament of whether this thing matters or not, I think is a really important kind of focusing and enforcing function for our security team and our underwriters.

0:45:16
Alex Bond

interesting interesting um i'm conscious of her time and i and i want to move towards the future because i think you know you've got such momentum in the business um want to talk about kind of what's next for you and like what are you excited about for the future of the of your business and maybe more broadly the industry um yeah so um you know from the

0:45:44
Rotem Iram

when I you know when I was in security the thing that frustrated me the most was that the technology company that build your technology stack don't take any responsibility over their role in the failures of your security you know I'll use a quick example imagine you bought a car for your business because you wanted you needed to drive around and you know you drive around and then suddenly your brakes fail. And when you survive the crash, you learn that the brake manufacturer posted on their blog site on their blog post that they have a critical vulnerability in their brakes that you needed to pass yourself.

0:46:23

And so they're not going to, they're not going to call you off. They're not going to recall the car. They're not going to fix the brakes themselves. And they are definitely not going to be liable for any damages that happened to you because the breaks failed. And so now you need to be up to speed on their blog. Now imagine you had 50 different vendors of parts in your car and each one was going to break twice a year.

0:46:46

All you wanted was a car. I mean, you're a small business owner. You just want to drive to work. Now you need to have a full-time mechanic reading blogs of these different vendors, patching and fixing systems on a weekly basis to make sure that the car doesn't crash. And by the way, this is where my metaphor where it breaks a little bit also in cyber insurance as a small business owner you're up against the chinese army the russian mafia like these are big big scary highly resourced very sophisticated attackers there is no military there is no fbi there's no police it's a wild west there's you're on your own and and on the internet you're next door neighbor with

0:47:27

every criminal on the planet. And like that stuff is like, we're just asking so much from, from small businesses. And what I like about insurance is that insurance has always played the role of market standard setter. I mean, if you, I can bet that on your ceiling, you have a smoke detector right now, and it's probably not because you are passionate about smoke detection technology and its effectiveness against fires, or that the specific brand of the smoke alarm is one that you just really kind of buy into what they do.

0:48:03

It's probably because the insurance company forces whoever built your apartment or your house to have it installed. And so the insurance company ends up figuring out what matters and then using its policy to force certain things to be adopted. right seat belts became a law after the insurance companies mandated that they wouldn't sell insurance unless there was a seat belt same thing is going to happen in security there are all these vendors running around promising a bunch of stuff nobody knows what matters there are a bunch of it companies who build porous fragile technology stacks that keep breaking with absolutely no accountability to what they're building and you know what today you know just to give you one example, if

0:48:49

you have a Microsoft Exchange email server, we find that you have 125 % more likely to have a breach. And so we don't, you know, we tell you either you move to Google, or you go to Office 365, or we're going to double your premium. And so now, Microsoft needs to decide whether it wants to be the product that causes you to double your premiums, you know, or maybe they want to do something about it. And I just love the opportunity that we have to learn and to set standards, to use our policy, to just push the world towards a better place.

0:49:34

To me, that's where, to be able to do that, you need to be a credible insurance company. You need to show that what you're doing actually works. So our ability to build and grow an insurance company to show that what we're doing actually drives down ransomware loss. You know, the fact that we've been able to save hundreds of businesses from having a ransomware, like that stuff is to me is, is, is amazing. You know, but then on the, on the more personal kind of company side, I I'm, I mean, we touched upon this a little bit earlier.

0:50:07

I mean, for me, the exciting part is I, I feel like we're building a really special company. I really do. We are, we have amazing people, you know, we have good people that are, you know, we have like this no asshole rule. I mean, there's just, you know, you have to be good at your job, but you also have to be a really good person. And, and I feel like we're building kind of a company that is just, I don't know, it's just inspiring in terms of the talent, the people, the way they treat each other, the way they work together.

0:50:37

I'm, I'm just super pumped of, uh about like that that part like it's just really really um it's probably the the proudest i've i've been in anything i've ever done in my life just just seeing kind of these people come together and what they can build together uh that stuff if we can grow this and help push this to be kind of the new standard uh um in you know in our industry to me that that that would be kind of the dream

0:51:04
Alex Bond

what a wonderful place to uh to bring it to a close i think i think that's a that's such a nice uh thing to hear because um yeah but using insurance as a force for good is definitely here but actually kind of the mechanics of that i obviously then immediately got nervous about what email server i'm using um i think it's 365 i think i'll be okay um uh but um but yeah no i I think absolutely that you can get lost in the numbers and the hype of venture capital back to businesses and actually stripping it back to being a no-ars-all rule company.

0:51:39

That's a good place to be and learn and develop is something we should all aspire to. So thank you so much for being a guest. I'm really glad we got to do this. It was a lot of fun. Yeah. And I just really appreciate your time. So thanks for being so kind of being a guest on the podcast.

0:51:56
Rotem Iram

Yeah, I appreciate it. thank you so much for having me thank you

0:52:14
Alex Bond

as always this podcast is brought to you by finpro search partners often simply known as finpro finpro is an executive recruitment business working in the insurance and insure tech space on an international basis. If you would like to find out more about FinPro, please visit our website, www.wearefinpro.com or our FinPro company page on LinkedIn. I've been your host, Alex Bond, and I would personally love to connect with anyone who is interested in the changing world of insurance.

0:52:43

So feel free to reach out to me directly, either on LinkedIn or via my email of alex at wearefinpro.com. I hope you enjoyed the podcast and I hope to see you back next week. Thank you.