# ‘What Does Insurance Look Like In 2030?’ : An Interview With Rob Galbraith, Insurance Futurist

- **Show:** The Leadership in Insurance Podcast
- **Published:** 9 Feb 2022
- **Source:** https://anchor.fm/alex-bond6/episodes/What-Does-Insurance-Look-Like-In-2030---An-Interview-With-Rob-Galbraith--Insurance-Futurist-e1duanf
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/leadership-in-insurance/what-does-insurance-look-like-in-2030-an-interview-with-rob-galbraith-insurance-d5702e/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

Rob Galbraith argues that insurtech is still in its early days and that insurance in the 2030s will look very different. Technology has long been part of insurance, but most newcomers still run the old model with a twist. He expects new products, cheaper operations, and competition on both data models and customer experience.

The tension is between hype and reality. Listed insurtechs like Root and Lemonade have fallen back to earth, and Galbraith sees few truly new business models. Yet he sees real innovation in underserved markets and in back-office automation. Both men stress that long-term thinking, diverse teams, and brave leadership are needed to break from incumbent habits.

## Key insights

1. **Insurers were early tech adopters, now burdened** Galbraith says insurers adopted mainframes and desktops in the 1970s and 1980s. Maintaining those old systems while adding new technology is why change is hard today.
2. **Most insurtechs still copy the incumbent model** Galbraith says many use the same contract forms and pricing processes, with a marketing or technology twist. He is still waiting for a company with a lasting competitive moat.
3. **Emerging markets may export innovation back to richer ones** He cites a startup in Mexico aiming to sell small business cover where about 92% of small firms are uninsured, and an African startup accepting recyclables as premium payment. He expects such ideas to spread to developed markets.
4. **Lower expense ratios will unlock new insurance products** Automation of manual back-office tasks and API-based integration cut costs. Galbraith argues cheaper operations make it viable to insure things that were previously too costly, such as stolen packages or micro-insurance.
5. **Plan ten years out, revisit assumptions twice yearly** Galbraith advises companies to examine economic, demographic, political and then technology trends, and to build plans around them. He says to re-check assumptions every six months, since short strategic horizons and bonuses push against long-term thinking.

## Questions this episode answers

### Why is it hard for traditional insurers to adopt new technology?

Galbraith says insurers were early computer users in the 1970s and 1980s, so they carry old proprietary systems. Keeping those running while moving to cloud and plug-and-play platforms is very difficult.

### What does S.C.A.L.E.D mean in insurance technology?

Galbraith uses it as an acronym for the technologies reshaping insurance: sensors, cloud computing, artificial intelligence, localized knowledge (like GPS and aerial imagery), efficient back-office tools, and digital distribution and communication.

### Why have insurtech stocks like Lemonade and Root struggled?

Galbraith says insurance is a high-capital, low-margin business that suits few investors, and many insurtechs are not fundamentally different from incumbents. He noted Root laying off 300 people and Lemonade's share price falling below its IPO price.

### What are the seven fatal flaws of insurance?

Galbraith names them from his book, starting with that insurance is too expensive, too complicated, easy to game through fraud, and a cash drain because premiums are paid upfront. He also says it doesn't cover all causes of loss.

### How could insurance be sold to people who never had it before?

Galbraith points to micro-insurance, crop insurance, parametric cover (payouts triggered by set events), and embedded cover sold through retailers or mobile phone providers. These lower-cost methods reach people in developing economies.

## Facts

- **Rob Galbraith** [0:01:12]: "we're coming on the three-year anniversary of the publication of my book, The End of Insurance as We Know It."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:03:06]: "USAA insurers, military members and their families, and they do business directly. They don't have agents, either exclusive agents or independent agents or brokers that they sell through."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:02:31]: "had the opportunity to work for the Federal Reserve Board, the central bank here in the United States where I'm based for the first two and a half years of my career."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:04:47]: "I spent two and a half years after leaving USAA as innovation lead at a company called AF Group that sells commercial lines insurance rather than personal lines"
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:07:17]: "They were early adopters. They were just early adopters in the 1970s and the 1980s when we had mainframe computing and then desktop computing following that."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:08:30]: "This week, we get news that Root is having to lay off 300 individuals and the lemonade share price has fallen below its IPO price."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:09:35]: "And so that's sensors, cloud computing, artificial intelligence, localized knowledge, think about GPS, aerial imagery, things like that."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:09:35]: "Efficiencies in the back office, so efficient technologies, RPAs, OCR, natural language processing, low-code, no-code solutions"
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:10:15]: "I think about micro insurance, I think about, you know, crop insurance, type products, parametric cover"
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:12:43]: "And that's different for our sector, because traditionally, right, the top companies have been the top companies for decades, if not for centuries."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:15:06]: "insurance is too expensive, meaning it's a large percentage of, you know, a household's budget or a business's budget. It's too complicated."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:16:03]: "your premiums are going to pay losses that other people had right in this year. And at the end of the year, right, there's no pot of money for you"
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:17:44]: "This is how Warren Buffett is really, you know, made a living."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:20:12]: "you have this high capital requirement and low margins."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:22:07]: "I look at companies like Guy Gleier and Duck Creek that not only are more and more companies going to those platforms"
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:28:34]: "here's an underserved segment of business that we think we can quickly gain market share and become a top 10 rider in for that particular line"
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:29:28]: "you can see that their cell of desktop max, isn't nearly what it was probably, you know, 34 years ago, but they've continued to reinvent themselves"
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:35:03]: "he wants to emulate what they've done at Next Insurance and sell small commercial business to Mexico."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:35:03]: "92 % or thereabouts of small businesses in Mexico don't have any insurance coverage, they don't have that kind of protection."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:36:05]: "I know that they were actually accepting recyclables for premium payments, right? As a way to kind of offset."
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:38:20]: "often their strategic horizon, quite frankly, is just three to five years, right?"
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:40:22]: "I've even talked to insure tech startups that are talking about entirely replacing their tech stack after three years, right?"
- **Rob Galbraith** [0:46:23]: "I am the co-host of a podcast called the InsurTech Geek Podcast."
- **Alex Bond** [0:23:34]: "Jeff Keist was on, from Montu, was on a podcast And he talked about how banks have for a long time done a very good job of getting you when you go to college"

## Transcript

**[0:00:00] Alex Bond:** Hello and welcome to the Leadership in Insurance Podcast. This is the podcast where we discuss what leadership looks like in the modern insurance business. We talk to insurtech leaders and founders, innovators and change agents from the insurance industry. We also talk to thought leaders from outside the industry, such as organizational psychologists, performance coaches and investment professionals. Anyone who can add value to the conversation on how to lead insurance businesses of the future. good morning and welcome to the Leadership in Insurance Podcast i'm your host alex bond and i'm really lucky today to be joined by rob galbraith who um unusually we're normally introducing to say like they run xyz business um and um man of many hats uh which we're

**[0:00:53] Alex Bond:** always talking about in insurtech land, but particularly author, futurist, speaker, thought person on insurtech. Rob, I don't know if that's accurately covering you off, but I'd let you kind of, how would you describe yourself and what the work that you do?

**[0:01:12] Rob Galbraith:** Sure, Alex, it's great to be on with you. And yeah, no, I think you spot on. I am in the process of setting up my own business, but haven't quite pulled the trigger yet because it'd be much easier to just say, I'm head of whatever at this firm and here's what we do. So I get to do a lot of the hand-waving without that. But absolutely, we're coming on the three-year anniversary of the publication of my book, The End of Insurance as We Know It.

**[0:01:39] Rob Galbraith:** And I'm still finding folks out there that said, oh, you're an author, when is your book coming out? And it's like, it's been out, it's done quite well, whatever. I definitely hope to write a second book, but don't have any firm dates I'm ready to commit to yet. So, yeah, we're kind of at that time where our days are fast and our years are slow or vice versa, I guess, with the pandemic. So I'm very much in that time vortex.

**[0:02:06] Rob Galbraith:** So, yes, but the man of many hats is a great way to put it.

**[0:02:10] Alex Bond:** Absolutely. But to give us some context, because I think that's, you know, we've had lots of plucky upstarts coming into the insurance landscape saying insurance is broken and I'm going to revolutionize it. That's not you. There's a very good predigree in insurance. So perhaps you'd kind of walk us through particularly your career at USAA and what you were doing there.

**[0:02:31] Rob Galbraith:** Yeah, happy to. So you're absolutely right. You know, I really kind of come from an insurance background. I actually started my degree at university in economics, had the opportunity to work for the Federal Reserve Board, the central bank here in the United States where I'm based for the first two and a half years of my career. Moved down to San Antonio, Texas, where I still reside and was able to fortunately catch on with USAA after short stood at Citibank and worked at USAA for almost 20 years in a variety of different roles.

**[0:03:06] Rob Galbraith:** And that really kind of led to the ability to innovate. USAA insurers, military members and their families, and they do business directly. They don't have agents, either exclusive agents or independent agents or brokers that they sell through. And so just give you kind of a picture that I think really neatly sums up their push for innovation. So after 9-11, when the Iraq war started, the Afghanistan war, and then the war in Iraq started, you know, mobile phones, right, became a big thing kind of at the end of the 2000s.

**[0:03:46] Rob Galbraith:** And so asking questions about, you know, can we have a mobile app? Could you have somebody that's deployed in Afghanistan at 2 a.m. on one bar that's trying to conduct business, right? And how can we serve their needs? And, you know, that's a very demanding environment. But if we can serve the needs of that individual, then the general public, whether they be an active duty military, somebody that's previously served, the son or daughter or a grandchild of somebody that served, we can probably meet their needs in just the shopping mall or whatnot, right?

**[0:04:17] Rob Galbraith:** On a Friday afternoon in a busy time or the Wi-Fi is crowded. So that kind of mentality just led to a lot of questioning about the business models and how can we do things better? And so I think that kind of infiltrated throughout a lot of my thinking and had the opportunity to explore a lot of emerging technologies, partner with a lot of startups. And really that led to me writing my book, which came out at the beginning of 2019 called The End of Insurance as we know it.

**[0:04:47] Rob Galbraith:** Had just an amazing reception for that book worldwide since that time. I spent two and a half years after leaving USAA as innovation lead at a company called AF Group that sells commercial lines insurance rather than personal lines at USAA, working through independent agents. And so got exposed to that channel and just how important distribution is in the marketplace and some of the challenges of going direct versus going to the agent channel. And obviously a lot of startups have, you know, I think originally said, you know, these are middlemen and we're going to eliminate that and kind of reduce costs.

**[0:05:23] Rob Galbraith:** And they realize that customer acquisition costs are quite challenging and have a lot have pivoted to either, you know, do both or go exclusively through agents or focus on improving the agent experience rather than directly through customers. So I've been on my own since August of last year and just, you know, enjoying after 25 years of working at large institutions, you know, kind of being a startup myself and advising a lot of companies, consulting, and as you mentioned, giving a lot of talks and workshops for different corporate clients.

**[0:05:58] Alex Bond:** awesome thank you for that it's it's um it's something i was thinking about when you talk about usaa which i've not i don't know why it's taken me so long to kind of think of this is that you know a lot of the technological developments that we see uh in the kind of consumer landscape come from military development and military application because you're saying right this is the this is the extreme end of what we have to cope with whether it be car safety or aviation and I hadn't thought to bring it down to the humble insurance you know like if we can if we can kind of build some technology that works for a person on one bar in

**[0:06:30] Alex Bond:** the in the back end of nowhere then we can probably do it for the the mum in the shopping mall and but that I think that's an interesting way to look at innovation saying what's the most extreme end of this and then how do we bring this into kind of day-to-day parlance I don't think I've set anyone a loftier first question than this so um i i sort of um thank you for being a good sport and and it's really sort of i love the fact that you've got this breadth of background and you've looked at different parts of the value chain and and different distribution models and um you know we're always talking on this um podcast

**[0:07:05] Alex Bond:** about the challenge of having enough breadth of experience to sort of have value for multiple insure techs um so loftiest question i can probably ask is uh 2022 what does

**[0:07:17] Rob Galbraith:** insurance look like in 2030 for you? Yeah, I think a lot of folks such as myself that have long careers in the insurance profession really have the wrong attitude towards insurtech. And they rightly point out that technology has been part of the insurance industry for a long time. There's a misnomer out there that insurance entities are slow to adopt technology, were actually the converse is true. They were early adopters. They were just early adopters in the 1970s and the 1980s when we had mainframe computing and then desktop computing following that.

**[0:07:54] Rob Galbraith:** And so maintaining those systems, keeping the trains running while then incorporating a lot of these new emerging technologies is exceedingly challenged. And a lot of these companies have built up significant technical data in the 2010s, of course, with a lot of buzz about digital transformation journeys. And it's a big change to go from a proprietary system that's on-premises to something that's perhaps based in the cloud and a more kind of platform ecosystem approach. The idea that, you know, you actually want your system to be able to plug and play with many other systems, some of which you may own, but many of which you don't directly own.

**[0:08:30] Rob Galbraith:** And that you even want to be open to partner with that startup that doesn't exist yet, but two years from now will be a key strategic partner of yours to offer some new product or service to your clients. So, InsurTech is not a fad. And I know there's been a lot of written, particularly early this year, as some of the early IPOs have fizzled out and the market returns. This week, we get news that Root is having to lay off 300 individuals and the lemonade share price has fallen below its IPO price.

**[0:09:06] Rob Galbraith:** So I think we're at a little bit of a nadir in terms of just, hey, are we losing momentum on the insure tech space? I actually feel like we're still very much in the early days. And so to your question about the 2030s, much of what I've seen is really improving on the same model that we've had for a really long time in insurance. And so maybe you're out marketing somebody, you've got some quick twist of use of AI or something.

**[0:09:35] Rob Galbraith:** But fundamentally, it's very much the same. And I see a lot of opportunity for just fundamentally rethinking insurance. I talk about the S.C.A.L.E.D technologies, scale being an acronym. And so that's sensors, cloud computing, artificial intelligence, localized knowledge, think about GPS, aerial imagery, things like that. Efficiencies in the back office, so efficient technologies, RPAs, OCR, natural language processing, low-code, no-code solutions, and then digital distribution and communication, right? That ability to transact business online or at least communicate with clients online, that important part.

**[0:10:15] Rob Galbraith:** And again, we're still very much in the early days of kind of incorporating those technologies, both traditional incumbents and startups, to the point where you're really coming up with a compelling value proposition to customers. And in many cases, it is starting in the personal line space and small commercial space. And what I'm seeing, particularly in a lot of developing economies, is the ability to offer insurance products to people that have never had insurance before. I think about micro insurance, I think about, you know, crop insurance, type products, parametric cover, things like, you know, being able to ensure the Amazon package getting stolen off your porch, right?

**[0:10:52] Rob Galbraith:** Travel insurance, you know, embedded has been a big thing. And so I think what you're going to see is really two things in the 2030s. One, a whole new, just suite and class of insurance products that don't exist today or are just starting to come out today. We're going to be buying insurance for a whole lot more things. And we may not even know who we're buying it from, right? It may be through a retailer or somebody else.

**[0:11:17] Rob Galbraith:** But I think we're going to want that type of production on all manner of different things. And bringing down the cost curve, the expense ratio, allows you to open up to a lot of new marketplaces. The second thing I think is going to be competing on both algorithms and experiences, right? So if you have the best data and the best algorithms, you're going to outcompete from a pricing underwriting standpoint. But of course, if you don't have that compelling experience part, you're going to really struggle to attract customers.

**[0:11:49] Rob Galbraith:** And so I think about things like telematics. I think about things like smart home devices, wearables, you name it. these sensors are able to stream data where we can kind of directly observe behavior of systems, right? We don't have to ask, right? What make and model is your car? We don't have to ask how old your home is, what's the size of your flat, things like that. And we really, you know, there are people that are collecting that data and they really looked at it, but we really haven't made this full paradigm shift to doing business that way.

**[0:12:21] Rob Galbraith:** And that eliminates a lot of the subjective questions that we have to ask, you know, agents to collect or ask of clients, a lot of the manual checkpoints that you have to do in underwriting our claims process. And so I just think we're going to see a fundamental rethink of insurance. And I think we're going to see some of the traditional insurers, you know, continue to be leaders in the space in 2030s, but I think we're going to see a host of new names as well.

**[0:12:43] Rob Galbraith:** And that's different for our sector, because traditionally, right, the top companies have been the top companies for decades, if not for centuries. Many of them have a very long and rich history. We're not used to that dynamicism that you might see in retail or entertainment or other sectors. And so I think that's going to be a big change that we'll see in the 2030s. There's going to be a lot of new names out there that don't exist or very minor today that I think are going to be household names globally in the 2030s.

**[0:13:13] Alex Bond:** Thank you. Thank you. I set you a lofty question and you answered it very fully, which I like. Something I couldn't help thinking about whilst you were talking was about the, I think when we talk about disruption, innovation, I keep thinking, come back to the customer because almost every podcast guest I have that sells an InsurTech product or InsurTech solution is talking about customer and focusing on that. And I just take it back to it. We take insurance back to first principles and not even first principles, just talking about the sort of rudimentary concept of sitting at Lloyd's Coffeehouse and there's a ship going out and we're all putting our name under it.

**[0:13:58] Alex Bond:** If it goes down, we'll cover you for the cost of it. Very simplistic, very transactional. There's a thing that we're insuring that if lost, we're going to repay for and to put good. and I think about the kind of evolution of insure tech as we look at it is it is it more reflective of the sort of demands of society that our demands are so nuanced now because let's be honest most sort of particularly sort of richest civilizations that if we lose a laptop it's an inconvenience you know it's an inconvenience it's like yes I'd like I'd like to return the money from my laptop but it's more of an inconvenience so we're getting into these nuanced insurances like the

**[0:14:39] Alex Bond:** amazon package getting stolen off my porch but that's because we live in a world where it's perfectly normal for me to get something delivered in 24 hours and it just sits on my porch you know rather than it being actually evolution of insurance and insurance being broken it's more of an evolution of society and therefore what we expect from from an insurance product do you i've taken a very long time to ask a question no i don't know if that trans came

**[0:15:06] Rob Galbraith:** I'm a cross. 100%. Yeah, no, you're 100%. And in my book, I talk about what I call the seven fatal flaws of insurance. And without going into too much detail, that is essentially that insurance is too expensive, meaning it's a large percentage of, you know, a household's budget or a business's budget. It's too complicated. So you might think about your utility bill and while it may be expensive to pay your electricity or your water, right?

**[0:15:31] Rob Galbraith:** The, the use cases and the benefits that you derive are fairly obvious. So you don't mind paying that. If you're, again, leasing an apartment or a car, you're making a car payment, these things are lots of money, but very compelling. The same isn't true of insurance. It's like I'm paying hundreds of dollars, thousands of dollars a month for something I hope I don't use. And then when I go to use it, of course, most people default to the idea of a bank account of, oh, you've been saving my premiums on the side to be this pot of money for me when I need to use it.

**[0:16:03] Rob Galbraith:** And the idea that actually, no, your premiums are going to pay losses that other people had right in this year. And at the end of the year, right, there's no pot of money for you, right? And if you have a loss, and that's going to come from other people, I think people still really struggle. And they don't understand certainly deductibles, right, sub limits, co-insurance, the whole nine yards that most of us that have been in the industry for a long time can certainly rip off and recite and are very kind of proud of our knowledge.

**[0:16:27] Rob Galbraith:** But that's not the way most people's mental model of insurance works. So when they interact with the product, you know, they have that claim or whatever, they get very confused. And again, that's where the agents or brokers really play a valuable role in terms of, you know, educating folks on something that they don't know much about and probably don't care to know much about. It's certainly easy to game the system, right? So fraud and then fraud prevention, both of those jack up the overall cost of insurance.

**[0:16:52] Rob Galbraith:** It's a cash drain. So in addition to being expensive, the liquidity, right? You mentioned losing your laptop or if your laptop's damaged. If you think about using a credit card to pay for that, it's like, I only have to incur the expense when the damage actually occurs. And then I have a lot of flexibility on paying it off. I could pay it off immediately right away, or I could pay a minimum balance over a period of time, or perhaps I pay a set amount until I get some bonus or some extra money.

**[0:17:19] Rob Galbraith:** And then I pay the whole thing off. So you have a lot of flexibility as somebody that's incurred that loss in terms of how you cover that with insurance, right? No, you know, you've got to pay the premiums up front in almost every case. And so losing the use of that money that, you know, the insurance company is going to invest that money, right? And that helps bring premiums down, but, you know, they're recouping the benefit of having that cash and being able to invest it.

**[0:17:44] Rob Galbraith:** This is how Warren Buffett is really, you know, made a living. It doesn't cover all causes of loss. It doesn't cover everything that you would want to insure, and it doesn't cover every one that we would want to insure. And so to the extent that we have people that are uncovered for things like, you know, flood and other things, you know, a lot of the burden falls upon the government. So it might be disaster assistance, or maybe some type of social safety net programs.

**[0:18:08] Rob Galbraith:** And as most of the developed countries really start to age, start to have more retirees, you know, the ratio of workers to retirees is going to become, you know, smaller and smaller. I do think that governments are going to be under pressure to limit the amount of spending and look for ways to kind of offload this. And if they can partner by, you know, working with private insurance entities that are willing to take on these risks that, you know, may be insurable, but are not offered today in a particular country, just because the government's providing that, I think you're going to see kind of a growing

**[0:18:42] Alex Bond:** size of the marketplace from them as well. Yeah, yeah. And we always see that, I mean, the more developing or richer civilization we see more insurances and excuse me becomes more nuanced and um i think that's the thing i think i think we become isolated from like the true the true purpose of insurance which is to basically ensure the ensure the level playing field of like society i really believe in that i really believe insurance is a social good and and um you know because i always bring it back to kind of that that familial situation if you had a family or a village and you look at the world like that then you know if we all covered each

**[0:19:18] Alex Bond:** other's kind of individual losses we'd all be in the same place but um uh but you know i'm a hipster that lives in brighton so we're kind of that always comes out always comes out of me um i wanted to ask you um um we we touched on it you touched on there earlier talking point was was was what's happened at root recently and we've seen the kind of drop in the we've seen the fall in the value of the really prominent neo insurers you know the lemonades and and the roots um i want to ask you what you think that means in reflection of the pricing of the incumbents.

**[0:19:49] Alex Bond:** Because to a certain extent, the incumbents have had a bit of a kind of PR kicking for the last few years. But surely they're feeling slightly smug right now, I would imagine, though. Yeah, they're probably sort of feeling, do you think they're underpriced? Or was it, were we victims of the hype machine, do you think, when it came to pricing those kind of emergent neo-insurers?

**[0:20:12] Rob Galbraith:** Yeah, I think part of it is simply not having a lot of experience, right? So this idea of new insurers, right, the neo-insurance companies, I mean, like I mentioned before, a lot of traditional incumbents have been around for Decorate, so you really haven't had a new listing for a long time. Maybe there's some type of demutualization or things like that. And so I don't feel like a lot of the incumbents are undervalued. I think insurance is a difficult sector relative to many other sectors in terms of an investor because you have this high capital requirement and low margins.

**[0:20:45] Rob Galbraith:** And so it's just not an attractive profile for a business for many investors, just depending on their time horizon. And so I think seeing a lot of the insurer techs and, you know, insurers kind of, I guess, you know, have a little bit of gravity, right, coming back to earth makes a lot of sense to me, particularly because in many cases, I don't see them as being fundamentally different than the traditional incumbents against they're competing against.

**[0:21:10] Rob Galbraith:** And so that's the part about InsureTech that I still kind of wait on. And I think we absolutely will see in the 2030s is that totally new, totally revolutionary. Fundamentally, a lot of these people are using the same contract forms. They're using a lot of the same pricing processes. There's often a twist. There's a marketing component. Some of that is hype. Some of that I think is absolutely real, right? There may be a lower expense ratio, for instance, if they're using a better use of technology.

**[0:21:41] Rob Galbraith:** But I think that, as I mentioned, I haven't seen just something that's just totally new, totally different. And particularly, I think about moats, right? So what is a competitive advantage for a business? If you're using a brand new source of data that nobody else has, it gives you better insight and risk. Or if you've got better algorithms that can make better sense of a lot of this data. And is that a lasting competitive advantage, right, a big motor?

**[0:22:07] Rob Galbraith:** Is that just a temporary advantage that you might have? And so particularly, we talked about the digital transformation journeys. And I look at companies like Guy Gleier and Duck Creek that not only are more and more companies going to those platforms, but because they are now having partner networks, they're able to integrate a lot of the mature tech startups, particularly those that are more technology focused rather than looking to compete. They're looking to enable incumbents. That actually simplifies a lot of the partnerships, a lot of the opportunities, if you can do it through a core systems platform.

**[0:22:41] Rob Galbraith:** So I'm sure there'll be kind of a back and forth over time. But what I'm kind of looking for, and I believe is out there, but I haven't really seen it yet, is a company that has carved out a true niche that is different than everyone else that's going to give them a lasting competitive advantage over time.

**[0:23:02] Alex Bond:** Yeah, I think there's a couple of things that came to mind when we were talking about that. One, I always want to be really clear that I have no agenda against the NEO insurers, and I'm sure I speak for you that you haven't either, but it's more the hype machine and more reflective of how we price such things in society rather than them overhyping it because, you know, the disparity between the way they were being priced versus the incumbent class for me was the massive warning sign.

**[0:23:34] Alex Bond:** It wasn't a reflection of the business model because what I saw was a modern take on a traditional insurance play. So better distribution, probably a better customer experience. And Jeff Keist was on, from Montu, was on a podcast And he talked about how banks have for a long time done a very good job of getting you when you go to college to get your first bank account and then staying with you because they were giving you free bank accounts because they saw you as a lifetime customer.

**[0:24:05] Alex Bond:** And I think what particularly Lemonade did, I thought that was incredibly smart, is that get you as a renter because you're going to be probably younger in age and then try and be basically your insurer for that life journey. so the long-term value of the lemonade model and the long-term value of a lemonade customer should ultimately be higher um but we were trying to kind of that's a long-term solution and unfortunately the way that we we value uh you know the stock market is is is in the short term and and i think i think that's where it was at odds so um you know i think this is kind of a sort of naturalization of the

**[0:24:41] Alex Bond:** market um and no reflection on those businesses because yeah it was a it was for me it was they were they were really interested nuances and i think long term they'll be incredibly successful um in maybe retaining customers if they have that attitude of going right once we get you it's all about losing you whereas insurance has become particularly on a personal lines basis it's so price sensitive it's so much about kind of transactional relationships but um the big shift is like can you get enough touch points with your customer to keep loyalty and that's where I think there's an interesting thing to play out but we'll only see that by 2030 so we'll have to we'll have to do

**[0:25:21] Alex Bond:** this in eight years and find out Rob and see if we're there. I think leading on from that and I think we were just about to get on to that was that you know do you think we well I think we both acknowledged they haven't you know why haven't we seen enough big leaps uh you know but we haven't seen those big leaps we've seen nuances in distribution we've seen nuances of that you know are we actually do you think we're actually seeing any true innovation or are we just seeing uh you know variations on a theme at this point

**[0:25:54] Rob Galbraith:** in time i definitely think there's true innovation um and again i think it's um you know a bit early days right where it hasn't kind of fully taken hold so you know there's some amazing technologies out there in all manner. So I feel like I'm going to leave somebody out. But for instance, I think about the ability to review documents, right? And medical bills, doctor's notes, things like that. There's a lot of back office processes that quite frankly require a lot of manual touch points.

**[0:26:28] Rob Galbraith:** And I think the pandemic has actually kind of shined light on this. So anybody that had kind of a mail operation that everyone moved work from home, it's like, well, how are we supposed to get the mail? How are we supposed to answer it? How are we supposed to process this? And if your job is to type information from screen one into screen two, and these systems clearly don't talk to each other, right? Or you're on the phone having to check with somebody all day.

**[0:26:49] Rob Galbraith:** There's a lot of that, a lot of manual touch points and a lot of our workflows. And so I think a lot of the insurtechs have tried to understand the idea of workflows, right? And the idea of trying to integrate in with a system and, you know, they may have a more compelling piece, but that's only one of 10 steps, right? In the workflow. And so, hey, if you don't do all 10, or if you don't integrate well with the systems that do the other nine or things like that, right, these become challenged.

**[0:27:18] Rob Galbraith:** So yes, on a strictly ROI for a particular step, right, that can be a challenge. So I just think, you know, the SAS model, software as a solution, subscriptions. It's giving, you know, access to enterprise level software that only the largest companies could have to a whole bunch more players now. And I think, again, through, you know, whether it be, you know, open insurance initiatives that we have in a lot of countries, just that idea of kind of moving to APIs, we're in kind of these early days, but you're going to see a lot more interoperability, you're going to see the ability to, adapt to a new solution relatively quickly.

**[0:27:55] Rob Galbraith:** And so things like billing reviews, things that are kind of manual touches today, I think you're going to see a lot of expense benefits. And for those companies that don't adopt, they're all of a sudden going to start kind of losing out because their expense ratios are going to become uncompetitive. So I don't know that those things are lasting competitive advantage, but I do think that they're going to move the industry to hopefully what is lower and lower expense ratios over time, which again is better for consumers, of course, and opens up a new range of products that otherwise might not have been possible because expense ratios were too high.

**[0:28:34] Rob Galbraith:** You mentioned Lemonade kind of starting with the renters, right? That's exactly why they started of, hey, here's an underserved segment of business that we think we can quickly gain market share and become a top 10 rider in for that particular line and then obviously expand out from there as we get known and as our customers, you know, age and mature and have needs for other products. And so I think you're going to see a lot more of that.

**[0:28:58] Rob Galbraith:** The other thing I'll mention, Alex, is we're talking about competitive advantage. And I think about a company like Apple, right, that they've done two things really well that I think is instructive for folks in the insurance industry. One is that ability to kind of turn over what their lead product is. So starting kind of with Macintosh, right. Going to an iPod, then you've got right. The, the, you know, iPhone, I've listened to you and AirPods now and all that.

**[0:29:28] Rob Galbraith:** And so, you know, you can see that their cell of desktop max, isn't nearly what it was probably, you know, 34 years ago, but they've continued to reinvent themselves, right. From a product standpoint, they've kept their products fresh. They've kept their products relevant. They talk about a beautifully simple design as kind of a theme throughout. And so they've been able to maintain that even from Steve Jobs to Tim Cook. So I just love the fact that if you look at the product mix, right, of what they've been able to sell, and iPhone obviously continues to still be the top one, you know, over a decade later, but, you know, they've, that's how they've become the largest company in the world.

**[0:30:04] Rob Galbraith:** The other thing that they've done is they've become a lifestyle brand. So I don't think about Apple as a technology company, right? Yes, that's actually what business they're in and that's what they sell. But they're more than that. I don't think of them as a competitor to a Microsoft or Lenovo or others, right? Or Samsung. I think of them kind of in their own class of business. Whereas I don't think about that for all those other names that I mentioned, I see them as kind of interchangeable.

**[0:30:29] Rob Galbraith:** And so I think that's where the insurance industry has really struggled is what's difference between these companies? Is there a meaningful difference or two point? Do I just kind of, you know, go on the aggregator and see who's cheapest this renewal. And so I think that companies that are able to do that, and that might be through not just offering insurance, but having insurance as a feature, right, as one aspect of a more compelling value proposition.

**[0:30:55] Rob Galbraith:** And that might be around, you know, digital health initiatives that might be around smart home. I don't know exactly what it's going to be, right. But I think when we kind of extend to be a more relevant offering, that's more of a lifestyle where you're embedded in my everyday life. And I think about you as a separate class from just an insurance company. I think there's a lot of ability to carve out kind of a bit of a fortress there competitively for anyone that's able to make that happen.

**[0:31:27] Alex Bond:** Yeah, I mean, as you were saying that, I was like, one of those two things, my raging hatred for anything Apple when it comes to my business, because I just have palpitations about I had a guy that put his laptop and three of his cables went in about the same month. And every time I went to buy one, I was like, how much are they? It was like, oh, like 40 pounds. It's like three pounds for my non-Apple product.

**[0:31:53] Alex Bond:** But I ran out of patience very quickly. It was cheaper to buy my laptop. But no, I think you're absolutely right. That brand piece is so powerful. And, you know, I do think that in a complimentary way about what Lemonade did, I think that they've made it cool to like an insurance company because of their message and some of the kind of not-for-profit elements of what they've been doing. But secondly, you know, I think that's why Embedded for me is so important and compelling as a proposition because it's, you know, we talk about hyper-personalization of insurance and the person, the insured.

**[0:32:28] Alex Bond:** you know surely we get to a point where you know I've got my smart watch on I wear it to the gym I wear it when I run I wear it when I work when I get home my phone's on me anyway so my phone and my watch can tell you whether I'm driving or flying or sitting down or at work and and almost surely we get to a point where I pay a variable insurance cost for at the end of the month or or you know that that covers off what I did what I actually did rather than what I should be doing and and yeah it's an all-in-one solution and i that for me feels like

**[0:33:02] Alex Bond:** the sort of almost the end point of what insurance um should be because you know i only want to pay for the things that i've used i think that's what everyone gets frustrated about um you know we're seeing that in small you know stages aren't we where your insurance turns off because you're home so you're not likely to get burgled or at least goes down and um you know you don't pay to you know you didn't pay to insure your car from a liability standpoint because it was sat in your driveway because we weren't allowed to drive anywhere during the pandemic and I think we're seeing those kind of steps in that direction but that for me seems like the

**[0:33:36] Alex Bond:** ultimate goal that we're driving towards. What that means from a company perspective is quite interesting but even the I think the evolution of things that we're seeing in the vertical stack you know if you've got a vertical stack for running a recruitment company like mine you can see everything so I'm going to I'm going to be able to get that insurance, which is just relevant for me and my business. But like we've done a lot of, you know, polite bashing, but we've pointed out some of the flaws.

**[0:34:04] Alex Bond:** But I wanted to talk about what's interesting you right now, what's impressing you that you're seeing out there, because, you know, there's so much creativity and innovation happening. any particular technologies or maybe even individuals, companies that you've got your eye on

**[0:34:22] Rob Galbraith:** you think are genuinely doing something different? Yeah, I think a couple areas and I won't name any specific companies, but first of all, there is so much innovation going on in areas such as Latin America and Africa and parts of Asia, that these have historically been kind of underserved by the larger companies. I think there's more penetration, right, in North America and Europe. And a lot of the offerings in those areas tend to be, you know, that office, right, of a larger company that might be based in Europe or is not in that area.

**[0:35:03] Rob Galbraith:** And so I'm seeing a ton of innovation from people that are in those markets, that know that markets, that know the challenge in those markets. For instance, I was talking with a gentleman that recently set up a business in Mexico, and he wants to emulate what they've done at Next Insurance and sell small commercial business to Mexico. And I'm going to, you know, apologize, I want to, you know, mess up the exact statistics, but it was something like, you know, 92 % or thereabouts of small businesses in Mexico don't have any insurance coverage, they don't have that kind of protection.

**[0:35:31] Rob Galbraith:** And so your point earlier, Alex, about families, folks saving away under the mattress or that rainy day fund. And so this is very, very common in many of these countries. And I think both there's a social element to being able to provide insurance products, but then also there's a societal benefit in terms of that frees up if that insurance product actually takes hold and gains the trust of consumers to where they really believe in it and they trust it and they don't need to save as much, then they're able to spend that, right?

**[0:36:05] Rob Galbraith:** And that might be consumption or that might be investment in their own business or whatnot. And so that's going to actually fuel economic growth in those areas. There's another startup in Africa, and I'm forgetting the specifics, but I know that they were actually accepting recyclables for premium payments, right? As a way to kind of offset. So there's just some true innovation out there. And I think that because these countries have been underserved by the existing markets, they're not necessarily tied to old systems or old paradigms or old ways of doing things.

**[0:36:38] Rob Galbraith:** And so they can be creative. They can come up with things that are applicable for the market. And then I actually see kind of this reverse innovation cycle where traditionally, right, it's happened in places such as Silicon Valley, right, and then kind of going out to the rest of the world. London certainly, right, the center for financial innovation and kind of spreads out. I actually think some of those are going to come to our area. So businesses that are entirely done by mobile phone, and in many cases in these countries, right, the mobile phone provider has partnered with that insurance company in terms of a low cost distribution method.

**[0:37:10] Rob Galbraith:** And so I think as we see successes in some of those areas, those will actually be kind of exported to the more richly penetrated areas that today are well served, doesn't mean it couldn't be better, but maybe don't have that so-called burning platform to innovate for insurance products as there are and many other areas that are are not adequately served by the industry today i love that idea i didn't i didn't

**[0:37:37] Alex Bond:** know about that like taking recyclables to pay for insurance premium um what great double incentive that is uh free insurance and and more cycling uh that definitely speaks to my uh my value uh off air i'll have to find out what company that is i'm really intrigued they need they need to be a guest that might be the next guest but um um final question really conscious of your time and thank you for being so generous i um i kind of wanted to know and this is a bit of a fun question really more than anything like where you think we are on this like insurance evolutionary time time frame you know are we standing upright yet are we uh

**[0:38:13] Alex Bond:** we still on all fours are we uh are we on our heels yet where do you think we are on the on the sort of evolution yeah great

**[0:38:20] Rob Galbraith:** question. I think we're still on all fours and we're crawling around some and we might be lifting up on the coffee table a bit to look around, but I think it's still very much early on. And again, one of the things that I talk to companies about, you kind of mentioned this insurance futurist, and we talk about the 2030s is I try to get companies to think beyond, often their strategic horizon, quite frankly, is just three to five years, right?

**[0:38:49] Rob Galbraith:** And it's usually more on the short end than the long end. And I get it. Everyone has goals for a year. Oftentimes bonuses and other incentives are tied to meeting those goals, but those can be counterproductive for looking at 10 years in advance. And so I certainly don't pretend to have all the answers, but when I talk to companies, I try to bucket things into four different categories. What are the economic and financial trends that you observe today and how do you think they're going to play out or could play out 10 years from now?

**[0:39:17] Rob Galbraith:** What are some of those demographic and societal changes? What are some of the things in terms of politics or evolving risks? Certainly a pandemic probably wasn't at the top of mind at the beginning of 2020, but right now we'll certainly be mindful. And then finally, the technology piece. And I see a lot of companies really start with the technology piece, but I actually asked them to focus on those technological trends last, because obviously there's this interesting interplay between technology and society and, and, you know, countries and behaviors and then vice versa, right?

**[0:39:51] Rob Galbraith:** There's kind of a feedback loop of, we think about people and shaping technology, but then what we've learned through, you know, social media and many other ways, right? That the technology actually shapes people and behaviors and can kind of change our course. So thinking about those kinds of dynamics. And then I ask companies, okay, now that you've painted a picture of what you think this future could look like, like, what are some of the key assumptions that are underpinning that and how do you think it's going to develop out and so build your plan around where you think you know the industry is going to be 10 15 years from now what investments do you need to be making now

**[0:40:22] Rob Galbraith:** so you're not in that you know hole of technical debt or you're not following yourself behind but then really hold yourself accountable to revisiting those assumptions every six months we know something's going to change i mean the only continent is change that's the one thing that we can say and so agility and flexibility building that into your enterprise is so key. And that's not easily done for traditional incumbents. And I've even talked to insure tech startups that are talking about entirely replacing their tech stack after three years, right?

**[0:40:49] Rob Galbraith:** Which just is, you can't believe it as somebody that's coming from that traditional incumbent world where you're still running mainframes in the 1970s and trying to get off of the green screens, right? But it is so imperative. And so I very much think that there's a lot of technologies that hold promise today that are just scratching the surface, just being explored that will be mainstream in the 2030s. And so which are those, which are fads versus which are going to have blasting power?

**[0:41:16] Rob Galbraith:** That's really the challenge for C-suite to try to anticipate and figure out and having kind of robust conversations. This is where diversity inclusion, quite frankly, is quite important, right? We value it for its own social good. It feels like the right thing to do, but it's also as a business benefit of getting people from different backgrounds, from different viewpoints to talk about these things. One final thought is this whole myth of experience that is out there.

**[0:41:44] Rob Galbraith:** Traditionally, it's been a very apprenticeship type model in the industry, right? Where you work as an underwriter or as a claims adjuster, and maybe after five years, you make it to senior. And after 10 years, you make it into management. If everything goes well, maybe you're an executive in 20 years, if all things work out. There's still elements of insurance that that is absolutely true and still holds. But there's also elements where millennials and now Gen Z entering the workforce, they have a different experience with technology because they've been immersed with it from the ground up.

**[0:42:15] Rob Galbraith:** And I see it in my three kids. And so they're going to have very different thoughts about how new technologies could be incorporated into insurance that are equally as valid as those such as myself that have been in the industry for over two decades. And so, you know, finding that right balance, having that difference of opinion, you know, making sure that you're really getting everybody's wisdom, and that could be the wisdom of the 19-year-old intern even, you know, as part of your discussions about, you know, where your company should head and how you should proceed, I think is critically important.

**[0:42:46] Alex Bond:** yeah that's i think that's so crucial i i think you know diversity and inclusion you know something that we're clearly trying to sort of support for the for the work that we do and whether that be um from the recruitment work we do and the way that we approach recruitment and proactive recruitment and you know blind cv submission and all that good stuff and and through to our flight series um uh the female leaders in insurance technology series you know it's about having those different ideas in the room and and i think you you look at insurance um and it's been very easy to throw stones at but you know the reason that we launched our flight series which is

**[0:43:22] Alex Bond:** that you look at insurtech and there's some very similar looking people um you know uh that are more likely to raise money and are more likely to sort of innovate and um and that's not discrediting anyone involved but i just you know it's it's it's it's friday afternoon here but we went out for lunch as a team today and and the two women that work for me are both 22 um their take on technology we were talking about social media and and you know just even the different interactions their view of it is completely different from mine and and because i came into this sort of social media world i'm 40 at the age of the answer of 24 25

**[0:43:58] Alex Bond:** they've grown up with it their whole life and so their interaction is different their expectations are different and therefore you've got this kind of very different consumer consumer kind of viewpoint on it and what they want from it and and clearly that impacts into how we're our expectations of insurance our expectations of these businesses and um you know i'm always impressed with businesses from a recruitment standpoint when they're brave you know and when they when they make brave decisions on you know hiring someone that yeah maybe doesn't have the sort of direct application of experience but we know he's talented and we think they can do it and and i think certainly um and i'm over sort of laboring the

**[0:44:37] Alex Bond:** point slightly but one of my concerns always big insurance businesses is they generally are large and they generally are shareholder led and and and as a result the incentives for the leadership to change when they get 4% growth year on year it's very difficult to justify change you know you're successful you're hitting your numbers why rock the boat and and it's going to take people to be brave and i suppose that for me is the importance of venture capital that's the for me is the importance of startups is is there's an opportunity to break be brave but as you said on the on some of those in their three-year journey already throwing out their tech stack once you

**[0:45:13] Alex Bond:** become once you become start to become part of the establishment you become bigger you become part of the kind of makeup of the insurance industry you risk being in the position of not being able to innovate yourself so it's it's a real complicated um situation um and and that's another hour-long podcast so uh i won't go any further with that one but um rob it's been a genuine pleasure i've really been looking forward to this um thank you so much for for being a guest and um and my final last slightly cheeky question because we started beforehand how long till we see you at the helm of your own innovative new thing is is that something for 2022 do

**[0:45:54] Alex Bond:** we think or should we should we keep posted on that

**[0:45:57] Rob Galbraith:** yeah absolutely that's that's the goal this year and uh you know you and i were talking and we're recording this at the very tail end of january and uh you know i've yet to make my new year's resolution so i know that's on the list but i haven't said that and formalized it and um you know i've i've been uh very fortunate to speak to folks you know all over the world on this as i mentioned, you know, coming up with the three-year anniversary of the publication of The End of Insurance as We Know It.

**[0:46:23] Rob Galbraith:** And I know how much that has really resonated. So whether that's, you know, another book, whether that's a newsletter of some type, whether that's my own podcast, which I am the co-host of a podcast called the InsurTech Geek Podcast. I have folks that encourage them to check out and to subscribe to, you know, whether that's a video series or whatnot. So I think there's a ton of interesting things going on in the insurance and insurtech world.

**[0:46:47] Rob Galbraith:** So hoping to kind of develop into a content creation model that's out there. So more to come on that once that's formalized.

**[0:46:55] Alex Bond:** Awesome. Well, thank you very much for your time. Really appreciate it. Thanks for being a guest on

**[0:46:59] Rob Galbraith:** Leadership Insurance Podcast. Pleasure to be with you, Alex. Enjoyed the conversation. Thank you so much. Cheers. Bye.

**[0:47:19] Alex Bond:** As always, this podcast is brought to you by FinPro Search Partners, often simply known as FinPro. FinPro is an executive recruitment business working in the insurance and insure tech space on an international basis. If you would like to find out more about FinPro, please visit our website www.wearefinpro.com or our FinPro company page on LinkedIn. I've been your host, Alex Bond, and I would personally love to connect with anyone who is interested in the changing world of insurance.

**[0:47:47] Alex Bond:** So feel free to reach out to me directly, either on LinkedIn or via my email at alexatwearefinpro.com. I hope you enjoyed the podcast and I hope to see you back next week. Thank you.
