# How BNY, The Bank Founded by Alexander Hamilton, Stays Innovative

- **Show:** Leadership Next (Fortune)
- **Published:** 11 Jun 2024
- **Source:** https://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/chtbl.com/track/36E7G4/traffic.megaphone.fm/FMC5632062697.mp3?updated=1718109010
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/leadership-next/how-bny-the-bank-founded-by-alexander-hamilton-stays-innovative-3057a9/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

BNY Mellon CEO Robin Vince argues that a 240-year-old bank lasts by being unseen infrastructure: the plumbing that manages, moves and safeguards money for the world's largest institutions. Its longevity rests on resilience, a client-first culture and a willingness to rebuild itself as a technology platform that clients rent rather than replicate.

The central tension is between age and change. Vince leans on history and tradition, yet insists on staying humble and paranoid, planning for several possible futures instead of one forecast. That shows up in cyber defense, interest-rate uncertainty, AI anxiety among workers, and a push to bring staff back to the office so younger employees can absorb the culture.

## Key insights

1. **BNY is plumbing, not a retail bank** Vince says BNY has no branches but holds about $50 trillion in assets under custody and administration and touches around 20% of investable assets worldwide. Most people are affected through pensions, 401(k)s and IRAs without knowing it.
2. **BNY now defines itself as a platforms business** Vince describes a bundle of software and services that clients build on instead of doing it themselves. He points to payments, custody, wealth, collateral and the US Treasury market, where clients borrow BNY's scale.
3. **Resilience means preparing for many futures** Vince says BNY does not bet the company on a single outcome, whether the Fed raises, cuts or holds rates. Alan notes that single-point forecasts are risky, and Vince says the same preparation applies to cyber and geopolitics.
4. **Culture is treated as a business tool** Vince borrows the line that culture eats strategy for breakfast and adds that execution eats strategy for lunch. He ties it to rapid analyst hiring and an in-office expectation so new staff learn through hallway conversations.
5. **BNY faces constant cyber probing like any large firm** Vince says BNY is constantly probed for gaps, as any Fortune 500 company is, and spends heavily on defense. Its scale also lets clients lean on BNY for some of that protection.

## Questions this episode answers

### What does BNY Mellon actually do if I have never seen one of its branches?

It is not a retail bank. CEO Robin Vince says it runs the back-end systems for managing money, moving money and keeping it safe, and serves nearly all of the top 100 financial institutions in the world.

### How big is BNY Mellon in the financial system?

Vince says it has roughly $50 trillion in assets under custody and administration and touches about 20% of the world's investable assets. About 40% of its revenue comes from outside the US.

### How does BNY Mellon make its money?

Vince says fees and net interest income, the spread between what it earns and pays on money, are the two big drivers. He describes its balance sheet as fairly low risk and focused on client needs.

### Why does BNY Mellon want employees back in the office?

Vince says serving clients is harder from home and that new hires need to learn from others. The firm has hired its largest ever analyst class, close to 2,000 summer and 2,000 full-time analysts, and he asks staff to be in more days than not.

### How is BNY Mellon helping employees cope with worries about AI and change?

Vince says employers should help workers navigate the anxiety. BNY gave every employee stock in the company about a year before the interview and added new mental health benefits.

## Facts

- **Robin Vince** [0:03:49]: "Yes, was actually we lent the first money to the new nation to help the nation get going."
- **Robin Vince** [0:02:33]: "The vision was born in downtown New York City, down in what is essentially now the Wall Street area."
- **Robin Vince** [0:02:54]: "We have President Washington's account for those two years when this was, in fact, the capital of the United States."
- **Robin Vince** [0:03:49]: "We've been involved in helping to enable infrastructure of various kinds, New York City subways, Erie Canal, all over the course of U.S. history."
- **Robin Vince** [0:03:49]: "in some cases serving clients around the world for over 100 years, 40 % of our revenues come from outside the U.S."
- **Robin Vince** [0:04:17]: "We now view our business as serving our clients by managing money, moving money, and keeping it safe."
- **Robin Vince** [0:04:41]: "We touch about 20 % of all investable assets in the world."
- **Robin Vince** [0:05:15]: "We were the first bank in the United States to make real-time payments on the new real-time payment rails a few years ago."
- **Robin Vince** [0:05:40]: "we are a fairly low risk balance sheet that is generally focused on making sure we're supporting our clients' needs. And fees and net interest income are the two big cylinders in our revenue engine."
- **Robin Vince** [0:06:29]: "we think now of ourselves as a platforms business, essentially a set of software and services that allow our clients to build on"
- **Robin Vince** [0:07:22]: "Well, we serve nearly all of the top 100 financial institutions in the world, but we also support something like 90 % of Fortune 100 companies,"
- **Robin Vince** [0:07:22]: "60 % of Americans have some type of investment in the stock market."
- **Robin Vince** [0:08:29]: "And we had plenty of lessons of that last year when we look back to 2023, the ups and downs in some of the smaller and medium sized banks in the United States"
- **Robin Vince** [0:10:49]: "Well, we're constantly under attack, as is any large enterprise these days, unfortunately, because we're being probed for various different gaps."
- **Robin Vince** [0:10:49]: "We may be the oldest Fortune 500 company, but in that, we're all in the same place of having to be prepared."
- **Robin Vince** [0:14:07]: "I remember the Russian default. I remember a long-term capital management. I remember September 11th, each one of these things, sort of their own crucibles of learning, if you will"
- **Alan Murray** [0:16:08]: "Your former employer just down the road, Goldman Goldman Sachs has been saying, by God, we want you in the office every day."
- **Robin Vince** [0:14:47]: "culture really does eat strategy for breakfast. And I'll add to that by saying, and execution eats strategy for lunch."
- **Robin Vince** [0:17:06]: "We've hired the largest analyst class of new incoming analysts that we've ever had as a company, which is double what it was the year before, and that was double what it was the year before that."
- **Robin Vince** [0:18:26]: "We're not pinning all of the company on one of those outcomes. We're being prepared for the different eventualities."
- **Alan Murray** [0:18:51]: "I heard someone say recently that the single point forecast is dead."
- **Robin Vince** [0:21:16]: "We made every employee in our company a shareholder about a year ago by giving them stock in BNY Mellon because they're part of our journey."
- **Jason Gerzatis** [0:11:44]: "We at Deloitte talk about it as the age of with, the age of technology with your workforce"

## Transcript

**[0:00:04] Alan Murray:** Leadership Next is powered by the folks at Deloitte, who, like me, are exploring the changing rules of business leadership and how CEOs are navigating this change. Welcome to Leadership Next, the podcast about the changing rules of business leadership. I'm Alan Murray and Mahal Lavram. I have a question for you. The question is, what is the oldest company on the Fortune 500 list?

**[0:00:33] Speaker 4:** Oh my gosh. I have the answer in front of me, so can I cheat? It makes IBM look really, really young, and it makes Fortune look very, very young. Spring chicken.

**[0:00:47] Alan Murray:** 240 years old. It's BNY, the bank. Robin Vince is the CEO. We did an interview in his offices surrounded by memorabilia from Alexander Hamilton, who actually created the bank. Really sorry you weren't there, Mahal. It was a fascinating dive into a really important financial institution that most people don't know much about.

**[0:01:09] Speaker 4:** I'm so sorry I wasn't there. I'm sure it was a fascinating conversation. And I'm especially sorry hearing that I missed out on seeing all sorts of artifacts. But what did you talk about? What's the company got going on today?

**[0:01:23] Alan Murray:** Well, it's interesting. It kind of runs a lot of the plumbing of the global financial system, massive amounts of money, something like $50 1 trillion in assets. There was a big computer screen on the wall where you could see how many treasury securities they had traded that day and, again, measured in the trillions. So a lot of things that you don't see on a regular basis but are handled by the bank behind the scenes.

**[0:01:50] Speaker 4:** Well, I am looking forward to hearing this conversation. And again, I'm sorry I missed it. I'm sure it was fantastic. And just a note to listeners, this interview was recorded before BNY Mellon changed its name to BNY.

**[0:02:07] Alan Murray:** Robin Vince, Bank of New York Mellon, thank you so much for being on Leadership Next. Thanks for having me. It's great to have you here also in the building. Well, it's good to be here. This is a historic place. Bank of New York Mellon has been around for, what, 240 years? That's right. We turned 240 this year, in fact. Oldest financial institution in the United States, started by Alexander Hamilton. I'm not sure everyone knows that. And started probably just a few blocks from where we're

**[0:02:33] Robin Vince:** sitting right now, right? That's right. The vision was born in downtown New York City, down in what is essentially now the Wall Street area.

**[0:02:40] Alan Murray:** So in spite of that, and by the way, we're surrounded by documents of your history that sort of highlight some of the key points of that 240 years, including Alexander Hamilton's ledger right over there. That's right. It's an impressive display.

**[0:02:54] Robin Vince:** That was his account. We have President Washington's account for those two years when this was, in fact, the capital of the United States. We have warrant number one, which is particularly fun. They call it the origin story of the $35 1 trillion worth of national debt today.

**[0:03:09] Alan Murray:** Yeah, so the remarkable thing is that in spite of that incredibly long history that sort of begins with the creation of the Republic, Bank of New York Melbourne is not that well known by most people.

**[0:03:22] Robin Vince:** So explain what it does and what it is. Well, we've been part of the fabric of the United States and actually the world's financial system for a lot of our time. And we started, as you pointed out, right with the birth of the Republic. And the first thing really that we did for the Republic in those early days, right after the British left New York, a little bit ironic that I have some British heritage, but we'll skip past that.

**[0:03:49] Robin Vince:** Yes, was actually we lent the first money to the new nation to help the nation get going. And so that's where we started. We've been involved in helping to enable infrastructure of various kinds, New York City subways, Erie Canal, all over the course of U.S. history. And then when we went global and we've been in countries around the world for 50, 60, 70 years, in some cases serving clients around the world for over 100 years, 40 % of our revenues come from outside the U.S.

**[0:04:17] Robin Vince:** We now view our business as serving our clients by managing money, moving money, and keeping it safe. And we provide a whole range of financial services to clients under those headings. But it's kind of like plumbing, right?

**[0:04:32] Alan Murray:** I mean, there's no corner Bank of New York Mellon. You know, I see JP Morgan. I see Citi. I don't see Bank of New York Mellon on my corner.

**[0:04:41] Robin Vince:** We're not a retail bank, if that's what you mean by corner. But we're really ever-present in the financial system. We power platforms for our clients that really support the pensions of the world, the savers of the world, the investors of the world, all through the financial system. And so we have $50 1 trillion or thereabouts of assets under custody and administration. We touch about 20 % of all investable assets in the world. So you may not see us on the corner front, but we are probably part of your financial life.

**[0:05:13] Alan Murray:** And so who's your competition?

**[0:05:15] Robin Vince:** Well, we have competitors all around the world and different types of competitors, depending on the business that we're in. We have large competitors in the custody business, but we have different competitors in the payments business. We were the first bank in the United States to make real-time payments on the new real-time payment rails a few years ago. We have a very large software and services platform that supports wealth managers and registered investment advisors all across the United States.

**[0:05:40] Robin Vince:** We help the U.S. Treasury and the Fed to run the U.S. Treasury system. So we really have different types of competitors in different places according to the business. So you make your money off of fees and off of interest rate spreads? Yeah, we are a fairly low risk balance sheet that is generally focused on making sure we're supporting our clients' needs. And fees and net interest income are the two big cylinders in our revenue engine.

**[0:06:08] Alan Murray:** Yeah. So talk about technology, because we all know we're in the midst of this remarkable technology revolution. We've seen everyone's imagination has kind of exploded with the introduction of generative AI and the possibilities. Technology is clearly, I've seen it walking around your offices here at the core of what you do.

**[0:06:29] Robin Vince:** Well, it is. It really helps us in everything that we do for our clients. I would describe clients as being what we're about and really the core focus. But technology gives us this incredible leverage to be able to help our clients. And we think now of ourselves as a platforms business, essentially a set of software and services that allow our clients to build on to our clients. of us to do everything that they're doing. Very exciting on the topic of AI, but technology for us is so much more.

**[0:07:01] Robin Vince:** It is about networks and connectivity to clients all around the world. And we have the ability to really give insights to our clients about what's going on in their business and to be able to allow them to leverage the efficiency and scale that we have as a company.

**[0:07:17] Alan Murray:** And when you talk about clients, you're talking mostly about financial, other financial institutions.

**[0:07:22] Robin Vince:** Well, we serve nearly all of the top 100 financial institutions in the world, but we also support something like 90 % of Fortune 100 companies, close to that for all of the largest asset managers in the world. And indirectly, we support the vast number of Americans and global participants in financial markets who are savers. 60 % of Americans have some type of investment in the stock market. They may have it in a 401k or they may have it in an IRA or they may have it in their own savings account.

**[0:07:54] Robin Vince:** But underlying that somewhere is probably a touchpoint to the various different businesses that we have.

**[0:08:00] Alan Murray:** Yeah. So with a footprint that large, Bank of New York Mellon has to be central to the safety and soundness of our financial system. Resilience has been a big theme for companies over the course of the last few years. We've seen lots of ups and downs, geopolitical threats that can translate into cyber threats. We've had financial uneasiness. How do you, your job is to make sure that the financial system survives through all of that. How do you do it?

**[0:08:29] Robin Vince:** Well, you said the most important word, Alan, which is resilience. We view resilience as a commercial attribute for our company, but it really is also table stakes for a large modern day participant in capital markets. And we had plenty of lessons of that last year when we look back to 2023, the ups and downs in some of the smaller and medium sized banks in the United States that occurred, some of the ups and downs and expectations for interest rates.

**[0:08:57] Robin Vince:** We had geopolitical events that either started or were continuing. So there are plenty of things going on in the world. And you only get to be 240 years old if you think about things. what lies around the corner, really being prepared and recognizing that resilience really matters.

**[0:09:14] Alan Murray:** Yeah. So can we talk a little bit about cyber security? Because obviously that's part of the geopolitical threat. Russia, China, Iran, all sources of cyber threats. New technology is accelerating the possibility of those threats. I hear people talking about quantum. The day quantum comes, there will be a quantum leap in cyber threats. How do you keep up with the rapid

**[0:09:41] Robin Vince:** escalation of the threats? Well, cyber is an incredibly important topic for any large company, any government, by the way, for individuals as well. We talk a lot about phishing and smishing. These things are their own version of a cyber online threat. And so everybody needs to pay close attention to making sure that they're well protected. Now, for our part as a company, of course, we spend a lot of money and devote a lot of attention to making sure that we are being prepared and we're thinking about what lies ahead and defending against the various different threats that come along.

**[0:10:16] Robin Vince:** We're also focused on helping our clients to do those things because we have the benefit of a scale that allows our clients to be able to rely on us for some of those things. And they find a lot of comfort in the fact that we are trying to think steps ahead

**[0:10:30] Alan Murray:** on the board for that. But it's a race, right? You've got to keep ahead of the bad guys.

**[0:10:34] Robin Vince:** And there are a lot of them out there. I think that's been true since the days of the first bank robbers, that the good guys have to stay ahead of the bad guys. But you're right.

**[0:10:42] Alan Murray:** So give us just some magnitude here. In a normal day, how many cyber attacks are you dealing with?

**[0:10:49] Robin Vince:** Well, we're constantly under attack, as is any large enterprise these days, unfortunately, because we're being probed for various different gaps. There's a way that people can come in, That's why we have a large team and a lot of resources that are devoted to making sure that we're fending off anything that happens like that. But that's a very standard thing for any Fortune 500 company these days. We may be the oldest Fortune 500 company, but in that, we're all in the same place of having to be prepared.

**[0:11:20] Alan Murray:** I'm here with Jason Gerzatis, the CEO of Deloitte U.S., who had the wisdom to sponsor this podcast. Thanks for joining me, Jason. It's a pleasure to be with you, Alan. Jason, the pace of technological change is mind-boggling these days, and it's really hard for people and human organizations to keep up with it. So how should CEOs prepare their teams for this pace of constant change?

**[0:11:44] Jason Gerzatis:** Well, the impact on the workforces of organizations is profound as it relates to technology, and there's probably nothing more important for CEOs, no matter what organization they're leading, to really be thinking about technology's impact on their workforce. It's really a function of how do you think about technology in concert with your workforce? We at Deloitte talk about it as the age of with, the age of technology with your workforce, and really embracing this idea of the co-dependency of technology and workforce.

**[0:12:13] Jason Gerzatis:** We're also an environment of a very tight workforce where there's a scarcity of top talent and an increased pressure on the diversity of top talent. That's going to be the challenge for organizations to demonstrate to top talent that they can grow and evolve the work that they do, working with leading technology in a very aligned way. Finally, it's what top talent really wants in an organization is to learn and grow and to be part of an organization that's supportive of them actually embedding technology in their work.

**[0:12:43] Jason Gerzatis:** Jason, thanks

**[0:12:44] Alan Murray:** for your perspective and thanks for sponsoring Leadership Next. Thank you. So let's talk a little bit about you. How did you get here? How did you end up at the top of this huge company? How many employees do you have, by the way? We have about 50 ,000. So this is a huge global operation. What was your path? Did you wake up one day and say, I want to run the biggest financial institution in the United States?

**[0:13:13] Alan Murray:** Or did it wind more?

**[0:13:15] Robin Vince:** Now, of course, it wound more than that. I'm very lucky with my past. I grew up in a different institution. But through my time in that institution, that's right. That's right. I joined right out of school. And that proved to be a really terrific set of experiences for me. And I say set of experiences because I had the good fortune to work under leaders who really moved me around the company and gave me different exposures to things.

**[0:13:39] Robin Vince:** I had the opportunity to work in different places. I had the opportunity to work in many of the different parts of the company. I grew up on the trading side, had a set of experiences there. And then I had the opportunity to work in risk and in treasury, help participate in sort of a regional view of the company. And these experiences really did help me. And they created this sort of cumulative set of knowledge, tests, financial crisis going through.

**[0:14:07] Robin Vince:** I remember the Russian default. I remember a long-term capital management. I remember September 11th, each one of these things, sort of their own crucibles of learning, if you will, and then working with the people in that institution prepared me very well. And one day I had the opportunity to come here. And that's really been just a tremendous opportunity to put a lot of that and those skills to work.

**[0:14:29] Alan Murray:** Those crises you're talking about seem to come faster, more frequently, more diverse in origin. and having the right culture to deal with that. When you talk about resilience, we know culture is at the core of it. How do you think about culture and what is the culture at Bank of New York Miller?

**[0:14:47] Robin Vince:** People often ask me, what is your focus on strategy? How do you think about the importance of it? And actually my answer to that is to sort of borrow the quote from another, culture really does eat strategy for breakfast. And I'll add to that by saying, and execution eats strategy for lunch. because without people and without the right alignment and without the right sense of purpose around what we're doing and without a sense of we're really trying to nurture a learning environment, an environment which is really focused on being high performing, no company can succeed.

**[0:15:20] Robin Vince:** And that's one of the things that I've really loved about BNY Mellon. We have a culture that's incredibly client-centric and that holds the firm also in high regard. People cherish our history. We've got this 240 years of having really powered financial markets. And people take a lot of pride in that. And so when we're out on campus recruiting people, when we're talking to our people about what we do and why it matters in the world, you talked about the scale and breadth that we had.

**[0:15:49] Robin Vince:** And I've illustrated it with some numbers. But at the very heart, it's people coming here wanting to be part of the financial system, part of improving things, helping make things work better for individuals and companies all around the world. And there's a lot of culture in that. There's a great culture experiment going on

**[0:16:08] Alan Murray:** here in downtown Manhattan as we speak. We still haven't completely recovered from the pandemic and the effects of that and distributed work. Your former employer just down the road, Goldman Goldman Sachs has been saying, by God, we want you in the office every day. Right across the street from them, American Express, another financial company is saying, no, it doesn't have to be every day. We could probably get by two, three days a week. Where do you fall in the great debate about office work?

**[0:16:36] Alan Murray:** How often do you, if you work at Bank of New York Mellon in the office, how often do you have to be in?

**[0:16:41] Robin Vince:** So the short answer to the question is more days than you're not. But let's just step back for a second and remember what are we trying to achieve? I would like our people to be here to be able to really serve our clients. It's hard sometimes to fully serve clients when you're actually not in the office because you may not be out with your clients as much as you otherwise would. What else are we asking our people to do?

**[0:17:06] Robin Vince:** We're asking them to pay it forward for the next generation. We've hired the largest analyst class of new incoming analysts that we've ever had as a company, which is double what it was the year before, and that was double what it was the year before that. We can't have all of these new summer analysts close to 2 ,000 and new full-time analysts close to 2 ,000 joining us and then not have people to learn from, not to have those hallway conversations.

**[0:17:33] Robin Vince:** I want them to be able to come in here, observe and absorb the culture. And in order to do that, we need to have a lot of people here. So that's what we've asked our people to do. Be here more than you want. And for people who have management responsibilities, be here even more.

**[0:17:49] Alan Murray:** Yeah. Robin, these days, what keeps you up at night? What worries you about your ability to keep this great institution going for another 240 years?

**[0:17:59] Robin Vince:** Staying humble and staying a bit paranoid was one of the things that I learned as I was growing up is a very healthy state of mind for a CEO to have. So never being comfortable and always worrying a little bit about what might lie around the corner. Now, what are we doing about that? We are obsessively focused on our clients. We are really making sure that we're running our company in a great way and never losing sight of the importance of culture.

**[0:18:26] Robin Vince:** Now, in order to do all of those things, how do we put it out in the world? Yeah, we're thinking around the corners. Will the Fed raise rates? Will the Fed cut rates? Will the Fed stay the same? We're not pinning all of the company on one of those outcomes. We're being prepared for the different eventualities. Same thing's true on cyber. The same thing's true for the geopolitics of the world. You've got to be prepared for how the world can zig and zag.

**[0:18:50] Robin Vince:** And that is ultimately -

**[0:18:51] Alan Murray:** I heard someone say recently that the single point forecast is dead. Anybody who runs their business based on a single point forecast of the future is ignoring the realities of our time.

**[0:19:01] Robin Vince:** It's risky and one might be right, but it's very unlikely that you're going to carry on being right, certainly over hundreds of years.

**[0:19:10] Alan Murray:** And what excites you most about the next 10 years? What do you see in the future of this business that really gets you going?

**[0:19:18] Robin Vince:** Well, I'll say two things that we're really focused on as a company. One for us, it's that opportunity to be platforms, rentable scale, insights into markets, capabilities that our clients can then go build their businesses on. There are so many things that we take for granted today that are essentially platforms that we all use every day that maybe 10, 20, 30 years ago, if you were a company, you might have done for yourself. And so having those market leading positions across payments, across custody, across wealth assets, across collateral, across the US Treasury market, across various forms of markets, these are all very real scale things where we are potentially the largest in many cases at what we do.

**[0:20:08] Robin Vince:** And that allows clients to be able to borrow our scale and to be able to get wrapped in our technology and our capabilities so they can focus on what they really want to be doing and what makes them really great.

**[0:20:21] Alan Murray:** There's obviously an enormous amount of pressure that goes with this job that you have. What do you do to unwind? What do you do to relax? What lets you breathe?

**[0:20:30] Robin Vince:** I heard Jamie Dimon say something the other day which actually really resonates with me, which is he sort of has two focus areas. One is his company and the other one is his family. I'm very much like that. It was once said, and I think this is not a bad expression, that you can have it all. You just can't have it all at the same time. And I think that's right for me. And so I've really devoted myself to saying this is an incredible franchise.

**[0:20:55] Robin Vince:** I want to serve our clients and serve our people as well. And at the same time, equally, maybe more importantly for me, is my family. And those are the two things that I do. There are plenty of other things that I enjoy, but those are the two things I deliberately make time for.

**[0:21:11] Alan Murray:** Robin, what's the biggest challenge that workers today are facing?

**[0:21:16] Robin Vince:** Well, there's a lot of anxiety that I recognize can exist for workers. There's a lot that's going on around the world. AI is, of course, an ever-present thing. I like to think about this as the responsibility of an employer to make sure that we're really helping our employees to navigate. We made every employee in our company a shareholder about a year ago by giving them stock in BNY Mellon because they're part of our journey. We've been leaning into benefits.

**[0:21:46] Robin Vince:** We've been created new mental health benefits for all of our employees as well because it's that essence of culture to bring your people along on the journey.

**[0:21:56] Alan Murray:** Great institution. Big job. Thank you very much for taking the time to be with me on Leadership Next. Great to be with you, and thank you for being with us. Fortune's editorial team. The views and opinions expressed by podcast speakers and guests are solely their own and do not reflect the opinions of Deloitte or its personnel, nor does Deloitte advocate or endorse any individuals or entities featured on the episodes.
