# Marc Benioff Weighs In On The AI-Powered Future

- **Show:** Leadership Next (Fortune)
- **Published:** 17 Dec 2024
- **Source:** https://www.podtrac.com/pts/redirect.mp3/chtbl.com/track/36E7G4/traffic.megaphone.fm/FMC2820415629.mp3?updated=1734382731
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/leadership-next/marc-benioff-weighs-in-on-the-ai-powered-future-c96d81/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

Marc Benioff argues that software is turning into 'digital labor'. AI agents will take over work such as customer support and follow-up, and they will do it at a different cost and scale than human staff. He says Salesforce already runs its own help site on agents, and that every CEO must now rethink how many people they need in each function.

The episode's tension is between enthusiasm and consequence. Benioff cites productivity gains, such as an engineering team no longer hiring and support staff being redeployed. Diane Brady pushes on whether employees should fear replacement. Alongside the AI talk, he returns to mindfulness, core values and giving back as the steady base that leaders need while technology changes fast.

## Key insights

1. **Agents are pitched as digital labor, not chatbots** Benioff describes agents that act on their own, such as texting a patient to check on their medication and booking a repeat lab test. Brady objects that this sounds like a high-end chatbot, and he answers that the software fills a role a person would otherwise have to fill.
2. **Salesforce says it is already using agents internally** Its help site now runs fully on Agentforce. Benioff says about 9,000 of the company's 75,000 employees work in support and some may be redeployed into sales roles. He also says his engineering chief asked to hire no new engineers because of a 30-plus percent productivity gain.
3. **Benioff says grounding data is what makes agents accurate** He argues that AI needs a company's data plus metadata (labels that say what the data means) to avoid hallucinations. He says this is why Salesforce sees 95 to 98 percent accuracy and why he calls Microsoft's Copilot a disappointment.
4. **Benioff keeps values separate from political parties** He says administrations change but Salesforce's core values do not, and the US government is a customer whoever is president. His concrete pledge is that any employee unhappy with the laws in their state can be moved to another office.
5. **He ties leadership to a beginner's mind and intention** He urges CEOs to practice 'shoshin', a beginner's mind, because agents do not fit existing business models. He closes by saying leaders should write down what they want and keep their intention in view while technology moves fast.

## Questions this episode answers

### What is an AI agent, and how is it different from a chatbot?

Brady describes an agent as software that carries out tasks on its own instead of only answering prompts. Benioff adds that it can take over work a person would do, such as checking in on a patient and scheduling a follow-up lab test.

### Is Salesforce actually using AI agents on its own business?

Yes, according to Benioff. He says help.salesforce.com now runs entirely on Agentforce, and that support staff have told him they are less busy as a result.

### Will AI agents cost people their jobs at Salesforce?

Benioff does not announce layoffs, but says he is weighing whether to move 1,000 to 4,000 of his 9,000 support staff into sales roles. His engineering chief also wants no new hires because of a 30-plus percent productivity gain.

### Why does Benioff say Microsoft's Copilot has disappointed customers?

He says it does not do more than ChatGPT, Perplexity or Gemini. In his view, AI only becomes accurate when it is grounded in a company's own data, metadata and workflows, which is what Salesforce's platform supplies.

### What is Salesforce's 1-1-1 model?

It is Salesforce's philanthropy model, in which the company puts 1 percent of its equity, profit and employee time into a foundation. Benioff says it has produced $1 billion in giving and 10 million volunteer hours, and that 20,000 companies have copied it.

## Facts

- **Marc Benioff** [0:02:28]: "I started writing my first software commercially and my first software product, How to Juggle, to my current software product, Agentforce."
- **Diane Brady** [0:04:15]: "I think the first tagline for Salesforce was the end of software, wasn't it?"
- **Marc Benioff** [0:04:24]: "Salesforce also introduced its philanthropic model which is our 1-1 -1 model where we put 1% of our equity profit and time into a foundation"
- **Marc Benioff** [0:05:01]: "and ended up giving away $1 billion and you know 10 million hours of volunteerism and 100 ,000 nonprofits run on our service for free."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:32:36]: "I guess one of the most fulfilling things is 20 ,000 companies have now copied our 1-1 -1 model."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:09:54]: "we have converted help.salesforce.com completely over to an agentic layer"
- **Marc Benioff** [0:10:28]: "Salesforce also has, of our 75 ,000 employees, 9 ,000 or so are in support."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:13:19]: "I don't want to hire any new engineers because I am 30 plus percent more productive this year"
- **Marc Benioff** [0:12:17]: "You probably saw in the third quarter while, you know, labor in the United States remained basically stagnant. Productivity went up actually significantly."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:14:59]: "Microsoft has been a disappointment to so many of our customers with CoPilot."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:15:37]: "you know, 230, 300 petabytes of data for our customers."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:15:37]: "that metadata is like data is a phone number. The metadata is this is a phone number."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:16:12]: "We have 135 ,000 customers. We have given them all AgentForce."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:17:40]: "two out of the five most accurate models are Salesforce models."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:17:40]: "We will do over 2 trillion, 2 trillion with a T transactions, AI transactions this week with our core platform, which is Einstein."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:18:13]: "where we're seeing accuracy up in the 95%, 96%, 97%, 98 % level on AI and agents"
- **Marc Benioff** [0:18:49]: "That's retrieval augmented generation. That's the ability for the AI to go out and get lots of data to ground itself."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:01:32]: "Hal Janine, the former CEO of ITT, you know, who wrote the book Managing."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:22:22]: "is what the Japanese say, Shoshin. Shoshin is the beginner's mind."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:25:20]: "We know that Salesforce is about trust. That's number one. It's about customer success. It's about innovation. It's about equality. It's about sustainability."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:25:20]: "or we call them our ohana, which is the Hawaiian word for family."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:27:58]: "We have offices in all the states and in all the countries. Where would you like to move?"
- **Marc Benioff** [0:28:54]: "the U.S. government's going to be our customer no matter who is the administrator, who is the president or what administration is in place."
- **Marc Benioff** [0:29:45]: "we are also the home of AI. And we have all the top AI companies in San Francisco, including Salesforce and others."
- **Diane Brady** [0:31:31]: "You mentioned the 25 years with Salesforce. I know before that you had 13 years at Oracle."
- **Diane Brady** [0:19:46]: "According to the latest Fortune Deloitte CEO survey, more than half of CEOs are experimenting with generative AI in their own daily activities"
- **Marc Benioff** [0:35:14]: "I love Stephen Covey, who's no longer with us, is an amazing leader, who said, begin with the end in mind."

## Transcript

**[0:00:04] Diane Brady:** Leadership Next is powered by the folks at Deloitte, who, like me, are exploring the changing rules of business leadership and how CEOs are navigating this change. Welcome to Leadership Next, the podcast about the changing rules of business leadership. I'm Diane Brady. In this week's episode, I speak with Marc Benioff of Salesforce. In addition to being one of the most successful leaders in tech and beyond, Mark is one of the most vocal when it comes to talking about everything from social issues in San Francisco to the future of AI.

**[0:00:41] Diane Brady:** He also happens to be one of the most curious when it comes to learning about leadership from others. So I started by asking him who are some of the most impactful leaders he's met.

**[0:00:52] Marc Benioff:** Some of my mentors, Colin Powell, I think, you know, really influenced me so dramatically in my core leadership. I would say maybe one of the most important people who I've ever had an opportunity to speak to also was Shimon Perez, who really gave me some incredible wisdom in terms of trying to create peace in the world. And I found that to be incredibly inspiring. And then I'd also add in, you know, really, I think the vision and the insights of some of the leaders who have done, you know, so much in business.

**[0:01:32] Marc Benioff:** And I guess I'll give you one of the people who I wish I had met, which is Hal Janine, the former CEO of ITT, you know, who wrote the book Managing. And people like that who have really been able to capture their wisdom and encapsulate it for us, I think, is so important.

**[0:01:51] Diane Brady:** Well, and I think that's what you bring to your own leadership. It's funny. Unprompted, I would have said Shimon Peres as well. What a great man. And I remember he mocked me for having a BlackBerry when he'd moved on to the iPhone. So that was when I knew I was behind the times. But I think that's something you bring a lot to your leadership, Mark, as we're talking about AI, is it seems like in addition to running your company, you do feel this, not compulsion, but this desire to be a translator of what's happening in technology to the rest of the world.

**[0:02:24] Diane Brady:** Do you think that's fair to say as you talk about AI agents?

**[0:02:28] Marc Benioff:** Well, yeah, we have a lot to talk about today, don't we, Diane? Yeah. I'll say that, yeah, I would say that my, you know, thought on that is I've really enjoyed being in the software industry for the last 45 years. When I was 15 years old is when I started writing my first software commercially and my first software product, How to Juggle, to my current software product, Agentforce. and when I look at them as a continuum, I've really enjoyed software and everything that software can be and what it does and how it works and how we can work with these computers to do all these amazing things.

**[0:03:06] Marc Benioff:** And especially as I've moved into business software, it's been amazing to help companies manage and share their information and become more productive to augment their employees. There's no question, but I think that right now I've never been more excited about software, more energized or motivated, inspired. And I think that we're about to move into a completely new world. And I don't really have all the words yet because in a lot of these areas that we're moving into, I'm not an expert and I feel like I need to pick up my level of expertise.

**[0:03:40] Marc Benioff:** And specifically, I think, you know, software is about to become digital labor. And that idea that we're going to have digital workers that are built in software that are replacing, in some cases, our human workers, augmenting our human workers, or just doing jobs that have never been done before, all of these things. Well, these are areas that I have very little expertise in, actually.

**[0:04:07] Diane Brady:** You must be using it, though.

**[0:04:08] Marc Benioff:** I'm quite energized because it's not very often that you get to learn so many new things all at once.

**[0:04:15] Diane Brady:** You know, I have to point out that I think the first tagline for Salesforce was the end of software, wasn't it? Wasn't that your – so we'll use the term software. That's exactly right.

**[0:04:24] Marc Benioff:** We were trying to make the point, you know, which is, hey, we want to really say you don't have to – you know, you were getting the software on CDs or floppy disks. And people were installing it and upgrading it and putting it all together. and that's certainly changed quite a bit hasn't it now that you know everybody understands now what the cloud is i don't have to explain that anymore thank god so you know we're in a new world which is the cloud world we have a new business model which is subscription salesforce also introduced its philanthropic model which is our 1-1 -1 model where we put 1% of our equity profit and time into a foundation

**[0:05:01] Marc Benioff:** and ended up giving away $1 billion and you know 10 million hours of volunteerism and 100 ,000 nonprofits run on our service for free. I mean, that's where we started. But today, I would say there is a new technology model, which is going to be this idea of agents and a new business model, which is you're paying per conversation. And there's no question there's a new labor model, a new productivity model, and a new economic model.

**[0:05:30] Marc Benioff:** Let's drill down on that a bit,

**[0:05:32] Diane Brady:** because I'll tell you how I think of agentic AI, if that's the right way to put it, which is basically, you know, you give the prompts to the chatbots of the world. And really, the agents, in essence, are executing on their own. So I think of it as that multi-agent model, like one will go and source, one will scope, and it'll come back to you with sort of a plan. So it's not based on what you've input, it's based on its own discovery.

**[0:06:00] Diane Brady:** Is that too simplistic? or how would you define an AI agent?

**[0:06:05] Marc Benioff:** Well, I kind of look at it like this. You know, we look at the healthcare industry right now as probably the largest and most important industry in the United States. It's so significant in our economy. I actually can't see this right now, but I'm wearing a boot because I ruptured my Achilles in September scuba diving. And I go through all of these healthcare processes like we all do. And you're very much an advocate for your own health in the United States.

**[0:06:30] Marc Benioff:** And, you know, here, Mark, you need to kind of take this scan. You need to get these labs, take these drugs and make sure you, you know, finish these and come and see your doctor. And then somehow it's all going to work out and you're going to, you know, your Achilles is going to repair itself and you're going to be healthy again and everything is fine. And the funny thing is, is that as you go through the process and you're kind of, you know, let's say you get the scan and they give you contrast on your MRI or your CT scan.

**[0:06:59] Marc Benioff:** and then they say, now make sure you drink some water and make sure you flush that contrast out. And then they give you the drugs and say, now here's the drugs and you're going to finish these drugs, but it's very important that you finish these drugs. Or you get your labs and they say, now here's the labs, but oh, this number's a little off, so you're going to need to get a repeat lab in 30 days.

**[0:07:17] Marc Benioff:** The burden is on you. You're carrying that burden. That is your monkey on your back to drink the water, to finish your drugs, and to get the repeat labs. And the reality is that you really are not relying on anyone and you know your doctor's kind of burnt out already and doesn't have the time to call you and there's nobody in the hospital that's going to be calling you. So that's all going to change. And the way it's going to change is these agents are going to deliver exactly the word that you used, I think, an agentic layer on the hospital.

**[0:07:48] Marc Benioff:** And you're going to be interoperating at the agentic layer. and things that do not happen in healthcare because we have nobody to do them, you're going to get a text that's going to say, hey, yeah, did you finish your drugs? And oh, yeah, hey, what is the pain like now on your leg? Are you doing all right? And how are you feeling? And do you have any questions about that boot you're wearing? Oh, one more thing, you know, we need to get you to come back for your repeat lab, so I scheduled it for next Tuesday at 8 o 'clock.

**[0:08:16] Marc Benioff:** Is that all right for you? And all those things and the constant interaction and kind of helping you to become healthy again are going to come through the agentic layer because we don't have anybody in the United States who does that. And we all know that because we're all living this health care system directly. This will actually make everyone a lot healthier because when you do those basic things, you do get healthier as a society or individually.

**[0:08:44] Diane Brady:** But it sounds a little like a high-end chatbot.

**[0:08:47] Marc Benioff:** I think it's a big idea, Diane, that this is like possible before providing digital labor. So in that case, there's somebody that's where, you know, the software is providing that capability. It's not a somebody. It's software, but it's taking the role of what, you know, theoretically would be somebody making that phone call or email or text message to you.

**[0:09:09] Diane Brady:** Now, this is supposed to be the year of agentic AI. So that would imply that we are already here. Have you used any of this yourself?

**[0:09:17] Marc Benioff:** Yes, I am. And our customers, let's talk about that for a second, because I think that that is so important. And you're right. This was not possible before. We now have hundreds and soon we'll have thousands of companies on our platform, which is called the Agentforce. And one of those companies is an amazing company with 75 ,000 people, $38 billion in revenue, number one in their class, incredible organization, great CEO. It's called Salesforce. And Salesforce has a service that we offer to our customers called help.salesforce.com.

**[0:09:54] Marc Benioff:** And help.salesforce.com is where our customers can go to get their questions answered. And, you know, the first round, if you're not authenticated into our system and we don't know who you are, you can ask questions and get answers that are pretty good. But then if you authenticate it and we know who you are and we know what products you have and what you've asked before, we can give you really good answers. And we have converted help.salesforce.com completely over to an agentic layer.

**[0:10:22] Marc Benioff:** So it's now 100 % Agentforce.

**[0:10:24] Diane Brady:** And those are chat bots who will then go operate on your behalf.

**[0:10:28] Marc Benioff:** They can go and operate on your behalf. And let me tell you why that's important. Salesforce also has, of our 75 ,000 employees, 9 ,000 or so are in support. So as the CEO, now what I'm actually seeing is a lot more productivity on the agentic layer. And those support agents are coming to me saying, hey, you know, we're not as busy as we were. What would you like us to do? And it turns out we're so busy at Salesforce, we want to redeploy them into being sales development representatives and business development representatives, in some case account executives, and other things directly working with customers because that agentic layer is working so well in support.

**[0:11:10] Marc Benioff:** So of those 9 ,000 support engineers today, on my mind is, well, are we going to redeploy 1 ,000, 2 ,000, 3 ,000, 4 ,000 of them? And how has the agentic layer changed our labor model at Salesforce? That is a big idea. And that's an idea and a thought I've never had to have before at Salesforce.

**[0:11:33] Diane Brady:** It's true. I'm trying to imagine somebody going to you and saying, I need more to do. That sounds like a perilous career move. But those 9 ,000 agents that you have, you wouldn't need 9 ,000 of them going forward, would you? Because I think about like in the 90s, if you had a team from India, you know, my favorite country on earth, and come over, you would think, okay, I'm training these people to replace me because Wipro and, you know, Infosys and all the other places you'd outsource to.

**[0:12:07] Diane Brady:** I'm imagining there must be some resistance among those 9 ,000 people as opposed to excitement. I would perhaps be nervous that this agentic AI is going to replace me.

**[0:12:17] Marc Benioff:** Well, I think that this is, you know, reality that we have to live in right now, which is we are entering a new world. This is a new horizon for business. And the thought that labor is going to change. You probably saw in the third quarter while, you know, labor in the United States remained basically stagnant. Productivity went up actually significantly. And economists are saying, economists who are not really technologists, that they're saying AI and the advancements in AI over the last several years is really an indication of why we're starting to see a little more productivity in the economy today.

**[0:12:51] Marc Benioff:** So when we start to apply that to our company at a company level, like with this example with help.salesforce.com, now there's another question, which is what other things are improving? And I'll give you another example in my own company because I know my company very well. We have about 13 ,000 software engineers. And our software engineering leader, who's an amazing executive, came to me and for the first time said, hey, we're building the new plan for fiscal year 26.

**[0:13:19] Marc Benioff:** we're going to start it February 1st of next year and I have something I want to tell you and I'm like well what's that he said I don't want to hire any new engineers this year and I'm like what did you say said no I'm not I don't want to hire any new engineers because I am 30 plus percent more productive this year based on technology that I have added into my organization using Agentforce and other special tricks that we have up our sleeve, our software engineering team is just a lot better.

**[0:13:50] Marc Benioff:** And that is also amazing. So here I am, you have to realize, I'm actually doing the work, right? I have to write a business plan for next year. And now I'm saying, okay, well, how many support engineers am I gonna have? And how many software engineers am I gonna have? And how many salespeople am I gonna have? And accountants and all the people who are so critical at Salesforce. and I can augment and extend and change different parts of my business based on this.

**[0:14:16] Marc Benioff:** And that is what every CEO has the opportunity to do right now, which is to rebalance, shift, and change what their business looks like based on what technology can do today that it could not do even just one year ago. And that could be in my industry or other industries. And I'd love to talk about that with you.

**[0:14:36] Diane Brady:** Well, I think it is exciting. I was listening to you in a different conversation where you compared Microsoft's CoPilot to Clippy. Talk a little bit about Microsoft because it definitely is, what would you say, I suppose, big man on campus with regard to having, you know, ChatGPT, OpenAI, CoPilot. Where does this leave a company like that?

**[0:14:59] Marc Benioff:** Microsoft has been a disappointment to so many of our customers with CoPilot. And I know anyone who's used Copilot has had the same experience that I've had, which is it doesn't seem to be able to do anything more than I can do with just ChatGPT or even Perplexity or Gemini or U.com on my phone. And the reason why is because to make this AI work and to get the value from the AI and to deliver the agentic layer to make it truly successful, to get the accuracy to lower the hallucinogenic capabilities, you have to ground it into data and metadata.

**[0:15:37] Marc Benioff:** You have to give it your workflow. You have to really let it know who your business is. And I think where Salesforce is really benefiting here is, you know, we're managing a lot of data, you know, 230, 300 petabytes of data for our customers. And because that data is there plus the metadata, you know, that metadata is like data is a phone number. The metadata is this is a phone number. So the AI, when it can get those two pieces of information, plus other things that we're able to feed it based on how you're using our platform, we've been able just to extend our platform.

**[0:16:12] Marc Benioff:** You know, AgentForce is just a switch you're turning on in Salesforce now. It's not something new you're installing or some new team you're hiring. And I think that that idea that it's easy for our customers just to turn this on now is very powerful. We have 135 ,000 customers. We have given them all AgentForce. They all have the ability to turn it on today. And not all of them are going to do that because either A, they don't have a desire, or B, they don't understand it, or C, you know, there might be some other, you know, situation where they're not ready in their business to do that.

**[0:16:46] Marc Benioff:** But we are seeing a very high rate of adoption where we're starting to see customers say, yes, I'm going to do this. And for new customers coming in, they're designing their systems and their companies agent first. And I think that will be a big moment where you're really saying, I'm designing my platform, my company, my industry to be agent first. And that is a big thought.

**[0:17:11] Diane Brady:** Yeah, no, I think it's interesting. It's almost like, you know, when we talk about the automobile originally just replacing sort of the horse and buggy. And once you get a critical mass, then you start to reimagine how cities are designed, how work is designed. So I think it's exciting. You did mention hallucinogenic. I want to stop and pause there. Do you worry about that? Because obviously the sophistication of deep fakes, the risk of hallucinations, as we call them, how do you think about that?

**[0:17:40] Marc Benioff:** Well, this has been a very interesting process for us. Now, Salesforce not only builds Agentforce, we build some of the most accurate and compelling models in the world, AI models. And two out of the five most accurate models are Salesforce models. And we do that in our incredible AI engineering team. You know, Salesforce is the number one provider of enterprise AI already in the world today. We will do over 2 trillion, 2 trillion with a T transactions, AI transactions this week with our core platform, which is Einstein.

**[0:18:13] Marc Benioff:** Many people know Einstein and use it every day. Now, Agentforce is kind of the next version above that. It's new models, new techniques, new capabilities. And one of the reasons that we've been able to basically kind of grind hallucinogens down to zero in many cases, where we're seeing accuracy up in the 95%, 96%, 97%, 98 % level on AI and agents, is because we're grounding this data into the model itself. And that is a big capability that we have that others don't have.

**[0:18:49] Marc Benioff:** And we're really doing some cool things. I also have to say we have other techniques that we've created at Salesforce, including new RAG techniques. That's retrieval augmented generation. That's the ability for the AI to go out and get lots of data to ground itself. And we are able to do some cool stuff. And we're getting some great results. And again, you can see it on our website, like help.salesforce.com that I mentioned, or if you go to salesforce.com on your phone, you'll see a test that I'm running right now where I'm running an ungrounded model as a front end of my website.

**[0:19:24] Marc Benioff:** And that idea of an agent on the front end of my website where you can just ask it about my products and even my competitors and product information has never really been done before. And that is really opening my mind in terms of all the new things that I can do with customers with a completely agent-first website.

**[0:19:46] Diane Brady:** Generative AI has been a transformative force in the business landscape for the last 18 months. According to the latest Fortune Deloitte CEO survey, more than half of CEOs are experimenting with generative AI in their own daily activities and, of course, trying to spread it throughout their organizations. I'm joined by Jason Garzadas, the CEO of Deloitte US, which is the longtime sponsor of this podcast. Jason, good to see you.

**[0:20:12] Jason Garzadas:** Hi, Diane. It's great to be with you.

**[0:20:13] Diane Brady:** How are businesses integrating AI into their organizations? Where do you see the most substantial benefits?

**[0:20:21] Jason Garzadas:** I think it's true, as you say, that every organization wants to capitalize on the benefits of AI, particularly generative AI. The benefits have been largely around efficiencies to date and looking for ways to automate routine tasks. The promise is there for more insight-driven use cases and innovation use cases. That's the next stage. We're seeing organizations looking to move from proofs of concept and pilots to see these technologies and models put in place in true operational uses at scale.

**[0:20:51] Diane Brady:** When you think about how much change there's been the last 18 months, really curious, how do you think it's going to evolve in the next 18 months, 36 months?

**[0:21:00] Jason Garzadas:** I think we're actually needing to change our timing horizon. By all indications, we're more in six-month intervals. And I think that's exciting, but also a challenge. Enterprises aren't accustomed to working in that type of cadence and with that type of pace. And so the winners, if you will, will be those that can assimilate this technology that quickly, which I think is putting real strain on organizations' ability to adapt that quickly. This is a perfect instance where leadership has to be in sync to assimilate technology that quickly.

**[0:21:29] Jason Garzadas:** I think as a CEO, it's important that we lead by example. So I've been through all the training. I've been through all the productivity tools that we have available within our organization. But then more broadly, we've embarked upon a significant investment to deploy this across all we do.

**[0:21:44] Diane Brady:** I'm feeling the urgency, Jason. Thanks for joining us.

**[0:21:47] Jason Garzadas:** Well, thank you, Diane.

**[0:21:53] Diane Brady:** it's interesting i think the first time i saw you you were holding up a philips sonic care brush talking about how much it had improved your your brushing and your teeth you are the quintessential salesman and for your for your own company and for your customers and you know i want to talk a bit about you as a leader let's start with that What is the hallmark of sort of a great salesman? Because not every CEO has the mindset you do.

**[0:22:22] Marc Benioff:** Well, I think that number one is what the Japanese say, Shoshin. Shoshin is the beginner's mind. And I think as a CEO, you've got a lot coming at you all the time. You know, you've got your text messages, your email messages, your one-on-ones, your operational reviews, your investors, your activist investors. You know, you have a lot. Your media. You know, there's a lot going on in the CEO life. And to those CEOs, I would say, I've been doing this 25 years, which is probably too long, Shoshin.

**[0:22:53] Marc Benioff:** That is, reclaim your beginner's mind. In your beginner's mind, you have every possibility, but in your expert's mind, you have few. And every day, are you starting with some practice? Mine is I have a meditation practice, prayer. You know, are we able to really have a beginner's mind and really look at things from the beginning? And I think in this example that we've been talking about, Agentforce, I need to have a beginner's mind because this is new.

**[0:23:23] Marc Benioff:** This is very different than anything that's ever happened before. It does not fit in existing models. Our models, and when I say models, I mean really business models. It doesn't fit in our business models or anything that I've seen in any other industry. So I need to have a beginner's mind, but this is something that I think is every CEO really needs to cultivate. And for those that get stuck and don't have a beginner's mind, they get in trouble because there's too many things happening too fast.

**[0:23:54] Marc Benioff:** And so if you are in that flow and you're in the river and you're fighting the river, you're going to have a problem. You've got to get into the flow of the river. And I do a lot of consulting with COs. They will call me, hey, I've got this problem or that problem or this activist investor or this, and I'll try to give them. But in all cases, I will tell them, hey, let's start really with your level of mindfulness and your mindset.

**[0:24:20] Marc Benioff:** Where are you? What do you really want? That is number one question. in wherever we're going to start. What do you want and what's important to you? And let's just start there in your vision and your values. And that is where I want to spend the time with you right now.

**[0:24:32] Diane Brady:** It's not something people like to talk about in public. I think your first book was Compassionate Capitalism. I know you've been very outspoken on a lot of social issues in San Francisco and elsewhere. We're entering a period right now with a different administration. You can certainly comment on that if you want. But what do you think about the state of society

**[0:24:54] Marc Benioff:** right now, Mark? Well, core values, that's what we're really talking about. And society can have values and your business can have values and you can have values. And when we look at administrations and presidents, and this is the time of the year when I'll get that question from on a podcast like this. And I will say, look, I've worked with a lot of presidents and a lot of administrations in a lot of countries all over the world.

**[0:25:20] Marc Benioff:** And administrations change, presidents change, our core values don't change. We know who we are. And this is the opportunity for all of us to like revisit, who are you? What is your core value? We know that Salesforce is about trust. That's number one. It's about customer success. It's about innovation. It's about equality. It's about sustainability. And those values are not gonna change. That's what's important to us and our employees, or we call them our ohana, which is the Hawaiian word for family.

**[0:25:51] Marc Benioff:** This idea that we believe that the business of business is not business, but it's the business of business is changing the world and that business is the greatest platform for change. This is our core values and our mindset at Salesforce. And look, we realize technology is not good or bad. It's what you're doing with this technology that matters. And the technology is constantly changing. that's constantly getting lower cost and easier to use. And we have to then apply that to make the world somehow better.

**[0:26:23] Marc Benioff:** And that's what we're doing with our lives and with our company. And that's

**[0:26:27] Diane Brady:** what we've been doing. And these are the things that, you know, I think personal values don't change. And I guess I was thinking more about the landscape where you've been, you were a pioneer, I think, in the gender pay equity. You've been outspoken on LGBTQ plus rights, homelessness, abortion rights. I mean, these are, it does feel like there's a lot of people right now who may be shocked, might be too strong a word, but how do you talk about this or do you talk about this internally to your employees?

**[0:26:58] Diane Brady:** Is it just about recapturing your corporate values and

**[0:27:02] Marc Benioff:** society will take care of itself? It's a funny thing. I think that a lot of people think, oh, he's this political persuasion or he's this party and he's interested in this issue. and really none of those things are true. And it's funny, I won't correct people even on social media when they said, well, you know, he's in this political party. And I'm like, I'm really not, but I'm not going to talk about that right now. You know, because the most important thing for me as a CEO is that I have my employees back.

**[0:27:33] Marc Benioff:** So in regards to changes that are happening in our country and in the states, and if we have an employee who is being discriminated against in a state, which has happened, you know, and is going to happen. I will say to them and they will complain and they'll say, you need to get involved and you need to call my governor and you need to do this and you need to do that. And I'm like, listen, I'm going to be able to do some things, but I'm not going to do everything.

**[0:27:58] Marc Benioff:** But I'll tell you one thing I can do, which is we have a big company. We have offices in all the states and in all the countries. Where would you like to move? And if you're not happy there because of a change going on with these laws or this politician or this political philosophy, we will move you. And I think that that is probably the most empowering thing that I can do as a CEO for my employees.

**[0:28:22] Marc Benioff:** And I think at a moment like this, I already know what's going to happen. It's going to be very tumultuous. And it'll be tumultuous in our conferences, and we'll be accused of things, and we're supporting this, and we're supporting that. But at the end of the day, the one group that we must support is our employees. And that is where my mindset will be because I already know what's about to unfold because we will be accused of being complicit in something that I don't even know what's about to happen because the U.S.

**[0:28:54] Marc Benioff:** government is our customer. So of course we have this agency XYZ running Salesforce and all of a sudden we'll be complicit in some action that someone will not like because we are a vendor. And of course, that's not true. So, and we're not, we're going to, the U.S. government's going to be our customer no matter who is the administrator, who is the president or what administration is in place.

**[0:29:16] Diane Brady:** And I think less regulation at a time of innovation is not necessarily a bad thing as we head into the next, you know, but you're right. There's no upside in discussing partisan politics, but I do think about just the mindset of customers and, you know, you're out in California. So I know that you, that's one of the reasons you built Salesforce Tower in downtown San Francisco, right? Was to keep it as a hub. I'm a fourth generation San Francisco.

**[0:29:44] Diane Brady:** I was born in

**[0:29:45] Marc Benioff:** San Francisco. And so San Francisco has influenced my life. You know, we are the home of Levi's, you know, the gold rush, you know, but we're also the home of the sourdough bread. We're the home of gay rights. I've grew up in that culture, in that world. And maybe that explains some of my views. Today, San Francisco is a more important city than any other in the world because we are also the home of AI. And we have all the top AI companies in San Francisco, including Salesforce and others.

**[0:30:22] Marc Benioff:** And look, San Francisco is an innovative city. We're a creative city. We're a place, you know, hate Ashbury. You know, there's a lot has happened in San Francisco. And there's a lot going to happen in San Francisco going forward. And sometimes it goes well, and sometimes it does not go well. And then some, and then, you know, San Franciscans have always been ones who've kind of come in to say, hey, we're going to support the hospital.

**[0:30:48] Marc Benioff:** We're going to support the public schools. We're going to support the public parks. We are going to help somebody who's homeless. Yes, We're going to do all of those things. That doesn't make you a Democrat or a Republican. It makes you a human being if you're actually going to go make sure people are educated, healthy, and have shelter. So I would say that that is incredibly important right now.

**[0:31:10] Diane Brady:** It's interesting. I think about your book, Trailblazer. But I think that's your fourth book, right? Maybe you could write, are you going to write a fifth one with AI? I suppose I should ask that first.

**[0:31:18] Marc Benioff:** I would like to write another book. I don't have time. I am making some notes on what I would say if I did write a new book. And if I get a little time, maybe I'll be able to start working on it. But it does take a lot of time to write a book.

**[0:31:31] Diane Brady:** That's what agents are for, I suppose, right? One of the many things we can use them for. But I do want to kind of end off by asking a bit about where you get the joy in your job. You mentioned the 25 years with Salesforce. I know before that you had 13 years at Oracle. You had your own, as you say, since you've been a teenager, you've been entrepreneurial. what is it that you think about right now that really you know lights up your eyes and fills your heart when you go to work and I know you work from home well I can tell you the joy

**[0:32:04] Marc Benioff:** at work is fleeting because you know it could be a lot of good days and a lot of bad days but I'm going more for the fulfillment you know I want to have look at my career and say that I was able to not just make a successful business, but also to have a business that improved the state of the world. And some of those things that we've been able to do for others and give back, those are the things that I think that have really been powerful.

**[0:32:36] Marc Benioff:** All the new products and all the new technology and the continuum of innovation and the continuum of customer success are extremely important to me. But I would say the continuum of giving is equally as important to me. And looking back over 25 years as CEO of Salesforce, I would say that is maybe the most important thing, and maybe in many cases, the most differentiated against other companies or what other CEOs have done. And I guess one of the most fulfilling things is 20 ,000 companies have now copied our 1-1 -1 model.

**[0:33:11] Marc Benioff:** And that has been great because I think every company and every business culture

**[0:33:17] Diane Brady:** can benefit from this idea. Do you know 80 ,000 companies have the term AI in their name now? Wow, that's cool. That's a statistic that wows me. But may I ask one other question, if you don't mind? Because I have three kids that have ADHD. I know you've talked about that. And I remember doing a book with John Chambers where he talked about dyslexia, which is now seen to be such an advantage in business. So many entrepreneurs have dyslexia.

**[0:33:43] Diane Brady:** I don't hear that conversation around ADHD. I'm just curious how you work differently, knowing that that's just part of who you are. Obviously, nobody questions your success or your vision, but I think it actually matters a lot to how people perceive themselves when they hear they have something

**[0:34:04] Marc Benioff:** like that? Well, I think that, you know, there's many different kinds of minds. And this is number one, there's many different kinds of human beings. And this is, we have to value the diversity of our genetics. It's kind of amazing. You know, it's one of the great gifts of the world that we have this genetic diversity. And so I think that we have to start there. And when it comes to different kinds of minds. You can have different labels.

**[0:34:31] Marc Benioff:** Somebody might have ADHD or ADD or OCD or dyslexia. And I think in all cases, I think getting some self-awareness around what kind of mind you have or what you're trying to accomplish, I'll come back to mindfulness. I think that this idea of mindfulness and prayer and meditation and having those moments during the day to kind of right size and align with your values and what's important to you and really look at what's preventing you from being successful or how will you know that you are successful and keeping track of those things and having some kind of a north star of where you're going with your life because it does go quickly and what you really want to do

**[0:35:14] Marc Benioff:** is have some clarity of hey I'm going here so when I look back at my career over 40 years in software I'm like wow yeah I've accomplished, I think, almost every single thing I've set out to do. And when I haven't accomplished something, I usually get to the point where I say, wow, that was never a goal of mine. You know, when I put my mind to it, I tend to get there. You know, I love Stephen Covey, who's no longer with us, is an amazing leader, who said, begin with the end in mind.

**[0:35:45] Marc Benioff:** And I think that that's a really key phrase for all of us in business or in life. And I think when we look at our different types of minds, all of us, regardless of the type of mind you have, have intention. That is, you have to be able to ask that question, what do you want? What is your intention? The Japanese call it ishii. What is it that you exactly want? Where are you exactly going? Because for the most part, regardless of the type of mind you have, if you could set your goal, you're probably going to go there if you focus on it continuously, persistently, every single minute of every single day.

**[0:36:26] Diane Brady:** That's great. And is there any question that – well, I should have, of course, asked about Time. Former sister publication, now I suppose rival publication. I'm not sure if you enjoy being a media owner, so you can comment on that. But anything else that I haven't asked that I should have, Mark?

**[0:36:43] Marc Benioff:** Well, I've enjoyed being with time. Media is a difficult business. I've learned a lot. I guess that's what I've enjoyed the most is how much I've learned with the magazine. I haven't published a piece today on digital workers and digital workforce. You can find it on my Twitter feed. And look, I think that this is just an incredible moment where, you know, we need to like just appreciate how much is happening in the world and the amount of change that's going on and then find our place in it and then go forward.

**[0:37:16] Marc Benioff:** I will get back to that thought of there's never been a more important time to have absolute clarity on what you really want. Because if you write it down, I think you will definitely achieve it. And with everything that's happening, we can get lost in our minds or get lost in our emotions. And we need to get back, you know, to our intention.

**[0:37:37] Diane Brady:** Great. It's a pleasure to speak with you. Thank you for joining us.

**[0:37:41] Marc Benioff:** Great to be with you always.

**[0:37:46] Diane Brady:** Leadership Next is edited by Nicole Vergala. Our audio engineer is Natasha Ortiz. Our producer is Mason Cohn. And our executive producer is Hallie Steiner. Our theme is by Jason Snell. Leadership Next is a production of Fortune Media. Leadership Next episodes are produced by Fortune's editorial team. The views and opinions expressed by podcast speakers and guests are solely their own. and do not reflect the opinions of Deloitte or its personnel, nor does Deloitte advocate or endorse any individuals or entities featured on the episodes.
