Questions
Does earning more money make you happier?
On average, yes. Matt Killingsworth's data shows happiness rising with income, and the joint study with Kahneman confirmed that more money correlates with more happiness. But the episode stresses this is a correlation, not proof that money causes happiness, and the effect is fairly small.
Is the famous $75,000 happiness limit real?
Not as a general rule. It came from a 2010 study by Kahneman and Angus Deaton, but the later work found the plateau only among the unhappiest 15 to 20% of people, at about $100,000 after inflation adjustment. For happier people, happiness kept rising with income.
Why did the 2010 study find a plateau when Killingsworth's data did not?
The 2010 study asked three yes-or-no questions, and about 85% of people answered yes to everything. That made it unable to separate happy people from very happy ones, so it was really measuring unhappiness. Killingsworth's slider measure had room above the typical answer, so it could keep showing gains.
What is an adversarial collaboration?
It is a method Kahneman favoured in which two researchers who disagree jointly design a study and write the paper together, rather than attacking each other in journals. Barb Mellors served as the neutral arbiter between Kahneman and Killingsworth.
Should I pick a career just to earn more money?
Killingsworth was hesitant to say so. He said money's effect on happiness is pretty small compared with other factors like social connections, exercise and living in the moment. He called the choice a personal decision, though he said engineering over art history might be worth considering if you are torn.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
The happiness-plateau idea comes from a 2010 paper by Nobel laureates Angus Deaton, an economist, and Daniel Kahneman, a psychologist.
“This idea comes from a paper by two famous Nobel Prize winners, Angus Deaton and Daniel Kahneman, famous economist and famous psychologist. They wrote it in 2010.”
0:06:38 · Nick Fountain · 2010 study · 2010
The Kahneman and Deaton study drew on responses from 450,000 US adults who were asked about their emotions the previous day, including whether they smiled or laughed a lot.
“450 ,000 adults in the U.S. were asked, did you smile or laugh a lot yesterday?”
0:08:32 · Nick Fountain · Study sample · 2010
The 2010 paper found basically no effect of additional income on emotional well-being beyond the $60,000 to $90,000 bracket, of which $75,000 is the midpoint.
“The paper actually finds that there's basically no effect after the $60 ,000 to $90 ,000 income bracket.”
0:09:18 · Sally Helm · Income plateau · 2010
The hosts say Daniel Kahneman died in March of the year the episode was made.
“He actually died quite recently in March of this year.”
0:07:03 · Sally Helm · Kahneman's death
Scientists have used beepers and then Palm Pilots to check in with people throughout the day for experience-sampling research.
“They check in with people throughout the day using beepers and then palm pilots.”
0:11:37 · Sally Helm · Experience sampling
Matt Killingsworth launched trackyourhappiness.org as a graduate student in the late 2000s to run experience sampling by smartphone.
“Matt is in grad school in the late 2000s, and he launches a project called trackyourhappiness.org to do experience sampling with smartphones.”
0:11:37 · Sally Helm · Track Your Happiness · late 2000s
Killingsworth's project has collected millions of data points from hundreds of thousands of people and is still collecting.
“Matt has collected millions of data points from hundreds of thousands of people, and he's still going.”
0:13:00 · Sally Helm · Data scale
Killingsworth published his paper finding no income plateau in 2021, and it drew great interest.
“What happens when he publishes his paper in 2021 is that people are very interested.”
0:15:10 · Nick Fountain · 2021 paper · 2021
Barb Mellors, a psychology professor at the University of Pennsylvania, where Killingsworth works, got the call from Kahneman that led to the collaboration.
“Across the campus at Matt's workplace, the University of Pennsylvania, a psychology professor picks up the telephone.”
0:17:17 · Nick Fountain · Mediator
Kahneman proposed an adversarial collaboration, in which researchers who disagree work together to design a study and write a paper.
“He wanted to do something he called an adversarial collaboration. Where researchers with scientific beefs try to figure out the truth.”
0:18:12 · Nick Fountain · Adversarial collaboration
The data in the 2010 Kahneman and Deaton study came from the polling company Gallup, which called more than 450,000 people.
“Theirs came from the professional polling company Gallup, who called more than 450 ,000 people to ask them these questions.”
0:20:34 · Sally Helm · Gallup data · 2010
The 2010 study's emotional well-being measure was essentially three yes-or-no questions about smiling or laughing, happiness and enjoyment the previous day.
“It was essentially three questions. Did you smile or laugh a lot yesterday? Did you feel happiness a lot yesterday? How about enjoyment?”
0:21:33 · Sally Helm · Survey design · 2010
In the 2010 dataset, the average happiness score was about 85%, meaning most respondents were at the top of the scale.
“On average, in the entire data set, the overall happiness measures were about 85%, meaning just about everyone was at the maximum of the happiness scale on that day they were measured.”
0:22:08 · Barb Mellors · Ceiling effect · 2010
Sally Helm explains that the 2010 measure effectively captured unhappiness rather than happiness, because the happier majority all gave the maximum answer.
“In fact, another way to say it is that Danny wasn't actually measuring happiness. He was measuring unhappiness.”
0:24:32 · Sally Helm · Mislabeled variable · 2010
Among the unhappiest 15 to 20% in Killingsworth's sample, reported happiness rose with income only up to about $100,000 a year, which matches Kahneman's earlier plateau after adjusting for inflation.
“People who made more said they were happier, but only up to about $100 ,000 a year. If you account for inflation, that is basically what Danny found all those years ago.”
0:26:21 · Sally Helm · Reconciled plateau
Barb Mellors says that among the happiest 15% of people, happiness rises very quickly with income.
“For the happiest people, those at the top 15%, what you find is that at that point, happiness goes up really fast.”
0:27:35 · Barb Mellors · Happiest group
Psychology has been going through a replication crisis, in which many results fail to replicate when other researchers repeat them.
“Psychology has been in the midst of what's been called the replication crisis.”
0:28:31 · Nick Fountain · Replication crisis
Before becoming a psychology researcher, Matt Killingsworth studied engineering and worked in tech.
“Before he was a psychology researcher, he studied engineering, worked in tech.”
0:30:41 · Sally Helm · Killingsworth background
Bernadette Joy Cruz Mullion and her husband have a net worth of about $1.7 million, mostly in retirement savings.
“Her and her husband's total net worth today is about $1.7 million, most of that in retirement.”
0:02:37 · Nick Fountain · Listener's finances
Bernadette Joy Cruz Mullion attended a BTS concert in Las Vegas in 2022.
“She also loves the mega famous K-pop group BTS. And in 2022, she went to see them perform in Vegas.”
0:03:28 · Nick Fountain · BTS concert · 2022