# Can money buy happiness?

- **Show:** Planet Money
- **Published:** 18 Sep 2024
- **Source:** https://www.npr.org/2024/09/18/1200121013/money-happiness-kahneman-killingsworth
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/planet-money/can-money-buy-happiness-6b6466/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

The famous idea that happiness stops rising once income passes about $75,000 a year is mostly a measurement artifact. Psychologist Matt Killingsworth found that happiness keeps climbing with income. When he and Nobel laureate Daniel Kahneman combined their data, they found the plateau was real only for the unhappiest group of people. Meanwhile the happiest people showed happiness rising faster with more money.

The episode is about how a bitter scientific disagreement turned into a collaboration. Kahneman did not defend his 2010 result or attack the younger researcher. He proposed an "adversarial collaboration" in which both sides assumed their data was good. That showed the old survey's yes-or-no questions could not tell happy people from very happy ones. The episode adds that correlation is not causation, and money's effect is modest.

## Key insights

1. **The $75,000 plateau was partly a measurement artifact** The 2010 study used three yes-or-no questions, and about 85% of people answered yes to all three. People who were merely happy and people who were extremely happy looked identical, so the survey could not show happiness rising at higher incomes.
2. **Experience sampling revealed no income plateau** Killingsworth pinged people at random moments and had them rate how they felt on a slider from very bad to very good. Because few people hit the top of the slider, his measure could keep rising, and it kept rising with income.
3. **The plateau survives only among the unhappiest** Within the unhappiest 15 to 20% of Killingsworth's sample, happiness rose with income only up to about $100,000. That is roughly the same level as Kahneman's old figure after adjusting for inflation. So the original finding was really about unhappiness.
4. **For the happiest, more money tracked faster gains** In the top 15% of happiness, the relationship accelerated, so more money went with more and more happiness. The researchers do not know why, and they only speculate that these people may spend money on things that make them happy.
5. **Adversarial collaboration beat trading attacks in journals** Kahneman asked Barb Mellors to mediate, and the pair assumed both datasets were valid. That approach located the cause of the conflict and produced a new finding, rather than one side being declared wrong.

## Questions this episode answers

### Does earning more money make you happier?

On average, yes. Matt Killingsworth's data shows happiness rising with income, and the joint study with Kahneman confirmed that more money correlates with more happiness. But the episode stresses this is a correlation, not proof that money causes happiness, and the effect is fairly small.

### Is the famous $75,000 happiness limit real?

Not as a general rule. It came from a 2010 study by Kahneman and Angus Deaton, but the later work found the plateau only among the unhappiest 15 to 20% of people, at about $100,000 after inflation adjustment. For happier people, happiness kept rising with income.

### Why did the 2010 study find a plateau when Killingsworth's data did not?

The 2010 study asked three yes-or-no questions, and about 85% of people answered yes to everything. That made it unable to separate happy people from very happy ones, so it was really measuring unhappiness. Killingsworth's slider measure had room above the typical answer, so it could keep showing gains.

### What is an adversarial collaboration?

It is a method Kahneman favoured in which two researchers who disagree jointly design a study and write the paper together, rather than attacking each other in journals. Barb Mellors served as the neutral arbiter between Kahneman and Killingsworth.

### Should I pick a career just to earn more money?

Killingsworth was hesitant to say so. He said money's effect on happiness is pretty small compared with other factors like social connections, exercise and living in the moment. He called the choice a personal decision, though he said engineering over art history might be worth considering if you are torn.

## Facts

- **Nick Fountain** [0:06:38]: "This idea comes from a paper by two famous Nobel Prize winners, Angus Deaton and Daniel Kahneman, famous economist and famous psychologist. They wrote it in 2010."
- **Nick Fountain** [0:08:32]: "450 ,000 adults in the U.S. were asked, did you smile or laugh a lot yesterday?"
- **Sally Helm** [0:09:18]: "The paper actually finds that there's basically no effect after the $60 ,000 to $90 ,000 income bracket."
- **Sally Helm** [0:07:03]: "He actually died quite recently in March of this year."
- **Sally Helm** [0:11:37]: "They check in with people throughout the day using beepers and then palm pilots."
- **Sally Helm** [0:11:37]: "Matt is in grad school in the late 2000s, and he launches a project called trackyourhappiness.org to do experience sampling with smartphones."
- **Sally Helm** [0:13:00]: "Matt has collected millions of data points from hundreds of thousands of people, and he's still going."
- **Nick Fountain** [0:15:10]: "What happens when he publishes his paper in 2021 is that people are very interested."
- **Nick Fountain** [0:17:17]: "Across the campus at Matt's workplace, the University of Pennsylvania, a psychology professor picks up the telephone."
- **Nick Fountain** [0:18:12]: "He wanted to do something he called an adversarial collaboration. Where researchers with scientific beefs try to figure out the truth."
- **Sally Helm** [0:20:34]: "Theirs came from the professional polling company Gallup, who called more than 450 ,000 people to ask them these questions."
- **Sally Helm** [0:21:33]: "It was essentially three questions. Did you smile or laugh a lot yesterday? Did you feel happiness a lot yesterday? How about enjoyment?"
- **Barb Mellors** [0:22:08]: "On average, in the entire data set, the overall happiness measures were about 85%, meaning just about everyone was at the maximum of the happiness scale on that day they were measured."
- **Sally Helm** [0:24:32]: "In fact, another way to say it is that Danny wasn't actually measuring happiness. He was measuring unhappiness."
- **Sally Helm** [0:26:21]: "People who made more said they were happier, but only up to about $100 ,000 a year. If you account for inflation, that is basically what Danny found all those years ago."
- **Barb Mellors** [0:27:35]: "For the happiest people, those at the top 15%, what you find is that at that point, happiness goes up really fast."
- **Nick Fountain** [0:28:31]: "Psychology has been in the midst of what's been called the replication crisis."
- **Sally Helm** [0:30:41]: "Before he was a psychology researcher, he studied engineering, worked in tech."
- **Nick Fountain** [0:02:37]: "Her and her husband's total net worth today is about $1.7 million, most of that in retirement."
- **Nick Fountain** [0:03:28]: "She also loves the mega famous K-pop group BTS. And in 2022, she went to see them perform in Vegas."

## Transcript

**[0:00:00] Sally Helm:** This message comes from University at Buffalo, where scientists are working to protect the Great Lakes and freshwater supplies around the world from harmful contamination. Learn more about their research at buffalo.edu slash NPR.

**[0:00:14] Barb Mellors:** This is Planet Money from NPR.

**[0:00:19] Sally Helm:** Back in 2010, a piece of research came out that kind of changed the way the world thought about an age-old question. Can money buy happiness?

**[0:00:31] Nick Fountain:** Yeah. The key finding, or at least the key finding that I took from it when I was in my 20s, was that money can buy happiness, but only up to a certain point. After you make about $75 ,000 a year, it doesn't matter.

**[0:00:46] Sally Helm:** Nick, I also heard about that happiness plateau back when I was in my 20s. And so did Bernadette Joy Cruz Mullion. I called her up because I wanted to talk about this happiness finding with someone who felt like they had lived it. And Bernadette turned out to be the perfect person.

**[0:01:06] Bernadette Joy Cruz Mullion:** I noticed that around that mark was where I do remember feeling like, OK, I'm not lacking for anything. And I'm not in this bracket where I feel like I have to keep up with the people with like the nice cars and shoes and all this other stuff.

**[0:01:19] Nick Fountain:** Bernadette confirmed for her, $75 ,000 a year felt like this happiness sweet spot. She'd grown up middle class. Her dad was an accountant. Her mom was a bookkeeper. They were a big family. Money was tight. Like, she loves roller coasters. And she said growing up, going to the amusement park was like a really special occasion. They could only afford to send her maybe once every four years.

**[0:01:43] Sally Helm:** Bernadette had a well-paying corporate job in her 20s. And after she hit that milestone, $75 ,000 a year, she really felt like money wasn't improving her life.

**[0:01:56] Bernadette Joy Cruz Mullion:** I was making exactly $100 ,000. And it was such a shock to my system that the more money that I made, I actually felt like the less happy I became. So Bernadette changed her whole life.

**[0:02:09] Sally Helm:** Not to make more money, but to find a path that would make her happier. She quit her job, took out loans to go back to school. After she graduated, she started a business, hustled to pay off her debt, bought and sold some real estate. And eventually, even though it had not been her explicit goal, Bernadette and her husband actually had a lot of money in the bank. All right, so you're like a millionaire. We are, in fact, a millionaire, yeah.

**[0:02:37] Nick Fountain:** Her and her husband's total net worth today is about $1.7 million, most of that in retirement. Last year, their household income was nearly $300 ,000. And they're debt-free.

**[0:02:49] Sally Helm:** And in her 30s, Bernadette started to be like, wait, if you spend it on the right things, having money is actually awesome.

**[0:02:59] Bernadette Joy Cruz Mullion:** My husband and I have a lot of freedom of time. And we have a lot of hobbies and interests. And I think because we are debt-free, I have this literal feeling that I don't owe people anything. And so then I have the freedom to choose how I want to spend my time. For example, remember Bernadette loves roller coasters. My husband and I, we have a season pass at our local amusement park. And I ride roller coasters by myself on like random Wednesday evenings.

**[0:03:28] Nick Fountain:** She also loves the mega famous K-pop group BTS. And in 2022, she went to see them perform in Vegas.

**[0:03:36] Bernadette Joy Cruz Mullion:** I remember just thinking like, I don't care how much this is going to cost. Like, I'm going to go to this concert with my best friend no matter what happens. They all went to the concert.

**[0:03:47] Sally Helm:** It was amazing. She felt alive again. And she said afterwards, she turns to her husband and is like, I feel so happy. And money made this possible.

**[0:03:59] Nick Fountain:** And she says that was the moment when she realized she'd been wrong about how more money didn't mean more happiness. Now, she felt like it did.

**[0:04:10] Sally Helm:** Yeah, in other words, maybe that $75 ,000 plateau idea is bunk. And at the end of our interview, I just asked her the big question, can money buy happiness? My answer is a resounding yes. Over the past decade, Bernadette has done a complete 180 on this question. And in the background, social science has been making almost the exact same 180, taking another look at what had seemed to be settled science. Hello and welcome to Planet Money.

**[0:04:49] Sally Helm:** I'm Sally Helm.

**[0:04:49] Nick Fountain:** And I'm Nick Fountain. When it comes to economics in our everyday lives, this is kind of the mother of all questions. How is money connected to our happiness? The data on this once seemed pretty definitive, but recently it has come under fire.

**[0:05:04] Sally Helm:** Today on the show, two researchers with totally opposite takes come together to try and hammer out a definitive answer about how income affects our happiness. And they find something that neither of them expected. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from University at Buffalo, where five decades of AI research is producing advancements that put people first, tackling real-world problems for progress, not profit. Empowering, not replacing. Learn how the University at Buffalo is using AI responsibly to create a better, brighter future for all at buffalo.edu slash npr.

**[0:05:50] Speaker 5:** This message comes from LinkedIn. As a small business owner, you wear many hats. You're the owner, the marketer, the seller, the hirer. With LinkedIn, you have the tools to help you boost your visibility, find prospective customers, and find the best team for your small business, all in one place. So while LinkedIn can't hang up all of your hats, it makes it easier to wear them all. Learn more at linkedin.com slash planet money show. This message comes from Dell.

**[0:06:19] Speaker 5:** Shop at

**[0:06:19] Sally Helm:** All right, Sally, we started with this idea about a happiness plateau.

**[0:06:38] Nick Fountain:** That as you make more money, you get happier. But that the relationship levels off when you're making about $75 ,000 a year. And beyond that point, more money does not correlate with more happiness. This idea comes from a paper by two famous Nobel Prize winners, Angus Deaton and Daniel Kahneman, famous economist and famous psychologist. They wrote it in 2010.

**[0:07:03] Sally Helm:** And one thing to know is that in the world of psychology, Danny Kahneman was an enormous deal. He actually died quite recently in March of this year. So I called up another happiness researcher, Matt Killingsworth at the University of Pennsylvania. I asked him about Kahneman and his work.

**[0:07:21] Nick Fountain:** I mean, he's just a giant in the field. I mean, probably, possibly the most important person who's ever existed and certainly the most important scientist has been alive in my lifetime.

**[0:07:33] Sally Helm:** Wait, did you say possibly the most important person who's ever existed?

**[0:07:37] Nick Fountain:** In that area of science, what psychologist has been more influential scientifically? Matt himself was really influenced by Danny Kahneman. They actually met once when Matt was a grad student. Kahneman gave him some advice for a study he was designing to answer the question, is life worth living? And I just remember Danny responding after a little pause, that's a very good question. Huh. With sort of a twinkle in his eye.

**[0:08:03] Sally Helm:** That said, one thing he really respects about that 2010 study is the careful way that it looks at the different parts of happiness. Because there are really a couple of ways you could define it, right? Like one way is to just ask, how satisfied are you with your life? But the one that we're going to focus on and that everyone focuses on when they talk about this paper, it has to do with emotional well-being. Just like moment to moment, as you go about your regular day, how do you feel?

**[0:08:32] Nick Fountain:** Which is kind of hard to pin down, hard to study empirically. So what Kahneman and Deaton did was they looked at people's answers to a bunch of different questions about their day yesterday. 450 ,000 adults in the U.S. were asked, did you smile or laugh a lot yesterday? Did you experience happiness during a lot of the day yesterday? How about enjoyment? They put all that together to try to get a measure of happiness. When it came to people's sort of day-to-day emotional state, kind of how they're feeling, that rose but only up to a point.

**[0:09:05] Nick Fountain:** Once, as they argued in the paper, at least once you got up to $75 ,000 a year, that didn't seem to change. Yeah, this is that really famous finding in the 2010 study. A happiness plateau.

**[0:09:18] Sally Helm:** Two quick caveats here. One, the $75 ,000 number is a little imprecise. The paper actually finds that there's basically no effect after the $60 ,000 to $90 ,000 income bracket. So $75 ,000 is just the midpoint of that range. And two, correlation is not causation.

**[0:09:37] Nick Fountain:** Scream it from the rooftop, Sally.

**[0:09:39] Sally Helm:** A tattoo it on my heart, Nick Fountain. This study looks at correlations between money and happiness, but it actually does not speak to the question of whether more money is causing greater happiness.

**[0:09:51] Nick Fountain:** But nevertheless, people really latch on to this idea. They love it. And you can see why. It's nice to know that science says what we know from the tabloids, that rich people, they're just like us. Just as happy or miserable as us. I was entering the workforce right when this study came out. And I took it quite literally to mean, aim for that solid middle class salary, but not the rat race. because it's not going to make me happier to be super rich.

**[0:10:22] Nick Fountain:** So many people are so focused on money. And maybe the idea that at least some aspect of our quality of life might not depend on that could be kind of liberating. I mean, so what if that person's on the yacht and, you know, I'm watching reruns of Frasier at home, but are they really having a better life than me? Maybe not.

**[0:10:42] Sally Helm:** Exactly. Over 75K, who cares? They're just miserable in the mansion. Um, when do you decide to take this study down?

**[0:10:53] Nick Fountain:** Well, I wouldn't quite say take it down. I mean, yeah, that really, really wasn't at least where I was trying to come from.

**[0:11:02] Sally Helm:** A couple of years ago, Matt Killingsworth found himself taking on the most important person who has ever existed, Danny Kahneman. And Matt truly, like, wasn't even trying to do this. His data almost did it for him.

**[0:11:18] Nick Fountain:** A big part of how I've approached my research is doing really large-scale, what's called experience sampling, which is basically the idea of, you know, rather than bringing people into the labs or, you know, sending them a paper survey to fill out, what if we could collect some data as people were going about their regular, everyday lives?

**[0:11:37] Sally Helm:** Experience sampling really is the gold standard for measuring moment-to-moment feelings. Over the years, scientists have found a number of ways to do it. They check in with people throughout the day using beepers and then palm pilots. Matt is in grad school in the late 2000s, and he launches a project called trackyourhappiness.org to do experience sampling with smartphones.

**[0:12:01] Nick Fountain:** So people get sort of pinged at random moments, and then I ask them a series of questions about their experience at the moment just before the ping.

**[0:12:09] Sally Helm:** Yeah, so imagine you're like doing laundry. You get a ping. How do you feel right now? You can answer on a spectrum that goes from very bad to very good. Move the little slider anywhere you want along that spectrum. So like, how happy am I doing laundry? I think maybe like a little bit over the midpoint in general. I kind of like doing laundry.

**[0:12:29] Nick Fountain:** Weird. Anyways. So what Matt's doing is not totally dissimilar from what Kahneman was looking at. Did you smile a lot yesterday? Et cetera, et cetera. Except Matt is looking at it right in the moment. Obviously, this is self-reported happiness, and there are ways that these self-reports might be messy. Maybe people are lying to you or lying to themselves. But Matt does ask a lot of people at all income levels, and he asks them over and over, which should help him separate out the signal from the noise.

**[0:13:00] Sally Helm:** And this was really the first big project of its kind. Matt has collected millions of data points from hundreds of thousands of people, and he's still going. The data points feed into this statistical software. They're updating all the time.

**[0:13:15] Nick Fountain:** I spend time almost every day looking at it. I mean, it feels a little bit like going in and like looking at the code in the matrix. It's like, here are all of these different variables from this gigantic number of people, and I kind of get to peek behind the curtain. One day, Matt realizes, wait a second, I'm collecting all this data about how people feel throughout their day. I also have income data. I wonder if when I look at my data, I will see Danny Kahneman's famous happiness plateau of around $75 ,000.

**[0:13:49] Nick Fountain:** And so at some point I looked in my data and saw, huh, it's actually, it doesn't look like that at all. There's no hint of a curve or a flattening or anything like that. It just keeps going up.

**[0:14:02] Sally Helm:** So you are finding there is not this happiness plateau at $75 ,000 that we've all been told about. It's not there.

**[0:14:09] Nick Fountain:** That's right.

**[0:14:10] Sally Helm:** Rich people are happier.

**[0:14:13] Nick Fountain:** That's right, to at least some degree.

**[0:14:15] Sally Helm:** More money, more happiness. Which is kind of a bummer, right? I mean, yeah, like Matt himself got into this happiness research in part because he felt like people focus on money too much. Like he wanted to broaden their horizons. But now he was finding higher income correlates with more happiness with no plateau. and he's feeling like a little bit of trepidation here. I mean, that plateau is so famous.

**[0:14:46] Nick Fountain:** I felt like I was pretty, I was totally confident, like statistically, this is what I'm seeing. There's no question. And I think the quality of the data is very, very high, but I'm not quite sure how this is going to go. If I start saying this is, what's Danny Kahneman going to think? What's the world going to think? I don't know. But at some point I just decided, you know, I'm seeing what I'm seeing. I'm going to just go ahead and say it and we'll see what happens.

**[0:15:10] Nick Fountain:** What happens when he publishes his paper in 2021 is that people are very interested. It really kind of happened in like an avalanche. So I, you know, because that previous finding had been so influential, people were then incredibly curious about this, you know, conflicting evidence that seemed to show something different. He's hearing from all sorts of people, but not from one particular person. Danny Kahneman. Matt spent him the one time, but it's not like they know each other.

**[0:15:44] Nick Fountain:** He'd never reach out.

**[0:15:45] Sally Helm:** And then one day, he hears through the psychology research grapevine that Danny has read the paper. And he wants to talk. That's after the break.

**[0:16:01] Speaker 5:** Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.

**[0:16:05] Sally Helm:** This message comes from University at Buffalo. where five decades of AI research is producing advancements that put people first, tackling real-world problems for progress, not profit. Empowering, not replacing. Learn how the University of Buffalo is using AI responsibly to create a better, brighter future for all at buffalo.edu.

**[0:16:27] Speaker 5:** This message comes from LinkedIn. Owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once. It's even harder to do it efficiently. But with LinkedIn, you get all the tools you need to grow in one place. With LinkedIn, simplify your sales, marketing, and hiring so that you can actually run your small business. Learn more at linkedin.com slash planetmoneyshow.

**[0:16:51] Sally Helm:** This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message. What if instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? No catching up on manual edits. No more guesswork. HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps your customer context current and helps you understand what to do next. So marketing builds more demand, sales wins more deals, and customers keep coming back. Learn more at HubSpot.com.

**[0:17:17] Nick Fountain:** All right. Across the campus at Matt's workplace, the University of Pennsylvania, a psychology professor picks up the telephone. Her name is Barb Mellors. And on the other end of the line is her good friend, Dani Kahneman. They're catching up.

**[0:17:33] Barb Mellors:** And he said, oh, by the way, do you happen to know a guy by the name of Matt Killingsworth? And I said, as a matter of fact, I do. And if you'd like me to introduce him to you, and if you'd like me to be an arbiter, I'd be happy to do that. So you knew what he was thinking? I knew exactly what he was thinking.

**[0:17:56] Sally Helm:** It seems he was not thinking, I want to take down that young Matt Killingsworth. I'm going to humiliate him in front of all his psychology heroes. No, no. Danny Kahneman wanted to collaborate. And he needed Barb's help.

**[0:18:12] Nick Fountain:** He wanted to do something he called an adversarial collaboration. Where researchers with scientific beefs try to figure out the truth. They agree to design a study and write a paper together.

**[0:18:24] Barb Mellors:** I think Danny just hated the common way of engaging in disputes, which is exchanges in journals where each side sort of caricatures the other. So he proposed an alternative method in which both sides jointly design an experiment that gets to the heart of the dispute.

**[0:18:47] Sally Helm:** Why is that? Is there an incentive to kind of caricature the other side in journals? Like, why does that happen?

**[0:18:54] Barb Mellors:** Oh, that's human nature. That's our natural, more base instinct, I think.

**[0:19:00] Nick Fountain:** But in this case, Danny does not want to attack Matt's research. He wants to do this adversarial collaboration thing, to work together to find the truth.

**[0:19:10] Sally Helm:** And he asks Barb to help set it up and serve as arbiter to mediate any disputes. So Barb reaches out to Matt, asks if he's game to meet. Matt says yes, of course. Their first conversation is on Zoom. And Matt told me there was a little bit of tension in the air.

**[0:19:28] Nick Fountain:** Danny was maybe not 100 % pleased. He was a little bit prickly, which was understandable.

**[0:19:36] Sally Helm:** But stressful, maybe.

**[0:19:37] Nick Fountain:** Yeah, on my side of the equation. I mean, you know, he's kind of at the pinnacle of influence and prestige. And, you know, having someone like that, even 1 % not happy with you, doesn't necessarily feel great. But at the same time, there's kind of part of me that's like, you know, I'm a scientist. I study data. Here's what I found. And that's what it is. So, you know. Right. And you'll know he will respect that.

**[0:20:02] Nick Fountain:** Like, that's what he's like, too.

**[0:20:03] Barb Mellors:** 100%. The question we were trying to answer was this. Barb Miller's again. Could there be a reality in which both Danny and Matt might be right? Suppose we start with the assumption that both of their data sets are valid and good. How could it happen? What do we have to know that would put the pieces together?

**[0:20:26] Nick Fountain:** Barb was like, look, everyone agrees that Matt's experienced sampling data is awesome.

**[0:20:31] Barb Mellors:** It's very good. Yeah, unusually good.

**[0:20:34] Sally Helm:** But Danny and Angus Deaton had really good data, too. Theirs came from the professional polling company Gallup, who called more than 450 ,000 people to ask them these questions. So it was a puzzle. Why did Danny find a plateau and Matt didn't?

**[0:20:51] Barb Mellors:** The graphs look totally different. And it's really a big question mark. How could these guys, both of whom have really great data sets, have such different findings?

**[0:21:04] Sally Helm:** They start trying together to imagine what they might be missing. And eventually, they realize there might be an alternate vision of reality here. one that actually aligns surprisingly well with both of their studies, if they just look at the data in a slightly new way.

**[0:21:25] Nick Fountain:** And to understand this, we're going to need to get a little bit nerdy about the two different kinds of data that Danny and Matt were working with. You ready? Sally, crack those knuckles.

**[0:21:33] Sally Helm:** Let us do it. Okay. So remember, Danny's 2010 study relied on people answering questions about their emotional well-being over the course of the previous day. It was essentially three questions. Did you smile or laugh a lot yesterday? Did you feel happiness a lot yesterday? How about enjoyment? And importantly, these were yes-no questions. So if you are the happiest person in the world, your answers will be yes, yes, and yes.

**[0:22:00] Nick Fountain:** And here is a key fact. In Dani's data, a lot of people were answering yes, yes, yes.

**[0:22:08] Barb Mellors:** On average, in the entire data set, the overall happiness measures were about 85%, meaning just about everyone was at the maximum of the happiness scale on that day they were measured. Okay, so that's a problem.

**[0:22:31] Sally Helm:** It's a problem because the happiest person in the world answers yes, yes, yes. But a lot of people who are less happy also answer yes, yes, yes. On average, in Danny's data, 85 % of people were answering yes, yes, yes.

**[0:22:47] Nick Fountain:** So Danny's happiness measure, it can't really distinguish between the happiest person in the world and someone who's just happy in a more normal, run-of-the-mill way. It's like people are maxing out the scale.

**[0:22:58] Sally Helm:** Yeah, because the only way they can describe their happiness is with these three yes-no questions. But if you gave them a bigger spectrum, they might be able to tell you more about just how happy they feel. And this is where we get to Matt's study. Remember, he had people report their happiness on a range that went from very good to very bad. You could put the little slider anywhere along that spectrum. And in Matt's data, very few people were putting it at the absolute maximum.

**[0:23:30] Sally Helm:** It was rare for someone to say, at this moment, I am feeling so good that I think I'm at the very top of this happiness scale.

**[0:23:37] Nick Fountain:** So there's almost always some room for it to be higher. And I measure over and over. So even if someone were, I'm just as happy as I could possibly score on this Tuesday in the afternoon, well, Wednesday morning, you're not going to be there. And I'm going to average all of those responses to say, on average, how happy does this person feel in everyday life? So I kind of had a much more sensitive measure of the variation.

**[0:23:59] Sally Helm:** And that could explain why Danny found a plateau and Matt didn't. Maybe the rich people in Danny's sample were happier. They just had no way to tell him that. All they could say was yes, yes, yes.

**[0:24:12] Nick Fountain:** But not everyone was saying yes, yes, yes. Something like 15 % of people were saying no, yes, yes, or no, no, no. Those were the people who did not smile or laugh a lot yesterday, who didn't feel enjoyment much yesterday. They're basically the sad people, or at least the people who were feeling sad yesterday.

**[0:24:32] Sally Helm:** So Danny's data couldn't see the whole range of happiness. But it could see the sadness. In fact, another way to say it is that Danny wasn't actually measuring happiness. He was measuring unhappiness. He had basically given the variable the wrong name.

**[0:24:53] Barb Mellors:** You know, it's an error. It's a mistake. And he had to sort of gulp and deal with that.

**[0:25:04] Sally Helm:** They had found this big error. And they could have just stopped right there. Case closed. End of story. But they did not.

**[0:25:12] Nick Fountain:** No, because this wasn't a takedown. It was a collaboration. And now that they understood Danny's mistake, they went back to the data sets to search through them again and see if there was any more insight they could mine. And what they found was so rad.

**[0:25:29] Sally Helm:** Yeah. Okay. So remember, the key realization was that Danny was really talking not about happiness, but about unhappiness. And there were unhappy people in Matt's sample, too. People who put the slider low, who said, I feel very bad right now.

**[0:25:45] Barb Mellors:** So we thought, well, maybe we could see that flattening if we looked at the least happy group.

**[0:25:55] Nick Fountain:** Yeah. If they zoom in on the unhappiest 15 to 20% of people in Matt's sample, people at all income levels who said they felt bad, would they see a different relationship between money and happiness? Was it possible that for that unhappy group, at a certain point, money stopped mattering? In other words, would they find that plateau?

**[0:26:17] Barb Mellors:** And that's what we did. And that's what we found.

**[0:26:21] Sally Helm:** They found Danny's plateau, hiding in Matt's data, but only for the unhappiest 15 to 20%. In that group, people who made the least money reported the least happiness. People who made more said they were happier, but only up to about $100 ,000 a year. If you account for inflation, that is basically what Danny found all those years ago.

**[0:26:46] Barb Mellors:** Oh, it was so beautiful. It just, I remember this feeling of awe and just the pleasure of doing science. You know, there's just a delight that you feel when things come together in a way that you haven't expected.

**[0:27:04] Sally Helm:** So this result, remember, it doesn't show anything about the causes of any of this. But it's like maybe money can kind of mitigate unhappiness up to a point. And after that point, maybe you're just a person dealing with one of the many problems that money can't fix. Heartbreak, depression, grief.

**[0:27:24] Nick Fountain:** All right. So mystery solved. Plateau identified. But it turned out there was another surprise lurking in Matt's data. Something that none of them had predicted.

**[0:27:35] Barb Mellors:** For the happiest people, those at the top 15%, what you find is that at that point, happiness goes up really fast.

**[0:27:46] Sally Helm:** For the very happiest group, there is actually an accelerating relationship. More money correlates with more and more happiness. Again, it's not clear why, but maybe these are people who just like know how to spend money really well on things that make them happy. So, for the unhappy group, there was the plateau. And for the happiest group, there was like the opposite of a plateau. Do you think that they were both sort of right or both sort of wrong?

**[0:28:18] Barb Mellors:** Is the glass half empty or half full? Yes, is the answer.

**[0:28:25] Sally Helm:** Barb definitely thinks the collaborative study added to what both of these researchers did on their own.

**[0:28:31] Nick Fountain:** And that is important. Psychology has been in the midst of what's been called the replication crisis. A lot of the results that one paper found, they don't replicate when another paper looks at the exact same thing. Economics has this problem, too. And maybe adversarial collaboration could help people get closer to the truth of the matter.

**[0:28:50] Sally Helm:** Yeah, you know, in a way, it's easier to tear down someone else's study to be like, your data is bogus, my data is awesome. And of course, some studies do deserve to be torn to shreds. But in this case, realizing that everyone had actually done a good job, that raised harder and more interesting questions and meant they learned something that they hadn't expected.

**[0:29:12] Nick Fountain:** They also did confirm that, on average, getting more money does at least correlate with more happiness, which is an important thing to know because we all make decisions about how much to pursue or value money in our lives. And if there is a takeaway from Matt Killingsworth's research, it's about this. How to weigh those tradeoffs. If you're at some critical juncture in your life, especially, you know, maybe thinking about someone in college and they're kind of like, well, I could major in art history or I could major in electrical engineering and I'm kind of, you know, 50-50 on both of them.

**[0:29:48] Nick Fountain:** Well, there might be some reasons to think about the engineering.

**[0:29:51] Sally Helm:** I feel like you're saying but not saying, yeah, you can follow the money. Like if you're 50-50 on art history and electrical engineering to think, well, I'll make a lot more money as an electrical engineer. Maybe I should do that. It might make me happier. Yep. Why are you saying it but not saying it, Matt? What makes you hesitate to say it?

**[0:30:14] Nick Fountain:** I think there's just a risk of feeling like that should overwhelm your other considerations. And I think, you know, that's just a personal decision people have to grapple with. Yeah, Matt said the effect of money on happiness is pretty small, actually. There are really lots of things that affect our emotional well-being. Social connections and exercise and living in the moment. And none of them really dominates over the others. You just have to find your own balance.

**[0:30:41] Sally Helm:** And that's actually what Matt did himself. Before he was a psychology researcher, he studied engineering, worked in tech. Staying on that path would have probably meant more money. But he felt drawn to these big questions about what makes life worth living. And he decided to follow those instead.

**[0:31:06] Nick Fountain:** Today's show was produced by Sean Saldana with help from Sam Yellowhorse Kesler and Emma Peaslee. It was edited by Meg Cramer. Engineering by Cena Loffredo. Fact-checking by Sierra Juarez. Alex Goldmark is our executive producer. I'm Nick Fountain.

**[0:31:21] Sally Helm:** And I'm Sally Helm. This is NPR. Thanks for listening. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
