In brief
The scratch-off lottery ticket, now a giant consumer product, only exists because one mathematician proved a rival instant ticket could be hacked. Massachusetts, a state that was cautious about gambling, became the first to sell scratch tickets in 1974. The episode argues that this one product turned legal gambling from a slow, boring state activity into the instant-reward habit that now shapes American gambling.
The central tension is trust versus novelty. States feared the mob and any whiff of fraud, so they rejected instant tickets until Massachusetts, led by a mathematician, took a chance. John Koza's security math, proven by a dramatic hack of a rival ticket, won the contract. The result was a huge hit, and the host leaves unsure whether Massachusetts should be proud of it.
Questions
Why do people in Massachusetts spend so much more on the lottery than people in other states?
Adults in Massachusetts spend about $1,037 a year on lottery tickets, far above New York or Michigan at roughly $500 to $600. The hosts say part of the reason is that the scratch ticket began there, in 1974.
Who invented the scratch-off lottery ticket and how did he come up with it?
John Koza, a computer science PhD student, helped a Chicago company design supermarket giveaway games with rub-off film and a very large number of ticket patterns. After the company went bankrupt in 1972, he started Scientific Games and brought that design to state lotteries.
Why were state governments afraid of instant lottery tickets at first?
Gambling in the 1970s was linked to the mob, so states were obsessed with security and credibility. They worried that a convenience-store clerk could spot winning tickets and hand them out, which would ruin trust in the lottery.
How did Koza prove the rival Massachusetts ticket could be hacked?
He showed three ways in: a cystoscope (a thin medical camera) to peek under the flaps, a photocopier that picked up the dents left by printing, and Fresca, which loosened the glue so a ticket could be opened and resealed. The state then cancelled that contract.
Are scratch tickets a big business compared to other lottery games like Powerball?
Yes. Ian Coss says Americans spend over $100 billion a year on lotteries and almost two-thirds of that goes to scratch tickets, even though Powerball jackpots get more press.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Massachusetts sells about $1,037 of lottery tickets per adult each year, the highest of any U.S. state according to Census Bureau figures cited in the episode.
“That's $1 ,037 of lottery tickets per adult sold every year in the state of Massachusetts.”
0:02:36 · Ian Coss · Lottery spending
Ian Coss says Americans spend more on scratch tickets than on pizza or on all Coca-Cola products.
“Americans now spend more on scratch tickets than we do on pizza, more than we do on all Coca-Cola products.”
0:04:18 · Ian Coss · Scratch ticket spending
John Koza published a board game about the Electoral College while a graduate student at the University of Michigan in the late 1960s.
“When I was a graduate student at University of Michigan in the late 60s, I had published a board game involving the Electoral College.”
0:06:24 · Speaker 3 · Koza's background · 1960s
In the 1960s supermarkets and gas stations gave away rub-off games for free with small prizes, which Kenny Malone describes as proto-scratch tickets.
“Stores would give them out for free as a little treat to customers and the prizes were fairly small.”
0:07:08 · Kenny Malone · Giveaway games · 1960s
John Koza and the game company developed a printing system that produced half a million different ticket patterns.
“We came up with a system of printing that produced a half million different patterns, which was an extraordinarily large number.”
0:08:37 · Speaker 3 · Ticket security
The game company J&H went bankrupt and let John Koza go in December 1972.
“J &H, went bankrupt. In December of 1972, they cut John loose.”
0:09:49 · Ian Coss · J&H bankruptcy · 1972
In 1972 only seven U.S. states operated lotteries, generally with weekly drawings at best.
“So at that time, 1972, there were just seven states operating lotteries.”
0:10:57 · Ian Coss · State lotteries · 1972
Ian Coss says early state lotteries were run by former FBI agents because of concern about organized crime.
“States were so concerned about organized crime that they didn't hire people who designed games for a living to run these lotteries. They got former FBI agents.”
0:12:44 · Ian Coss · Lottery staffing · 1970s
Ted Harrington, head of the Boston-based organized crime strike force, helped develop mafia informant Vincent Teresa.
“And Ted helped to develop a key mafia informant right there in Boston named Vincent Teresa”
0:13:33 · Ian Coss · Organized crime · 1970s
Illegal numbers rackets stayed popular because they offered daily action and untaxed winnings that state lotteries lacked.
“Yeah, the illegal numbers rackets were still popular because the illegal games could offer their customers things the state lottery couldn't. Daily action. Winnings with no worries of taxes.”
0:15:51 · Ian Coss · Numbers rackets · 1970s
John Koza and Dan Bauer founded Scientific Games after Koza was laid off.
“So after John was laid off, he and another jobless colleague, Dan Bauer, decided to start their own company, Scientific Games.”
0:17:18 · Ian Coss · Scientific Games · 1973
John Koza says the Massachusetts lottery director, called Dr. Peralt in the episode, held a PhD in mathematics.
“The director there was a Ph.D. in mathematics, so he happened to really understand the scientific basis for what we were doing.”
0:17:55 · Speaker 3 · Lottery director · 1973
Massachusetts lottery officials let John Koza take 50 of a rival company's tickets home to try to hack them.
“John was allowed to take home 50 of these new tickets and do his best to prove they could be hacked.”
0:19:47 · Ian Coss · Ticket hacking test · 1973
About 25 million of the rival company's instant tickets were already printed and stored when Koza showed they could be hacked.
“tickets were already printed and in the warehouse ready to be issued. And there were 25 million of them.”
0:22:57 · Speaker 3 · Rival tickets · 1973
One of the three weaknesses John Koza demonstrated involved using a cystoscope, a medical device, to look under the ticket flaps.
“One of them involved a cystoscope, which is a medical device.”
0:23:18 · Speaker 3 · Ticket hack · 1973
The rival tickets could be run through a photocopier, which revealed the hidden numbers because the printer left raised impressions in the paper.
“So method number two was that if you ran the tickets through a photocopier, that raised impression from the printer was just prominent enough that the hidden numbers would come out in the copy.”
0:23:52 · Ian Coss · Ticket hack · 1973
John Koza poured Fresca on a rival ticket to dissolve its glue, letting the ticket be opened and resealed.
“He poured the fresca on the ticket, and the glue, which was supposed to be the ticket's sacred seal, it simply let go.”
0:24:04 · Kenny Malone · Fresca demonstration · 1973
After Koza's demonstration, the Massachusetts lottery cancelled its existing instant-ticket contract and opened a new bid, which Scientific Games won.
“The lottery canceled their existing contract and put out a new bid.”
0:25:29 · Kenny Malone · Contract · 1973
The first scratch ticket went on sale in Massachusetts on May 29, 1974.
“On May 29th, 1974, just over 50 years ago, people walked into convenience stores and gas stations around the state and saw that ticket.”
0:25:48 · Ian Coss · Scratch ticket launch · 1974
John Koza says he projected $6 million in first-year sales, a bank forced him to cut the figure to $1 million, and actual first-year sales were $6 million.
“So we cut it back to a million. And the first year sales was $6 million.”
0:26:27 · Speaker 3 · First-year sales · 1974
John Koza recalls that five or six other state lotteries began instant games in 1975.
“the other lotteries in 75, I think it was five or six other state lotteries simultaneously”
0:26:27 · Speaker 3 · Spread to other states · 1975
Americans spend over $100 billion a year on lottery tickets, almost two-thirds of it on scratch tickets.
“Today, Americans spend over $100 billion a year on lottery tickets. Almost two-thirds of that total is spent just on scratch tickets.”
0:27:12 · Ian Coss · Lottery market
Kenny Malone says Americans spend more on scratch tickets than on movie, concert and sports tickets combined.
“We now spend more on scratch tickets than we do on movie tickets, on concert tickets, on sports tickets combined.”
0:27:46 · Kenny Malone · Scratch ticket spending
Scratch & Win, the GBH series hosted by Ian Coss, has eight parts and the episode played is roughly the first.
“just go look for Scratch and Win to listen to the entire eight part series.”
0:30:36 · Kenny Malone · Scratch & Win