OpenNashPodcasts

Planet Money

How the scratch off lottery changed America

5 Feb 2025 · 29m · Kenny Malone, Ian Coss · 24 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

The scratch-off lottery ticket, now a giant consumer product, only exists because one mathematician proved a rival instant ticket could be hacked. Massachusetts, a state that was cautious about gambling, became the first to sell scratch tickets in 1974. The episode argues that this one product turned legal gambling from a slow, boring state activity into the instant-reward habit that now shapes American gambling.

The central tension is trust versus novelty. States feared the mob and any whiff of fraud, so they rejected instant tickets until Massachusetts, led by a mathematician, took a chance. John Koza's security math, proven by a dramatic hack of a rival ticket, won the contract. The result was a huge hit, and the host leaves unsure whether Massachusetts should be proud of it.

Key insights

  1. Security math, not marketing, won the first contract

    John Koza's printing system created about half a million ticket patterns, and he spent years learning how players cheated on supermarket games. That experience let him prove a rival ticket was hackable, which won his firm the Massachusetts deal.

  2. States distrusted instant tickets because of the mob

    In the early 1970s gambling was tied to organized crime, so lotteries hired former FBI agents and feared any fraud. A single forged or fixed ticket could have destroyed public trust in the whole lottery.

  3. Illegal games forced lotteries to innovate

    Numbers rackets offered daily action, no taxes, better payouts and betting on credit, so boring weekly state drawings lost out. Koza's instant ticket gave states something the mob could not match.

  4. A cheap soda exposed an expensive printing mistake

    The rival tickets used thin paper and glue, and Koza showed that Fresca dissolved the glue so numbers could be read and the ticket resealed. About 25 million were already printed, and the state cancelled the contract.

  5. Scratch tickets became the lottery's financial backbone

    Massachusetts sold $6 million in the first year, against Koza's own projection that the bank had cut to $1 million. Today scratch tickets make up almost two-thirds of the $100 billion Americans spend on lotteries yearly.

Questions

Why do people in Massachusetts spend so much more on the lottery than people in other states?

Adults in Massachusetts spend about $1,037 a year on lottery tickets, far above New York or Michigan at roughly $500 to $600. The hosts say part of the reason is that the scratch ticket began there, in 1974.

Who invented the scratch-off lottery ticket and how did he come up with it?

John Koza, a computer science PhD student, helped a Chicago company design supermarket giveaway games with rub-off film and a very large number of ticket patterns. After the company went bankrupt in 1972, he started Scientific Games and brought that design to state lotteries.

Why were state governments afraid of instant lottery tickets at first?

Gambling in the 1970s was linked to the mob, so states were obsessed with security and credibility. They worried that a convenience-store clerk could spot winning tickets and hand them out, which would ruin trust in the lottery.

How did Koza prove the rival Massachusetts ticket could be hacked?

He showed three ways in: a cystoscope (a thin medical camera) to peek under the flaps, a photocopier that picked up the dents left by printing, and Fresca, which loosened the glue so a ticket could be opened and resealed. The state then cancelled that contract.

Are scratch tickets a big business compared to other lottery games like Powerball?

Yes. Ian Coss says Americans spend over $100 billion a year on lotteries and almost two-thirds of that goes to scratch tickets, even though Powerball jackpots get more press.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Massachusetts sells about $1,037 of lottery tickets per adult each year, the highest of any U.S. state according to Census Bureau figures cited in the episode.

“That's $1 ,037 of lottery tickets per adult sold every year in the state of Massachusetts.”

0:02:36 · Ian Coss · Lottery spending

Ian Coss says Americans spend more on scratch tickets than on pizza or on all Coca-Cola products.

“Americans now spend more on scratch tickets than we do on pizza, more than we do on all Coca-Cola products.”

0:04:18 · Ian Coss · Scratch ticket spending

John Koza published a board game about the Electoral College while a graduate student at the University of Michigan in the late 1960s.

“When I was a graduate student at University of Michigan in the late 60s, I had published a board game involving the Electoral College.”

0:06:24 · Speaker 3 · Koza's background · 1960s

In the 1960s supermarkets and gas stations gave away rub-off games for free with small prizes, which Kenny Malone describes as proto-scratch tickets.

“Stores would give them out for free as a little treat to customers and the prizes were fairly small.”

0:07:08 · Kenny Malone · Giveaway games · 1960s

John Koza and the game company developed a printing system that produced half a million different ticket patterns.

“We came up with a system of printing that produced a half million different patterns, which was an extraordinarily large number.”

0:08:37 · Speaker 3 · Ticket security

The game company J&H went bankrupt and let John Koza go in December 1972.

“J &H, went bankrupt. In December of 1972, they cut John loose.”

0:09:49 · Ian Coss · J&H bankruptcy · 1972

In 1972 only seven U.S. states operated lotteries, generally with weekly drawings at best.

“So at that time, 1972, there were just seven states operating lotteries.”

0:10:57 · Ian Coss · State lotteries · 1972

Ian Coss says early state lotteries were run by former FBI agents because of concern about organized crime.

“States were so concerned about organized crime that they didn't hire people who designed games for a living to run these lotteries. They got former FBI agents.”

0:12:44 · Ian Coss · Lottery staffing · 1970s

Ted Harrington, head of the Boston-based organized crime strike force, helped develop mafia informant Vincent Teresa.

“And Ted helped to develop a key mafia informant right there in Boston named Vincent Teresa”

0:13:33 · Ian Coss · Organized crime · 1970s

Illegal numbers rackets stayed popular because they offered daily action and untaxed winnings that state lotteries lacked.

“Yeah, the illegal numbers rackets were still popular because the illegal games could offer their customers things the state lottery couldn't. Daily action. Winnings with no worries of taxes.”

0:15:51 · Ian Coss · Numbers rackets · 1970s

John Koza and Dan Bauer founded Scientific Games after Koza was laid off.

“So after John was laid off, he and another jobless colleague, Dan Bauer, decided to start their own company, Scientific Games.”

0:17:18 · Ian Coss · Scientific Games · 1973

John Koza says the Massachusetts lottery director, called Dr. Peralt in the episode, held a PhD in mathematics.

“The director there was a Ph.D. in mathematics, so he happened to really understand the scientific basis for what we were doing.”

0:17:55 · Speaker 3 · Lottery director · 1973

Massachusetts lottery officials let John Koza take 50 of a rival company's tickets home to try to hack them.

“John was allowed to take home 50 of these new tickets and do his best to prove they could be hacked.”

0:19:47 · Ian Coss · Ticket hacking test · 1973

About 25 million of the rival company's instant tickets were already printed and stored when Koza showed they could be hacked.

“tickets were already printed and in the warehouse ready to be issued. And there were 25 million of them.”

0:22:57 · Speaker 3 · Rival tickets · 1973

One of the three weaknesses John Koza demonstrated involved using a cystoscope, a medical device, to look under the ticket flaps.

“One of them involved a cystoscope, which is a medical device.”

0:23:18 · Speaker 3 · Ticket hack · 1973

The rival tickets could be run through a photocopier, which revealed the hidden numbers because the printer left raised impressions in the paper.

“So method number two was that if you ran the tickets through a photocopier, that raised impression from the printer was just prominent enough that the hidden numbers would come out in the copy.”

0:23:52 · Ian Coss · Ticket hack · 1973

John Koza poured Fresca on a rival ticket to dissolve its glue, letting the ticket be opened and resealed.

“He poured the fresca on the ticket, and the glue, which was supposed to be the ticket's sacred seal, it simply let go.”

0:24:04 · Kenny Malone · Fresca demonstration · 1973

After Koza's demonstration, the Massachusetts lottery cancelled its existing instant-ticket contract and opened a new bid, which Scientific Games won.

“The lottery canceled their existing contract and put out a new bid.”

0:25:29 · Kenny Malone · Contract · 1973

The first scratch ticket went on sale in Massachusetts on May 29, 1974.

“On May 29th, 1974, just over 50 years ago, people walked into convenience stores and gas stations around the state and saw that ticket.”

0:25:48 · Ian Coss · Scratch ticket launch · 1974

John Koza says he projected $6 million in first-year sales, a bank forced him to cut the figure to $1 million, and actual first-year sales were $6 million.

“So we cut it back to a million. And the first year sales was $6 million.”

0:26:27 · Speaker 3 · First-year sales · 1974

John Koza recalls that five or six other state lotteries began instant games in 1975.

“the other lotteries in 75, I think it was five or six other state lotteries simultaneously”

0:26:27 · Speaker 3 · Spread to other states · 1975

Americans spend over $100 billion a year on lottery tickets, almost two-thirds of it on scratch tickets.

“Today, Americans spend over $100 billion a year on lottery tickets. Almost two-thirds of that total is spent just on scratch tickets.”

0:27:12 · Ian Coss · Lottery market

Kenny Malone says Americans spend more on scratch tickets than on movie, concert and sports tickets combined.

“We now spend more on scratch tickets than we do on movie tickets, on concert tickets, on sports tickets combined.”

0:27:46 · Kenny Malone · Scratch ticket spending

Scratch & Win, the GBH series hosted by Ian Coss, has eight parts and the episode played is roughly the first.

“just go look for Scratch and Win to listen to the entire eight part series.”

0:30:36 · Kenny Malone · Scratch & Win

Chapters

  1. 0:01:16The $50-a-day scratch ticket player at Joe's Market

    A mechanic in Quincy shows what heavy scratch-ticket play looks like in the state with the highest lottery spending per adult.

    “I'm dreaming to get the big one so I can retire.”
  2. 0:08:37John Koza and the secure supermarket game tickets

    A failed board game led Koza to a Chicago game company, where he built a printing system with enormous numbers of ticket patterns.

    “a system of printing that produced a half million different patterns”
  3. 0:12:17Why states feared instant lotteries

    Association between gambling and organized crime made state officials cautious, which is why Koza's early pitches failed.

    “gambling in the 70s was largely associated with the underworld, the mob”
  4. 0:14:52Vincent Teresa and the war on illegal gambling

    A mob informant's Senate testimony shaped the idea that gambling funded organized crime, and the illegal games still beat the state lottery on service.

    “Without gambling, they got nothing.”
  5. 0:18:57A mathematician-run lottery and a rival contract

    Massachusetts was ready to listen, but another company's paper-flap tickets were already printed and in the warehouse.

    “They had already given a contract for the instant game to another company.”
  6. 0:24:04Hacking the rival tickets with a can of Fresca

    Koza's demonstration exposed three weaknesses and convinced the state to cancel its contract.

    “John opened a bottle of Fresca, something you certainly could find in the”
  7. 0:25:48The first scratch ticket launches in 1974

    The new ticket sold out fast, beat sales forecasts, and prompted other states to copy within a year.

    “On May 29th, 1974, just over 50 years ago”
  8. 0:29:41How scratch tickets shaped modern gambling

    The host argues that the instant ticket moved gambling from the margins into a pervasive industry.

    “It's this ubiquitous, incredibly aggressive industry.”

Transcript

0:00:00
Speaker 5

This message comes from Edward Jones, where they believe rich means opening yourself to new possibilities. That's why your dedicated financial advisor meets you where you are, helping you move forward with confidence. Let's find your rich. Edward Jones, member SIPC.

0:00:18
Kenny Malone

This is Planet Money from NPR. Joe's Market in Quincy is one of the biggest lottery retailers in Massachusetts. It's got all your convenience store staples, but the area behind the counter is dominated by scratch tickets. At least 50 different clear plastic boxes, all numbered and all dangling these colorful tickets. Could I ask you a few questions for the podcast?

0:00:46
Ian Coss

So what are you playing right now?

0:00:48
Speaker 3

I play $50 every day.

0:00:51
Ian Coss

Have you won yet?

0:00:51
Speaker 3

Yeah. So far I've spent $300 on the bucket, there's nothing.

0:00:55
Ian Coss

What this man is playing is the state's brand new $50 scratch ticket. He points at the serial number on the top right corner to show he's keeping track.

0:01:05
Kenny Malone

This is ticket number seven for today. The other six are in the trash bucket already. Six $50 tickets.

0:01:12
Speaker 3

Keep going until I'm broke.

0:01:14
Kenny Malone

So why do you keep playing?

0:01:16
Speaker 3

I'm dreaming to get the big one so I can retire. I'm 75 years old. I don't have money in retirement. Too late to start now because I already spent so much money.

0:01:28
Ian Coss

So maybe this one, but end up getting broke and broke. This man is happy to talk money. A couple times he opens up his wallet and shows me exactly how much he has left, how much he's spent. But he doesn't want to say much about himself, including his name.

0:01:45
Kenny Malone

We know that he lives nearby, that he works as a mechanic, which fits with the dark blue work pants and black t-shirt. He comes here on his lunch break, part of his daily routine.

0:01:54
Speaker 3

Yesterday I had 1 ,500. Count that. Only about 900 left. 600 already out. If the wife find out, you're dead. Done.

0:02:07
Ian Coss

The U.S. Census Bureau collects lottery sales figures for every state. And you can see right away there are some stragglers on the low end, like Wyoming, North Dakota, where the average adult spends around $50 a year on the lottery.

0:02:21
Kenny Malone

Then there are a lot of states in the middle, California, Texas, Illinois, all in about the $300 range. Towards the top, you've got New York, Michigan, Georgia. They're all around $500 or $600 per adult per year.

0:02:36
Ian Coss

But then there is the lone outlier, way off the charts at $1 ,037. That's $1 ,037 of lottery tickets per adult sold every year in the state of Massachusetts. That is the reason I'm here at Joe's Market, to try and understand that number. You got a winner.

0:02:58
Speaker 3

No, 100. O-H-N.

0:02:59
Kenny Malone

On his next $50 ticket, number eight for the day, our anonymous mechanic catches a break. He wins $100. So what are you going to do with that $100?

0:03:08
Ian Coss

I'm going to buy number two. All right? That $100 he won turns into another round of tickets. Then another round. Not a loser. Then one last round. I'm going to buy one more and that's it. This time, it sticks. That's it. I'm done.

0:03:26
Speaker 3

All right.

0:03:27
Ian Coss

Back to work. I try to ask his name one more time as he opens the door, and he responds, Jack. Jack. Jack. Thank you, Jack, for talking to me. What? Which I know is not his name. It's the name of the store clerk. Everyone turns to look.

0:03:42
Kenny Malone

I am the Jack. Everybody's Jack.

0:03:46
Ian Coss

Everybody's Jack, someone says. And with that, the man is gone.

0:03:55
Kenny Malone

Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Kenny Malone. And I'm Ian Coss. And Ian, you are here today as the host of a special series from NPR member station, GBH in Boston. That series is called Scratch and Win. It chronicles the history of lotteries in America. and Ian, you have brought us part of that series today, yes.

0:04:18
Ian Coss

Yeah, specifically, we're talking about the birth of the scratch ticket, which more than any other lottery game, totally transformed the way we gamble. Kenny, get this. Americans now spend more on scratch tickets than we do on pizza, more than we do on all Coca-Cola products. Yet the scratch ticket, as a consumer item, has only existed for 50 years. And it all started in Massachusetts.

0:04:43
Kenny Malone

Today on the show, the unlikely story of how Massachusetts became the lottery capital of America. It's a tale of high-level mathematics, organized crime, and perhaps the single most important use of a can of Fresca in American history.

0:05:02
Speaker 5

Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from the UPS Store. The UPS Store is open this holiday to help make sure your small business can stay at its best. During the holiday, customers have access to professional printing, packing and shipping, shredding, mailbox services, notarizing services, and everything else your small business could need. Find nearby locations and keep tackling important tasks at the upsstore.com. Most locations are independently owned. Products, services, pricing, and hours of operation may vary.

0:05:34

See Center for details.

0:05:35
Speaker 4

This message comes from Open Door. with Cash Now, More Later. Get cash up front for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now and move on your own timeline. Cash Now, More Later. Now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com slash NPR. Profits calculated after fees and costs. Eligibility and offer price may vary. This message comes from Capital One. Capital One offers checking accounts with no fees or minimums.

0:06:07

What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash Bank Guy for details. Capital One N.A. Member FDIC.

0:06:15
Kenny Malone

The story of scratch-off lottery tickets begins with an apparently not very good board game.

0:06:24
Speaker 3

When I was a graduate student at University of Michigan in the late 60s, I had published a board game involving the Electoral College.

0:06:34
Ian Coss

This is John Koza.

0:06:35
Speaker 3

Which, by the way, was a commercial failure and way too complicated.

0:06:40
Ian Coss

So back in the 1960s, John was in grad school studying computer science. The board game was won in a string of side hustles and pet projects.

0:06:50
Speaker 3

In any case, an executive of this game company in Chicago, this was a company that made supermarket and gas station giveaway games, read an article about this game that I had produced. and he thought it might be relevant to his company's business.

0:07:08
Kenny Malone

So this company's business, the supermarket games, these were popular in the 1960s. Stores would give them out for free as a little treat to customers and the prizes were fairly small. We're talking like as small as half a penny. But these games did use a kind of rub-off film. What the company was making was, in effect, proto-scratch tickets.

0:07:30
Speaker 3

And we got to talking and it turned out that they were trying to produce a kind of game where every ticket could be a winner.

0:07:38
Kenny Malone

Yeah. So the way this particular game worked was there were 10 scratch off spots on the game ticket and each revealed a playing card, you know, like ace, king, queen, jack. So you scratch off three spots. If those match, you win. Again, mostly just small prizes like pennies.

0:07:57
Ian Coss

The catch was that if the company printed all the game tickets exactly the same, people would notice the pattern and just keep winning. So what this company needed help with from John was a way to make many, many different versions of this ticket, all different, so that people couldn't just know where the matching cards were.

0:08:17
Speaker 3

They were looking for somebody who knew something about probability and combinatorics and finite mathematics, which, as it happened, was something I was very much involved in as a student.

0:08:31
Kenny Malone

So, while still chipping away at his PhD, John started to work with this game company.

0:08:37
Speaker 3

We came up with a system of printing that produced a half million different patterns, which was an extraordinarily large number. And that was enough to provide security for the games. At least security in theory. Probably in about half the games we ran, there would be sort of a little run of tickets in a little town. And you'd realize that somebody in that town figured out some weakness in the game that we had missed.

0:09:06
Ian Coss

For example, a player might notice some subtle but distinct pattern in the layout of the tickets and be able to predict where the matching cards were. Or maybe they'd figure out a way to actually see what was printed underneath that scratch-off film.

0:09:20
Speaker 3

And of course, we would fix it for the next game. So we never had a big problem, but it was a knife-edge process.

0:09:28
Kenny Malone

Still, you know, like having a chance to encounter those weaknesses, those vulnerabilities in a low-stakes environment, it was kind of giving John the chance to beta test a method and work out all the bugs.

0:09:42
Speaker 3

We had perfected a system that could produce a very, very secure ticket.

0:09:49
Ian Coss

Unpredictable and unhackable. A perfect game of chance with the odds calibrated exactly how the company wanted. And just when it seemed like they had it all figured out, this game company John was working for, J &H, went bankrupt. In December of 1972, they cut John loose.

0:10:07
Speaker 3

Which, coincidentally, was exactly the month when I graduated and got my Ph.D.

0:10:14
Ian Coss

So now you're a newly minted Ph.D., unemployed, with years of experience in the nascent instant ticket business. What do you do with all that?

0:10:25
Speaker 3

Well, again, a lucky coincidence. In the last year of J &H's existence, we actually made some sales calls on state lotteries trying to see if they would like to run a game like this.

0:10:39
Kenny Malone

Yeah, so the idea was to take this ticket design that John had perfected in the form of a fun promotional gimmick and bring it into the big leagues of actual gambling. Like, instead of pennies, the ticket could offer up thousands of dollars, if, that is, they could find a state willing to try this.

0:10:57
Ian Coss

So at that time, 1972, there were just seven states operating lotteries. And to be clear, these were generally, at best, weekly drawings. There weren't like ping pong balls and giant fish bowls on television every night. It was not that.

0:11:12
Kenny Malone

It was not the Pennsylvania lottery. Seared in your mind. Oh, for the rest of my life, that jingle will exist. Anyway, yes. In other words, the lottery was boring and slow, notably slow. You buy a ticket, you wait, which is definitely not like, I don't know, a slot machine where you pay and then you play and you get the adrenaline rush of finding out right away.

0:11:35
Ian Coss

The scratch ticket promised to change all that. It was an instant lottery in your hands.

0:11:41
Kenny Malone

In fact, that was John's pitch, like instant gratification, excitement. That was the lottery of the future. And when states heard that pitch, well, it apparently did not work, actually, did not land.

0:11:54
Speaker 3

State government bureaucracies are not usually known for being too innovative too quickly. And since it was a state government operation, they were super concerned with security and credibility and integrity.

0:12:08
Kenny Malone

Right. Credibility and integrity over innovation because of organized crime.

0:12:17
Ian Coss

I mean, it's hard to imagine passing on the instant ticket now, but gambling in the 70s was largely associated with the underworld, the mob. So these state-run lotteries were very, very conservative.

0:12:30
Kenny Malone

Yeah, lotteries, gambling, was a shadowy business that states were wading into cautiously. And any whiff of irregularity, a fixed drawing, a forged ticket, it would shatter the public's trust.

0:12:44
Ian Coss

States were so concerned about organized crime that they didn't hire people who designed games for a living to run these lotteries. They got former FBI agents.

0:12:54
Kenny Malone

So, yeah, organized crime may have been in the back of states' minds when they were not interested in John's flashy new lottery scratchers. However, ironically, the mob might also be the reason that Massachusetts decided to be less conservative about their lottery. Which brings us to the tale of Fat Vinny the Stool Pigeon.

0:13:19
Ian Coss

It's the early 1970s. The head of the organized crime strike force based out of Boston was a man named Ted Harrington.

0:13:27
Speaker 3

I took over the strike force sometime in 69 or 70.

0:13:33
Ian Coss

And Ted helped to develop a key mafia informant right there in Boston named Vincent Teresa, known to his critics as, you guessed it, Fat Vinny the Stool Pigeon. The two would meet secretly in guarded motel rooms around the state.

0:13:48
Speaker 3

He was a big, big burly guy, and he knew a lot of people. I remember that.

0:13:56
Ian Coss

Was he a little intimidating?

0:13:59
Speaker 3

No, he was a different type of gangsters, at least in my judgment. There's the killer or there's the con man. Vinny was the con man.

0:14:16
Kenny Malone

And Vinny was also the informant, of course. And as an informant, Mr. The Stool Pigeon testified in court lots of times. And perhaps most notably for our story, he also testified in front of a United States Senate hearing about organized crime.

0:14:35
Speaker 3

When you speak of the mob, when you speak of that...

0:14:39
Ian Coss

So here we've got Vincent Teresa sitting in front of federal lawmakers, slick suit, TV cameras rolling. And he says this organized crime stuff, it all boils down to one thing.

0:14:52
Speaker 3

I'm talking about a definite syndicate operation that strictly starts with gambling. It all starts with gambling. All starts with gambling. Without gambling, they got nothing.

0:15:04
Ian Coss

Did his testimony inform your thinking?

0:15:07
Speaker 3

Well, of course, it shaped everybody's conception of organized crime.

0:15:14
Ian Coss

Vinnie once described gambling as, quote, a chain-link fence that stretches to every place in the world. From it comes the corrupt politician and policeman, the bribes and payoffs, and sometimes murder. If you could crush gambling, you would put the mob out of business.

0:15:32
Kenny Malone

In fact, part of the reason state lotteries were popping up in the first place was to do just that, to offer a legal alternative and ideally put the mob out of business. And I mean also so that the states could have a little extra revenue stream, but, you know, whatever. Yes, put the mob out of business. But that was not working.

0:15:51
Ian Coss

Yeah, the illegal numbers rackets were still popular because the illegal games could offer their customers things the state lottery couldn't. Daily action. Winnings with no worries of taxes.

0:16:04
Kenny Malone

Yep. Better odds, better payouts. Anonymity, I guess. And also the ability to bet on credit if you feel pretty good about your kneecaps.

0:16:15
Ian Coss

Kneecaps aside, though, why would you want to play the boring state lottery?

0:16:20
Speaker 3

As Al Capone said, I'm performing a public service. I'm giving the public what they want. and at the initiation of the lottery,

0:16:33
Ian Coss

the underworld was still providing better services. When something that was illegal becomes legal, it's tempting to think you get a simple substitution. What once happened in the shadows now happens in the open. But the reality is that the two worlds compete. They innovate. They dance. They force each other to change. And the end result is something entirely new, often unexpected, one of those strange outcomes is the scratch ticket.

0:17:03
Kenny Malone

Yes. To John Koza, our unemployed computer scientist, the potential of his game design seemed completely obvious. Again, it was instant lottery, something that even the mafia could not

0:17:18
Ian Coss

offer their customers. So after John was laid off, he and another jobless colleague, Dan Bauer, decided to start their own company, Scientific Games. It was just the two of them operating out of an apartment in Ann Arbor, Michigan, and a kitchen table in Chicago. And in 1973, the year after his first round of pitches, John started going back to those same lotteries they had pitched before.

0:17:43
Kenny Malone

But this time, there was one place that was ready to hear them out. Massachusetts. Even better, the director of the Massachusetts lottery was not one of those FBI agents.

0:17:55
Speaker 3

The director there was a Ph.D. in mathematics, so he happened to really understand the scientific basis for what we were doing.

0:18:07
Ian Coss

Everyone called the lottery director Dr. Dr. Peralt. And in addition to being a mathematician, Dr. Peralt also happened to be an expert bridge player who once took his eight children on a family vacation to Las Vegas, in part to study the wheels and cards as illustrations of statistics.

0:18:27
Kenny Malone

You know those kids still talk about that vacation and hate it, right, Ian? There's no way that was a good vacation. But when John Koza was there, lucky for him, the PhD in computer science worked well for Dr. Peralt. He arrived in Massachusetts with his pitch for an instant ticket. Things seemed promising, you know. That man in charge spoke his language, combinatorics and all. And the people around him were eager to try something new. There was just one problem.

0:18:57
Speaker 3

They had already given a contract for the instant game to another company.

0:19:03
Ian Coss

So it turned out another company had beaten them to the same idea. It was not a scratch ticket this other company was offering. It was much more low-tech, like an advent calendar with little paper flaps. But still, it claimed to offer the same basic novelty of an instant reveal. And those brand-new tickets? They were already in the warehouse.

0:19:25
Kenny Malone

Yeah, quite bad for John. But he was convinced his ticket was better. You know, John had spent so much time making those supermarket scratcher tickets. He had seen the ways that people hacked those tickets at first. And he was sure that this other company, they could not have made a ticket as secure as his. There was no way.

0:19:47
Ian Coss

So John told Dr. Peralta and the lottery officials as much, and they made a deal on the spot. John was allowed to take home 50 of these new tickets and do his best to prove they could be hacked.

0:20:00
Speaker 3

They gave us the tickets. I went back to Ann Arbor, Dan went back to Chicago, and they gave us a week or so.

0:20:07
Kenny Malone

After the break, how to hack a lottery with a can of Diet Citrus Soda.

0:20:14
Speaker 4

Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.

0:20:18
Speaker 5

This message comes from the UPS Store. The UPS Store is open this holiday to help make sure your small business can stay at its best. During the holiday, customers have access to professional printing, packing and shipping, shredding, mailbox services, notarizing services, and everything else your small business could need. Find nearby locations and keep tackling important tasks at the upsstore.com. Most locations are independently owned. Products, services, pricing, and hours of operation may vary. See Center for details.

0:20:47
Speaker 4

This message comes from Open Door. With cash now, more later. Get cash up front for your home. Plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now, no cash left behind later. Skip the showings now and move on your own timeline. Cash now, more later. Now available nationwide. Start your offer at opendoor.com slash NPR. Profits calculated after fees and costs. Eligibility and offer price may vary. This message comes from LinkedIn. As a small business owner, you wear many hats.

0:21:17

You're the owner, the marketer, the seller, the hirer. With LinkedIn, you have the tools to help you boost your visibility, find prospective customers, and find the best team for your small business, all in one place. So while LinkedIn can't hang up all of your hats, it makes it easier to wear them all. Learn more at linkedin.com slash planet money show.

0:21:40
Kenny Malone

Now, the thing the Massachusetts lottery was worried about, the danger in starting a brand new instant lottery ticket, is that if that instant ticket had a vulnerability, then any convenience store clerk with a stack of tickets might be able to figure out which ones of those are winners, which ones are losers, and then, you know, hand out the winners to friends, keep them for themselves, like just corrupt the whole system. Again, lotteries were terrified of losing credibility and trust.

0:22:09

This would have done just that. So John Koza, back in Ann Arbor, he got to work. This other company's ticket was made of pretty thin paper with flap doors over the hidden numbers held down by glue. So John's goal was to see if he could reveal those numbers without visibly altering the ticket. That would be hacking the ticket. And within 24 hours,

0:22:34
Ian Coss

John was ready to report his findings. So he flew back to Boston. This time, Dr. Peralt,

0:22:40
Kenny Malone

Great vacation giver. No, just kidding. This time, Dr. Peralt was waiting on the runway to greet them and carry their bags. Everybody convened at lottery headquarters, probably like half a dozen men in dark suits gathered around a conference table, eagerly awaiting this presentation from John.

0:22:57
Speaker 3

Remember, they had not only given a contract to this company to print the tickets, tickets were already printed and in the warehouse ready to be issued. And there were 25 million of them.

0:23:09
Ian Coss

Patiently, John began to walk the lottery staff through his findings. There were, he explained, at least three distinct vulnerabilities.

0:23:18
Speaker 3

One of them involved a cystoscope, which is a medical device.

0:23:23
Kenny Malone

A cystoscope has a tiny lens on the end of a thin, flexible tube. A doctor might use it to examine the inside of a patient's bladder, for example. John used it to peer underneath the ticket's flap doors.

0:23:36
Speaker 3

That was one way in. And these tickets were printed on just really ordinary paper with line printers. Line printers like a typewriter. It would make a physical bang impression and indent the paper.

0:23:52
Ian Coss

So method number two was that if you ran the tickets through a photocopier, that raised impression from the printer was just prominent enough that the hidden numbers would come out in the copy.

0:24:04
Kenny Malone

Now, the average convenience store clerk probably does not have access to a cystoscope and may not have a copier in 1973. And so John presented his final foolproof technique. In a dramatic demonstration, John opened a bottle of Fresca, something you certainly could find in the average convenience store. He poured the fresca on the ticket, and the glue, which was supposed to be the ticket's sacred seal, it simply let go. You could peel the whole thing apart, read the numbers, and glue it back together again.

0:24:40
Speaker 3

It was compelling, let's put it that way. When the demonstration was over, there was no doubt.

0:24:47
Kenny Malone

Now, Ian, do we know why fresca? Was it like what John had around? Was it an ingredient in fresca? Like, what is happening?

0:24:55
Ian Coss

You know, John did not elaborate on why Fresca in particular. But as you're saying, you know, it's a citrusy, acidic kind of drink. So I don't know. Maybe it's a good solvent. I'm just speculating. I have no idea.

0:25:07
Kenny Malone

We're an economics podcast. We're not a science show.

0:25:09
Ian Coss

I'm totally out over my skis here. What John did say is that after this presentation, the lottery staff were horrified.

0:25:16
Speaker 3

Had they run it, it would have been a disaster. and there would never have been an instant lottery, I'm sure, in any state for decades. It would have been a totally discredited idea at that point.

0:25:29
Kenny Malone

The lottery canceled their existing contract and put out a new bid. John Coase's company, Scientific Games, won the new contract and their product, which used an indentation-free paper and, of course, that famous shiny metallic film that became the world's first scratch ticket ever.

0:25:48
Ian Coss

On May 29th, 1974, just over 50 years ago, people walked into convenience stores and gas stations around the state and saw that ticket.

0:25:58
Kenny Malone

One liquor store owner described the scene as, quote, instant insanity. A pharmacy had to set up separate sales counters at the back of the store just for lottery tickets so that non-lottery customers wouldn't be disturbed by the apparently unruly crowds. within a day, stores across Massachusetts had run out of tickets and were waiting to be resupplied.

0:26:20
Ian Coss

Did you realize that you had created something that would be huge? That would spread?

0:26:27
Speaker 3

In fact, when I submitted the business plan to our local bank, I had predicted that we would sell $6 million in tickets the first year. And the vice president of the bank that I was working with at the time, he said, I can't submit this to the loan committee. They will just laugh at this. So we cut it back to a million. And the first year sales was $6 million. And that was because the other lotteries in 75, I think it was five or six other state lotteries simultaneously

0:27:01
Kenny Malone

started instant games. Yeah. The other states had waited for someone else to take the plunge, but once they saw what was happening in Massachusetts, they jumped right in.

0:27:09
Speaker 3

We knew we had the world by the tail.

0:27:12
Ian Coss

Today, Americans spend over $100 billion a year on lottery tickets. Almost two-thirds of that total is spent just on scratch tickets. Yes, the big Powerball jackpots are what you see in the window of the convenience store on the billboard. They get more press, and the keynote numbers are always flashing on the TV screen in the corner. but the scratch ticket. That's the bread and butter day in, day out game that keeps the money flowing. Do you play other lottery games or just scratch tickets?

0:27:45
Speaker 5

Just scratch tickets.

0:27:46
Kenny Malone

We now spend more on scratch tickets than we do on movie tickets, on concert tickets, on sports tickets combined. And the fact that the scratcher all started in Massachusetts, Well, that is part of the reason that Massachusetts is spending more per person on average on lottery than anywhere else in the country.

0:28:09
Speaker 3

It's just been a hit. Scratch tickets. People want scratch tickets. Absolutely. You want to win on the spot. Is that why you still play? Yeah. Lack of brains. One of those, please.

0:28:25
Kenny Malone

so ian costs massachusetts native now lottery expert i i how do you end up feeling about being from a home state that is like the scratch capital being part of the state that spends way more on the lottery than any other place do you have a you have a sense of pride in this how

0:28:44
Ian Coss

are you feeling look so i mean kenny have you been to massachusetts ever uh yes a bit if you've ever set foot in this state, you know, we take great pride in like our firsts, our distinctions. We love a good historic marker. We've got plaques for everything. Here's the thing. I've never seen a plaque celebrating the lottery or the invention of the scratch ticket. I didn't really know any of this stuff before I started working on this story.

0:29:13

And I think that's kind of telling. It's like, And it's something that people are not entirely sure how they feel about, whether they're proud of or not. And I'll include myself in that. Which is ultimately why I love this topic so much. It's kind of a little uncomfortable. I mean, the way I see it, state lotteries and scratch tickets in particular are really kind of the key to understanding the world we live in today. And it's a world where gambling, right?

0:29:41

Legal gambling is everywhere. It's at the corner convenience store. It's on your phone. It's on TV. And it's pretty crazy if you think about it, that in just a few decades, we went from this world where gambling is like a shady business run by the mob, kind of on the margins, to now gambling is an industry, right? It's this ubiquitous, incredibly aggressive industry. And however you feel about that, if you want to know how we got from there to here, the answer is lotteries.

0:30:10
Kenny Malone

Yeah. And I suppose it's the instant gratification of the instant ticket is so much more like the kind of gambling we see today on our phones for sports than what lotteries ever were. So in that sense, we can thank instant lottery tickets for creating a social norm around that kind of thing.

0:30:33
Ian Coss

Instant gambling in the palm of your hand. That's where it starts.

0:30:36
Kenny Malone

Yeah. Well, look, if you would like to hear more of Ian's fantastic series, just go look for Scratch and Win to listen to the entire eight part series. I mean, what we've basically just played for you now is sort of episode one. So Ian, why don't you tell folks what they can expect from the rest of the series?

0:30:55
Ian Coss

Yeah, so in part two, we're actually going to go back to before the scratch ticket to the story of how a state like Massachusetts got into the gambling business in the first place. The answer, which was very surprising to me, involves Churchill Bingo. And it also involves a state treasurer who was so into vaudeville music that he installed a piano in the statehouse and started his own singing group called, and this is one for the Planet Money listeners, the Treasury Notes.

0:31:24
Kenny Malone

I mean, come on. The T-Notes. If that doesn't get you to listen, I don't know what will. is produced by Isabel Hibbard and edited by Lacey Roberts. The executive producer is Devin Maverick-Robbins.

0:32:00
Ian Coss

Special thanks to Jonathan Cohen for helping me connect with John Koza and for sharing so much material and insight from his own research. Thanks as well to my brother, Sebastian, for all the great hand-me-down shoes and clothes they do still fit. And also to the staff at Joe's Market in Quincy.

0:32:18
Kenny Malone

And also to all the Jacks over at Joe's Market at Quincy. This one's for the Jacks. Shout out Jacks 1 through 15. Yeah. I'm Ian Coss. I'm Kenny Malone. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.

0:32:38
Speaker 5

Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.