# Summer School 1: An Economic History of the World

- **Show:** Planet Money
- **Published:** 10 Jul 2024
- **Source:** https://www.npr.org/2024/07/10/1197960937/where-did-money-come-from
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/planet-money/summer-school-1-an-economic-history-of-the-world-01f8f6/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

Money is not one invention. It grows from two sources: communities that agree to treat a scarce, beautiful thing as a store of value, as on the island of Yap, and rulers who create money to bind people together and pay armies. Historian Rebecca Spang argues that money works because people trust someone will accept it later, not because of what "backs" it.

The episode contrasts a stable money system built on shared belief with one that collapsed. John Law's 1710s French experiment with paper money, a bank, government debt and shares in the Mississippi Company anticipated modern finance. It failed when people lost confidence and demanded gold and silver. The tension: the system worked while trust held, and Spang says today's version "seems to work" for the same reason.

## Key insights

1. **Yap's stone money worked without moving** Owners of the giant stone disks transferred them by agreement, leaving the stones where they were. One stone sank at sea, yet everyone still honored its owner's claim, which shows money can rest purely on shared belief.
2. **Economists judge money by three tests** Money should store value, act as a unit of account and serve as a medium of exchange. Yap stones pass the first, partly pass the second, and fail on divisibility and portability, though people effectively solved portability by never moving them.
3. **Governments create money to feed armies** Spang says a state that pays soldiers in tokens, and forces others to accept them for food, keeps its army fed. As the army advances, so does the area where the tokens circulate.
4. **Law's key move was tax-payable paper money** In 1717 the Duke of Orleans ordered Parisians to pay taxes with the Banque Générale's notes. That requirement turned a bank run from Law's house into real money.
5. **Money's value comes from future acceptance** Spang says value comes from whether someone will take it from you later, not from what backs it. When that future becomes uncertain, panics follow, as in 1720 when Law's notes were suddenly halved in value.

## Questions this episode answers

### What is money, according to economists?

Economists say money has three jobs: a store of value (it keeps its worth over time), a unit of account (a common measuring stick for prices), and a medium of exchange (something you can use to buy things).

### Why did people on Yap use giant stone disks as money?

They were beautiful and hard to get, since they had to be carved on another island and carried back by raft, so they became the society's version of gold. They were used for big events like weddings rather than everyday purchases.

### Who was John Law and why does he matter?

John Law was a Scottish gambler and duel-killer who talked France into letting him build a bank, paper money and a trading company in the 1710s. His system resembled modern finance but collapsed, which is why he is remembered as both an innovator and a failure.

### What is fractional reserve banking, and why is it risky?

It is when a bank lends out more than it holds in actual gold or cash, so it can create money. If everyone demands their money at once, a bank run, the bank cannot pay, as happened to Law's bank.

### If today's money isn't backed by gold, why does it still work?

Historian Rebecca Spang says money has value as long as someone will accept it from you. Trouble starts when that acceptance becomes uncertain, which leads to financial panic.

## Facts

- **Robert Smith** [0:06:27]: "Around 5 ,000 years ago in ancient Mesopotamia, money was written into clay tablets to keep track of debts and promises."
- **Robert Smith** [0:06:27]: "And paper money shows up in China in the 11th century."
- **Robert Smith** [0:07:26]: "And Palau is about 250 miles south, southwest of Yap."
- **Robert Smith** [0:07:26]: "Well, oral traditions talk about a Yappies navigator named Nagumang who traveled from Yap to Palau."
- **Robert Smith** [0:09:31]: "it's on the range of four to five metric tons. That's about the size of two small cars."
- **Robert Smith** [0:13:53]: "they ran into this big storm and the stone ended up on the bottom of the ocean."
- **Robert Smith** [0:20:09]: "John Law kills a man in a duel, a sword fighting duel. He's convicted, sent to prison. Then he escapes and heads to continental Europe."
- **Robert Smith** [0:21:34]: "At one point, the king had to melt down his silver and gold plates to pay his soldiers"
- **Robert Smith** [0:22:01]: "Goldsmiths started giving people receipts for the gold. And after a while, people started to use the receipts themselves to buy stuff or to settle debts."
- **Robert Smith** [0:22:26]: "if everybody with a claim check came back to the goldsmith and asked for their gold back, the goldsmith would not have enough."
- **Robert Smith** [0:23:14]: "the king of France at this moment, Louis XV, five years old, not super into finance or banking."
- **Robert Smith** [0:24:38]: "In 1716, he sets up the first real bank in France. He's jumped from card game banker to actual real banker."
- **Robert Smith** [0:26:19]: "And Law gets the Duke to grant the company a monopoly on trade with all of France's territory in North America."
- **Antoine Murphy** [0:26:52]: "we'll name after you. We'll call it La Nouvelle Orleans, New Orleans."
- **Robert Smith** [0:27:46]: "OK, instead of paying for the stock with money, pay for it with government bonds."
- **Robert Smith** [0:29:04]: "As of 1719, French settlers had built a total of four houses in New Orleans."
- **Robert Smith** [0:30:15]: "He decides that by the end of the year, paper money will no longer be redeemable for gold and silver."
- **Robert Smith** [0:30:40]: "The Duke, Law's pal, fired Law, placed him under house arrest, and Law fled France"
- **Robert Smith** [0:30:40]: "The Duke and France gave up on paper money altogether, went back to gold and silver coins."
- **Robert Smith** [0:31:07]: "This story appeared in Jacob's book, Money, the True Story of a Made-Up Thing."

## Transcript

**[0:00:00] Speaker 3:** This message comes from University at Buffalo, where scientists are working to protect the Great Lakes and freshwater supplies around the world from harmful contamination. Learn more about their research at buffalo.edu slash NPR. Thank you for listening to Planet Money. We wanted to check in with you to see what we're doing well and how we could improve. If you can, please take a short anonymous survey at npr.org slash pmsurvey. That's all one word. It takes less than 10 minutes, and you do all of us at Planet Money a huge favor by filling it out.

**[0:00:35] Robert Smith:** We especially want to hear from people who haven't taken a survey before or are new listeners. That's npr.org slash pmsurvey. Thank you. This is Planet Money from NPR. It is finally summer. A time to relax, touch some grass, and think about nothing but the sun on your face, the breeze in your hair, and the entire economic history of the world. Welcome back, everyone, to Planet Money Summer School. Whenever the temperature rises and nature beckons, we show up with a new batch of stimulating lessons to make sure your brain has something to do on the long drive to the beach.

**[0:01:22] Robert Smith:** Every Wednesday till Labor Day, we will tackle the biggest questions in economics. In summers past, we've covered Econ 101, investing skills and business strategy. This summer, we'll look back, way back, at how we got to the bewildering economy we have today. Consider it the world's easiest master's degree in economic history. I'm your host, Robert Smith. Now, I know, you might be thinking, Robert, the past is dead and gone. No grown-up needs to know about the Whiskey Rebellion of 1794 or the Smoot-Hawley Tariff.

**[0:02:00] Robert Smith:** True, you do not have to know this stuff. You want to know this stuff. Because everything we take for granted in the economy today had a start somewhere. When you hear about banks collapsing or inflation surging, strange new forms of money and tariffs, you can be the one to say, I know why this is happening. We have been here before. Now, if you talk to historians, they will tell you, you have to be careful. The past never exactly repeats itself.

**[0:02:30] Rebecca Spang:** You cannot step in the same time twice.

**[0:02:34] Robert Smith:** That's Rebecca Spang, a professor at Indiana University Bloomington, and she'll be our guide for this first episode.

**[0:02:40] Rebecca Spang:** The mistake that is often made in history is that people look to a past example and think they know, ah, this is what I should do now in the present.

**[0:02:50] Robert Smith:** So if history isn't a roadmap, why study it?

**[0:02:54] Rebecca Spang:** History shows us examples over and over again of when things changed. Things changed because people took certain actions. And if you remember that nothing that's happened in history is actually inevitable. It's not set in stone. It's the product of actions that people make at particular times in particular situations. I think that helps us to feel that we have a little bit of power to affect the world that we live in today.

**[0:03:25] Robert Smith:** Empowerment. We will take it. On this season of Summer School, we'll bring you some classic yarns from economic history. You'll meet the rogues and murderers who created modern finance. We'll watch as the workers try to start a revolution against the machines. We'll travel with the Vikings and fight mythical creatures for rare and valuable cinnamon. On today's show, we will jump right in with a surprisingly hard question. What is money?

**[0:03:50] Rebecca Spang:** Money is mysterious. Money works best, I think, if we don't actually think about why it's working. If we pay too much attention to the things we do with money, I mean, how bizarre is it that I can go into a store and I can take all this food and I just give somebody a piece of plastic and they say, okay, fine. Then I walk away with all the food. I mean, it's really amazing. But if I stopped and thought about it, if we all sort of stopped and thought about, hold on, what are we doing here?

**[0:04:24] Rebecca Spang:** The whole thing would just kind of come crashing down around our heads.

**[0:04:28] Robert Smith:** All right, well, let's put on our hard hats then, because we have two history stories today that will definitely make you think too hard about money. And we'll have our professor along to offer lessons for today. Let's start with a giant stone coin, lost but not forgotten at the bottom of the ocean. After the break. Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.

**[0:04:59] Speaker 3:** This message comes from University at Buffalo, where scientists are working to protect the Great Lakes and freshwater supplies around the world from harmful contamination. Learn more about their research at buffalo.edu slash NPR.

**[0:05:13] Robert Smith:** This message comes from Bombas. Putting on clean, comfortable clothing every day is a powerful thing. That's why every Bombas purchase sparks the donation of essential clothing to someone experiencing homelessness, not just around the holidays, but all year long. Since 2013, your purchases have powered over 200 million donations and counting. This year, consider giving a gift that gives back. Visit B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash N-P-R and use code N-P-R for 20 % off your first purchase.

**[0:05:46] Robert Smith:** This message comes from Capital One. Capital One offers checking accounts with no fees or minimums. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash Bank Guy for details. Capital One N-A. Member FDIC. Welcome back, class, to Planet Money Summer School. In every lesson, we'll provide a few historical flashbacks and then bring our professor back to draw out the economic lesson inside. We're going to start with the most basic question you can have in economic history.

**[0:06:15] Robert Smith:** Who invented money? Our professor, Rebecca Spang, says the answer is not so simple.

**[0:06:20] Rebecca Spang:** Because money is many different things. It doesn't have a single invention. It happens lots of different times, lots of different places.

**[0:06:27] Robert Smith:** For lots of different reasons. Around 5 ,000 years ago in ancient Mesopotamia, money was written into clay tablets to keep track of debts and promises. And paper money shows up in China in the 11th century. Sometimes money seems to arise naturally. Humans have something shiny that they value and becomes a tradable form of wealth. Other times it takes a king or ruler to create a form of money that can be used as a sort of tool.

**[0:06:54] Robert Smith:** Today in summer school, we'll have both kinds of origin stories. Let's start with the shiny stuff. And I don't mean gold or silver. I mean shiny stones. Very, very large shiny stones on a tropical island in the Pacific, the island of Yap. Now, we don't have records of how long the people of Yap used stone money. But when explorers encountered the island hundreds of years ago, they found that value was stored as giant stone disks with holes in the center.

**[0:07:26] Robert Smith:** Let's play some of the episode we did about Yap in 2010 with hosts David Kestenbaum and Jacob Goldstein. They were talking with Scott Fitzpatrick, an anthropologist now at the University of Oregon. Scott says the stones probably began with a navigator from Yap who canoed to another island and found something really, really nice. Well, oral traditions talk about a Yappies navigator named Nagumang who traveled from Yap to Palau. And Palau is about 250 miles south, southwest of Yap.

**[0:07:58] Robert Smith:** And they talk about this navigator going and finding this milky white crystalline stone, which is limestone. And Palau has an abundance of that. So Nagamang finds this strange, beautiful thing. And it's not like his first thought is, hey, I'm going to invent money. He's just thinking, you know, I'm going to carve some beautiful fish out of this stone. But remember, all he's got is this little canoe. and according to the story, he looks up at the moon one night and he thinks to himself, you know, a big piece of stone in the shape of the moon, that would be a lot easier to bring back to Yap than a great big stone fish.

**[0:08:33] Robert Smith:** So he carves this big round disc out of stone and then he puts a hole in the middle of it, probably so he can stick like a branch through it and maybe roll it back to his boat. So he brings the stone back to Yap and the people go crazy. They love it. Pretty soon anybody who is anybody wants one of these stones. And, you know, money often starts out this way, like gold coins. Before we had gold coins, you know, gold was just something that rich people and kings kept around.

**[0:08:59] Robert Smith:** They made like, I don't know, what did they make? A crown, maybe? Yeah, it's a king, right? You know, but before it was money, it was just something that people liked. And that says you're rich, right? Like, hey, I'm the king. I got gold. So anyway, the people of Yap, they start sending lots of expeditions over to this other island. People are going out in these little boats and bringing back these huge stones. Some of the evidence that we've looked at and trying to estimate how big of a stone could a bamboo raft actually move, we're probably talking about not in excess of two meters.

**[0:09:31] Robert Smith:** How heavy would that have been? Well, it's on the range of four to five metric tons. That's about the size of two small cars. It's pretty big. So, David, let's pause to reflect here. You have this pre-industrial society. You have these guys carving these giant stone disks that are taller than a man, putting them on these tiny little rafts and taking them hundreds of miles across the open ocean. But they do this. They do it over and over again because, you know, the stones are really pretty.

**[0:09:59] Robert Smith:** They don't have gold or silver on the island, but they do have these nice shiny stones. If you scrub them, they're really beautiful. Just kind of this milky, crystalline white. They're almost blind to you. They're so bright. So at some point, we don't know when, the people on Yap realize what almost all societies realize. They need something to store value. They need something that everyone in society agrees you can use to pay for stuff. And like many societies, the people of Yap, they took the thing they had that was pretty and hard to get, the thing that was their version of gold.

**[0:10:33] Robert Smith:** And they decided these giant stone disks were going to be money, even though they were giant and stone. So a piece of stone money, it was really valuable. It wasn't like you would roll one of the big ones down to the corner store and buy some fish. I mean, it seems like for day-to-day stuff, they would maybe use shells. But for big stuff, special occasions, you would use stone money. I mean, you can think of it like a $10 ,000 bill.

**[0:10:57] Robert Smith:** In oral traditions, they talk about, for example, a couple getting married and their family members or friends might give them a certain number of pieces of stone money. If somebody was in real dire straits and they were – something happened to their crop of food or they were running low on provisions and they had some stone money, they might trade those for food or for help. So let's get back to this question of what is money and see how the stone money holds up.

**[0:11:30] Robert Smith:** Now, economists actually have a three-part definition they use for money. Part one is money should be a store of value. So you couldn't, for example, use coconuts because coconuts will rot. So stone money definitely meets that one. We can check that one. The second is usually it has to be a unit of account. And here things get a little slippery for classifying these stones as money. Unit of account means there's broad agreement that there's a specific value attached to it.

**[0:11:56] Robert Smith:** And it wasn't like people priced things in stones like, hey, you want to buy that canoe? That's three stones. On the other hand, some stones were clearly worth more than others. There were bigger ones or some famous guy went and got it. It might be worth more. So I think you can give stone money sort of a half checkmark on unit of account. All right. So we got one and a half check so far. The third item on the list is money should be what economists call a medium of exchange, which basically means something you can use to buy stuff.

**[0:12:23] Robert Smith:** One economist who was writing about the stone money said you need something to be storable, recognizable, divisible, and portable. So for storable and recognizable, yeah, giant stone disks are storable and recognizable as hell, right? A divisible, that one, it actually doesn't work. You cannot, in fact, break a giant stone disk in half and have like half as much money. That doesn't work. And then we get to portable. So, I mean, remember, one of these things can weigh as much as two small cars or something, right?

**[0:12:51] Robert Smith:** And this is where something really profound happens. The people of Yap decide that if you give somebody a piece of stone money, you don't actually have to give it to them. Here's Scott Fitzpatrick. They often talk about the stone themselves not changing hands at all. In fact, most of the time they won just the sheer amount of labor it would take to do it. You know, it's so funny because on the one hand, like these are very concrete forms of sort of money, you know, but it also very quickly becomes abstract just because of their size.

**[0:13:24] Robert Smith:** So they don't actually move it in financial transactions. They just say, OK, it's yours now, even though it's outside my house. Right, right. And the really interesting thing about this whole process, I think, too, is that everybody knows whose it is. So, okay, so you can imagine, you know, everybody sees the stone and knows somebody owns it. You know, I know Kestenbaum's stone is the one over there by that tree. But as it turns out, you don't even have to see a stone for it to have value.

**[0:13:53] Robert Smith:** There's this story that one time a crew of workers was bringing back this great big piece of stone money back to Yap on a little boat. And just before they got back to Yap, they ran into this big storm and the stone ended up on the bottom of the ocean. But the people, they get back to Yap and they tell the story and everybody says, no problem. That stone money, it's still good, even though it's sitting on the bottom of the ocean.

**[0:14:16] Robert Smith:** So somebody owns this piece of stone money, even though nobody's ever seen, you know, nobody's seen it for over 100 years or more. Does that seem kind of amazing to you, though? Yeah, yeah. I got it was a huge one. It was giant and more beautiful than anything. But unfortunately, I don't have it here. Man, that is the definition of abstract money. Yeah, it really is, isn't it? So, Jacob, when we're reading these stories, they seem kind of funny.

**[0:14:37] Robert Smith:** And then at some point you realize, oh, you know, I use stone money all the time. I mean, if I write you a check, right, what actually changes in the world? In the physical world, essentially nothing, right? Like the numbers in your bank account change a little and the numbers in my bank account change a little. But it's essentially like there is some stone on the bottom of the ocean that you used to own. And now that stone belongs to me.

**[0:15:01] Robert Smith:** Even though we have this much more advanced financial system, money, it's basically faith in something that you can't see. There's mutual agreement that there's something out there in the world that has a certain value. It's like trust plus invisibility equals money. That was David Kestenbaum and Jacob Goldstein from an episode we did in 2010. Joining us again is our professor today, Rebecca Speng. Hello. I'm glad to be here. So, Rebecca, like, what is the modern-day equivalent of these giant stone coins on YAP?

**[0:15:37] Rebecca Spang:** Do we have things like it today? In many ways, we don't. So what you need to think about is the giant stone coins are not part of what we think of as the market economy. They're used in the prestige sphere for really important events like weddings or to cement a political alliance. So they're things that you would never, ever consider using as ordinary money. In the same way that we today, some of us, may have things that we value, but that we would actually feel really bad about cashing in.

**[0:16:19] Rebecca Spang:** So imagine if you have jewelry that you inherited from your great-grandmother. You want to hold on to it instead of putting it into circulation.

**[0:16:29] Robert Smith:** Economists love the story of Yap because it shows how money might arise naturally when a society needs it, you know, when you need to store value or make transactions easier. But as a historian, I know that you focus on something else that gives rise to money, which is power, governments, kings. Why do they need money to exist and how do they make it happen?

**[0:16:52] Rebecca Spang:** So the state, a government, an administration, uses money as a way of bringing people and communities into their orbit. So once you know that you use little shiny coins with owls on them, then you feel like you're part of the owl community, right? You are part of that sort of system of belief. So it's actually one of the ways that communities recognize themselves. There's another reason why governments need to have something like money, because governments in many parts of the world at many times have armies, and armies are expensive.

**[0:17:40] Rebecca Spang:** If you can pay your army in little shiny things, and then if your army can force other people to accept the little shiny things in exchange for food, then you can keep your army fed. And as your army keeps advancing, the territory where your little shiny things circulate and are accepted gets wider and wider.

**[0:18:04] Robert Smith:** And over time, new forms of money keep popping up. After the break, we'll take money to the next level and hear what happens when one man, a rogue and a murderer to be exact, tries to create a whole new financial system from scratch.

**[0:18:23] Speaker 3:** Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from University at Buffalo, where five decades of AI research is producing advancements that put people first, tackling real-world problems for progress, not profit, empowering, not replacing. Learn how the University at Buffalo is using AI responsibly to create a better, brighter future for all at buffalo.edu slash npr.

**[0:18:50] Robert Smith:** This message comes from LinkedIn. Owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once. It's even harder to do it efficiently. But with LinkedIn, you get all the tools you need to grow in one place. With LinkedIn, simplify your sales, marketing, and hiring so that you can actually run your small business. Learn more at linkedin.com slash planetmoneyshow.

**[0:19:13] Speaker 3:** This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message. What if instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? No catching up on manual edits. No more guesswork. HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps your customer context current and helps you understand what to do next. So marketing builds more demand, sales wins more deals, and customers keep coming back. Learn more at HubSpot.com.

**[0:19:40] Robert Smith:** We're going to set the summer school time machine to the 1700s now, and across the globe from the Pacific Ocean to Europe. It's the story of a giant leap forward in modern finance, followed closely by finance collapsing and blowing up the entire world. You know how that works. It's a cautionary tale for any economy that moves beyond stone coins. It starts with a Scotsman named John Law. L-A-W. John Law. He's in his early 20s, well off, and living the high life in London.

**[0:20:09] Robert Smith:** He's gambling, affairs with women. We don't know the exact reasons, but John Law kills a man in a duel, a sword fighting duel. He's convicted, sent to prison. Then he escapes and heads to continental Europe. That's the personal drama. But now, the economic drama begins. Jacob Goldstein and Mary Childs pick up the story around 1714. So John Law is on the lam. He's popping up in one city after another across Europe, Amsterdam, Venice, Paris, and he's always at the gambling tables playing cards.

**[0:20:42] Robert Smith:** And he's always winning. People are starting to notice this gambler who's getting rich. When he arrives in Paris, the chief of police sends this warning letter to the foreign minister. He writes, quote, A Scott-named law, gambler by profession and suspected of evil intentions toward the king, appears at Paris in high style and has even bought an impressive home, although no one knows of any resource except fortune in gambling, which is his whole profession. But Law caught a break.

**[0:21:08] Robert Smith:** The minister wrote in the margin of that letter, he is not suspect he may remain in peace. So John Law is living in Paris, gambling, making money. But he's also got this, I don't know, a hobby, a little side hustle he's been trying to get going. He's trying to convince France, the whole country of France, to completely change the way it is running its economy. So France has been fighting war after war, spending all this money, and now the country is basically broke.

**[0:21:34] Robert Smith:** Farmers can't borrow money to plant seeds. At one point, the king had to melt down his silver and gold plates to pay his soldiers, which was kind of emblematic of the whole bigger problem. The whole economy ran on gold and silver, and there wasn't enough gold and silver to go around. John Law knew something about this problem in particular. His father was a goldsmith, and during John Law's lifetime, goldsmiths in Britain were kind of becoming banks.

**[0:22:01] Robert Smith:** What happened was goldsmiths had safes in their shops. So people started storing the gold with the goldsmiths. Goldsmiths started giving people receipts for the gold. And after a while, people started to use the receipts themselves to buy stuff or to settle debts. The receipts were like proto-paper money. They were money adjacent. This wasn't the first time people in the world had used paper money. China had actually used it hundreds of years earlier. But it's a new thing in Western Europe.

**[0:22:26] Robert Smith:** Then the goldsmiths went further. They started making loans. Goldsmiths would give you a claim check for gold that you could go out and use as money, but you didn't have to deposit any gold. Your claim check is for gold that kind of doesn't exist. The goldsmith is creating money out of thin air. So if everybody with a claim check came back to the goldsmith and asked for their gold back, the goldsmith would not have enough. To be clear, this is basically how banks work today.

**[0:22:53] Robert Smith:** We call it fractional reserve banking. And similarly today, if everybody with a bank deposit came and asked for their money at the same time, we call that a bank run. The bank doesn't have the money. That is just how banks work. But on the flip side, if your economy, say, runs on silver and gold and you are so low on silver and gold that you just melted down your very favorite chalice, fractional reserve banking is exactly what you need.

**[0:23:14] Robert Smith:** So John Law is ready to pitch this idea in France. Normally, the kind of guy he is, he would just go straight to the top, pitch it to the king. But the king of France at this moment, Louis XV, five years old, not super into finance or banking. And France at this time is being run by a regent, a duke, the Duke of Orleans or Lyon. Or Lyon. OK. So the duke's hobbies include working in his home chemistry lab, composing operas and staying up all night with nobles and opera singers and actresses who would all get drunk, sleep with each other and say, quote, vile things at the tops of their voices.

**[0:23:52] Robert Smith:** So I bet you know who the Duke is going to love. John Law. We talked about this with Anne Murphy. She is a historian, but she also used to work as a derivatives trader. So she knows a few things about finance bros like John Law.

**[0:24:06] Speaker 3:** He's out there networking, getting to know the right people.

**[0:24:10] Robert Smith:** And he manages to convince them to allow him to set up a private bank. A bank. owned and run by John Law. And France doesn't really have banks as we know them at this point, right? It's not a thing in France, banking, like we have banks. Not really, no. There's a bit of a suspicion about what banks are and what they can do. I mean, there's a suspicion of banks here and now, but they exist, nevertheless.

**[0:24:38] Robert Smith:** Yes, and every country, I think, has to figure out how to make its peace with what banks are and what they do. So this is step one of John Law's scheme. In 1716, he sets up the first real bank in France. He's jumped from card game banker to actual real banker. It's called the Banque Générale, which is a fancy name, but it's run out of his house. He prints paper money, backed by gold and silver, but everybody thinks his bank is kind of a joke.

**[0:25:09] Robert Smith:** The next year, though, John Law got another break. His drinking buddy, the Duke, made a new rule that said, everybody in Paris has to use the bank's paper banknotes to pay their taxes. And, you know, a reasonable definition of money is it's the thing you pay your taxes with. Because once the government says you have to use this thing to pay your taxes, whether that thing is silver coins or cloth or dollars or paper money from the Banque General, then everybody knows that at some point they're going to need to have that thing to pay their taxes.

**[0:25:41] Robert Smith:** When the Duke forced people to use John Law's paper money to pay their taxes, his paper bills became real money. So France's economy is now running on the full faith and credit of John Law. So let's pause here for just a moment and go to Law's biographer, Antoine Murphy, for the recap.

**[0:25:59] Antoine Murphy:** He killed a man in a jewel. He was sentenced to death and then he escaped from prison. So you wouldn't have expected a great monetary economist to develop from such a figure.

**[0:26:11] Robert Smith:** Depends on your views of monetary economists.

**[0:26:14] Antoine Murphy:** It sure does. It sure does. Yeah.

**[0:26:19] Robert Smith:** Antoine Murphy says John Law really believed that if you build an economy right, everybody can get richer, including but not limited to John Law. And so he thinks, OK, now that I have the bank, I'm going to go even bigger. I'm going to go international. I'm going to create a company that will be bigger and better than any that has ever existed. It'll come to be called the Mississippi Company. And Law gets the Duke to grant the company a monopoly on trade with all of France's territory in North America.

**[0:26:45] Antoine Murphy:** It's literally half of the landmass of the current United States.

**[0:26:51] Robert Smith:** Not counting Alaska.

**[0:26:52] Antoine Murphy:** And Law, once he gets the Mississippi Company moving, he's sending ships over to North America. And they're coming in to a small little port in the Gulf of Mexico, which he says to the regent, we'll name after you. We'll call it La Nouvelle Orleans, New Orleans. And suddenly you have New Orleans named after the regent.

**[0:27:19] Robert Smith:** Now, there is an important twist here.

**[0:27:21] Antoine Murphy:** A twist.

**[0:27:21] Robert Smith:** A twist. Then, as now, government debt was one of the most important parts of finance and of the economy as a whole. England, France's rival, had started this new kind of bank, the Bank of England, that was helping it deal with government debt. France also had this huge national debt from fighting all these wars against England. France had borrowed all this money, sold all these government bonds, and it's having a hard time making the interest payments on the bonds.

**[0:27:46] Robert Smith:** The national debt is just killing the French economy. So a law comes up with a plan to help the Duke. to help France really solve its national debt problem. When he first sells stock in the Mississippi Company, Law says to the public, OK, instead of paying for the stock with money, pay for it with government bonds. You give me some of those bonds that the government isn't going to be able to pay back, and I'll give you a share of my company, a share of all the riches in the new world.

**[0:28:11] Robert Smith:** It is amazing how fast this is happening. This truly is one of those moments in the history of money when everything is happening all at once. You know, it's just 1717 right now. Not long ago, France was a country where the king was melting down his forks to pay the bills. Now in France, you can borrow paper money, lend that to the government to get government debt, and then trade that debt in to get shares in a multinational corporation that controls half of North America.

**[0:28:37] Robert Smith:** And John Law, by the way, gets a cut of all of this. John Law's scheme is working. Paper money is working. It's easier for people to borrow money. In the countryside, farmers are growing more food. In Paris, artisans are making more dishes and clothes. And John Law and the Mississippi Company are taking over more and more. Essentially, all of France's foreign trade, tobacco sales, the entire French national debt, all flowing through John Law and the Mississippi Company.

**[0:29:04] Robert Smith:** If we can say that John Law created modern finance, which he sort of did in ways, then we can say that he also created the first modern financial collapse. collapse. The trouble started in Mississippi, where the big plans were really not working out. As of 1719, French settlers had built a total of four houses in New Orleans. Most of the people moving to the territory died of disease or starvation. The company does have tons of other businesses going by this point.

**[0:29:37] Robert Smith:** But the price of the company's stock is so high that all of the businesses put together are not enough to justify it. What ends up happening is lots of people sell their stock back to the company, and Laws Bank prints more and more paper money to buy back the stock. People start getting nervous now about Law's scheme. Suddenly, everybody wants to go to the bank and turn in their paper money for gold and silver. But once people started trying

**[0:30:01] Antoine Murphy:** to convert their paper money into gold and silver, problems arose because there wasn't enough gold and silver to pay them. Law said, sorry, you can't have that. He had spent years promoting this dream

**[0:30:15] Robert Smith:** of paper money, and now it was all unraveling. So he starts kind of flailing around, looking for ways to save his system, to save paper money. He decides that by the end of the year, paper money will no longer be redeemable for gold and silver. It will just be paper. Oh, and by the way, the value of each paper bill will be half of what it is now. This was too much for the people of France.

**[0:30:40] Robert Smith:** They flipped out, they took to the streets, they threw rocks through the windows of John Law's bank. The Duke, Law's pal, fired Law, placed him under house arrest, and Law fled France, just like he had fled England decades earlier. The Duke and France gave up on paper money altogether, went back to gold and silver coins. John Law is remembered as a failure, as a con man. Modern economists don't think of him as one of the great forefathers of their field.

**[0:31:07] Robert Smith:** But our world today looks a lot like what he had envisioned. Mary Childs and Jacob Goldstein from 2020. This story appeared in Jacob's book, Money, the True Story of a Made-Up Thing. After the break, how John Law's big idea stayed with us to this day, and how some of the flaws in his system got fixed.

**[0:31:31] Speaker 3:** Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from University at Buffalo, where scientists are working to protect the Great Lakes and freshwater supplies around the world from harmful contamination. Learn more about their research at buffalo.edu slash NPR.

**[0:31:50] Robert Smith:** This message comes from LinkedIn. Owning a small business comes with a lot of challenges and means juggling multiple things at once. It's even harder to do it efficiently. But with LinkedIn, you get all the tools you need to grow in one place. With LinkedIn, simplify your sales, marketing, and hiring so that you can actually run your small business. Learn more at linkedin.com slash planetmoneyshow.

**[0:32:13] Speaker 3:** This message comes from Mint Mobile. This holiday season, unwrap a new wireless plan from Mint Mobile. Keep your current phone and your number and go to mintmobile.com slash switch.

**[0:32:25] Robert Smith:** All right, all right, class. Time for discussion and analysis. Returning to the whiteboard is our professor, Rebecca Spang. Hello. Rebecca, I love this story because John Law had all the pieces of a modern financial system going. He was juggling it all for, I don't know, two or three years, and then it blew up. And yet today we do the exact same things, paper money, government debt, risky investments, but now it seems to actually work. What's the difference?

**[0:32:54] Rebecca Spang:** So the key word I want to underline there is seems, right? It seems to work today until it doesn't. And we never know when it's not going to work. And so we continue to operate on the assumption that it will. And that's because it's no longer new. It's familiar. We take it for granted that there's a Federal Reserve Bank, that governments have debt. These are normal parts of the world. When John Law introduced them, they were new.

**[0:33:22] Rebecca Spang:** They were shocking. Some historians have argued they were revolutionary. And so many people who didn't like this change opposed it and called attention to it.

**[0:33:31] Robert Smith:** It is different when you have an institution, a government creating debt, companies who are investing, a central bank that is sort of producing money rather than some guy that you see at the gambling table.

**[0:33:46] Rebecca Spang:** Right Right. I mean, part of the problem for John Law is that he already had a reputation as a gambler and a foreigner. That sort of international playboy thing doesn't necessarily go very well with the senior banker position that he tried to craft for himself.

**[0:34:11] Robert Smith:** I know you've written entire books on this and, of course, taught year-long courses. But give us a take-home message that we can bring with us, a principle of money and banking that will allow us to understand the world.

**[0:34:24] Rebecca Spang:** I think people tend to assume that money has value because of where it's coming from, because of what it's, quote-unquote, backed by. All right? So people get a little freaked out when they're like, you mean there's nothing backing the dollar? I think that what really gives money its value isn't where it's come from, but where it's going. Money has value as long as there's somebody who's willing to accept it from you. And it's when that transaction, that transaction into the future, becomes more and more risky, more and more uncertain.

**[0:35:06] Rebecca Spang:** That's when we get a financial panic, a monetary crisis.

**[0:35:11] Robert Smith:** Before we finish up our lessons on summer school, we like to leave the listeners with a sort of study guide on the big ideas we've covered today. We have, of course, the three things that economists say is needed to make something money. Money should be, one, a store of value, which means that it lasts. It's worth something in the future. Money should be, two, a unit of account, like a measuring stick for what something is worth.

**[0:35:35] Robert Smith:** And money is three, a medium of exchange. You can use it to get stuff. And in the more anthropological sense, Rebecca, you brought up the term prestige good when talking about the yapstones. What does that mean?

**[0:35:50] Rebecca Spang:** There are goods that basically cannot be bought and sold for ordinary money, but that nonetheless might sometimes change hands.

**[0:36:00] Robert Smith:** Rebecca Spank, thank you so much for being our professor for this episode.

**[0:36:03] Rebecca Spang:** Thank you for the invitation.

**[0:36:05] Robert Smith:** And students, I hope you were taking good notes. We'll have a quiz at the end of the season and a not-quite-legal diploma for you if you pass. No need to cram, though, because this year we also have videos. Our Crack Planet Money TikTok team will be distilling one economic lesson each week into an entertaining few minutes. You can find it in our show notes or by searching TikTok and Instagram. Next time, our Planet Money History of the World makes a stop at the Black Death and the Industrial Revolution.

**[0:36:35] Robert Smith:** So bring your mask and your pitchforks because the workers of the world are mad as hell and they are not going to take it anymore. Before we end today, we'd like to ask a favor of you. We want to hear what you think of the work we're doing. You can find a short anonymous survey at npr.org slash pmsurvey, all one word. It takes less than 10 minutes and you do all of us a huge favor by filling it out.

**[0:36:57] Robert Smith:** We especially want to hear from people who haven't taken a survey before or are new listeners. Welcome. That's npr.org slash pmsurvey. Planet Money Summer School is produced by Audrey Dilling. Our project manager is Devin Mellor. This episode is fact-checked by Sofia Shchukina and engineered by Sina Lafredo, Planet Money's executive producer. And our editor today is Alex Goldmark. We will be back with Summer School every Wednesday until Labor Day. And you can find your brand new episodes of regular Planet Money on Fridays.

**[0:37:26] Robert Smith:** I'm Robert Smith. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.

**[0:37:32] Speaker 3:** Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.
