In brief
Economic progress can be measured by how little work it takes to buy something. Light is the example. In ancient Babylon, a full day's wages bought about ten minutes of light. By the 1990s, Yale economist Bill Nordhaus estimated a day's work bought around 20,000 hours. The episode argues that the history of light is the history of economic growth: things getting faster, cheaper and more efficient, so the pie can get bigger.
For about 4,000 years almost nothing changed. Then around 1800 the pace of improvement jumped. Organized science produced kerosene, and Edison's electric light succeeded because investors, patents and corporations were already in place. The tension is that growth brought real costs, such as pollution from early coal-fired power plants, and it raises the question of whether improvements can continue forever or hit physical limits.
Questions
Why is light used to explain economic growth?
Because you can measure how much light a day's wages buy over thousands of years. Economist Bill Nordhaus found it rose from about 10 minutes in ancient Babylon to around 20,000 hours by the 1990s, which shows progress as things getting cheaper and more efficient.
How did people make light before light bulbs?
They burned animal fat on a wick, and the episode describes candles made from beef fat, dried salmon candles and oily seabirds used as lamps. All of it was laborious: Jacob Goldstein spent hours making six crooked, smelly candles.
What changed around 1800 to speed up improvements in light?
Nordhaus says the pace of improvement jumped around 1800, when scientists started doing experiments at universities. That work led to kerosene around 1850, which gave about five hours of light per day's wages, compared with about one hour from whale oil.
Was Thomas Edison's invention the main reason electric light became cheap?
Not by itself. The episode says Edison was also a businessman who constantly compared costs to gas lighting, and his power plant was financed by J.P. Morgan's bank and investors. Edison scholar Paul Israel says most economic growth comes from the structure around inventions.
Did the growth in cheap light have downsides?
Yes. Early power plants burned coal and caused heavy pollution, and the company tried to stop health department photographers from capturing its smokestacks. The hosts describe this as a tradeoff against having a city lit by cheap electric light.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
For thousands of years, people lit their homes by burning animal fat on a wick.
“For thousands of years, if you wanted to light up your cave, your mud hut, or if you were really lucky, your castle, you had to find some fat, something to use for a wick”
0:01:09 · Jacob Goldstein · Early lighting
Jacob Goldstein spent hours making six small, crooked beef-fat candles from two pounds of fat.
“After hours of work, not counting raising the cow or killing the cow or making the twine, I had six tiny, crooked, smelly candles.”
0:02:47 · Jacob Goldstein · Candle making · 2014
According to Jane Brox, Native Americans in the Pacific Northwest used dried salmon as a candle.
“In the United States, in the Pacific Northwest, Native Americans used dried salmon. They basically made a salmon candle.”
0:06:25 · Jacob Goldstein · Early lighting
In the north of Scotland, people dried the oily storm petrel seabird, threaded a wick through it and used it as a lamp.
“The storm petrel in the north of Scotland, which is a very oily seabird, which they'd catch and dry and thread a wick down its throat and then light it.”
0:06:49 · Jane Brox · Early lighting
Writer Harriet Beecher Stowe said making animal-fat candles was seven times as bad as washing clothes.
“The writer Harriet Beecher Stowe said making candles from animal fat was seven times as bad as washing clothes.”
0:07:21 · Jacob Goldstein · Candle making
Bill Nordhaus obtained Babylonian wage and price data from a Yale colleague to compare the cost of light over 4,000 years.
“she actually had wage data and price data from the Babylonian era, so 4 ,000 years ago.”
0:08:34 · Bill Nordhaus · Cost of light · Babylonian era
Bill Nordhaus built and measured an ancient-style lamp in his dining room, using a light meter borrowed from Yale.
“I did this in my dining room. Where else?”
0:09:03 · Bill Nordhaus · Nordhaus experiment
In ancient Babylon, a full day's wages bought about ten minutes of light equivalent to a dim modern bulb.
“An entire day's wages got you the equivalent of 10 minutes of light from a kind of dim light bulb.”
0:10:12 · Jacob Goldstein · Cost of light · Babylonian era
At one point Paris had a law requiring residents to hand their keys to a magistrate and lock themselves in each night.
“In Paris, at one point, there was actually a law that said every night, everybody has to give their keys to a magistrate, go home, and lock themselves in the house.”
0:10:41 · Jacob Goldstein · Darkness
Bill Nordhaus says improvements in lighting from Babylonian times to about 1800 were very modest.
“From Babylonian times to around 1800, there were, even though there were improvements, as best we can tell, they were very modest.”
0:12:07 · Bill Nordhaus · Lighting history · 1800
Around 1850 a man in Canada developed a breakthrough lamp fuel, which the episode identifies as kerosene.
“And around 1850, a guy in Canada comes up with something that's not just a slightly better wick or a slightly more efficient lamp.”
0:12:30 · Jacob Goldstein · Kerosene · 1850
Bill Nordhaus says a day's work bought about an hour of whale oil light but about five hours of kerosene light.
“You work a day, you get about an hour of whale oil. Kerosene, you get about five hours.”
0:13:12 · Bill Nordhaus · Cost of light · 1800s
Bill Nordhaus says Yale had no scientists a century before the kerosene era, teaching Greek and logic instead.
“Well, Yale didn't have scientists a century earlier. They were teaching Greek and they were teaching logic.”
0:13:55 · Bill Nordhaus · Rise of science · 1700s
Edison switched on his Manhattan power station at 3 p.m. on September 4 from J.P. Morgan's office.
“So at 3 p.m. on September 4th, Edison flicked on the switch here at J.P. Morgan's office.”
0:17:59 · Speaker 2 · Pearl Street Station · 1882
J.P. Morgan's bank and other investors financed Edison's first central power station in lower Manhattan.
“J.P. Morgan's bank and a bunch of investors, they put up the money for the power plant.”
0:17:34 · Jacob Goldstein · Financing · 1882
When switched on, the power station lit about a square mile of lower Manhattan with electricity.
“It went on. And as did, lights all over the district. About a square mile of lower Manhattan suddenly was lit by electricity.”
0:18:06 · Speaker 2 · Pearl Street Station · 1882
Edison scholar Paul Israel says Edison's notebooks constantly compared the cost of his electric system with gas lighting.
“if you look at his notebooks, constantly he's going through and comparing the cost of what he's doing to what the cost of a gas system is.”
0:18:15 · Jacob Goldstein · Edison economics
Edison relied on patents and a corporation so investors could pool money to build the power plant.
“He needed patents, a way to protect his ideas so no one would steal them. He needed a company, a way a bunch of different investors could come together and risk money”
0:19:06 · Jacob Goldstein · Financial structure · 1880s
Per the New York Times, Edison's company stopped feeding coal whenever health department photographers appeared, to hide smokestack pollution.
“when it was found health department men were trying to photograph the smokestacks, scouts were put on the company's roof, who ordered the feeding of coal stopped whenever photographers appeared.”
0:19:33 · Jacob Goldstein · Pollution · 1880s
Bill Nordhaus estimated that by the 1990s a day's wages bought about 20,000 hours of light.
“20 ,000 hours, yeah. I mean, you basically, you have your house lit up, you have your streets lit up, you have all your equipment on”
0:20:48 · Bill Nordhaus · Cost of light · 1990s
John Edmond co-founded an LED bulb maker, transcribed as Creep, whose bulbs are more efficient than regular bulbs.
“This is John Edmond. He's one of the founders of a company called Creep. They make LED light bulbs, which, of course, are much more efficient than regular bulbs.”
0:21:41 · Jacob Goldstein · LED bulbs · 2014
Bill Nordhaus died at age 85, the week before this rerun aired.
“Last week, Bill Nordhaus died at the age of 85.”
0:00:46 · Jacob Goldstein · Bill Nordhaus
Bill Nordhaus won the Nobel Prize in economics a few years after this episode was first recorded, for his work on the economics of climate change.
“And a few years after we talked to him for this episode, he actually won the Econ Nobel for his work on the economics of climate change.”
0:00:46 · Jacob Goldstein · Bill Nordhaus