# The history of light (classic)

- **Show:** Planet Money
- **Published:** 4 Nov 2026
- **Source:** https://www.npr.org/2026/11/04/nx-s1-6027986/william-nordhaus-yale-nobel-obituary-history-light
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/planet-money/the-history-of-light-classic-4cb4d9/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

Economic progress can be measured by how little work it takes to buy something. Light is the example. In ancient Babylon, a full day's wages bought about ten minutes of light. By the 1990s, Yale economist Bill Nordhaus estimated a day's work bought around 20,000 hours. The episode argues that the history of light is the history of economic growth: things getting faster, cheaper and more efficient, so the pie can get bigger.

For about 4,000 years almost nothing changed. Then around 1800 the pace of improvement jumped. Organized science produced kerosene, and Edison's electric light succeeded because investors, patents and corporations were already in place. The tension is that growth brought real costs, such as pollution from early coal-fired power plants, and it raises the question of whether improvements can continue forever or hit physical limits.

## Key insights

1. **Babylonian workers earned minutes of light daily** Nordhaus combined Babylonian wage and price records with a lamp he built and measured at home. A full day's pay bought roughly ten minutes of modern-bulb light, which shows how hard everything was.
2. **Light barely improved for four thousand years** Romans made slightly better lamps and people turned to whale oil. Even in the 1700s, life still looked more like ancient Babylon than the modern world. Nordhaus says the pace of improvement changed enormously around 1800.
3. **Kerosene and science made light five times cheaper** Nordhaus says a day's work bought about an hour of whale oil but about five hours of kerosene. He ties the jump to universities hiring scientists. A century earlier, Yale was still teaching Greek and logic.
4. **Edison's light bulb needed Wall Street money** J.P. Morgan's bank and other investors paid for the first central power station in lower Manhattan, which went live in 1882. Edison switched it on from Morgan's office. Patents, corporations and banks were already in place, and the episode argues that structure mattered more than the invention itself.
5. **Growth made light cheap but cost pollution** By the 1990s a day's labor bought around 20,000 hours of light. Early coal-burning plants polluted heavily, and the company hid its smokestacks from health department photographers. The episode calls this a tradeoff, not pure progress.

## Questions this episode answers

### Why is light used to explain economic growth?

Because you can measure how much light a day's wages buy over thousands of years. Economist Bill Nordhaus found it rose from about 10 minutes in ancient Babylon to around 20,000 hours by the 1990s, which shows progress as things getting cheaper and more efficient.

### How did people make light before light bulbs?

They burned animal fat on a wick, and the episode describes candles made from beef fat, dried salmon candles and oily seabirds used as lamps. All of it was laborious: Jacob Goldstein spent hours making six crooked, smelly candles.

### What changed around 1800 to speed up improvements in light?

Nordhaus says the pace of improvement jumped around 1800, when scientists started doing experiments at universities. That work led to kerosene around 1850, which gave about five hours of light per day's wages, compared with about one hour from whale oil.

### Was Thomas Edison's invention the main reason electric light became cheap?

Not by itself. The episode says Edison was also a businessman who constantly compared costs to gas lighting, and his power plant was financed by J.P. Morgan's bank and investors. Edison scholar Paul Israel says most economic growth comes from the structure around inventions.

### Did the growth in cheap light have downsides?

Yes. Early power plants burned coal and caused heavy pollution, and the company tried to stop health department photographers from capturing its smokestacks. The hosts describe this as a tradeoff against having a city lit by cheap electric light.

## Facts

- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:01:09]: "For thousands of years, if you wanted to light up your cave, your mud hut, or if you were really lucky, your castle, you had to find some fat, something to use for a wick"
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:02:47]: "After hours of work, not counting raising the cow or killing the cow or making the twine, I had six tiny, crooked, smelly candles."
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:06:25]: "In the United States, in the Pacific Northwest, Native Americans used dried salmon. They basically made a salmon candle."
- **Jane Brox** [0:06:49]: "The storm petrel in the north of Scotland, which is a very oily seabird, which they'd catch and dry and thread a wick down its throat and then light it."
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:07:21]: "The writer Harriet Beecher Stowe said making candles from animal fat was seven times as bad as washing clothes."
- **Bill Nordhaus** [0:08:34]: "she actually had wage data and price data from the Babylonian era, so 4 ,000 years ago."
- **Bill Nordhaus** [0:09:03]: "I did this in my dining room. Where else?"
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:10:12]: "An entire day's wages got you the equivalent of 10 minutes of light from a kind of dim light bulb."
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:10:41]: "In Paris, at one point, there was actually a law that said every night, everybody has to give their keys to a magistrate, go home, and lock themselves in the house."
- **Bill Nordhaus** [0:12:07]: "From Babylonian times to around 1800, there were, even though there were improvements, as best we can tell, they were very modest."
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:12:30]: "And around 1850, a guy in Canada comes up with something that's not just a slightly better wick or a slightly more efficient lamp."
- **Bill Nordhaus** [0:13:12]: "You work a day, you get about an hour of whale oil. Kerosene, you get about five hours."
- **Bill Nordhaus** [0:13:55]: "Well, Yale didn't have scientists a century earlier. They were teaching Greek and they were teaching logic."
- **Speaker 2** [0:17:59]: "So at 3 p.m. on September 4th, Edison flicked on the switch here at J.P. Morgan's office."
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:17:34]: "J.P. Morgan's bank and a bunch of investors, they put up the money for the power plant."
- **Speaker 2** [0:18:06]: "It went on. And as did, lights all over the district. About a square mile of lower Manhattan suddenly was lit by electricity."
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:18:15]: "if you look at his notebooks, constantly he's going through and comparing the cost of what he's doing to what the cost of a gas system is."
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:19:06]: "He needed patents, a way to protect his ideas so no one would steal them. He needed a company, a way a bunch of different investors could come together and risk money"
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:19:33]: "when it was found health department men were trying to photograph the smokestacks, scouts were put on the company's roof, who ordered the feeding of coal stopped whenever photographers appeared."
- **Bill Nordhaus** [0:20:48]: "20 ,000 hours, yeah. I mean, you basically, you have your house lit up, you have your streets lit up, you have all your equipment on"
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:21:41]: "This is John Edmond. He's one of the founders of a company called Creep. They make LED light bulbs, which, of course, are much more efficient than regular bulbs."
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:00:46]: "Last week, Bill Nordhaus died at the age of 85."
- **Jacob Goldstein** [0:00:46]: "And a few years after we talked to him for this episode, he actually won the Econ Nobel for his work on the economics of climate change."

## Transcript

**[0:00:00] Speaker 5:** This episode's sponsor is HubSpot, which offers the following message. What if instead of updating your CRM, your CRM updated you? HubSpot's self-updating CRM keeps your customer context current so you can win more deals. Learn more at HubSpot.com.

**[0:00:16] Jacob Goldstein:** Hey, it's Jacob Goldstein. There is an episode of Planet Money that I co-hosted a long time ago that I still think about a lot, like at least once a week. And at the heart of the show is what I think is the biggest, most important lesson that I learned covering economics. And that is this. The pie can get bigger. It is at least theoretically possible for everybody to be better off. The economist whose work is at the center of the show is a guy named Bill Nordhaus.

**[0:00:46] Jacob Goldstein:** And a few years after we talked to him for this episode, he actually won the Econ Nobel for his work on the economics of climate change. Last week, Bill Nordhaus died at the age of 85. And so today, we are rerunning this episode in his memory. I hope you like it.

**[0:01:04] Speaker 5:** This is Planet Money from NPR.

**[0:01:09] Jacob Goldstein:** Long before there were light bulbs, there was fat. For thousands of years, if you wanted to light up your cave, your mud hut, or if you were really lucky, your castle, you had to find some fat, something to use for a wick, maybe some moss, maybe a piece of fabric. and you had to light it on fire. This was not easy. Even today, it's a hard way to get light. Adam and I? Yeah, hi. Do you sell fat, maybe beef fat?

**[0:01:37] Jacob Goldstein:** No. I don't carry that, no. Okay, thanks very much. Thank you. Hi, do you sell fat, like beef fat? No, we don't sell any of that. Suet? No. Okay. Okay. Thanks very much. That's your videos? Yeah, hi. Do you sell beef fat? Yeah, that we have all the time. How much is that? $2.98 a pound. Okay, great. Thanks very much. You're welcome. Bye. I got two pounds. A big, nasty lump of fat came from around the cow's kidney.

**[0:02:07] Jacob Goldstein:** I got some twine from the hardware store, and I went home to my apartment to try and make candles. God. It's a little harder to chop than, you might think. It kind of sticks to itself. I put the fat on the stove. It's pretty melted. It smells really nasty. It's like animal nasty. I strained it, then I started dipping the wicks into it. Dipping, dipping. You have to let the fat dry, then you have to dip the wick some more.

**[0:02:47] Jacob Goldstein:** More dipping. It was maybe, I don't know, 45 minutes or so of dipping. Dip. Dip. I got kind of dip crazy in there. Dip. Dip. After hours of work, not counting raising the cow or killing the cow or making the twine, I had six tiny, crooked, smelly candles. Hello and welcome to Planet Money. I'm Jacob Goldstein. And I'm David Kestenbaum. Today on the show, the story of how we got from dim little candles made out of cow fat to as much light as we want at the flick of a switch.

**[0:03:24] Jacob Goldstein:** And I don't think I'm exaggerating here. This one little story, it explains why we are where we are today. Why billions of people don't have to worry about starving today. Why we aren't all subsistence farmers. Why we can afford to have artists and massage therapists and plumbers. And yes, radio reporters doing stories about the history of light.

**[0:03:52] Speaker 5:** Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors.

**[0:03:56] Speaker 2:** This message comes from LinkedIn. As a small business owner, you wear many hats. You're the owner, the marketer, the seller, the hirer. With LinkedIn, you have the tools to help you boost your visibility, find prospective customers, and find the best team for your small business, all in one place. So while LinkedIn can't hang up all of your hats, it makes it easier to wear them all. Learn more at linkedin.com slash planet money show. This message comes from Capital One.

**[0:04:50] Speaker 2:** Capital One offers checking accounts with no fees or minimums. What's in your wallet? Terms apply. See CapitalOne.com slash bank guy for details. Capital One

**[0:05:01] Jacob Goldstein:** N.A. Member FDIC. Jacob, you brought these scraggly little candles in the office. I'm holding them up here. They look, uh, they look a little gnarled. They're definitely not straight and they're not like sleek. No, it looks like some mold has grown on a... On a string. On a string, yeah. So you brought these candles into the office here and we wanted to show them to an expert. And we sat down with this woman, Jane Brox.

**[0:05:28] Jacob Goldstein:** Jane wrote a book called Brilliant, The Evolution of Artificial Light. So I made a few different candles. I tried...

**[0:05:36] Jane Brox:** Oh, look, they're beautiful. I thought they're beautiful.

**[0:05:40] Jacob Goldstein:** You're going to be a total disaster.

**[0:05:43] Jane Brox:** In the olden days. If a mother was trying to teach her daughter to make candles, she would not be pleased with these candles. But we'll see what happens.

**[0:05:54] Jacob Goldstein:** I was afraid when we lit these things that we might set off the fire alarm or the sprinkler system in the office. I mean, that is how weird it is to have light from fire these days. I was afraid we weren't going to be able to light them at all. I mean, it's just beef fat and twine. But we pulled out a lighter.

**[0:06:10] Jane Brox:** Oh, we have light. Great. That's not too bad. Should we see how long it lasts?

**[0:06:18] Jacob Goldstein:** It's not pretty, but I'm very impressed.

**[0:06:20] Jane Brox:** It's a beautiful color. Look at the nice yellow flame, wouldn't you say?

**[0:06:25] Jacob Goldstein:** Dude, you made a candle. Jane says that the quest for this, for something that gives you light after the sun goes down, drove people to do all kinds of things. In the United States, in the Pacific Northwest, Native Americans used dried salmon. They basically made a salmon candle. In the tropics, people would catch fireflies and try to make a kind of firefly lantern. And then there's this bird called the petrel.

**[0:06:49] Jane Brox:** The storm petrel in the north of Scotland, which is a very oily seabird, which they'd catch and dry and thread a wick down its throat and then light it. And then that was a lamp.

**[0:07:05] Jacob Goldstein:** Just carry around a dead bird?

**[0:07:06] Jane Brox:** Well, it would be on a table. and I would imagine they'd have a little storage area with a lot of dead storm petrels. Martha, we need another petrol.

**[0:07:21] Jacob Goldstein:** The petrol supply is getting low. These ways of making light were all a huge hassle. They took a lot of work. It was not just that I didn't know what I was doing when I made those candles. The writer Harriet Beecher Stowe said making candles from animal fat was seven times as bad as washing clothes. I mean, think about it. You've got to get a cow. You've got to raise the cow. You've got to have food to feed the cow.

**[0:07:44] Jacob Goldstein:** You've got to kill the cow. You've got to get the fat out of the cow. You've got to put the fat in your Cuisinart. Which isn't going to be invented for 100 years. From an economic perspective, if you want to try to quantify how much of a pain in the butt it is to make something, or at least how hard it is to get that thing, you can ask a simple question. How much does it cost?

**[0:08:03] Jacob Goldstein:** Bill Nordhaus, an economist at Yale a while back, got obsessed with this question. He decided he wanted to calculate exactly how expensive light was thousands of years ago and how that cost changed over time. Because light, you know, light is this thing society has needed and sought forever. It was a way to track progress, not just in light, but in all kinds of things. Unfortunately, in order to do this, he needed to know how much things cost thousands of years ago, like in ancient Babylon.

**[0:08:31] Jacob Goldstein:** He wasn't even sure those numbers existed, but they did.

**[0:08:34] Bill Nordhaus:** I ran into a woman at Yale, and she, believe it or not, it's just unbelievable, actually, she actually had wage data and price data from the Babylonian era, so 4 ,000 years ago.

**[0:08:51] Jacob Goldstein:** So now he has these numbers, but he needs to know one other thing. How much light are people getting for their money? In ancient Babylon, people used lamps for light, so Nordhaus decided to make one.

**[0:09:03] Bill Nordhaus:** I did this in my dining room. Where else?

**[0:09:07] Jacob Goldstein:** He buys an ancient-style lamp from a catalog. He gets it burning. To measure how bright it is, he borrows a light meter from a facility's guy at Yale, and he does some science.

**[0:09:17] Bill Nordhaus:** And I would just measure it and write it down, just the way you see in the old movies, some guy in his lab coat writing down the measurements.

**[0:09:26] Jacob Goldstein:** Jacob, odd little note here. I happen to be taking Nordhaus's economics class right around this time, which I will say was a pretty serious, like, no-nonsense class. And it is so funny for me to think that at night he was going home and measuring ancient lamplight in his dining room with a light meter. So he does this, the light meter in the ancient lamp, and he has his numbers. But now he has to figure out a way to compare the price of light over thousands of years.

**[0:09:51] Jacob Goldstein:** So here's one measure he uses. If you take a day's wages, you work all day, you take all the money you earn in that day, and you spend it on light, how many minutes could you light up a small room at night with as much light as you get from today's modern light bulb? Here's the answer for ancient Babylon.

**[0:10:08] Bill Nordhaus:** Maybe 10 minutes. It was really expensive.

**[0:10:12] Jacob Goldstein:** An entire day's wages got you the equivalent of 10 minutes of light from a kind of dim light bulb. Economists talk a lot about productivity, how much one person can produce with a day's labor. And back then, the answer was not much. I mean, everything was hard. Growing food was hard. Making candles, for instance, took hours. And it used up fat. Fat, which, by the way, was expensive because raising animals was hard. This was a world where when the sun went down, almost everyone lived in the dark.

**[0:10:41] Jacob Goldstein:** And this may sound sort of romantic, but basically it was awful. The dark was not some beautiful thing you went out and explored. It was dangerous. It was something that trapped you. In Paris, at one point, there was actually a law that said every night, everybody has to give their keys to a magistrate, go home, and lock themselves in the house. And for basically 4 ,000 years, very little happens with light or with the economy in general.

**[0:11:05] Jacob Goldstein:** Most people work all day, and that gets them enough to eat. The way things get better, the way an economy grows, the way people get richer, is that someone comes up with a better way to do something, a way that takes a little less work. Over time, there are small improvements in life and in light. The Romans figure out how to make a lamp that's a little more efficient. People start to use whale oil. This, of course, is very, very bad for whales.

**[0:11:31] Jacob Goldstein:** But whales have a lot of fat. They were like these big swimming sources of fuel. Still, even when you get all the way to the 1700s, life still looks more like ancient Babylon than the modern world. People still travel the same way, by foot, by horse, by sailing ship. Most people are still subsistence farmers, usually living in some kind of hut, trying to grow enough food not to starve to death. Year after year, there are tiny gains in productivity, little bits of economic growth, but not a lot.

**[0:11:59] Jacob Goldstein:** And light? Light still comes from finding stuff that's lying around and just lighting it on fire. Again, economist Bill Nordhaus.

**[0:12:07] Bill Nordhaus:** As you look at the picture of what happened here, it's economic history in a nutshell. From Babylonian times to around 1800, there were, even though there were improvements, as best we can tell, they were very modest. And then around 1800 in the lighting, you can see it so clearly in lighting. It's just an enormous change in the pace of improvement.

**[0:12:30] Jacob Goldstein:** What happens in the 1800s is a few things. We start to really actively experiment. We try to discover stuff. And around 1850, a guy in Canada comes up with something that's not just a slightly better wick or a slightly more efficient lamp. It is this magical liquid. With the right techniques, you can get it from coal or oil. This big breakthrough? Kerosene. Not cutting edge now. But back then, Jane Brock says, kerosene was a huge deal.

**[0:12:58] Jane Brox:** When the first kerosene lamps came out, it was, as one historian said, it was the kind of oil people had dreamed about for centuries.

**[0:13:06] Jacob Goldstein:** It was brighter, it was cleaner, and importantly, it was much cheaper.

**[0:13:12] Bill Nordhaus:** You work a day, you get about an hour of whale oil. Kerosene, you get about five hours. Wow. So it's about five times more efficient. Kerosene lit the world and saved the whales.

**[0:13:31] Jacob Goldstein:** So if kerosene was so great, why did it take the world so long to find it? Science. This idea of professional scientists, this idea that there are lots of people who go to work every day at universities and do experiments. In the 1800s, this is still a new thing. If you happen to be president of Yale University, this is around the time when you're thinking, you know, maybe we should get one of those science departments.

**[0:13:55] Bill Nordhaus:** Why weren't they doing those experiments a century earlier? Well, Yale didn't have scientists a century earlier. They were teaching Greek and they were teaching logic.

**[0:14:06] Jacob Goldstein:** Now all these scientists are working on better ways to make light. And light is getting cheaper. More people are using it. No more locking yourself in and huddling in the dark all night. Around this time, streetlights start popping up. And people start going out at night. So we have kerosene. What's the next big advance after that?

**[0:14:22] Bill Nordhaus:** Okay, next big advance after that is the electric lamp.

**[0:14:26] Jacob Goldstein:** The big one.

**[0:14:28] Bill Nordhaus:** Well, you might think so.

**[0:14:30] Jacob Goldstein:** You know, Jacob, I thought I knew the story of the light bulb. You know, Thomas Edison, the great inventor, story about science and innovation. You know, Edison trying all these different filaments, these different designs and finally getting one that'll glow for hours. But this Eureka light bulb moment, it is not it's not enough to get you to the world of really cheap light because Edison needed this other thing. He needed money. He needed lots and lots of money.

**[0:14:55] Jacob Goldstein:** After the break, how many bankers does it take to turn on a light bulb? One, J.P. Morgan, more or less.

**[0:15:03] Speaker 2:** Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from LinkedIn. As a small business owner, you wear many hats. You're the owner, the marketer, the seller, the hirer. With LinkedIn, you have the tools to help you boost your visibility, find prospective customers, and find the best team for your small business, all in one place. So while LinkedIn can't hang up all of your hats, it makes it easier to wear them all.

**[0:15:29] Speaker 2:** Learn more at linkedin.com slash planet money show. This message comes from BILT. Rent and mortgages keep getting more expensive. That's why BILT created three credit cards designed to offer rich rewards on everything you spend on. You can earn up to 1.25x points on every housing payment with no transaction fee, which can be redeemed for flights, hotels, a future housing payment, and more. Apply at joinbilt.com slash money. Terms apply, subject to approval and eligibility.

**[0:16:27] Speaker 2:** Built cards are issued by Column N.A., member FDIC, pursuant to license from MasterCard International Incorporated.

**[0:16:36] Jacob Goldstein:** So right now we're at the location of the original power plant in lower Manhattan. This is Paul Israel. He's an Edison scholar. We met him here in New York City. We're standing in front of this plaque. It says Thomas Alva Edison in big letters. And there's this picture, an etching. And the image that they show is the generator room of the power plant. With a bunch of guys in really long mustaches and hats. Right. This is 1882.

**[0:17:03] Jacob Goldstein:** So lots of mustaches at that point. The money part of building the power plant is so important that when they finally get this historic thing completed in 1882, they get the power plant built, and they're ready to turn it on. Edison is not here. He's a few blocks away at a big, impressive stone building, Where today there is another plaque to a guy you may have heard of, J.P. Morgan. It reads, The capitalists' capitalists, known throughout the world of finance, sought out by presidents, helped bankroll the industrialization of America.

**[0:17:34] Jacob Goldstein:** Can't write that on too many people's plaques. J.P. Morgan's bank and a bunch of investors, they put up the money for the power plant. To be clear, they built this great, big, expensive, complicated power station, the first central power station in the world, right? basically inventing electric light, and when they turn it on, Edison is not there. Right. He was where he needed to be with the people who had funded the whole thing.

**[0:17:59] Speaker 2:** So at 3 p.m. on September 4th, Edison flicked on the switch here at J.P. Morgan's office.

**[0:18:05] Jacob Goldstein:** And what happened?

**[0:18:06] Speaker 2:** It went on. And as did, lights all over the district. About a square mile of lower Manhattan suddenly was lit by electricity.

**[0:18:15] Jacob Goldstein:** You think of Edison the inventor, but even more important is Edison the businessman. At the time, buildings in lower Manhattan were running off gas lights, and Edison knew that was who he had to be. So he spent a lot of time thinking about economics. Yeah, well, he did. In fact, if you look at his notebooks, constantly he's going through and comparing the cost of what he's doing to what the cost of a gas system is. You never think about that.

**[0:18:39] Jacob Goldstein:** Well, and that's what made him such a good innovator, right? Because he recognized that these economic questions were just as important in designing what he did in the laboratory. When you think of economic growth, how much do you think of it as coming from individual eureka moments and inventions and stuff like that? And how much is it the stuff around it, like the ability to finance these things, the economic structure around it? So most of it is actually the structure around it.

**[0:19:06] Jacob Goldstein:** To light a square mile of lower Manhattan, Edison needed a whole financial system. He needed patents, a way to protect his ideas so no one would steal them. He needed a company, a way a bunch of different investors could come together and risk money, a lot of money, to build a power plant and lay wires so you could try this crazy thing, light without fire. Edison comes along at a time when all this machinery, patents, corporations, banks is in place.

**[0:19:33] Jacob Goldstein:** There were consequences to growth. I mean, those first power plants burned coal and pollution was pretty bad. Edison built a huge power plant on the east side of Manhattan. And at some point, the city health department got involved. And this is according to the New York Times, quote, when it was found health department men were trying to photograph the smokestacks, scouts were put on the company's roof, who ordered the feeding of coal stopped whenever photographers appeared.

**[0:19:55] Jacob Goldstein:** On the other hand, you now had a city lit up with cheap electric light. Tradeoffs. Around this time, everything is getting faster and cheaper. Scientists keep making new discoveries. You get the internal combustion engine, the tractor. For the first time in human history, most people don't have to work as farmers. This went on decade after decade all through the 20th century. All kinds of things got much cheaper, like light. And if you look at the really long arc here, it's amazing.

**[0:20:22] Jacob Goldstein:** I mean, go all the way back to the Babylonians, okay? Babylonians worked all day. You got the equivalent of 10 minutes, 10 minutes of light. 4 ,000 years later in the 19th century with kerosene lamps, things are better. A day's labor gets you five hours of light. And by the time Nordhaus does his light study in the 1990s, if you work a day, how much light do you get?

**[0:20:45] Bill Nordhaus:** Maybe 20 ,000.

**[0:20:47] Jacob Goldstein:** 20 ,000 hours?

**[0:20:48] Bill Nordhaus:** 20 ,000 hours, yeah. I mean, you basically, you have your house lit up, you have your streets lit up, you have all your equipment on, you have your air conditioner on, you have all the stuff you're doing. is you're saturated with light. The main thing is you're saturated with light.

**[0:21:09] Jacob Goldstein:** Economic growth isn't all good. There is pollution. There are environmental consequences. But fundamentally, growth is about things getting faster, getting cheaper, getting more efficient. It's about doing the same amount of work and being able to buy 20 ,000 hours of light instead of 10 minutes. And as a result, it's about being able to work less or to buy other stuff that used to be just for the wealthy. We can buy books. We can take vacations. Even today, there are still people who go to work every day and try to figure out how to make a better light bulb.

**[0:21:41] Jacob Goldstein:** This morning, I went to the bulb factory for about an hour. This is John Edmond. He's one of the founders of a company called Creep. They make LED light bulbs, which, of course, are much more efficient than regular bulbs. You'll try and experiment, and you'll say, holy crap, we just got more light out of this thing. by using this contact material or flipping the chip over. Jacob, when we talk about economic growth every year, you know, when we say the economy grew a couple percent, that happens because every day out there, someone somewhere in some corner of the economy has figured out how to do something a little bit better or a little bit faster or a little less expensively.

**[0:22:20] Jacob Goldstein:** And this process has gone on year after year for hundreds of years now. And one question I always have when I think about this is like, and not just with light, But this whole story of constant economic growth, constant productivity improvement, my question is, is it going to go on forever? Or at some point, we're going to run out of ways to make things better? We might double from where we are now, but we're not going to be tripling and quadrupling it because there are physical limits.

**[0:22:46] Jacob Goldstein:** I mean, will a car go a million miles an hour? No. It just won't. It's not going to happen. For the light bulb, at least, John says, we may actually be near the end. That episode was from 2014. Today, I host a podcast called Business History. It's a show about the history of business. If you like Planet Money, I think you'd like business history. We recently did an episode on the banana business in the early 20th century.

**[0:23:12] Jacob Goldstein:** It's got capitalism and imperialism and communism. It's got all of the isms, and it's got bananas. The show is called Business History. Check it out. Also, please sign up for the Planet Money newsletter. Every week, the newsletter takes an issue in the news or your life and finds the economics behind it. This past week, newsletter writer Greg Rizalski looked at California's proposed wealth tax. He reviewed the arguments over whether the tax would generate money for the state or chase it away.

**[0:23:41] Jacob Goldstein:** Sign up at npr.org slash planet money newsletter. That's npr.org slash planet money newsletter. Or just click the link in the show notes. This episode was originally produced by Caitlin Kenney and Damiano Marchetti. I'm Jacob Goldstein. This is NPR. Thanks for listening.

**[0:24:05] Speaker 2:** Stay tuned for the following announcements and messages from our sponsors. This message comes from Google Workspace with a Gemini. Ever notice how every new AI tool asks you to explain your business to it all over again? Google Workspace with Gemini skips that. You get Google's AI built right into the premium versions of Gmail, Google Docs, Sheets, and more. No new tools, no extra logins, just one subscription that gives you personalized AI right inside your actual workflow.

**[0:24:34] Speaker 2:** Try Google Workspace with Gemini at goo.gle slash workspace with Gemini. This message comes from NPR sponsor Charles Schwab. Financial decisions can be tricky. Your biases can lead you astray. Financial Decoder, an original podcast from Charles Schwab, can help. Download the latest episode and subscribe at schwab.com slash financial decoder.
