In brief
Miriam Vogel, CEO of EqualAI, argues that AI should be governed like cars: government sets baseline safety rules and standards, while local rules can vary. She says almost every company now uses AI in important decisions, so responsible practice is not optional. Trust depends on knowing who an AI system was tested on, and on clear documentation, accountability and audits.
The tension is between moving fast and building trust. Vogel says the U.S. must stay competitive with countries that have more resources, yet she believes it wins by listening to diverse stakeholders. She sees progress in agency statements, voluntary commitments and congressional education, but says jurisdiction is unclear, deepfakes are a growing risk, and lawmakers must learn quickly.
Questions
Does AI need brand-new laws, or do existing laws already apply?
Vogel says many existing laws already apply, citing the FTC on exaggerated AI claims, the CFPB on unexplained financial decisions, and an EEOC and Department of Justice statement on civil rights law. She agrees there are new questions and risks, and that overlapping agency authority needs sorting out quickly.
Why does Vogel compare AI regulation to cars?
Most people cannot build a car but trust it because government sets safety rules for drivers and mechanics. She says AI needs national standards like that, while local rules, like speed limits, can vary by region.
What should a company do to use AI responsibly?
Vogel says to choose a framework such as the NIST risk management framework, make a senior leader accountable, document what was tested and on which populations, and audit regularly. She says doing this builds trust with consumers.
What is the NIST AI risk management framework?
It is a framework that Congress told NIST, the National Institute of Standards and Technology in the Commerce Department, to create. Vogel says it works for any industry, company size or legal setting, and helps organizations ask the right questions about AI risks and opportunities.
Why is AI bias a problem in healthcare?
Vogel says AI tools can post impressive success rates, such as in spotting cancer, without anyone knowing which patient groups they were tested on. A patient outside those groups could get a wrong result that a clinician trusts.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Miriam Vogel led President Barack Obama's Equal Pay Task Force and helped create implicit bias training for federal law enforcement at the U.S. Department of Justice.
“So I led President Obama's Equal Pay Task Force and also helped create implicit bias training for federal law enforcement at the Department of Justice.”
0:01:47 · Miriam Vogel · Vogel's career
EqualAI was launched about five years before this episode, prompted by growing understanding of bias and hidden harms in AI.
“originally, five years ago, when we launched EqualAI, it was this confluence of events where we were first understanding that there were bias and hidden harms in this exciting technology”
0:02:21 · Miriam Vogel · EqualAI founding
Miriam Vogel argues that almost all companies today are effectively AI companies because they use AI in pivotal functions.
“Almost all companies today are AI companies, if you look at the way that they're using AI in pivotal functions.”
0:03:41 · Miriam Vogel · AI adoption
Miriam Vogel says competitors abroad are advancing AI at full speed with much greater access to resources and investment than the United States has.
“There are competitors out there that are going at this full speed with much greater access to resources and investment than, for instance, we have in the United States.”
0:05:18 · Miriam Vogel · AI competition
Miriam Vogel says AI tools for identifying cancer are reported to outperform doctors, but it is unknown for which patient populations those success rates hold.
“We're seeing AI do better than the doctors. That said, we don't know for whom.”
0:06:42 · Miriam Vogel · Medical AI
Vijay Pande notes that children generally do not take part in clinical trials and are dosed like small adults.
“certainly children generally don't go through clinical trials and we dose them like small adults for better or worse”
0:07:03 · Vijay Pande · Clinical trials
EqualAI convened an AI summit of leading thinkers to agree on must-haves for being a responsible AI actor, which fed into its forthcoming white paper.
“we have an AI summit and we came together with some of the leading thinkers to decide on together what are some of the absolute must-haves if you're going to be a responsible AI actor.”
0:09:24 · Miriam Vogel · EqualAI white paper
Miriam Vogel uses car regulation as a model for AI: national government sets safety standards, while rules like speed limits can be set locally.
“Now, speed limits, however, are not necessarily federal or nationalized. That is something that can be region, neighborhood specific.”
0:00:28 · Miriam Vogel · AI regulation
Miriam Vogel says the Federal Trade Commission has said companies that exaggerate their AI capabilities fall within its authority.
“if they were talking about their AI capabilities in ways that were exaggerated, well, FTC has purview over you.”
0:11:09 · Miriam Vogel · FTC oversight
Miriam Vogel says companies that give financial scores without being able to explain a denial fall under the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.
“If you're giving financial scores and not able to explain what the bases are for denying somebody an opportunity, you've got the CFPB.”
0:11:47 · Miriam Vogel · CFPB oversight
The Equal Employment Opportunity Commission issued a joint statement with the Department of Justice saying civil rights laws apply whether or not AI is used.
“They then went a step forward a year later and had a historic, unprecedented joint statement with the Department of Justice saying, The civil rights laws on the books are absolutely applicable, whether it's AI use or not.”
0:11:47 · Miriam Vogel · Civil rights law
Congress mandated that the National Institute of Standards and Technology, part of the Commerce Department, create an AI risk management framework.
“Congress mandated that NIST, the National Institute for Standards and Technology at the Commerce Department, create this framework.”
0:14:06 · Miriam Vogel · NIST framework
The NIST AI risk management framework was designed to apply regardless of industry, organization size or legal setting.
“And what they did is they made it industry agnostic, size agnostic, and law agnostic.”
0:14:36 · Miriam Vogel · NIST framework
Miriam Vogel advises companies to run regular audits because AI systems keep learning new patterns and can develop new risks.
“You need to have an audit system. You need to know that your AI will continue to iterate. It will learn new patterns.”
0:15:33 · Miriam Vogel · AI audits
Miriam Vogel cites a fake image of the Pentagon on fire and fake video of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky conceding to Vladimir Putin as examples of AI disinformation.
“We've seen pictures go around the internet of the Pentagon on fire. We've seen images and video of President Zelensky conceding to Vladimir Putin.”
0:18:15 · Miriam Vogel · Deepfakes
Miriam Vogel says the market reacted in real time to the fake Pentagon fire image.
“With the Pentagon example, we saw the market respond in real time to that disinformation.”
0:18:54 · Miriam Vogel · Deepfakes
Frontier AI model companies made voluntary commitments with the White House to use watermarking or other labels so deepfakes are identified as such.
“as was part of the voluntary commitments we saw that frontier model companies make with the White House last month, where they committed to having some kind of watermarking or other labels to ensure that deep fakes are identified as such.”
0:19:29 · Miriam Vogel · Voluntary commitments · 2023
Miriam Vogel says the average age of Congress is in the upper 60s, which she cites as a challenge for understanding AI.
“I think the average age of Congress is in the upper 60s.”
0:22:26 · Miriam Vogel · Congress
Senator Chuck Schumer started an Insight Forum bringing leading thinkers from Silicon Valley and civil society to educate himself and other senators about AI.
“Senator Schumer has started this insights forum where he's bringing on some of the leading thinkers from Silicon Valley, from civil society and elsewhere to come educate himself and several of his peers.”
0:22:56 · Miriam Vogel · Senate AI forum · 2023
Miriam Vogel says that when she began AI work about five years earlier, Congress held AI hearings quarterly at best, versus a few a day by this episode.
“I think when I started this work five years ago, there were quarterly AI hearings at best.”
0:22:56 · Miriam Vogel · Congressional hearings
Miriam Vogel says useful AI legislation has already addressed matters such as barring AI from nuclear armament and requiring watermarking of deepfakes.
“that it should not be used in nuclear armament, that it should be used in some educational spaces, making sure there's watermarking when you're talking about deep fakes”
0:23:33 · Miriam Vogel · AI legislation · 2023