In brief
CISA's Deputy Director Nitin Natarajan argues that protecting critical infrastructure, especially healthcare, depends on partnerships rather than regulation. CISA covers 16 sectors and cannot defend them alone, so it works voluntarily with HHS, industry and international allies. He says cybersecurity must be treated as an enterprise risk owned by CEOs and boards, and that vendors must build secure products by default.
The central tension is that healthcare is a prime target but has little money to defend itself. Natarajan describes under-resourced sectors, rapid pandemic-era technology choices that were never fully reviewed, and AI tools that arrive without clear visibility. His answer is more transparency, plain-English education for executives, and shifting security earlier in decisions. He also stresses that every person has a security role, not only technical staff.
Questions
What does CISA actually do?
Natarajan says CISA is America's cyber defense agency and also handles physical security. It supports 16 critical infrastructure sectors and is responsible for cybersecurity across the federal civilian executive branch, meaning everything except the Defense Department and the Intelligence Community.
Can CISA force hospitals or companies to improve their cybersecurity?
No. Natarajan says CISA is mainly a partnerships agency using voluntary mechanisms and is not a regulator in this space. It focuses on education, such as helping CEOs and boards understand the risks they are accepting.
Why is healthcare such a big cybersecurity concern?
Natarajan says healthcare is both a target-rich and resource-poor sector, with thin profit margins and limited room for security investment. It also depends on a wide chain of organizations, from pharma and labs to insurers, that rely more and more on IT and operational technology.
What does 'secure by design' mean?
It means technology makers should build products that are secure out of the box, rather than leaving customers to fix weaknesses. Natarajan gives the example of ending default logins like 'admin' and 'password', and says customers should not pay extra for security.
How is AI changing the cyber risk picture?
Natarajan says CISA looks at AI both as a tool for its own defense and as something adversaries could use to make attacks faster and easier. Host Ed Gaudet adds that vendors are adding AI to products hospitals already own, often without much visibility, and Natarajan notes similar concerns about vendors changing where data is stored.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency works with 16 critical infrastructure sectors, including dams, emergency services, finance, food and agriculture, and healthcare and public health.
“we look at 16 critical infrastructure sectors and everything from dams and emergency services to the financial sector, food and agriculture, and healthcare and public health.”
0:01:01 · Nitin Natarajan · CISA sectors
The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency is responsible for cybersecurity of the federal civilian executive branch, excluding the Defense Department and the Intelligence Community.
“we are actually responsible for the cybersecurity of the entire federal civilian executive branch of government. So that's everybody except for the Defense Department and the Intelligence Community.”
0:01:49 · Nitin Natarajan · Federal cybersecurity
Nitin Natarajan spent 13 years as a first responder in New York, working as a flight medic, paramedic and firefighter.
“I spent 13 years as a first responder here in New York. I was a flight medic and paramedic and firefighter for years.”
0:02:38 · Nitin Natarajan · Career background
Nitin Natarajan was recruited to the federal government to work for HHS and was then sent to the White House to work on critical infrastructure protection and policy.
“Got recruited there to the federal government to do that for HHS. They shipped me over to the White House to do critical infrastructure protection there and then critical infrastructure policy.”
0:03:02 · Nitin Natarajan · Career background
After leaving the White House, Nitin Natarajan worked at the Environmental Protection Agency in its office of land and emergency management.
“I took a detour when I left the White House, I went to the EPA. And what's funny, they recruited me to help their office of land and emergency management.”
0:20:25 · Nitin Natarajan · Career background
In 2023 the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency prioritized four sectors: election security, K-12 schools, water and wastewater, and healthcare and public health.
“when you look at CESA in 23, we looked prioritizing four sectors. We looked at election security, K-12 schools, water and wastewater, and health and public health.”
0:03:45 · Nitin Natarajan · CISA priorities · 2023
Natarajan says CISA's view of healthcare includes medical manufacturing, pharma, labs, blood, biotech, health IT, insurers, payers and HMOs, not just hospitals.
“it's about medical manufacturing, pharma, labs, blood, biotech, health IT, insurers, payers, HMOs, every aspect that's required for that clinician to provide care at the bedside.”
0:04:10 · Nitin Natarajan · Healthcare scope
The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency has an effort called corporate cyber responsibility to move cybersecurity discussions from CISOs to CEOs and boards.
“we're looking at an effort we have underway of corporate cyber responsibility. How do we elevate that discussion of cybersecurity from our CISOs and physical security from our chief security officers to the C-suite, to the CEOs and boards of directors?”
0:04:39 · Nitin Natarajan · Corporate responsibility
Natarajan describes risk as a three-legged stool of identification, mitigation and acceptance, and says acceptance is the most overlooked.
“risk to me is the three-legged stool. We talk a lot about risk identification. We spend a lot of time on risk mitigation. We forget the third leg, which is risk acceptance.”
0:05:01 · Nitin Natarajan · Risk management
The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency promotes secure by design and secure by default so that products are secure out of the box.
“really looking at secure by design, secure by default. How do we force industry to start producing products that are secure out of the box, right?”
0:05:48 · Nitin Natarajan · Secure by design
Natarajan says the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency is mainly a partnerships agency that uses voluntary mechanisms and is not a regulator in the area of corporate cyber responsibility.
“CIS is predominantly a partnerships agency. So we're having conversations about how we can do this with that voluntary mechanism. Obviously, we're not a regulator in that space.”
0:06:37 · Nitin Natarajan · CISA role
Natarajan argues that mergers and acquisitions in healthcare should include due diligence on the cybersecurity of the organization being joined to a network.
“But we're about to bring an organization either onto your network or connect their network to yours. Have we done our due diligence on our cybersecurity?”
0:07:29 · Nitin Natarajan · Mergers and acquisitions
Natarajan says the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency is studying how adversaries might use artificial intelligence against the United States.
“the other aspect that we're looking at CISA is understanding how our adversaries are potentially using AI against us.”
0:09:24 · Nitin Natarajan · AI threats
Natarajan says some companies learned that the country where their vendor stored their data had changed, which alters their risk.
“I've heard from companies where they thought their data was being stored, the country in which they thought their data was being stored was being moved.”
0:10:39 · Nitin Natarajan · Data location
Natarajan says it is a misconception that AI runs on one global central model.
“there's a perception that there's one model, right? There's some global central, you know, singular model, which we know is not the case of how these systems and tools work.”
0:11:03 · Nitin Natarajan · AI literacy
Natarajan says that in pandemic planning discussions around 2007-2008, the main worry was that on-premises IT could not handle everyone teleworking during an H1N1 outbreak.
“our biggest concern for actually was that if we flipped that switch during H1N1, H1N1, and people had to go home overnight, the IT infrastructure couldn't take it.”
0:13:20 · Nitin Natarajan · Pandemic planning · 2007
CISA's Secure by Design document was first published with eight nations on board and a revision months later had 16.
“we published the first version in the springtime. We had eight nations on board. We had 16 with a revision just a handful of months later.”
0:16:15 · Nitin Natarajan · Secure by design
Natarajan says CISA's pre-ransomware notifications warn victims that an adversary is on their network before encryption, with over 800 sent in the year and over 85 in healthcare.
“are pre-ransfer notification, for instance, where we're able to actually make notifications when an adversary is on your network before they lock you up. Done over 800 this year, we've done over 85 in healthcare alone.”
0:16:43 · Nitin Natarajan · Ransomware notifications
Natarajan says the adversaries CISA defends against include cyber terrorists and cyber criminal organizations as well as nation-states such as Russia, China and Iran.
“we're not just talking, you know, Russia, China, Iran, or three. We're talking cyber terrorists, cyber criminal organizations.”
0:23:39 · Nitin Natarajan · Threat actors