Episode #68. The Health Industry Cybersecurity Strategic Plan Unveiled, with Greg Garcia, Executive Director of the Health Sector Coordinating Council Risk Never Sleeps ยท 27 Feb 2024 Source: https://www.censinet.com/ Transcript: https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/risk-never-sleeps/episode-68-the-health-industry-cybersecurity-strategic-plan-unveiled-with-greg-g-42dfba/ (via OpenNash Podcasts, machine-generated) Ed Gaudet, Welcome to Risk Never Sleeps, where we meet and get to know the people delivering patient care and protecting patient safety. I'm your host, Ed Gaudet. Ed Gaudet, Welcome to the Risk Never Sleeps podcast in which we learn about the people that are on the front lines delivering and protecting patient care. I'm Ed Gaudet, the host of our program. And today, I am pleased to be joined by my good friend, Greg Garcia, Executive Director for the Health Sector Coordinating Council. Welcome, Greg. Thank you, Ed. Glad to be here, as always. How are you? How are you doing? I'm just doing great. I'm just really excited about everything that we're doing in the council and a lot of the work that you personally are contributing to. So it's members like you that make this job really fun. And we've just got so much more work to do, even having done as much work as we already have over the past five years. So a lot going on today. Tell us about the announcement you just made at Vive. Oh, it was, today is a great day. We've been working for 20 months on producing our health industry cybersecurity strategic plan. This is something that pulled together almost 200 senior executives from within the sector coordinating council's membership, not just cybersecurity executives, but clinical and other management executives who were first looking at what are the major healthcare industry trends over the next five years, not having to do with cybersecurity at all, but what are the big industry trends like hospital at home, wearable and implantable devices, mergers and acquisitions across the healthcare industry and consolidations and many other things. And then what are the cybersecurity challenges that those trends present to us? And what should we be doing about it as an industry to get ourselves in better cybersecurity position, basically to upgrade ourselves from the critical condition that we were diagnosed in 2017 up to stable condition. That is, healthcare, cybersecurity needs to be in stable condition by the year 2029. So a fairly big undertaking. It's a continuation of the big undertaking that we have been doing over the past five years, but we needed to refresh that. There is nothing in this plan that will surprise anyone. It's really just more looking at what's the end state? What does the future of healthcare cybersecurity look like in 2029? And here's the roadmap for us to get there. And by us, I mean everybody. It is a shared responsibility across the healthcare sector, whether you are a health provider, small, large, medium, a hospital system or clinic, whether you're a medical device company or a pharmaceutical lab, whether you are a plan or a payer, whether you're a health IT company, all of them are part of this interconnected ecosystem. So, yes, it's a big undertaking for everybody. But if we do it collectively and every individual organization looks at strategic plan and asks themselves, well, where do I see myself in this plan? We have 10 major goals and 12 objectives that would implement those goals. There's something here for everybody. I think if we address this as a collective, as an industry imperative, all organized around the principle that cyber safety is patient safety, then I think we're going to succeed. Excellent, excellent. And can you take us through a little more of the details behind the plan itself? Yeah. So first, we started with, as I mentioned, we started with one of the big trends. So we really have to look at where is the industry headed? And from those trends, and I mentioned a couple of them, that we're going to have more disruptive technologies where we're seeing quantum computing and blockchain. We're seeing artificial intelligence and hospital at home and all kinds of new technologies that we're going to have to keep up with. we're seeing a continuation of financial stress among small, rural, critical access hospitals. And as long as they continue to be a weak link, weak cybersecurity link in the healthcare ecosystem, we need to address that. So there are many others. There are seven total industry trends that we identified. And from that, we said, okay, then what are the major goals that would, if we achieve them would materially, measurably address those industry trends. For example, if we say that there will be a continuation of mergers and acquisitions and consolidation, one of the goals is that healthcare cybersecurity needs to start at the top. That is a culture of cybersecurity. And that is in the C-suite. We have to develop a set of resources, simple and digestible for senior executive management across the industry, that healthcare cybersecurity is not just for the security team. It is a shared responsibility for everybody and that the C-suite establishes the culture within their organization and that cyber security needs to be a part of an overall risk management, enterprise risk management program. So things like that. And so as we go through these 10 major goals, and as we explain to the audience today at the Vive conference here in Los Angeles, we're asking each enterprise to just pick one of those goals. Another goal is, for example, we will have an incident response and information sharing system that is reflexive and always on. That means that we need to have better when incidents are happening. Just last week, we saw the incident of Change Health, a major event that's affecting a whole lot of healthcare organizations. How do we best respond to that to maintain operational continuity as an ecosystem? We're not there yet. So those are a couple of examples of how we can take the strategic plan in piece parts. You say it's a big undertaking. It's a lot easier undertaking if you just start with one, with your enterprise, with your industry group and consider how you can either implement or promote those major goals. I love that. I love that. And as you talked about those objectives, they also map to those measurable outcomes so we can start to measure that progress towards achieving those goals, which I think, again, makes it much more tangible than just a document that sits on a shelf. Well, yes. And you mentioned measurable outcomes, and that's a key point here. One of the things in the strategic plan that you will see, we've simplified it in terms of a table format. And on the far right-hand side of the table is a column that says sample measurable outcomes. What we want to be able to do is as this strategic plan is being digested by the community, and the community includes all of the healthcare stakeholders and government as well, Well, let's do a deeper dive. Okay, goal number seven. Okay, what are the measurable outcomes that would indicate to us that we have achieved goal number seven, or at least we are making progress on goal number seven? And then what are the actual metrics? Is it a number? 90 % of the surveyed healthcare industry is implementing the NIST cybersecurity framework or the HICCUP, the health industry cyber practices that we published. We need to, we will be starting up a new task group open to the entire membership or anyone else who wants to participate to really drill down on what are those measurable outcomes and the measures of success, the metrics. And then hopefully by the end of 2024, we will really, we will have that lined out. So now, then we've got something to shoot at and something to measure progress toward. then we know that by 2029, we should have a good, precise, numerical indication of how well we are doing. So that I or anyone else in our leadership occasionally were called up to Capitol Hill to testify before the Senate or House committees. And they'll ask, are we doing better today here in 2029 than we were five years ago? And I'd like to be able to say, yes, Madam Chairman, we are doing better. And here's how. Yeah, I love that. I love also the foundation is built on a set of guiding principles that keeps the scope manageable, too. So it's not only those things we're going to focus on, but those things we're not going to focus on, which is equally important. And then, which, again, was different from my perspective from the previous plan, this notion of mobilizing the industry. Talk about that in the context of the plan. That's a really important part of this, Ed. It takes the village. It takes the whole healthcare industry. It is a shared responsibility. And by mobilizing, we're just saying that today on publication day, we are seeing a lot of LinkedIn posts that say, hey, healthcare cybersecurity strategic plan with a link to it. We are implementing it. Our organization, my hospital, we are working this. You should too. I mean, when you think about the crowdsourcing of promoting, I would love it to go viral across the healthcare industry, so that every major organization and every small organization can say, yeah, we better be on this train. Why are we not on this train? We need to have that national culture that says this is an imperative and I as an organization have a responsibility to this. So at the most simple tactical level, that just means everyone ought to be out there promoting this on social media. Every time a senior executive goes to speak at a conference on health care or health care cybersecurity, they need to be talking about the health care strategic plan. Webinars and podcasts like Risk Never Sleeps. This is how we get the word out. That's the tactical communications, marketing, if you will, mobilization effort. But then where the rubber meets the road is talk is cheap. Where the rubber meets the road is when the organizations are actually doing something about it. They are making the investments. They are organizing. The small hospital may actually hire an IT security person for the first time. They might not call them a chief information security officer, but put somebody in charge. Start there. So every one of these goals and objectives has something for every organization across the healthcare system. Three Musketeers, man, all for one and one for all. I love it. I love it. And recently, HHS and a number of organizations came together to release the cybersecurity performance goals. So how do those relate to this overall plan? How should a CISO or a CIO think about those in relationship to the five-year plan? Yes, the cyber performance goals should be seen as some of those basic tactical table stakes that collectively would support various goals and objectives in the strategic plan. So it's all perfectly aligned. So you've always want to start with a high level strategic vision, and that's the strategic plan. And then from that, you need to break it down into operational tactics for how you get there. It's the stepping stone. So the CPGs is part, is among those stepping stones. And what's good about the CPGs is that we worked with HHS, we being the sector coordinating council, on what those CPGs would entail. And of course, you, Ed, and Censinet were part of helping us lay out the landscape of what are those vulnerabilities in the healthcare system that are most frequently exploited for a successful cyber attack? And then how do we position ourselves to address those vulnerabilities and to reduce the risk of cyber incidents happening based on those? And that's really the genesis of what the CPGs, the Cyber Performance Goals, was about, that we wanted to, we advised the government on what we thought based on that analysis and a lot of other reporting. What are those really most important, the essential Cyber Performance Goals and the enhanced Cyber Performance Goals? What are the most essential ones? What are the minimum controls that every health care organization needs to be implementing? And so that in turn, the healthcare CPGs align with Department of Homeland Security, CISA, the Cybersecurity Infrastructure Security Agency, developed broad cross-sector cyber performance goals for all of the critical industry sectors. So remember, we are just, healthcare is one of the critical industry sectors in the country, such as electricity and telecom and oil and gas and such. So our CPGs are really a mapping to the national cyber performance goals, but tailored specifically to what the healthcare industry needs. Great. Excellent. There were other folks involved. Obviously, a lot of folks came together to get this plan published today. Any groups you want to call out specifically? Or, for example, the folks at Deloitte, I know, did a lot of work on this. Absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah, we have. First off, we established in this really got kicked off in April of 2022 at our spring all hands meeting in Chicago. And so that was about 70 organizations who signed up for the strategic plan. And ultimately, it was it was co-led by two organizations, as with all of our sector council task groups. There is an industry and a government co-lead. The industry co-lead was Primera, and that is the CISO for Primera, Adrian Mayers. And then the government co-lead was FDA, Linda Ritchie. And then when it was clear that to do this right, we needed to outsource the facilitation, the drafting, the convening of our membership in order to build in all of the content. We took donations from our membership and those 10 funders who stepped up are recognized in the strategic plan. We hired Deloitte to do that. They have a very deep bench in health care and in cybersecurity. And it was a truly collaborative exercise in their working with our general membership in our all hands meetings. And then in the five-year plan, the strategic plan task group, the steering committee of about 40 organizations who participated. So what came together after 18 months was finalized at the end of last year and early this year. And so today is the big day. So a lot of people involved in it, not least of which, of course, is our chair, Eric Decker, the CISO for Intermountain, and Chris Tyberg, the CISO for Abbott. Yeah. The vice chair. Yeah. And the publication speaks for itself. It's an incredible piece of work, deliverable, collaborative, deliverable across the industry that I'd love your thoughts on how you think it differs from the previous five-year plan. And I know every year, every time we do these, we learn a little more and get better at this. Yeah, that's a great question. What guided our work as a sector council over the past five years was what you mentioned, the 2017 Healthcare Industry Cybersecurity Task Force, the HCIC. That was established by HHS. It had a couple of dozen industry and government experts from healthcare and cybersecurity. And they were, it was a task force that was directed by the Congress for HHS to a point. And they just had to answer two questions. Why is the healthcare industry getting hit so hard with cyber attack? Number one. And number two, what do we do about it? And so they laid it out in terms of six major imperatives. And under those major imperatives was a cascade of 105 action items, essentially a to-do list for the health industry. And in 2018, when the cybersecurity working group reorganized, we had this wonderful plan, task force report handed to us on a silver platter and said, go do it. And we did. So over the past five years, we have been addressing those many recommendations through the formation of the task groups. functionally specific cybersecurity task groups in our membership? Like, what does it mean to be better at medical device security? How do we do information sharing better? What about workforce development, third-party supply chain risk? All of these recommendations in the HCIC report found their way into documentation from the Health Sector Council, developed, written by our members, by the sector for the sector to provide a library of resources to everyone in the healthcare industry about what they ought to be doing in cybersecurity, wherever the gaps are. What makes ours different here is that really we looked at the HKIC report as a snapshot in time. That was that their analysis, their assessment of the healthcare industry was of that day. And we wanted to look ahead, say, OK, now we know that since 2017, the health care industry has changed an awful lot over the past five years. And we know it's going to change still more over the next five years. Can we be forward thinking and build a cybersecurity plan that anticipates changes in the industry in ways that will expand the attack surface, if you will? And so that's maybe the main difference is that that is forward looking more than it is a snapshot in time. So that now for every new initiative we think about, so we're about to start up a new task group and the new task group, every task group is going to be asked to tell us which of the major, which of the 10 major goals. or which of the 12 major objectives, implementing objectives, which of those does this task group answer? Which does it address? So for everything we do, all of our work streams in the future are going to be focused on making sure that we apply our scarce resources to those major goals and objectives that we have identified so that that train will take us to 2029. Yeah. And what I also love about the structure is, but those things that we haven't even considered, if they come up, you can quickly spin up a task to deal with it, which has been, it's been amazing to watch that actually happen. It's funny you mentioned that because one of the things you said, what's good about the plan is the guiding principles, which says what we will focus on, but we will, what we also will not focus on. So one of the things we were saying, it was just our bogeyman. It says, we're not going to talk about asset management. We're not going to talk about multi-factor authentication. That's not in the plan. Why? Because MFA might be a thing of the past in three to four years. It could be totally AI driven. The same thing with asset management. So let's not stick ourselves in the present to say, what are today's big problems? We had to think a little bit more futuristically. So that's an interesting piece of this is that, yes, you need to establish policy and operational resiliency based on circumstances. And the circumstances will change. Yeah, especially over five years. And the fact that the organization is so agile to respond to those as we've seen over the last five years is just, again, a testament to the right structure, the right partnership that we have, not only with the government, with private sector as well. Yeah, absolutely. And you orchestrate all that, Greg. So kudos to you, sir. That's a big job. And as you mentioned earlier, there's ways to get involved. So how can someone get involved in the health sector coordinating council if they want to participate? Two ways. You can reach me directly. My email is an open door for anyone who wants to contribute to this organization. It's greg.garcia at healthsectorcouncil.org. And healthsectorcouncil.org is our website address as well. So go to the website. We have a new and improved website today, which is more user-friendly and more organized to categorize the many different documents that we have published. Like, what do you want to do today? I want to improve my medical device cybersecurity. Okay, well, here are the four publications we have that will help you do that. I want to improve my hospital cybersecurity best practices. Okay, here are the several documents we have for that. There's an app for that too. So that's the website is now more more usable. Don't need to dwell on a website, but it is our resource. It is our library. And there you will also find a contact page. And if you connect with us through the contact page, then we will get back to you and give you an orientation as to membership is open essentially to regulated health care entities. That is health providers, medical technology and pharmaceutical companies regulated by FDA, plans and payers. They're in the payment system like CMS, health IT companies, public health. Those are the owners and operators in our health care system. And then we have really valued members like Censinet, who are in the advisor category, who are not specifically regulated as healthcare entities, but obviously have a deep understanding of healthcare and healthcare cybersecurity. And we really benefit from the participation of that group of members. So we welcome anyone who meets those categories. And the final thing I would say is on our website is a pledge that we want all healthcare organizations to sign. It's more of a statement of support. It's the health care, the health industry cybersecurity strategic plan is supports the imperative that cyber safety is patient safety. And we embrace the principles of that plan, which essentially says a noncommittal way of saying we're going to do the best we can to make to make this a reality. I love that. I love that. So we have a couple of seconds or a couple of minutes left. And I'd be remiss if I didn't ask you this question. And you've had some interesting events happen in your life over the last year since we last spoke, I think, on this program. What's the riskiest thing you've done recently? And I think this is your cue. There it is. Well, my wife and family would have said it was my Everest base camp track. And that does not mean that the peak you see there over my right ear is where I was. That is the peak of Mount Everest. But I did do a base camp trek with my brother-in-law, which was just an extraordinary experience, which means it's a nine-day hike, a very steep hike up to 17 ,000 feet to base camp. Perhaps it's risky for those who might have get altitude sickness, but it was one of the most extraordinary, I would say, existential experiences that I've had. What it really means to feel alive and the beauty of the environment. So that's certainly, if not the riskiest, then the most spectacular thing I've ever done. Awesome. A great way to end the program. This is Ed Gaudet from the Risk Never Sleeps program. And if you're on the front lines protecting patient safety and delivering patient care, remember to stay vigilant because Risk never sleeps. Thanks for listening to Risk Never Sleeps. For the show notes, resources, and more information on how to transform the protection of patient safety, visit us at Censinet.com. That's C-E -N-S -I-N -E-T dot com. I'm your host, Ed Gaudet. And until next time, stay vigilant because risk never sleeps.