[SFF 2024 Special] Panel on Bridging the Financial Gap with ANEXT Bank and Triple-A Singapore Fintech Festival ยท 14 Nov 2024 Source: https://omny.fm/shows/moneyfm-under-the-radar/sff-2024-special-panel-on-bridging-the-financial-g Transcript: https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/singapore-fintech-festival/sff-2024-special-panel-on-bridging-the-financial-gap-with-anext-bank-and-triple-6a07ac/ (via OpenNash Podcasts, machine-generated) MoneyFM 89.3, your ears on the ground at Singapore FinTech Festival 2024. That's right, you're listening to a special broadcast of MoneyFM 89.3 right here from Singapore Expo Hall 2. That's where the Singapore FinTech Festival 2024 is held. Now this year's Singapore FinTech Festival surrounds six major themes that will frame 2025. one of the themes among industry leaders is the need to bridge the financial gap and ensure equitable access and usage of financial services and products to the underserved. Now on this note, did you know that 1.4 billion people globally still lack access to bank accounts? And that is in fact according to an article published on the World Economic Forum in just September this year. So what can we then do to level the playing field for the underbanked and the underserved, both individuals as well as budding entrepreneurs who are starting out. Well, the numbers appear to point to fintech as the answer, given increased internet adoption and digitalization. After all, if we look at data by Statista, the global average internet penetration rate is at roughly 67.1%, with the number of internet users worldwide standing at 5.45 billion as of July this year. But what does bridging the financial gap look like exactly? Well, in part one of our two-part conversation on bridging the financial gap, we speak with Kai Qiu, Deputy CEO and CTO of ANEXT Bank, and Eric Barbier, CEO of Triple-A. Welcome, Kai and Eric. Great to be here. Yeah, thanks a lot, Indian. Welcome. And before we start the conversation proper, could you spend about one minute each to briefly introduce yourself, share a little bit more about your roles at ANEXT Bank and Triple-A, respectively. In particular, who are your underserved consumer groups and how do your companies aim to make financial services more accessible to the underserved? At A &X Bank, we focus on servicing micro, small and medium enterprises, especially for those who struggle with the traditional banking barriers, such as limited credit history, lack of access to the cross-border accessibility and things like that. And so what we're trying to do is leverage the advanced embedded finance solutions and try to lower the barriers and provide the essential financial services such as payments and financing as well as even wealth management. And our goal and objective is really to provide a secure, accessible and seamless financial tools so that those SMEs can leverage and achieve their own growth. What about you, Eric? At Triple-A, what we're trying to do is to help is the global financial inclusion. So in emerging markets, there's been a lot of progress when it comes to having mobile wallets, mobile bank accounts, and so on. But one of the issues a lot of people have in emerging markets is having access to the G7 currency, the US dollar in particular. And so there's a new technology called stablecoin, which enables practically anyone on the planet to be able to access the US dollar, which was difficult to get until then. Okay. Now let's talk more about the theme for today's conversation, which is bridging the financial gap. and if I may start with Kai this time around, close to 70 % of ANEXT Bank's customers, I understand, are micro, small and medium enterprises or the so-called MSMEs. What are the key limitations and challenges MSMEs face in accessing traditional finance services? I know you recently completed a survey in October this year. Tell us more about the findings. The survey result actually is quite interesting, actually. It shows that for those businesses in the next 12 months, the top three priorities for them are product innovation, market expansion, and digital transformation. But I think it's one universal challenge that remains on chain, which is lack of capital, which also holds them back from pursuing those critical goals. So what we're trying to do is really to help them out and how we can provide as NX, provide additional services and come up with innovative and more inclusive financial solutions and even tailor our product features to better suit their needs. Okay. If I may go to you, Eric, this time around, I understand Triple-A enables businesses to pay and also get paid in digital currencies anytime, anywhere without touching them. But what were the challenges faced by your customers and the traditional payment systems? And what were the motivations that prompted them to use your services then? Across the world, a lot of people are not able to access credit cards like we know them, like Visa or MasterCard. And so in those markets, the only form of currency is through digital currencies, including stable coins like USDC or PayPal US. And so one of the challenges of a traditional system is that it is taking a long time to make an international payment. So when you're going through a swift message from banks to banks, it can take several days plus the bank holidays. The beauty of using stablecoin payments is that you can do real time 24-7, even during bank holidays. Now, Eric, this question is for you. You talked a lot about stablecoin payments, right? So if you could take some time to take a look at this question. You mentioned that stablecoin payments can help emerging markets and underserved segments be financially included in the global economy. But aside from real-time transactions, could you provide us more granularity on the benefits of using stablecoin payments? And what is your approach to bridging the financial gap at scale? Let me give you an example. We're working with Grab here in Singapore. And one of the problems is when people are coming from emerging markets, someone coming from Colombia. And obviously, you need to have Grab when you're in Singapore. But his issue is that his credit card was refused because it was perceived as a high risk. So what he's been able to do is to use his stable coins to actually top up his GrabPay wallet. So that was really a lifesaver for him. So that's a very concrete example on how people in emerging markets, which are not fully included in the global system, where they are able to actually spend their money when they're traveling. Any thoughts on that, Kai, before I move on to talk more about Anex? Totally agree with what Eric mentioned. I think the key is really how to embrace the new technology as well. A stable coin is not new, but I think a lot of times, I think we require a lot of education to our customers as well. And Ty, if I may go to you with this follow-up question, right? How are the technologies at ANEXT Bank helping SMEs better be included in the global economy, so to speak? One of the most key solutions that we're trying to provide to our customers is through the InBetter Finance. So InBetter Finance means that we are going to work with partners. So working with partners is the first mindset we have. No one can grow alone. So you have to work very closely with all the digital platforms. And when we try to build our technologies framework, for example, we always take that into consideration. When we build our API gateway for connectivities, we also offer different types or different models of integration, ranging from a light touch of redirection, or we do a hybrid mode of combining the redirection as well as API connectivity, as well as a fully embedment with the digital platforms. So this allows us to feed any different type of partners whenever they are needed. Now, if you're just joining us, we are now in conversation with Kai Qiu, Deputy CEO and CTO at ANEXT Bank and Eric Barbier, CEO at Triple-A. Earlier, Eric, you talked a lot about partnerships. You talked about Grab, right? So let's touch on the topic of partnerships. Triple-A had this tie up with Grab in March this year. You talked about that. But aside from that, that is also a collaboration with AXS to allow users to pay bills, fines, taxes and student fees in digital currencies. Tell us more about the partnership. How far do you think such collaborations are key to helping you bring embedded finance to scale and really bridging that financial gap? Our approach to the partnership is to do everything usually in white labels. And what partners like Grab or AXS, what they are looking at are people who are licensed by MS. Obviously, digital currency being new have some specific risk. Compliance with AML and CFT regulation is absolutely key. And so that has been a very important consideration for both of them to make sure that nobody is able to use this technology to form terrorists. Right, and if I can go to you, Raikai, what's ANEXT Bank's take on partnerships and further enhancing financial inclusion, especially for micro businesses and SMEs? So our goal is really to avail financial services to the SMEs at the place where they work at. That's the gist of the embedded finance. So that's how we work with different digital platform owners, for example. Right now, I think we've worked with five or six platform owners already, ranging from different industries, including payment service providers, supply chain platforms, as well as food and beverage delivery platform as well. So, for example, Shopmatic is the Singaporean e-commerce platform where we already provide our embedded finance solution to their merchants. They can apply business loan directly, and when it's approved, they can just get dispersed immediately. Another example on the site is Delivery Chinatown, who is the Singaporean food and delivery services. There's around 1 ,000 F &B companies on the platform. Our services are available on their merchant portals, which means that the restaurants, the F &B companies are able to get access to our financing products. They can draw down from their credit line for their daily operation or for the expansion for new outlets or restaurants. Now let's begin to wrap up the conversation by taking a look at the wider business environment. Kai and Eric may be starting with Kai this time around. what is the number one trend you are keeping your eyes on when it comes down to ensuring more equitable access to financial services as well? And how does it influence business decision at ANEXT Bank and also Triple-A for Eric? That's a very good question, Tian Tian. I think the number one trend we've observed or we've closely watched on is the rapid globalization for micro-small SMEs because more and more SMEs are trying to pursue their globalization journey because of digital advancement or market demand. But it's not coming up without challenges, right? Because if you want to do a globalization, what you need is to access to a unified financial services. For example, cross-border payments and financing to get your financing needs whenever you need to run the business act. So what we're trying to do as NX Bank is we're trying to unify the financial services so that we can empower them to get all the business needs or financing needs whenever they do business. Now, what about you, Eric? Building on that, you know, especially in the Singapore context, whether you're small or big, Usually because the Singapore market is limited, you have to work internationally. And one of the challenges you're facing is how do you get paid more efficiently and rapidly. So that's for us the key trend we're looking at. Okay. Kai and Eric, any comments to share on the use cases of fintech and bridging the financial gap before we head into the news break and part two of the conversation where we'll talk about identifying areas for further intervention and investment? To me, I think the key is really addressing the real pain points of MSMEs. And then the right approach is really to work with partners. So Invent Finance is the key to go. And that's what we believe in. Okay, what about you, Eric? Yeah, on my side, I wanted to share some real stories. What we're seeing more and more is people like freelancers, web designers, developers, and so on, in emerging markets, in Bangladesh, in Vietnam, even across Africa. And what we're seeing as a big trend is those people, they prefer to get paid in stablecoin instead of their local currency. So that enables really them to be financially included in the global economy. Let's talk a bit more about what success means to the both of you. What metrics would you use to determine your progress towards equitable financial outcomes? Could you give us two examples each, maybe starting with Kai? Success to us simply means that you're going to address the real pain point of your MSME customers. You're going to deliver value for them. Otherwise, whatever you do, you have to be purposeful. So I think simply speaking, I think the metrics of success can be number of underserved MSMEs that you onboarded, your customer satisfactory score and the time you take to process a financing application, for example. If I can try my luck before I move on to Eric, right, could you share some examples as to maybe the adoption of your products and how many people you have served, so to speak? So for example, our product, we're trying to lower the barriers, as I mentioned before, right? So the minimum loan amount that we avail is $5 ,000, which makes it very, very simple and accessible for the SME customers. It doesn't require any additional documents when it's less than $30 ,000 in a month. They can just simply apply using their NOA. And we work with our partners as well, avail all the services through the Inventa Finance solution as well. Now going to you, Eric, what does success mean to you? And could you share with us two examples of how you measure progress towards financial inclusion? For us, the key measure of success is how much we're able to grow the revenues of our clients, and especially for the revenues they're making from an emerging market. For instance, I could mention Razer, the gaming company headquartered in Singapore, but operating all across the world. What we've been enabling them to do is by adding stablecoin payments on top of their existing payment option, was to really grow. And sometimes in some emerging market, we're representing like 50 % of their checkout size because people in those markets, they have no other choice than using digital currency to make those payments. So that's a consumer example. Another example would be, we're working with a mobile phone exporter. They're selling to Vietnam, but the Vietnam importer has difficulty to get access to the US dollar. So using USDC in this case to make the payments to the Singapore exporter was a way for the Singapore company to make more revenues. Don't mind me trying my luck over here. As a layman, right, why is the exporter in Vietnam facing difficulties getting the USD? Because today when you want to make a USD payment, you have to go to the bank, fill in a lot of paper. It will take a couple of days to be approved by the bank. Why do you buy mobile phones and so on and so on? So many paperwork and question asked. And also the exchange rate you're going to get might be not really good. So that's why using digital currency to bypass the traditional banking system enables those people to have something which is way faster and way cheaper. We talked about using technologies at Inex Bank and also at Triple-A to help level the playing field and bridge the financial gaps. But building that technology infrastructure to do so requires capital investments as well. So how do you balance the need to manage your balance sheet and manage your CapEx versus ensuring that the very technology that you are building right now remains affordable to your target customers who cannot meet the traditional barriers to entry for traditional financial services? In Anex, we're always taking cost-effective and cost-efficient into the consideration when we build a solution. I think as 100 % own subsidiary of N International, we are also at a sweet spot that we can leverage a lot of advanced technology from a group as well. and we have a bunch of very talented engineers and we can actually make our architecture and technology solution very nimble and truth to be told, we build the entire banking system from ground zero. So we are not relying on any vendor system. We don't need to pay license fees so we can actually handle the cost rather easily and then we can transform those cost savings to our customers. What about you, Eric? On our side, to maintain the cost very low, we don't charge setup fee, we don't charge minimum monthly fees or anything of this nature. And the over-available technology for payment being the traditional credit card, this is very costly to merchants. Can, you know, 3 % for a domestic payment, up to 6%, and sometimes even more for a cross-border transaction. However, when you're using digital currency, usually always below 1%. So that's a huge cost saving for businesses doing cross-border business. So you talked about keeping, you know, the prices of using your services affordable to your users. but how are you managing your own costs to ensure your business sustainability as well? It's a volume game. The more volume we're able to process, the cheaper it gets. That's really what we're trying to build here. Okay. Now, if I can zoom in on the cost side of things, right? Kai and Eric may be going with Kai first this time around. Foundational tax stacks, they are said to sort the cost to serve and drive economic empowerment. But first things first, if we could take one step back, what are foundational tax stacks for the man in the street? How have you used them at ANEXT Bank and also at Triple-A for Eric? And how effective have they been in helping firms remain true to their cost of ensuring equity when it comes down to access to financial services? That's a very good question, Tin Tin. When we talk about foundational tech stack, I want to bring up two concepts. One is from a technical perspective. Of course, we talk about our system is cloud-native. Microservices, you can leverage a lot of cloud benefits like high availability, extensibility, and so on. So that's more of a technical perspective. We also adopt advanced technology like AI, and we develop a very in-depth data analytics capability as well. But more importantly, in addition to that, you're going to consider about the foundational design thinking. The openness in your design thinking is also foundational and critical. So we actually embrace that open design thinking into all our change management processes, our enhancements, our new feature, a new product design throughout. So in that way, we will know that how we can actually better serve our customer and better collaborate with our partners. Any thoughts, Eric? I fully agree with what has been said so far. I think I would add one thing is what we're trying to do is to build everything based on open source technologies so that no matter the partner we're working with, we know that we will be able to continue to operate even if the partner has an issue. Now, this question is for you, Eric, as well. A study by the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research out back in 2022 found that the top 10 ,000 individual Bitcoin investors, they hold 5 million Bitcoins, over a quarter of that 19 million Bitcoins in circulation. Now, granted that Bitcoins are different from stablecoins and the other cryptocurrencies, how can we ensure that solutions like Triple-A, which facilitates payments using crypto and digital tokens as well, can close up the wealth gap instead of widening it? Yeah, Bitcoin, you know, some of the early Bitcoin adopters have been piling up when it was so cheap and so easy to mine. We know that a lot of them are not moving. So we think that some of the early Bitcoins will never be seen again because they lost their keys to those. And I think all the speculative cryptocurrencies and so on are probably not the best way to promote financial inclusion. And that's why really what has been the product market fit in the digital currency space is the stablecoin. Okay. Okay, now speaking of, I know we talked about digital tokens, so if I may stay on that, we can't help but think about the US presidential elections and this one person, US President-elect Donald Trump. So I'm going to give you three words each. You tell me what you think about them, okay? Starting with Kai, Donald Trump, interest rates and banking. From a bank perspective, I would think about interest rates. I think the interest rate is going downwards. And at NX Bank, we are trying to consider the impact to our customers. So for those customers who are trying to look for additional investment options, then we also explore other products such as Money Market Fund with our partners. And so in NX Bank, we're trying to look at all the possible means to help our SME customers. And the three words for you, Eric. Ready? Donald Trump, digital tokens and fluctuations. So with the arrival of Donald Trump, I think we're going to see some more clarity on the regulation. You know, in Singapore, we've been very lucky because we've got regulation on the digital payment tokens. since 2020. While in the US, there's been a lot of debate, there's just so many regulators, and there's no agreement on how digital currency should be regulated. And it looks like, and remains to be seen, that Mr. Trump said it would provide clarity. So we really welcome this because that's really what's missing on the US market. Neither just tuning in or just joining us, we are now in conversation with Kai Qiu, Deputy CEO and CTO of ANEXT Bank, and Eric Barbier, CEO of Triple-A. Now let's talk about taking financial inclusion to the next level, maybe starting with Kai, then Eric. How do you identify areas for further intervention and further capital investment at ANEXT Bank and also at Triple-A for Eric? Which are the gaps or the geographical markets that make a good business case for you to double down on your investments? Actually, the investment to us, it doesn't mean that we're going to invest or buy over another company or subsidiary. It's more about investing in our own people, the talents, as well as investing in our product design, product feature, and enhancing the customer experiences. And also even talk about global product supports our globalization of the MSMEs. What about you, Eric? On the other side, you know, I started the company here in Singapore five years ago. We have expanded in Europe a couple of years. What we're seeing for 2025 is continue the geographic expansion. And it's mostly in the US where we're seeing a lot of growth for our business. And if I can try my luck over here, right? If you were to pick one right spot or one industry gap where you can come in to double down on your CapEx and to better serve the underserved consumers, what would that be? To me, it would be more addressing the cross-border transactions and those MSMEs that are trying to go global and those products and features that they are lacking of, for example, from a financing perspective, from a payment perspective, really can get the financing support as and when they need it. What about you, Eric? On our side, obviously, cross-border, we're seeing import-export of physical goods moving more and more into using digital currency. So this is really an area where we want to double down. Now, before we let you go, Kai and Eric, first time around, starting with Eric. This is a question that we ask all our panelists and interviewees throughout the two-day show. Any closing remarks and what is the one takeaway that you hope the audience who are tuning in or joining us right now in person would take home from this conversation? I think you may have heard that digital currency, Bitcoin and so on was just purely speculative. What I hope you understood from what's happening and what we explained is that it's actually a reality. There's today 400 million people around the world who are using digital currency on a daily basis to make payments. So we are way beyond the early adopters. What about you, Kai? So in closing, just a recap, InXBank, we're committed to transforming financial landscape of MSMEs by making financial services more accessible, seamless and secure. So today's takeaway, I would say, is that leveraging advanced technology, innovative technology, as well as partnerships, we can empower MSMEs to achieve sustainable growth, which will bring us even closer to our true mission of financial inclusion. Lots to watch. Indeed, thanks a lot for joining us. Kai and Eric, that was Kai Qiu. Deputy CEO and CTO of ANEXT Bank and Eric Barbier, CEO of Triple-A. Thank you both. Thank you. Thanks a lot. I'm your host and producer for today. Chua Tiantian. Keep it right here with us on MoneyFM 89.3.