# Ep5: Elias Zerhouni

- **Show:** The Long Run with Luke Timmerman
- **Published:** 8 Nov 2017
- **Source:** https://soundcloud.com/longrunpodcast/ep5-elias-zerhouni
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/the-long-run/ep5-elias-zerhouni-c3ce99/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

Elias Zerhouni, Sanofi's head of R&D and a former NIH director, argues that American scientific and economic leadership depends on two things: welcoming talented immigrants and funding basic research with government money. Both, he says, produce the people who drive innovation. Cutting either one, he warns, gives away human capital the country cannot easily replace.

The episode moves from Zerhouni's personal immigrant story to the policy threats of a travel ban, tighter visas and a proposed 20% NIH budget cut. The tension is between his warnings, such as a waning US lead and a lost generation of young scientists, and his stated optimism that the US is still the world's innovation country and should fight to keep it.

## Key insights

1. **Immigrants are central to American science** Zerhouni says half of American Nobel Prizes went to people of immigrant background. He cites a study claiming only three of 31 Nobel winners since 2000 would be admitted under today's proposed rules.
2. **Talented scientists are rare and worth recruiting** Zerhouni uses the uranium-235 analogy: he says 98% of science is created by 2% of scientists. Attracting that small group, he argues, matters far more than the size of the overall workforce.
3. **A 1% NIH cut once hit young scientists hard** Because NIH gives five-year grants, only about 20% of its budget is available for new awards each year. After the Katrina-era 1% cut, young investigators funded fell from 1,800 to 1,000.
4. **Government funds basic research to train people** Zerhouni says basic research is mainly human capital formation. It trains the scientists who later staff universities and industry, and he credits Vannevar Bush's tripartite model of industry, government and academia.
5. **Drug development is hard because biology is poorly understood** Zerhouni says translating knowledge we lack is partly a statistical gamble. He adds that clinical trial costs have soared, and that most experts think we know only 10 to 15 percent of what we need to know.

## Questions this episode answers

### Why does Elias Zerhouni say immigration matters for science?

He says immigrants have won about half of American Nobel Prizes and founded half of Silicon Valley's companies. He argues that losing them means giving away human capital the US needs.

### What would a 20% NIH budget cut actually do?

Zerhouni says it would basically stop every new grant, since new grants usually go to new scientists. He warns this would be catastrophic for the next generation of researchers.

### Why did a small 1% cut at NIH cause so much damage?

NIH funds grants over five years, so only about 20% of the budget is free each year. A 1% cut therefore acts like a 5% cut on new grants, and young investigators funded dropped from 1,800 to 1,000.

### Is the US still the leader in biomedical innovation?

Zerhouni says the US lead in patents and publications is narrowing, especially against Europe and China. But he believes the US is still the top country for transformative innovation.

### Why is developing a new drug so slow and expensive, according to the episode?

Zerhouni says science still understands too little about human disease biology, so drug development involves many bets that often fail. He also says clinical trials have become far more expensive.

## Facts

- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:08:59]: "I came with my wife, actually. I just got married, and two weeks later we left. Our honeymoon was Hopkins."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:07:39]: "I had a scholarship for three months. I had won that as a medical student."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:08:09]: "my dean was actually a former NIH scientist. He had done research there and was a very well-known neurophysiologist."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:09:51]: "the chairman, who was actually German by birth and immigrated from East Germany in the 50s."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:10:40]: "One of the residents left the program, so they had a spot."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:15:03]: "I had been elected to the Institute of Medicine."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:27:08]: "when I did the roadmap for NIH, one of the tenets of the roadmap was interdisciplinary research."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:17:26]: "one half of all the Nobel Prizes actually were won by people of, you know, immigrant backgrounds."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:17:26]: "of the 31 Nobel Prizes that were won since 2000, only three would have been accepted in this country."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:18:49]: "Half of the companies in Silicon Valley have been created by non-U .S. born citizens."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:19:29]: "the greatest gift of human capital a country ever gave for free to the United States."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:22:10]: "The big one is going to be the H-1B, the number of visas that have decreased."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:25:40]: "Uranium-235 is rare. But uranium-235 is what makes the difference, right?"
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:32:39]: "it was created by Vannevar Bush in the 40s. He was an advisor to President Roosevelt, and he wrote a paper called Science, the endless frontier."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:32:39]: "the success will come from the tripartite collaboration between industry, government, and academia."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:33:54]: "Congress actually voted that down a couple of days ago."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:36:52]: "Katrina, you know, because it really cost a lot, forced us to cut every agency's budget. And it was only 1 % for NIH."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:36:52]: "NIH only gives five-year grants, so any one year they have 20 % of their budget available to them."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:29:55]: "it was highest in the 50s. And it's half and half right now."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:41:51]: "the cost of hospitalization is four times what it is in Europe, and on and on."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:42:32]: "do you think we know 10 % of what we need to know or 50 % of what we need to know? Most people would say 10%, 15%."
- **Elias Zerhouni** [0:43:33]: "I have my best friend from school. He has two children and they both went to China."
- **Luke Timmerman** [0:00:49]: "He took his current job at Sanofi in 2011."

## Transcript

**[0:00:08] Luke Timmerman:** Welcome to The Long Run. This is a podcast for biotech adventurers. I'm your host, Luke Timmerman. Today's guest is Elias Zerhouni. He's the president of Global R &D at Sanofi, one of the world's biggest makers of drugs and vaccines. Zerhouni, for those unfamiliar, has had quite a career. He started out as an academic researcher in radiology at Johns Hopkins. He then became an entrepreneur and an academic administrator. He served as the director of the National Institutes of Health under President George W.

**[0:00:49] Luke Timmerman:** Bush. He took his current job at Sanofi in 2011. Zerhouni also happens to be an immigrant, a native of Algeria, a Muslim-majority country in North Africa. I wanted to ask him about that life experience and how he got to where he is today. In this episode of The Long Run, we spoke mostly about how immigrants are crucial to the scientific enterprise. At the risk of stating the obvious, immigration is one of the reasons the U.S.

**[0:01:21] Luke Timmerman:** remains the number one place in the world for biotech and pharma innovation. We also talked about the threats to government budgets for scientific research, and what would happen if budgets get slashed at a time of so much possibility in biology. Now before we get going, a couple quick plugs. Some of you may have heard that I'm training to climb Mount Everest in 2018 as part of the Climb to Fight Cancer. This is a charity fundraising program at the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center in Seattle.

**[0:01:51] Luke Timmerman:** I'm thrilled to be a part of this inspiring program to support cancer research and science itself. I'm training hard. Thanks very much to EBD Group for its support as a Basecamp sponsor of The Climb. EBD Group, as many listeners know, co-produces the Biotech Showcase Conference each January in San Francisco. I'd encourage you to go register for the Biotech Showcase today. I'll be there on a media panel as usual. By registering for the Biotech Showcase today, you will get to attend a great networking event.

**[0:02:27] Luke Timmerman:** And if you would be so kind when registering to attend, please leave the organizers a just a brief one line comment to say you appreciate their generous support of the long run podcast and the climb to fight cancer. Sponsorship is necessary for me to continue doing this show. I'm an entrepreneur and I've been shouldering all the production costs out of my own pocket the past few months to get it going. Now, of course, if you like this podcast, I'd encourage you to go to TimmermanReport.com and subscribe.

**[0:02:57] Luke Timmerman:** If this show is the appetizer, then TimmermanReport.com is the full meal deal. It goes for the bargain rate of $149 per reader per year. The next episode of the Long Run Podcast will feature Steve Holtzman. He's a veteran biotech executive and really someone who has seen it all. He's currently the CEO of Boston-based Decibel Therapeutics, a startup working to treat hearing loss. Holtzman has also been quite outspoken over the past year. He has helped mobilize other biotech CEOs to speak out on political issues they have historically avoided.

**[0:03:34] Luke Timmerman:** Watch for that episode in your iTunes or Stitcher feed. Now, join me and Elias Zerhouni for the long run. I'm here today in New York City with Elias Zerhouni. He's the Executive Vice President of R &D at Sanofi. Welcome. Thanks for joining me today, Elias. Thank you, Luke. So I'd like to ask a little bit about you first to introduce you to our listeners, and then I'd like to talk about a couple of major issues in our country and facing our industry, that being immigration and funding of basic sciences at the NIH, which you're very familiar with, and we'll get there.

**[0:04:16] Luke Timmerman:** But first of all, I'd like to ask you a little bit about your background. Yeah. You were born and raised in Algeria. That's right. And this is a country where the vast majority of the population are followers of Islam. You got your medical degree there.

**[0:04:32] Elias Zerhouni:** That's right.

**[0:04:33] Luke Timmerman:** And then came to the United States for your medical residency at Johns Hopkins. That's right. Radiology, actually. So what brought you to America?

**[0:04:43] Elias Zerhouni:** Well, it's simple. Well, you know, I had a very unusual set of skills that my father was a teacher of mathematics. And so for him, you know, mathematics, physics, engineering, that was where the action should be was. And I grew up in a family of seven brothers, and I was number five. And so I was very, very good at physics and math. But then I went to volunteer when I was a student in the mountains, and I saw the misery of people poor and suffering from tuberculosis, and I wanted to make a difference there, so I decided to go to medical school.

**[0:05:25] Elias Zerhouni:** So when I went to medical school, I realized that medical school in those days was very much rote learning, recipe learning. It didn't have that profound beauty and logic of math and physics. And then one of my teachers showed me a CAT scan one day. And he said, oh, you know, this thing is a new method to look inside the brain. And there was a very fuzzy picture. And I said, how is this acquired? How is it done?

**[0:05:52] Elias Zerhouni:** And he said, well, there's a computer, and then there's an x-ray tube that turns around the patient. The data is sent to the computer. The image is reconstructed. And I clicked because I said, that's perfect. That's exactly what I am good at, understanding mathematics, but I also like biology. I like medical medicine. And so I decided to pursue that.

**[0:06:15] Luke Timmerman:** Now, this would have been the 1970s. So you're in medical school.

**[0:06:21] Elias Zerhouni:** I'm in med school.

**[0:06:22] Luke Timmerman:** University of Algiers?

**[0:06:23] Elias Zerhouni:** Yeah, and I'm finishing med school at that time. And you had to decide what you wanted to do. So that moment told me I want to do computerized imaging, and I want to be in the imaging sciences at all levels, and especially quantitative imaging, where I thought there was a lot of potential. And so when I wanted to do that, my medical school said, we don't have a program. You have to go abroad and go train and come back.

**[0:06:52] Elias Zerhouni:** And I said, where do you train? They said, well, the U.S. or Sweden at the time, or the U.K. and that's how I learned English and I took my exams and, you know, my equivalency exams at the time was called ECFMG. So growing up, you spoke Arabic? I spoke French, I spoke Arabic, and I learned German at school. But not English? Not English, yeah, which is probably a good thing because I didn't learn it badly.

**[0:07:20] Elias Zerhouni:** I learned it here, the U.S., and, you know, learning it in immersion with the people who speak it, allowed me to probably speak it better than I would have if I had learned it at school.

**[0:07:32] Luke Timmerman:** Okay, so you decide to come to the United States. Did you ever consider one of those other countries?

**[0:07:39] Elias Zerhouni:** Yeah, I consider Sweden, because Sweden was very, very good in imaging sciences at the time, the UK. The opportunity was really in the U.S., because the dean of my medical school knew the dean of Johns Hopkins. And I had a scholarship for three months. I had won that as a medical student. And so he talked to him, and I had asked that my dean. I said, where are the best schools? It's Harvard or Hopkins. I said, well, if you get me a shot there, I'll go.

**[0:08:09] Elias Zerhouni:** That was it. And funnily, he called the dean who knew him because my dean was actually a former NIH scientist. He had done research there and was a very well-known neurophysiologist. And so he said, look, I have this kid. I don't know what he wants to do. I can't offer him any program here. Can you take him for three months, six months, so he can see what it is and decide what he wants to do?

**[0:08:36] Elias Zerhouni:** So that's how I came to Hopkins on a scholarship that I had that I decided to spend the time at Hopkins doing research on computer tomography, computerized tomography.

**[0:08:48] Luke Timmerman:** So you're already focused on radiology. Yeah. Hopkins was a great place then, as always. It's 1975?

**[0:08:56] Elias Zerhouni:** Yeah, that's correct.

**[0:08:57] Luke Timmerman:** And you come here by yourself?

**[0:08:59] Elias Zerhouni:** No, I came with my wife, actually. I just got married, and two weeks later we left. Our honeymoon was Hopkins. Okay.

**[0:09:07] Luke Timmerman:** Working in the lab there. How did you come? Was this on a student visa or some other?

**[0:09:12] Elias Zerhouni:** Yeah, no, it's these exchange things that I can't remember what category it was, but it was an exchange visa at the time.

**[0:09:23] Luke Timmerman:** So how did things go in the early days there at Hopkins?

**[0:09:27] Elias Zerhouni:** It was interesting. The first day I arrived there, my English wasn't so good. So the vice chair, Stan Siegelman, was the name of the vice chair, and he talked to me and he said, you know, you might want to go take some English before you come here. And I said, no, no, I can't do that. He said, why not? He said, I only have three months of a scholarship, so I'll be gone by the time I learn English.

**[0:09:51] Elias Zerhouni:** I want to do what I need to do. And he said, really, you want to do that? I said, don't worry about me. I'll do it because I knew how to read it and write it, but I didn't speak it very well. Then I went to see the chairman, who was actually German by birth and immigrated from East Germany in the 50s. And he noticed the same thing. He said, well, what do you want to do?

**[0:10:16] Elias Zerhouni:** And I was in my broken English. And he said, well, I don't quite understand what you're saying. I said, well, let me speak in German. So I spoke German to him. And he said, well, your German is very good. And I said, yeah, but that doesn't help me here. He said, well, if you learn German, you can learn English. And from there, I went with the medical students first to go through, you know, getting used to.

**[0:10:40] Elias Zerhouni:** And then I started working, you know, in the lab. And within like three, four months, I made some contributions. And then I worked in the emergency room to make some money. So I learned the hard way at night in the emergency room at Hopkins. And then by the end of that, they offered me a residency position. One of the residents left the program, so they had a spot. And Stan Siegelman, who, you know, had not seen me for a few months, talked to me and said, well, your English is much better.

**[0:11:12] Elias Zerhouni:** And in those days, imaging was not that popular. It's not what it is today. It was really still considered backwater. But I thought it was the up-and-growing technology for biology.

**[0:11:27] Luke Timmerman:** When did you decide you wanted to become a citizen?

**[0:11:32] Elias Zerhouni:** Late, actually. Initially, I didn't want to. I wanted to go back. And then what happened was really very simple. the situation degraded itself there. I tried to go back, couldn't find a welcoming environment, and Hopkins said, look, we have a position for you. Go back, see if it works out. If not, come back. And so I came back. How did it degrade? Well, basically, I think the political system became a little more corrupt. It was more authoritarian.

**[0:12:07] Elias Zerhouni:** And then the situation that you have, if you stay too long abroad, you're perceived as a foreign body. That, oh, my God, he's coming. He knows all these things about, you know, the advanced technologies. He's American training. He might take our job. So then you get this sort of pressure. And that's one of the things that I know you want to discuss about immigration. A lot of immigration is a one-way street. There's not a lot of ways to come back unless the country that sent you is willing to bend over backwards to get the returnees.

**[0:12:47] Luke Timmerman:** Well, you had a position at Hopkins. Obviously, it didn't take you very long to find your niche in radiology. When did you decide that this is where you really want to be long term and build your career?

**[0:13:01] Elias Zerhouni:** You mean in terms of the US?

**[0:13:02] Luke Timmerman:** The United States.

**[0:13:04] Elias Zerhouni:** I'm really 81, 82, six, seven years into it. I really, you know, Hopkins has been such a great institution for me. And it was very nurturing. The opportunities were great. I needed to do, you know, work to get a visa, obviously. So I didn't become a citizen in 81, became a citizen later. But that was the decision. It was about that time. I had two children. And there are things that happen. And my wife was in training.

**[0:13:34] Elias Zerhouni:** She's a physician, too. Things that happen that you don't really control. And they dictate, almost, what you want to do. But, frankly, things were going so well that it would have been not so smart not to take it on.

**[0:13:47] Luke Timmerman:** So we can fast forward now. I mean, you carve out this academic career at Johns Hopkins. You're specializing in CT and MRI imaging. I mean, this is radiology kind of at the beginning of a great boom era. You're making inventions. you're publishing papers, you're starting companies, you're working your way up even into administrative roles later in your time at Hopkins, you eventually get to become the director of the National Institutes of Health. So I think a lot of people would look at this background and say, what a classic immigrant success story.

**[0:14:24] Luke Timmerman:** I mean, this is fantastic, right? You've probably heard this a hundred times.

**[0:14:30] Elias Zerhouni:** Yeah, actually, I heard that in my, you know, when you get to be NIH director, you get nominated by the president, but you get confirmed by the Senate. And it was interesting in those days because the president was Republican and the Senate was controlled by the Democrats. So you had to have double hurdle, you know, you had to pass the first thing and be qualified to run the NIH. And at that time, the administration had decided that they wanted an external person to transform the NIH, changed the NIH, was too much into its ways.

**[0:15:03] Elias Zerhouni:** And frankly, I wasn't beholden to any particular group or any particular strategy. And what I had done at Hopkins as dean for research and the executive vice dean had been noted. So I had been elected to the Institute of Medicine. So I made the list, if you will. But the thing is the confirmation, and I remember it was Senator Warner, I think, and his first statement was, well, I'm so glad to present Exhibit A for the American Dream.

**[0:15:30] Elias Zerhouni:** So you're right. But I always feel that that's a sort of caricature. Frankly, it's not the immigrant who's special. It's what I said when I was confirmed. I said it says more about the U.S. than it says about me. The U.S. is unique in that regard. I mean, only in America could this happen. If I had been in France or UK or so? I don't believe it would have happened in any other country, including my own

**[0:15:58] Luke Timmerman:** mother country. So when the things have things have happened in the last year in this country, as you know well politically, there's a wave of anti-immigrant sentiment that brought a new president into office. We had a travel ban enacted in January against people from majority Muslim countries. There's been the recent rescinding of the DACA executive order that protected children of people who came here illegally. This is upset a lot of people, I mean, in the country, but also in the pharmaceutical industry, where I believe about half of the biomedical researchers in this country were born in another country.

**[0:16:47] Luke Timmerman:** First of all, what has been your reaction to this anti-immigrant wave of sentiment?

**[0:16:54] Elias Zerhouni:** Well, it's a global wave, actually. You know, I work between Europe and here in my job, and I see it in Europe as well as I do here. In really, maybe 20-30 % of the population, It's not a majority thing, but it is there. And I think the U.S. is no exception. It has multiple sources. Obviously, as you understand, I mean, people are afraid of the foreigner, and there's this thing about, so there's a little bit of xenophobia, and afraid about jobs, so there's a bit of economics in there.

**[0:17:26] Elias Zerhouni:** Although, you know, with an unemployment rate of 4.7%, you say, well, what's going on? But people are saying, well, it's depressing wages. And so I can see all the reasons. But the response is not the right one because fundamentally, you know, when you look at immigration and sciences, one half of all the Nobel Prizes actually were won by people of, you know, immigrant backgrounds. You mean the Americans? American Nobel Prizes, yeah. Yeah. And so there was a study recently, I just read it, that if you apply the rules that we want to apply today of the 31 Nobel Prizes that were won since 2000, only three would have been accepted in this country.

**[0:18:10] Elias Zerhouni:** 29 or 28 would have been turned away. I would have been turned away. I don't think I could make it today. And I would not have contributed both in my science as well as my administrative leadership or my startups and so on. So I think it's short-sighted to really lump everything into one populistic slogan. I think you need to be smarter than that, frankly. It's a disservice to America and its mantra, its creed. I think America holds together not because of ethnicity or geography or religion.

**[0:18:49] Elias Zerhouni:** It holds together because of its constitutional principles. And that's what I think is critical. And clearly in science, more than anything else, in technology, more than anything else, the degree of enrichment of our economic base because of that is enormous. Half of the companies in Silicon Valley have been created by non-U .S. born citizens. And if you look at the big companies, it would be Microsoft, Google, Novartis. I mean, you name it, you see this explosion of talent that we've been able to attract and retain.

**[0:19:29] Elias Zerhouni:** If we don't do that, it's almost like giving up, giving away the human capital that the country needs. It's what happened to Germany when Germany expulsed all the non-German and the immigrants and the non-pure. What happened was the greatest gift of human capital a country ever gave for free to the United States. I mean, all of the great scientists that came out of that exodus have made us win the war in part. So I think there's a historical dimension that is missed for the purposes of short-term political gain, which, you know, you can understand.

**[0:20:07] Elias Zerhouni:** People are afraid. People are insecure. People basically want to scapegoat.

**[0:20:14] Luke Timmerman:** Running a global R &D enterprise like you do, you do understand that the most valuable assets of the company are the people who walk in and out of the door every day. way, and not just in companies, but in academia as well. And the fact that the United States has had generally open borders for many, many decades, welcoming to people like yourself, is a key part of the reason that this is the place where most biomedical innovation occurs.

**[0:20:42] Luke Timmerman:** It doesn't occur in the Netherlands or France to nearly the same degree, more homogeneous type places. Are you planning your trip to San Francisco in January like so many biotech executives and investors? Check out the Biotech Showcase, co-produced by EBD Group. This meeting at the Hilton Union Square, San Francisco is a beehive of biotech and an annual tradition for me. It is a place to connect with interesting people working on all kinds of provocative ideas.

**[0:21:17] Luke Timmerman:** I'd like to thank EBD Group for stepping up as the first sponsor of the Long Run Podcast. When you register for the Biotech Showcase, please just type in a brief comment to say you registered after listening to this show. Not only will you get to be part of a great biotech networking opportunity at Biotech Showcase, but you will support this podcast and encourage EBD Group to see the value in its sponsorship over the long term. How does this new political reality affect the operations of a company like a Sanofi on a day-to-day basis?

**[0:22:00] Luke Timmerman:** I mean, do you hear stories of scientists who need to travel to one conference or another and they're afraid that maybe they can't go or can't come work here in the first place?

**[0:22:10] Elias Zerhouni:** Not much to date, because a lot of the policies and statements have just not been effective. I mean, the ban did not go through legally, and all of the measures that people are talking about have not yet taken their effect. The big one is going to be the H-1B, the number of visas that have decreased. That's the quality, that's the band of people, the type of people we most want. You know, the ones who are super qualified, that often we trained ourselves.

**[0:22:40] Elias Zerhouni:** You know, we have all these PhD candidates and these postdocs who are in our country today and are contributing today. And I'm afraid we're going to lose them because we're restricting the ability for us to recruit them here. What that means is that they'll go to China and I'll set up a lab in China or in France or in Germany. So it will have a long-term effect, but I don't know that it has had a short-term effect at this point in time.

**[0:23:10] Luke Timmerman:** You think that's a real possibility, that we could lose the United States leadership?

**[0:23:16] Elias Zerhouni:** We're already, you know, if you look at the trending in patents, for example, publications, I mean, the gap between the U.S. and the other countries is closing, especially when you look at the European and China and you know there's been a welcome widening of the number of people who are at the top of science in the world and that's really important to solve our problems. So I think the supremacy that we enjoyed in the 50s and the 60s and the 70s is waning.

**[0:23:49] Elias Zerhouni:** It's not the same degree of supremacy that we have. However, when you look at true innovation, transformative innovation, the ability to really translate that into an economic reality, you can see that the U.S. is still the innovation country.

**[0:24:06] Luke Timmerman:** So all is not lost, but it can't be taken for granted.

**[0:24:12] Elias Zerhouni:** Never. No, if you take human capital for granted, you've lost.

**[0:24:19] Luke Timmerman:** So, have you had an opportunity to speak to some members of Congress or members of the administration, given your background as former head of NIH? You know some people there.

**[0:24:31] Elias Zerhouni:** Yeah, I've done, actually, I've written an editorial in Science a few years back, because this topic comes on and off all the time. It's not a new topic. When you look at immigration, it's been a festering issue, which has divided people and, frankly, needs resolution. But there's no political win in trying to resolve it, as you can see from the experience of those who tried. So I think, from my point of view, I think we need to say what I just said.

**[0:25:03] Elias Zerhouni:** And I share it with you, and I share it with anybody who wants to hear me. is that a good percentage of the economic future and the economic present of the country is driven by our ability to what I call enrich the mix. And I wrote an editorial saying that, you know, in science or in enterprise or anything, the difference is made by a few people. And I call that the enrichment of uranium, right? You know, when you want to make an atomic weapon, uranium-238 is very common.

**[0:25:40] Elias Zerhouni:** Uranium-235 is rare. But uranium-235 is what makes the difference, right? It's the same thing in human capital. 98 % of science is created by 2 % of scientists, right? So 2 % of scientists worldwide is not a big number. But if we can attract that, then we have a successful future in front of us. You understand?

**[0:26:02] Luke Timmerman:** Yes, but it's also, I've also heard of the weak ties hypothesis. Have you heard of this? No. That we get the best ideas from the people who are not in our immediate circle. The people that we see and talk to every day, we kind of have a good feeling for the way they think about issues and problems. True, true. But it's the bumping into, it's when you're a molecular biologist and you bump into the biochemist at the water fountain and you say, Hey, I thought about this from a different angle.

**[0:26:28] Luke Timmerman:** And that's when the connectivity occurs. The sparks fly. And that also is aided, I believe, in part by diversity, by having people who are trained in different places.

**[0:26:38] Elias Zerhouni:** Right. So you're completely right. Actually, I believed in that in the 90s when I set up my lab at Hopkins. I created it that way. It was a multidisciplinary lab because I believe in what I call scientific convergence. So what you see today is that biological sciences are converging with physical sciences, converging with mathematical sciences, with information sciences, in a way that just wasn't there 20 years ago. You could have a great career in a silo field.

**[0:27:08] Elias Zerhouni:** Not anymore. And this is probably one of the reform I brought at my school, which were noted by the folks who asked me to direct the NIH, because I believe in that. So when I did the roadmap for NIH, one of the tenets of the roadmap was interdisciplinary research. And how do we encourage it? how to avoid the silos, how to break the barriers between not people but disciplines as well, and create that diversity of ideas from which history will tell you great transformative ideas come from and great research comes from.

**[0:27:46] Elias Zerhouni:** So you're completely right. It's not just an immigration problem. It's also a diversity of backgrounds and ideas that tend to accelerate the progress of science. You know, science goes to the country that welcomes it. And scientists throughout history have gone to the countries that welcome science. So when you look at Athens, or you look at Baghdad and its big day of wisdom, and then look at Renaissance, what you see is the scientists migrate to where the society at the time welcomes it and encourages it.

**[0:28:23] Elias Zerhouni:** And that's where you see economic growth and economic brilliance at the time. So, you know, if you look at every country, I don't know of any civilization that succeeded without attracting a diversity of talents from different horizons.

**[0:28:40] Luke Timmerman:** Now, this leads me into another point, which about the welcoming of science, as you say. We also have an environment that's anti-science. There's a strong strain in the culture that's very skeptical of things like climate change or the use of vaccines. Really anything that were to come out of peer-reviewed research creates a difficult operating environment. Does that concern you?

**[0:29:14] Elias Zerhouni:** Well, yes, absolutely. I think there's been a change in the public attitude towards science and technology because of the environmental damage that unbridled industrialization has done. I think that the side effects of certain advances are, you know, put in great magnification. You know, a few complications in vaccines, for example, have led to, you know, the sense that vaccines may be dangerous for you. There is the rise, if you will, of what you would call non-scientific ideas and theories that people do buy into.

**[0:29:55] Elias Zerhouni:** So that's one thing. And if you look at the trust level of the general public towards science and technology, it was highest in the 50s. And it's half and half right now. So science and scientists have not done a good job, I think, yet. They need to do more in truly educating. We're not doing that very well. The scientific fields, what we call STEM education, is not served well in our educational system. So quantitative, logical, analytical skills are not there for allowing a citizen to say, well, what's right, what's wrong.

**[0:30:35] Elias Zerhouni:** The rise of social network and the multiplication of that. So all of that tells you that there is a need for us to truly do better. The second trend is the issue of vested interests. I mean, if you move economic systems away from coal energy or away from, you get obviously a reaction, which is what I think explains a lot of the global warming debate that is ongoing. The sense also that the balance of evidence is never perfect.

**[0:31:05] Elias Zerhouni:** So, you cannot prove 100 % of anything, and the balance of evidence is really what you should look into. But some people catch on to two or three outrageous papers that have not been validated, and they make a policy out of that, and they ignore 97%, 98%, 99 % of the other evidence. And then the third source is what you mentioned initially, which is really the religious versus science debate that has gone on with science being seen by the religious people as anti-religious and scientific people looking at religion as anti-science.

**[0:31:47] Elias Zerhouni:** That's a false debate. It really is a debate that unfortunately led to the Middle Ages, and when that was resolved in a way by Francis Bacon and the Renaissance occurred. So you have to be very careful because absolute declarations that science is the enemy can be very destructive of society.

**[0:32:13] Luke Timmerman:** Well, we see its downstream manifestation in things like a proposed 20 % cut to the NIH budget. Now, to some people looking at that at first glance, they might think, well, that could just be, there's waste, there's fat to trim, maybe that's just good stewardship of the taxpayer dollars. I happen not to believe that, but what do you see when you see something like

**[0:32:39] Elias Zerhouni:** that proposal come through? Well, it's driven by ignorance, really. They don't appreciate what the ecosystem of research is, has been, needs to be, and will be. You know, it was created by Vannevar Bush in the 40s. He was an advisor to President Roosevelt, and he wrote a paper called Science, the endless frontier. It's probably the most important paper of the 20th century because it dictated American policy relative to that. We wouldn't be the power we are without that strategy of saying, look, the success will come from the tripartite collaboration between industry, government, and academia.

**[0:33:18] Elias Zerhouni:** And he made it happen. The atomic bomb happened because of that. The It didn't occur inside either one of those three. So if you really want to succeed, you need to understand that the role of each is different. Academia is discovery, new ideas. Government is really infrastructure. So when we say indirect costs, indirect costs are very relevant to the vitality of your research. So 20 % cut was more dictated not by an anti-science feeling, but as a small government, no waste in the government.

**[0:33:54] Elias Zerhouni:** in the sense that maybe universities were overcompensated, which is not the case. And Congress actually voted that down a couple of days ago. So I think it's a false debate.

**[0:34:04] Luke Timmerman:** But the point, one of the things I think Bush was making in that paper was that we should invest as a government in basic science and trust that it will, we don't know which directions this will always go. That's the definition of basic science. But it will, this is an investment that only government can make. industry is in the business of more applied research and development, and it's part of a continuum. We need all of it.

**[0:34:32] Luke Timmerman:** You can't just, out of ignorance, declare, oh, we're doing fruit fly research with government funds. What a big waste of money. Fruit flies have taught us a lot about

**[0:34:44] Elias Zerhouni:** genetics. That's right. I mean, without fruit fly, we probably wouldn't know how to appreciate genetics in humans today. I think you're right. I think, to me, the priority of the investment of the government should be threefold. One is basic research, right? But basic research is not done by machines. It's human capital formation that I'm talking about. The people who get educated and become capable translators of universal principles into discoveries of the basic type. You can't do basic research without having a policy where you can sustain and support young investigators who want to give their lives to the discovery of new principles that could potentially help, but that's not the purpose.

**[0:35:36] Elias Zerhouni:** The purpose of basic research is to understand the universe.

**[0:35:38] Luke Timmerman:** But we already have a big problem with the human capital development. Because of NIH budget stagnation in recent years, it's become much more difficult for young scientists to win that first peer-reviewed grant. They're often in their 40s. Many people leave science before they ever get there.

**[0:35:55] Elias Zerhouni:** Yeah, I see that as the number one issue, frankly, in my view. I've been a very strong advocate of young investigator funding. I did that when I was at the NIH. I created programs that allowed us to fund brilliant young scientists earlier than what the system does. I think it's a demographic issue too with the baby boomers, you know, having crowded the space, if you will. But I think that that is an issue for the whole country to deal with because it's not just NIH or biomedical research.

**[0:36:24] Elias Zerhouni:** It's the same thing everywhere. So I think we need to, A, preserve basic research as a government-funded activity because it's through that activity that you create a very capable human workforce, I mean, scientific workforce.

**[0:36:38] Luke Timmerman:** And that's why when I see something like a 20 % budget cut, knowing that we already have an extraordinarily difficult environment for young people, basically we would be turning away an entire generation of young scientists.

**[0:36:52] Elias Zerhouni:** That is the risk. I mean, I've said that, I wrote in that regard editorials with Rush Holt, the AAAS president and others. that the impact it would have is catastrophic. Because when I was at the NIH, we had Katrina, if you remember. Well, Katrina, you know, because it really cost a lot, forced us to cut every agency's budget. And it was only 1 % for NIH. But people forget that NIH only gives five-year grants, so any one year they have 20 % of their budget available to them.

**[0:37:28] Elias Zerhouni:** So if you cut a year on the same year, you cut 1 % as equivalent of 5%. 5 % is actually a quarter of the grants, right? Because you have 20 % to give, you take away 5%, and so the impact was dramatic. I mean, the number of young investigators funded that year went from 1 ,800 to 1 ,000. So I had to react and create a new policy that said that we need to preserve the generation, the next generation of scientists.

**[0:38:00] Elias Zerhouni:** Now, why is this? Now, we could... So 20 % would be dramatic. I mean, it would basically stop every new grant. Well, new grants are usually associated with new scientists, you know, next gen.

**[0:38:12] Luke Timmerman:** Now, we could sit here and make moral arguments about immigration and, I think, common sense, long-term arguments about basic science funding. But wearing your hat as a pharmaceutical R &D leader, I mean, why is this just good business to have reasonably open borders and proper channels for people to come here and, you know, robust basic science funding?

**[0:38:41] Elias Zerhouni:** It's good for not just business. It's good for the economy as a whole. You don't make anything happen without bright people who are in that uranium-235 category that I'm talking about. Well, what do you generate those? You generate them through basic research that trains capable people who get excited by discovering new things, eventually become the workforce for academia, for industry. They become the professors. They become the researchers in the industry. And they can be from anywhere.

**[0:39:12] Elias Zerhouni:** So that train of basic research leading to translational ideas that creates a whole generation after generation of capable scientists, capable translators, capable engineers across all fields is absolutely essential to a strong economy. It's not just business. I mean, business is only a reflection of the economic prowess and potential of any one country.

**[0:39:40] Luke Timmerman:** But you don't just import those people. You bring them in when they're 24 years old, like a young Elias Zerhouni, and then you nurture them. You develop them. You give them the freedom to pursue wherever their ambitions will lead.

**[0:39:54] Elias Zerhouni:** And the thing that's good about our system is that it rewards performance, and it rewards excellence. It doesn't reward who you are, where you're from, what age you are. It depends on what you accomplish. As long as we keep that and we give the pump the ability to prime itself with new talent all the time, we'll be the best country in the world for a long time.

**[0:40:19] Luke Timmerman:** One last question. The central problem in pharmaceuticals is this lack of R &D productivity. The time, the expense, the risk that's still involved in developing a new drug. It's awfully high. I know you're doing a lot of things to try to improve that. You're investing in lots of technologies. You've got partnerships. I asked one of your partners, George Yankopoulos, about this a couple weeks ago. But what's your philosophy on how the industry can kind of slay this dragon?

**[0:40:50] Elias Zerhouni:** I really think it's not just an industry issue. It's really a knowledge issue. What I always tell people is that I thought I knew more about biology when I joined the NIH than when I left the NIH. Because I was a little bit arrogant when I went there, and I've been a successful academic, and I thought a lot of things were known. And I developed imaging techniques for cellular and molecular things, and I was like all excited.

**[0:41:16] Elias Zerhouni:** And I said, how come these guys can't develop a vaccine? I mean, there must be something wrong with them. Well, what you realize is that we just don't know enough. So translating something you don't know is really hard to do, especially that, you know, biology, you know, we've learned a lot about biology, but we haven't learned as much on human disease biology. So we have work to do. And translating from something you don't know becomes a little bit of a statistical game, stochastic in nature to some extent, where you try to make bets.

**[0:41:51] Elias Zerhouni:** and the success rate is what it is. In addition to that, regulatory costs and the expense of having clinical trials now, which is the biggest expense, is just skyrocketed. You know, health care costs are high, and they're very, very high in the U.S. in particular. I mean, people complain about the cost of drugs, but look, I mean, the cost of hospitalization is four times what it is in Europe, and on and on. So conducting trials has been exponentially more expensive in a field where we don't quite understand what we need to understand in disease biology.

**[0:42:32] Elias Zerhouni:** When I ask people, people who know, do you think we know 10 % of what we need to know or 50 % of what we need to know? Most people would say 10%, 15%. So we still have a lot to learn.

**[0:42:43] Luke Timmerman:** Everybody has their part to play in academia and industry.

**[0:42:47] Elias Zerhouni:** Yeah. Yeah. Well, you know, millions of people are waiting and hurting, and so we need to hurry up and not create false problems like the ones you mentioned. We need to fund research. We need to really continue to understand the fundamental impact of science and technology on our economic future. and that can only be done by dedicated people that feel encouraged and feel like their career will be better or at least as attractive in a field like this than it would be in real estate or finance.

**[0:43:23] Luke Timmerman:** I don't know if you could answer this, but if you were in your mid-20s coming up in Algeria in 2017, do you think you'd still come to America or see it in the same way?

**[0:43:33] Elias Zerhouni:** I asked that question actually from young people I know, and I have my best friend from school. He has two children and they both went to China. So I was like surprised and I asked him, why would you go there? He said, well, America is really rejecting us and so on. It may have to do with the fact that they're from a Muslim majority country and they feel like maybe they'll be ostracized or whatnot. And I try to tell them otherwise.

**[0:44:03] Elias Zerhouni:** I still believe America is the country of innovation, and you can see it. We still have that momentum. And if we lose that, then we've lost the country and its potential for innovation.

**[0:44:20] Luke Timmerman:** I'd hate to see it, especially at such a moment of great potential.

**[0:44:25] Elias Zerhouni:** I know you say that, and everybody says that, but I'm completely optimistic about the future, to be honest with you. I'm not pessimistic at all. We need to fight the things that could derail that. But frankly, when you look at what we have as a society, our universities, our schools, and so on, I still believe that we are the country of innovation. We are the country of experimentation. We are the country of transforming ideas. And if you travel the world, you will see that the influence that this country has in sciences and technology is enormous.

**[0:45:05] Elias Zerhouni:** I haven't seen yet a transformative technology or a transformative something coming out of some other country that wasn't derived from what had happened here. So I think we shouldn't give up and we shouldn't be so pessimistic that we get paralyzed. I think we can fight and we should. And this is what I think makes our country great. But also for humanity, I mean, if other countries stop, because other countries also are not funding research the way they should, except China maybe.

**[0:45:36] Elias Zerhouni:** And if that happens, then what? Right? What? I mean, we go back into the dark ages or what? So I do not believe that the future is as bleak as people think it is. The young people think it's bleak, but you know what? We fund more researchers now than we did in the past because there are more sciences to fund and more disciplines to support, and the interaction is the key. So I think there is a little bit of over-pessimism that I don't think is justified, and we need to fight for optimism, not for pessimists.

**[0:46:15] Luke Timmerman:** Well, I'll take a little dose of optimism today. Thank you very much for joining me today, Elias, and I'll let you get back to work.

**[0:46:21] Elias Zerhouni:** Thank you. Enjoy. Take care.

**[0:46:24] Luke Timmerman:** Thanks for listening to The Long Run, a production of Timmerman Report. Pedro Rosado of Headstepper Media was the producer and editor. Music for the show comes from D.A. Wallach. Todd Bennings created the logo. Thanks to EBD Group for sponsoring this episode. Next on The Long Run, listen to my conversation with Steve Holtzman. A more than 30-year biotech veteran, Holtzman has become quite outspoken over the past year on a number of issues. He has helped mobilize other biotech CEOs to speak out on political issues they have historically avoided.

**[0:47:01] Luke Timmerman:** Don't miss this upcoming episode of The Long Run.
