In brief
David Maisel argues that Marvel's success came from owning its characters and making its own films, rather than licensing them to studios that kept most of the profit and creative control. By building a connected universe from individual hero films, Marvel could turn one hit into many sequels and tie-ins, with far better economics than studio licensing.
The central tension is between a bold vision and a skeptical environment. Maisel had no film-making track record, a tiny bankroll, a frugal boss, and a stock price that fell for four years. He won by understanding what each person needed in order to say yes, and by sweating creative details like the first and last scenes of Iron Man.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
Maisel says Iron Man was licensed to Warner Brothers for roughly eight or nine years for about $50,000 and never made into a movie.
“Iron man was actually at Warner Brothers for about eight, nine years as a license deal for like $50,000 they paid, and they never thought it was worthy to make it into a movie.”
0:16:16 · David Maisel · Iron Man rights
Marvel went from a roughly $30 million purchase to a $100 million market cap and was sold to Disney for about $4 billion in cash plus stock, around $10 billion in total value, per the discussion.
“30 million to 100 million market cap and then sold to Disney for 4 billion, yeah, really, ten with stock”
0:20:38 · Sean Callagy · Disney sale
Maisel says he did not shop Marvel to other studios and reached a deal with Disney CEO Bob Iger within an hour of a private meeting.
“I didn't shop it to any other studio, I just went right to Bob, had a secret meeting with him, and within an hour, we came up with a deal.”
0:21:04 · David Maisel · Disney deal
Maisel says Disney stock around $25 at the time of the sale was undervalued, and it later reached about $200 before falling to around $110.
“I knew the stock at $25 was severely undervalued and that it was at least a double.”
0:21:28 · David Maisel · Disney stock · 2009
Maisel says Marvel Studios was announced on CNBC in 2004 and Marvel's stock then fell for four years.
“In fact, I announced Marvel Studios on C N B C in 2004, and our stock went down for four years.”
0:34:31 · David Maisel · Marvel stock · 2004
A 2007 New York Times article laid out reasons Marvel Studios would fail, a year before Iron Man was released.
“an article right outside my office, um, from the New York Times in 2007, a year before Iron Man came out, talking about all the reasons Marvel Studios would fail.”
0:34:31 · David Maisel · Press skepticism · 2007
Maisel says Ike Perlmutter bought back about a third of Marvel's stock at low prices, which became valuable when Marvel was sold to Disney.
“He ended up buying back a third of the company at that cheap price, which was very valuable when we sold it to Disney.”
0:35:00 · David Maisel · Stock buyback
Maisel says Angry Birds had declined in popularity by 2016 because it failed to move from paid to free games as competitors did, yet he made a film of it anyway.
“Angry Birds had collapsed in popularity. Um, they didn't navigate, going from paid games to free games, uh, in the way other competitors did”
0:39:18 · David Maisel · Angry Birds movie · 2016
Maisel says he left an hour of each shooting day for Robert Downey Jr. to improvise, producing at least half of Iron Man's comedy.
“I left an hour a day in the schedule for Robert to improvise, and I'd say at least half of the comedy in Iron Man came out of him riffing”
0:42:00 · David Maisel · Improvisation · 2007
Maisel produced a Broadway show before founding Marvel Studios.
“I was able to do a Broadway show before I did Marvel, and I had a lot of success.”
0:47:03 · David Maisel · Maisel career
Iron Man ends with Tony Stark announcing 'I am Iron Man', departing from the comics, followed by the Ozzy Osbourne song.
“Where Tony Stark never says he's Iron man, he keeps that Iron man's, his like bodyguard, he says, I am Iron man.”
0:51:18 · David Maisel · Iron Man ending · 2008
Maisel says Kevin Feige came up with the post-credits Samuel L. Jackson 'Avengers initiative' scene after shooting finished, requiring actors to be recalled.
“That was just inspiration that Kevin Feige, my president of production, had actually, um, after we finished shooting and we had planned it and we had to call all the actors back”
0:51:18 · David Maisel · Post-credits scene · 2008
Maisel says Iron Man grossed roughly $600 million worldwide while The Dark Knight grossed over a billion dollars.
“Iron man did like 600 million and change, and dark knight, which was a great movie. Chris Nolan, Christian Bale did over a billion.”
0:58:28 · David Maisel · Box office · 2008
Maisel says The Dark Knight gave 30% of gross revenue to its director and lead actor, 15% each to Christopher Nolan and Christian Bale.
“they gave 30% gross, meaning off the top of the revenues, 30%, independent of profitability. Went to the director and actor, 15% to Christian, Chris, uh, Christian Bale, and 15% to Chris Nolan.”
0:59:34 · David Maisel · Profit participation · 2008
Maisel says Marvel gave no gross participation to Iron Man's director or actors and kept 100% of the film's equity.
“I gave 0% to my actors or my director for Iron Man. And then to make it worse, I kept 100% of the equity, so we had 100% of the upside.”
0:59:34 · David Maisel · Iron Man economics · 2008
Maisel says DC sold half of its Batman film rights to financier Legendary for cost.
“DC, which I still don't understand why, sold off half of Batman to a essentially financing entity called Legendary Studios for cost”
0:59:34 · David Maisel · Batman financing
Maisel says he promoted Kevin Feige to president of production and put him in charge of Marvel Studios when he sold the company.
“I did a battlefield promotion of Kevin, um, and when I sold the company and put him in charge to run it, so I could do other things”
1:04:01 · David Maisel · Kevin Feige
Maisel acquired rights tied to Michael Turner's Aspen Comics after James Cameron's option expired, and is developing the Ecos universe from it.
“with this acquisition of Michael Turner's comic book company, Aspen Comics, after James Cameron let the rights expire, um, that's what I've been working on”
1:17:21 · David Maisel · Ecos
Maisel is developing Mythos Studios, which includes a Greek and Roman mythology universe called the Mythovers alongside Ecos.
“we have something called the mythovers, which is going to be in my studios called Mythos Studios, um, to work on those two universes.”
1:22:02 · David Maisel · Mythos Studios