Ray Dalio: Seek Out Thoughtful Disagreement View From The Top (Stanford GSB) · 3 Sep 2019 Source: https://tracking.swap.fm/track/zA4xtlPBvf2K1K9zesjz/op3.dev/e/rss.art19.com/episodes/f024e133-22a8-4e82-8b12-6e9deb714795.mp3?rss_browser=BAhJIhpwb2RjYXN0cy5vcGVubmFzaC5jb20GOgZFVA%3D%3D--127c2b111482b9f79a2a6133892dd1fcfbf13bf8 Transcript: https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/view-from-the-top/ray-dalio-seek-out-thoughtful-disagreement-1f6bf3/ (via OpenNash Podcasts, machine-generated) The best comes from learning from mistakes and doing that in a systematic way. Failure is just part of the journey. Paperboy, snow shoveler, golf caddy, Ray Dalio has had a lot of jobs. But the one he's best known for is founder and current co-CIO of Bridgewater Investments, the most successful hedge fund in history. Dalio has been called the Steve Jobs of investing. In an interview with an MBA student at Stanford Graduate School of Business, Dalio talks about the downfall of arrogance and how strength comes from a conflict of ideas. You're listening to View from the Top, the podcast. Ray, we are so excited to have you here tonight at Stanford. Thank you for joining us. I'm so excited to be here. Well, Ray, as a tribute, as our little tribute to Bridgewater, we are going to videotape this conversation. But I had to veto any of this live scoring stuff. I'm just not at your level in handling feedback yet. We've got a lot to cover. Your life, your principles, and how you think about the future. But before we start, I want to get a feel for our audience here tonight. so please raise your hand if you have read or are reading Ray's book Principles. Wow. Pretty good. Okay, and for the rest of you, how many of you are planning to read Principles? Yeah, they're an ambitious group. And for anyone else out there, do you at least have your own moral principles? Okay, good, good. Let's start back in the early days on Long Island. Now, you were quite the capitalist growing up. You were a paperboy, a lawnmower, a snow shoveler, and a golf caddy. And at the ripe old age of 12, you made your first investment in the stock market. Talk to us about how that even happens. Well, you know, everybody was talking about the stock market. It was no big deal, really. at the time in the 60s the stock market was the hottest it has ever been literally if you got a haircut or anything everybody would talk to you about the stock market so when I was caddying they were talking to me about the stock market and I'd take my $6 a bag I'd take my $12 and when I got $50 I'd put it in the stock market it was just a natural thing to do and it did pretty well the first investment Yeah, it was the only company that I ever heard of that was selling for less than $5 a share. So I figured I could buy more shares, which meant if it went up, I'd make more money. That was my rationale. That was a stupid rationale, right? And it was a company that was about to go broke, but another company acquired it, it tripled in value. And I thought, this game's easy, I can make a lot of money. Game's not easy, but that's what got me hooked. So you got a bit of a rolling start, but you continued to invest through high school and university, and you later enrolled at a business school, one we like to call the Stanford of the East, where you met, of course, Joel Peterson. Joel was in my head group, and we have good memories. Now, we'll talk about those later. Now, Ray, for your summer internship, many of your classmates were going to Wall Street, and they were seeking these glamorous equity trading positions. You, on the other hand, sought out a role in commodities trading, which at the time wasn't just less prestigious. It was pretty obscure for an MBA to seek out that kind of a role. So talk to us about what that experience of going against the grain taught you. Well, it was, I figured they had low margin requirements, right? you only had to basically put up about 10 % of the money. So I figured if you're going to be right, you'll make more money because of the low margin requirements. So I got hooked on commodity trading. And then there wasn't anybody who would go from Harvard Business School. So this was 1972, the summer of 1972. And I went to the director of commodities and I begged for a job. And he gave me a job. and that was just before the 1973 oil crisis and the oil shock. And then Wall Street went to hell and commodities became hot and I was lucky and so I went into commodities. So you were hot property by second year. I never really knew anything about commodities other than the summer job but I was then a hot property because there was no Harvard Business School type person in commodities. So I got a job, which was stupid to hire me, but they did. And then that company then got into trouble. Then I went to another company, and I did that for about a year and then started Bridgewater. So I just want to – you skipped over something there. Now, many of us here in the room, Ray, we know you as a master, a master of thoughtful disagreement, okay? But you didn't have that concept fully nailed back in those early days. So talk to us about that disagreement you had with your boss on New Year's Eve. Well, I mean, we got drunk and then we, you know, I slugged him. And he was a good guy. And what he did, he, but he drove home. He totaled his car. His wife chewed him out because they missed their party. And he came in with a black eye, and he didn't fire me then. He didn't fire you? He did not fire me then. And then it was another incident that caused him to fire me. I'm sure I want to know what got you fired. Can you tell us what got you fired? But anyway, that was the best thing that actually happened to me because then I was on my own. Now, some of our career advisors around here, we might frame that one as passion, right? It was, you know, kind of in retrospect, it was a stupid thing to do, right? But it was just what I was like at the time, I guess. And so you go ahead and start Bridgewater Associates from your two-bedroom apartment in New York. So you're 26 years old. you're a first-time entrepreneur and a professional investor. Now, something those roles would seem to have in common is you have a high risk of being wrong and making mistakes. Talk to us about your relationship with mistakes and how those led to your principles. Yeah, I think just generally as an entrepreneur or in the markets, you have to think differently in order to be successful. In the markets, whatever the view is, is built into the price because it reflects the consensus. And as an entrepreneur starting out a business, you have to think differently. And there's a high risk of being wrong. And so what I learned over that period, you have to be audacious, you have to think differently, you have to be confident. and then you also experience a high risk of being wrong. And I think we're going to go to a clip of one of the really big mistakes that I made that changed my whole approach to decision-making. So I, in 1980, 81, I had calculated that American banks had lent a lot more money to foreign countries and those countries were going to be able to pay back and that we were going to have a debt crisis. and I thought that that would cause an economic collapse. And in August 1982, Mexico defaulted on its debt and I received a lot of attention for that and I was asked to speak to Congress at that time and I was also on Wall Street Week. And we brought a clip of that so you'll get a sense of that. So, Zach, can you hit the button and show the clip? Mr. Chairman, Mr. Mitchell, it's a great pleasure and a great honor to be able to appear before you in examination with what is going wrong with our economy. The economy is now flat, teetering on the brink of failure. You were recently quoted in an article. You said, I can say this with absolute certainty because I know how markets work. I can say with absolute certainty that if you look at the liquidity base in the corporations and the world as a whole, that there's such a reduced level of liquidity that you can't return to an era of stagflation. Wasn't I arrogant? Incredibly arrogant. I couldn't have been more wrong. I was so wrong. That was the exact bottom in the stock market. August 1982, Mexico defaulted on its debt, and it was the bottom in the stock market. We had a big bull mark. And I had then, I think, like eight people at Bridgewater, and I had to let them go. And I was so broke that I had to borrow $4 ,000 from my dad in order to pay for my family bills. And that was very painful. And it changed my whole approach to decision-making, because it made me think, in the future, how do I know I'm not wrong? How do I know I'm right? It gave me the humility that I needed to balance with my audacity. And it made me bring in people that would disagree with me. So I wanted to find the smartest people that would disagree with me. And I really started to think about how would I deal with disagreement. And I would say that this is a big thing. It's such a pleasure to be here, by the way, because you're beginning this phase of your career. you're just about to this what I would call the second phase of your life first phase of your life is when you're dependent on others and you're learning second phase of your life is that when you're working and then eventually others become dependent on you and in that second phase it's totally different and I'm going into my third phase and so to be able to sort of pass along some things that were helpful to me where is uh is a treat and along those lines I would say you're going to keep having failures as well as successes. And it's in the failures that you learn the most. And so my attitude began to change in terms of making decisions. Most importantly, I would view every failure as a puzzle that would give me a gem if I could solve the puzzle. And the puzzle was what would I do differently in the future so that I wouldn't have that bad outcome? And if I could solve that, that would give me the gem. And the gem was a principle. And the other thing that I did was write down all my decision-making principles. When I would make a decision, I would take the time and say, what are my criteria for making that decision? And that was so invaluable. I'd want to pass that along to you. You're going to encounter so many things in your life and you're just going to make decisions like that. If instead you pause and you think, what are my criteria for making that decision? You write it down and then you reflect on it. You'll start to realize that the same thing happens over and over again. And when the next one comes along, you'll reflect on that principle and you'll refine it. And it serves the purpose also of letting you communicate very effectively with others. So when I started my business, it was great because we would all know what we could expect and why, that whole process. So that, I mean, I think it's really that whole notion of the best comes from learning from mistakes and doing that in a systematic way. Failure is just part of the journey. And to get to those mistakes, Ray, to bring them out into the open, you needed an idea of meritocracy. and for that you needed radical truth and radical transparency. Talk to us a little bit about those two concepts. I don't know, Zach, you have that diagram? Okay, Zach's busy today. This is the way it worked for me. So in order to be successful I needed independent thinkers who would disagree with me and that we would disagree with each other because otherwise it's that false confidence. How do you stress test each other to get to the best ideas. So I needed independent thinkers who were also wanting to go for the audacious goals. So if you have independent thinkers, how are you going to get past the disagreement? You actually have to have a system for disagreeing well and getting past the disagreement. So I needed an idea meritocracy, in other words an actual process that organizes disagreement to get past it. And in order to do that, then And I needed to have that principled. I needed to write it down and we all needed to know what that rules are. And then we need to make these systems. And then when we did that, that changed everything, right? That thoughtful disagreement. Because it's collective decision making in which you significantly increase the probabilities of making a right decision. I think the greatest tragedy of people, probably one of the greatest tragedies of mankind, is people who hold opinions in their mind that they're attached to that are wrong that they could so easily stress test and significantly raise the probability of being right. So we needed to do that. And when we did that, we had our successes and our failures. But the people believed in that idea of meritocracy, and it was fair. Because the system, if you have a system in which you can fight for your arguments and you know that the system's going to be fair, you can care more. And so that's the type of organization I needed to... And that was the key, right? Whatever success I've had in my life has had more to do with my knowing how to deal with what I don't know than because of anything I know and that idea of meritocracy, that triangulation with smart people. So Ray, I want to go a layer deeper on this radical truth and radical transparency. I think for many of us hearing it here, it's very hard to argue with the logic of what you're saying. And yet the culture at Bridgewater feels quite foreign to what most of us have experienced in our personal or professional lives. What is it about this concept that is so difficult for us to embrace? By the way, that's the competitive edge, right? Because if it was, you know, if you were to say, what's the edge? That's the edge. I think we have ego and blind spots barriers that stand in our way. And so that notion of attached to what you know is such a big thing for your ego or your blind spot. And so there's this subliminal reaction when somebody disagrees. Rather than producing curiosity, it produces antagonism, like it's an amygdala reaction. and I think a lot has to do with the education system too. You're rewarded for knowing or you're rewarded for not making mistakes rather than knowing what your weaknesses are. So in order to go through that, one has to intellectually go through it to say does it make sense. So let's say we're going to have a relationship and you're working there and you're my partner. Great. Oh yeah? I want to see what it's like. But I would say, do you want to know what I really think? Do you want to tell me what you really think? Do you want to know your weaknesses? Do you want me to know my weaknesses? Intellectually, you would say you would want to know your weaknesses. Why wouldn't you want to know your weaknesses? Emotionally that can be difficult So it takes adapting to So what we describe it as There's two you's There's the And this is correct in terms of literally There is a conscious thoughtful you That might say I would like me to do those things I'd like to know my weaknesses So I can know how to deal with them And then there's an emotional you that's subliminal and it's really the battle with your two you's that you have with yourself and once people start to realize that and they come in that environment then they see that they're really more struggling with themselves than each other so that radical truthfulness so the way it is is in order to have the radical truthfulness you have to put what you honestly think on the table can you do that and then transparency means that you can get to see everything So what I did was put everybody could see everything. So that was the main thing. So when I would make decisions, I would be doing, I'd be very, very radically open about what I was doing in the most difficult decisions that we would make. And then I would refer to the principles, and then I'd have everybody challenge me on whether that made sense. And so our intellectual approach overcame our emotional barriers. But I think it's like that for physical. You know, I was, H.R. McMaster's here, and he was a great host to me down, and I got to see Ranger School. And I think about those people pushing themselves and how they were pushing themselves, and they were doing the physical equivalent, although the mental was equally important. and that produces that particular strain. They wanted that and that's what Bridgewater is about. But it's not for everybody, just like some people would wash out of the Army Rangers. It's not for everybody, but it's powerful because you build meaningful work and meaningful relationships. In other words, I think that that's the power. If you are committed to your mission, like you're excited, we're going to do this thing together, Maybe a startup or maybe whatever it is. You're on that mission together. And then at the same time you're on that mission, you have these meaningful relationships, which means total honesty. And with that total honesty and that meaningful relationship, you get a joy out of the relationship as well as you get a joy about being successful. And it doesn't have that two-faced nature. It doesn't have politics behind it. It's just straightforward. So yeah, that's what it's like. So that's really what you're avoiding. It's the kind of politics and the gossiping that you might get in the normal world, albeit it's not for everyone. Not everyone can kind of take this. It changes the ethic. Like, there's no talking behind somebody's back. And the reason it is, is it's almost like, first of all, it's unproductive. If you're talking behind somebody's back, then you're not dealing with a particular issue. In a place like where we value anybody speaking up with their point of view, then you can raise it and you can then deal with it. But also it then becomes sort of an ethic thing. That like don't you have the guts to talk about what you're saying? And so if you have the guts, so it's almost humiliating to talk behind somebody's back. And so that standard then carries forward and it leads to that kind of radical truthfulness, that radical transparency. So you have some people, you know, it's not at all for, and then you have people who couldn't work anywhere else because they wouldn't want to work. They go into the company and everybody's smiling and they're giving them high fives and whatever, and they're all talking behind each other's backs. There's a lot of politics going on, and that they can't deal with. So a lot of people wouldn't want to work anywhere else, and some people it's not the right place for. So Ray, you've built a machine, really, that supports this culture, and you also have a belief that humans are machines. I think few companies have done more than Bridgewater to try and use data to understand their employees, to put their attributes and their talents into numbers. So I'm curious if you see a tension between this explicit labeling of a person's abilities with what Carol Dweck at Stanford might call this growth mindset, The idea that a person's abilities, talent, even intelligence is more fluid and can change. Well, I think that I'm just trying to be as accurate as possible. And change, if a change occurs, then is reflected in the numbers and everybody sees the change. So it's a light snapshot, really. But I think that at any point in time, you have to be realistic of where you are. And you have to recognize that people have different strengths and weaknesses. is. And if you're not dealing with that, that's a particular problem. It stands in the way of the growth of the particular people. And then also people are making choices about other people there, right? So if I'm your boss or making that decision, if I'm not open, if I don't give you that constant feedback, and also if I'm not collecting data from others because I'm not sure that I'm right. So the data kind of helps to speak for itself in terms of understanding what a person is like. So I think it's a good thing. It doesn't mean that you stand in the way of evolution. It means that to whatever extent evolution occurs, you get to see it. So I think that the bigger context here is many of us will be graduating in a few months, and some of us will be making a choice. Do we return to a job and a function we know how to do that suits us well, or do we branch out down anew on tested path? From what you've seen at Bridgewater, what might you advise us and how we think about that? This is the time for your adventure, your experimenting, your learning, right, for that experimentation. And I'll guarantee you that wherever you're going to be in five years is going to change. You know, go for the experience. But I think the most important thing I would say when you're going on that adventure is to understand how to triangulate well. What I mean is find the three or four smartest people who are dealing with the most important questions that you're facing, particularly if they're willing to disagree with each other and disagree with you on that. And then with that triangulation, where there are areas of the disagreement, that'll bubble to the surface and you'll find out what might be, you'll learn a lot. And then through that, that humility, you go through experiences and make the most out of your failures. Be adventurous, make the discovery, go for it. All right. Right? All right, well, we're done. Thank you very much. I'm joking. But the other question we face, Ray, is what type of organization do we join? I think culture is the most important thing. I think who you're with and where you are is much more important than what you do. Sorry, let me take you up on that. So let's assume you're in our shoes. You're about to go into the working world and you want to work in an idea meritocracy. Many in this room are going to join large organizations that have embedded hierarchies, cultures, and norms. So talk to us in a practical sense about how we can bring some of these ideas to the workplace. Well, you have the choice to work in wherever culture you want. The most important thing is do you work in the culture? Now, you were raised here in your education and before to try to have the opportunity to make sense of things. Okay. So I would go into your job and say, if something doesn't make sense to me, do I have the right to say it doesn't make sense to me and ask you why it makes sense and to be able to probe you? Or do I not have that right? And I think you should think hard about whether you want to be in the organization that doesn't give you that right. So I think the most fundamental thing is to be in that kind of organization with humility, in other words, recognizing that you might not, But you always have the right to make sense of things. And if something doesn't make sense, to say it doesn't make sense. So I would say that that would be the most important thing for me if you're gonna learn, because otherwise you're gonna be somebody schlep. You know, they're going to say, do these things, and you're just gonna run and follow their instructions and so on. And you're not gonna learn if you're following their instructions. Cuz you have to think for yourself, I think. And you've given us plenty of tools to do that, Ray. I want to talk a little bit about your legacy. You've accumulated these principles over 40 years. You've decided to share them as part of what you're calling this third phase in your life. A question Joel often asks the class is what does winning look like to you? You've invested huge amounts of your time and energy in this public-facing role. What does winning look like in this third phase? I think through life it's all just a matter of personal evolution and contributing to evolution. For me, you evolve. And there's an instinctual reaction that I had that what I wanted to do is pass along the things that are valuable to me so I can move beyond that. And my son at 2014, when I was making this transition, gave me this book, Joseph Campbell's Hero of Thousand Faces, and he describes these various phases of our lives, which I related to. I won't take you through them all, but there's a call to adventure. You go on the venture, you have your ups and downs, you reflect on them and so on. And then when you get to this stage in your life, the thing that you want more is not to be successful. You've done it. You don't want to be more successful. You want to help others be successful without you. And that's what I feel. And then I feel like if I've done that best job, I will have done my best job and we're good. And so that's my instinctual reaction at this time. Well, you've given us a lot to start, and I know there's plenty out there who haven't read the book, so you're not quite there yet. I want to say just for everybody, and I'll mention it maybe later, what I did was there's the book, and then I converted the book into an app that has the actual cases of Bridgewater. So you could go into meetings, and you can actually see this in action. We call it Principles in Action. It's a free app on the Apple Store. and it'll take you into that so you get a sense of what the thing is like. Plenty more case studies. We love those, Ray. Now, Ray, we could spend another hour on these principles, but unfortunately you've got far too many other perspectives we want to probe you on. Let's start with history. You're a student of history. You've stated that everything that happens is just another one of those. So I'm curious, when you look at today, our stage in the economic cycle, our political tensions, our geopolitical tensions. What's the historical precedent for what you see, and what does that tell us about what happens next? Well, I think there are cause-effect relationships, and then they repeat through history. I think it's important to not just assume that because they happened in the past that they'll happen again, but also to understand the cause-effect relationships. So in answering your question, I'd like to refer to both. One of the things that I learned was that almost every time I was surprised, I was surprised by things that did not happen in my lifetime, but happened many times before. And as a result of that, I really found that I really needed to understand history and why things happened before. it and that in 2007 because I studied what happened in the Great Depression, we were able to anticipate the 2008 financial crisis because of what happened in 1929 and 32. So the period that I think that is most analogous is the late 1930s and I'll explain why. And this is just the mechanics of it. We had a debt crisis in 1932, 1929 to 1932. And in both of those cases, interest rates hit zero. Only two times in the century that that happened. When interest rates hit zero, they had to, the central banks had to print money and buy financial assets. We call that quantitative easing. Those purchases of financial assets push financial asset prices up, and as a result of pushing that up, it makes the economy go up. So 1932 to 1937, the economy, the stock market went up, everything went up in much the same way as it did from 2009 until recently. And then, but because they bought financial assets, those with financial assets benefited more than those who didn't have financial assets. And there were other factors, like we have technology today replacing people. And as a result, we had a large wealth gap. So if you look today, the top one-tenth of 1 % of the population's net worth is equal to the bottom 90 % combined. And if you take that or measures like that, the wealth gap is the same as it was in that period of time, that 1930s period of time. And with a large wealth gap and differences in values, then you have populism, the emergence of populism, populism of the left and populism of the right. And if you go through history, if you were to say, when did the last time you had populism in major countries? It was in that period of time for similar reasons. And with that time also, you had the classic rising of a power to challenge an existing power. In that case, it was Germany rising to challenge the British Empire, and then Japan and Asia. And like now we have China rising and there's a rivalry, a conflict. So the only periods of time that you could see that was analogous recently, the most recent period of time is like that. So I would say what are the big issues of the time? The big issues today are that there is a limited ability of central banks to ease monetary policy because we have interest rates near zero most cases around the world and so the capacity of central banks to ease is limited. We have a very large wealth gap and with that we have polarity, a lot of political polarity, democracy even being challenged by that polarity. And then you have these conflicts around the world. And so that populism of the left and populism of the right has big economic implications. What it'll mean for tax policy and what will it mean for even conflicts between countries. And so we have that rising power situation. So that period of time looks most analogous to today. You've covered a lot of things there, Ray, and we'll try and dive into a few at the time we have left. On a high level, it's a pretty shocking comparison to make. And we know how the 1930s ended. Do you believe that on our current trajectory we're heading towards some sort of conflict? Well, we're certainly heading to different kinds of conflict. The question, I think, is how we're going to handle them. We certainly are headed domestically to lots of conflict, right? If you were to take the polls of the Republican Party is the most conservative it has been ever, the Democratic Party is the most liberal it is ever, the voting according to party lines is the most it has been ever. 94 % of the votes are according to party lines. And so we certainly have an internal conflict. And that internal conflict has to do about the combination, I think, of the economic conditions, the left and the right, or let's say socialism and capitalism are issues. And then there's also ways that we are to be together. I would say, you know, I don't know that we're clear on what principles bind us together as a country. I think we should go to principles. What principles bind us together as a country? What do we believe in? What are the principles that divide us? But anyway, we are having more domestic conflict, I think. And then international conflict. There will be a challenge, a competition, that is going on between the United States and China and other places, but particularly the United States and China, which is a whole other discussion. That doesn't have to be a military conflict, though it could be. and it depends I think on how we handle the conflict. So I think there's the China-American relation, that's a topic we could digress into if you want to cover it, but I think it's all how are we going to be with each other, right? So let's say this issue of the wealth gap and the left and the right. My big fear is that the conflict and then just badly engineered policies can cause us to have worse conditions than we need to. There's like there's enough resources to go around to move us toward more equal opportunities in various ways. We can deal with this together. But, yeah, I think that we're in an environment in which conflict is going to be more problematic than we have actually experienced. Now, Ray, there's two issues. There's the external conflict. There's the internal conflict in our own country. You've talked about redistribution, and you've recently published a piece, How and Why Capitalism Needs to be Reformed, and a Need for Greater Redistribution. Because it's tax day, April 15th. Apologies. Would you agree that a person of your resources and your wealth should be taxed more by the U.S. government to help further this? Yes. I believe that it's inevitable that we should. Yes. But I think the real question is, the most important, is are we striving to have a country? What is our American dream? are we striving to have a country that is something along the lines of equal opportunity? Are we striving along the... How do we feel when there are school districts that don't have adequate, anywhere near adequate resources, that there's not enough, it goes to nutrition? There's nothing approaching equal education. I broke the economy up into two parts so that I could see it, because it gets lost in the averages. So the top 40 % and the bottom 60%, because I wanted to see what the majority of people, the bottom 60 % is like. And certain things like the average in the top 40%, they will spend five times as much on their children's education than in the bottom 60%. And school districts are starved for resources. and there's a whole different life. I can rattle it off. If you want to go see it, I'd really love you to go see it. It's a study that's on LinkedIn and it shows the outcomes. So I guess when I'm looking at that, I would say that's not, I think, a fair system. And beyond that, it's a system that threatens to destroy us if we don't find a way to reform it. Now, I'm a capitalist. I do believe in the idea of working hard and earning and then saving. And what capitalism is, is you buy an instrument, a capitalist. You buy stocks. That's capitalism. You own a piece of that business. And I believe that that's fantastic. But what has, like anything, everything has got to be improved with time, with reformation. So are we producing the outcomes that we want? So when you read that, you see if we're producing the outcomes we want. I don't think so. So I'm saying I think we have to modify that. Now, how we do that is going to, most importantly, be a very, it has to be a good exercise, engineering exercise, that I think has to be first, it's got to be done in a bipartisan way, because I think this division is a problem. And I really believe in thoughtful disagreement. So if you bring together people who are living in these communities and then you have metrics, I think it would be great if the leadership, it could be the leadership of the United States, it could be the leadership of the state, says that this is a critical issue that we have to deal with, that they put metrics on it so they own it. In other words, numbers and KPIs. And they say, here's that condition. Is that living standard the same or is it rising? And what are we doing in terms of education? And with those measures, then work together in terms of doing sensible engineering. I have my own views of what could be done, but how we get into that, that's a whole conversation. I'm not so sure my views should matter. This is just one of other views. But if we don't do it together and we don't treat it as a really important critical issue, I think the most critical issue of our time right now, I think we're going to be in trouble. So yes, of course, but there needs to be redistribution of opportunity. It's not just redistribution of money, but get the school books, get the nutrition, get those basic things. I think that's fundamental. Well, Ray, we're at least out of time for now. I want to make sure our audience here have the chance to ask their questions of you. So anyone out there who has a question, please raise your hand. We'll find you with a microphone. And then if you're selected, please stand up and introduce yourself before you ask your question. Hello. My name is Max. I'm MBA1. I'm from Russia. I'm so sorry I don't know the local political landscape that well. But my question is, having such a great reputation, knowledge, and leadership experience in this country, why are you not running for the president of the United States? Because I don't think me and the political system would get along. I don't think I'd – I think it's a very difficult system. I don't think it would be effective. I think the political system, even the way it's structured, where the two parties and the way they go about it, I think it's a challenge that's almost impossible to win. And anyway, I'm able at this moment in time, this short moment in time, to pass along some thoughts that others in that position or any position could take or leave. Thanks for being here. I'm Ida Germa. I'm a first-year MBA student. I have two questions. If you want to be fair, you could just pick one to answer. One is we understand that you're really quite quantitative and systematic about the way you think about decisions for investments, for your business, and in personal life as well. I'm wondering what you think about this notion of intuition. Do you believe in it? Do you use it? And my second question is, you know, I'm quite inspired by how you talk about equality of opportunity. I think it's fantastic. I suspect that you have peers and colleagues who may not think the same things, and how do you have conversations with them about this thing that you're so passionate about? Yeah, so what was the first question? Intuition, intuition, yeah. I think decision making is subliminal and logical. And fabulous ideas come from subliminal decision making. But you don't know if they're great or not, that you have to reconcile them with the logic. so yes intuition can be very very valuable we feel it, you see it, it's subliminal the ability to collect dots connect dots and see things in that way imagination, all of that some of the best ideas come in a subliminal way like if you're taking a hot shower and these ideas come to you, it's not like you're sitting there working hard on those ideas As they come up, they can be fabulous. I think the key is to reconcile them with your logic because they could be misleading too. So yes, I would say they're at least as valuable as the logical idea. So, and the second question was about, what? How do you have those conversations with your peers about equal opportunity? Just the art of thoughtful disagreement. I mean, I love disagreement. I just have to say what I believe and others say what they believe, and then we have a conversation about it. And I love it to do that openly. So if you were to sit here and have a conversation, I would welcome anybody who has a different point of view. Have a thoughtful conversation. That's easy. I don't see any reason why there shouldn't be good thoughtful disagreement. Hi, Ray. I'm Will. I'm also a first-year MBA student. I know you're a member of the giving pledge, so I was wondering what principles you apply to your giving in order to maximize your social return on investment in the same way you did with your financial returns. Yeah, the saying that it's tougher to give away money than it is to make it is actually true because when you're pursuing a profit, you will know whether you're succeeding or failing. When you're giving away money, it's very difficult to have those kinds of metrics and weigh one thing or another. It's a lot more confusing. But I tend to take the same approach that I would in my investing, meaning I try to think in terms of return on investment, but I think in terms of double bottom line return on investment. In other words, what is the social impact? It has to stretch your mind because how do you relate? what is the value of saving a life? What is the value of an education? How do you weigh? It doesn't have a common denominator like return on investment has a number. It's money and it's how that is. So that becomes a challenge. For me, it's very important though to try to do that. So we'll establish key performance indicators and do that. But also relating to me is the passion. like I've decided how am I going to take that approach and that approach I make it a family activity my family members different in varying degrees are interested in their own philanthropic efforts and each one of them has their own particular passion I think that's great so I would say that when you get past the certain point what you think about is what do you really want to do you don't think about profit as much as you think about like what do you want to do and I think maybe as you get older or you feel more connected and you also realize the blessings that I've had because I didn't have anything and then I've evolved and you see what other people are is that marginal benefit of spending money on yourself and to being able to help other people makes a big difference so those things return on investment how do I make it sustainable How do I measure? How do I judge how good we are doing as a family? How do I establish principles? We've got a whole bunch of principles that people have to abide by in order to do it well. So it's similar, but it's more difficult because of the fact that you can't account for it very well. So if you were to think, what should you give money to? Are you going to be able to measure whether education here or life? Those are difficult questions to answer, but you work yourself through it. I joined the Giving Pledge mostly because I learn a lot. The people in there are in somewhat similar circumstances, and they brainstorm well, and it's a learning process. Hi. Ruben Arnold, MBA2. So I know you've tried to transition out of the company and transition control of the company several times in the last years as you're moving into this third phase. I was wondering if you could speak a little bit to the dynamics that might have made that transition difficult. Well, I fortunately had this principle. Here's the background. Something like nine years ago, I decided that I wanted to transition. It was an important thing. And I didn't know how long it was going to take me. I thought it would take me about two years because I was working with the people for a number of years and I thought it was going to be great. But then on the other hand, I learned never to believe what I think is a theory. If I haven't done something before successfully, then I can't assume that I know how to do it. So I said that maybe it could take up to 10 years. I think it took me about eight and a half years in order to do that well. So you go down a journey. I didn't know anything about governance I had just run the company with this idea of meritocracy that I put myself in a position that I would report to this management committee they could hire, fire me, they could operate that way so that I had myself held accountable to this idea of meritocracy and I thought this thing was going to work I made the transition and then with the difficulty realized that it wouldn't work and we all agreed that it wasn't working and then we set up a governance system you know the proper board and I realized I learned a lot about governance and I learned about how to pass those responsibilities along to others and then you know we worked that out and it's been about a year and a half since I transitioned out of that so I think the lesson is I have a saying if you haven't done something three times before successfully, don't assume you can do it. And that was really helpful to me. So through that trial and error, it was part of the learning process. So I think that's the saying, I guess that would be the principle. If you haven't done something successfully three times before, don't assume you know how to do it. Hi, Alyssa. I'm an MBA one. And when people talk about economic opportunity, a lot of the times we talk about children of the poor becoming rich, but we rarely talk about children of the rich making room for other people. And so I was wondering if your emphasis on equal opportunity affected the way that you parent. Well, yes. See, but I think I had an experience because, and I think my kids were lucky, because I didn't have, I had the most important things. I shouldn't say I didn't have anything. I had parents who loved me. I had adequate nutrition, I was well taken care of. I went to a public high school, but I didn't have much more than that. And then when I was, for most of my life, my kids didn't have much more than that. So they got to, they know the difference. They know what the marginal utility of having a lot is relative to that, it's not very much. and then you start to create that sense of value. So my own experience affected my reaction to it. I don't know what it would be like to be born rich and then find out what that's like. I don't know what that would be like. It must be much more difficult in terms of that. So my experience naturally told me the differences. And I think it's important to understand there have been a number of studies on happiness around the world. probably Stanford's got their professors who want to study happiness. And the one thing is that they found that there's no correlation past the basic level of money and happiness. But the one thing that is the most important thing that seems across communities is a sense of community. And your relationships, your personal relationships. And so I think that that's affected my approach. but I wouldn't know how to do it if I didn't experience it, I don't think. Maybe time for one more question. Hi, I'm David, and I'm a third-year undergrad. In your interviews and your book, you talk about some great leaders like Steve Jobs and Lee Kuan Yew. Could you talk about some of your favorite stories of great character from people like that? Great character? Stories of great character. Stories of great character. Well, different qualities in those two people, But I think Lee Kuan Yew was a person who was wise and balanced and self-sacrificing, a great leader who had the vision and the common sense and the wisdom to also suffer the slings and arrows of his position to make Singapore a very special place. And I had the opportunity to know him a little bit, and he was a remarkable people. But I think that if you read Joseph Campbell's book, Hero of a Thousand Faces, you could almost say, what are the archetypical characteristics of great leaders and there's this evolution and that's described in that book in which people with the sense of adventure and caring they go out on their adventure and then they are on a mission and they succeed and they fail and they do it with other people and that the mission and the other people eventually becomes more important to them than themselves. And then they start to rise in terms of seeing things different, which I think is the essence of what spirituality is. Spirituality, I don't mean religion, I mean the sense of connectedness to others and the whole. And when that becomes more important to them than themselves they become that's what constitutes being a hero and so people like Lee Kuan Yew and such people had those particular qualities and made you know and did what they did so there are many many many cases I mean I'm saying this man over here H.R. McMaster is for me a hero for me and so I see it all around me and I think it is those qualities that make a person a hero. Well, Ray, we've got a few minutes left. You talked about connectedness. In touchy-feely language, I might say I feel more connected to you now. And you've been very generous. You've shared your principles with us. And so as a token of our gratitude, we thought we might share some of our principles with you. So this is, I thought it would be a thin book. It's actually nearly as thick as yours. So this is some of our GSB principles from a lot of students here in the audience. today. Oh, cool. Yeah. This is for real. This is real. This is great. Great. These are your principles. These are our principles. On this app, I do want to take one of the things on the app, there's part of the app is a coach. And one of the things on it is the coach allows you to describe, I'm in this situation. What principle is best for that situation? So, because you just You just don't want a pile of principles, you want to go to find the ones that are most appropriate. And one of the most important things about it is it allows you to put your principles in. And so you could take your principles and drop it into that coach. I'm gonna be really interested. I think that's the most important thing. I think we're in an era where we're confused about principles. That I don't think we spend enough time thinking about principles. We think about doing so much. And maybe as religions have become less important and other things, we don't think about that. So I think it's so valuable that you've done it. And I think it's a real treat, a great gift. Thank you very much. I really appreciate it. You're very welcome. Wait Wait. One sec, one sec. We're actually not quite done yet. You're not right off the hook. There's one more thing. In the interest of radical truth and radical transparency, we need to clear a few rumors up about you, okay? So I'm going to give you a series of statements, and I want you to tell us if these are true or false, okay? You played a pivotal role in the creation of the Chicken McNugget. I thought so. Your devotion to meat commodities led you to name your first son after a cow. True. You caddied as a child for Richard Nixon and the former King of England. True. Who's the better golfer? Richard Nixon, actually. And he wasn't a very good golfer. You can imagine he's in the water a lot, is he? Yeah. You were inspired by the Beatles to take up meditation, and you still practice 50 years later. True, and one of the most important things, I think. It's helped me a lot. You've committed to giving away over half your wealth in your lifetime. Yeah, true. You exclusively fly JetBlue out of loyalty to Joel. He was chewing me out about that. So that's a no. Not yet. Not yet. More roots. You've worked for 44 years at Bridgewater, but have never once got promoted. I got demoted a few times. You secretly wish that you went to Stanford. No comment. Ladies and gentlemen, Ray Dalio. Too political. Too political. Thank you guys. Thank you. You've been listening to View from the Top, the podcast, a production of Stanford Graduate School of Business. This interview was conducted by Will Quinn McCann of the MBA class of 2019. Lily Sloan composed our theme music and produced this episode. You can find more of this podcast on our website at gsb.stanford.edu. Follow us on social media at Stanford GSB. Thank you.