# S5E8: Sundar Pichai: "Reward Effort, Not Outcomes"

- **Show:** View From The Top (Stanford GSB)
- **Published:** 16 Jun 2022
- **Source:** https://tracking.swap.fm/track/zA4xtlPBvf2K1K9zesjz/op3.dev/e/rss.art19.com/episodes/ea959986-4c26-47b6-88b4-437332b8501e.mp3?rss_browser=BAhJIhpwb2RjYXN0cy5vcGVubmFzaC5jb20GOgZFVA%3D%3D--127c2b111482b9f79a2a6133892dd1fcfbf13bf8
- **Transcript:** https://podcasts.opennash.com/shows/view-from-the-top/s5e8-sundar-pichai-reward-effort-not-outcomes-2c2660/
- **Provider:** OpenNash Podcasts (machine-generated)

## In brief

Sundar Pichai argues that a large company stays innovative only if it deliberately rewards effort and tolerates failure, rather than paying out only for results. He says companies grow more cautious as they get richer, because people reward outcomes and so choose safer bets. He ties this to a mission he traces back to his childhood in India: making technology accessible and affordable to as many people as possible.

The main tension is scale. Google's size brings money and reach, but also lost shared context, harder culture, employee protest, regulation and political pressure. Pichai describes responding with openness to employee voice, flexible hybrid work, early engagement with regulators, and large long-term commitments in skills training, clean energy and emerging markets. Some questions, such as access in Syria, he admits he cannot fully answer.

## Key insights

1. **Growth makes companies cautious unless effort is rewarded** Pichai says larger firms have more cash yet make more conservative decisions, because people tend to reward outcomes and so take safer bets. His counter is to reward effort and accept failure, to keep the early-days culture of shipping and innovating.
2. **Chrome began as a quiet small-team project** Then-CEO Eric Schmidt was hesitant because he had lived through the browser battles. Pichai says he did not tell people for a while, kept the team small, and only won support once there was something to show.
3. **Google targets 24/7 carbon-free operations by 2030** Google says it has been carbon neutral since 2007, which can rely on offsets. The 2030 goal is stricter: running operations on carbon-free energy around the clock, which needs new technology such as geothermal, carbon capture and energy storage.
4. **Pichai expects technology to become a regulated industry** He points to Europe's GDPR privacy law, which Google spent almost 18 months preparing for, as legislation that gave certainty to citizens and businesses. He says AI regulation should come earlier than it did for the internet, with many stakeholders involved.
5. **Childhood scarcity shapes his push for access** He waited five years for a rotary phone as a child, and says the phone made his family's life and community better. Today that shows up in cheaper Android phones, Chromebooks, a possible $30 smartphone in India and a product center in Nairobi.

## Questions this episode answers

### What does 'reward effort, not outcomes' mean in practice?

Pichai says big organizations tend to pay out only for good results, which pushes people toward safe bets. He wants companies to accept failure and recognize the work and risk-taking itself, so innovation continues as they grow.

### How did Google's Chrome browser get started?

Pichai says a small committed team built it quietly, and he did not tell people for a while. Eric Schmidt, then CEO, was hesitant because of the earlier browser battles, and support came once there was a working product to show.

### What is Google's hybrid work policy, according to Pichai?

Google started with a '3-2' hybrid option, meaning three days in the office and two elsewhere, and let employees apply to be fully remote. Pichai says Google supported 85% of those remote applications, and office attendance was already over 70% of pre-pandemic levels.

### What is the difference between carbon neutral and carbon-free at Google?

Pichai says Google has been carbon neutral since 2007, which can use offsets. Its 2030 goal is to be carbon-free, meaning operations run on carbon-free energy 24 hours a day without relying on offsets.

### How does Pichai say technology should be regulated?

He says technology is becoming a regulated industry and companies should work with regulators early. He cites Europe's GDPR privacy law as an example that gave clarity, and says AI needs thoughtful regulation that still leaves room for innovation.

## Facts

- **Sundar Pichai** [0:04:32]: "we were on a wait list for a rotary telephone. It took five years to be on the wait list and get the phone."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:03:28]: "the final school is Svanavani, which is inside the campus where your dad went to college."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:05:21]: "walking to Sweet Hall at the time and seeing rows of computers was life-changing for me."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:06:21]: "I was a PhD student in material science. I was studying semiconductor physics."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:10:42]: "I remember him being angry once because he realized we were trying to build a browser."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:10:42]: "I didn't tell people for a while. I just had a small team and, you know, worked on it."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:15:28]: "When I became CEO, one of the biggest directional changes we made is we said, we're going to approach everything as AI first."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:19:18]: "One of the companies we spun out of, Google, which was Niantic, did that, precisely that, with Pokemon"
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:21:14]: "The walkout was a moment when the company hadn't gotten something right, and that's what the walkout was about."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:23:34]: "last year in Pixel and in our camera technology, we launched Realtone, you know, a more inclusive way to capture pictures to cover all skin tones."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:25:59]: "We are starting with a 3-2 hybrid option. but we have encouraged employees to apply to be fully remote as well. And, you know, we have supported 85 % of those applications."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:26:30]: "as we opened up, we are easily at over 70% already back to our pre-pandemic."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:29:42]: "So we announced a $700 million investment, both in office space and to hire more people in Poland."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:31:15]: "in the US, we launched a career certificate program. It's a nine month program. We have done it on four major areas and we back it up with working with employers to recruit people."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:31:15]: "75 ,000 people have gone through it and almost 50 % of it is from underrepresented groups."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:32:48]: "we've been carbon neutral since 2007. So Google has been carbon neutral since 2007."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:32:48]: "What we have now committed is by 2030 to be carbon-free, so not using offsets, but actually running our operations 24-7 carbon-free."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:33:35]: "when we bought some of the earliest wind and solar contracts in 2010, and costs have fallen by 85 % in the last 10 years."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:33:35]: "We just have a whole data center now up and running with geothermal."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:35:08]: "we are working on a cheaper, high-quality smartphone, maybe around the $30 price point."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:35:08]: "we just announced in Africa our product development center in Nairobi, hiring engineers, UX designers, and so on."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:37:30]: "We invested almost 18 months of work to get ready for it."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:39:29]: "to use YouTube as an example, we raise what we think of as authoritative information."
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:41:56]: "he would see me he would ask me what ties did you break this week"
- **Sundar Pichai** [0:44:42]: "Android is open source. Things do make their way into these countries."

## Transcript

**[0:00:00] Sundar Pichai:** Be okay with failure and reward effort, not outcomes. Very hard to do in an organization. People tend to reward outcomes, which means over time, the organization becomes more conservative. They take safer bets.

**[0:00:16] Archana Samshetty:** Welcome to View From the Top, the podcast. That was Sundar Pichai, CEO of Google and Alphabet. Sundar visited Stanford Graduate School of Business as part of View From the Top, a speaker series where students like me sit down to interview business leaders from around the world. I'm Archana Sohmshetty, an MBA student of the class of 2022. This year, I had the pleasure of interviewing Sundar on campus. He shares the importance of rewarding effort, not outcomes, ways to lead with authenticity and putting employees first, and how gaining access to technology makes lives better around the world.

**[0:00:57] Archana Samshetty:** You're listening to View from the Top, the podcast. Welcome back to Stanford.

**[0:01:04] Sundar Pichai:** It's great to be here, and it's nice to be back physically with people in the room, so it's terrific.

**[0:01:10] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, and as you can tell, my classmates and I are so excited that you're here with us today. And this conversation is extra special for me because your story hits so close to home. Like you, my dad is from South India. He is an alumnus of IIT and immigrated here about 30 years ago with grit and determination. He's right here in the audience. He's a role model for me, and so are you. So truly, thank you for being here.

**[0:01:54] Sundar Pichai:** Oh, the real pleasure is mine. It's very nostalgic. I was just telling John I saw a volleyball court outside. Stanford was the end of my fledgling volleyball career, coming here and seeing how good people were, but it's really nice to be back.

**[0:02:08] Archana Samshetty:** Lots of talent around here. And, you know, when you first became the CEO of Google, it created quite a buzz. Your Wikipedia page had over 350 edits just in the week that you became the leader. Have you seen some of these edits?

**[0:02:26] Sundar Pichai:** Advice I would have for all of you is don't read about yourself online.

**[0:02:31] Archana Samshetty:** Well, we thought it'd be a good way to start the conversation by visiting some of these Wikipedia edits, some of our favorite ones, with Fact vs. Fake News, your Wikipedia page edition. first of all someone claimed that you decided to join iit at the young age of eight years old fact or fake uh i think that was

**[0:02:58] Sundar Pichai:** fake i was my parents were tired of me they sent me to school i think when i was about two and a half to kindergarten i was pretty young when i came to stanford but that is not true

**[0:03:10] Archana Samshetty:** At the same time, everyone wanted to claim you from their hometown and high school. So there are quite a few edits to your page on which high school you came from. Where did you go?

**[0:03:28] Sundar Pichai:** There are two schools which are right, but the final school is Svanavani, which is inside the campus where your dad went to college. So that's where I went to school.

**[0:03:38] Archana Samshetty:** Wow. Okay. So the person that said you were homeschooled was definitely wrong.

**[0:03:45] Sundar Pichai:** I don't think I was homeschooled unless it involved playing cricket. You know, I wasn't homeschooled.

**[0:03:52] Archana Samshetty:** Well, on that note, were you the captain of your high school cricket team?

**[0:03:58] Sundar Pichai:** I would have loved to be. But I was quite far from it, yeah.

**[0:04:04] Archana Samshetty:** In another life.

**[0:04:05] Sundar Pichai:** In another life.

**[0:04:12] Archana Samshetty:** So now that we have the fiction out of the way, we can turn to some of the facts. You grew up in India with limited access to technology. And when you discovered technologies, it had a profound impact on you. How did you go from an initial delight in technology to devoting your career to access to technology for all?

**[0:04:32] Sundar Pichai:** No, it was, you know, I had, you know, growing up for me, you know, every technology transition was very vivid, even as a kid, because I had to wait a long time for it. You know, we were on a wait list for a rotary telephone. It took five years to be on the wait list and get the phone. You know, I would go to get my grandparents' blood test results, and it would be an hour round trip each way.

**[0:04:57] Sundar Pichai:** And you would go all the way to the hospital, and they would say, it's not ready today, come back. tomorrow. And then this phone came and I could call and they would tell me whether the results were ready or not. And so to me, that was like super profound. And people would come to our house to make calls. I saw how it created a sense of community. So I've always had this vivid sense of how technology can make a profound difference.

**[0:05:21] Sundar Pichai:** And so a lot of what I've tried to do is bring that access to technology. What I got, I got a lot more of it when I came to Stanford, walking to Sweet Hall at the time and seeing rows of computers was life-changing for me. And, you know, I was very inspired by Negroponte's One Laptop Per Child project. And even today, a lot of what I'm able to do at Google, be it make cheaper phones through Android, bring the next billion people online or Chromebooks and try to make affordable laptops, all hit close to that mission.

**[0:05:55] Sundar Pichai:** So definitely.

**[0:05:56] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, and I can tell the way that you speak about technology had this impact on you. And it manifested in your studies as well. You got your engineering degree from IIT and then a master's here at Stanford in engineering. And we're about to pursue a career in academia and get your PhD. Clearly, that's not the path you ended up taking. What changed your mind? Why did you decide to leave academia at the time?

**[0:06:21] Sundar Pichai:** I still once in a while have a conversation with my dad. I think I disappointed him a little bit, not getting that PhD. But, you know, I literally came to Silicon Valley for me. It was as literal. I mean, this was the place where semiconductors were built. I came here for the Silicon and Silicon Valley. And, you know, I was a PhD student in material science. I was studying semiconductor physics. And definitely that's what I thought I would do.

**[0:06:49] Sundar Pichai:** A few things. One is I was surrounded by other grad students who had worked on at the time what was the rage. It was superconductors, what was called high-TC superconductors. And I realized many of them had spent their life, and it didn't happen. And so that gave me pause. And I think something you all probably deal with, being in the valley, there's so much happening outside. There's a lot that beckons outside. And so I was definitely interested in that.

**[0:07:14] Sundar Pichai:** I had financial reasons to go get a job. And so the combination of all that made me go out and be in industry. And a great learning moment. The semiconductor industry is extraordinarily cyclical. In my first year, in the company I worked, we hired 3 ,000 people, and the next year we laid off 1 ,700 people. And so you get out and you go through that life learning. But that was the early days of the Internet, too.

**[0:07:41] Sundar Pichai:** And definitely seeing what the promise the Internet had and connecting it back to what I wanted to do was what led me find my way back to Google. and I went to business school along the way, not here, but another great school, and eventually made it back to the Valley.

**[0:07:58] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, it seems like you saw the rapid change of technology outside of academia.

**[0:08:04] Sundar Pichai:** Oh yeah, you know, Stanford itself is a special place. I think there are, you know, most faculty here are very, you know, it's a very symbiotic relationship which I've always thought is unique amongst many places in the world. And so definitely both being in the campus, You get a good sense for what's happening outside. And going to industry here, you really get the sense for the dynamism. We take it for granted. But as I travel around the world, most people outside are trying to understand how the valley works and how to do better.

**[0:08:39] Sundar Pichai:** So it's an extraordinary place.

**[0:08:41] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah. And many of us here are in a transitory period of our lives, figuring out which industry we want to go and impact. You've been at Google for now quite a while, 20 years, and faced several crossroads during your time. Sometimes choosing to leave an industry is as difficult as choosing to stay. What drew you to stay at Google over the past 20 years?

**[0:09:05] Sundar Pichai:** It's been very busy, partly that. It's an extraordinary place. I think the breadth of talent you see, the kind of projects you get exposed to. You're on the cutting edge of everything. It's like, I'm not a surfer, but I use this analogy. I don't know why, but it's like I've tried a couple of times and I fail. But it feels like surfing and being on the edge of something all the time. So definitely I enjoy that.

**[0:09:37] Sundar Pichai:** And a big part of it is, if you look at our products, search works everywhere around the world. We take pride in providing it and it's accessible to everyone as long as they have computing and connectivity. Whether you're here at Stanford or a kid in rural Indonesia, Google works for you. And that's the philosophy we bring across our products, be it Gmail, be it Maps, be it YouTube. So we think about scale, being able to reach people and make technology more accessible.

**[0:10:09] Sundar Pichai:** And it's what I wanted to do in my life. And so it's a privilege to do it.

**[0:10:14] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, and there's no shortage of products to work on.

**[0:10:17] Sundar Pichai:** There's no shortage, sometimes too many at Google, but that's another story.

**[0:10:21] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, one of the early products that you worked on was Chrome. You led the team, and initially there was some pushback. High development costs, competitors in the space, but you had conviction that the browser was the way to go. Where did the conviction come from, and how did you convince skeptics that Chrome was the future?

**[0:10:42] Sundar Pichai:** Yeah, that time Eric was our CEO, Eric Schmidt. And, you know, I remember him being angry once because he realized we were trying to build a browser. And he was like, do you know what it takes to build a browser? You know, it takes, because he had gone through the browser battles. He definitely didn't, you know, was hesitant for us to do it. Partly, how did I do it? I didn't tell people for a while. I just had a small team and, you know, worked on it.

**[0:11:07] Sundar Pichai:** And only when we had something to show, you know, we had a chance to show the product and that got people excited. And so, but it is, you know, it's a good lesson. I think if you have a set of committed people, passionate people, you can achieve, you know, even I couldn't have foreseen what it would eventually become. But, you know, shows the power of a small group of committed people and actually not knowing the odds of what you're working on.

**[0:11:35] Sundar Pichai:** So I think both helps.

**[0:11:37] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, and you can obviously see the direction that Chrome grew into as one of the most popular browsers today. And you really have seen Google transition from pre-IPO to the 1 trillion-dollar company it is today. It's challenging to scale an organization of that size. Over the years, what do you think Google has done well as it's scaled?

**[0:12:01] Sundar Pichai:** You know, I mean, it is a complex thing scaling a company. I would say things we have gotten right. The first thing that struck me about Google when I joined the company was very different in the sense that it was a very optimistic place. So it was a rare place in which if you walked the hallways and you spoke to people and you had ideas, people expanded on them. You know, most of the times people try to tell you why things won't work.

**[0:12:28] Sundar Pichai:** I felt the spirit was different. You know, people would tell you, oh, that's a great idea. You could do it this way and it would be better. So that struck me, that optimism, the fact that you can innovate, make things better, solve problems, I think is a spirit I've tried to carry now. And it takes a lot of hard work. You have to encourage innovation. You know, one of the counterintuitive things is companies become more conservative as they grow.

**[0:12:55] Sundar Pichai:** You have a lot more cash. You have a lot more resources. But companies tend to become more conservative in their decision making. And so encouraging the company to take risks and innovate and be okay with failure and reward effort, not outcomes. And that's very hard to do in an organization. People tend to reward outcomes, which means over time, the organization becomes more conservative. They take safer bets and so on. So a lot of scaling up is about making sure you preserve the good things you had in the early days.

**[0:13:28] Sundar Pichai:** And that gets harder as the company becomes bigger. You have to work harder at it. But I think a big part of what we try hard to do is keep that culture of innovating with technology, building products, shipping things. And, you know, and so that's one of the many things. But, yeah.

**[0:13:45] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah. And maintaining that culture as the company grows is not easy. It's a difficult endeavor. What were some of the other kind of growing pains that you've seen Google have over the last couple of years?

**[0:13:57] Sundar Pichai:** Yeah, I mean, definitely a lot. I mean, when you're a small company, you know, think about the size of the business school. All of you have shared context. You know, you understand better what others are going through. And so you have better context around everything that's going on. A larger company definitely gets harder, right? And Google was built on, you know, everyone. It's a very open culture, even today. One of the most common things people tell me when they come from other companies is, you know, they're shocked at how transparent the company is.

**[0:14:30] Sundar Pichai:** You know, you have literally access to what's happening across the company. But it can be overwhelming. And just because you have transparency doesn't mean you have context. It's very different from when organizations are smaller. So that's been a big part of trying to figure out how to scale up the company and how do you organize more independently, coordinate only when needed, but can have more parts of the company move as smaller units. And that's a hard balance to get right.

**[0:14:59] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah. And now you're at the helm of Google and you see all of these teams working in different directions. But one thing that you've been vocal about and enthusiastic about is AI. You've said AI is the most important thing humanity has ever worked on. And many of us will go on to work with AI or advanced computing in some form. How should we be thinking about AI to help humanity versus harm humanity?

**[0:15:28] Sundar Pichai:** No, it's a great question. When I became CEO, one of the biggest directional changes we made is we said, we're going to approach everything as AI first. and we are applying it across everything we do in the company. It's a big part of the R &D we spend. And the progress is palpable. Every year, it's exciting. There's a lot of progress. I think we concretely see the evidence of, just when you look at the scale at which translation works, or in search how we use AI, or in Gmail when you type and we give suggestions, It's applied across all our products.

**[0:16:09] Sundar Pichai:** And so definitely we can see the path by which we're making things better. I think it will profoundly transform pretty much every sector. You see the potential in areas like health care. I think it will still take a decade for it to fully play out. But we definitely see the potential. I think to your question of how do you make sure we develop it in a way, I think that the essential struggle of humanity with every technology is, you know, harnessing it so that it benefits society.

**[0:16:43] Sundar Pichai:** You know, you can see the same debates about the Internet, even before you think about AI. You know, has the Internet been a force of good? Obviously. You know, has it had effects which we didn't fully anticipate? Yes. And we are, you know, and that's that's the debate. And we are working about how best to address it. With AI, I think we need to think about it earlier. So part of how we are approaching, we have clearly articulated publicly a set of AI principles and publicly stated it.

**[0:17:13] Sundar Pichai:** And we publish a lot of research, the open source technology. But that's only part of the problem. I think academic institutions need to play a big role. We were a founding member for Stanford's AI Institute, HAI, and proud to be a supporter there. I think they're doing terrific work. But in academic institutions, nonprofits, and the public-private partnership, government will end up having a role. There has to be regulation, thoughtful regulation about AI. You have to get the balance right so that there is innovation.

**[0:17:46] Sundar Pichai:** But I think it's important to think it through earlier than other technologies. So I think, and so doing it and engaging all the stakeholders is the only way I can think of approaching it.

**[0:18:00] Archana Samshetty:** So it seems like it's a living, breathing framework that evolves as AI also evolves.

**[0:18:06] Sundar Pichai:** That's right. And it needs to involve many people from many different institutions to make it work.

**[0:18:13] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah. I want to touch on your point on technology, being forward about technology and thinking about the benefits and harms as we're building it. In a post-COVID world, many of us have realized the importance of human connection and we crave human connection. yet sometimes technology can breed disconnection. How are you thinking about the future of quality connections with each other as technology becomes a larger part of our lives?

**[0:18:41] Sundar Pichai:** I mean, technology is an enabler. Ultimately, you know, it's people in society. You know, we have to organize around how we use technology. I think, you know, you're raising a very important point and thinking through about how technology is not isolating or immersive in a way in which it prevents you from engaging, I think genuinely it's a good topic. I think all of us who have kids worry about it and struggle about it. I did like when our sons were playing in a middle school band.

**[0:19:18] Sundar Pichai:** It's what you want to see them do more of. But every generation always is very worried about technology of the future. It's always been true when you look back at it. And so I think that's part of the process. Technology done correctly can enable interactions in the real world. One of the companies we spun out of, Google, which was Niantic, did that, precisely that, with Pokemon, and got people to move about and do stuff in the real world, which I found inspiring.

**[0:19:48] Sundar Pichai:** But I think, you know, I think over time, part of even if we get augmented reality right, today, you know, when you see people on their phones walking on the streets immersed, you know, you see that in some ways technology forces you to engage with it. It hasn't adapted enough to how humans live life. And so part of solving, you know, more natural ways by which you can interact with computing, be it voice, be computing understanding what you're looking at, you know, may actually help us do this better.

**[0:20:23] Sundar Pichai:** Done wrongly can be even more isolating, but done correctly with the right attributes, I think it can help bridge that gap. And so I think that's a potential for AR if done correctly.

**[0:20:34] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, so it's thinking in advance about the implications and then being there as the technology develops. That's right. Yeah. I want to take a step back and look at Google more as a whole, some of the biases we've talked about with AI, but more broadly, what goes on with Google's culture. In 2018, employees staged a walkout for women's rights. In 2020, Google was accused of mishandling the treatment of minorities on the ethical AI team. To start us off, as these events were happening, what was going through your head?

**[0:21:12] Archana Samshetty:** What was your reaction?

**[0:21:14] Sundar Pichai:** One of the fortunate things I felt is, unlike most companies, from day one, Google has had a strong employee voice. And for me as a CEO, running a large company, I've always found it helpful because you trust your employees to get it right at scale. So I view it as the strength of the company. When employees speak up, I think it's important for us to take it seriously. The walkout was a moment when the company hadn't gotten something right, and that's what the walkout was about.

**[0:21:47] Sundar Pichai:** So internalizing it, acknowledging it, owning up to it, and committing and making the company better is how you approach those moments. And even today, I think employee input is something as a company we value deeply. And I would argue they push the company to be better across all the things we do. It is complex, as I said earlier. The context around these decisions, some of these decisions are always hard. And at scale, not everyone has the full context.

**[0:22:19] Sundar Pichai:** But for what it's worth, I've personally always felt one of the strengths of the company. And when it comes to being getting AI right or doing things at scale and getting it right, you know, and we do it in many countries around the world. And, you know, I still today take great comfort in knowing that our employees, you know, deeply are guardians of our values and will do everything to get it right.

**[0:22:43] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, and I guess these past events help inform the future decision-making of Google. How are you thinking about promoting DE &I, diversity, equity, and inclusion at Google moving forward?

**[0:22:56] Sundar Pichai:** You know, one of the most important moments as a company we went through, and I think many companies around the world, was the racial equity moment around the murder of George Floyd. As a company for us, it was a profound moment internally. I've never seen anything affect the company that much in the 16 years. We publicly committed to, I consulted and worked with our black leadership advisory group in the company. And understanding most of the company wanted to do the right thing, tapping on the moment and converting it into lasting commitment.

**[0:23:34] Sundar Pichai:** So we have publicly committed to a set of initiatives and we are holding ourselves accountable. We give transparency reports on how we are making progress on that. And be it committing to improving our leadership representation from underrepresented groups. be committing to driving improvements in our products. You know, last year in Pixel and in our camera technology, we launched Realtone, you know, a more inclusive way to capture pictures to cover all skin tones. I mean, these are all examples of how you can use technology to make progress here.

**[0:24:13] Sundar Pichai:** Scaling and giving more people access to technology, particularly in underrepresented groups. These are all commitments we have made. And, you know, that's one part of how we work through moments like those.

**[0:24:26] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, so it seems like you're taking a technological approach as well as an empathetic approach, listening to your employees, hearing what they have to say. What's top of mind for employees right now is the future of work. You recently released your future of work plan for Google employees. And I can imagine you're balancing a lot of perspectives that are competing. How did you integrate competing preferences when crafting your future of plan work?

**[0:24:54] Sundar Pichai:** For me, for what it's worth, I am incredibly excited about this next phase of the future of work. And I think 20 years ago, Google was kind of, it's now done so much around the Valley, people take it for granted. But Google did rethink what workspaces could be. You know, they thought workspaces could be fun. We had slides in our offices. You know, we bridged, you know, we changed workplaces pretty radically. We gave people a lot of agency.

**[0:25:22] Sundar Pichai:** Our employees had a lot of agency. It felt fun to be in the offices. And we didn't think that was at odds of being productive, right? So the sense of creating community, fostering creativity in the workplace, collaboration, all makes you a better company. I view giving flexibility to people the same way. To be very clear, I do think we strongly believe in in-person connections. But I think we can achieve that in a more purposeful way and give employees, again, more agency and flexibility.

**[0:25:59] Sundar Pichai:** So I think hybrid work is great. We're going to leverage the scale of the company. We have many locations around the world so people can move to other places and work. We are starting with a 3-2 hybrid option. but we have encouraged employees to apply to be fully remote as well. And, you know, we have supported 85 % of those applications. So I'm excited. You know, you earlier asked about, you know, diversity. One of the best ways we can now approach diversity is actually showing up in places where diverse talent is.

**[0:26:30] Sundar Pichai:** More importantly, when we get that talent, them being in communities which have the supporting structure for them. And so we are now in Atlanta, in Chicago, in D.C., you know, recruiting employees. I think being able to support the participation of women in the workforce, I think the flexibility is going to be a huge asset. So I'm excited by it. And I think, you know, and I think I find when people come back and people are very excited to come back to the office, by the way, you know, as we opened up, we are easily at over 70% already back to our pre-pandemic.

**[0:27:07] Sundar Pichai:** presence in the offices, and it's growing. But giving people that choice, it always bothered me that the stress around commutes, or when people had parent-teacher conferences, or doctor appointments, balancing all that, there's a lot of stress which people were carrying. So I think it gives us a chance to rethink. Also, as a technology, since we build products like Gmail, Docs, Meet, and so on, it gives a chance to rethink products too and make it all work better.

**[0:27:38] Sundar Pichai:** So, you know, I think it's one of the most exciting things that's happening in the workforce. You know, and I think you'll see the benefits of it over time.

**[0:27:49] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, absolutely. It seems like you're emphasizing intentionality and flexibility when it comes to hybrid work. And your plans really do set the stage for other companies in Silicon Valley and beyond. So we're all looking to you and your leadership for guidance on things like this. So you also recently just got back from Warsaw. You were helping out with the Ukraine refugee crisis. How do you, when is it appropriate for corporations to step in on public issues like Ukraine, Russia?

**[0:28:24] Sundar Pichai:** Well, first of all, for us, we are directly involved because both we have employees in Ukraine and Russia. Our products work in these regions. Being an information company at moments like this, it's really critical for us to get these moments right. So we approach it a few ways. Foremost, the safety of our employees, like every other organization, making sure employees are safe. Second, very critical for us, is getting access to information right, tackling misinformation, removing what we felt were propaganda information, and raising what we do in search and YouTube at moments like that is raising higher quality information, including providing information within Russia at moments like this.

**[0:29:11] Sundar Pichai:** It's been a large part of the work we do. Launching important things like air raid alerts on Google Maps in Ukraine, Being in Warsaw, one of the things that struck me, and it's true for pretty much everyone there, an average Google employee had two to three refugee families with them. These are mainly women and children. You know, people don't speak the same language all the time. People are using Google Translate on their phones to communicate. So we had to do a sprint to get the language translation working right.

**[0:29:42] Sundar Pichai:** We opened up a portion of our space to NGOs, as well as entrepreneurs from Ukraine. And more importantly, we committed to investing in Poland. So we announced a $700 million investment, both in office space and to hire more people in Poland. And we're going to commit to investing in Central and Eastern Europe at this pivotal time. But I think definitely the war shows how much we have to continue fighting for. And so it's an important moment to get right.

**[0:30:12] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, it's incredible to see corporations like Google committing time, resources, financial investment, and technology to causes like this. And I'm personally in awe of how many causes that you're invested in. Apart from Ukraine, Russia, you also have announced plans recently in investment in Africa and things like job skills training for low to middle income folks. More broadly, how do you choose which causes you want to invest your time and effort into?

**[0:30:44] Sundar Pichai:** It's a great question. You know, with the company at scale, there's a lot of things that come your way. I think you have to be disciplined about where you think Google can make a difference and, you know, what is a unique perspective or value proposition you can bring to the table. And, you know, over time, we have understood by things we can do well and things other organizations are better at doing. An area, for example, given our focus on information, skilling has been a big focus for us, digital skilling.

**[0:31:15] Sundar Pichai:** I think there is no substitute for college, but unfortunately not everyone has access to and can afford to go to a college. And so skilling people, bringing them, giving them access to digital skills has been a big push. in the US, we launched a career certificate program. It's a nine month program. We have done it on four major areas and we back it up with working with employers to recruit people. And it's been extraordinarily successful. 75 ,000 people have gone through it and almost 50 % of it is from underrepresented groups.

**[0:31:54] Sundar Pichai:** And when I look at the demand there is from people for these things, and so I think as a society, we need to figure out about how we can scale and give access to digital skilling to more people. So, but that's an area where we feel Google can strongly contribute. And so we choose and get involved in areas like that. Sustainability is another one. So, you know, we choose where we

**[0:32:17] Archana Samshetty:** think we can add value. Yeah. So it seems like you look at your strengths and then look at what impact you can make based off of your strengths and pursue those issues. That's right. Yeah. And And you touched on this briefly, but sustainability. A couple years ago, you announced this lofty goal of being carbon neutral at Google by 2030. And you have to unify many business units and product lines to achieve this goal. How are you going about getting the whole company to rally behind a goal of sustainability?

**[0:32:48] Sundar Pichai:** One of the important things, and if I could clarify one thing, because it's subtle and people, we've been carbon neutral since 2007. So Google has been carbon neutral since 2007. and one of the earliest companies to do so. Sustainability has long been an important goal. What we have now committed is by 2030 to be carbon-free, so not using offsets, but actually running our operations 24-7 carbon-free. That is a hard challenge because today we can use offsets, and that involves investing and developing new technologies beyond wind and solar, you know, be it carbon capture, how do you store energy, and to do it around the world.

**[0:33:35] Sundar Pichai:** And so what it excites us is because it's a lot of R &D again, and you can apply technology. And when we bought some of the earliest wind and solar contracts in 2010, and costs have fallen by 85 % in the last 10 years. And so, again, looking at these new technologies, We just have a whole data center now up and running with geothermal. And so tapping into new technologies, and we want to bootstrap it and help drive the technology and the cost curve over the next decade so that we can reach there.

**[0:34:09] Sundar Pichai:** But it's a challenge. It stresses us out. But I'm incredibly excited as a technologist, the chance to make progress like that.

**[0:34:16] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah. And, you know, none of these big initiatives were asked of you and asked of Google. These are things that you as a company and you as a leader have decided to take on. The theme for our slate of speakers this year is beyond expectations. So we'd love to hear what motivates you to go above and beyond what is expected of a business leader.

**[0:34:40] Sundar Pichai:** You know, I would tie it back to the first question, at least in the context of the work I do. You know, I travel around the world and, you know, I still today, particularly when you go into emerging markets, it's a very different view from here. You see how eager people are to get access to technology because they understand how it will make their lives better. So you see it, you feel it. And I go to Vietnam or India or Africa.

**[0:35:08] Sundar Pichai:** And so, you know, and there's a lot more work to be done. And just in India recently, we are working on a cheaper, high-quality smartphone, maybe around the $30 price point. And last week, we just announced in Africa our product development center in Nairobi, hiring engineers, UX designers, and so on. When you see the appetite and the desire for people to make their lives better by gaining access to technology, You know, that's what compels me to go beyond.

**[0:35:40] Sundar Pichai:** And I think it's very consistent with what our company has set out to do.

**[0:35:45] Archana Samshetty:** Yeah, I can tell how much intentionality you have behind all the initiatives within Google and externally. So truly, thank you so much for giving us a framework and ideas behind how you make decisions that we can kind of take away from here. With that, we do have student questions, so we can turn it over. Right there. Hi, Sundar. My name is Melissa Zhang, and I was a former Tapestry employee, so great to meet you. My question is, going back to the year, or forward to the year 2030,

**[0:36:20] Sundar Pichai:** in what capacity do you see Alphabet partnering the most with governments? And this can be from tech access to grids to search. And what will make you feel most proud of getting right? The second part is I do think sustainability is going to be the defining issue for us to get right in the next decade or so. So we are definitely committing Alphabet seriously. Just to get to a carbon-free goal would involve billions of dollars in incremental investment from us.

**[0:37:00] Sundar Pichai:** But we think it's the right thing to do. It will be good for us as a business, I think, over time. But I think that is something I want us to be able to get right. And I think definitely something we'd be proud of if we can get there. To your first question, I presume you're asking by 2030, how do you see us engaging with governments and so on? Look, I think tech, one of the bigger, more profound changes underway is I think technology is going to be a regulated industry.

**[0:37:30] Sundar Pichai:** and part of, you know, as a company working at scale is anticipating working constructively with regulators and because I think at the end of the day, technology affects citizens and so every country is going to be thinking about this deeply and take Europe's GDPR as an example. It's an important foundational privacy legislation, right? And I think we had to anticipate it. We invested almost 18 months of work to get ready for it. And I think it's given certainty to both European citizens.

**[0:38:03] Sundar Pichai:** It gives businesses certainty about how to operate. So that's one example of legislation working. And so, you know, we would expect to be constructively working with, you know, governments around the world. You know, Archana mentioned AI, and, you know, I think that's going to be important for us to get right. And I think governments will end up playing a key role in the time frame.

**[0:38:29] Archana Samshetty:** Hi, Sundar. I'm Shanice. Thank you for being here. Yesterday, we had the privilege of having Barack Obama on campus, and he spoke about how changes in the way we communicate and consume information has a massive impact on our democracy. So while Google is not a social media company, I'm curious to know what you see Google's role in that debate is.

**[0:38:57] Sundar Pichai:** I mean, first of all, I think it was an important speech. And, you know, I think this is something we think about deeply. It's in our stated mission. You know, if you think about search, this is what we are trying to do for every query, right? We are trying to sort what is higher quality information. And so it cuts to the essence of what we do. You know, in YouTube, we brought the same principles. One example, such a complex topic, but maybe I can answer it with an example.

**[0:39:29] Sundar Pichai:** You know, it's actually easier to do this as a company when society agrees on an area. So when society converges and agrees, you can see that happening in the context of the war, Russia, Ukraine. And I think that's why you see a lot of companies be able to get it right. When society is very divided about where to draw the lines, it inherently gets harder. But the way we approach is generally on important areas, to use YouTube as an example, we raise what we think of as authoritative information.

**[0:40:05] Sundar Pichai:** That's journalistic content. Or in the case of if it's health-related, maybe from universities or hospitals or public health organizations. So we use those tools, just like we have done in search, to try and think hard about what are higher quality sources of information, and we view that as a goal, and that's one way by which we tackle the problem. But it's an important issue, and I think part of it is, if there are better rules, including laws and legislation, I think it will actually make it easier, but you'll find writing the law and legislation is hard, Because I think as a society, we're still grappling with what we think is the right answer for many of these things.

**[0:41:05] Archana Samshetty:** Hi, Sundar. I'm the Adil Archana at the business school. And also from Midras, so it's really nice to meet you. I used to work for the Gates Foundation thinking about bringing innovation to emerging markets and underserved people, so everything you say resonates.

**[0:41:20] Sundar Pichai:** My question is a more personal one. Doing the work you do, there are many difficult days, difficult moments, highs and lows. Do you have any everyday habits or personal mantras that keep you going when things get tough? It's a great question. First of all, I mean, most decisions, it took me a while to realize when decisions come to you, you know, the higher up you're in an organization, the easy decisions don't come to you, right? And by definition, when something has come to you, it's because, you know, others have spent time on it and they can't resolve it.

**[0:41:56] Sundar Pichai:** So in some ways, I realized that. So two things. One is I think you making that decision is the most important thing you can do. you know we you know you're breaking a tie and it unlocks the organization to move forward and uh and so you know and it's it's an important thing one of the mentors here bill campbell uh you know thought that to me early every week he would see me he would ask me what ties did you break this week and and so it's always struck with me so i view making these decisions as you know you're really helping the company and so that that makes it a bit more fun the second is you know with

**[0:42:36] Sundar Pichai:** time you realize most of those decisions aren't consequential it might appear very tough at the time you know it may feel like a lot rides on it but you look later and you realize you know it wasn't that consequential there are a few consequential uh decisions and judgment is a big part of leadership and you don't always get it right and you have to learn from it. But I think most decisions aren't that consequential. And so, you know, so thinking through both helps me think about it as it's just another normal day in the office.

**[0:43:10] Sundar Pichai:** And so you keep going through it. All right. So I think we have time for one more

**[0:43:15] Archana Samshetty:** question right back there. Hi, Sundar. My name is Nick Bashur. I'm from Syria. And in Syria, 20 million people don't have access to all of the products that Google produces. That's because of regulations that are put in place by countries like the United States and certain countries in the European Union.

**[0:43:38] Sundar Pichai:** So on top of being under a dictatorship, 20 million Syrians don't have access to the financial world, don't have access to basic technology products, and the gap between the developed and developing world is really just increasing. You're one of the most important leaders in the world. What are you doing to advocate on behalf of these people and give truly universal access to technology products? Thank you. That's a great question. You know, as a company, you know, our mission is to provide universal access to information.

**[0:44:08] Sundar Pichai:** And, you know, any time, you know, we are not able to do that for a set of reasons. I mean, you know, we struggle with it. You know, we feel compelled to try to find a way. We do have to comply with laws as a company. And in areas like Syria, the ways we have contributed, A, we have been involved in the refugee workaround, Syrian refugees, for a long time. We build access to open source technologies in many of these cases and support things.

**[0:44:42] Sundar Pichai:** Android is open source. Things do make their way into these countries. So we work at an open source level in areas where we are not fully able to directly work. But I think it's an important question. I don't have all the answers here, but thanks for asking it, and I'll think about it more.

**[0:45:00] Archana Samshetty:** Awesome. So we typically conclude our conversations with a lightning round. I will start a sentence, and you will finish it. So it's a fill in the blank. So first of all, something that inspires me is?

**[0:45:16] Sundar Pichai:** You know, watching the next generation blossom and, you know, I think society always worries that the next generation isn't as good as they are. That is not true. And the next generation ends up making the world even better. So that inspires me.

**[0:45:33] Archana Samshetty:** I am the most proud of.

**[0:45:38] Sundar Pichai:** Trying my best to do the right thing by the people I am involved with, both obviously personally and professionally, people I work with.

**[0:45:47] Archana Samshetty:** During my time at Stanford, I loved...

**[0:45:51] Sundar Pichai:** I used to love just being out in the court and sitting and grabbing lunch with friends. Driving today reminded me of that, for sure.

**[0:46:00] Archana Samshetty:** I am the happiest when.

**[0:46:03] Sundar Pichai:** Many things, but being around people building products and solving problems still makes me very happy.

**[0:46:12] Archana Samshetty:** And finally, the best piece of leadership advice I've received is?

**[0:46:19] Sundar Pichai:** Be authentic to yourself and be the best leader you can be. I think there's no one right template, and don't try to be in someone else's mold.

**[0:46:30] Archana Samshetty:** That's wonderful. Sundar, thank you so much. It's been such a pleasure. You've been listening to View From the Top, the podcast, a production of Stanford Graduate School of Business. This interview was conducted by me, Archana, of the MBA class of 2022. Lily Sloan composed our theme music. Michael Riley and Jenny Luna produced this episode. You can find more episodes of this podcast at our website, www.gsb.stanford.edu.
