OpenNashPodcasts

Topic

Ziad Obermeyer

Ziad Obermeyer is an emergency doctor and researcher whose work on medical algorithms, bias and health data was discussed on the podcasts Freakonomics, M.D. and Me, Myself, and AI. Host Bapu Jena described his studies of heart-attack testing in emergency rooms and of a widely used healthcare algorithm.

Jena said the algorithm affects around 200 million people a year. Obermeyer said it ranked healthier white patients ahead of sicker Black patients for extra help, because it was trained to predict costs, a poor proxy for needs. Jena also said Obermeyer helped launch Nightingale Open Science, a nonprofit health data resource for researchers.

16 facts from 2 episodes, in date order. These are what speakers said on the shows, each linked to the moment it was said. They aren't independently verified.

1950s

Obermeyer says the original studies of knee arthritis were done in the 1950s in England on white male coal miners.

“Well, all those studies were done in the 1950s in England in coal miners who were all white and male”

Guest · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:23:41

2019

Obermeyer and collaborators published a paper on algorithmic bias in the journal Science in 2019.

“Well, let's look at an example from a recent paper by Ziad and his collaborators. It came out in the journal Science in 2019.”

Bapu Jena · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:14:24

Undated

Emergency doctor Ziad Obermeyer once had appendicitis and did not recognize it until his appendix burst.

“Ziad himself once walked around with appendicitis, not realizing the pain for what it was until his appendix burst.”

Bapu Jena · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:05:43

Undated

Obermeyer and Sendhil Mullainathan analyzed roughly 250,000 ER visits from more than 100,000 patients at one large hospital.

“They analyzed roughly 250 ,000 emergency room visits from more than 100 ,000 patients.”

Bapu Jena · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:07:49

Undated

The heart-attack algorithm judged about two-thirds of the patients doctors chose to test as not worth testing.

“about two-thirds of all of the patients that doctors choose to test today, the algorithm says, don't test this person.”

Guest · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:08:53

Undated

Patients the algorithm flagged as high risk but whom doctors did not test later had adverse events resembling missed heart attacks at rates above the guideline testing threshold.

“And it turns out that those people have adverse events that look like missed heart attack at very high rates, like much higher than the clinical guidelines would have suggested testing at.”

Guest · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:09:57

Undated

Obermeyer's team repeated the heart-attack analysis on national Medicare data covering millions of ER patients and found very similar results.

“national Medicare data. And that was in the, I think, millions of patients visiting ERs across”

Guest · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:10:31

Undated

Obermeyer's paper on AI and heart-attack prediction was slated for publication in the Quarterly Journal of Economics.

“Ziad's paper, which is coming out soon in the Quarterly Journal of Economics, shows that AI may be better than doctors at predicting who's at risk of having a heart attack.”

Bapu Jena · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:11:19

Undated

The researchers studied a commonly used healthcare algorithm, and algorithms like it affect around 200 million people a year.

“They looked at a commonly used algorithm developed by a company. Algorithms like it affect around 200 million people a year.”

Bapu Jena · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:15:28

Undated

Obermeyer says the studied algorithm ranked healthier white patients ahead of sicker Black patients for extra chronic-care help.

“Effectively, this algorithm was helping healthier white patients cut in line ahead of sicker Black patients for access to this extra help with their chronic health needs.”

Guest · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:15:51

Undated

Adjusting the algorithm would have raised the share of Black patients receiving extra help from almost 20 percent to nearly 50 percent.

“The researchers found that by adjusting the algorithm, they could increase the percentage of Black patients getting extra help from almost 20 % to nearly 50%.”

Bapu Jena · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:16:28

Undated

The biased algorithm was trained to predict healthcare costs, which Obermeyer says is a poor proxy for healthcare needs.

“The algorithms were trained to predict how much healthcare costs a given patient was going to generate. But that is not a great proxy for someone's healthcare needs.”

Guest · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:17:06

Undated

Ziad Obermeyer helped launch Nightingale Open Science, a nonprofit housing health data focused on medical images for researchers.

“That's why ZIAD helped launch Nightingale Open Science. It's a nonprofit that houses health data focused on medical images that researchers can use.”

Bapu Jena · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:30:10

Undated

Obermeyer is working on a randomized trial of the heart-attack testing algorithm across several hospitals in one health system.

“a really important project that I'm working on now is translating that algorithm that we discussed about testing for heart attack in the ER into a big randomized trial at a health system with a bunch of different hospitals.”

Guest · 25. Would You Rather See a Computer or a Doctor?, 0:31:21

Episodes