In brief
The episode argues that open banking in the U.S. only works if consumers can move their own financial data to fintech apps without banks charging gatekeeper fees. Guests Phil Goldfeder and Penny Lee say JPMorgan Chase's planned fees would hurt consumers, small businesses and competition. They also say the CFPB's Section 1033 rule says banks must provide data 'upon request', not 'upon a fee'.
The central tension is between big banks and fintechs, and between rules that bring clarity and the legal uncertainty around them. The CFPB defended the rule, then asked a court to vacate it, and JPMorgan moved while the rules were unsettled. The guests allow that some fee may be reasonable, but say a punishing one would push the industry back to screen scraping.
Questions
What is Section 1033 and why does it matter?
It is a part of the Dodd-Frank Act that the CFPB turned into a final open banking rule in October 2024. Penny Lee says it confirms consumers can permission their data to an agent, trustee or representative, such as a fintech app.
Why is JPMorgan Chase charging fintechs for data access?
The bank's argument, as Phil Goldfeder describes it, is that it pays for regulatory oversight, data privacy and infrastructure. The guests answer that customers already pay through account fees and that fintechs built infrastructure too.
Will consumers end up paying these fees?
JP Nichols says the fees are charged to the data aggregators, who will pass them on to consumers 'one way or the other'. Goldfeder calls it a 'double dip' on consumers who already pay their bank.
What is screen scraping and why is it a concern?
It is an older method in which an app logs in as the customer and copies data from their bank account, instead of using a bank-provided connection. Lee and Goldfeder say high fees could push the industry back to it, including AI-assisted versions they call unhealthy.
Is open banking dying according to the guests?
No. Goldfeder calls this a 'maturity process' in which incumbents push back, and Lee expects consumers to protest if the services they use are cut off. Both still want clear, lasting rules.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau finalized its Section 1033 open banking rule under the Dodd-Frank Act in October 2024.
“in October of 2024, October of this last year, in which the CFPB did promulgate, did finalize a final rule around this section of the Dodd-Frank Act”
0:02:17 · Penny Lee · Section 1033 · 2024
Penny Lee says a large-bank trade association sued in Kentucky within hours of the rule being unveiled at the Philadelphia Fed FinTech conference.
“within hours of this being unveiled at the Philadelphia Fed FinTech conference, within hours, the Large Bank Trade Association did sue, sued in Kentucky to challenge this rule.”
0:03:03 · Penny Lee · Rule lawsuit · 2024
The Financial Technology Association filed a motion to intervene in the lawsuit over the Section 1033 rule in roughly February 2025.
“So we filed a motion to intervene roughly, you know, right in February, we filed the motion to intervene.”
0:03:55 · Penny Lee · Litigation · 2025
According to Penny Lee, the CFPB asked a court to vacate its own open banking rule, arguing that the rule's definition of a consumer was unlawful.
“And to vacate, they said that the definition of who a consumer is was unlawful.”
0:05:43 · Penny Lee · CFPB reversal · 2025
Bloomberg confirmed that JPMorgan Chase intends to charge fintech data aggregators for access to customer data, according to JP Nichols.
“On Friday, Bloomberg confirmed that JPMorgan Chase's intent to charge for access to this personal data, charge to the fintech aggregators who will certainly pass this on to consumers one way or the other.”
0:01:21 · JP Nichols · Data access fees · 2025
The Bank Policy Institute sued over the Section 1033 rule on behalf of the nation's largest banks, according to Penny Lee.
“Obviously, Bank Policy Institute, BPI, sued on this rule on behalf of the nation's largest banks”
0:25:29 · Penny Lee · Rule lawsuit
Phil Goldfeder says about 25 percent of the American Fintech Council's membership is community banks offering innovative services.
“we're the American FinTech Council. 25 % of our membership is made up of community banks who are offering innovative services”
0:17:28 · Phil Goldfeder · Membership
JP Nichols says the U.S. has roughly 5,000 banks and 5,000 credit unions, many partnering with fintechs.
“there are 5 ,000 banks and another 5 ,000 credit unions in this country, many of whom are partnering with fintechs, and they want to compete too.”
0:28:01 · JP Nichols · Banking landscape
Penny Lee argues the Section 1033 rule requires banks to provide consumer information 'upon request' and does not authorize charging a fee.
“if the rule is to stay as is, it does say in the rules, banks shall make available upon request information, consumers' information that the bank holds.”
0:34:05 · Penny Lee · Section 1033
Penny Lee says JPMorgan Chase built its own data API several years ago and had not charged for it before announcing fees.
“JPMorgan Chase built an API, you know, on their own several years ago, have not been charging for it.”
0:13:59 · Penny Lee · JPMorgan API
Penny Lee says compliance deadlines for the Section 1033 rule were pushed back about 90 days, with aspects taking effect around August 2026.
“the compliance deadlines got pulled by about 90 days. So the rule doesn't go into effect, aspects of the rule don't go into effect until, you know, right around August of 2026.”
0:03:55 · Penny Lee · Compliance deadlines · 2026
Phil Goldfeder recalls appearing on stage with CFPB Director Rohit Chopra at FinTech Nexus in New York City in April 2023 to discuss competition in financial services.
“I remember sitting on the stage in April of 23. At that point, it was FinTech Nexus in New York City with Director Chopra talking about exactly this”
0:06:36 · Phil Goldfeder · Rulemaking history · 2023
Phil Goldfeder says the open banking provision had been pending for about 14 years since Dodd-Frank.
“we've been playing with this for 14 years, right? 14 years we've been sitting on this.”
0:42:45 · Phil Goldfeder · Rule timeline · 2010
Penny Lee says Europe, the UK, Singapore, Brazil and India are ahead of the U.S. because they embraced open banking and open finance.
“Europe, UK, Singapore, Brazil, India, so many other jurisdictions are way ahead of us because they did embrace this open banking, open finance”
0:39:59 · Penny Lee · Global open banking
JP Nichols says European banks resisted providing data access under PSD and PSD2, and the final implementation was scaled back from the original ambition.
“the big banks didn't want to provide access to data, and it ended up being what was finally implemented, was pared down from the original ambition of it.”
0:38:54 · JP Nichols · PSD2
Phil Goldfeder says the largest U.S. banks dismissed products such as earned wage access and buy now, pay later before trying and, in his view, failing to build competing ones.
“the biggest banks in the country that laughed at some of the new products that were coming out and said, there's no way those products”
0:08:19 · Phil Goldfeder · Bank competition
Penny Lee says bank data arrives raw and messy, and fintech data aggregators spend resources cleaning it into a usable form.
“when you receive your data, oftentimes it's very raw, it's very messy, it's very, you know, hard to determine.”
0:12:53 · Penny Lee · Data aggregators
JP Nichols says aggregators such as MX, Plaid, Yodlee and Finicity count banks among their largest clients.
“many of their largest clients are banks, right? because they have challenges with their own data.”
0:18:11 · JP Nichols · Data aggregators
Penny Lee says large banks, citing regulatory pressure, have largely stopped small loans under $100,000, a gap fintechs have filled.
“You know, they would say from regulatory pressure, they really can't lend to anybody under $100 ,000 in that loan size. And so fintechs have filled that gap.”
0:46:20 · Penny Lee · Small business lending
Phil Goldfeder says that during the prior administration, the main regulatory clarity for innovative banks came from reading consent orders issued to other banks.
“I would say outside of the last six months, you know, the 18 months before that, the only regulatory clarity that we got was by reading the consent orders that innovative banks were getting, right?”
0:29:32 · Phil Goldfeder · Regulatory clarity
Penny Lee says the Financial Technology Association argued that the rule's limits on secondary use of data actually hindered some fraud prevention tools.
“We actually argued that the restrictions on secondary use actually prevented some of the fraud prevention tools to be taking place”
0:21:00 · Penny Lee · Secondary use