In brief
Ben Weiss argues that Disney's lasting advantage is its flywheel. Original stories and characters build emotional attachment, and that attachment is then monetized through theme parks, consumer products, cable networks, movies and streaming. Few companies have kept this going for a century. Weiss says it works because Disney can tell great stories, take creative risks and buy more story-driven businesses such as Pixar and Marvel.
The central tension is a shift from a declining but very profitable cable business to a streaming business that is still losing money. Weiss calls this an innovator's dilemma. In his bull case, Disney+ becomes a large, profitable subscription business worth roughly today's whole company. In his bear case, Disney lacks the will to fund the shift and the cable profits fade.
Questions
What parts of Disney actually make the most money?
Ben Weiss says the theme parks and consumer products segment and the cable and broadcast networks are the two biggest, each earning about $8 billion in segment profit in fiscal 2022. Movies are the source of the characters, but they are not the biggest profit source.
What is the Disney flywheel in plain English?
It is a loop in which great stories and characters make people emotionally attached, and that attachment sells park visits, toys and streaming subscriptions. Those businesses then support more storytelling and keep the characters in people's minds.
Why is Disney+ losing money when it has so many subscribers?
Weiss says Disney has to build expensive streaming technology and pay for movies and shows years before they earn revenue. Streaming lost about $4 billion on $19 billion of revenue, and he views this as an investment that should pay off later.
Why did Bob Iger come back as CEO?
Weiss says he does not know exactly what happened. He describes a board disagreement over mounting streaming losses and reports that creative talent felt alienated under Bob Chapek, the CEO who followed Iger (the transcript renders the name as Chapik). Iger returned in November for a stated two-year term to guide the shift from cable to streaming.
What could go wrong for Disney over the next ten years?
Weiss says the main risk is that streaming fails to replace the profits of the shrinking cable business. Disney would have to give up some profitable existing business to put its best content behind its own paywall, and it might lack the will or technology to do so.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
The Walt Disney Company generated $82.7 billion in revenue, close to $12 billion in EBITDA and $3 billion in net income in fiscal year 2022, according to Ben Weiss.
“Disney generated $82.7 billion in total revenue in 2022 to close to $12 billion in EBITDA and $3 billion in net income.”
0:02:02 · Ben Weiss · Financials · 2022
The Walt Disney Company was founded in 1923 by Walt Disney and his brother Roy as the Disney Brothers Cartoon Company.
“The company was founded in 1923 by Walt Disney and his brother Roy as the Disney Brothers Cartoon Company.”
0:04:39 · Ben Weiss · Founding · 1923
Mickey Mouse was created in 1928.
“in 1928 was Mickey Mouse was created, maybe the most indelible character in the Disney canon.”
0:04:39 · Ben Weiss · Mickey Mouse · 1928
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs, Disney's first animated feature, came out in 1937, and Disneyland opened in 1955.
“1937 was the first animated movie, Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs. 1955 was when Disneyland opened.”
0:05:16 · Ben Weiss · Milestones · 1937
Disney acquired ABC/Capital Cities in 1996 or 1997, in a deal Ben Weiss says Michael Eisner architected, and it brought ESPN into the company.
“ABC Cap Cities was 96 or 97. That was a huge acquisition that Michael Eisner really architected.”
0:06:44 · Ben Weiss · ABC acquisition · 1996
Disney acquired Pixar in 2006, Marvel in 2009 and Lucasfilm in 2012.
“Pixar was 2006, Marvel's 2009, and Lucas was 2012.”
0:06:44 · Ben Weiss · Acquisitions · 2006
Disney's parks, experiences and products segment had close to $29 billion in revenue and about $8 billion in segment operating profit in fiscal 2022, according to Ben Weiss.
“The two biggest parts of the business are the parks, experience, and products, which last year was close to $29 billion in revenue and about $8 billion in segment operating margin.”
0:03:27 · Ben Weiss · Parks segment · 2022
Disney invested $3.4 billion in capital expenditure in its parks segment in 2022, about 12% of segment sales.
“Disney invested $3.4 billion in CapEx in the parks segment in 2022 for about 12 % of sales.”
0:12:29 · Ben Weiss · Capital spending · 2022
Ben Weiss says roughly 100 million US households subscribed to cable, which gave Disney's cable networks very wide distribution.
“because there are 100 million houses roughly in the United States that were subscribing to cable.”
0:11:19 · Ben Weiss · Cable
Ben Weiss says Disney's cable networks business had operating margins of about 40%.
“So that had 40 % or so operating margins, which is an incredible business, very high returns on incremental capital”
0:17:59 · Ben Weiss · Cable margins
Ben Weiss cites estimates that Disney was paid about $78 per subscriber per month for ESPN, in addition to advertising revenue.
“Disney was getting paid $78 per sub on ESPN per month, and then also generating advertising revenue.”
0:19:08 · Ben Weiss · ESPN fees
Ben Weiss says Disney+ had about 46.6 million domestic subscribers and 161 to 162 million globally.
“Disney Plus has about 46.6 million domestic subscribers, 161 million, 162 million globally.”
0:22:34 · Ben Weiss · Subscribers
Disney's Disney+ subscriber count includes the Hotstar business in India, which came with its acquisition of Fox.
“That includes a big business in India, which they got when they acquired Fox called Hotstar.”
0:22:34 · Ben Weiss · Hotstar
Ben Weiss says Disney owned 67% of Hulu, with Comcast holding the remainder.
“they own 67 % and we'll see if Comcast sells them the other piece that they don't own”
0:26:01 · Ben Weiss · Hulu
Pixar's Cars (2006) was reported to cost $120 million to make, and Ben Weiss estimates a similar amount to market it.
“Costs are reported $120 million to make, probably cost the same to market that.”
0:29:14 · Ben Weiss · Cars · 2006
Cars was reported to have earned $314 million from DVD and Blu-ray sales.
“monetize the movie through the sale of DVD and Blu-ray. It was reported $314 million they made there.”
0:29:43 · Ben Weiss · Cars
Cars merchandise sales at retail were reported to exceed $10 billion, according to Ben Weiss.
“and the merchandise sales at retail reported to be over $10 billion.”
0:30:09 · Ben Weiss · Merchandise
Cars Land at Disneyland anchored a roughly five-year, $1.1 billion investment, according to Ben Weiss.
“And the IP is also leveraged to create Cars Land at Disneyland, which was the anchor of the five-year investment in roughly $1.1 billion.”
0:30:09 · Ben Weiss · Cars Land
Ben Weiss says he thought Bob Iger's successor as CEO, Bob Chapek (spelled Chapik in the transcript), was doing a good job before Iger returned.
“I thought the CEO who succeeded Bob Iger, Bob Chapik, was doing a really good job.”
0:35:08 · Ben Weiss · Leadership
Ben Weiss notes that Disney has had only two main CEOs in the past 25 years and argues this is because the job is hard to fill.
“One of the reasons you could argue they haven't been able to have that many different CEOs in the last 25 years, they really only had two”
0:33:06 · Ben Weiss · CEOs
Ben Weiss says Marvel has generated over $20 billion at the box office and is a key pillar of Disney's streaming business.
“So Marvel, over 20 billion in the box office, a global franchise, one of the key linchpins of the streaming business”
0:37:22 · Ben Weiss · Marvel · 2009
Ben Weiss estimates that 200 million households paying $15 a month for Disney+ would make roughly a $36 billion business.
“So that would be roughly a $36 billion business, and that's a software business, which should be predictable, a recurring revenue”
0:40:03 · Ben Weiss · Streaming valuation