OpenNashPodcasts

Conversations with Mike Milken

Ep. 46: Stewardship, with DBS Group's Piyush Gupta

19 May 2020 · 25m · Piyush Gupta, Mike Milken · 25 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Piyush Gupta, CEO of DBS Group, argues that a company's long-term preparation determines how well it handles a crisis. DBS's years of digital investment, its built-in sense of purpose, and its habit of judging clients by character let it protect staff and serve customers quickly during COVID-19. He also argues that societies must balance privacy against collective needs.

The main tension is between short-term relief and long-term damage. Gupta says government support buys time, but a pandemic lasting two or three years could blur the line between a company being short of cash and being insolvent. He expects bankruptcies, moral hazard, social backlash and uncertainty over remote work, cyber risk and productivity.

Key insights

  1. Digital investment made DBS's pandemic response fast

    Because DBS had already digitized, its data team traced infected staff contacts within 24 hours using door, calendar and Wi-Fi data. Digital volumes rose and market share grew in the following weeks.

  2. Governments are only buying time, not solving insolvency

    Gupta says that if the virus lasts two or three years, liquidity problems become solvency problems. That would bring broader bankruptcies that spill into the financial system and force governments to put in equity as well as debt.

  3. Pandemics can justify sharing personal data

    Gupta argues data is partly a public good. He says contact tracing is defensible, as are border controls and bank know-your-customer checks.

  4. Data should be regulated like knives, not guns

    Gupta says guns are controlled in advance through notice, consent and registration, while knives are controlled by context and use. He expects data rules to move toward the knife model because of its volume, variety and velocity.

  5. Character still comes first in lending decisions

    Gupta says banks are taught the five C's of credit, and character comes first. He has widened it to cover management approach and philosophy, so DBS keeps weighing the people behind a business.

Questions

How did DBS respond so quickly to its first COVID-19 case?

Gupta says DBS used its business continuity plans and, within 24 hours, set up testing, tracing and quarantine rules. His data team used turnstile, door, calendar and Wi-Fi data to find staff in contact with infected people, and the first two degrees of contacts were quarantined at home.

Why does Piyush Gupta say every company is a technology company?

He says that thinking this way changes employees' mindset and prepares the company to work without paper and use data and AI routinely. It also helps with customers, because they were already encouraged to use digital channels.

What does Gupta mean by the difference between liquidity and solvency?

Liquidity means having enough cash to pay bills now, while solvency means being fundamentally able to pay what you owe. Gupta says that if the pandemic lasts two or three years, government support may stop being enough and many firms could fail.

Why does Gupta think India and Africa had fewer COVID-19 cases than expected?

He says he does not know and is not a scientist. He suggests heat and humidity, BCG vaccination and widespread malaria as possible factors, and says deaths are harder to hide than cases, so low death counts suggest the low case counts are real.

Will remote work stay after the pandemic, according to Gupta?

He expects the way people work to change but is unsure how far. He says remote work is productive in the short term, but creative work may suffer, and it raises risk appetite and cyber risk.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

DBS was formed in the 1960s as the Development Bank of Singapore to help industrialize Singapore.

“We were formed in the 1960s, about 50 years ago, as the Development Bank of Singapore with the express purpose of helping the industrialization of this country.”

0:01:37 · Piyush Gupta · DBS founding · 1960s

DBS Group says about half its business is in Singapore, with the rest spread across 17 other countries.

“But the balance is now spread across 17 other countries, mostly in the region.”

0:01:37 · Piyush Gupta · DBS footprint · 2020

Piyush Gupta says DBS's balance sheet would rank just behind Morgan Stanley if it were a US bank.

“we would stack up just after Morgan Stanley and probably a tad ahead of most of the rest of the super regional in the country.”

0:02:13 · Piyush Gupta · Bank size · 2020

DBS first faced COVID-19 challenges in the third week of January 2020, when its colleagues in China began lockdown.

“our first encounter with the challenges of COVID actually happened in the third week of January, just around Lunar New Year, when our colleagues in China started going into lockdown mode.”

0:02:13 · Piyush Gupta · COVID timeline · 2020

Gupta says Taiwan and Hong Kong reacted early to COVID-19 because they had been hit hard by the 2003 SARS crisis.

“Taiwan and Hong Kong had been so impacted with the SARS crisis in 2003.”

0:02:48 · Piyush Gupta · SARS legacy · 2003

Gupta said Singapore had about 20,000 COVID-19 cases and only 20 deaths at the time of the interview.

“even though we now have about 20 ,000 cases, the actual number of fatalities are only 20.”

0:03:24 · Piyush Gupta · Singapore COVID · 2020

DBS had its first direct engagement with COVID-19 in Singapore on about 11 February 2020, when it had its first case.

“our first direct engagement effectively happened, I think the 11th of February, when we had our first case of the virus.”

0:03:24 · Piyush Gupta · DBS COVID case · 2020

After the first case, Gupta began alternate-day business continuity planning calls with all DBS regions.

“We pulled out our business continuity plans. I started conducting alternate day BCP call with the entire group, all of the region, and we pulled out all stops.”

0:03:58 · Piyush Gupta · Crisis management · 2020

DBS's data analytics and AI team used turnstile, door, calendar and Wi-Fi data to identify contacts of infected employees.

“which used things like turnstile tab data, door tab data, Outlook calendar data, internal Wi-Fi data, and establish quickly who had been the first degrees of contact for the infected persons.”

0:03:58 · Piyush Gupta · Contact tracing · 2020

DBS put first- and second-degree contacts of infected employees into two weeks of home quarantine.

“the first and second degrees of separation were immediately put into home quarantine for two weeks.”

0:04:49 · Piyush Gupta · Quarantine protocol · 2020

Gupta says that through February 2020 many countries lacked personal protective equipment supplies or imposed export bans, complicating DBS's procurement.

“most countries either did not have enough supply or even if they did, they started putting export bans into place.”

0:05:19 · Piyush Gupta · PPE supply · 2020

DBS built digital bridges within four weeks to close gaps in its customer digital tools.

“within four weeks, we built digital bridges where we thought there were gaps which would prevent customers from using our tools as quickly as they could.”

0:05:55 · Piyush Gupta · Digital banking · 2020

Mike Milken recalled that Piyush Gupta had named Alibaba and Tencent as DBS's likely future major competitors.

“you immediately told me you thought it was going to be Alibaba. Then another year, you said, well, it might be Tencent, and then you went back to Alibaba.”

0:06:25 · Mike Milken · Competition

Gupta said DBS's market share rose in the previous six to eight weeks because customers found its digital tools easier to use.

“our market share has gone up in the last six or eight weeks because it's quite clear that customers find it easier to deal with us”

0:08:37 · Piyush Gupta · Market share · 2020

Gupta thinks the virus might last two to three years, which would blur the line between liquidity and solvency problems.

“If the virus is long-lasting, which I personally think might be the case, it might be a two, three-year scenario, then the line between liquidity and solvency starts blurring.”

0:10:16 · Piyush Gupta · Economic outlook · 2020

Gupta predicts governments will have to provide equity support to some failing companies as well as debt.

“in addition to debt, the government is going to start having to put equity support into several companies.”

0:11:25 · Piyush Gupta · Government support · 2020

Mike Milken said the Milken Institute's tracker was monitoring more than 200 COVID-19 therapies, about 100 of them vaccines.

“our tracker at milkeninstitute.org, we're monitoring more than 200 different therapies. 100 of those are vaccines.”

0:11:43 · Mike Milken · COVID tracker · 2020

Gupta says DBS's purpose is deeply embedded because it was created as a development bank.

“Unfortunately, at DBS, because we were created for the specific role of helping development, etc., this idea of purpose is deeply embedded in our DNA.”

0:12:42 · Piyush Gupta · Corporate purpose

Gupta says letting staff work from home at scale raised DBS's risk appetite and raised cybersecurity uncertainty.

“In letting people work from home at scale, there is no question but that we have dialed up our risk appetite.”

0:13:54 · Piyush Gupta · Remote work · 2020

Gupta cites immigration control and bank know-your-customer checks as existing examples of using personal data for collective benefit.

“We already do this in other contexts. When we have immigration control at our borders to prevent terrorism from coming in, when banks use know-your-customer protection mechanisms to prevent money laundering.”

0:16:08 · Piyush Gupta · Data privacy

Gupta contrasts guns, controlled in advance through notice, consent and registration, with data, which he says should be controlled by context and use, like knives.

“A gun is controlled ex ante through notions of notice and consent and registration and control.”

0:16:40 · Piyush Gupta · Data regulation

Gupta says India imposed a comprehensive lockdown that was economically devastating, while much of Africa had no comprehensive lockdown.

“India went through a really comprehensive and in some ways economically devastating lockdown.”

0:18:11 · Piyush Gupta · India lockdown · 2020

Gupta cited BCG vaccination and malaria exposure as possible explanations for low COVID-19 numbers in India and Africa, while saying he is not a scientist.

“whether it is the fact that everybody in these countries still gets inoculated for BCG or whether malaria is so prevalent in these countries that they build some immunity systems.”

0:19:51 · Piyush Gupta · COVID theories · 2020

Gupta says impact-weighted accounting has no globally accepted standards, so organizations each take their own approach.

“There are no globally accepted standards. And therefore everybody tends to do their own thing.”

0:22:40 · Piyush Gupta · Impact accounting

Gupta says the first of the five C's of credit he was taught was character, which he has extended to management approach and philosophy.

“The first C we were taught was called character.”

0:24:07 · Piyush Gupta · Credit underwriting

Chapters

  1. 0:03:58DBS's background and early COVID-19 response

    Gupta explains DBS's origins and how its China, Taiwan and Singapore teams reacted to the virus. It shows how quickly tracing and protective measures were set up.

    “We pulled out our business continuity plans.”
  2. 0:07:15Digital transformation as preparation

    Gupta explains why seeing DBS as a technology company helped inside the bank and with customers. Digital volumes and market share rose.

    “every company, every industry is really a technology company at heart.”
  3. 0:10:16Economic fallout and moral hazard

    Gupta warns of job losses, bankruptcies and social backlash if the virus lasts for years. Governments may need to inject equity as well as debt.

    “then the line between liquidity and solvency starts blurring.”
  4. 0:12:42Changing how DBS operates

    Gupta says purpose, remote work, risk appetite and cybersecurity will all be re-examined. DBS will experiment before settling on answers.

    “getting a license from civil society will be even more important in the future”
  5. 0:16:40Data privacy and the knife analogy

    Gupta argues that a pandemic can justify sharing personal data for the collective good. He proposes regulating data by context and use.

    “we will have to start thinking of controlling data, not like we control a gun”
  6. 0:19:51India and Africa's low case counts

    Gupta discusses possible reasons for the surprisingly low numbers, while admitting uncertainty. He stresses that deaths are harder to undercount.

    “I'm not a scientist, so I can't speculate on what the answer is.”
  7. 0:24:07Valuing human and social capital

    The two discuss why accounting misses human, social and natural capital, and why character remains central to lending.

    “The first C we were taught was called character.”

Transcript

0:00:00
Speaker 3

Now from the Milken Institute, responding to COVID-19, conversations with Mike Milken.

0:00:06
Piyush Gupta

Most times, your right for personal privacy trumps other kinds of needs. But a pandemic is when it becomes quite clear that sometimes the needs of the collective, the needs of society, trump the needs of the individual.

0:00:20
Speaker 3

That's Piyush Gupta. He's the CEO and director of DBS Group, a leading financial services company based in Singapore. Known throughout the industry as an innovator, Gupta's move toward digital and remote banking laid the foundation for DBS's response to the pandemic. He spoke recently with Milken Institute and Faster Cures chairman, Mike Milken.

0:00:42
Mike Milken

Thank you for joining us today.

0:00:45
Piyush Gupta

Very happy to join you, Mike, forward to doing this.

0:00:48
Mike Milken

And you've now joined a very successful club, the Club of Grandparents. Laurie and I couldn't be more excited for you and your lovely wife with your first grandchild.

0:01:03
Piyush Gupta

Well, I have to admit, it is a special feeling. And to have a lovely young granddaughter in the middle of this doom and gloom is like a ray of sunshine. So we are looking forward to it.

0:01:16
Mike Milken

So particularly for our listeners outside of Asia or Southeast Asia, I think it would be good if we could just get an overview of the DBS group, its founding. And then when did you realize that COVID-19 was going to be a big challenge? How did you respond?

0:01:37
Piyush Gupta

We were formed in the 1960s, about 50 years ago, as the Development Bank of Singapore with the express purpose of helping the industrialization of this country. Since then, obviously, we evolved to become a commercial bank. And today have a broad range of activities from corporate banking, retail banking, wealth management, investment banking, and so on. We are still about 40 % of our employees in Singapore. Half our business is in Singapore. But the balance is now spread across 17 other countries, mostly in the region.

0:02:13

In terms of size, I think we are about number 40 in the world in terms of balance sheet, which means that if you physically picked us up and put us into the US, we would stack up just after Morgan Stanley and probably a tad ahead of most of the rest of the super regional in the country. Now, because we have a presence in China, our first encounter with the challenges of COVID actually happened in the third week of January, just around Lunar New Year, when our colleagues in China started going into lockdown mode.

0:02:48

Interestingly, our colleagues in Taiwan and Hong Kong reacted even sooner than that because Taiwan and Hong Kong had been so impacted with the SARS crisis in 2003. The public at large pushed the government to start bringing down the borders with mainland China. People started wearing masks in both of these countries very, very early. One of the things that makes a big difference, and that's true in Singapore particularly, clearly, is the quality, not just if you're testing, tracing, quarantining facilities, but ultimately the quality of your health care.

0:03:24

In Singapore, it's interesting that even though we now have about 20 ,000 cases, the actual number of fatalities are only 20. So that's 0.1 % is the smallest percentage of fatalities. And that tells you that even if you do wind up getting the virus with good medical treatment and good health systems, you can actually manage that virus relatively well. In Singapore, our first direct engagement effectively happened, I think the 11th of February, when we had our first case of the virus.

0:03:58

We pulled out our business continuity plans. I started conducting alternate day BCP call with the entire group, all of the region, and we pulled out all stops. Now, we've been somewhat advantaged because all of our digital transformation work over the last several years has proven to be extremely helpful. When we had our first case, we were within 24 hours able to set up a protocol for testing, tracing and quarantining. My data analytics and AI team was quickly able to pull together data which used things like turnstile tab data, door tab data, Outlook calendar data, internal Wi-Fi data, and establish quickly who had been the first degrees of contact for the infected persons.

0:04:49

We call them the first degree of separation. Then they did the same thing for the next level and we created a second degree of separation. and then finally a third degree of separation. And we set up a protocol where the first and second degrees of separation were immediately put into home quarantine for two weeks. We started providing all of our colleagues in every country personal protective equipment immediately. That included masks, sanitizers, thermometers, temperature check and so on.

0:05:19

Now this was more challenging than it appears because as you remember through February, most countries either did not have enough supply or even if they did, they started putting export bans into place. So our procurement people had to look and be very creative about where we could source this PPE from. It was not an easy exercise, but we were able to achieve it. And the confidence it gave our own people, the fact that we were able to provide them equipment, we were thoughtful and thinking about their health and safety was actually very, very beneficial to us.

0:05:55

The other thing we did through February was dialed up rapidly our digital access tools for all of our customers. Now, we already have a very advanced digital set of products, mobile banking, et cetera. But with all of these, there are always some gaps. I call them the last divide, the last mile. And so within four weeks, we built digital bridges where we thought there were gaps which would prevent customers from using our tools as quickly as they could.

0:06:25
Mike Milken

Let me recall a visit to your office many, many years ago. You asked me, Mike, who do you think our major competitor will be in the future? And I'm thinking, well, there's a few banks that have as many as 10 ,000 employees in Singapore. And what I'm thinking, you immediately told me you thought it was going to be Alibaba. Then another year, you said, well, it might be Tencent, and then you went back to Alibaba. And as I think about how you've been able to operate throughout Asia, I have to believe your views many years ago that your major competitor in the long run would be digital companies like Alibaba and Tencent.

0:07:12

How did that prepare you for what's occurred?

0:07:15
Piyush Gupta

Mike, I still continue to believe that today, every company, every industry is really a technology company at heart. In our case, a technology company offering financial products and services. If you start thinking like that, then it enables you in two important ways. One, it enables you internally, not just the technology capability of the company, but the psyche of your employees that changes. and it empowers you and prepares you to being able to handle everything without paper, to digitize everything, and more importantly, start thinking about things like using data and using artificial intelligence as a way of life.

0:08:00

The second way it prepares you is in the external interface. In the last five or six years, our percentage of digital access customers has increased dramatically and we actually have a whole range of programs to incentivize customers to give up paper give up physical forms of interaction and move to digital forms of interaction and so when a crisis like this happens and you then create and accelerate some other interface and interaction mechanisms as you go out and communicate to customers that this is an easier way to deal with the bank.

0:08:37

In the last three months, our digital volumes have just gone through the roof. Not only has it improved life for our customers, frankly, it has also improved our own business prospects because our market share has gone up in the last six or eight weeks because it's quite clear that customers find it easier to deal with us with the tools that

0:08:58
Mike Milken

we have made available to them. You and I have looked at business, banking, finance in many ways over the years. And one of the things I particularly enjoyed is our discussions about the ramifications in society and what's going on in terms of access to capital, evening of the economic opportunities. First, focusing on the economy and what's occurring How is that affecting the political issues, such as moral hazards as to who survives and who doesn't? How does this lead to social change?

0:09:39

What is the response going to be?

0:09:42
Piyush Gupta

From a macroeconomic standpoint, it's quite clear that there is more massive demand destruction than we have ever seen. And the scale of the economic problem is not consistent. It varies by country. Some countries just have the economic wherewithal to be able to do a lot more fiscal pump priming as well as put more money into the system. And then perhaps most of all, it is the man in the street, the consumer. I think the amount of job loss you will see coming out of this crisis is going to be very significant.

0:10:16

Even though the governments are trying to buy time, in the longer term, they're kicking the can down the road. If the virus is short-lived, that's an effective strategy because over time, companies will come back and people survive. If the virus is long-lasting, which I personally think might be the case, it might be a two, three-year scenario, then the line between liquidity and solvency starts blurring. And so while you can buy time, maybe this year, what happens next year, you will start seeing a much broader range of bankruptcies, which will then start spilling over into the financial system as well.

0:10:56

There is also, in this whole government response, a lot of moral hazard. It's the right thing to do in the short term. But there is no question that as you think longer out, people are already making choices and decisions. Who gets to survive? Who doesn't get to survive? And the social backlash will wind up with looking for somebody to blame. It'll either be, can we blame China? Or can we blame the rich people? Or can we blame the companies?

0:11:25

A second challenge will be that as companies start failing, governments will realize that they need to keep the basic bulwark of the economy in place. And so in addition to debt, the government is going to start having to put equity support into several companies.

0:11:43
Mike Milken

When I think about how you've responded and your views of the world, I think you can understand why at the Milken Institute and our medical foundations and our family foundations, we have reoriented our efforts here to accelerate work on medical and health solutions. At this time, our tracker at milkeninstitute.org, we're monitoring more than 200 different therapies. 100 of those are vaccines. And as you've said, we need to make sure this is not a 2021 or 22 problem because as you've outlined, the economic, the political, and the social effects have the potential to be so devastating.

0:12:29

But one of the things that's coming out of this going forward, I have to believe you are rethinking the way DBS operates. How do you see this changing the way

0:12:42
Piyush Gupta

you lead DBS? I think society is going to want to ensure they understand why the company exists and what the company's true role is. So getting a license from civil society will be even more important in the future than it has been in the past. Unfortunately, at DBS, because we were created for the specific role of helping development, etc., this idea of purpose is deeply embedded in our DNA. So we're well positioned, but I think this is something most large companies and corporations will have to think very hard about.

0:13:17

The second way things will change is what amount of work happens remote, working from home. Do we really change our physical premises? Do we need branches? I do believe that all of this is going to be re-evaluated in substantial measure. Productivity works in the short term, but will productivity be consistent in the long term? Already, there's some things which we think are easier to do away from office. But when it comes to more creative stuff, starting things anew afresh, I think productivity might not be able to keep pace, certainly from what we can see right now.

0:13:54

The second big challenge which we're struggling with right now is this idea of how much risk are we prepared to take? In letting people work from home at scale, there is no question but that we have dialed up our risk appetite. What all of this means to an increased degree of cybersecurity and cyber risk is a third dimension that we are not entirely clear about at this stage. So I guess the answer to your question is that we are going to be experimenting with a lot of these things.

0:14:23

I'm convinced that the world will change, the method of working will change. But how far it gets, how rapid the change is, and what the most productive way to approach it might be is something which I think we will only learn with time.

0:14:37
Mike Milken

You recently wrote a thoughtful piece, which I read in the Financial Times, focusing on balancing data privacy and collective action. And this becomes particularly important during times of crisis. How do you see this balance playing out?

0:15:00
Piyush Gupta

Mike, as a general rule, I think that we as human beings, as mankind come together in societies, we agree to some basic principles that some things are best left to the collective to do. That is the premise on which we create a police force, as opposed to each individual being responsible for protecting himself or herself. I believe that data in some ways and at some times falls into the category of a collective or a public good.

0:15:30

Now, data is peculiar because most people value personal privacy. And I would argue that most times your right or your requirement for personal privacy trumps other kinds of needs. But a pandemic is a great use case when it becomes quite clear that sometimes the needs of the collective, the needs of society, trump the needs of the individual. You might not want anybody to know where you went, but if to facilitate contact tracing and quarantining for the good of society, it is important for people to know who you are in touch with and whether you could be infected.

0:16:08

well then it seems to me that that's defensible and arguably a good thing for society to do. We already do this in other contexts. When we have immigration control at our borders to prevent terrorism from coming in, when banks use know-your-customer protection mechanisms to prevent money laundering. These are good examples when it becomes quite clear that collective or broad use of data is beneficial to society. So I think there will be situations and circumstances when this will happen.

0:16:40

My own view to data is that in the long term, just the volume, variety and velocity of data is such that we will have to start thinking of controlling data, not like we control a gun, but like we control a knife. A gun is controlled ex ante through notions of notice and consent and registration and control. Whereas a knife you can go buy in the neighborhood store. But the knife is controlled through the idea of context and use.

0:17:11

If you use the knife to stab somebody, you go to jail. If you use the knife in the right context for the right purposes, like eating your food, it's okay. I think we'll probably wind up with a net use of data which is not dissimilar. that there will be situations where the context will allow you to use data more completely and other situations where it will not be acceptable.

0:17:32
Mike Milken

I think it's a very interesting analogy. I had not heard that one before. I'd like to turn to a whole different subject. And this is one over the years we've spoken about and one that I think is near and dear to your heart. And that is what might happen to India and Africa in this coronavirus crisis. At the moment, these regions have been somewhat of a surprise to the world in their concern in the number of cases and what's occurred.

0:18:02

Why did these regions surprise us when we expected so many cases and so much potential devastation?

0:18:11
Piyush Gupta

Mike, it's hard to say. Each of these regions has followed different strategies. India went through a really comprehensive and in some ways economically devastating lockdown. And large parts of Africa, different countries followed different programs, but nobody had a really comprehensive lockdown either. Nevertheless, all of these regions, you've seen that the number of cases of the virus are low. And more importantly, the death counts are very low. Now, the cases of the virus, you can argue that testing is not very good.

0:18:47

And it's quite true. These large countries with large populations not being tested will result in a fewer number of cases being found. But I would argue that the number of fatalities is more easy to get your hands around. If people are dying because they're not able to breathe, well, by and large, most of these countries, that statistic would be picked up. And the truth is, you're not seeing a lot of that either. So there is some other force at work, which is keeping the number of cases and the fatalities in these countries much lower than you would expect.

0:19:22

Normally, given the population, the density and the number of people crammed into small surroundings in these countries. So my own sense is that it's one of two or three possibilities. One is just this whole idea of heat and humidity. It might have a bearing on the fact that the virus has not been as extensive in these countries. Somebody asked me, why would that not apply to Singapore? And the fact is that Singapore, everything is pretty much air conditioned.

0:19:51

And even though it's a hot and humid country, most people are indoors in air conditioned environments. That's not true in India and Africa. So that might be the case. There are other theories as well, whether it is the fact that everybody in these countries still gets inoculated for BCG or whether malaria is so prevalent in these countries that they build some immunity systems. I'm not a scientist, so I can't speculate on what the answer is. But I think it is definitely true that the incidence of this disease in these countries has been surprisingly low.

0:20:25
Mike Milken

Lastly, one of the things that we've discussed, and I think it might be more relevant today than ever before is the fact that so many companies, it's not the financial balance sheet that you give, but the talent of your people, the human capital, the human potential, your training, et cetera, and the social capital that's created and what your organization stand for. These are things you never find on the balance sheet. And as we've discussed over the years, the only industry truly that puts their people on the balance sheet is professional sports, which is player contracts that might or might not be accurate in reflecting the people's ability.

0:21:10

How do you look at a financial institution when you don't see the people, you don't see the social capital on the balance sheet, you don't see what you stand for and what you've created as a mission?

0:21:24
Piyush Gupta

It's a good question. The reality is that whether it is human capital or social capital or even natural capital, this doesn't come into the accounting, the gap-based accounting structure that we have all built and lived by. As a matter of fact, most public goods don't come into this measure because this measure is generally focused on traded markets. And therefore, it tends to focus on privately traded goods. Public goods, as a consequence, get disregarded. I think one of the things the pandemic brings sharply into focus is the importance of something like public health or the role of the government in that regard.

0:22:06

i think as we go forward the big issues and challenges of sustainability and climate are going to also further accentuate the need to think about how do you value public goods like environment like climate like carbon emissions so my own view is that there's a lot of nascent effort right now in trying to capture some of these non-captured goods onto alternative mechanisms of accounting impact weighted accounting sometimes it's called. I think this is going to pick up some degree of momentum.

0:22:40

One of the problems is that these are not easy things to do and there are no globally accepted standards. And therefore everybody tends to do their own thing. But I think it's only a matter of time before the world starts developing some protocols to better measure and capture some of these onto alternative methods of value and accounting. I think we will slowly and surely

0:23:03
Mike Milken

have to get there? It's more than 50 years ago that I developed my own theories really heavily focused on these areas and of the hundreds or thousands of companies that we backed or financed over the years or I still am involved with. To me, the most important factors in investing in those companies or financing those companies was the people that worked for them, what they stood for, what their mission was. And in looking at many of the great entrepreneurs, I've had a chance to participate in their building their companies over the decades.

0:23:40

It was the decision on which individuals to back in the long run that made the decision. Is this an area as a financial institution that you have flexibility in deciding how important is the management team, the people, their mission statements, where they stand on the environment or other issues, and your decision whether to financially back these companies.

0:24:07
Piyush Gupta

When I started my banking career, for credit underwriting, we were taught the five C's of credit. And many of those C's still exist, cash flow, collateral, capital, and so on. The first C we were taught was called character. And character over the years, I have extended to embrace some of the things you talk about. It is really management capacities, management approach, management philosophies. And so for us at DBS, this whole understanding of the people we are backing continues to be front and foremost in our thinking about who to work with and who to support.

0:24:46

This is not going to change. I want to congratulate you

0:24:50
Mike Milken

on your activities. They were so focused on the health of your own employees, the access to capital for your customers, and your commitment to excellence. And I want to, once again, thank you for joining me and congratulating you for entering the world

0:25:08
Piyush Gupta

of grandparenthood. Thank you, Mike. I enjoyed doing this.

0:25:20
Speaker 3

you'll also find the latest COVID-19 updates. Until next time, stay safe and healthy.