OpenNashPodcasts

Crime Junkie

MISSING: Gabby Petito

19 Sep 2021 · 45m · Ashley Flowers · 17 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Host Ashley Flowers argues that the Gabby Petito case, already getting huge media attention, still deserves coverage because widespread public attention can produce tips. She lays out what was known on September 19, 2021: Petito vanished on a cross-country van trip, and her fiancé Brian Laundrie came home alone and stopped talking. She uses the episode to ask listeners to share information and to spotlight Lauren Cho, a missing woman getting far less attention.

The episode moves from a family's growing alarm, to police body-camera footage of an August Moab traffic stop showing the couple's strained relationship, to Laundrie's disappearance and a TikTok hitchhiker sighting. The tension is between what the footage and timeline suggest and how little is actually known, since Laundrie's family would not cooperate. It closes by contrasting Petito's national coverage with Cho's near silence, arguing that time is precious in both cases.

Key insights

  1. Laundrie returned home alone nearly two weeks early

    Police learned on September 11 that Brian Laundrie had driven Gabby Petito's van to Florida on September 1. Her family had been unable to reach him or his family in the meantime, which made a late-August text from her phone seem suspect.

  2. A Moab police stop recorded the couple's conflict

    On August 12 officers pulled over the couple's van after a reported domestic dispute. They weighed an assault charge, then wrote it up as a mental health break and separated the couple for the night with no charges.

  3. A TikTok video became a possible lead

    A TikTok user said she and her boyfriend gave Laundrie a ride near Grand Teton on August 29, and police said they might use her information in their timeline. Flowers notes the timing is tight and questions why he was hitchhiking if he had the van.

  4. Searches spread across several states and territories

    Police searched a large area around the Carlton Reserve in Florida, and the FBI extended its search through Grand Teton National Park into Wyoming. An AllTrails profile reportedly showing Puerto Rico added a further, unverified twist.

  5. Lauren Cho's case has received little coverage

    Cho left her lodging on June 28 and has not been seen since, and searches found no trace of her. Flowers says only a few news articles exist, and she wants her audience to help spread word.

Questions

Why was Gabby Petito's family so worried in early September 2021?

They could not reach her for days, and a text claiming she had no service in Yosemite felt wrong to her mother. They then learned her fiancé Brian Laundrie had been home in Florida since September 1 without telling anyone.

What is a person of interest, and was Brian Laundrie named one?

A person of interest is someone police want to question because they may know something, without being charged with a crime. According to The Independent, police officially named Laundrie one on September 15.

What happened in the Moab police body-camera video?

Officers stopped the couple's van on August 12 after a report of a domestic dispute, and each gave their own account of a fight. The officers decided not to charge anyone, called it a mental health break, and had the couple spend the night apart.

Why did a TikTok video matter to the investigation?

A TikTok user said she and her boyfriend picked up Laundrie hitchhiking near Grand Teton on August 29, with no van and no Gabby. Police confirmed she contacted them and said they were potentially using her information in their timeline.

Who is Lauren Cho and why did the host include her?

Lauren Cho, called Elle by friends, is a chef who disappeared on June 28 after walking away from where she was staying in California. Ashley Flowers included her because her case has had very little media coverage compared with Petito's.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

According to CNN, Gabby Petito's mother received a text from Petito's phone on August 30 reading "no service in Yosemite."

“Gabby's mom had received a text that had said as much from Gabby's phone on August 30th. According to CNN, it read, quote, no service in Yosemite.”

0:03:32 · Ashley Flowers · Final text · 2021

Gabby Petito's mother and stepfather reported her missing in Suffolk County, New York, on the morning after the September 10 visit.

“By the next morning, her mother and stepfather reported Gabby missing in Suffolk County, New York, where they live.”

0:05:34 · Ashley Flowers · Missing report · 2021

Police seized Gabby Petito's van from the Laundrie home and reportedly found material inside, which had not been described as of the recording.

“Police seized the van from the house and found quote-unquote material in there, though as of this recording, we don't know exactly what that was.”

0:07:11 · Ashley Flowers · Van evidence · 2021

Gabby Petito's mother said the couple had broken off their engagement and gone back to being boyfriend and girlfriend.

“Though Gabby's mom says that they broke off the engagement and decided to go back to just being boyfriend and girlfriend.”

0:07:48 · Ashley Flowers · Relationship status · 2021

A Moab Police Department case document says officers were dispatched on August 12 to a reported domestic problem near the Moonflower Co-op.

“According to a case document by the Moab Police Department filed for an incident that occurred on August 12, quote, MCPD officers were dispatched to a report of a domestic problem that had taken place near the Moonflower Co-op.”

0:11:57 · Ashley Flowers · Moab incident · 2021

The police report described the couple as leaving the scene in a white Ford Transit van with a black ladder on the rear.

“It appeared that a male and female had left the scene traveling north on Main in a white Ford Transit van with a black ladder on the rear”

0:12:42 · Ashley Flowers · Couple's van · 2021

The Moab officer's report classified the incident as a mental health break, and the couple separated for the night, with Brian Laundrie going to a hotel and Gabby Petito taking the van.

“Ultimately, he wrote up in his report that this was a mental health break. The couple separated for the night. Brian went to a hotel and Gabby took the van.”

0:31:52 · Ashley Flowers · Moab outcome · 2021

A friend of Gabby Petito named Rose told the Daily Mail that Brian Laundrie had jealousy issues.

“a friend of Gabby's named Rose came forward and told the Daily Mail quote, he's got these jealousy issues”

0:33:05 · Ashley Flowers · Friend's account · 2021

Police believed Brian Laundrie went to the Carlton Reserve in Florida early in the week of the recording.

“Police think he went to an area known as the Carlton Reserve sometime early this week. But at this point, they don't know any more.”

0:35:49 · Ashley Flowers · Laundrie search · 2021

According to Newsweek, the FBI extended its search for Gabby Petito through Grand Teton National Park into Wyoming.

“according to Newsweek, the FBI has extended its search through Grand Teton National Park into Wyoming.”

0:35:49 · Ashley Flowers · FBI search · 2021

According to Fox News reporting, police confirmed the TikTok user who described picking up Brian Laundrie had been in contact with them.

“According to Peter Aitken's reporting for Fox News, police confirmed that this user had been in contact with them”

0:39:58 · Ashley Flowers · TikTok tip · 2021

Lauren Cho traveled from New Jersey to California in a tour bus with her friend and former partner Corey.

“she hopped in a tour bus with her friend, who she used to date, named Corey, and they drove from New Jersey to California”

0:43:51 · Ashley Flowers · Lauren Cho · 2021

Lauren Cho was a chef who, per High Desert Star, bought an old school bus in California and was converting it into a food truck.

“Elle was a chef, and while she was out there, according to Stacey Moore's reporting for High Desert Star, she, quote, bought an old school bus and was converting it into a food truck, end quote.”

0:44:30 · Ashley Flowers · Lauren Cho · 2021

The sheriff's office searched again for Lauren Cho on July 24, including with a plane, and found nothing.

“They tried again on July 24th, even with a plane, but again, they found nothing.”

0:46:53 · Ashley Flowers · Cho search · 2021

Investigators served a second search warrant at Lauren Cho's residence on July 31 at 6 a.m.

“investigators started looking a little closer to Lauren's home base because they served what we now know was a second search warrant on that Saturday at 6 a.m.”

0:46:53 · Ashley Flowers · Search warrant · 2021

The FBI asked anyone with information about Gabby Petito to call its tip line at 1-800-CALL-FBI.

“anyone with information about Gabby Petito is asked to contact the FBI tip line at 1-800-CALL-FBI.”

0:47:57 · Ashley Flowers · Tip line · 2021

Ashley Flowers warned that fraudulent fundraising pages were circulating alongside the family's approved GoFundMe for Gabby Petito.

“there are a number of fraudulent pages out there right now trying to exploit the tragedy.”

0:48:30 · Ashley Flowers · GoFundMe scams · 2021

Chapters

  1. 0:00:36Why a breaking story and a second case

    Flowers explains why she is breaking her usual rule about headline stories and previews her plan to also highlight another missing woman.

    “We don't chase headlines.”
  2. 0:03:32Family loses contact with Gabby

    The family's alarm grows as Gabby stops responding, and a late-August text from her phone raises doubts.

    “According to CNN, it read, quote, no service in Yosemite.”
  3. 0:06:10Laundrie turns out to be home alone

    Police learn Brian Laundrie returned to Florida with the van days earlier, and the family refuses to answer questions.

    “He drove Gabby's van back solo and arrived home on September 1st.”
  4. 0:11:57The Moab traffic stop and body-camera footage

    Police footage from August 12 gives the public a look at the couple's strained relationship and the officers' decision-making.

    “a report of a domestic problem that had taken place near the Moonflower Co-op”
  5. 0:31:52Officers choose no charges and separate the couple

    After debating an assault charge, officers treat the incident as a mental health break and separate the couple overnight.

    “he wrote up in his report that this was a mental health break.”
  6. 0:35:17Laundrie reported missing as searches widen

    Gabby's family distinguishes between Laundrie missing and hiding, while police and the FBI search in Florida and Wyoming.

    “Brian isn't missing. Our daughter is the one who's missing.”
  7. 0:39:58TikTok sighting and the AllTrails puzzle

    A TikTok user's hitchhiking account and an app location showing Puerto Rico add leads and uncertainty.

    “potentially utilizing her info into our timeline”
  8. 0:43:51The disappearance of Lauren Cho

    Flowers shifts to a lesser-covered missing woman, describing her move to California and the sparse search efforts.

    “Her name is Lauren Cho, but her friends called her Elle.”
  9. 0:47:57Call to action and tip lines

    Flowers asks listeners to share both cases, gives tip lines, and warns about fake fundraising pages.

    “We need to get this on TikTok and social media”

Transcript

0:00:01
Ashley Flowers

Want to know the secret to making every holiday party better? Bring delicious ice-cold Coca-Cola to the table. Because while everyone celebrates the season a little differently, there's one thing everyone can agree on. Coca-Cola is the ultimate crowd-pleaser, bringing delicious, refreshing taste to every meal and extra joy to every holiday gathering. Bring the joy this season. Enjoy Coca-Cola. Tap the banner to shop now. Hi, Crime Junkies. I'm your host, Ashley Flowers. And I'm solo today because this isn't a regularly scheduled episode.

0:00:36

We are still releasing a full-length episode out wide tomorrow, like always. But I'm here to bring you an extra episode this week. And honestly, for I think the first time ever, a breaking story. And normally, we don't do breaking stories outside of our headline segment in the fan club. We don't chase headlines. and if a story is getting massive amounts of attention, honestly, I sometimes find myself thinking that the case doesn't need our little podcast and I should focus on something lesser known.

0:01:06

I even did an interview recently and I said I probably wouldn't cover the case I'm going to talk about for that very reason. But then I got to thinking, A, if it were my daughter who was missing, I would want everyone, big and small, talking about it, and there would be no such thing as enough coverage. B, we aren't that small anymore. I still feel like the same podcaster I was almost four years ago because I feel like I haven't changed.

0:01:33

So sometimes I forget that our audience size has, and we do have an incredible reach of millions of people every week. And C, I realize that I can use this opportunity to give you the story that you've been asking me to tell. And my God, you have been asking. I mean, in almost four years of doing this show, I have never, I mean, never seen you guys in a frenzy the way you are now. Our emails are flooded.

0:01:59

Our DMs are flooded. Our fan club, it is the only thing you want to talk about in the fan club. So I figured I should do the story that you want to hear because I want you to have a say in what we cover on this show. But in doing so, I could do the other thing that's important to me and tell you about another young woman who is missing under equally bizarre circumstances, who I'm sure you've heard nothing about, but her family and loved ones deserve the same attention.

0:02:26

So let me tell you everything you need to know as of this recording, Sunday, September 19th, about Gabby Petito. In the early days of September, Gabby Petito's family started to worry about her. She and her boyfriend, Brian Laundrie, had taken a van out west earlier in the summer. They wanted to hit up all the national parks and document their journey online. And the trip had been going well, at least from the pictures on Gabby's Instagram and the frequent calls or video chat she'd made to her mom back in New York.

0:03:32

But now it had been a few days since her mom and stepdad in New York or her dad in Florida had been able to get a hold of her. And sure, sometimes when you're traveling, reception is spotty. Gabby's mom had received a text that had said as much from Gabby's phone on August 30th. According to CNN, it read, quote, no service in Yosemite. But the more time passed without word from Gabby, the less sure her family was that that text even came from her at all.

0:04:01

When her mom thought back on the last time she remembered really talking to her daughter, hearing her voice or seeing her face, it was the 23rd, maybe the 24th, even up to the 25th, according to Newsweek. Either way, it had been too long. Something was wrong. It seems that while they tried to reach Gabby, they were also trying to reach Brian or his family. Because according to an interview Gabby's parents did on Fox News, her mom tried to call and text Brian's mom on the 10th, September 10th, to tell her that she was worried about the kids because she hadn't heard from them.

0:04:36

But she couldn't even get a call or a text back from Brian's mom. And when Gabby's dad found out, he too tried to call and text, even escalating it, telling them that the next step is they were going to call the police. But even that didn't garner a response. And at that point, according to reporting by Michael Ruiz for Fox News, on September 10th, her father had had enough waiting. And he drove to Brian's family's home looking for answers as to where his daughter was.

0:05:06

Now, Brian and his family also live in Florida, and Gabby was living with them. Based on the reporting, we don't know what was said at the home or who he talked to when he arrived. Just that he got there at 6.30 on the night of the 10th, and we know he didn't go inside the house. But obviously, because there is a report, we know that at some point police were called and there was a public service incident report made.

0:05:34

By the next morning, her mother and stepfather reported Gabby missing in Suffolk County, New York, where they live. Police seem to have taken the report pretty seriously since the same day they contacted police in Northport where Laundrie's family lived. And they asked them to go down there and basically see what's up, do a welfare check, maybe see if they have been able to get a hold of Brian, who is supposed to be with Gabby. But when police down there get to the family's door, instead of being met with another set of concerned parents, they were hit with a bombshell.

0:06:10

First, they learned that Brian, oh, he's been home for a week. He drove Gabby's van back solo and arrived home on September 1st. This is we're finding this out on September 11th, though all the time her family was looking for her or trying to get in contact with him. He wouldn't speak to them. Again, they didn't even know he was home until right now. And it's at this point, according to what Gabby's mom told Fox News, that they were even more certain that that August 30th text didn't come from Gabby.

0:06:46

Because if Brian is home in Florida on the 1st, then how would that even be possible? She didn't make any mention that they were separated or that she didn't have her van. Now, her mom doesn't have cell phone data to show where the phone pinged from when that text came through. She assumes the FBI is looking into all of that. But to her, it's, quote, obvious that it didn't come from her daughter at Yosemite, like it said.

0:07:11

But if police have questions about all of this and, hi, they have a lot of questions about all of this, no one in the family is willing to answer those questions. because according to a quote from law enforcement to CNN, the police were essentially given an attorney's number and told, if you got any questions, talk to him. This did not sit well with police and it certainly didn't sit well with Gabby's family. Police seized the van from the house and found quote-unquote material in there, though as of this recording, we don't know exactly what that was.

0:07:48

And this is about the time that this story started hitting all of your radars. A couple on a camping trip, the boyfriend comes home, but for 10 days doesn't mention to anyone that he came home without his girlfriend. And actually, according to what they were telling people just days before Gabby went missing, she was his fiancée. Though Gabby's mom says that they broke off the engagement and decided to go back to just being boyfriend and girlfriend.

0:08:13

But either way, fiancée or not, they were together. He claimed to have loved her, and yet here he was, alone, refusing to talk to anyone, refusing to say when he last saw Gabby, why he's here alone, even despite pleas from her parents. And they weren't just asking Brian to talk. They were begging, absolutely begging, anyone in his family to talk as well. I mean, my God, they all lived with Gabby. Surely they cared about her well-being.

0:08:43

Why wouldn't they convince Brian to cooperate? And was there anything that they could tell police to help? Gabby's family released a statement through their lawyer directed to Brian's family and published it in a number of outlets. Quote, Please, if you or your family have any decency left, please tell us where Gabby is located. Tell us if we are even looking in the right place. All we want is for Gabby to come home. Please help us make that happen.

0:09:14

We haven't been able to sleep or eat and our lives are falling apart. End quote. The Laundry's statement to the public was that they wouldn't be talking. They had nothing to add. It was essentially no comment. So without getting any information from the family, police put the pressure on a little by officially naming Brian a person of interest on September 15th, according to The Independent. By this point, the whole country is watching the case and following every single move.

0:09:46

How could this man just not say anything? Where did you leave her? If nothing bad happened, just talk. It was the not talking that people became obsessed with. Because they would look at her Instagram and his Instagram and they seemed so happy. But you know what I know. Social media is a lie. It only lets you see the shiny parts of their lives. Kissing on the mountains, doing cartwheels on the beach. It doesn't give you insight into the real parts of a relationship.

0:10:20

The darker parts. But there are no glowing filters on police body cameras. And on September 16th, the world finally got a real look into their relationship. The new Peacock original limited series The Good Daughter is a suspenseful thriller wrapped in an emotional story about love, family, and resilience. Rose Byrne and Megan Fahey star as sisters who have spent the last 20 years trying to piece together their lives after a single night of violence. When another attack splinters their small town, the sisters, now both lawyers like their father, become embroiled in the case.

0:10:59

As the case unfolds and twists through painful memories and buried secrets, what emerges is not just a story of survival, but of enduring ties between a father and his daughters and the complex bond between sisters. Based on the bestseller by Karen Slaughter, The Good Daughter is streaming November 12th only on Peacock. Let's face it, if student loans are slowing down your financial goals, it might be time for a smarter strategy. That's where today's sponsor SoFi comes in.

0:11:30

SoFi is helping you tackle student debt by refinancing your loans with flexible monthly payments that fit your budget. We're talking about the potential to lower your interest rate, reduce your monthly payment, or even pay off your loan sooner depending on the term you choose. You can also consolidate your student loans into one simple monthly payment so you could save more each month and work towards achieving your long-term financial ambitions. SoFi offers competitive, fixed, and variable rates and no origination fees, prepayment fees, or late fees required.

0:11:57

It takes just two minutes to check your rate with SoFi, and they have already helped over 500 ,000 members refinance more than $50 billion in student loans. Visit SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie to see how much you can save. That's SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie and start making smarter money moves with SoFi. SoFi student loans are originated by SoFi Bank and a member FDIC. Additional terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891. According to a case document by the Moab Police Department filed for an incident that occurred on August 12, quote, MCPD officers were dispatched to a report of a domestic problem that had taken place near the Moonflower Co-op.

0:12:42

It appeared that a male and female had left the scene traveling north on Main in a white Ford Transit van with a black ladder on the rear after the male and female had engaged in some sort of altercation. End quote. By the time officers got to the co-op, the couple was gone. But an officer on the road spotted the van. Here are portions of the dashcam video released by police. The full video can be found on the Fox 13's YouTube page, which you can link to through our source material list on our website.

0:13:20
Speaker 2

The driver is showing some obscure driving, possibly intoxicated. Currently doing 45 miles an hour. Zone through here is 25. Oh! Subjects just hit the curb. Correction speed limit is 15.

0:13:47
Ashley Flowers

The officer pulls over and gets out of the car.

0:13:53
Speaker 2

You want to place your vehicle into park and go ahead and turn it off for me? No, park? Oh, it is in parking. Okay, turn off your engine. Go ahead and set your keys on the dash for me, all right? What's your guys' names? Gabby. Gabby, Brian, okay. What's going on? How come you're crying? I'm just crying. We've just been fighting this morning. Some personal issues. It was a long day. We were camping yesterday and camping got supplies and stuff.

0:14:22

I'm sorry I hit the bump there. I was distracting him from driving. I'm sorry. Can I get you to step out of the vehicle for me, ma 'am? Yeah! Just hang tight right there. Do you mind if I take your keys and just put them on your hood? You got it. I'm so sorry. Thank you. Oh, no, you're fine.

0:14:45
Ashley Flowers

At this point, the officer wants to get Gabby and Brian separated. So he asks Gabby to get out of the car and takes her away to talk to her in private.

0:14:55
Speaker 2

You want to tell me what's going on? Yeah, I don't know. It's just, some days I have really bad OCD. And I just, I was just cleaning and spading up the back of the van before. And I was apologizing to him and saying, I'm sorry that I'm so mean. because sometimes I have OCD and sometimes I just get really frustrated. Not like me and Lauren's time. I just like... I guess my vibe is like... I'm in a bad mood.

0:15:24

And I was just saying, I'm sorry if I'm in a bad mood. I'm just really stressed. I had so much work I was doing on my computer this morning. What do you do for a living? Well, I hate sport getting an all-organic juice bar, but I just hit my job. I was a nutritionist. That's what I did. That's cool. I just did my job to travel across the country and I'm trying to start a blog.

0:15:48

Okay. So I've been building my website so I've been really stressed and he doesn't really believe that I could do any of it. So that's kind of been like a, I don't know, he's like down there, I don't know, we'd have been fighting one morning and he wouldn't let me in the car before. Why wouldn't he let you in the car? Because of your OCD? He told me I needed to calm down. Yeah. But I'm perfectly calm.

0:16:12

I'm calm all the time. And he really stresses me out. And I just, this is a rough morning. Well.

0:16:21
Ashley Flowers

At this point, the officer says, listen, have a seat in my car. You're not in trouble. Just take a breath. I'm going to go talk to Brian. And he brings Brian out of the car. And same thing, says, you're not in trouble right now. Just tell me what's going on.

0:16:36
Speaker 2

Come on over here. You're not in any trouble right now. So, tell me what's going on. The seat just gets worked up sometimes, and I try and really distance myself from her, so I lock the car and I walk away from her. What happened this morning is that she's trying to start up her own little website blog and everything, so I give her time. We really had a nice morning, if anything, but she just worked up because we were trying to get going and get our day going because you want to go like hard to play this up at the time.

0:17:06

Okay. You want to tell me about those scratches on your face? She had a cell phone in her hand. That's why I was pushing her away. Because I, she wanted, I locked the keys so I could walk away. I said, let's just take a breather and let's not, you know, go anywhere, let's just calm down for a minute. She's doing a little workup. And then she had her phone and was trying to get the push through and she was batting away.

0:17:25

I was just trying to, I know I shouldn't push her, but I was just trying to push her away. You know, let's just take a minute, step back and breathe. and we see she got me a purple. Can I see your hand? No, you got a mark right here. Oh, that's from a wire. That's from a wire? Yeah. You want to tell me about hitting that curve? Hitting the curve was her grabbing the wheel. She grabbed the wheel?

0:17:44

Yeah. She said, I can't believe we're getting pulled over. And then she grabbed the wheel. What about the speed? Did she take over the pedal on you? No, I'm sorry. If I was going fast, I'm sorry. No, it was probably just the moment of like, I'm still shaking now. The adrenaline, seeing the lights flashing up, and then her grabbing the wheel. So if I sped up, I'm sorry about that. Or if I was speeding beforehand, I'm sorry about that.

0:18:03

Yeah, she's going to do quite a bit to catch up to you.

0:18:07
Ashley Flowers

He has him sit on the curb while the officer runs a check on Brian. Another officer is also talking to Gabby in the car, and you can hear them in the background of this body cam. She's admitting to hitting him and says that he grabbed her by the face, but she says he didn't hit her. At this point, the officer with the body cam comes back, and they start to ask Gabby about why she and Brian hit the curb when they were getting pulled over.

0:18:32

Had they been drinking?

0:18:34
Speaker 2

Did you already tell him all this? I didn't get that far into it. She was hyperventilating a little bit. She's saying that they don't drink, but at the point when you lit them up. They don't drink or anything. She started hitting it. I was yelling at him, and then when you turned to her, I said I kind of punched him. She said she was saying he hit the curb. You said it was Gabby? No. I'm sorry, everyone's got a name.

0:18:56

It was Gabby.

0:18:57
Ashley Flowers

There's some audio redacted here, and it cuts in and out. But basically, one of the officers goes on to ask her about her anxiety. And she says, yes, she has anxiety, stress, and OCD. They ask her, how is Brian? Is he pretty patient with you? And she says, well, you know, he definitely gets frustrated. A chunk more of the audio is cut out, and it comes back with the officer telling Gabby about his own personal experience in a bad relationship, where he says, listen, And I'm not telling you what to do with your life, but look at the situation.

0:19:28

And if you both are feeding off one another and making it worse, maybe this isn't the best. They leave Gabby at that point and go back to talk to Brian again. They ask him, start at the beginning, tell them the whole story again, and start further back.

0:19:44
Speaker 2

Well, I don't want to go too far back, but we've been in Bionland for the past week or so. and the flies here are pretty intense, so the flies have definitely been getting to her. And then my feet are dirty and everything, so I think our little squabble started because we were hanging out at the coffee shop and when we got back to the bin there was some dirt and stuff to ban and I moved our food around as a little disorganized so she gets a little...

0:20:09

So it was just more of a disagreement in that I just wanted to... What was the disagreement about? It was... I wouldn't even call it a disagreement. It was just that I'm dirty and I can't change being dirty like I got dirty feet. I got sand on my football tops and stuff like that. It was that we were at the coffee shop for so long, because we were there from 9 to 3. So there's a few little things, just little relationships.

0:20:31

I don't know if you have a relationship, but I'm sure you have. I've been married for over 5 years now. There's a lot of little things. And we, I get it. We weren't physically before the point where I said, alright, let's just take a breather and walk away for a minute. and I'll walk the van up and I'll go for a walk this way and you can go walk that way in the block. You know, there's that moon, what is it called?

0:20:53

Moonflower? You know, nice areas. You can go either way, it's all shaded. So I just go for a little walk and breathe and come back. You know, we're happy with that. But she's, I'm not upset with her. She worked up and she had her phone in her hand and her keys and everything. She wanted, not her keys, her rings, her things, her phone. And I was holding on to the keys because I just, I didn't want to go anywhere.

0:21:15

and my big tears, I don't have my phone, I don't really, I don't have a phone, so she goes off without me. But I'm, all right, I'm on my own. So I was saying, let's just go for one, because she was trying to get the keys from me, so I just went, hey, just wait, back up, back up, and then she hit me, and I didn't get, I don't want to push you, but I didn't get, I didn't get overtly physical, I was just trying to keep her away and not get hit.

0:21:39

And then I got really loud, and I guess probably threw everyone's attention where I was going, you know, Back up, get away, just give me a... Okay, so you said you pushed her to create some distance, obviously, right? What happened after that? What got the scratches on your hand? The phone. The phone. So you pushed her and she hit you? She was... It wasn't like a push when she jumped on me. She was already... She was already...

0:22:03

I don't know. She was already swinging. A lot of angles, a lot of nails, a lot of rings. Yeah, you got... Three scratches on your neck. You got one on your left side of your neck. You've got one in your face here, and you've got four for the weaving over there. So you just try it out. It looks like two hands. Do you mind lifting up your right sleeve for me? I'm curious about something. I'm fine, and I love you.

0:22:23

I hope she doesn't have too many complaints about me. I'm just, you know, I feel bad after it gets so public. I was just trying to be loud and serious and useless. You know, I just try to make her calm down and be like, look, everyone's watching.

0:22:37
Ashley Flowers

The new Peacock original limited series, The Good Daughter, is a suspenseful thriller wrapped in an emotional story about love, family, and resilience. Rose Byrne and Megan Fahey star as sisters who have spent the last 20 years trying to piece together their lives after a single night of violence. When another attack splinters their small town, the sisters, now both lawyers like their father, become embroiled in the case. As the case unfolds and twists through painful memories and buried secrets, What emerges is not just a story of survival, but of enduring ties between a father and his daughters and the complex bond between sisters.

0:23:16

Based on the bestseller by Karen Slaughter, The Good Daughter is streaming November 12th only on Peacock. Let's face it. If student loans are slowing down your financial goals, it might be time for a smarter strategy. That's where today's sponsor SoFi comes in. SoFi is helping you tackle student debt by refinancing your loans with flexible monthly payments that fit your budget. We're talking about the potential to lower your interest rate, reduce your monthly payment, or even pay off your loan sooner depending on the term you choose.

0:23:45

You can also consolidate your student loans into one simple monthly payment so you could save more each month and work towards achieving your long-term financial ambitions. SoFi offers competitive, fixed and variable rates and no origination fees, prepayment fees, or late fees required. It takes just two minutes to check your rate with SoFi, and they have already helped over 500 ,000 members refinance more than $50 billion in student loans. Visit SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie to see how much you can save.

0:24:12

That's SoFi.com slash Crime Junkie and start making smarter money moves with SoFi. SoFi student loans are originated by SoFi Bank, N.A. member FDIC. Additional terms and conditions apply. NMLS 696891. 9-1. They ask Brian if he takes any medications or anything like that. Again, there's a chunk redacted, but it comes back in with them saying, so you don't take any, and he shakes his head, and the officers ask if he's normally this hyper, and he just says that, you know, his adrenaline is going because of this interaction with police.

0:24:44

He mentions Gabby doesn't take any medications either. Now, in the meantime, while this is going on, another officer is making contact with the witness from back at the co-op, the person who actually called this altercation to begin with. He got him on the phone to see if he could confirm the story they were hearing from Gabby and from Brian. And he did.

0:25:08
Speaker 2

He said that he never saw the male strike the female. He saw the male trying to lock her out of the vehicle. She even told us that he was trying to lock her out, told her to go take a walk. so that she was trying to get in. She eventually couldn't get in and actually clawed her way in through the driver's door. He says, I don't understand why she's doing that. Well, I think it's because it was the only door that wasn't locked that she could get through.

0:25:30

She's trying to get in over him. He's trying to disengage from her. I guess he hung her backpack on the back probably so she'd have her shit so that he didn't have to engage with her. Everything she's saying is the same thing. I haven't heard what he said, but if that's what he said, it's also what the witness is saying. The witness says, I never saw him hit her. I saw him shove her, but I couldn't tell if it was an aggression against her or a defense against her, as far as her, you know, being the aggressor.

0:25:56

So at this point, unless the guy's screaming that he needs to go to jail and did something to this girl, it sounds to me like she is the primary aggressor. Now, the problem with her being the primary aggressor is in an instance of domestic assault, be it a male or be it a female, we shall arrest. Now, that doesn't necessarily mean they have to go to jail. We can do a citation if it meets one of three criteria, which one of them is making sure that they're not going to further risk each other's safety.

0:26:30

But the problem with that is they live in the same vehicle. That's what I was going to say. The other part of it is... There was actually an injury, too, to the victim, which is him. Right. And I'm getting conflicting stories about why they hit the curb up here. What did he say, why he hit the curb? Well, I've watched this is what I saw first saw him cross the double yellow. I was doing 42 miles an hour I was I don't know probably two car lengths behind him Tapping my whales at him trying to get his attention.

0:26:56

They knew I was behind him And then after he crossed the double yellow merged over into the right lane and then out of nowhere just He said that she grabbed the wheel and turned it real hard. She said that she was hitting him in the arm So, I'm sure if I'm driving and my arms on the wheel and I'm getting hit in the arm, I'm probably pulling at the wheel. And I'm sure it was a little of both.

0:27:23

I'm using the truth somewhere between. He's probably trying not to say that he hit her because he probably doesn't want her charged with assault, domestic assault. He probably would rather say she pulled the wheel than hit him. You know what I mean? So, fortunately for her, we cannot, just because he's bigger and stronger, even if he's not

0:27:44
Ashley Flowers

They go on to talk about charging Gabby with assault. Even though she's smaller, she appears to have been the aggressor. So they go to explain this to Brian, saying, listen, we don't, like, have the ability to, like, use discretion for domestic assaults. Meaning we can't decide that, like, some people get charged and others don't just because of their sex or their size or how they look.

0:28:23
Speaker 2

I don't know. I don't want to take this small 20-year-old. 22-year-old. 22-year-old. You could definitely defend yourself against, but at the same time, we can't say because you're a male and she's a female, we can't treat this differently than if you and a male hit her. We got treated the same. But she's kind of in a tough spot. So unless you have an idea about how she could not go to jail and be separated, you have friends in town, somewhere she could stay, tomorrow if you want to, it's up to you.

0:29:03

You can go to jail. You can't because you'll have to charge for me. Now tomorrow, if you wanted to be with her again tomorrow. I'm going to take your radio. If you want to be with her again tomorrow, because it's after 5, so office is closed. You can go to the police department and fill out a waiver to drop the no contact door so you guys can still get together. She's going to have a court date online.

0:29:26
Ashley Flowers

After some back and forth and making some calls and more discussion, the officers wonder if this is more a mental health break than anything. So they go talk to Gabby one more time. She's on the phone in the car with one of her family members when they do.

0:29:44
Speaker 2

Gabby, this is a very, very important question. How you answer this question is going to determine what happens next. But the only person who can answer this question is you. Think very hard before you answer the question. Do not quickly answer. Think very hard. When you slapped him those times, were you attempting to cause him physical pain or physical impairment? Was that what you were attempting to do? No. What were you attempting to do? What was the reason behind the slapping and stuff?

0:30:21

What was it you were attempting to accomplish by slapping? I was trying to get him to stop telling him to come down. Well, it doesn't sound to me like she attempted to injure her. It's your call. This is 100 % your call. I support you either way.

0:30:39
Ashley Flowers

The officers go off and have a little sidebar where they seem to be having a discussion about who's going to take who. And then something is said that echoes in my mind.

0:30:51
Speaker 2

You got this? I'm making this decision. I'm going to cite anything. I'm going to go through the first. Would you feel more comfortable handling that guy? Yeah. Go handle that guy. Go handle that guy. Go handle that guy. If you're more comfortable. Well, it's six one way, half dozen. I mean, it's a headache whether I go left or it's a headache whether I go right. Another option is to not charge them, but separate them through the night.

0:31:16

If they find themselves together again, what is it to you? You separate them. You provide it for safety.

0:31:21
Ashley Flowers

If they find themselves together, what is it to you? That's what he said that stays with me. Now, he goes on to explain this a little bit more. And from the way one officer is talking to the other, it sounds like he's training him, like this other guy might be new on the job. And he's not saying it like, F them, it doesn't matter. He says, you have to abide by the law. You can't give them a warning like, hey, you know, if you call one more time, someone's going to jail because then if they need police and they don't call, something worse could happen.

0:31:52

So he's basically letting the officer know how to think of it, that if you don't do anything, if no charges are filed, you have to be okay letting them go and the rest is on them. Are you okay with that? And the officer was. Ultimately, he wrote up in his report that this was a mental health break. The couple separated for the night. Brian went to a hotel and Gabby took the van. now Gabby's dad said he can't bring himself to watch the whole thing and he said it doesn't matter anyways because that happened days if not a week before she actually went missing so he said he needs to stay focused on finding her right now but I think

0:32:36

the family wasn't as shocked by the release of this footage as we in the public might have been because they already knew about it in the body cam footage again Gabby asked for her phone to call her family she's on the phone with them when they come back to the car at one point. So her family knew that they had trouble. And her dad made a statement to Fox News that he was told not to talk about his quote previous relationship with Brian, which to me doesn't imply that they had a good one.

0:33:05

And Brian might not have had a good relationship with anyone in Gabby's life because a friend of Gabby's named Rose came forward and told the Daily Mail quote, he's got these jealousy issues and he's struggles from what Gabby called these episodes, where he would hear things and hear voices and wouldn't sleep. Gabby had to stay at my house a bunch of times because she just needed a breather and didn't want to go home to him. When I saw that Brian was back from the trip, that was the first thing that popped into my mind, that Brian had one of his episodes, and I was just hoping he didn't have a snapping moment.

0:33:42

End quote. So we all thought that this is where we would wait for a while, intently looking at Brian and his family to say something and tell police where to start looking. But we just learned that police can't press Brian anymore because no one knows where he is. The new Peacock original limited series The Good Daughter is a suspenseful thriller wrapped in an emotional story about love, family, and resilience. Rose Byrne and Megan Fahey star as sisters who have spent the last 20 years trying to piece together their lives after a single night of violence.

0:34:24

When another attack splinters their small town, the sisters, now both lawyers like their father, become embroiled in the case. As the case unfolds and twists through painful memories and buried secrets, what emerges is not just a story of survival, but of enduring ties between a father and his daughters and the complex bond between sisters. Based on the bestseller by Karen Slaughter, The Good Daughter is streaming November 12th only on Peacock. It was reported by CNN that the Northport police spokesperson said, quote, According to the family, he'd been missing since Tuesday.

0:35:17

Tuesday! And they're telling police on Friday. But according to reporting by ABC7, Gabby's family says, no, there is a difference. Brian isn't missing. Our daughter is the one who's missing. And they think he knows something. They think Brian is hiding, which to them is very different than missing. So police organized a search that is happening literally right now as I am recording this episode to scour more than 24 ,000 acres, according to ABC7's Eyewitness News team.

0:35:49

Police think he went to an area known as the Carlton Reserve sometime early this week. But at this point, they don't know any more. And at the same time, according to Newsweek, the FBI has extended its search through Grand Teton National Park into Wyoming. Now, apparently, where they're searching for Brian came from, I believe, scent dogs. So when they went to his house, they actually pulled out bags of clothes to use in a search for him.

0:36:16

So I'm thinking that that is what led them to this particular area that they're searching rather than information from his family. Because, I mean, again, we know that his family hasn't cooperated. So I doubt that they're saying anything more if they know it. And if they are saying where to look, I would almost discount anything they said because they're not cooperating. And at this point, if things weren't twisty enough, have you guys seen TikTok? There was a video that blew up of this girl who said that she and her boyfriend picked up Brian hitchhiking on August 29th in Grand Teton.

0:36:53

Here's the audio from user at Miranda Baker underscore.

0:37:23
Speaker 2

at 554. This is off my mom's because my texts just don't go back this far. Um, and then, you know, it says we dropped him off at 600. So this is where we picked him up. We picked him up in Colter Bay and we dropped him off, um, by this dam. He was hitchhiking. There was no van. Gabby was not with him. It was just him. So this is what the dam looked like. We dropped him off at the turnout because this is going south.

0:37:50

If you're going like this. He then said, I'm going to get out. I'm going to hitchhike, find a different ride. He said he was going to go across to the parking lot over here, which was filled with a bunch of people. Again, this is on August 29th at 609. So this is a map of Grand Teton National Park. During our ride, he said, well, before he got in the car, he said, I wanted to go to Jackson.

0:38:13

So this, okay, this is Jackson. Like right there, you can see it says Jackson, south of the park, right? Jackson, Jackson Hole is commonly referred to as well. So I said, you know what? We're going to Jackson. Hop in. You know, he was very nice. He offered us $200 to give him this ride. And we picked him up. You can see here, Colter Bay right there. It's like pretty north of the park. And he said he was hiking along Snake River, which is up here.

0:38:40

And it kind of like goes down a little bit. And he said he was gone for multiple days. And he had left his fiancee, never called her by her name, back at their campsite, which he said they camped in a dispersed campsite, so it's not a regulated campsite. And he was gone for multiple days without her, and he was sleeping on a tarp. When we picked him up, he had a backpack, long sleeves, a hat on, and scruff.

0:39:06

He wasn't clean shaved, and he had hiking boots on, but he didn't look dirty. The only thing dirty about him were his shoes. and he was very nice during the trip, you know, very calm. We were making small talk. He was agitated when I said Jackson Hole, okay? So we were going south to Jackson. There's no other place in the Tetons called Jackson. Why he, like, became agitated, I don't know. He just was very set on getting out of the car, which is why we pulled out by the dam And that's why he got out.

0:39:45

I don't know why he wanted to get out so bad. I don't know what other place he wants to go to because there's only one Jackson. So that's all I have. And I hope she's returned safely and they find her safe.

0:39:58
Ashley Flowers

This was all the reminder I needed of how important it is for everyone to talk about missing persons cases, whether your reach is big or small. She realized it was him who had been in her car from TikTok videos. not from the big news outlets, from TikTok. According to Peter Aitken's reporting for Fox News, police confirmed that this user had been in contact with them, and they are, quote, potentially utilizing her info into our timeline, end quote.

0:40:30

What I find so interesting is that sometime in that hour and 17-minute body cam footage, if you listen to the whole thing, Brian at one point says he doesn't have money for a hotel when they're talking about splitting him up and he needs to stay in a hotel for a night. He's like, I don't have enough money. So how did he have $200 to offer them for this ride? And why did he suddenly freak out as Miranda says, like, oh, we're going to the exact place you need to go to.

0:40:57

Now, even the timeline is tight. If this is the 29th and then we know he's home with the van on September 1st, that doesn't leave him a lot of time. And my biggest question is, why is he hitching rides if he has the van? And Gabby's already gone like so many people suspect. Of course, even though Britt's not on this episode, her and I were talking about it. And we've seen theories that maybe he was trying to get back to the van after coming from wherever Gabby might be.

0:41:27

I don't know. But I have to think that police are at least considering this claim to be legitimate because their quote that they're potentially using it seems promising to me. Otherwise, you would think that they would just disregard the sighting. Now, I have one last curveball to throw your way. As of this morning, September 19th, Mia.com posted an article that I found really interesting. According to the author, Kunal Day, Gabby's AllTrails app, which she had been using to kind of like log her journey or at least like check in a few places, is now saying that she's in Puerto Rico.

0:42:03

And I don't even know how to process that. I looked at her profile, which, to be fair, everyone is assuming is her profile because it has her name and then some checked in places that look consistent with her travels. But there's no picture and it doesn't have a ton of info. And I can't even tell when the location was changed to Puerto Rico. Of course, the Internet is in a frenzy that maybe Brian is there with her phone and anything's possible.

0:42:30

I mean, I would encourage our listeners in Puerto Rico to keep an eye out just in case. But my gut says he's still in Florida. And those listeners need to have their eyes peeled. And same for our listeners, you know, around Grand Teton and literally across the country. So that is where you come in and why I decided to do this episode. Yes, everyone is talking about it. But if this story can reach the one person who didn't know about Gabby or Brian, like that girl on TikTok, maybe this will help.

0:43:02

I'm going to have pictures of their van up online, pictures of both of them. Please take a look. The link is right in the show notes. And if you're in our app, the pictures have been coming up all along as you've been listening to this episode. So if you remember even just seeing something in passing that maybe didn't mean much at the time, call police. Their info is in the show notes as well. I'm not willing to write Gabby off.

0:43:28

She could still be out there in need of help and time is precious. And please take a minute to do an updated search of your own after this episode. Literally, since writing this, new information has come out every hour that I've had to work into this script. And I'm confident there will be an update in the hours it takes to edit and publish this. Definitely, there will be updates if you're listening to this a couple of days later.

0:43:51

And while I have your attention, there's another woman out there who needs your help, whose case hasn't even gotten a fraction of the coverage Gabby's has. and time is precious for her as well. And we're already behind. Her name is Lauren Cho, but her friends called her Elle. Elle, like Gabby, had this dream of kind of starting over, driving across country in a van, being on the road. So she hopped in a tour bus with her friend, who she used to date, named Corey, and they drove from New Jersey to California, where they were staying in this like Airbnb situation with a bunch of other artists.

0:44:30

Elle was a chef, and while she was out there, according to Stacey Moore's reporting for High Desert Star, she, quote, bought an old school bus and was converting it into a food truck, end quote. But all her dreams seemed to have come to a crashing halt on June 28. That's when she walked out of the place that she was staying at 3 p.m. and was never seen again. Her friends didn't know where she was going.

0:44:56

According to a statement Corey gave Stacey Moore, quote, She was apparently trying to take her car at the time, but she didn't have the keys. She had an intention to go somewhere, and I know she was dating again, end quote. He talked more about her dating, saying that he knew that she'd gone out with someone previously, but he didn't ask who. And of course, now he's kicking himself that he didn't. Because in like the 10-minute window when they weren't together, she walked out and he hasn't seen her since.

0:45:26

Now, something felt wrong to him right away about her walking away. Again, you know, if I didn't see my friend in 10 minutes, maybe I wouldn't freak out. But he was freaking out. He immediately started looking for her and even got a group of friends to go out towards the mountains and trails in the direction he saw her walking to look for her. But they couldn't find anything. After a couple of hours, like at 5.13, they were calling the sheriff for help.

0:45:50

Now, because of how little reporting there is out there on this case, I don't have a ton of background about what happened before she walked out. But there was a reason for everyone being so frightened so quickly. According to Jake and Gracia's reporting for News Channel 3, Elle had made some comments about self-harm before walking out the door that day. So there was an urgency in looking for her. But when the sheriffs got out there, they found something interesting.

0:46:20

Quote, they found all of my tracks and my friend's tracks, but none of hers. End quote. And that was a quote from Corey. Corey and the others wonder if she got in a car with someone. Maybe that's someone who she was seeing, or maybe she even hitchhiked. In the early days, everyone hoped that this was some big misunderstanding, like she didn't even know people were looking for her. According to High Desert Star, quote, quote, sheriff's calls show others claim to see her with a man at a restaurant in Yucca Valley, end quote.

0:46:53

But nothing seems to have materialized from that. The sheriff's office did searches in the first two days, but after no one found anything, those were called off. They tried again on July 24th, even with a plane, but again, they found nothing. And at that point, Elle had been missing for almost a month. On July 31st though, instead of searching out in the wilderness, investigators started looking a little closer to Lauren's home base because they served what we now know was a second search warrant on that Saturday at 6 a.m.

0:47:26

to where Elle was living. But since that update, which came in early August, there has been nothing. Even in the month she was missing. There were only three or four news articles. So if there's a chance that she is out there and just doesn't know people are looking for her, how is it going to get to her? I am glad that Gabby is getting national attention to help find her. And I'm glad that literally every outlet has a story on her.

0:47:57

Her and her family deserve that. But I think Elle and every other missing person deserves that too. We need to get this on TikTok and social media because there's another missing woman for whom time is precious. Anyone with information about Lauren Cho is asked to call Detective Shaunna Ables at the Sheriff's Station 760-366-4175. There's a reference number in our show notes. And anyone with information about Gabby Petito is asked to contact the FBI tip line at 1-800-CALL-FBI.

0:48:30

That's 1-800-225-5324. And if you want to contribute to! Gabby's family's GoFundMe to help with their investigative efforts, a lot of that is going to travel as they make trips across the country to search for their daughter. There is an approved GoFundMe by the family linked in our show notes and on the website, but please make sure to use the link as there are a number of fraudulent pages out there right now trying to exploit the tragedy.

0:48:58

Again, I encourage you all set your Google alerts, look for follow-up. This case is breaking as we speak and I hope that there will be an update soon where we can finally get some answers and find out where Gabby Petito is. You can find all the source material for this episode on our website, CrimeJunkiePodcast.com. Don't forget to follow us on Instagram at Crime Junkie Podcast. And I want to give a huge thank you to my brother and sister, David Flowers and Alyssa Flowers.

0:49:41

They are both here in the office with me on a Sunday, pulling this episode together for you guys. It is a true family operation. It is making me feel like it is, you know, the OG days, like when we first started. I can't thank them enough for coming in and getting it done. I owe them a huge, huge thank you. So thank you, guys. And thank you to the fuzzy guy who keeps me going, our other family member.

0:50:05

What do you think, Chuck? Do you approve? Coca-Cola. For the big. For the small. The short. And the tall. Peacemakers. risk takers for the optimists pessimists for long distance love for introverts and extroverts the thinkers and the doers for old friends and new coca-cola for everyone pick up some coca-cola at a store near you