OpenNashPodcasts

Everything is Logistics

The Logistics of SHEIN: From Imports to Influencers

10 Sep 2024 · 44m · Blythe Brumleve, Grace Sharkey · 20 quoted facts

▶ Play episodeOriginal source ↗

In brief

Shein and Temu now account for roughly 30% of e-commerce shipments entering the US West Coast, and because parcels under $800 enter tax-free, customs agencies cannot inspect more than a sliver of them. The hosts argue this flood of cheap goods creates a fraud and enforcement problem that officials are only starting to manage with data tools. It also raises ethical questions about how consumers, influencers and companies share responsibility for the fast-fashion supply chain.

The episode moves from the customs story to a consumer-ethics debate. After influencers took a Shein-sponsored trip to China and were attacked online, the hosts say the blame is misplaced and sits mainly with large corporations. They also admit they shop cheap when they need clothes quickly. The tension is between wanting ethical sourcing and having little visibility into supply chains, which leaves consumers exhausted and inconsistent.

Key insights

  1. Customs can only inspect a tiny share of parcels

    Grace Sharkey says CBP (US Customs and Border Protection) cannot open every small package after e-commerce boomed around 2018. It now relies on data firms such as Altana to point it at the riskiest shipments.

  2. Sham importers show how easy paperwork fraud is

    In Operation Mirage, as Grace tells it, only about 55% of 150 textile importers checked in China were real. Some were just a person who rented out their address for a small payment per transaction.

  3. Shein's strength is logistics and influencer marketing

    Grace points to Shein's buy-now-pay-later tools, reverse logistics through Narvar's 200,000-plus drop-off points, tracking tools and loyalty rewards. She says these help it compete with US retailers and keep deliveries fast.

  4. The influencer backlash targeted the wrong party

    Blythe argues the influencers took far more heat than Shein itself. She says big corporations benefit when responsibility is pushed onto shoppers who cannot easily trace supply chains.

  5. Fast fashion carries heavy environmental costs

    The hosts cite polyester shedding microplastics, textile dyeing accounting for about 20% of global wastewater, and shoppers buying a new garment every five days. They cite a YouTube video for some of these figures and offer thrifting and wool brands as alternatives.

Questions

Why do Shein and Temu packages enter the US with so little inspection?

The hosts say shipments valued under $800 enter tax-free, and the volume is huge, with Shein and Temu making up about 30% of West Coast e-commerce shipments. Grace says customs cannot open every small package, so it uses data tools to pick which ones to check.

What was Operation Mirage?

Grace describes it as a customs effort where agents visited the addresses of about 150 top textile importers in China. Only around 55% turned out to be real, and others were just people lending out their homes for fees.

Why were influencers criticized after visiting Shein in China?

They toured Shein operations on a trip the company arranged and then defended it, and critics said they ignored concerns about labor and sourcing. Influencer Danny Carbonari said the trip was unpaid for posts, but that she should have researched more.

Is Shein trying to go public in the US?

Blythe says Shein is trying to IPO (sell shares to the public) in the US. Grace thinks it has paused because of an uproar from elected representatives, since a smooth listing needs fewer legal fights.

What can shoppers do if they want to buy more ethically?

The hosts suggest buying vintage or thrifted clothing, using a ratings site for brand sourcing, and considering durable wool brands such as Sheep Inc. Grace adds that people who criticize Shein should avoid ordering from it and could contact their elected representatives.

Facts

Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.

Blythe Brumleve says shipments valued under $800 enter the United States tax-free.

“as long as those shipments are valued at under $800, it ships into this country tax-free”

0:00:47 · Blythe Brumleve · Import rules

Grace Sharkey says Janet Labuda consults on customs policy for Maersk after about 25 years at US Customs and Border Protection.

“works as a consultant for customs uh policy for maersk and she had spent most of her career i think 25 years of it working for uh the customs border protection”

0:02:17 · Grace Sharkey · Customs careers

Grace Sharkey says Operation Mirage involved US Customs and Border Protection examining about 150 of the top textile importers.

“So this is when she was working textiles for CBP and they took like 150 of the top textile importers.”

0:03:03 · Grace Sharkey · Operation Mirage

Grace Sharkey says only about 55% of the 150 textile importers checked in China were legitimate.

“only 55 % of those 150, I believe, importers were legit. The other half were just like a woman in a house.”

0:03:33 · Grace Sharkey · Import fraud

Grace Sharkey says one woman paid per transaction for lending her address to a Chinese importer earned about $10,000 a month.

“I provide them my address. I get a penny per transaction. And this woman had made like $10 ,000 a month”

0:04:06 · Grace Sharkey · Import fraud

Grace Sharkey says around 2018 the rise of e-commerce small packages led CBP to start planning how to control imports.

“I think 2018, e-commerce started to be a big deal. And the CBP was like, we need to address this.”

0:04:46 · Grace Sharkey · E-commerce enforcement · 2018

Grace Sharkey says about two milligrams of fentanyl is a lethal dose, and customs once caught over five pounds of it.

“a drop of fentanyl will like kill you it's two milligrams i think is lethal dose”

0:06:08 · Grace Sharkey · Drug seizures

Blythe Brumleve says she tried the Temu app after seeing its Super Bowl commercial.

“they had, you know, that Superbowl commercial and I was like, Oh, you know, let me, let me try it out.”

0:07:22 · Blythe Brumleve · Temu marketing

Blythe Brumleve says shirts that cost roughly $8 to $10 are listed by resellers for around $30.

“We're talking like anywhere from like $8 to $10 for a shirt that you'll see on a lot of different e-com shops, Amazon shops that those shops will list it for around $30.”

0:12:38 · Blythe Brumleve · Fast fashion pricing

Grace Sharkey says Shein flew the influencers to China for the factory trip.

“they did fly them to china so they did go”

0:14:47 · Grace Sharkey · Influencer trip

Grace Sharkey says Shein works with Narvar, a returns provider with over 200,000 drop-off locations.

“They work with a company called Narvar that has over 200 ,000 drop off locations.”

0:16:07 · Grace Sharkey · Reverse logistics

Grace Sharkey says Shein's plan for a US IPO has likely been paused because of objections from elected representatives.

“I think they put it on pause just because of the uproar from representatives, knowing that the fight's there.”

0:17:42 · Grace Sharkey · Shein IPO

Grace Sharkey says Shein is valued at over $100 billion, with the average buyer purchasing 14 items a year and 28% of US fashion sales going to it.

“they're valued at over $100 billion i think it's the average person has bought 14 items every year from them uh and 28 of u.s fashion sales is going to them as well”

0:21:57 · Grace Sharkey · Shein scale

A news report says influencer Danny Carbonari went on a Shein brand trip to Tahoe where she raised concerns with executives.

“She explains the company took her on a brand trip to Tahoe where she says she brought up many concerns and questions to the higher-ups.”

0:26:17 · Speaker 4 · Influencer trip

In a clip, the influencer says she and others were not paid for the China trip or to post, but their travel accommodations were covered.

“The trip, we were not paid for the trip. We were not paid to post. Our travel accommodations were taken care of.”

0:27:12 · Speaker 3 · Influencer disclosure

Blythe Brumleve, citing a YouTube video, says fast fashion began once clothing machines industrialized in the early 1900s.

“it wasn't until the early 1900s that these machines started being industrialized. And that's when fast fashion started.”

0:33:12 · Blythe Brumleve · Fast fashion history · early 1900s

Blythe Brumleve says about 70% of deep-sea animals have microplastics inside them and links this to plastic-based clothing fibers.

“deep sea ocean animals where like 70 % of the animals in like the deep sea have microplastics inside of them”

0:35:48 · Blythe Brumleve · Microplastics

Grace Sharkey says textile dyeing accounts for about 20% of global wastewater.

“actually 20% of global waste uh water comes from just the dying process itself”

0:36:14 · Grace Sharkey · Textile pollution

Blythe Brumleve says Sheep Inc. sends buyers a button that lets them trace the supply chain of their wool clothing, including the sheep it came from.

“they will send you a button with your wool clothing so you can see the entire supply chain of that product”

0:37:53 · Blythe Brumleve · Supply chain tracing

Blythe Brumleve says some overseas sellers copy American designers' designs and then use fake accounts to review-bomb or file takedowns against the originals.

“a lot of these companies will rip off the original design of American companies. And then they'll get all of these other shops or all of these other fake accounts to try to review bomb”

0:41:56 · Blythe Brumleve · Counterfeits

Chapters

  1. 0:00:47Temu and Shein dominate West Coast parcel flow

    The episode opens with the stat that frames everything else: a huge share of US e-commerce arrives tax-free from two Chinese platforms.

    “all e-commerce shipments coming into the West Coast of the United States”
  2. 0:03:33Operation Mirage and sham importers

    Grace recounts a customs story showing how many importers were fronts, which explains why fraud is hard to catch.

    “only 55 % of those 150, I believe, importers were legit.”
  3. 0:05:18How customs uses data to cope with small parcels

    Because e-commerce volume exploded, agencies lean on technology firms to decide where to look.

    “Altana Technologies is one, Boxee is another one that I've talked to in the past”
  4. 0:08:23Blythe's Temu cart experience

    A personal anecdote shows how app design and low product quality shape the Temu experience.

    “it opened up a separate cart from the one I already had”
  5. 0:11:39The Shein influencer trip controversy

    The hosts set up why influencers who toured a Shein operation drew backlash.

    “a bunch of influencers were invited to visit a factory”
  6. 0:16:07Shein's technology and marketing machine

    Grace explains the logistics and loyalty investments behind Shein's speed and low prices.

    “they're deep into buy now, pay later systems. Their reverse logistics is pretty huge.”
  7. 0:20:36Who should carry the ethical burden

    Blythe argues corporations, not individual shoppers or influencers, should be held to account for supply-chain ethics.

    “it's in their best interest to put the onus on the consumer”
  8. 0:27:12The influencer's response clip

    A played news clip gives the influencer's side and prompts the hosts' reaction.

    “We were not paid to post. Our travel accommodations were taken care of.”
  9. 0:36:14The environmental cost of fast fashion

    The hosts cover polyester, dyeing, and alternatives like thrifting and wool.

    “actually 20% of global waste uh water comes from just the dying process itself”
  10. 0:39:57Intellectual property and closing thoughts

    Grace raises design theft as another reason to think before buying.

    “are you also hurting the person that came up with this idea?”

Transcript

0:00:01
Blythe Brumleve

Navigating the complexities of the logistics industry is not for the weak. But you can stay ahead with Cargorex, your compass in logistics. Whether you're a researcher seeking trends, a leader forging partnerships, or a creator amplifying your voice, Cargorex simplifies it all. With advanced search tools, insight, analytics, and a community of innovators, Cargorex helps you explore, discover, and evolve. Don't just keep up with logistics, lead the way. Visit Cargorex.io and start your journey today. Welcome into another episode of Everything is Logistics, a podcast for the thinkers in freight.

0:00:47

I'm your host, Blythe Brumleve, and we are proudly presented by SPI Logistics. And in this episode, I want to resurface a couple of conversations around e-commerce and how one of those companies, Shein, dominates the discussion. Because 30 % of all e-commerce shipments coming into the West Coast of the United States belongs to Temu or Shein. 30%. And as long as those shipments are valued at under $800, it ships into this country tax-free. So in this first segment I have prepared for y 'all, we're going to be bringing up my good friend Grace Sharkey to talk about the influx of these shipments, how our Customs and Border departments are trying to keep up with it.

0:01:27

And then later on, we're going to get into the retail and influencer side of Shein's business practices. All of the talks that I went to were fantastic. One of yours in particular was the one on like AI and like customs and border trade. And I, I've said on this, on the series, you know, lots of times I am such an obsessed fan of To Catch a Smuggler. That's a show that comes on National Geographic. So I'm obsessed with like customs and border policies and like, you know, I just the flow of goods through country to country.

0:02:00

And you had a woman on your panel, Janet, I'm blanking on her last name, but I, she was like 70 years old talking about like adopting AI, talking about trade compliance. She stole the show. Like she was so brilliant during that talk. Do you have a little bit, I guess, maybe background

0:02:17
Grace Sharkey

or insight on her? Yeah. So she, Janet Labuda and for everyone out there, actually, I, my latest article on freight waves is about this panel so you can get some of the stories off of uh that from that blight's talking about uh she it works as a consultant for customs uh policy for maersk and she had spent most of her career i think 25 years of it working for uh the customs border protection so uh she the best way to explain it is like you know i think some people hear customs border CBP and they just think oh the people like checking our checking us out when we cross the border she made it like I think they should they

0:03:03

deserve a tv show I mean she like made it very like NCIS-y where it was like wow like you've seen some things in your life you know and one of my favorite stories and I talked about this in an article she's she talks about I don't know you You might have came in right after Operation Mirage where they took. So this is when she was working textiles for CBP and they took like 150 of the top textile importers.

0:03:33

And they wanted to prove that they were who they said they were, like see how how legit some of these importers were. So they they went to China. They went and visited all of the physical addresses on the paperwork for these imports. And only 55 % of those 150, I believe, importers were legit. The other half were just like a woman in a house. And then they're like, how does this work? How are you doing all this paperwork?

0:04:06

And she's like, I don't do any of it. I provide them my address. I get a penny per transaction. And this woman had made like $10 ,000 a month from like allowing the Chinese government to like use her location or the Chinese importer to use the location for fraud. So it's that is like and that's just like choosing 150. Like imagine all the importers that they see on a daily basis. Right. And here's the problem. And she brought, I actually brought it up because I knew exactly, I knew she knew what I was talking about.

0:04:46

But a couple of years ago, right, I think 2018, e-commerce started to be a big deal. And the CBP was like, we need to address this. So they, you can Google it. I actually have a link to it in the article. they came up with a plan to start figuring out how to get their control of all these imports and all these e-commerce, I mean, all these small packages, right? Like we can't open up every single one that there's no way, there's no way to prove that a lot of this is right.

0:05:18

So there's a number of tech companies, Altana Technologies is one, Boxee is another one that I've talked to in the past that works with Customs Board and the Department of Defense as well to help them figure out, okay, if this is the limited number of resources we have to watch for fraud, watch for drugs, watch for even like counterfeit goods, right? Then this is who you should target or these boxes is what you should be looking at and and helps them at least pinpoint where to start and it's just kind of funny to like you don't really think about it but all of the packages that are coming in right like they don't check every single one of them say

0:06:08

they don't even check they don't even have time to check all the trucks that come through the border so it's um there's one uh i talked about in the article but like there's one time they caught like five pounds like over five pounds of fentanyl and i know it doesn't sound like a lot but a drop of fentanyl will like kill you it's two milligrams i think is lethal dose so that comes out to potentially when killing close to a half a million people so um yeah it's uh it's pretty interesting and i like like i said she really like she's fascinating she started writing a book like on the plane to the event like she was reading us like

0:06:45

her first like paragraph and uh so i can't wait for this book to come out because i think it's gonna be

0:06:51
Blythe Brumleve

full of stories that's for sure and i think she too she had a mind-blowing stat of something like 30 of e-commerce shipments that are coming from china to the west coast are all from the the company Temu yes so Temu like the the gamified like shopping e-commerce app um it's kind of adjacent to uh xian kind of not really uh maybe a lot of the same technology everything like

0:07:18
Grace Sharkey

Yeah. And everything. It's like Groupon, right? Where it's like,

0:07:22
Blythe Brumleve

what's not on this site? Right. And it's one of those, it's one of those experiences that I've never felt like I was duped, like online shopping. Yeah. But Temu duped me. Yeah. I did the thing I, I, they had, you know, that Superbowl commercial and I was like, Oh, you know, let me, let me try it out. Let me download the app. And I downloaded the app and I started up a cart of just some, you know, obviously some knockoff things, um, that looked interesting, like the Dyson, uh, hair dryer that has like the five, uh, tools in one.

0:07:54

Like I got that thing. Um, I got, you know, a bunch of other things and it's crap. It's crap products. You really have to like look for, um, the good products and really just be willing to roll the dice on it. But anyways, I started up a, a cart of the things that I wanted. And then, you know, you, you do what you do. You leave the app and you don't buy anything yet. So I went to social media and I was browsing on there and I got an ad on Instagram for a few products that looked interesting from Temu.

0:08:23

And so I click on the ad, it opens up the app. What happened is that it opened up a separate cart from the one I already had. So I thought that I was adding things to my current cart. And when I saw the total price, I was like, oh my gosh, like that includes everything. That includes everything that I had just already added and the new stuff that was targeted to me in a social media post.

0:08:45

And I clicked order, purchase, and then I go back and find out that, no, they just created a separate cart for me altogether. So I thought that that was a little bit shady. And I didn't like that because it was definitely misleading. Have you bought anything from them?

0:09:02
Grace Sharkey

I've been on the app, but that's kind of like my thing. I'm like, I know this is just going to be destroyed once I get this. So no, unfortunately, I haven't followed through with a purchase for it yet, but I've gotten awfully close. And I will say I love watching Temu unboxings. They do those on Instagram as well.

0:09:25
Blythe Brumleve

but it's no buy the Dyson dupe. It is not good. No, not good. It's already getting returned. And you know how much of a hassle some of these companies are with, with their returns anyways. So that was a really good stat from, from Janet and her talk was incredible. I hope you have her on the show soon. She was just filled with like a wealth of knowledge. And what was so refreshing is that she's like, I'm a 70 year old woman.

0:09:51

And I think that AI is like the next big thing. Like she's already using it and her processes. And I was like, oh, thank God. We don't have some kind of doomer speech on AI and helping her do her job more efficiently. And the other two women on the panel were fantastic too. But Janet just sort of stood out to me as panel-wise, from all the panels that I saw, she was the most entertaining. So kudos to you.

0:10:17

Are you in freight sales with a book of business looking for a new home? Or perhaps you're a freight agent in need of a better partnership? These are the kinds of conversations we're exploring in our podcast interview series called the Freight Agent Trenches, sponsored by SPI Logistics. Now, I can tell you all day that SPI is one of the most successful logistics firms in North America who helps their agents with back office operations, such as admin, finance, IT, and sales.

0:10:43

But I would much rather you hear it directly from SPI's freight agents themselves. And what better way to do that than by listening to the experienced freight agents tell their stories behind the how and the why they joined SPI. Hit the freight agent link in our show notes to listen to these conversations, or if you're ready to make the jump, visit spi3pl.com. Now that you have a general idea of the massive amount of shipments coming into the U.S.

0:11:11

from these two companies, let's talk a little bit more about Shein. Last year, they and a bunch of influencers got in some hot water when the company tried to PR their way into good supply chain messaging. The internet doing what the internet does best was not going to let them or the influencers off the hook. So Grace and I are going to be talking about this story plus the moral dilemma of trying to shop in a world where everything is trying to kill you.

0:11:39

First topic though, fast fashion in the supply chain because there are a lot of Shein influencers right now that are in a lot of shit and sort of, I guess, you know, the too long didn't read, the too long didn't watch. This is making big waves and sort of like the fashion beauty landscape because a bunch of influencers were invited to visit a factory in, I think it was in Denver or around the Colorado area, or they were flown to China.

0:12:06

One of the two, I couldn't really grasp where they actually did the factory tour. I would be surprised if they did a factory tour Or in the United States, because I didn't know that Shein had any factories in the United States. So anyways, they took this trip. It was Shein, a little bit of backstory. They have some rumblings about their supply chain morals. They use low-cost labor, to put it mildly. They have factories staged all over the world where they can take advantage of low-cost labor.

0:12:38

and that is the reason why you can get very, very cheaply made clothes pretty fast and very cheap. We're talking like anywhere from like $8 to $10 for a shirt that you'll see on a lot of different e-com shops, Amazon shops that those shops will list it for around $30. So it just kind of, I guess it shines a light on their supplier system and where they're getting a lot of these clothing. So the influencers went there.

0:13:08

They looked at a lot of their different operations within a warehouse. And because of that, a lot of folks have come out and started commenting and targeting these influencers because they didn't know about or maybe they didn't know about some of their shady manufacturing policies. They just got a tour of a warehouse and got some behind the scenes footage. And now they're being blamed for Shein's, I guess, supply chain. So with all that said, Grace, I know you've done plenty of work on these types of stories.

0:13:43

So what is your early read on this one? SBI Logistics has been sponsoring this podcast since the day we went independent in January 2023. Their support has directly led to the growth of this show and the creator investments that we've been able to make. So if SBI supports a podcaster like me, imagine how they support their own freight agents. Don't believe me? Hear it directly from one of their agents like Tyn and Goothy. Or hear from Steve Burrows, who is one of my favorite podcast guests of all time, on how the impact of SPI's technology, financials, and support system helped his company.

0:14:25

This is just a fraction of the conversations we've had with SPI agents and their executive team. You can listen to all of these conversations over on the Everything is Logistics website, or if you're ready to make the jump from your current agency partner, visit spi3pl.com.

0:14:47
Grace Sharkey

uh i will say they they did and they did fly them to china so they did go okay okay i and i will say i have like uh i have mixed feelings because i've attempted this this same flight myself uh there's a big company out in china called jd.com and i've tried they they're like the amazon of china they've got like all robotics like warehouses and stuff like that and i have tried so hard to get close to their marketing team and i'm like and they're they did kind of the same thing uh years ago and so i was like if you're ever doing this again like the list just because i think i've never been to china i

0:15:29

think i would love it and uh uh hopefully i would be blind to whatever atrocities that are happening behind the scenes uh also i will say i i'm i bought from the the site once or twice and i've never been fully thrilled by the quality so at first i was like okay interested in seeing like maybe how i've done deep dives on their uh technology though they have a ton of investment that they've done uh in the past uh in particular that uh it's pretty interesting uh and

0:16:04
Blythe Brumleve

Are your algorithms really sophisticated?

0:16:07
Grace Sharkey

Yes. Yeah. I mean, they're deep into buy now, pay later systems. Their reverse logistics is pretty huge. They work with a company called Narvar that has over 200 ,000 drop off locations. They put a lot of money into the influencer side of things, right? um gaining that loyalty and retention really gamifying rewards for customers uh and for and for those influencers um they i know of big areas uh traceability visibility tools i think that's a lot of people will say right if i do buy from them uh it usually gets to me pretty quickly and it usually is they're pretty open to the delivery times and things of that nature so it is it's pretty interesting as a whole i

0:17:00

think where they're investing in making sure that they're competing really well with more of these uh u.s uh operations now uh how are they getting things done so fast and so cheap uh probably not great labor practices which is why everyone is really fighting against them uh when i say everyone i mean our elected representatives so So I guess she and girls, if you're out there in your eyes and you want to fight against it, reach out to your your your representatives and let them know to stop it.

0:17:34
Blythe Brumleve

But yeah, because they're trying to block the IP. She is trying to IPO in the United States, but they're blocking it, I think.

0:17:42
Grace Sharkey

Yeah, well, I think they put it on pause just because of the uproar from representatives, knowing that the fight's there. right? Whenever you want to go public, you want to make it as smooth as possible, aka pay less lawyers as much as possible. So I think that's part of the reason they're holding off for now. But yeah, a lot of representatives aren't happy that, and it makes sense. I mean, they are a powerful being. They're anti-competitive and the fact that you're using labor that no one else here is allowed to use so um yeah i guess i i wasn't surprised though that they brought in influencers it's a it's a pretty smart attempt to try to cover yourselves up

0:18:24

but i think what um happened right is that backlash on the influencer themselves knowing whether or not you saw any of it knowing okay well how's no one there asked the tough question of but you're also in china who's trying to ask tough questions that's it's like who's who gets trip to china it's like okay now that we're here and you know right everyone wants to pretend as if

0:18:47
Blythe Brumleve

they're an investigative journalist and it's no it is nobody does it more than like the keyboard warriors who see and i think that there's kind of like a few things going on i think that there's a little bit of jealousy going on from the commenters seeing somebody get advantage get um get get the advantages of you know getting flown out um going on these you know behind the scenes type tours and, you know, not having access to those sort of same opportunities.

0:19:17

And then also, you know, there's, you know, the geopolitical like struggles between the US and China is, that's another kind of play involved as well. And then there's, you know, the folks who are really passionate about the environment. So it's like all of these things that are coming together, and obviously labor laws as well, and, you know, ethical sourcing, which is just, it's kind of like exhausting at times so i don't blame like these in it because from like a greater point i there's a lot of responsibility that's put on the consumer to know these things to know the entire supply chain of these big conglomerates when sometimes you just need to dress in a few days you just need

0:20:01

something cheap in a few days So are you, you know, some days I'm not going to have my, you know, morality standards, you know, eyes wide open on every single thing that I'm doing. I just think that they're, they got a little, I think the overwhelming majority of these influencers got too much heat when that heat should be directed towards the company. because it's something like close to 71 companies or like the top 100 companies are responsible for 71 % of emissions since like the 1980s.

0:20:36

And it's these big corporations, it's in their best interest to put the onus on the consumer. And so if they make it challenging to find out the, I guess the morality and the ethical nature of the supply chain, if they put that on the consumer, then they can kind of wash their hands of it. And that's what's happening right now with these influencers because Shein is not coming in to help and defend them. They're getting blocked, like they're not getting blocked, but a lot of these influencers have turned their comments off.

0:21:11

They've deleted the posts. There's one girl in particular, which I should probably play the clip now. She seems to be the one that is getting a lot of the, I guess, ire of folks is being directed towards her. But she apparently I haven't seen the videos. Some of them were taken down. She deleted them because she was trying to like double down on her message of like, I met with them behind closed doors in Denver. And I think that's where Denver comes from.

0:21:37

So she met with she and people in Denver to kind of talk about some of those ethical issues. And she said that she was comfortable with their answers. And so she created a bunch of comment or content defending Shein. And so I think that that's why that she's getting a little bit of this heat.

0:21:57
Grace Sharkey

Yeah. And so let me see if you know, it's interesting, too, is like, you're exactly right. Like, as much as our generation wants to say, like, hey, we stand for these like ESG initiatives and sustainable practices they're valued at over $100 billion i think it's the average person has bought 14 items every year from them uh and 28 of u.s fashion sales is going to them as well so wow yeah that is huge so at some point it's like i say this to people too on anything political like you know what doesn't change things yelling at people on social media like take that same energy write a letter to your representative go visit them right as you're

0:22:47

gonna fly to china go go visit your representative down the street who's in an office that's completely approachable and and let them know like that's how you feel but like yeah bullying a bunch of influencers on tiktok which if we want to go down that rabbit hole is owned by the chinese Chinese. They're being bullied on Instagram, too. China's like, win, win, win. Ching, ching, ching. Yeah, ching, ching, ching. Which is God, that's probably not the right phrase to use this.

0:23:18

But I mean, like, money wise. Quite literally, they're like, oh, yes. Oh, yes. Go go make content on TikTok and yell at each other

0:23:25
Blythe Brumleve

there. That's not good for us either. And tweet it from your iPhones and text it from your iPhones that are also, you know, I mean, how deep are we going to go with this like ethical supply chain? Because I would be willing to bet that the overwhelming majority of those, I would be willing to bet all of them, that all of those comments that were made in a negative fashion were coming from a phone that has natural resources that were sourced using a lot of the same corrupt labor practices.

0:23:53

So that's, I guess that's not an excuse, but it is something that, you know, from like a fast fashion standpoint, it is becoming, I think, more just aware with our generation, but also with younger generations. I think that's why we're seeing, you know, a lot of the increases in like vintage fashion and vintage finds. And I don't, you know, anecdotally here in Jacksonville, there are a handful of shops that have popped up all over Jacksonville specializing in like, you know, vintage sports gear from like Florida-based teams or just really anywhere, you know, people who are getting rid of their old stuff and they're going to thrift stores and they're finding them and they're sourcing them themselves and then selling

0:24:33

it in their retail shops. So it's shops specifically designed to, is it rethread or not rethread, but I guess up scale, up sale. I don't know what that phrase is called, but it's basically just making sure that the clothes that you're buying has a certain shelf life where you can reuse them multiple times, multiple you know, decades versus like the Shein clothes, which, you know, may fall apart after a couple of days. There was one shirt I bought from Shein, and this is totally my fault, but I tried to put iron on it and melted right to the iron.

0:25:07

So it's not the best made stuff either. But let me play this clip really quick, because this is the chick I was talking about. That is, she's facing the most because she's doubled down. She has since gone and deleted a lot of those posts. But this is her sort of explaining. Brokering success demands a battle-ready strategy. Thai TMS equips freight brokers with the ultimate battle station for conquering a tough market. With Thai, brokers gain access to a comprehensive platform where rate intelligence and quote history converge on a single screen.

0:25:42

It's not just a page, it's a strategic command center designed to help brokers win. Thai equips your team with all of the data they need to negotiate with confidence and allows them to communicate directly with carriers and customers from a simple control base. Revolutionize the way your brokers perform by giving them a competitive advantage with TIE TMS. For more info, go to tai-software.com backslash battle stations. And we also have a link for you in the show notes to sign up for a demo.

0:26:13
Speaker 3

Feel like a show. It didn't feel like something was quickly put together.

0:26:17
Speaker 4

Influencer Danny Carbonari is speaking out against growing criticism. after posting glowing reviews of Shein's operations in China. In an almost 12-minute video, the influencer begins by saying she is imperfect and can take accountability for her actions. She describes being interested in the brand over their size, inclusivity, and affordability and said she's friends with someone who worked there who helped make further introductions. She explains the company took her on a brand trip to Tahoe where she says she brought up many concerns and questions to the higher-ups.

0:26:48

Later, she said she had an off-the-record meeting with political people and journalists where higher-ups addressed more questions and gave answers.

0:26:56
Speaker 3

To me, I'm a very logistic person, and they just gave so many numbers. And that's when I learned about their auditing system and how they do have so many suppliers.

0:27:07
Speaker 4

She explains that the China trip was organized because the company wanted to put an end to criticism.

0:27:12
Speaker 3

We're aware of all these rumors and all this stuff that's going on, and we want to put an end to it. The trip, we were not paid for the trip. We were not paid to post. Our travel accommodations were taken care of.

0:27:22
Speaker 4

But ultimately, Dani still says she needs to do better, adding that the experience has caused her to revaluate her brand and herself.

0:27:29
Speaker 3

I should have done more research. And I think content creators in general, we don't do enough research. And I think especially plus size content creators, we're just so happy to be included. I'm sorry and sad that a lot of people that don't know me are so angry and upset. But the best thing that I can do moving forward is to lead with the same intention and authenticity. I always have an ad in doing the research, doing my part.

0:28:00
Grace Sharkey

So, thoughts? I'm like a logistics person, okay?

0:28:07
Blythe Brumleve

that's why i wanted to play that clip because she said that line i was like we have to play this because she's trying to bring the the logistics girlies into her drama and we're

0:28:15
Grace Sharkey

not going to stand for it logistics girlies i want to use what audience is she talking to our audience how dare she uh she's starting to creep in they found out i also love that they actually like forced her into labor too how chinese of them uh it's so awesome like she's at one point literally packing boxes like this is perfect um uh you know it's interesting because like they could have i would knowing not knowing china and our best friends but knowing china's antics like there's always other like that could have been like a warehouse i would be surprised if that's like a upfront warehouse that they take clients too oh for sure i mean i doubt that's where

0:29:07

it's all happening i mean for the amount of clothing and stuff in that like no there's no way that's where that's all happening um i just hate i will say i hate apology videos just like do it and move on like i i don't know why people spend this time like oh my god i made a mistake like no you got a free trip to china

0:29:27
Blythe Brumleve

know, like great for you. Yes, like double down on that. Like who would I mean, I we've seen, you know, some of these logistical operations up close at like the manifest conference, for example, where you can see these robotics and like these intricate systems that truly is fascinating. And I can totally empathize with getting an opportunity like that being able to getting a flight getting travel accommodations to go to another most people would not turn that opportunity down yeah um i would have had a lot more respect for if she just doubled down on it and she said hey you know this is what i'm doing and this is why i'm doing it and 90 of y 'all would do

0:30:06

the exact same things 90 of y 'all would take this trip um but now she has since um she has deleted all those videos promoting um the i guess behind the scenes not tours that she's done but behind the scenes conversations because she called herself an investigative journalist oh god ma 'am you take outfit photos you are not an investigative journalist it's a completely

0:30:32
Grace Sharkey

different skill set she's she's a logistics person and an investigative journalist it's like we do not accept you yeah exactly i know those people say no they don't have time for whatever you're doing right now oh my god that's so funny you know it's it's tough because i am excited when you talk about visibility tech in this space, I think it'll be much easier as we move forward to get more insight into like our supply chains and be able to say, Hey, this is who I'm buying from.

0:31:02

This is where the product's from. It's just, you know, Hmm. I want, maybe I'll just, let's play men for this one because at the end of the day, we just need dresses sometimes for events to look good really fast. And if society hadn't put that pressure on women for hundreds of years, maybe she wouldn't be what it is today.

0:31:24
Blythe Brumleve

So I need to actually link in the show notes. That's my conspiracy. I embarrassingly like know very little about like the fast fashion supply chain. I should know more. But I think a part of me for a long time did not want to know. Because it's almost like, you know, where, you know, when you start asking questions of like, where did the eggs come from? Where does meat come from? And then you start diving into a lot of those different questions.

0:31:56

I don't want to know those answers. I just want to be in peace. and it kind of goes back to like my earlier point of like so much of this responsibility is put on the consumers and so if this responsibility is put on the consumers there's a certain level of exhaustion that comes into play where sometimes you want to be really really morally a good person and sometimes you need to dress in two days uh it's it's gonna happen some days your morals are gonna be a little bit compromised and i don't think that you know consumers should have the, bear that responsibility, you know, all of the time where, like I said earlier, there's the overwhelming, the top 100

0:32:36

companies have contributed to more than 70 % of emissions since the 1980s. And so that's where the blame should be. That's where the change should be. But that YouTube video talked about how, you know, how, where did fast fashion, you know, sort of, where was it born? And when did the concepts of like fashion begin? And, you know, how did they start, you know, replicating outfits? Because before fashion very much was like you, one artist made clothing for one person, and it was somebody who was very well to do royals, you know, that sort of market.

0:33:12

And it wasn't until the early 1900s that these machines started being industrialized. And that's when fast fashion started. So it was like English countrysides. Apparently what happened is all these farmers were kicked out of their lands in like the British UK area. They were kicked off their land. And when they were kicked off their land, they were forced to move into these bigger cities. Well, the bigger cities had all of the factories in it. And so that's where the concept of fast fashion was born.

0:33:40

And then when it became like, you know, politically not good to have those fast fashion factories in the UK area, then they started searching for other areas. So they started searching for other areas of the world to outsource that part of the production. And that's how, you know, fast fashion was born. And so I thought it was super interesting that, you know, a lot of those same issues that were developed in one country were just – they knew of them.

0:34:07

They knew of these issues, and they still chose to outsource to other countries. And so that's where, like, the onus of, you know, greenwashing comes into play, which is starting to become, you know, more apparent. You know, a lot of food brands will use the phrase, like, organic. There's no sort of government-regulating body that can determine if something is truly organic or not. It's kind of a marketing ploy. So now we're starting to see this with retailers who are saying like, oh, you know, sustainably sourced.

0:34:35

But then you do a little bit of digging and they're not so sustainably sourced. So one app that I did find that can help you if you are looking to maybe start slowly changing your habits, your purchasing habits of getting away from, you know, I need the dress in two days to these other brands. And one site that you can look this up is called Good For You. And so they will basically go to a brand's website.

0:35:02

They have a certain amount of criteria on where the sources come from, what the labor, you know, what the workers' labor environment looks like. And then, you know, return shipping and how long the – you know, what kind of materials are in the stuff that you make. polyester I heard is one of the worst I guess offenders because they have so much like there was microplastics in their materials so that when you wear them they don't last very long and to your point earlier we're buying so much more clothing now but that clothing isn't lasting as long it's being sent to a landfill where it's something like a dump truck of clothes are burned every second of the day globally.

0:35:48

So we're consuming so much more and polyester materials are a big part of that. And they're getting found in like these deep sea ocean animals where like 70 % of the animals in like the deep sea have microplastics inside of them. And they think that that's how, is because of these clothings that are made of plastic end up in our water systems. And it's just a whole chain of events.

0:36:14
Grace Sharkey

Really crazy. it's uh i think i think i had a couple of facts up here too when i did something in fast fashion uh yeah 60% of most of it's made from the plastic based materials like you said and then the text the textile dying actually 20% of global waste uh water comes from just the dying process itself so oh wow yeah it's uh it's not good for the environment uh But it's tough because, like you said, the average person buys at least 14 items of new clothes every single year.

0:36:50

From Shein. Yeah. So at one point, are we...

0:36:55
Blythe Brumleve

Yeah. Where do you... And from that same video, they also said the average person buys a new piece of clothing every five days. So if you're buying those pieces of clothing and they're only lasting maybe two, three times that you're going to wear them, that's where these other companies that are coming – like the Good for You site where they'll go and they'll analyze all of those things of what the brand is saying sustainability-wise if it's just kind of bullshit or if they're actually a good company.

0:37:24

So they have a ranking of like five different, you know, like avoid or we support. One of the companies that I thought was really cool that probably deserves a little bit of a deep dive, maybe, you know, an idea for a future point of sale episode is Sheep Inc. They make wool. So wool is like apparently like the superstar as far as like sustainable fabrics. Cotton is next, but, you know, the recyclability of it is a little bit questionable.

0:37:53

but wool apparently is is like the upper echelon of of quality fabrics um that can be reused and reworn for years and it had you know less of an environmental impact all that good stuff but this company sheep inc and every purchase you make they will send you a button with your wool clothing so you can see the entire supply chain of that product and the impacts that each part of that supply chain so like and you could also see the sheep that your piece of clothing came from oh they're not dead so yeah at first i was like wait so they're still alive yeah they're still

0:38:28
Grace Sharkey

that's part of the sustainability like oh wait yes no that's good good um but it looked it looked

0:38:36
Blythe Brumleve

really cool my first thought though because i that's always like i guess where my first thought though goes is okay these buttons that you're sending how sustainable are the buttons um so that was sort of like my first point i was like hmm how sustainable are we if we're sending you know an electronic device um and that was probably made from plastic um i don't know what the actual button looks like um but i have seen the button in action and the content that they give you which i think is really um interesting because you can see the entire supply chain including the sheep that your clothing came from.

0:39:12
Grace Sharkey

That's interesting. That would be cool to have. But then again, you're also thinking as a buyer and I'm buying something every five days at some point, I'm like, who cares?

0:39:23
Blythe Brumleve

Also, the button, the novelty of it would be so cool for like five seconds.

0:39:29
Grace Sharkey

Exactly. And then what do you do with the button? By storing these buttons somewhere?

0:39:32
Blythe Brumleve

I feel like they could probably just maybe send you a link.

0:39:35
Grace Sharkey

We're basically tearing this up Shark Tank style right now.

0:39:39
Blythe Brumleve

Well, that's actually a perfect segment or a perfect transition to go into our next segment, which we wanted to talk about. Or wait, I guess I should probably ask any last thoughts on sort of fast fashion and what folks can do or not do.

0:39:57
Grace Sharkey

I would say I think there's other things to consider too when you look at the fast fashion behemoths out there. IP is one of them. You brought this up, right? A lot of celebrities and a lot of people have sued. These companies are stealing their ideas in different styles and stuff like that. So always consider that, right? Like, are you also hurting the person that came up with this idea? Imagine you came up with this yourself.

0:40:32

Are you happy that China is just pushing these things out at no cost to you, really, or them? That's another thing I have with it. But it's also, I think, just being reasonable as a consumer. If you don't like it and you're going to stand up and to the point where you're going to shame someone on Instagram about it, you better not order anything off that site again. Right. Like just talk the talk, walk the walk type of situation I think is big here.

0:41:04

I don't think they're going away anytime soon. I think that they could easily make themselves adhere to SEC rulings if there are any. But that's the thing. I don't think we'll see any. So it's kind of like a kick rock situation, especially it really depends. Right. We have an election coming up where that could go to.

0:41:24
Blythe Brumleve

Yeah, pretty well said. So I guess to be continued, especially in that world. But I'll leave a couple of those helpful links in the show notes. Should you want to, you know, sort of take your, I guess, morality to the next level and start searching for, you know, these companies that are trying to do good and they deserve to be supported? because that's a really good point you brought up about, you know, some of these smaller designers and creators who are coming up with these different outfit ideas, and then they're getting counterfeited, essentially, which we all know the counterfeit market in China is ridiculous.

0:41:56

There's hardly any kind of laws to protect the Etsy sale sellers have been going through this. You know, even, you know, some of the shoppers on Amazon who sell custom items, that is what What happens, which is super interesting, is that a lot of these companies will rip off the original design of American companies. And then they'll get all of these other shops or all of these other fake accounts to try to review bomb or to try to get takedown notices for the original creator of it.

0:42:27

So there's a lot of like kind of like, I guess, retail warfare that's going on in addition to, you know, the ethical nature of the where you're buying the product. So there's a whole lot of strings to pull on that discussion. But felt like we needed to defend the logistics girlies out here from getting infiltrated.

0:42:48
Grace Sharkey

You know me, guys, I'm about logistics.

0:42:51
Blythe Brumleve

What's funny is that she said logistic. She didn't say logistics. Yeah. Dead ringer.

0:42:57
Grace Sharkey

I'm about logistic. Oh my God.

0:43:27
Blythe Brumleve

Dispatch, where we help you build a better website. Now, a lot of the times we hand this task of building a new website or refreshing a current one off to a coworker's child, a neighbor down the street, or a stranger around the world, where you probably spend more time explaining the freight industry than it takes to actually build the dang website. Well, that doesn't happen at Digital Dispatch. We've been building online since 2009, but we're also early adopters of AI, automation, and other website tactics that help your company to be a central place to pull in all of your social media posts, recruit new employees, and give potential customers a glimpse into how you operate your business.

0:44:07

Our new website builds start as low as $1 ,500, along with ongoing website management, maintenance, and updates starting at $90 a month, plus some bonus freight marketing and sales content similar to what you hear on the podcast. You can watch a quick explainer video over on digitaldispatch.io. Just check out the pricing page once you arrive, and you can see how we can build your digital ecosystem on a strong foundation. Until then, I hope you enjoyed this episode.

0:44:36

I'll see you all real soon, and go Jags! you