In brief
Fed Vice Chair for Supervision Michael Barr argues that US financial rules should make the banking system sturdier while still leaving room for payments innovation. He says FedNow, the Fed's new real-time payment system, will take years to catch on. He says the proposed higher bank capital rules would add only a tiny cost to borrowers, and that failures like Silicon Valley Bank came mainly from bad management and weak supervision.
The main tension is between speed and safety. Real-time payments, lighter-touch innovation and cheaper credit pull one way, while lessons from Silicon Valley Bank, the 2008 crisis and the March 2020 Treasury market stress pull the other. Barr says banks need stronger capital, supervisors need to act faster, and new areas like hedge fund leverage, cyberattacks and stablecoins need clear guardrails.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
The conversation with Michael Barr was recorded live at The Clearing House annual conference in New York on November 17th.
“This is a live conversation that we recorded with Michael Barr, the Fed's vice chair for supervision at the The Clearing House annual conference in New York on November 17th.”
0:01:02 · Tracy Alloway · Episode recording · 2023
Michael Barr said payments innovations such as banknotes and checks, which rose in the 1700s, took a very long time to build networks.
“whether it's the development of banknotes or the rise of checks in the 1700s, or really any kind of innovation we've seen in payments, they take a very long time to build a network.”
0:02:43 · Speaker 4 · Payments history · 1700s
The Clearing House developed its own real-time payment system about a decade before FedNow.
“I do remember 10 years ago, the The Clearing House also developed its own real-time payment system.”
0:03:12 · Tracy Alloway · Private payment rails
Tracy Alloway said the UK had a comparable real-time payment system around 2007, years before FedNow launched in 2023.
“I think the UK had something equivalent in like 2007, and we're here in 2023 just launching it.”
0:05:36 · Tracy Alloway · Real-time payments · 2007
Michael Barr attributed the long development of FedNow to the Federal Reserve being a conservative institution that people expect to provide reliable services.
“Look, the Federal Reserve is a conservative institution, and I think that's appropriate. You know, people expect us to be able to provide trustworthy, reliable services”
0:05:50 · Michael Barr · FedNow development
Michael Barr said Silicon Valley Bank's failure stemmed from deep mismanagement of interest rate and liquidity risk and a highly networked deposit base.
“The real issue in Silicon Valley Bank was deep mismanagement of interest rate risk and liquidity risk, and then the highly networked nature of their deposit base.”
0:08:37 · Michael Barr · Bank failure · 2023
Michael Barr said banks using FedNow can set their own limits, including size limits and caps.
“own limits on the way in which they use the technology. They can set size limits if they want. They can cap it.”
0:09:14 · Michael Barr · FedNow risk controls
Michael Barr said the Fed's capital proposal mostly changes rules for trading and other non-lending activity, with only a small portion related to lending.
“The capital proposal that we put forward mostly changes the rules for trading and other non-lending activity. A very small portion is actually related to lending.”
0:18:00 · Speaker 5 · Basel endgame · 2023
Michael Barr said that if banks passed all added capital costs to borrowers with no competition, the average increase in loan costs would be 0.03%.
“If there's no competition at all and all of it is passed through to the borrower, the average increase would be 0.03%.”
0:18:34 · Speaker 5 · Loan costs · 2023
Michael Barr said the proposal would apply stricter capital requirements to the top eight banks and to banks with over $100 billion in assets.
“those stricter capital requirements should not only apply to the top eight banks in the country, but they should also apply to banks that are over $100 billion.”
0:19:17 · Speaker 5 · Capital requirements · 2023
Michael Barr said the United States has over 4,000 banks and fewer than 40 would be covered by the proposal.
“We have over 4 ,000 banks in the banking system. So less than 40 out of 4 ,000 are covered.”
0:19:35 · Michael Barr · Bank coverage · 2023
Michael Barr said Silicon Valley Bank did not have to account for unrealized losses on its securities, which the proposal would require of institutions of that size.
“with respect to Silicon Valley Bank, they didn't have to account for the unrealized losses on their balance sheet, reduction in value of securities.”
0:20:04 · Michael Barr · Unrealized losses · 2023
Michael Barr said the Fed's report on Silicon Valley Bank's failure found that supervisors identified the bank's risks but did not feel empowered to push hard enough for action.
“identified the risks at the bank, but they didn't feel empowered to push hard enough to get the bank to take action.”
0:23:24 · Michael Barr · Bank supervision · 2023
Tracy Alloway said an internal Silicon Valley Bank presentation showed it removed interest rate hedges because they were expensive and it did not expect the Fed to raise rates.
“I saw the internal presentation where they talked about doing that. And it was basically like, well, we have these hedges. They're expensive.”
0:24:41 · Tracy Alloway · Interest rate hedges · 2022
Michael Barr said the FOMC publishes a summary of economic projections every other meeting showing each member's individual views on the economy.
“The FOMC, every other meeting, puts out a summary of economic projections that are designed to show what each individual member of the FOMC believes about the path going forward for the economy.”
0:27:32 · Michael Barr · Fed communication · 2023
Michael Barr said Fed Chair Jerome Powell has made clear that interest rates will need to stay at their peak for some time to bring inflation back to 2%.
“I think Chair Powell has made it clear that we're going to need to hold interest rates at their peak level for some time in order to make sure that we're on the right path to get inflation back to 2%.”
0:28:04 · Michael Barr · Interest rates · 2023
Michael Barr said he had brought about 50 substantive supervisory matters or rulemakings to the Fed board, almost all decided unanimously.
“we've had about 50 substantive either supervisory matters or rulemakings that I've brought to the board for consideration.”
0:38:09 · Michael Barr · Fed board votes · 2023
Tracy Alloway said the US private credit market is now as big as the broadly syndicated market for junk-rated bonds.
“I was shocked to find out that the private credit market in the US is now as big as the broadly syndicated market for junk rated bonds.”
0:41:14 · Tracy Alloway · Private credit · 2023
Michael Barr said hedge fund activity in the Treasury market is often conducted with no margin at all, making the trades extremely highly leveraged.
“the activity is being conducted with, in many cases, no margin at all, which means the trades are extremely highly leveraged.”
0:42:04 · Michael Barr · Treasury market · 2023
Michael Barr said hedge funds were among the contributors to the disruption in the Treasury market in March 2020.
“So in March 2020, hedge funds were among the contributors to the disruption in the Treasury market.”
0:42:40 · Michael Barr · March 2020 stress · 2020
Michael Barr said the Federal Reserve established a standing repo facility, and a facility for foreign official counterparts, to relieve pressure in the Treasury market.
“one of the steps that the Federal Reserve took is to establish a standing repo facility and a facility for foreign official counterparts”
0:46:04 · Michael Barr · Repo facility
Michael Barr said the SEC's move toward central clearing of Treasury securities might be an appropriate next step for market resilience.
“I think that the SEC's move towards central clearing of treasury securities might be an additional appropriate next step.”
0:47:01 · Michael Barr · Central clearing · 2023
Tracy Alloway said FTX appears to have bought a US bank through a Cayman-based company, a possible channel for crypto into the banking system.
“But he did buy, or FTX appears to have bought a U.S. bank through a Cayman-based company”
0:48:12 · Tracy Alloway · FTX bank purchase · 2022
Michael Barr said the Federal Reserve established a novel activities supervisory program to bring experts together to help supervise banks engaged in crypto-related activity.
“We've established a novel activities supervisory program to bring experts from around the Federal Reserve System together to help supervisors deal with issues at banks that are engaging in some crypto-related activity.”
0:48:56 · Michael Barr · Crypto supervision · 2023
Michael Barr said dollar-linked stablecoins borrow the trust of the Federal Reserve, which is why he says they need strong federal oversight.
“In the case of a stablecoin linked to the dollar, stablecoins are really borrowing the trust of the Federal Reserve.”
0:51:05 · Michael Barr · Stablecoins
Michael Barr said Congress requires the Federal Reserve to determine that debit card interchange fees are reasonable and proportional to certain specified costs.
“Congress has said that we need to determine that debit card interchange fees are reasonable and proportional in relation to certain specified costs.”
0:53:14 · Michael Barr · Debit card fees