Questions
What does Lloyd Blankfein mean by Goldman's partnership culture?
He describes a sense of shared ownership in which employees feel responsible for the whole firm, not just their own division. Leaders discuss ideas with colleagues and adjust rather than simply giving orders.
How did Goldman Sachs react earlier than others to the 2007 financial crisis?
Blankfein says the firm marked its holdings to market, with controllers deciding the prices, so losses showed up quickly and forced people to sell. In summer 2007 he also noticed an asset-management fund that moved 6% on a day when it normally moved about four basis points.
What is the difference between a private partnership and a public company, according to Blankfein?
In a partnership, partners owned the firm, cared about long-term earnings, and were paid out their capital when they retired. In a public company, outside shareholders own it and want smoother, more predictable earnings, which support a higher stock multiple.
What does it mean to manage a firm in risk management mode?
Blankfein says it means asking what could possibly happen, even if unlikely, and what you would do about it, rather than debating what you expect to happen. The point is to protect against tail risk, meaning rare but severe events.
Why did Goldman start the 10,000 Women and 10,000 Small Businesses programs?
Blankfein says consumers, citizens and taxpayers did not know Goldman, a wholesale firm with no consumer business, and that hurt it during the financial crisis. The programs offered education and help raising capital, and let employees see real-world impact.
Facts
Stated by the speakers. Each quote matches the transcript, which shows what was said, not that it is true.
As a youth, Lloyd Blankfein sold food at the old Yankee Stadium for a small commission, which he put at $0.07 on a $25 item.
“This was in the old Yankee Stadium, steep steps. You have to go. And some guy, you made a commission of $0.07 on a $25 item.”
0:02:02 · Lloyd Blankfein · Early life
Lloyd Blankfein grew up in public housing in Brooklyn and describes his upbringing as a struggle.
“I did grow up in public housing in Brooklyn. And it was kind of a struggle.”
0:02:37 · Lloyd Blankfein · Childhood
Blankfein says he learned of Harvard by attending a college night at another high school, because few from his own school went to college.
“I went to a college night at a different high school because nobody from my high school went to college or very few did”
0:03:29 · Lloyd Blankfein · Harvard admission
Blankfein says he went straight to law school after Harvard partly because student loans came due unless he stayed in school.
“at that time you had to take out big loans loans start to you know come into effect unless you keep going to school”
0:03:57 · Lloyd Blankfein · Education
Blankfein was turned down by every financial firm he applied to, including Goldman Sachs, but got a job at J. Aron while Goldman was acquiring it.
“got turned down by everyone, including Goldman. but I did get a job at Jay Aaron while Goldman was acquiring Jay Aaron.”
0:04:33 · Lloyd Blankfein · Career start · 1982
Dennis Suskind interviewed Lloyd Blankfein for his job at J. Aron.
“I was interviewed by Dennis Suskind, who's a big personality, big guy and big personality.”
0:04:45 · Lloyd Blankfein · J. Aron hiring · 1982
Blankfein says he tested trading candidates by placing them at the far end of the trading floor to see if they could yell across the room.
“I used to interview people later on by putting at the last interview I put somebody at the opposite end of the trading floor”
0:04:45 · Lloyd Blankfein · Trading floors
Blankfein says the Hunt brothers' attempt to corner the market helped drive gold from about $35 to $850.
“the Hunt brothers were cornering the market and gold went from like $35 to $850, which by the way, took only about 35 years to get back to.”
0:06:09 · Lloyd Blankfein · Gold market
Blankfein jokes that J. Aron's traders sold the firm to Goldman Sachs near the peak of their gold-trading success.
“they extrapolated that out to infinity and sold it to Goldman Sachs, thereby establishing the relative trading acumen of the two organizations.”
0:06:09 · Lloyd Blankfein · J. Aron acquisition
Lloyd Blankfein was chairman and CEO of Goldman Sachs from 2006 to 2018, after serving as president and chief operating officer under Hank Paulson.
“Lloyd served as our chairman and CEO from 2006 to 2018 after serving as president and chief operating officer under Hank.”
0:00:43 · David Solomon · Leadership · 2006
David Solomon says Goldman Sachs, 27 years after its IPO, still has a deep partnership culture.
“27 years after the IPO, that this public company, you know, still has this deep, deep partnership culture.”
0:08:07 · David Solomon · Partnership culture · 1999
Blankfein says that in the early years as a public company, Goldman's partners still controlled it and the board was mostly Goldman partners.
“even as a public company in those years, the partners controlled it. In fact, the board of directors was still a majority Goldman Sachs partners.”
0:12:13 · Lloyd Blankfein · IPO era governance
Blankfein says that in the private partnership, partners received their capital only on retirement and so focused on long-term earnings.
“It's sort of, you know, you work for your career. You didn't get any money until you retired and you got your capital.”
0:12:36 · Lloyd Blankfein · Partnership economics
Blankfein says holding riskier assets on the balance sheet can raise earnings but lower the valuation multiple investors pay, and he cites a multiple of 10 against competitors' 17 as an illustration.
“but if you're trading, you know, at a multiple of 10 and your competitors are trading at 17, you give up a little bit of E for a little bit more PE.”
0:13:48 · Lloyd Blankfein · Valuation
In mid-2007, Blankfein noticed a Goldman Sachs Asset Management fund that normally moved about four basis points on a wild day had moved 6%, his first sign of the crisis.
“there was this fund that on a busy wild day would move four basis points and it moved 6%.”
0:15:55 · Lloyd Blankfein · 2007 crisis · 2007
Blankfein attributes Goldman's early reaction to the crisis to its culture of marking positions to market.
“we were very good at responding early to early signs because we had this culture of mark to market, which not everybody had.”
0:16:49 · Lloyd Blankfein · Mark to market · 2007
At Goldman Sachs, the control department had authority over what prices were used to value positions, and traders could appeal only by selling at their price.
“we also had a culture where the people in the control department really governed what marks to use.”
0:16:49 · Lloyd Blankfein · Risk controls
Blankfein says that in risk management mode he asked what could possibly happen and what the firm was doing to protect against tail risk.
“I only want to know what could possibly, even with a low probability, happen. And what are we doing to protect ourselves against that tail risk?”
0:18:13 · Lloyd Blankfein · Risk management
Blankfein says that in a risk-off panic, assets once thought unrelated can become perfectly correlated as everyone sells everything except Treasury bills.
“two things that in a million years you never thought were correlated, guess what? I now have a correlation of one.”
0:19:57 · Lloyd Blankfein · Market correlations
Blankfein notes that events described as 13 standard deviation moves happened several times during the financial crisis.
“how many times during the financial crisis said, oh, this is a 13 standard deviation event? Well, guess what? There were a few of them.”
0:19:57 · Lloyd Blankfein · Financial crisis · 2008
David Solomon says Blankfein launched the 10,000 Women and 10,000 Small Businesses programs during his tenure.
“you launched during your tenure two programs that really, you know, have had an enormous impact, 10 ,000 women and 10 ,000 small businesses.”
0:21:40 · David Solomon · Philanthropy
Blankfein says Goldman Sachs was a wholesale firm with no consumer business, so the public did not know it well during the financial crisis.
“We were a wholesale firm. We didn't have a consumer business. We didn't deal with consumers.”
0:22:00 · Lloyd Blankfein · Public perception · 2008
Blankfein describes the 10,000 programs as roughly 10-week courses run with business schools that also helped participants find capital and advice.
“albeit in a 10-week kind of a course, in partnership with real business schools and real institutions, help them line up capital and give them advice.”
0:22:23 · Lloyd Blankfein · 10,000 Women
Blankfein cites the Analyst Impact Fund, which began near the end of his tenure, as another program where employees raise capital for philanthropic causes.
“the Analyst Impact Fund, where they're going out and they're really doing kind of doing the same thing.”
0:23:28 · Lloyd Blankfein · Analyst Impact Fund
Blankfein says he paused his memoir for about three years after reaching the part where people could contradict him, then resumed with help organizing it.
“I sort of put my pen down and then I picked it up again three years later”
0:25:08 · Lloyd Blankfein · Memoir writing
Blankfein says his parents died when he was in his early 30s, which motivated him to write a record for his children.
“My parents passed away when I was in my early 30s, never got to chat.”
0:24:46 · Lloyd Blankfein · Memoir motives
John Cohn, then chief of staff, told new partners including Blankfein to keep Goldman to no more than three of nine obituary paragraphs.
“If at the end, they write an obituary about you, and that obituary is nine paragraphs long, make sure that no more than three of them are about Goldman Sachs.”
0:26:39 · Lloyd Blankfein · Life advice
Blankfein says that when he became a partner, Goldman set up a private foundation for each new partner.
“This was before there were donor advised funds. They actually set up a private foundation for everyone.”
0:26:18 · Lloyd Blankfein · Partner philanthropy